电子通信设备制造企业R&D国际化研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
R&D国际化是指R&D资源和活动的跨国界行为,它既包括东道国企业海外R&D活动,也包括外资企业在东道国的R&D活动。随着技术发明和应用周期的日益缩短、R&D投资风险的加大、经济全球化趋势的增强以及现代信息网络技术的广泛使用,企业的R&D国际化得到了迅猛发展,其R&D国际化研究亦引起了人们广泛关注。电子通信设备制造业是我国国民经济战略性产业之一,20世纪90年代以来,随着新兴市场的扩张及3G业务升温,我国电子通信设备制造业飞速增长,其增加值在制造业28个门类中稳居第一位,占GDP的15%左右。因此,研究电子通信设备制造企业R&D国际化对其R&D国际化的发展和提升国际竞争力具有重要的意义。
     本文从R&D国际化的视角切入,以电子通信设备制造企业作为研究对象,运用交叉学科理论与方法,对电子通信设备制造企业R&D国际化的动因、组织结构与选择机制、评估、效率测定以及管理进行了系统研究,分析讨论了研究结果和R&D国际化的经验启示,提出了相应的政策建议。主要研究内容如下:
     首先,科学界定了电子通信设备制造企业R&D国际化的概念和内涵。在此基础上,分析了电子通信设备制造企业R&D国际化的发展趋势,提出了其R&D国际化的内外部动因,进而采用问卷调查法,对我国电子通信设备制造企业R&D国际化的动因进行了实证研究,研究发现各动因按从高到低的顺序排列依次是:跟踪和获取技术;利用全球R&D资源,增强技术竞争力;支持当地生产和市场,适应本土化的要求;寻求短缺的R&D资源;制订或推广技术标准;获得范围经济;节约R&D时间;规避风险;避过贸易壁垒。
     其次,对电子通信设备制造企业R&D国际化的组织结构进行了研究。指出了五种组织类型和三种组织模式,提出了电子通信设备制造企业需要根据成本、技术保密、核心竞争力、东道国的科研水平与技术发达程度、发展战略、企业的经济与技术实力、R&D效率、企业国际化程度等因素来选择相应的组织类型和模式。然后,对电子通信设备制造企业R&D国际化水平及R&D国际化技术效率与影响因素进行了测评研究。选择了“改进”的拉开档次法作为评估的方法,从R&D资金、机构、活动、产出国际化四个层面,构建了电子通信设备制造企业R&D国际化评估的指标体系,根据电子通信设备制造大中型三资企业的面板数据,对其R&D国际化水平进行了评估。同时,选择数据包络分析法(DEA)作为技术效率测定的测算方法,引入了电子通信设备制造企业R&D国际化的物质资本、人力资本及研发资本这三个要素对其技术效率影响的回归模型,以电子通信设备制造大中型三资企业R&D数据为样本,对技术效率及其影响因素进行了实证研究。结果表明,我国电子通信设备制造企业R&D国际化的投入和产出均逐年递增,但R&D国际化技术效率并不是逐年提高;上述三要素对技术效率既有积极影响,也有消极影响。
     第三,从区位选择、人力资源管理、基于进化博弈分析的跨国R&D战略联盟管理机制三个方面探讨了电子通信设备制造企业R&D国际化的管理。对于海外R&D区位的选择提出了市场寻求型、技术寻求型和资源寻求型区位选择模式。对人力资源管理提出了实施本地化人才战略、加强对人才的培养、建立公正的评估制度、保持对人才的激励、尊重员工和建立员工对公司的归属等措施。对于跨国R&D战略联盟的管理,构建了揭示联盟演化特征的进化博弈模型,并在对博弈结果进行分析的基础上指出了决策应以长远利益为目标;减小超额收益、增加联盟的净利润以及推出被市场广为接受的行业标准以促进联盟的稳定;同时提出了联盟中企业应按各自技术水平的高低以及联盟R&D的前景选择合作策略,并根据R&D净利润最大化的一阶条件来合理安排自己的R&D活动等管理建议。
     最后,以积极参与R&D国际化活动、成果显著的国际电子通信设备制造优秀企业爱立信为案例研究对象,对其R&D国际化进行了深度剖析,挖掘了其成功的经验,并验证了本文提出的关于电子通信设备制造企业R&D国际化的观点与结论。进一步,提出了促进我国电子通信设备制造企业R&D国际化发展的相关启示和政策建议。
R&D Internationalization refers to R&D resources and activities across the national borders, involving overseas R&D activities of host countries and those of foreign invested enterprises in host countries. As life cycles of technological innovations and applications have been increasingly shortened, the investment risk for R&D is getting higher, the support of economic internationalization is strengthened, and modern information and network technology is widely used, the R&D internationalization of electronic and communication equipment manufacturing enterprises has been rapidly developed. Due to these aspects, the R&D internationalization of electronic and communication equipment manufacturing enterprises has aroused extensive research interest in the international academic circle. The electronic and communication equipment manufacturing is one of the strategic industry of China's national economy. As new markets emerge and the Third Generation telecommunication industry expands, China's electronic and communication equipment manufacturing has, since1990s, advanced rapidly, with its added value ranking No.1among the28manufacturing industries, and its output value accounting for15percent of China's GDP. Therefore, it is of great significance to study the internationalization of the R&D in implementing globalization strategies and promoting the competitiveness of China's players in electronic and communication equipment manufacturing. Focusing on the R&D internationalization, the dissertation takes electronic and communication equipment manufacturing enterprises as subjects with an interdisciplinary approach. It studies the motivations of the R&D internationalization, the organizational structures and their choice, the evaluation, efficiency measuring, and their management in a systematic way, analyzes and discusses the research findings and the R&D internationalization experience, and makes a series of policy suggestions. The key components of research as follows:
     In the first place, the dissertation attempts to define the concept and the connotation of the internationalization of electronic and communication equipment manufacturing enterprises. On that basis, the dissertation analyses the tendencies and suggests the external motivation of the internationalization of electronic and communication equipment manufacturing enterprises. Then the dissertation proceeds with a questionnaire for an empirical research on external motivations of the internationalization of China's electronic and communication equipment manufacturing enterprises. The research findings on motivations in the order of significance are keeping track of and acquiring relevant technologies, utilizing global R&D resources, enhancing technological competitiveness, seek absent R&D resources, making and spreading technological standards, achieving scope economy, saving R&D time, avoiding risks, and evading trade barriers.
     Secondly, the dissertation studies the organization structures of the internationalization of electronic and communication equipment manufacturing enterprises. It classifies5types of organizations and3organization models, points out that electronic and communication equipment manufacturing enterprises need to select types and models of organization corresponding to the factors, such as their costs, technology secrecy, core competitiveness, and the level of research and technological development in host country, their development strategies, their own economic and technological strength, their R&D efficiency, the degree of globalization of their enterprises. Then the degree of the internationalization of electronic and communication equipment manufacturing enterprises, and the technological efficiency of the R&D of and influence factors are evaluated. The improved ranking method is adopted to evaluate the enterprises in terms of the4categories of R&D investment, R&D institute type, R&D activity, and output internationalization, constructs the index system for evaluating the degree of internationalization of electronic and communication equipment manufacturing enterprises, and evaluates the degree of internationalization of wholly foreign owned, equity joint venture and contractual joint venture of electronic and communication equipment manufacturing enterprises according to their panel data. At the same time, this dissertation uses DEA methodology to measure the technological efficiency. It uses the physical capital, human capital and R&D capital of ploughed in by electronic and communication equipment manufacturing enterprises for R&D internationalization to regress on the technological efficiency effects. With sample data of the wholly foreign owned, equity joint venture, and contractual joint venture of electronic and communication equipment manufacturing enterprises, an empirical study is conducted to analyze the technological efficiency and the influence factors. The results show that China's electronic and communication equipment manufacturing enterprises input for and output from R&D internationalization are increasing year by year, but the technological efficiency is not increasing every year. The above three factors have both positive and negative effects on technological efficiency.
     Thirdly, the dissertation discusses the management mechanism of electronic and communication equipment manufacturing enterprises from three aspects:the location selection, human resources management mechanism, and multi-national R&D strategic coalition based on evolutionary game. For overseas R&D location selection, the dissertation proposes three models:market seeking model, technology seeking model, and resources seeking model. For human resources management, it suggests implementing human resources localization strategy, strengthening staff training, establishing fair performance evaluation system, maintaining motivation to elite staff, respecting staff and strengthening staff's identification with the enterprise. Concerning multi-national R&D strategic coalition management, the dissertation constructs an evolutionary game model to reveal the coalition evolution features, and points out, on the basis of the game model results, that electronic and communication equipment manufacturing enterprises should seek the long-term goals, reduce excess return, increase net profit for the R&D coalition parties and seek to introduce an industry standard that are sure to be extensively welcomed by the market to consolidate the foundation for the coalition. At the same time, the dissertation proposes that the enterprises in the coalition should select their cooperation strategies in accordance with their own technological advantages and the cooperation prospects for their R&D cooperation and arrange their own R&D activities in terms of the first order condition for the maximization of the R&D net profit.
     Finally, the dissertation makes a case study of Ericsson, an electronic and communication equipment manufacturing enterprise who has actively and fruitfully participated in R&D internationalization. This dissertation explores its R&D internationalization, summarizes its successful experience and validates the conclusions on R&D internationalization of electronic and communication equipment manufacturing enterprises put forward in this dissertation. In the end, the dissertation concludes with the revelations and policy suggestions on the development of China's electronic and communication equipment manufacturing enterprises' R&D internationalization.
引文
[1]黄鲁成,罗亚非.R&D国际化研究.北京:清华大学出版社,2006,5-180
    [2]Donald H. Globalizing industrial research and development. U.S Department of Commerce, September 1999
    [3]German Companies Intensity theirs research and development activities abroad. Economic Bulletin,2000,37(6):175-182
    [4]UNCTAD. World Investment Report. New York, United Nations,2001
    [5]刘云.跨国公司技术创新.北京:科学出版社,2007,10:1-58
    [6]张静.电子及通信设备制造业技术创新能力评价研究:[南京航空航天大学硕士学位论文].江苏:南京,2009
    [7]龚健,黄鲁成.R&D国际化的国内外研究综述.研究与发展管理,2003,(5):1-6
    [8]田大洲.IT制造业科技人力资源对行业产出的贡献.全球科技经济瞭望,2009,24(12):51-55
    [9]吕学海.ICT背景下中小企业的竞争优势.广东科技,2008,(17):89-93
    [10]Granstrand O, Hakanson L, Sjolander S. Internationalization of R&D.Research Policy,1993,22(5-6):413-430
    [11]Teece D J, Pisano G, Shuen A. Dynamic capabilities and strategic management. Strategic Management Journal,1997,18(7):509-533
    [12]龚健.企业海外R&D资源整合模式:[北京工业大学博士学位论文].北京,2004,23-30
    [13]Grant R M. The resource-based theory of competitive advantage:implication for strategy formulation. California Management Review,1991,33(3):114-135
    [14]Pearose E T. The theory of the growth of the firm. London: Basil Blackwell,1959
    [15]Barley J B. Firm resource and sustained competitive advantage. Journal of Management,1991,17(1):99-120
    [16]郭渊静.巧用网络外部性掘金增值业务.中国电信业,2010,(3):61-64
    [17]Shapiro C. Navigating the patent thicket:cross licenses, patent pools, and standard setting. Innovation policy and economy,2000,1(1):119-150
    [18]Karz M, Shapiro C. Networks Externalities, Competition and Compatibility. American Economic Review,1985,75(3):424-440
    [19]李忆.基于网络效应理论的移动通信消费行为研究:[重庆大学硕士学位论 文].重庆,2005
    [20]Economides N. Network Externalitie, Complementarities, and Invitation to Enter. European Journal of Political Economy,1996,12(2):211-133
    [21]Farrell J, Saloner G. Standardization, Compatibility and Technological Innovation. Rand Journal of Economics,1985,16(1):70-83
    [22]帅旭,陈宏民.网络外部性、转移成本与企业兼容性选择.系统工程理论与实践,2003,23(9):71-74
    [23]Schmidt, Susanne K, Raymund W. Coordinating Technology:Studies in the International Standardization of Telecommunications. MIT: Cambridge,1998
    [24]Farrell J, Saloner G. Standardization and Variety. Economics Letters,1986, 20(10):71-74
    [25]Jario J C.On Strategic Networks. Strategic Management Journal,1988,9(1):31-41
    [26]Dunning J. Internationalizing Porter Diamond.Management International Review,1993,33 (2):7-15
    [27]徐忠爱,刘东.网络经济条件的柔性组织:企业与市场的融合.晋阳学刊,2004,(6):33-36
    [28]孙国强,李维安.网络组织治理边界的界定及其功能分析.现代管理科学,2003,(3):3-4
    [29]Stephen P B, Pacey C F. The Network Paradigm in Organizational Research:A Review and Typology. Journal of Management,2003,29(6):991-1013
    [30]方放.标准设定动因下高技术企业研发能力提升机理与评价研究:[湖南大学博士学位论文].湖南:长沙,2009
    [31]Mario B.Governance Factors in a Network Process Approach. Journal of Management Sciences,1997,11(3):269-281
    [32]Goyal, Moraga G. R&D Network. Rand Joural of Economics,2001,32(4): 686-707
    [33]Smith M. The Theory of Games and the Evolution of Animal Conflict. Journal of Theoretical Biology,1974,47(1):209-221.
    [34]王伟.制度变迁的进化博弈分析及其对我国的启示:[复旦大学硕士学位论文].上海,2004
    [35]Kataro Suzumura. Cooperative and Noncooperative R&D in An Oligopoly with Spillovers. The American Economic Review,1992,82(5):1307-1320
    [36]Zhang L, et al. Research and Development of Cooperative Evolution. Journal of Shanghai Jiaotong University,1999,33(10):1332-1328
    [37]龚健,黄鲁成,罗琳.企业海外R&D战略联盟的进化博弈模型.科学学研究, 2003,21(1):85-89
    [38]Hymer S H. The International Operations of National Firms:A Study of Direct Foreign Investment. Cambridge:MIT Press,1976
    [39]Kindleberger C P. American Business Abroad:Six Lectures on Direct Investment. New Haven:Yale University Press,1969
    [40]Caves R E. Cause of Direct Investment:Foreign Firm's shares in Canadian and UK Mamufacturing Industries. Review of Economics and Statistics,1974,56(3): 279-293
    [41]Johnson H G. The Efficiency and Welfare Implication of the International Corporation. In C P kindelberger. Cambridge:MIT Press,1970
    [42]Knickerbrocker F T. Oligopolistic Reaction and Multinational Enterprises. Boston:Harvard University Press,1973
    [43]樊增强,宋雅楠.企业国际化动因理论述评.当代经济研究,2005,(9):18-22
    [44]Vernon R. International Investment and International Trade in the Product Cycle. The Quarterly Journal of Economics,1996,80(2):190-207
    [45]王玉萍.跨国直接投资理论主流学派思想探析.生产力研究,2006,(6):61-62
    [46]Pearce R D, Singh S. Globalizing Research and Development. London: Macmillan Press Ltd,1992
    [47]Cantell J. The Globalization of Technology:What Remain of the Product Cycle Model? Cambridge Journal of Economics,1995,19:155-174
    [48]Buckley P J, Casson M C. The Future of Multinationals. Macmillam Press,1976
    [49]Hankson L, Robert N. Determinants of foreign R&D in Swdeish multinationals. Research Policy,1993,22(5):396-411
    [50]Manuel G, Serapio J, Donald H Dalton. Globalization of Industrial R&D:an Examination of Foreign Direct Investments in R&D in the United States. Research Policy,1999,28:303-316
    [51]Pearce R. The internationalization of research and development by multinational Enterprise. New York: St. Maritin's Press,1989
    [52]薛澜,王建民.跨国公司在中国设立研发机构影响因素分析.科研管理,2001,22(4):35-42
    [53]郑京淑.跨国公司海外研发机构的区位研究.世界地理研究,2000,9(1):10-16
    [54]江小涓.跨国公司在华投资企业的研发行为.科技导报,2000,(9):37-42
    [55]Ronstadt R C. Research and Development Abroad by U.S. Multinationals. Praeger, New York,1997
    [56]Hood N, Young S. US Multinational R&D:Corporate Strategies and Policy Implications for the UK. Multinational Business,1992,2(1):10-23
    [57]Brockoff K,Vithala R.Toward a demand forecasting model for preannounced new technological products. Journal of Engineering and Management,1993,10(3): 211-228
    [58]Kuemmerle W.Foreign direct investment in industrial research in the pharmaceutical and electronics industries-results from a survey of multinational firms. Research Policy,1999,28(2):179-183
    [59]Gassmann O,Zedwitz M.New concepts and trends in international R&D organization. Research Policy,1999,28(2):231-250
    [60]Meyer Krahmer Reger C. New perspective on the innovation strategies of multinational enterprise:Lessons for technology policy in Europe. Research Policy,1999,28(7):571-576
    [61]吕萍,杨震宁,王以华.我国高技术企业研发国际化的发展与现状.中国软科学,2008,(4):115-122
    [62]陈劲,童亮,戴凌燕.中国企业R&D国际化的组织模式研究.科学学研究,2003,21(4):391-395
    [63]葛顺奇,李诚邦.跨国公司实行配套产品本土化.中国外资,2002,(11):66-67
    [64]OECD. Globalization of Industrial R&D:Policy Issues. Paris:OECD,1999
    [65]United Nations Conference on Trade and Development UNCTAD. World Invest-ment Report, United Nations New York and Geneva,2005
    [66]Patel P, Pavitt K. National Systems of Innovation under Strain:The internationalization of Corporate R&D. SPRU Electronic Working Disseration Series No.22, Science Policy Unit, University of Sussex, U.K.1998
    [67]J Edler. Creative internationalization:widening the perspectives on analysis and policy regarding international R&D activities.The Journal of Technology Transfer, 2007,33(4):337-352
    [68]Hemmert. The Influence of Institutional Factors on the Technology Acquisition Performance of High-tech Firm:Survey Results from Germany and Japan. Research Policy,2004,33(6-7):1019-1039
    [69]C V Beers,E Berghall,T Poot.R&D Internationalization,R&D Collaboration and Public Knowledge Institutions in Small Economies:Evidence from Finland and the Netherlands.Research Policy,2008,37(2):294-308
    [70]肖文,候田,林高榜.R&D国际化水平及效率研究.浙江大学学报,2009,39(4):161-170
    [71]寇文煜,杨光怀.从美国专利看跨国公司研发国际化的本质.财贸经济,2004, (4):73-77
    [72]张仁开,孙长青.外资R&D机构本地绩效测评指标体系研究.科技管理研究,2008,28(9):106-109
    [73]Pillal A S,Joshi A,Rao K S.Performance Measurement of R&D Projects in a Multiproject,Concurrent Engineering Environment.International Journal of Project Management,2002,20(2):165-177
    [74]谢光亚,高飞.中国通信制造业研发国际化投入产出模型分析.未来与发展,2008,(12):9-13
    [75]MacDougall D. Why Are EU Countries on R&D Credits. Journal of International Taxation,2004,15(7):38-43
    [76]Moenaert R K, Filip Caeldries et al. Communication Flow in International Product Innovation Team Product Innovation Management,2000,14(5):360-377
    [77]景劲松,陈劲,吴沧澜.我国企业R&D国际化的现状、特点及模式.研究与发展管理,2003,15(4):41-47
    [78]马勇,周天瑜.跨国公司R&D国际化发展趋势与我国应采取的对策分析.科技管理研究,2009,29(3):1-4
    [79]黄敏,张铀.R&D国际化对我国技术创新能力提高的影响.云南科技管理,2006,19(2):31-33
    [80]胡峰.论国际研发投资中的东道国投资促进政策的选择.科学学与科学技术管理,2007,28(4):46-50
    [81]Kuemmerle W. Building effective R&D capabilities abroad. Harvard busines review,1997,75(2):61-70
    [82]肖麟.国际直接投资理论评析.国际政治研究,2005,(1):143-150
    [83]Pearce R D, Singh S. Globalizing Researh and Development. London Macmillan Press Ltd,1992
    [84]Dunning J. International Production and the Multinational Enterprise. London: George Allen&Unwin,1981
    [85]Dunning J. Multinational Enterprises and the Global Economy. Cheltenham: Unwin Hyman Published,1982
    [86]Cheng J, Bolon D. The Management of Multinational R&D:A Neglected Topic in International Business Research. Journal of International Business Studies,1993, 24(1):1-18
    [87]洗国明,葛顺奇.跨国公司的国际化R&D的国际化战略.世界经济,2000,10:47-52
    [88]斋腾优.技术开发论——日本技术开发与政策.北京:科学技术出版社 1996:39-55
    [89]Suzumura K. Cooperative and Noncooperative R&D in an Oligopoly with Spillovers. American Economic Review,1992,82(5):1307-1320
    [90]Kestelook K, R Veugelers. Stable R&D, Cooperation with Spillover. Journal of Economics and Management Strategy,1995,4(4):651-672
    [91]Eaton B, Eswaran M. Technology Trading Coalitions in Supergames. Rand Journal of Economics,1997,28(1):135-149
    [92]Allen R H, Sriram R D. The role of standard in innovation. Technological Forecasting and Social Change,2000,64(2):171-181
    [93]Basen Stanley M, Farrell Joseph.Choosing How to Compete:Strategies and Tactics in Standardization.Journal od Economic Perspectives,1984,8(2): 117-131
    [94]Duhaime, Irene M. Determinants of Competitive Advantage in the Network Organization Form:a Polit Study. Working Disseration,2002
    [95]Sloane A. The Standards Process:Tools and Methods for Standards Tracking and Implementation. Computer Standards& Interfaces,2000,22(1):5-12
    [96]Cantwell J. Innovation as the Principle Source of Growth in the Global Economy: Innovation in the Global Economy. Cambridge:Cambridge University Press, 1998
    [97]Moris, Francisco. Foreign Direct Investment, R&D, and Innovation:Concepts and Data. Background note prepared for UNCTAD,2005
    [98]杨金锋.跨国公司在华R&D投资行为研究:[哈尔滨工业大学硕士学位论文].黑龙江:哈尔滨,2005
    [99]李林琳.跨国公司在中国设立R&D中心影响因素研究:[浙江大学硕士学位论文].浙江:杭州,2008
    [100]Hakanson L,Nobel R.Foreign Research and Development in Swedish Multinationals. Research Policy 1993,22(5-6):373-396
    [101]Jussi Koskinen.Internationalization of R&D in Finnish Firms.In Pajarinen, Mika and Yla-Anttila, Pekka(eds.) Cross-broder R&D in a small country. Helsinki: Taloustieto Oy,1999
    [102]张晖明,丁娟.企业技术创新战略联盟的理论分析.社会科学,2004,(8):4-9
    [103]Costa, Ionara. Notes on R&D and TNCs Affiliates in Brail. Disseration presented at the UNCTAD Expert Meeting on the impact of FID on development. Geneva, 2005
    [104]吴文华.高技术企业技术标准联盟治理研究:[湖南大学博士学位论文].湖南: 长沙,2008,5-68
    [105]UNCTAD Survey on the Internationalization of R&D Current Patterns and Prospects on the Internationalization of R&D. New York and Geneva,2005
    [106]Veugelers, Reinhilde and Bruno Cassiman. Importance of international linkages for local kown-how flows:some econometric evidence from Belgium. European economic review,2004,48 (2):455-476
    [107]Chiesa v.Managing the Internationalization of R&D Activities.IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management,1996,43(1):7-23
    [108]Medcof J W. A Taxonomy of Internationally Disoersed Technology Units and its Application to Mamagement Issues. R&D Mamagement,1997,27(4):301-318
    [109]Brockoff K. Internationalization of Research and development. Spring-verlag Berlin:Heidelberg,1998
    [110]Asakawa K. organizational Tension in International R&D Management:The case of Japanese firms.Research policy,2001,30(5):735-757
    [111]Jack N Behman, willian A. Fischer.Overseas R&D Activities of Trsnsactional Companies. Cambridge:Oelgeschager, Gunn&Hain, publishers,1980
    [112]Gulati R, Gargiulo M. Where Do International Networks Come From.American Journal of sociology,1994,104 (5):1439-1493
    [113]Osborn R N, Hagedoorn J, etal. Embedded Patterns of International Alliance Formation. Organization studies,1998,19(4):617-638
    [114]Japan, METI. Dai 32-kai Wakakuni Kaigai Jigyo Katsudo. Tokyo:National Printing Bureau,2004
    [115]陈劲.创新全球化——企业技术创新国际化范式.北京:经济科学出版社,2003:18-65
    [116]李铭,王高尚,于汶加,刘占成.中国石油资源安全评价.地质学报,2010,31(5):686-692
    [117]张涛.提升山东省成长型中小企业竞争力对策研究:[山东大学硕士学位论文],山东:济南,2008
    [118]罗荣桂,杨贵斌.模糊综合评判法选择战略联盟合作伙伴.科技进步与对策,2003,20(7):30-32
    [119]陈宏伟.北京地区系统集成企业核心竞争力比较研究:[北京化工大学硕士学位论文],北京:2008
    [120]郭亚军.一种新的动态综合评价方法.管理科学学报,2002,5(2):50-54
    [121]郭亚军.综合评价理论、方法及应用.北京:科学出版社,2007:126-127
    [122]朱承亮,岳宏志,李婷.中国西部大中型工业企业技术创新能力实证分析. 科技管理研究,2009,(9):173-176
    [123]Park S O, Ungson G R.Interfirm Rivalry and Managerial Complexity: a Conceptual Framework of Alliance Faiure.Organization science,2001,12 (1): 38-39
    [124]Holtshouse D. Knowledge Research Issues. California management review, 1998,40 (3):288-280
    [125]Chung S, Singh H, LeeK. Complementary Status Similarity and Social Capital as Drivers of Alliance Formation. Strategic management journal,2000,21(1): 21-22
    [126]Geringer J. Hebelrt L.Measuring Performance in International Joint Venture. Journal of international studies,1991,22(2):249-263
    [127]Schuman et al. Measuring R&D Performance. Research Technology Management,1995,38(3):45-54
    [128]Daniel Sullivan. Measuring the Degree of Internationalization of a Firm. Journal of International Business Studies,1994,25(2):325-342
    [129]Elch, Lawrence, Luostarinen R. Internalization:Evolution of a Concept. Journal of General Management,1988,14(2):34-55
    [130]吴延兵.R&D存量、知识函数与生产效率.经济学,2006,5(4):151-178
    [131]Nunamaker T. Using Data Envelopment Analysis to Measure the Efficiency of Non-profit Organizations:a Critical Evaluation. Managerial and Decesion Economics,1985, (6):50-58
    [132]Parkin D, Hollingsworth B.Measuring Productivity Efficiency of Acute Hospitals in Scotland 1991-1994:Validity Issues in Data Envelopment Analysis. Applied Economics,1997,(29):1425-1433
    [133]Brenda Gannon.Testing for Variation in Technical Efficiency of Hospitals in Ireland.The Economic and Social Review,2005,36(3):273-294
    [134]Souza G S,Gomes E G, Gazzola R,et al. A Parametric Approach for Evaluating the Technical Efficency of the Brazilian Agricultural Sector. In:The Industrial Engineering and the Sustainable Development. Brazil:Salvador,2009
    [135]Kostas Kounetas, Kostas Tsekouras.Are the Energy Efficiency Technologies Efficient? Economic Modelling,2010,27(1):274-283
    [136]盛垒.跨国公司在华R&D投资的溢出效应研究——基于随机前沿分析方法(SFA检验).世界经济研究,2010,(6):68-74
    [137]李静娴,慎少辉,王方方.产业结构相似性与省际间经济增长的溢出效应.云南财经大学学报(社会科学版),2009,24(6):26-29
    [138]李国璋,周彩云,江金荣.区域全要素生产率的估算及其对地区差距的贡献.数量经济技术经济研究,2010,(5):49-61
    [139]吴延兵.用DEA方法评测知识生产中的技术效率与技术进步.数量经济技术经济研究,2008,25(7):67-79
    [140]牛树海.我国不同类型工业企业生产效率的区域差异研究.经济经纬,2006,(6):53-55
    [141]柴志贤,黄祖辉.集聚经济与中国工业生产率的增长——基于DEA的实证分析.数量经济技术经济研究,2008,(11):4-16
    [142]徐海洪,刘凤朝.电子及通信设备制造业R&D效率的地区差异分析.科技进步与对策,2009,11(22):95-99
    [143]黎开颜,陈飞翔.深化开放中的锁定效应与技术依赖.数量经济技术经济研究,2008,25(11):56-70
    [144]胡小娟,刘姣.我国制造业进出口贸易与生产率增长研究.山西财经大学学报,2010,32(6):70-76
    [145]任海云,师萍.企业R&D投入与绩效关系研究综述——从直接关系到调节变量的引入.科学学与科学技术管理,2010,(2):145-153
    [146]孙道军,王栋.高新技术产业集群下区域R&D投入与创新产出的实证研究.现代管理科学,2010,(6):71-73
    [147]郑瑜.外资参股国内银行效应与风险管理研究:[南京理工大学硕士学位论文].江苏:南京,2007
    [148]赵彦云,张明倩.中国制造业产业竞争力评价分析.经济理论与经济管理,2005-5:23-30
    [149]王安宇,司春林,赵武阳.知识生产组织模式演变及其对我国实施自主创新战略的启示.科学学与科学技术管理,2010,(6):96-101
    [150]吴林海,杜文献.中国R&D投入与经济增长的关系——基于1991~2005年间中国科技统计数据的协整分析.科学管理研究,2008,26(2):91-94
    [151]Miller S, Upadhyay M. Total Factor Productivity and the Convergence Hypothesis. Journal of Macroeconomics,2002,24(2):267-286
    [152]Fare R, Grosskopf S, Lovell C. Production Frontiers.Cambidge:Cambidge University Press,1994
    [153]Hall B H, Mairesse J. Exploring the Relationship Between R&D and Productivity in French Manufacturing Firms. Journal of Econometrics,1995,65 (1):263-293
    [154]Griliches Z, Lichtenbegr F. Interindustry Technology Flow and Productivity Growth:A Reexamination. Review of Economics and Statistics,1984,66(2): 324-329
    [155]Goldsmith R W. A Perpetual Inventory of National Wealth.In Studies in Income and Wealth,1975,27(2):125-151
    [156]张军,章元.对中国资本存量的再估计.经济研究,2003,(7):35-43
    [157]Griliches Z. Patent Statistics as Economic Indicators:A Survey.Journal of Economic Literature,1990,28(4):1661-1707
    [158]Scherer F M. The Propensity to Patent. International Journal of Industrial Organization,1983,16(1):107-128
    [159]朱平芳,徐伟民.政府的科技激励政策对大中型工业企业R&D投入及其专利产出的影响——上海市的实证研究.经济研究,2003,59(6):43-53
    [160]李小平,朱钟棣.国际贸易的技术溢出门槛效应——基于中国各地区面板数据的分析.经济研究,2004,21(10):27-32
    [161]Dunning J. The Eclectic Paradigm Of International Production:A Restatement and Some Possible Extensions.Journal of International Business Studies,1988, 19(1):1-38
    [162]Suresh Narayanan, Lai Yew Wah. Technological Maturity and Development without Research:The Challenge for Malaysian Manufacturing. Development and Change,2000,31(2):435-457
    [163]Mohd Nazari Ismail.Foreign Direct Investments and Development: The Malaysian Electronics Sector Bergen:Michelsen Institute,2001:336-351
    [164]Hu, Albert G Z, Jefferson G H., Qian Jinchang. R&D and Technology Transfer:: Firm-level Evidence from Chinese Industry. Review of Economics and Statistics,2005,87(4):780-786
    [165]Kumar S, Robert Russell. Technological Change, Technological Catch-up, and Capital Deepening:Relative Contributions to Growth and Convergence. American Economic Review,1992,92(3):527-548
    [166]王欣,陈丽珍.外商直接投资、前后向关联与技术溢出.数量经济技术经济研究,2008,25(11):86-98
    [167]Mansfield E D, Teece D J, Romeo A.Overseas Rsearch and Development by US-based Firm. Economica,1979,46(182):187-196
    [168]Zejan C. R&D Activities in Affiliates of Swedish Multinational Enterprises. Scadinavian Journal of Economics,1990,92(3):487-500
    [169]Warrant. Overseas R&D Investment by Multinationals in Foreign Center of Excellence. Journal of International Business Studies,1993,18(3):167-184
    [170]杜德斌.论跨国公司R&D国际化趋势.世界地理研究,2000,(9):1-9
    [171]杜德斌.跨国公司R&D全球化的区位模式研究.上海:复旦大学出版社,2001:165-198
    [172]Rugman A M. Inside the Multinationals:The Economics of Internet Market. London:Croom Helm Press,1981:211-234
    [173]Suresh Narayanan, Lai Yew Wah.Technological Maturity and Development without Research:The Challenge for Malaysian Manufacturing. Development and Change,2000,31(2):361-551
    [174]Multinelli, Piacitello M L. The Entry Mode Choice of MNEs:an Evolutionary Rpproach. Research of Policy,1998,27(5):491-506
    [175]周伟丹.跨国公司在华R&D投资区位选择研究:[浙江大学硕士学位论文].浙江:杭州,2008
    [176]赵永乐,张永耀.企业研发人才研究.中国人力资源开发,2003,(11):7-11
    [177]许树沛.试论战略联盟中的人力资源整合.南开管理评论,2001,(4):21-25
    [178]Bonnie G. Mani, Performance Appraisal Systems, Productivity, and Motivation: a Case Study.Public Personnel Management,2002,31(2):141-159
    [179]Jin Feng Uen, Shu Hwa Chien.Compensation Structure, Perceived Equity and Individual Performance of R&D Professionals. The Journal of American Academy of Business,2004,3:401-405
    [180]周建伦,叶琳.跨国公司人力资源管理变革及其对我国企业国际化的启示.现代管理科学,2008,(8):45-47
    [181]李俊霞新兴技术企业研发人员管理科技管理研究2007,(2):107-109
    [182]Youndt M A, Snell S A. Human Resource Configurations Intellectual Capital, and Organizational Performance. Journal of Managerial Issues,2004,16(3): 337-361
    [183]Chiesa V. Managing the Internationalization of R&D Activities. IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management,1996,43(1):7-23
    [184]Kuemmerle W. Building Effective R&D Capabilities Abroad. Harvard Business Review,1997,75(2):61-70
    [185]朱燕.基于心理契约的企业文化激励机制研究:[浙江师范大学硕士学位论文].浙江:江华,2007
    [186]刘遵乐.终端营销人员激励机制探讨.民风,2008,(19):116
    [187]Arnold, pacey.Technology in World Civilization. Cambridge:MIT Press,1994
    [188]Gulati R. Does Familiarity Breeds Trust? The Implications of Repeats Ties. Academy of Management Journal,1995:38(1):85-112
    [189]Osborn R N, Hagedoorn J, Denekamp J. Embedded Patterns of International Alliance Formation. Organization Studies,1998,19(4):156-163
    [190]张欣阳.试析激励机制在跨国企业中的应用.牡丹江师范学院学报,2009,(4):15-17
    [191]邱发丽.跨国公司人力资源管理模式的研究:[天津师范大学硕士学位论文].天津,2004
    [192]Smith M. The Theory of Games and the Evolution of Animal Conflict. Journal of Theoretical Biology,1974,47(1):209-221
    [193]陆琳.我国物流企业战略联盟的进化博弈研究.改革与战略,2009,25(5):55-56
    [194]敬嵩,雷良海.利益相关者参与公司管理的进化博弈分析.管理科学学报,2006,9(6):82-85
    [195]魏遥,雷良海.金融系统演变的进化博弈分析.系统管理学报,2009,18(4):373-377
    [196]Siegel et al. Transferring Knowledge from Academicians to Practioners: Qualitative Evidence from University Technology Transfer Offices. University of Nottingham,2000
    [197]Ham R M, Mowery D C. Impoving the Effectiveness of Public-private R&D Collaboration:Case Studies at a US Wapons Laboratory. Research Policy,1998, 26(6):661-675
    [198]Hagedoorn J, Link A, Vonortas N.Research Partnerships. Research Policy,2000, 29(4):567-586
    [199]Hagedoorn J, Narula R. Choosing Organizational Modes of Strategic Technology Partnering. International and Sectoral Differences. Journal of International Business Studies,1996,27(2):265-284
    [200]Narula R, Hagedoorn J. Innovating Through Strategic Alliances:Moving Towards Internationaol Partnerships and Contractual Agreements. Tecgnovation, 1999,19(5):283-294
    [201]黄武军,刘天虎,许维胜,吴启迪.N人合作博弈的Nash及演化均衡稳定策略分析.计算机工程与应用,2010,46(17):15-18
    [202]许冉,王文彬.关于企业建立技术联盟的博弈分析.科技与管理,2007,(3):27-29
    [203]Kataro S. Cooperative and Noncooperative R&D in an Oligopoly with Spillovers. The American Economic Review,1992,82(5):1307-1320
    [204]Goyal, Moraga Gonzalez. R&D Network. Rand Joural of Economics,2001, 32(4):686-707
    [205]Ohtsuki H, Martin A. Evolutionary Games on Cycles. The Royal Society,273(5): 2249-2256
    [206]孙庆文,陆柳等.不完全信息条件下演化博弈均衡的稳定性分析.系统工程理论与实践,2003,23(7):11-16
    [207]Weibull J W. Evolutionary Game Theory. Boston MIT Press,1998:32-48
    [208]Maynard S J. Evolutionary and the Theory of Games. London:Combridge University Press,1982
    [209]Taylor P D, Jonker L B. Evolutionarily Stable Strategies and Game Dynamics. Mathematical Bioscience,1978,40(1):145-156
    [210]Young H P. The Evolution of Conventions. Econometrica,1993,61(1):57-84.
    [211]Nooteboom B. Inter-Firm Alliances——analysis And Design. London: Routledge,1999
    [212]宋冬梅,张云宁.企业合作竞争的进化博弈分析.价值工程,2004,(7):44-46
    [213]张良桥.进化博弈:理论与方法.经济评论,2007,5(3):37-42
    [214]谢识予.经济博弈论.上海:复旦大学出版社,2000年
    [215]杜晓君,马大明,张吉.基于进化博弈的专利联盟形成研究.管理科学,2010,23(2):38-44
    [216]NSF. Research Alliances:Trends in Industry, Governmenr, and University Collaboration.Science and Enginneering Indicators,2002
    [217]陆奇岸.强势企业与弱势企业联盟的博弈分析及其启示.管理科学,2006,19(16):12-16
    [218]刘吉云.技术标准与中小企业技术创新的博弈分析.中国外资,2009,(12):137-138
    [219]Vonotras,Nicholas.Inter-Firm Cooperation in Imperfectly Appropriable Research:Industry Performance and Welfare Implication. Working Paper,1989
    [220]Goyal A,Welch I.Predicting the Equity Premium With Dividend Ratios.The National Bureau of Economic Research,2003,49(5):639-654
    [221]Friedman D. Evolutionary Game in Economics. Econometrica,1991,59(3): 637-666
    [222]Yin R. The Case Study Crisis:Some Answers. Administrative Science Quarterley,1981,26(1):58-65
    [223]王金红.农村干群冲突的依法解决之道——对一桩广东农民依法维权案例的分析.岭南学刊,2006,(1):57-60
    [224]Yin R.Discovering the Future of the Case Study. Method in Evaluation Research. American Journal of Evaluation,1994,15(3):283-290
    [225]孙耀吾.基于技术标准的高技术企业技术创新:[湖南大学博士学位论文].湖南:长沙,2007
    [226]Eisenhart K M. Building the Theories Form Case Study Research. The Ccademy of Management Review,1989,14(4):532-550
    [227]Haklm C. Research Design. Lecture, Cardiff University,2005
    [228]毕文明.爱立信网络无限产品战略研究:[复旦大学硕士学位论文].上海,2006
    [229]成媛.我国通信设备企业发展战略比较研究:[华东师范大学硕士学位论文].上海,2007
    [230]李崑.爱立信(中国)通信有限公司3G市场竞争策略研究:[北京邮电大学硕士学位论文].北京,2008
    [231]张照刚.爱立信研发的资源配置与流程管理研究:[上海交通大学硕士学位论文].上海,2009
    [232]张祯珍.FDI对中国产业国际竞争力的影响研究:[上海师范大学硕士学位论文].上海,2009
    [233]隆国强.吸引跨国公司研发机构的机遇与对策.重庆工学院学报,2006,20(1):7-12

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700