地方政府债务风险预警体系研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
转轨时期我国地方政府面临着经济分权与政治集权的制度环境,地方政府已成为具有独立经济利益和分散决策权的重要主体。我国分税制改革推出后,在明显地强化和改善了中央宏观调控能力的同时,又不同程度地提高了各地方对中央财政的依赖度,由此引起地方政府的资金困境。随着市场经济深化和政府职能转变,地方政府为了调整经济结构、加快基础设施建设,运用多种融资方式,多渠道筹集建设资金,在一定程度上有力推动了地方经济建设和社会事业发展。但是,由于对地方政府缺乏必要的立法规范和有效监管,地方政府形成了多头、无序的融资局面,随之而来的是地方政府明里、暗里举债,显性和隐性债务负担日益严重。由于地方政府财政窘迫,偿债能力有限,债务风险日益突出,已经产生很多负面影响。
     既然地方政府债务问题在我国已无法避免,而且规模巨大、已形成风险,与其遮遮掩掩,不如公开面对、予以规范、加强管理。为防范和化解风险隐患,确保经济金融平稳运行,必须加强地方政府债务管理,那么如何预警风险就显得尤为迫切。在这种情况下,本文选择地方政府债务风险预警体系进行研究,希望能有助于风险预警,并采取相应对策,防御、降低风险。
     第一章评述了国内外在地方政府债务风险及其预警方面的研究成果和不足。第二章首先从债务负担和地方政府可支配资源两方面对地方政府债务风险进行界定,强调了地方政府双重主体身份,作为公共主体和经济主体,地方政府融资手段不同,由此形成的债务风险也不同。然后,从分权改革和地方政府竞争、行政管理体制缺陷、财政体制不完善、过度的市场化融资、债务管理缺乏规范以及经济体制转轨多层次多角度,全面分析地方政府债务风险形成机制。
     第三章建立了地方政府债务风险评估预警的理论框架。指出从总体层面和项目层面相结合构建地方政府债务风险预警基本框架,分析探讨了地方政府债务风险预警体系内涵、预警目标、预警程序、预警方法,并定性构建了相对完善的地方政府债务风险预警指标体系。
     第四章以江苏省为例对地方政府债务风险进行模拟分析。首先分析了江苏省地方政府债务和可支配资源现状,无论是流量经济资源,还是存量经济资源,都可以看出江苏省可用于抵御地方政府债务风险的资源是很紧张的。农村税费改革、规范土地出让金、加强社会保险资金的监督管理、紧缩地方融资政策等无疑将加剧地方政府债务风险。然后运用江苏省2000-2004年相关数据,在定性预警指标体系基础上,运用聚类分析法建立实际有效的指标体系,通过因子分析法,找出预警指标4个公共因子,分别是狭义债务风险因子、赤字风险因子、或有风险因子和收入结构风险因子。运用汤姆生因子得分法,得到公共因子以及风险临界值的得分,在此基础上借助神经网络理论构建地方政府债务风险预警模型,对2005年江苏省地方政府债务风险进行预警。
     目前由于体制的原因,政府动力不足,所以,监控和预警赋之于实践并且法制化还远不能做到,地方政府债务管理意识还没有真正树立起来,地方政府债务风险预警结果能否付诸于实施,防御、降低债务风险必须有相关制度建设配合。为此,本文第五章提出了一系列制度建设建议。包括建立地方政府债务风险预警组织体系、地方政府债务风险预警法规化、建立地方政府债务风险信息披露制度、建立偿债基金制度、建立地方政府债务风险预警结果处理机制。
During the transition period of China's local governments, economic and political decentralization of the system of centralized environment, the local government has become an independent economic interests and decentralized decision-making power of the main important. After the introduction of the reform of China's System of Tax Distribution, is obviously to strengthen and improve macro-control capacity of the central authorities at the same time, to varying degrees, all localities to increase the dependence on the central finance, the resulting plight of local government funding. As the market economy and deepen the transformation of government functions, local governments in order to readjust the economic structure, speeding up infrastructure construction, the use of various means of financing, through various channels to raise funds for construction, to a certain extent on strong impetus to local economic construction and social development of the cause. However, because the local governments lack the necessary legislative norms and effective supervision, the local government formed a long, the financing situation of disorder, the attendant is that local governments, covertly borrowing, dominant and recessive debt burden is becoming increasingly serious. As the local government financial distress, limited solvency, debt risks have become increasingly prominent, have produced many negative effects.
     Since the debt problem in China's local governments have been unable to avoid, but large-scale, has formed risks, and its concealment, better public face, be standardized, strengthen management. To guard against and defuse potential risks to ensure the smooth operation of economy and finance, local governments need to strengthen debt management, how early warning on the risk it is particularly urgent. In such circumstances, I choose the local government debt risk early warning system to study, hoping to contribute to the risk of early warning and to take corresponding countermeasures, defense, reducing risk.
     Review of the first chapter of the domestic and foreign debt in local government and its early warning of the risks of research results and inadequate. Chapter II First, from the debt burden and local government resources available to both local government debt risks defined, the local government stressed that the main dual identity as a public body and economic entities, different means of financing local government, the resulting debt risks Are also different. Then, from the decentralization of local government reform and competition, the administrative system defects, imperfect financial system, excessive market-oriented finance, debt management and a lack of standardized economic system restructuring and multi-level multi-angle, a comprehensive analysis of local government debt risk mechanism.
     Chapter III of the establishment of the local government debt risk assessment warning of theoretical framework. That the overall level of integration and project level debt risk early warning local governments build the basic framework for analysis of the local government debt risk early warning system meaning, early warning objectives, early warning procedures, early warning methods, and build a qualitative improvement of local government debt relative risk warning Index System.
     Chapter IV of Jiangsu Province as an example of local government debt risk simulation analysis. First of Jiangsu Province, local government debt and available resources of both flow of economic resources, economic resources or stock, can be seen in Jiangsu province can be used to resist the resources of local government debt risk is very tense. Rural tax and fee reform, standardizing the land transfer payment, social insurance funds to strengthen the supervision and management of local financing policy tightening, such as local government debt will undoubtedly aggravate the risk. Jiangsu Province, and then use the data from 2000 to 2004, in the qualitative indicators of early warning system based on the use of cluster analysis to establish practical and effective system of indicators, through factor analysis to identify early warning indicators of four public factor, which are narrow debt risks Factor, the deficit risk factor, or a risk factor and revenue structure risk factor. Thomson factor scoring method used by the public as well as risk factors critical value of the scoring, on the basis of this theory with neural network build local government debt risk early warning model, the 2005 Jiangsu Province, local government debt risk warning.
     Because the reasons for the current system, the power shortage, therefore, monitor and give early warning of the legal system and practice is still far failed to do, local government debt management awareness has not really established, the local government debt risk early warning can put the results in Implementation of defense, reducing the risk of debt must be related with the building of the system. To this end, the paper put forward a series of Chapter 5 of the proposed system the building. Including the establishment of local government debt risk early warning system organizations, local government debt risk early warning and regulations, establishment of local government debt risk information disclosure system, and actively establish and implement the sinking fund system, the establishment of local government debt risk early warning mechanism for handling results.
引文
[1]杰佛瑞·布伦南,詹姆斯M.布坎南,宪政经济学,中国社会科学出版社,2004
    [2]王军,中外专家谈地方财政建设,中国财政经济出版社,2006
    [3]萨尔瓦托雷·斯基亚沃-坎波,丹尼尔·托马西,公共支出管理,中国财政经济出版社,2001
    [4]毛程连,中高级公共经济学,复旦大学出版社,2006
    [5]杨之刚等,财政分权理论与基层公共财政改革,经济科学出版社,2006
    [6]杨柏、刘宜、岳中志,地方性主权外债风险及其防范,经济管理出版社,2007
    [7]刘尚希,财政风险及其防范问题研究,经济科学出版社,2004
    [8]丛树海,财政扩张风险与控制,商务印书馆,2005
    [9]武志,中国地方金融体系的改革与重构,东北财经大学出版社,2006
    [10]李建发,政府财务报告研究,厦门大学出版社,2006
    [11]邓子基,地方税系研究,经济科学出版社,2007
    [12]刘海英,地方政府间财政关系研究,中国财政经济出版社,2006
    [13]石英华,政府财务信息披露研究,中国财政经济出版社,2006
    [14]刘星,岳中志,刘谊,地方政府债务风险预警机制研究,经济管理出版社,2005
    [15]陈志楣,中国县乡财政风险问题研究,人民出版社,2007
    [16]宋立,刘树杰,各级政府公共服务事权财权配置,中国计划出版社,2005
    [17]陶勇,地方财政学,上海财经大学出版社,2006
    [18]高培勇,才是财政管理,经济科学出版社,2002
    [19]王雍君,中国公共支出实证分析,经济科学出版社,2000
    [20]薛薇,统计分析与SPSS的应用,中国人民大学出版社,2001
    [21]张建同,孙昌言,以Excel和SPSS为工具的管理统计,清华大学出版社,2005
    [22]许国根,许萍萍,谭宪林,MATLAB在化学中的应用,西安交通大学出版社,2005
    [23]曹信邦、裴育、欧阳华生,经济发达地区基层地方政府债务问题实证分析,财贸经济,2005(10)
    [24]姚绍学、宋立根、黄朝文,地方财政风险问题研究,财政研究,2001(12)
    [25]辛家鼎,关于规范地方政府融资体系的思考,山东电大学报,2001(1)
    [26]范红辉、芦杨,市场经济条件下政府职能与政府融资的研究,唐山学院学报,2005(9)
    [27]张远,地方政府债务的效应及形成机制新探,南京政治学院学报,2005(3)
    [28]赵迎春,地方政府债务风险防范研究——基于发达地区政府债务的样本分析,中央财经大学学报,2006(10)
    [29]严李锁、刘红全、成淑元,地方政府债务危及金融稳定问题初探,西安金融,2005(1)
    [30]宋立,市政收益债券:解决地方政府债务问题的重要途径,管理世界,2004(2)
    [31]顾建光,地方政府债务与风险防范对策研究,经济体制改革,2006(1)
    [32]宋立,分类分流解决地方政府债务问题,宏观经济管理,2004(4)
    [33]曹艳杰,赋予发债权与地方政府行政运行现状的关系,中共福建省委党校学报,2006(3)
    [34]唐云锋,公共选择理论视角下地方债务的成因分析,财经论丛,2005(1)
    [35]吴垠,公共选择视角下中国财政制度的演进方向,重庆工商大学学报(社会科学版),2005(4)
    [36]刘尚希、赵全厚,政府债务:风险状况的初步分析,管理世界,2002(5)
    [37]卢文鹏、尹晨,隐性担保、补偿替代与政府债务,财贸经济,2004(1)
    [38]马栓友,中国公共部门债务和赤字的可持续性分析,经济研究,2001(8)
    [39]谭建立、王继光,关于我国统一财权制度必要性的思考,山西师大学报(社会科学版),2006(1)
    [40]邹江涛,论我国地方财政运行中的道德风险问题,中央财经大学学报,2006(1)
    [41]殷士浩、刘小兵,政府资产风险:地方财政风险分析的一个新视角,财贸研究,2004(4)
    [42]孙克竞,美国地方公债管理与我国地方政府举债预研,汕头大学学报,2006(3)
    [43]马欣,法国地方政府的债务管理,中国投资,2002(8)
    [44]傅志华、陈少强,美国防治地方财政危机的实践与启示,国际经济评论,2004(7)
    [45]陈晓红、梁庆凯,目前国家开发银行城建贷款的风险及其防范,中南大学学报(社会科学版),2004(10)
    [46]王美涵,土地出让金的财政学分析,财经论丛,2005(7)
    [47]陈文府,我国地方债券市场的开放逻辑探析,北方经贸,2006(3)
    [48]陶雄华,试析中国地方政府债务的债券化,财贸经济,2002 (12)
    [49]刘守英、蒋省三,土地融资与财政和金融风险——来自东部一个发达地区的个案,中国土地科学,2005(10)
    [50]黄春蕾,外国地方政府债务管理的比较与启示,金融教学与研究,2006(3)
    [51]欧阳华生,我国地方政府显性债务问题实证分析,审计与经济研究,2005(11)
    [52]唐云锋,我国地方政府债务的扩张机制研究——基于委托代理理论框架下的分析,财经论丛,2006(3)
    [53]钟振强、宋丹兵、刘寒波,现代预算理念与中国政府预算管理制度改革——兼论新型综合财政预算的构建,贵州财经学院学报,2006(2)
    [54]毕记满、杨成文,隐性债务下的政府会计改革探析,审计与经济研究,2007(5)
    [55]刘顺义,中国地方政府届别机会主义倾向经济行为探讨,甘肃理论学刊,2005(3)
    [56]李砚忠、李军保,地方政府债务的内源性探析与解决路径,今日中国论坛,2007(4)
    [57]袁佩佳,资产负债管理框架下的地方财政可持续性分析,地方财政研究,2006(3)
    [58]邓宏祥,地方公共债务纳入财政预算管理的思考,四川财政,2002(3)
    [59]黄燕、孟繁 ,地方政府行为演变的阶段性特征及其趋势分析,管理现代化,2006(4)
    [60]赵健梅、王春莉,财务危机预警在我国上市公司的实证研究,数量经济技术经济研究,2003(7)
    [61]孙昂,基层政府债务问题的宏观视角透析,现代经济探讨,2005(8)现代济探讨
    [62]张陆伟,波兰地方政府融资发展过程及对我国的借鉴意义,中国社会科学院研究生院,2007(3)
    [63]刘尚希,财政风险:从经济总量角度的分析,管理世界,2005(7)
    [64]刘尚希,财政风险:一个分析框架,经济研究,2003(5)
    [65]岳晓菲,财政风险研究的新思路,内蒙古科技与经济,2007(2)
    [66]张志超等,财政风险——成因、估测与防范,中国财政经济出版社,2004(6)
    [67]侯荣华、葛建新.中国财政风险研究,中国计划出版社,2005(4)
    [68]王金龙等,财政风险与金融风险,中国财政经济出版社,2004 (12))
    [69]邢会强,财政危机防范法:国外经验及其借鉴,中国财经信息资料,2005(1)
    [70]盛光明、周会,地方财政风险转嫁问题研究,长春大学学报,2007(7)
    [71]寇铁军、张海星,地方政府债务风险评价及预警系统研究,投资研究,2004(2)
    [72]裴育、欧阳华生,地方债务风险预警程序与指标体系的构建,当代财经,2006(3)
    [73]贾建学,地方政府债务预算编制初探,安阳工学院学报,2007(4)
    [74]马树来、洪中强,防范财政风险必须将政府债务收支纳入预算管理,预算管理与会计,2004(6)
    [75]马海涛、吕强,我国地方政府债务风险问题研究,财政经济评论,2003(2)
    [76]杨萍,发展市政债券市场的相关问题研究综述,经济研究参考,2006(33)
    [77]张明喜,关于我国财政风险和风险预警的研究综述,上海财经大学学报,2007(4)
    [78]胥德勋、周剑波,基层政府高负债与高金融相关性分析及对策建议,西南金融,2004(2)
    [79]黄继鸿、雷战波、凌超,经济预警方法研究综述,系统工程,2003(3)
    [80]冯兴元、李晓佳,论城市政府负债与市政债券的规则秩序框架,管理世界,2005(3)
    [81]朱柏铭、徐利君,公债适度规模评判指标的剖析及改进,中央财经大学学报,2002(5)
    [82]匡小平,论地方财政可持续性的分析方法,财经理论与实践(双月刊),2004(11)
    [83]刘军民,我国地方财政健康程度的评价分析与改进思路,华中师范大学学报(人文社会科学版),2007(3)
    [84]欧阳华生、裴育,我国地方政府债务的区域比较分析,财经论丛,2006(1)
    [85]裴育,欧阳华生,我国地方政府债务风险预警理论分析,中国软科学,2007(3)
    [86]李龙、李东、张玉龙,进一步完善会计制度,把政府债务如实反映在帐面上,现代审计与会计,2006(2)
    [87]王晓光,地方政府债务的风险评价与控制,统计与决策,2005(9)下
    [88]李军杰,地方政府竞争引发调控困境,中国投资,2006(10)
    [89] June Pallot ,Local Government Reform in New Zealand: Options for Public Management as Governance. http:// www.willamette.org/ipmn/test/papers/pallot.htm.
    [90] Honohan、Patrick and Daniela,Klingebiel, Controlling Fiscal costs of Banking Crises. Mimeo,World Bank,2000..
    [91] Hana .Polackova , Government Contingent Liability—A Hidden Risk ,Quarterly Magazine of the IMF, Volume36, Number 1, March 1999.
    [92] RichardM.Bird & Thomas A.Wilson. A Tax Strategy for Ontario. http:// www.law-lib.utoronto.ca/investing/index.htm
    [93] The Public Finance Sector Debt Management Strategy in t he years 2005—2007,波兰财政部网站。
    [94] Kaminsky,Graciela.,Lizondo,Sau1.And Reinhart,CarmenM.(1997)“Leading indicators of Currency Crises”.IMF WorkingPaper WPI97/7
    [95] Iev Freinkman、Gohar Gyulumyan and Artak Kyurumyan,Quisi-Fiscal Activities,Hidden Government Subsidies,and Fiscal Adjustment in Armenia, World Bank.
    [96] Allen Schick. Budgeting for Fiscal Risk. 2000. The World Bank.
    [97] Hana Polackova Brixi & Allen Schick. Government at Risk. Contingent Liabilities and Fiscal Risk. World Bank and Oxford University Press,2002.
    [98] Hana Polackova Brixi &Ashoka mody. Dealing with Government Fiscal Risk:An overview. World Bank and Oxford University Press,2002.
    [99] Hana Polackova Brixi, Hafez, Ghanem & Roumeen , Islam. Fiscal Adjustmentand Contingment Liablities. Case Studies of the Czech Republic and Macedonia. Working Paper,1999, No.2177.World Bank.
    [100] Bohn . H ,A Positive Theory of Foreign Currency Debt. Journal of Intemational Economics,1990.
    [101] Hana Polackova Brixi、Sergei、Shatalor & Leila , Zlaoui, Managing Fiscal Risk in Bulgaria. Working Paper ,2000, No.2282.World Bank.
    [102] Tanzi、Vito & George Tsibouris. Fiscal Reform Over Ten Years of Transition, Working Paper ,2000, No.113, World Bank.
    [103] Allen Schick, Toward a Code of Good Practice on Managing Fiscal Risk.,Oxford University Press,2001.
    [104] Asad Alam & Mark Sundberg,A Decade of Fiscal Transition,Working Paper,2002,No.2835. World Bank.
    [105] Dornbusch, Rudiger and Mario Draghi, Public Debt Management Theory and History , Canbridge University Press,1990.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700