摘要
研究林纸一体化项目规模经济问题,对于处理好林业内部细分产业之间、林业与农业之间以及林业与浆纸业之间的协调发展,兼顾好林纸一体化项目与交通运输等行业的促进和制约关系,在项目规划和建设中确定林纸一体化项目的适度规模、减少社会资源的浪费、提升项目的经济、生态以及社会效益,有着很重要的作用。
本文依据森林经理学基本原理及森林可持续经营规划与资源管理方法,在研究现有林纸一体化及规模经济理论成果和实践经验的基础上,综合运用理论归纳、定性分析、计量分析、MFA和CSA模型创建、实证分析等方法,结合实际案例对林纸一体化项目规模经济问题开展研究。
论文分为七个部分,首先叙述了本文的研究背景、目的和意义,并对研究思路、方法与结构作了叙述。
第二部分为理论研究,主要阐述林纸一体化和规模经济理论,重点分析了纸业原料路线的演变、林纸一体化内涵及国内外学者的研究动态;论述了规模经济的内涵、作用、新特征、理论基础及形成机理,分析了国内外关于规模经济的研究进展,总结了关于规模经济的主要理论成就。笔者对理论研究进展提出了自已的观点。
第三部分对林纸一体化国内外现状开展对比分析,主要分析了造纸工业的作用、特点、林纸一体化的优点以及国际和国内林纸一体化现状;指出了实施林纸一体化存在的难点问题及在项目规模经济方面存在的误区。
第四部分采用MFA(Multi-factors analysis)和CSA(Cost structure analysis)分析林纸一体化项目规模经济的影响因素,研究各种影响因素的定性或定量关系,深入分析了林纸一体化项目的主要影响因素,以及这些影响因素对林纸一体化项目产生制约和促进作用的具体途径和方式,研究分析了林纸一体化项目木材原料的定价方法及其对项目规模经济的影响,建立了项目适度经济规模的计量模型,对林纸一体化项目规模经济问题开展了比较透彻的分析论证。
平均成本ACp=[(C1+C2+C3+C4)/Qw+Lp1*(β1+α1Q)]*(1+θ)*4+Lp2*(β2+α2Q) +Ω+0.7*[Pe+Lp3*(β3+α3Q)]+0.4*[Pc+Lp4*(p4+α4Q)]+λQγ+φ
其中λ>0,γ<0 (4-27)
ACp'=Lp1*α1*(1+θ)*4+Lp2*α2+0.7*Lp3*α3+0.4*Lp4*α4+λγQγ-1(4-28)
ACp"=λγ(γ-1)Qγ-2>0 (4-29)
平均成本最小时的产量Q*=[-(Lp1*α1*[(1+θ)*4+Lp2*α2+0.7*Lp3*α3+ 0.4*Lp4*α4)/(λγ)]1/(γ-1)是单调递减的幂函数,当主要物资的运输费用率Lp1、Lp2、Lp3、Lp4上升时,林纸一体化项目最低成本产量值变小。
项目利润π=P*Q-[(C1+C2+C3+C4)/Qw+Lp1*(β1+α1Q)]*4*Q- Lp2*(β2+α2Q)*Q-Ω*Q-0.7*[Pe+Lp3*(β3+α3Q)]*Q-0.4*[Pc+Lp4*(β4+α4Q)]*Q-ρQμ-φ*Q,其中ρ>0,μ>1 (4—35)
π'=P-4*(C1+C2+C3+C4)/Qw-4*Lp1*β1-8*α1Q-Lp2*β2-2*Lp2*α2*木Q-Ω-0.7*(Pe+ Lp3*β3)-2*0.7*Lp3*α3Q-0.4*(Pc+Lp4*β4)-2*0.4*Lp4*α4Q-ρμQμ-1-φ(4-36)
π"=-8*α1-2*Lp2*α2-2*0.7*Lp3*α3-2*0.4*Lp4*α4-ρμ(μ-1)Qμ-2<0,林纸一体化项目总利润存在极大值。
第五部分案例研究,通过四川泸州竹林浆纸一体化项目规模经济问题的实证分析,验证了项目规模经济计量模型,证实了本文研究成果对实际工作的指导效果。
第六部分研究了加快实现林纸一体化项目规模经济性的策略和措施;提出了实现林纸一体化项目规模经济特性的八项建议意见。
第七部分对整篇论文进行总结,指出了本文的主要创新点,提出了本文研究成果的应用建议,对今后学习和研究的方向作出了展望。
It has a very important role to study on the economies of scale in terms of forestry-paper integration project, for the deal with the coordination between the forestry industry within the subdivision, forestry and agriculture, forestry and pulp-paper industry, the development of forestry-paper integration project with a good balance between transportation and other industries, the relationship between promotion and constraints in forestry-paper integration project planning and construction to determine appropriate scale and reduce the waste of social resources to enhance the project's economic, ecological and social benefits.
In this paper, it has been based on the basic principles of forest management and sustainable forest management planning and resource management, the basis of existing theoretical results and practical experience about forestry-paper integration and economies of scale, and the integrated use of theory induction, qualitative analysis, quantitative analysis, MFA and the CSA model creation, empirical analysis and other methods, combined with practical case of economies of scale on the forestry-paper integration project to undertake research.
The paper is divided into seven parts. Firstly, the research background, purpose and significance, and research ideas, methods and structures were described.
The second part is theoretical research, mainly on theory about forestry-paper integration and economies of scale. The evolution of guidelines on the paper industry's raw material, the connotation of forestry-paper integration and the results of domestic and foreign scholars' research are analyzed. The meaning, function, new features, theoretical foundations and the formation mechanism of economies of scale and the progress of the domestic and international research on economies of scale are discussed. The major theoretical achievements on economies of scale are summarized. At this chapter, the evaluation of theoretical research results has been made.
The comparative analysis of forestry-paper integration situation between domestic and foreign are carry out at the chapter three. In this chapter, the main role and the characteristics of paper industry, the advantages of forestry-paper integration and the situation of forestry-paper integration between international and domestic are analyzed. The difficult problems of the implementation of forestry-paper integration and the existence error of economies of scale in the project are pointed out.
In the fourth part, MFA (Multi-factors analysis) and CSA (Cost structure analysis) are used to study the factors of economies of scale in terms of forestry-paper integration project, the qualitative or quantitative relationship between these various factors. The main factors of forestry-paper integration project and the specific constraints and promote ways and means of these factors on the forestry-paper integration project are analyzed in-depth. Wood raw material pricing model and its impact on economies of scale of the project is researched and analyzed. The measurement model about appropriate scale of forestry-paper integration project was established. The analysis and demonstration in economies of scale of forestry-paper integration project were carried out relative clearly.
The average cost is expressed by ACP. ACP=[(C1+C2+C3+C4)/Qw+Lpi*(β1+α1Q)]* (1+θ)*4+Lp2*(β2+α2Q)+Ω+0.7*[Pe+Lp3*(β3+α3Q)]+0.4*[Pc+Lp4*(β4+α4Q)]+λQγ+φ, whereλ>0,γ<0 (4-27)
ACp'=Lp1*α1*(1+θ)*4+Lp2*α2+0.7*Lp3*α3+0.4*Lp4*α4+λγQγ-1 (4-28)
ACp"=λγ(γ-1)Qγ-2>0(4-29)
The scale of production with the lowest average cost is expressed by Q*.Q*=[-(Lp1*α1* (1+θ)*4+Lp2*α2+0.7*Lp3*α3+0.4*Lp4*α4)/(λγ)]1/(γ-1). This is a monotonically decreasing power function, when the rate of major goods transport costs Lp1、Lp2、Lp3、Lp4 rise, the lowest cost production value of forestry-paper integration project becomes smaller.
Project profit is expressed byπ.π=P*Q-[(C1+C2+C3+C4)/Qw+Lp1*(β1+α1Q)]*4*Q-Lp2*(β2+α2Q*Q-Ω*Q-0.7*[Pe+Lp3*(β3+α3Q)]*Q-0.4*[Pc+Lp4*(β4+α4Q)]*Q-ρQμ-φ>*Q, wherep>0,μ>1 (4-35)
π'=P-4*(C1+C2+C3+C4)/Qw-4*Lp1*β1-8*α1Q-Lp2*β2-2*Lp2*α2*Q-Ω-0.7*(Pe+ Lp3*β3)-2*0.7*Lp3*α3Q-0.4*(Pc+Lp4*β4)-2*0.4*Lp4*α4Q-ρQμ-1-φ(4-36)
π"=-8*α1-2* Lp2*α2-2*0.7* Lp3*α3-2*0.4*Lp4*α4-ρμ(μ-1)Qμ-2<0, there is the maximum total profits of forestry-paper integration project.
PartⅤis the case studies. Through the empirical analysis of economies of scale about bamboo pulp-paper integration project in Sichuan Luzhou, the econometric model of project scale is verified and the results of this study guiding the actual work is confirmed.
In partⅥ, the strategy and measures to accelerate the realization of economies of scale of forestry-paper integration project were studied and the eight proposals to achieve economies of scale features of forestry-paper integration project were put forward.
PartⅦis the conclusion, the whole thesis is summarized and the main innovation is pointed out. The application proposal of this research is presented. The future direction of Study and research is forecasted.
引文
[1]佘光辉,森林资源(生态)监测理论与方法,2009,9
[2]胡元明,抓住机遇实现我国林纸产业一体化发展,林业经济,1995.(6):20-24
[3]周卫玲,组建林业造纸集团是实现林纸一体化的有效模式,中国林业企业.1988.(1):37-39
[4]李德深等,松花江沿江林区发展林纸一体化经营的探讨,东北林业大学学报,1999.27(2):48-51
[5]孙春雷等,林纸一体化企业总体构架和运作模式的基本思路,中华纸业,1999.(6):16-21
[6]张树军等,实施林纸一体化是解决我国林兴纸旺的有效途径,林业科技开发,2000.4(3):55-56
[7]曹朴芳,关于加快造纸工业原料林基地建设促进我国木浆造纸发展的思考,中华纸业,2001.22(12):14-17
[8]童南燕,林纸一体化企业集团的组建与资本运营,中华纸业.,2001.22(6):10-12
[9]肖友智,林纸结合的有关思考,林业经济问题(双月刊),2001.21(2):108-110
[10]胡楠,林纸一体化与投资多元化,中华纸业,2003.24(2):8-12
[11]袁晖,中国造纸工业现状和林纸一体化,四川林勘设计,2003.(2):12-17
[12]贺燕丽,贯彻落实林纸一体化规划努力推动林纸一体化发展,中华纸业,2004.25(7):6-9
[13]张忠根等,林纸一体化的收益与成本分析,绿色中国,2004.(5):54-55
[14]张素风等,造纸工业要重视资源与环境问题走循环经济的工业化道路,西南造纸,2005.34(2):4-6
[15]邹毅实,我国林纸一体化的模式构建与综合评价研究,南京林业大学博士论文,2006,22-23
[16]Edgard Campinhos.Jr.More wood of better quality through intensive silviculture with rapid-growth improved Brazilian Ecualyptus [J].Tappi,1980,63(11):145
[17]Seppo Kellomzhi. Forest resources and sustainable management [J].Papermaking Science & Technology, 1998, (7):2-4
[18]Guoliang Liu, John D. Nelson, Chad W. Wardman. A target-oriented approach to forest ecosystem design-changing the rules of forest planning [J].Ecological Modelling,2000, (127):269-281
[19]Christian Gamborg, Jorgen Bo Larson. Back to nature-a sustainable future for foresty? [J].Forest Ecology and Management,2003, (179):559
[20]Hannu Oinonen. Russia wants investment [J]. Paper & Timber,2003, (2):72-75
[21]Dan W Cumbo, Robert L Smith, Charles W Becker Ⅲ. Value analysis of lumber produced from small diameter timber [J].Forest Products Journal,2004, (54):29-36
[22]芬兰F&P北欧林纸集团,2004,芬兰林纸技术及其发展概况,纸和造纸,2004.增刊:97-100
[23]萧启寿,我国林纸结合的回顾与展望,国际造纸,1995.14(4):10-13
[24]陈贵松,展望林纸结合的新发展,林业经济问题(双月刊),2001.21(1):18-21
[25]吴武汉等.林业与造纸工业可持续发展的“吨纸田”生产模式[J].天津造纸,1995,(3):2-11
[26]陈奇志,1996,造纸原料林基地建设,国际造纸,1996.19(3):6-13
[27]张钢.林纸结合概述[J].世界林业研究,1996,(4):32-35
[28]聂影,任启芳,王书存.我国造纸工业可持续发展的系统分析[J].中华纸业,1998,(5):17-20
[29]任启芳,王书存.可持续发展与我国造纸工业[J]中华纸业,1999,(1):12-13
[30]韦国海.合理利用非木材原料与中国造纸工业的可持续发展[J].国际造纸,1999,18(3):1-4
[31]王树生等.发展木浆造纸实现可持续发展[J].中国林业企业,2000,(4):11-14
[32]罗海滨.浅析中国造纸工业的可持续发展道路[J].浙江造纸,2000,(3):10-11
[33]刘伟平.林纸结合的制度变迁研究[J].林业经济问题,2000,20(4):194-206
[34]牛素芬等.推行清洁生产是造纸工业走可持续发展的必由之路[J].山东环境,2000(增):11-12
[35]吴福骞.加强林业建设增加造纸用材[J].中国造纸,2000,(2):46-50
[36]陈克复,对广东省造纸工业持续发展的思考,中华纸业,2001,22(5):34-36
[37]陈炎生.谈上海造纸工业的可持续发展[J].中华纸业,2001,22(2):33-34
[38]林凤鸣等.日本林产品供需现状和发展趋势[J].世界林业研究,2002,15(1):68-73
[39]肖友智,论林纸结合的理论根源及战略再造,林业经济问题,2002,1
[40]毛吏.纸业可持续发展的思考[J].国际造纸,2003,22(2):11-13
[41]郭勇.日本造纸业考察记[J].纸和造纸,2004,(5):96-97
[42]刘文英等.我国造纸业发展循环经济的构想[J].中国人口.资源与环境,2004,14(5):108-112
[43]王海刚.实施造纸工业的可持续发展[J].纸和造纸,2004,(2):5-8
[44]吴武汉等.中国在林纸一体化进程中必须走创新之路[J],天津造纸,2004,(3);21-22
[45]杨懋暹,发展林纸一体化.突破木浆“瓶颈”之我见,中华纸业,2004.25(10):8-12
[46]叶尚言.林纸紧密结合的巴西制浆厂[J].纸和造纸,2004,(1):83-85
[47]国家林业局,全国林纸一体化工程建设“十五”及2010年专项规划,造纸信息,2004.(4):1-6
[48]肖平,张敏新.原料基地的战略价值研究—期权定价模型的应用[J].林业科学,2004,40(6):165-169
[49]张意轩.国外的“林”“纸”关系[J].新闻周刊,2004,(12):5-26
[50]张忠根等.林纸一体化的收益与成本分析[J].绿色中国,2004,(5):54-55
[51]顾民达.循环经济在我国造纸工业中的应用[J].上海造纸,2005,36(3):3-8,38
[52]胡宗渊.实施林纸一体化加快建设造纸速生林基地走循环经济之路为实现现代造纸工业而努力[J].造纸信息,2005,(10):4-6
[53]胡宗渊.调整我国造纸原料结构合理利用非木材纤维资源[J].上海造纸,2005,36(2):4-6,54
[54]张静.大力推进林板(纸)一体化建设促进河北林业可持续发展[J].中国林业企业,2005,(1):3-4,10
[55]林文耀.我国非木材纤维制浆与碱回收的现状和发展前景[J].中华纸业,2005,26(4):24-27
[56]林文耀.我国非木材纤维制浆与碱回收的现状和发展前景(续)[J].中华纸业,2005,26(5):23-26
[57]吴福骞,谈造纸工业循环经济(二)——保护、培育和利用森林资源,中华纸业,2005,26(7):14-17
[58]吴福骞.谈造纸工业循环经济(三)[J].中华纸业,2005,26(8):18-21
[59]吴玉辉等.在循环经济的轨道上实施苇纸一体化发展绿色造纸产业[J].中华纸业,2005,26(1):13-16
[60]姚卫星,宋岭,新疆博斯滕湖地区造纸企业发展循环经济启示[J],生产力研究,2005,(5):111-113
[61]余贻骥.关于林纸一体化工程建设的探讨[J].上海造纸,2005,36(4):3-18
[62]余贻骥.实施全国林纸一体化工程建设的前景展望[J].纸和造纸,2005,(1):9-10
[63]张素风等,造纸工业要重视资源与环境问题走循环经济的工业化道路,西南造纸,2005,34(2):4-6
[64]顾民达.中国正在加快推进林纸一体化工程建设[J].中华纸业,2006,27(10):19-25
[65]刘文英等.循环经济模式:生产、消费、分解与生态、资源的统一——以造纸业循环经济为例[J],生产力研究,2006,(9):35-37
[66]王妹,张智光.林纸一体化企业的资源一环境核算研究(I)森林资源资产会计核算[J].林业经济问题,2006,26(2):125-125
[67]王妹,张智光.林纸一体化企业的资源一环境(II)森林资源资产会计核算[J].林业经济问题,2006,26(4):335-338
[68]邹毅实,张智光.林纸一体化动力机制模型的构建与分析[J].南京林业大学学报(自然科学版),2006,30(4):33-37
[69]邹毅实,张智光.林纸一体化动力系统形成理论的研究[J].中华纸业,2006,26(4):26-29
[70]邹毅实,杜姗姗,张智光.林纸一体化模式分析与探讨[J].中华纸业,2006,25(7):60-4
[71]邹毅实,张智光,杜姗姗,林纸一体化理论支撑体系的研究[J],林业经济问题(双月刊),2006,26(3):220-223
[72]陈帆,祝秀莲,黄国忠.生态工业园区对于我国造纸工业的可持续发展适用性研究[J].中国资源综合利用,2007,25(1):14-17
[73]范文波,陈奇志.合理利用外资促进我国纸业可持续发展[J].造纸信息,2007,(5):16-19
[74]吴栋钢.试论造纸工业循环经济——兼述部分企业的实施经验[J].中华纸业,2007,28(3):10-18
[75]余贻骥.中国造纸工业循环经济的进展[J].纸和造纸,2007,26(1):1-3
[76]杨加猛,邹毅实,张智光.林纸一体化模式的评价方法及应用研究[J].中国造纸,2007,26(2):61-64
[77]张琼,杨少辉.我国废纸回收利用与造纸工业可持续发展[J].造纸科学与技术,2007,26(2):30-33
[78]姜华等.林纸一体化项目环境影响分析及其对策建议[J].环境保护,2008,(2):24-27
[79]张智光.多视角下的林纸一体化体系结构研究IJ].中国造纸,2008,27(1):67-71
[80]李忠正.我国制浆造纸工业现代化的思考[J].北方造纸,1997,(1):26-30
[81]李忠正.禾草类纤维制浆特性及进一步发展我国非木材纤维造纸的对策[J],中华纸业,2006,27(2):6-11
[82]李忠正.合理利用禾草类纤维造纸的理论与实践[J].上海造纸,2006,37(5):4-9
[83]李忠正.中国草类纤维制浆的理论与技术研究[J].中国造纸,2007,26(12):71-74
[84]姚惠芳,中国造纸工业循环经济系统研究(D),博士论文,2008,6
[85]林金忠.论规模经济的四种形态[J].经济科学,2002,6
[86]迈克·波特.竞争优势[M].华夏出版社,1997
[87]施蔚,江苏木材加工产业的规模经济问题研究,2007
[88][美]平狄克,鲁宾费尔德,微观经济学(Microeconomics by R.S.Pindyck, D.L.Rubinfeld)第四版中译本
[89]黎诣远,西方经济学微观经济学(第3版),高等教育出版社,2007,9
[90]亚当·斯密.国民财富的性质和原因的研究[M].商务印书馆,1972
[91]约翰·斯图亚特·穆勒.政治经济学原理[M].商务印书馆,1991
[92]卡尔·马克思.资本论(第一卷)[M].商务印书馆,1994
[93][英]马歇尔.经济学原理(上卷)[M].商务印书馆,1994
[94]斯拉法.用商品生产商品[M].商务印书馆,1991
[95]阿林·杨格.报酬递增与经济进步[J].经济社会体制比较,1996(2)
[96]梁小民、姚开建主编.西方经济学名著概览[M].中国物资出版社,1998
[97]戴骥,葛琼,规模经济问题的文献综述[J],经济师,2009,(1):52-53
[98]Coase. R., The Nature of The Firm. Economic[M],4,1937
[99]威廉姆森.反托拉斯经济学——兼并、协约和策略行为[M].经济科学出版社,1999
[100]巴克利,卡森.跨国公司的未来[M].中国金融出版社,2005
[101]钱德勒.企业规模经济和范围经济—工业资本主义的原动力[M].中国社会科学出版社,1999
[102][美]大卫·M·安德森,B·约瑟夫·派恩二世,21世纪企业竞争前沿:大规模定制模式下的敏捷产品开发,机械工业出版社,1999
[103][美]迈克尔·迪屈奇.交易成本经济学[M].经济科学出版社,1999
[104]彭光明.规模经济与银行战略——基于银行业务性质的研究[D].硕士论文,2008
[105]Layard, P. and Verry, D.W., cost functions for university teaching and research[J].economics journal, 1975, V85, Issue337:55-74
[106]梁小民,姚开建.西方经济学名著精览[M].中国物资出版社,1998
[107]Chambers, Robert G.. Economies of scale and scope at depositary financial institutions:a review of the literature[J].Economics review, V73,1988
[108]Hunter, william C., Timme, Stephen G. Some evidence on the impact of quasi-fixed inputs on bank scale economy estimation[J].Economic review, V76, N.3,1991
[109]Subal C.Kumbhakar. Short-run returns to scale, farm-size.and economic efficiency[J].review of economics and statistics, MIT Press,1993, Volume 75, Issue 2
[110]Aller M. Featherstone and charles bomoss.Measuring economics of scale and scope in agricultural banking[J]. Journal of American agriculture economics,1994, N4
[111]H. E. Frech Ⅲ and Lee Rivers Mobley. Resolving the impasses on hospital scale economics:a new approach[J].Applied economics,1995, V27N3
[112]Greg walker, Economics of scale in Australian banks 1978-1990[J], Australian economic papers, V37, N.I,1998
[113]Catherine J.Morrison Paul and Donald S.Siegel, scale economics industry agglomeration externalities:a dynamic cost function approach[J],the American economic review,1999.3, V89, N1
[114][美]小艾尔弗雷德·D·钱德勒.企业规模经济与范围经济[M].中国社会科学出版社,1999
[115]徐传湛,郑贵廷,齐树天.我国商业银行规模经济问题与金融改革策略透析[J].经济研究,2002(10)
[116]杜莉,王峰,齐树天.我国商业银行规模经济及其状态比较[J].吉林大学社会科学学报,2003(1)
[117]刘宗华,邹新月.中国银行业的规模经济和范围经济—基于广义超越对数成本函数的检验[J].数量技术经济研究,2004(10)
[118]刘光大.西方规模经济理论与应用评价[J].石油化工技术经济,1995,11(2):68-74
[119]中国造纸协会,中国造纸工业2009年度报告,中国造纸年鉴,2010
[120]胡楠,制度创新是我国纸业发展战略的核心,造纸信息,2001.(6):3
[121]王亚平,加快发展我国林纸一体化,宏观经济管理,2002.(10):40-42
[122]国家轻工局、国家林业局,关于加快林纸一体化建设振兴中国纸业的请示,中华纸业,2001.22(12):85-86
[123]钱志新,竞争力三元结构—大型企业集团发展论,江苏人民出版社,1999
[124]任浩等,企业集团组织设计,学林出版社,2005
[125]徐声星,中国造纸产业国际竞争力研究,2008,10
[126]中国造纸学会,中国造纸年鉴,中国经工业出版社,2010
[127]黄和亮,林地资源的价格体系研究,林业经济问题(双月刊),2006,6,26(3):234-236,264
[128]刘家顺,论林业分类经营和森林资源分类经营,林业经济,1996,(5):13-14
[129]国家发改委,全国林纸一体化工程建设“十五”及2010年专项规划,造纸信息,2004
[130]国家发展和改革委员会,全国林纸一体化工程建设“十五”及2010年专项规划,造纸信息,2004,4
[131]曹振雷.林浆纸一体化的国家战略意义及实践中的困难.中造纸学报.2004,19
[132]傅光华.林纸一体化是国民经济发展的必然要求.中国造纸学会第十二届年会学术论文集(上),2005