森林资源资产批量评估研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
随着我国林权制度改革的不断深入和我国森林资源资产市场的快速发展,各种森林资源资产的交易日趋频繁,交易规模也不断扩大。而森林资源资产交易的核心问题是森林资源资产价格的确定,为森林资源资产产权交易提供价值服务的森林资源资产评估工作的重要性日趋显著。在我国的森林资源资产评估的实践过程中,大量的森林资源资产评估业务操作采用的是传统的单项评估方法,存在一致性差、效率低、成本高、耗时长、评估结论较难被市场接受等问题。将批量评估方法引入到森林资源资产评估业务中,不但能很好地解决采用单项评估方法存在的问题,而且能够为森林资源资产评估提供一个新的评估路径,丰富了森林资源资产评估的理论体系。
     以森林资源资产批量评估研究为主线,在梳理了国内外研究动态及进展的基础上,辨析了森林资源资产批量评估相关概念的内涵,分析了森林资源资产单项评估实践中存在的问题,探究了森林资源资产批量评估方法的适用性;进而设计了森林资源资产批量评估的总体框架;依据东北林区森林资源资产的特点及价值影响因素,利用黑龙江省某国有林场林权制度改革的实际数据,构建了适用于东北林区的森林资源资产批量评估模型并进行了实证分析;提出了推进森林资源资产批量评估开展的外部环境建设具体措施。
     研究结论表明:影响幼龄林单位评估价值的主要因素有林龄、平均树高、公顷株数、前三年的营林生产成本、树种;影响中龄林单位评估价值的主要因素有林龄、平均胸径、平均树高、公顷蓄积、原木销售价格、原木出材率、树种、木材经营成本(含税费);影响成熟林单位评估价值的主要因素有原木销售价格、木材经营成本(含税费)、公顷蓄积、平均树高、平均胸径、原木出材率、运距、树种。由于幼龄林、中龄林、成熟林森林资源资产单位评估价值的影响因素不同,应分别构建幼龄林、中龄林、成熟林的批量评估模型。分别构建的批量评估模型实证结果表明公顷株数、林龄的自然对数、平均胸径的自然对数、优势树种等解释变量对幼龄林单位评估价值有重要影响;原木销售价格、林龄的自然对数、公顷蓄积的自然对数、优势树种等解释变量对中龄林单位评估价值有重要影响;原木销售价格、公顷蓄积的自然对数、平均胸径、原木出材率的自然对数、优势树种等解释变量对成熟林单位评估价值有重要影响。此外,推动森林资源资产批量评估开展应做好建立“注册资产评估师(森林)”执业资格制度、对森林资源资产评估机构实行分级管理、深化林业体制改革以激发社会需求、对森林资源资产评估与森林价值核算实行分类管理、加大森林资源资产评估人才的培养力度、加快推进林业信息化以搭建森林资源资产批量评估的数据平台等外部环境建设。
With the further reform of forest tenure and rapid development of forest resource asset markets in China, more and more forestry assets resources trading arises with the increasing size. The core problem of the forest resource asset trading is how to determine the price of forest resource asset, so that the appraisal of forest resource asset value that provides the value service for the property transaction of the forest resource asset is increasingly important. In practice, the traditional individual appraisal method is used in quantities of forest resource asset appraisal business in China, resulting in some problems such as poor consistency, low efficiency, high cost and time consuming, as well as the appraisal conclusion that is difficult to be accepted by the market. The introduction of mass appraisal method into forest resource asset appraisal business can properly solve the problems existing in individual assessment methods, and also provide a new path to appraise forest resource assets so as to extend the theoretical system of forest resources asset appraisal.
     Based on the researches at home and abroad on the mass appraisal of forest resource assets, through a thorough review of research progress and development at home and abroad, the paper discriminates the connotation of concepts relating to the mass appraisal of forest resource assets, analyzes the problems in the practice of individual appraisal of forest resource assets, and explores the applicability of mass appraisal method of forest resource assets in order to design the overall framework of mass appraisal of the forest resource assets. According to the factors affecting the characteristics and values of forest resource assets in northeast forest area, using actual data of forest tenure reform from some state-owned forest farm in Heilongjiang Province, the paper presents the model for mass appraisal of forest resource assets in the Northeast forest area through an empirical analysis, and proposes the specific measures for promoting the development of the external environment for mass appraisal of forest resource assets.
     The research results show the main factors affecting the appraisal value per unit young forest include stand age, average tree height, number of trees per hectare, forest production cost over the past three years, tree species, and those affecting the appraisal value per unit immature forest include stand age, average DBH, average tree height, growing stocks per hectare, sales price of timber, outturn percentage of timber, tree species, timber operating costs (inclusive of taxes), and those affecting the appraisal value per unit mature forest include sales price of timber, timber operating costs (inclusive of tax), growing stocks per hectare, average tree height, average DBH, outturn percentage of timber, load distance, and tree species. Due to the difference among the factors affecting the appraisal value per unit young, immature and mature forest resource assets, the mass appraisal models should be built for the young, immature and mature forests respectively. The empirical results of the above models indicate explanatory variables such as number of trees per hectare, natural logarithm of stand age and average DBH, dominant tree species exerting a significant impact on the appraisal value per unit young forest, those such as timber sales price, natural logarithm of stand age and growing stocks per hectares, and dominant tree spices on the appraisal value per unit immature forest, and those such as timber sales prices, natural logarithm of growing stocks per hectare, average DBH, natural logarithm of outturn percentage of timber and dominant tree species on the appraisal value per unit mature forest. Furthermore, in order to promote the development of mass appraisal of forest resource assets, the vocational qualification system of "Certified Public Valuers (Forestry)" and level-to-level management of forest resource asset appraisal institutions should be established, while deepening the forestry system so as to stimulate social demand, implementing classification management of forest resource asset appraisal and value accounting, increasing forest resource asset appraisal personnel training, and accelerating the forestry information so as to build external environment such as the data platform for the mass appraisal of forest resource assets.
引文
[1]国家林业局森林资源管理司.中国森林资源第七次清查结果及其分析.林业经济.2010,(02):66~72
    [2]张卫民.森林资源资产价格及评估方法研究.北京林业大学博士论文.2010:4~5
    [3]井上由扶.森林评价.于政中译.北京:中国林业出版社,1984:23~25
    [4]冈和夫.森林公益效能的计量方法.胡馨芝译.中国林业出版社,1983:28~35
    [5]Kenneth P. Davis. Forest Management:Regulation and Valuation.McGraw-Hill,Inc. 1996:1-20
    [6]R. Atje, L. Christanty, T. Feridhanusetyawan, K. Roesad. Forests as Strategic Assets. Indonesian Quarterly.2001,29(3):132-142
    [7]Jon I. Barnes, James J. MacGregor, Olimpio Nhuleipo, Petrus I. Muteyauli. The Value of Namibia's Forest Resources Preliminary Economic Asset and Flow Accounts. Development Southern Africa.2010,27(2):159-176
    [8]W. Zhaojun, J. Minyuan. State-Owned Forest Resources Assets Operation Supervision System Innovation. Scientia Silvae.2005,41(1):142-148
    [9]X. Zhegen, S. Mengjun,C. Xinfeng. Situation and Prospect on Property Right Alteration of National Forest Resources Assets in Southern Collective Area of China. World Forestry Reseach.2004,17(3):36-40
    [10]Kathleen Herbohn. International Accounting Standard (IAS) 41:What Are the Implications for Reporting Forest Assets. Small-Scale Forestry.2006,5(2):175-189
    [11]EUIZOSJAT,EUROPEAN COMMISSION.Valuation of European Forests-Results of IEEAF Test Applications, Luxembourg:Office for Official Publications of the European Conmmnities.2000:37-42
    [12]Courtland L. Washburn, Clark S. Binkley. On the Use of Period-Average Stumpage Prices to Estimate Forest Asset Pricing Models. Land Economics.1990,66(4):379-393
    [13]Zinkhan F. Christian. Timberland Investment Management Organizations and Other Participants in Forest Asset Markets:A Survey. Southern Journal of Applied Forestry. 1993,17(1):32-38
    [14]Courtland L. Washburn, Clark S.Binkley. On the Use of Period-Average Stumpage Prices to Estimate Forest Asset Pricing Models. Land Economics.1990,66(4):379-393
    [15]Alig Ralph J.,Adams Darius M.,Chmelili John T.,Bettinger Pete.Private Forest Investment and Long-Run Sustainable Harvest Volumes.New Forests.1999,(12):310-312
    [16]Goebel Allison, Campbell Bruce,Mukamuri Billy, Veeman Michele. People Values and Woodlands & Colon.A Field Report of Emergent Themes in Interdisciplinary Research in Zimbabwe.Agriculture and Human values.2000,(12):387-390
    [17]Victor,P.A.Indicators of Sustainable Development:Some Lessons Form Capital Theory.Ecological Economics,1991, (4):191-213
    [18]Costanza,R.The Value of the World's Ecosystem Services and Natural Capital.Nature.1997,387(3):115
    [19]Rob Koeling,Adam Kilgarriff.An Evaluation of a Lexicographer's Workbench Incorporating Word Sense Disambiguation.Lecture Notes in Computer Science.2003, 2588(3):78-81
    [20]Iaria Goioa, Geremia Globs, Claudio Paullina.The development of Forest Accounting in the Province of Trenton.Forest Economics.2008,14 (2):177-196
    [21]Adam G. Drucker, Veronica Gomez and Simon Anderson. The Economic Valuation of Farm Animal Genetic Resources:a Survey of Available Methods.Ecological EconomicsJanuary.2006,23(8):1-18
    [22]Delali B.K.Doviea,Charlie M.Shackletonb,E.T.F.Witkowskia. Valuation of Communal Area Livestock Benefits, Rural Livelihoods and Related Policy Issues.Land Use Policy. 2006,46 (5):260-271
    [23]M. Siegmund-Schultze, B. Rischkowsky, J. B. Da Veiga,J.M.King. Cattle Are Cash Generating Assets for Mixed Smallholder Farms the Bastern Amazon.Agricultural Systems. 2007,94 (6):738-749
    [24]J.G.Ferreira,A.Sequeira,A.J.S. Hawkins,A. Newtonc, T. D. Nickell, R. Pastres, J. Forte, A. Bodoy, S. B. Bricker. Analysis of Coastal and Offshore Aquaculture:Application of the FARM Model to Multiple Systems and Shellfish Species.Aquaculture.2009,292 (11):129-138
    [25]N.J. Beaumont,M.C.Austen, S. C. Mang. I.M. Townsend. Bconomic Valuation for the Conservation of Marine Biodiversity.Marine Pollution Bulletin.2008,56(7):386-396
    [26]Diwakar Poudel,Fred H.Johnsen.Valuation of Crop Genetic Resources in Kaski,Nepal: Farmers'Willingness to Pay for Rice Landraces Conservation.Environmental Management. 2009,90 (4):483-491
    [27]Norman G. Miller, PHD and Sergey Markosyan. The Academic Roots and Evolution of Real Estate Appraisal.Chicago. Appraisal Institute. The Appraisal Journal.2003, (4):172-184
    [28]Olli Tahvonen.Optimal Forest Rotation with in Situ Preferences.Journal of Environmental Economics and Management.1999,(11):106-128
    [29]Jeffrey R.Vincent.A Framework for Forest Accounting. Forest Science.1999, 45(4):552-561
    [30]Ian W.Hardie, Tulika A, Narayan, and Bruce L.Gardner. The Influence of Agricultural and Nonfarm Factors on Real Estate Values:An Application to the Mid-Atlantic Region. American J.Agricultural Economics.2001,(2):120-132
    [31]H Gyde Lund. When Is a Forest not a Forest?. Journal of Forestry.2002,100(8):21-28
    [32]Goebel Allison, Campbell Bruce, Mukamuri Billy,Veeman Michele. People, Values, and Woodlands & Colon; A Field Report of Emergent Themes in Interdisciplinary Research in Zimbabwe.Agriculture and Human Values.2000,(12):385-396
    [33]Daniel.B.Thornton.Green Accounting and Green Eyeshades. CA Magzine.1993, (10):34-40
    [34]Costanza R, Arge R, Groot R.et al.The Value of the World's Ecosystem Services and Natural Capital. Nature.1997,387:253-260
    [35]Chadwick Bearing Oliver. Sustainable forestry:What Is It? How Do We Achieve It?.Journal of Forestry.2003,101(5):8
    [36]秦安臣.森林经营管理.北京:中国林业出版社,2000:116~144
    [37]阎光锋.试论可持续发展下的森林资源资产化管理.林业资源管理.1996,(4):29~33
    [38]陶仁川.森林资源资产现状与未来.林业财务与会计.1998,(10):27~28
    [39]孔繁文,戴广翠,何乃惠等.森林环境资源核算与政策.北京:中国环境科学出版社,1994:33~35
    [40]于政中,刘建国,元新刚等.关于森林资源资产化和林地评估的意见.林业资源管理.1995,(1):20~26
    [41]于政中.林地和林木评价,林价与森林较利.北京:中国林业出版社,1987:47-82
    [42]粟娟,蓝盛芳.评估森林综合效益的新方法——能值分析法.世界林业研究.2000,13(1):32~37
    [43]Odum H T. Tropical Forest Systems and the Human Economy.In:Tropical Forests:Management and Ecology.Springer-verlag New York, Inc:1995:343-393
    [44]高兆蔚.福建省森林资产化管理问题初探.林业资源管理.1994,(1):38~41
    [45]陈平留,林杰,刘健.用材林资产评估初探.华东森林经理.1994,8(3):42~47
    [46]陈伯贤.关于国有森林资源资产评估的几个问题.林业资源管理.1994,(1):32~38
    [47]黄清麟.天然阔叶用材林林木资产评估的若干问题探讨.林业资源管理.1995,(6):7~9
    [48]郑四渭.论国有林场林木资产评估的基本要求.林业资源管理.1998,(2):23-26
    [49]张惠光.林木资产评估中收获现值法的应用研究.林业勘察设计.2000,(1):1~4
    [50]郑德祥,陈平留,陈昌雄等.用材林幼龄林资产评估调整系数的确定.福建林学院学报.2000,20(4):325~328
    [51]王广建.林木资产动态评估系统模型的建立.东北林业大学学报.2002,30(4):67~70
    [52]徐琳.用材林营林生产中的林木资产评估.中国林业企业.2004,(4):38~39
    [53]郑德祥,陈平留.林业税费变化对林木资产评估价格的影响.西南林学院学报.2005,25(1):56~59
    [54]邹继昌.收获现值法在用材林林木资产评估中的应用分析.绿色财会.2006,(8):33-35
    [55]万道印,李耀翔.用材林林木资产评估模式及方法.森林工程.2007,23(4):80~81
    [56]孙福清.现行市价法在林木资产评估中的运用.中国资产评估.2007,(11):11~12
    [57]孙福清.林木资源资产评估中收获现值法与群体评估模型的探讨.中国资产评估.2007,(3):30~31
    [58]谭旭红,吴青.基于灰色关联度分析的林木资产评估现行市价法研究.生态经济(学术版).2008,(2):118~120
    [59]王兆君,刘降斌.森林资源资产评估若干理论问题研究.林业经济问题.2009,29(4):292~295
    [60]王兆君,刘降斌.基于回归分析的森林资源资产批量评估问题探究.学术交流.2009,(5):97~101
    [61]蓝金宣,叶绍明.国内外森林资产评估研究现状及对策探讨.林业经济.2010,(7):117~120
    [62]郑媛榕,魏远竹.认证对林木资产评估的影响分析——以福建省兴林林场为例.林业经济问题.2011,(5):445~451
    [63]郭晓毅.李子园林场林地、林木资产评估研究.甘肃林业科技.1998,(4):30-35
    [64]陈柯,周学安,磊鸣放等.林地资产及其价值评价理论研究综述.辽宁林业科技.1999,(5):36~38
    [65]单胜道.林地资源效益及其评估.国土开发与整治.2002,12(1):52~54
    [66]冯建孟.林地资源评价理论及其技术路线初探.中国林业企业.2002,(5):9~10
    [67]单胜道,尤建新.林地价格评估方法体系研究.中国生态农业学报.2003,11(2):126~128
    [68]刘健,陈平留.林地期望价修正法,一种实用的用材林林地资产评估方法.林业经济.2003,(3):45~46
    [69]刘健,叶德星,陈平留等.闽北用材林林地标准地租的确定.福建林业科技.2006,33(1):1-5
    [70]刘健,陈平留,郑德祥等.用材林林地资产动态评估模型构建研究.林业经济.2006,(11):53~56
    [71]刘降斌.林地资源资产评估方法研究.哈尔滨商业大学学报.2007,(2):42~45
    [72]陈伟,刘祖军.阔叶林地地租研究.中南林业调查规划.2008,27(1):57~60
    [73]胡瑶瑶,奚祥华.林地资产评估方法应用研究.中国林业经济.2009,(6):17~19
    [74]阮春雄.林地评估及林地期望价法的应用分析.中国资产评估.2010,(8):32~34
    [75]丁长迎.不列颠的森林景观价值及其对林业内部收益率的影响(一).国外林业.1995,25(1):34~38
    [76]杨文学.不列颠的森林景观价值及其对林业内部收益率的影响(二).国外林业.1997,25(2):23~26
    [77]杨学军.略论森林景观的生态经济研究及其应用.生态经济.1997,(6):27~29
    [78]杨学军,姜志林.溧阳地区森林景观经济效益特征的动态分析.林业科技.1999,24(4):52~54
    [79]曹辉,兰思仁.福州国家森林公园森林景观游憩效益评价.林业经济问题.2001,21(5):296~298
    [80]赵国华,龚晓林.森林资源的价值内涵和补偿机制探析.华东森林经理.2004,18(2):20~22
    [81]欧阳勋志,廖为明,黄晓全.婺源县森林景观游憩价值的经济评价.地域研究与开发.2006,25(1):78~82
    [82]刘降斌.森林景观资产价值特点及评估方法选择与评价.中国资产评估.2007,(7):45~48
    [83]李金兰,郭万军,王锡武等.森林景观资产与森林环境资产的评估方法.中国资产评估.2008,(11):41~43
    [84]孙宏斌,马华泉,谷松.条件价值法(CVM)在森林景观资源资产评估实例中的应用.佳木斯大学社会科学学报.2010,28(5):16~21
    [85]刘超,程胜高,曾克峰等.江西星子县大排岭矿区森林景观的价值评估.林业经济问题.2011,31(5):420~423
    [86]刘超.调查评价法在非景区型森林景观价值评估中的应用.生态经济.2012,(1):163~165
    [87]杭州市财政局直属征收管理局课题组.房地产批量评税技术的理论探索与实践创新.北京:经济科学出版社,2009:11~20
    [88]Economic and Social Council.Workshop on Mass Valuation Systems of Land(Real Estate) for Taxation Purposes. Working Party on Land Administration.2003,(11):17-18
    [89]Arvvdas BAGDNAVICIUS and Steponas DEVEIKIS;"Individnal and Mass Valuation-Present and Future Practices";From Pharaohs to Geoinformatics,FIG Working Week 2005 and GSDI-8, Cairo, Egypt.2005,(4):16-21
    [90]Daiva CIBUISKIENE and Virginija GURSKIENE 2005;The Lithuanian Real EstateTaxation Svstem in the Context of Alien Countries;Vida MALTENE, International Journal of Strategic Property Management.2005,(9):17-32
    [91]John D. Benjamin, Randall S. Guttery and C. F. Sirmans. Mass Appraisal:An Introduction to Multiple Regression Analysis for Real Estate Valuation. Journal of Real Estate Practice and Education,2002,7(1):65-77
    [92]Maurizio d'Amato. A Comparison between MRA and Rough Set Theory for Mass Appraisal, A Case in BARI. International Journal of Strategic Property Management.2004,(8):33-36
    [93]Nancy C Tomberlin, Sheldon Bluestein, Pamela M Dubov, et al. Mass Appraisal of Real Property.Assessment Journal.2002,(9):47-52
    [94]John H Detweiler, Ronald E Radigan:Computer-Assisted Real Estate Appraisal:A Tool for the Practicing Appraiser.The Appraisal Journal.1999,67 (7):24-28
    [95]Shoreh Elhami.The Tax Collector Cometh with GIS.Geospatial Solutions.2001,11(4): 59-63
    [96]Robert J Gloudemans. Comparison of Three Residential Regression Models:Additive, Multiplicative and Nonlinear.Assessment Journal.2002,(9):40-45
    [97]Carbone Robert & Longini Richard.A Feedback Model for Automated Real Estate Assessment.Manaent Science.1997,(11):69-73
    [98]Federal Land Cadastre Service of Russia on Behalf of the UNECE Working Party on Land Administration. Land (Real Estate) Mass Valuation Systems forTaxation Purposes in Europe,2004:35-43
    [99]J Scott Renne.Valuation Methodologies for the Assessment Function.Current and Past Practices Assessment Journal.2003,(2):103-108
    [100]L A U Chihong Milton. Conceptual Framework of Applying Mass Valuation in Hong Kong Urban Renewal Compensation Scheme.Journal of Harbin Institute of Technology.2004,(11):155-159
    [101]Shaun Cooney. Mass Appraiser. Canadian Appraiser.2000,44(4):19-21
    [102]Tim Wilmath, Ken Engel. The Mass Appraisal of Hotels. Journal of Property Tax Assessment & Administration.2005,2(1):15-31
    [103]R. A.Dantas, L. A. C. M. Sa, J. L. Portugal. Mass Appraisal by Spatial Inference. Journal of Property Tax Assessment and Adminstration.2005,2(2):53-63
    [104]John Kilpatrick. Expert Systems and Mass Appraisal. Journal of Property Investment & Finance.2011,29(4):529-550
    [105]Josephine Lim. Introduction to the 1996 Mass Appraisal Contest Publication. Assessment Journal.1996,6(3):72
    [106]Vilius Kontrimas, Antanas Verikas. The Mass Appraisal of the Real Estate by Computational Intelligence. Applied Soft Computing.2011,11(1):443-448
    [107]Rund M. Kathmann. Neural Networks for the Mass Appraisal of Real Estate. Computers, Environment and Urban Systems.1993,17(4):373-384
    [108]Marco Aur, Lio Stumpf Gonz, Carlos Torres Formoso. Mass Appraisal with Genetic Fuzzy Rule-Based Systems. Property Management.2006,24(1):20-30
    [109]纪益成.税基评估有关问题研究.国有资产管理.1999,(6):26~28
    [110]周叔敏.积极推进不动产税基评估工作实施税收制度的重大改革.中国资产评估.2004,(3):15~17
    [111]耿星.开征物业税中的评估问题.税务研究.2004,(4):53~55
    [112]陈百庆.物业税若干立法问题初探.吉林大学硕士论文.2004:34~36
    [113]纪益成.再论税基评估的有关问题.中国资产评估.2005,(7):5-7
    [114]纪益成,傅传锐.批量评估:从价税的税基评估方法.中国资产评估.2005,(11):5~9
    [115]周叔敏.不动产税征收中的税基评估方法.中国资产评估.2005,(7):8~11
    [116]陈滨.金融不良资产批量评估初探.中国资产评估.2005,(7):18-19
    [117]郭文华.为合理计算不动产税立陶宛引入计算机化批量评估系统.国土资源情报.2005,(6):9-12
    [118]纪益成,王诚军,傅传锐.国外AVM技术在批量评估中的应用.中国资产评估.2006,(3):11~17
    [119]李明,练奇峰.试析房地产税基评估技术标准.税制改革研究.2006,(5):59~62
    [120]陈小悦,孙力强.关于建立中国房地产税批量评估系统的几点思考.财政研究.2007,(12):48~51
    [121]张平竺.房地产税基评估研究.厦门大学博士论文.2007:65~88
    [122]周琳娜.基于物业税开征目的的批量评估系统研究.厦门大学硕士论文.2007:45~47
    [123]程敏.基于税收征管目的不动产批量评估研究.消费导刊.2008,(23):82
    [124]宋永发.基于征税目的不动产价值批量评估体系研究.价值工程.2009,(2):53~54
    [125]赖晓燕,王霞.基于多元回归分析的森林资源资产批量评估模型研究.福建电脑.2009,(11):94~95
    [126]龚科,肖智,李丹.基于支持向量机的物业税税基批量评估.涉外税务.2010,(5):35~39
    [127]陈慧华.县域杉木林地批量评估研究.福建农林大学硕士论文.2010:55~56
    [128]樊慧霞.优化我国房地产税基批量评估方法体系的政策建议.科学与管理.2011,(1):53~55
    [129]唐慧,吴翔华.存量房交易计税价格批量评估典型技术路线比较.税务与经济.2012,(1):92~99
    [130]陈平留,刘健,陈昌雄等.森林资源资产评估.北京:高等教育出版社,2010:6~7
    [131]于鸿君.资产评估教程.第二版.北京:北京大学出版社,2010:28~38
    [132]杨忠直.资产估价学引论.北京:科学出版社,2008:41~44
    [133]郝前进.特征价格法与城市住宅价格的决定机制.南京:南京大学出版社,2009:22~25
    [134]Bolton, Michael. What will AVM Do for Brokers? - Automated Valuation Models Are Being Promoted as the Future of Mortgage Valuation. Money Facts.2007,219(3):14-15
    [135]Fortelny, A. The Increasing Use of Automated Valuation Models in the Australian Mortgage Market. Australian Property Journal.2005,38(6):452-458
    [136]Muhammad Faishal Ibrahim, Fook Jam Cheng, Kheng How Eng. Automated Valuation Model:An Application to the Public Housing Resale Market in Singapore. Property Management.2005,23(5):357-373
    [137]景谦平,侯元兆.森林资产评估的基本要素.世界林业研究.2006,19(2):1~6
    [138]景谦平,侯元兆.森林资源资产评估管理.世界林业研究.2009,22(3):5-7

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700