现代多式联运的发展及其经济组织
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
经济的发展离不开高效货运系统。未来高效货运系统的发展方向是综合货运系统,其核心是各种运输方式的有效衔接和一体化。而实现这种衔接与一体化的表现形式就是多式联运。作为一种先进的运输组织形式,多式联运充分发挥了联运链条上不同运输方式的内在优势,实现了运输产品的完整性和高效率。尤其是从20世纪50年代后期开始,由于集装箱作为联运工具的引入,进一步方便了不同运输方式间的快速衔接,从而极大地拓展了多式联运的规模,使集装箱多式联运成为现代运输业发展的一大亮点。
     本文选取集装箱多式联运作为研究对象,以经济组织问题为切入点来考察提升现代多式联运链条效率的途径。本文认为多式联运链条效率的提升是籍由链条上经济主体之间交易效率的提升来实现的,经济组织的创新是推动现代多式联运发展的关键性因素,具有显著规模经济的运输行业及企业必须改变组织形态,以便充分发挥规模经济,提升多式联运链条的效率,实现运输市场中分散化需求和集中供给的匹配,满足经济发展对综合运输体系的要求。同时,本文通过分析我国铁路集装箱多式联运所存在的组织问题,指出铁路集装箱多式联运的组织变革是改善我国多式联运发展现状的必要条件,同时也是促进我国铁路行业由传统行业向现代行业转变的重要推动力。
     为论证上述观点,本文综合应用了交易费用经济学理论、中间层组织理论和运输业“产品—资源—网络经济”思想方法,构建了一个整合交易特性和生产特性的链网组织理论,并在深入分析现代多式联运系统特性的基础上,研究了多式联运的组织结构、组织形态及其影响因素,进一步完善了现代多式联运经济组织的解释框架。其次,借助历史及事件研究方法,在系统考察现代多式联运发展历程的基础上,研究经济组织变革对现代多式联运发展的作用及意义。随后,又进一步考察了海运业在适应现代多式联运发展中的组织变革,进一步讨论组织变革对于具有显著规模经济的运输行业参与多式联运的重要作用和意义。同时,通过对欧美等发达国家多式联运经济组织的案例研究,进一步归纳经济组织的方式及其决策因素,并检验本文的解释框架。最后,结合海运业适应多式联运发展所作的组织变革过程,借鉴欧美发达国家在铁路集装箱多式联运经济组织方面的成效,针对中国铁路集装箱多式联运存在的组织问题,提出通过改善经济组织提升联运链条效率的建议,并最终归纳全文的结论。
The development of economy is highly depended on an efficient freight transport system. The future of the system is one integrated freight system in which each mode of transport is effectively connected and integrated. As an advanced organized form of transportation, Intermodal Freight Transportation (IFT) utilizes the inherent advantages of each mode involved, creating synergies and efficiencies not otherwise attainable and realizes the integration and high efficiency of transport service. Especially, the phenomenal growth of containerization during the past 50 years has expanded the scale of IFT. Accordingly, the intermodal container transportation becomes one highlight of the modern transport industry.
     The major objectives of this thesis are to describe and analyse the economic organization of IFT and the relationship between the development of IFT and its economic organization. In this thesis, the author presents two economics propositions as follows:(1) the achievement of production efficiency is depended on the improvement of transaction efficiency, the innovation of economic organization is a key factor to promote the development of IFT, the transport industry and corporations with significant economies of scale must change the organizational form in order to maximize economies of scale, enhance the efficiency of intermodal transport chains to achieve to the matching of the diversified demands and focus on supply in the transportation market and meet the need of the economic development to the integrated transport system. (2) The organizational change of rail intermodal container transprot is the status quo to improve the necessary conditions of development for Chinese intermodal transport, but also an important impetus for change to promote Chinese railway industry from the traditional industry to one modern industry.
     To demonstrate the above proposition, this paper studied the role and significance of economic organizational change in modern development of the intermodal transports with the history and the event study method, based on the study of the development process of modern multimodal transport. Second, the integrated application of transaction cost economics theory, the middle layer of organization theory and transport "production-resource-network economy" way of thinking, studied the multimodal transport organizational structure, morphology and its influencing factors, based on the in-depth analysis of characteristics of a modern inter-modal system, to build an interpretative framework for multimodal transport economic organizations. Subsequently, further studied the organizational change of the maritime industry in the modern multimodal transport development, for further discussion of the important role and significance of organizational change to the transportation industry with significant economies of scale involved in multimodal transport, and At the same time, through the case study of multimodal transport economic organizations during Europe and the United States and other developed countries, further refine the way of economic organizations and its decision-making factors, and testing the interpretation framework of this article. Finally, combing the organizational changes process of shipping industry adapted to intermodal development, drawing on the effectiveness of economic organization of the rail intermodal container transport in European and American developed countries, for the existing organizational issues about rail intermodal container transport system in China, raised suggestions by improving the economic organization to enhance efficiency of the intermodal freight chains, and ultimately summarized the conclusions of the full text.
引文
[1].王杨堃,荣朝和.多式联运经济组织的演变及其启示.综合运输,2007(9):p.60-65.
    [2].马克.莱文森.集装箱改变世界.北京.机械工业出版社.2008.
    [3].荣朝和.关于我国尽快实行综合运输管理体制的思考.中国软科学,2005(2):p.10-16.
    [4].斯科特.E.马斯腾 主编.契约和组织案例研究.北京.中国人民大学出版社.2005.
    [5].荣朝和.关于运输经济研究基础性分析框架的思考.北京交通大学学报:社会科学版,2009.8(2):p.1-9.
    [6]. Bontekoning, Y.M., C. Macharis, and J.J. Trip. Is a new applied transportation research field emerging?-A review of intermodal rail-truck freight transport literature. Transportation Research Part a-Policy and Practice,2004.38(1):p.1-34.
    [7]. Jones, W.B., C.R. Cassady, and R.O. Bowden, Developing a Standard Definition of Intermodal Transportation.
    [8]. Szyliowicz, J.S., INTERMODALISM: THE CHALLENGE AND THE PROMISE.2001.
    [9]. UN/ECE, ECMT, and EC, TERMINOLOGY ON COMBINED TRANSPORT.2001.
    [10].Panayides, P.M. Economic organization of intermodal transport. Transport Reviews,2002. 22(4):p.401-414.
    [11]. Alt, R., P.W. Forster, and J.L. King, The Great Reversal:Information and Transportation Infrastructure in the Intermodal Vision, in National Conference on Intermodal Transportation Research Framework.1997, Transportation Research Board: Washington, DC.
    [12].泉水.多式联运讲座(1).集装箱化,2002(2):p.36-39.
    [13]. Jennings, B. and M.C. Holcomb. Beyond Containerization: The Broader Concept of Intermodalism. Transportation Journal,1996:p.5-13.
    [14].谈大洋.联合运输知识.北京.人民交通出版社.1987.
    [15].王庆功.货物群合运输.北京.中国铁道出版社.2004.
    [16].王稼琼.联运发展论.北京.中国民航出版社.1995.
    [17].李士珍.联合运输经济概论.北京.中国铁道出版社.1994.
    [18].胡思继.综合运输工程学.北京.清华大学出版社;北京交通大学出版社.2005.
    [19].刘鼎铭,王根兴,李玉如.集装箱化与现代物流辞典.上海.东华大学出版社.2003.
    [20].郭小碚.综合运输体系发展的理论与实践.综合运输,2000(11):p.1-5.
    [21].高家驹.综合运输概论.北京.中国铁道出版社.1993.
    [22].肖平安.我国国际集装箱多式联运之探讨.交通企业管理,2006.21(8):p.46-47.
    [23].Daddino, M., Intermodal transport: A force in the new economy, in Area Development Site and Facility Planning.1999.
    [24]. Yevdokimov, Y.V. Measuring economic benefits of intermodal transportation. Transportation Law Journal,2000.27(3):p.439-452.
    [25].Handman, A.L. Intermodalism-A solution for congestion at the millennium? The Review of Policy Research,2002.19(2):p.51-61.
    [26].Brown, T.R. and A.B. Hatch, The Value of Rail Intermodal to the U.S. Economy.2002. p.1,6.
    [27].Kreutzberger, E., et al. IS INTERMODAL FREIGHT TRANSPORT MORE ENVIRONMENTALLY FRIENDLY THAN ALL-ROAD FREIGHT TRANSPORT? A REVIEW. in NECTAR Conference No 7. Umea, Sweden.2003.
    [28]. Janic, M. Modelling the full costs of an intermodal and road freight transport network. Transportation Research Part D,2007.12:p.33-44.
    [29].Szyliowicz, J.S. Decision-making, intermodal transportation, and sustainable mobility. International Social Science Journal,2003.55(2):p.185-197.
    [30].COMMUNITIES,C.O.T.E.,INTERMODALITY AND INTERMODAL FREIGHT TRANSPORT IN THE EUROPEAN UNION.1997.
    [31].Bithas, K. and P. Nijkamp, Decisive Conditions for an Effective and Efficient Multi-modal Freight Transport Network in Europe:A Meta-Analytic Perspective.1997, Amsterdam:Tinbergen Institute.
    [32].徐剑华.全球贸易格局的变化为多式联运产业的发展提供了机遇.国际商务研究,1993(2):p.24-26.
    [33].徐淑芬.国际集装箱海铁联运的现状及其发展前景.中国铁路,1994(4):p.10-14.
    [34].王克武.国际多式联运与铁路集装箱运输的发展.铁道运输与经济,1996.18(10):p.11-13.
    [35].魏际刚,荣朝和.中国集装箱多式联运发展的宏观经济因素分析.中国软科学,2000(8):p.40-44.
    [36].林益恭.WTO与我国多式联运的发展对策研究.铁道经济研究,2001(4):p.34-35,38.
    [37].安丙申.浅谈铁路如何积极参与国际集箱多式联运.铁道经济研究,2001(5):p.22-24.
    [38].Banomyong, R. and A.K.C. Beresford. Multimodal transport:the case of Laotian garment exporters. International Journal of Physical Distribution & Logistics Management,2001.31(9):p. 633-685.
    [39].Islam, D.M.Z., J. Dinwoodie, and M. Roe. Towards Supply Chain Integration Through Multimodal Transport in Developing Economies: The Case of Bangladesh. Maritime Economics & Logistics,2005.7:p.382-399.
    [40].Macharis, C. and Y.M. Bontekoning. Opportunities for OR in intermodal freight transport research: A review. European Journal of Operational Research,2004.153(2):p.400-416.
    [41].Merrina, A., A. Sparavigna, and R.A. Wolf. The intermodal networks: a survey on intermodalism. World Review of Intermodal Transportation Research 2007.1(3):p.286-299.
    [42].Konings, J.W. Integrated centres for the transshipment, storage, collection and distribution of goods-A survey of the possibilities for a high-quality intermodal transport concept. Transport Policy,1996.3(1/2):p.3-11.
    [43].张琦,杨浩.铁路集装箱内陆港物流中心化的相关问题研究.中国铁路,2005(11):p.54-57.
    [44].Klink, H.A.v. and GC.v.d. Berg. Gateways and intermodalism. Journal of Transport Geography, 1998.6(1):p.1-9.
    [45].Roson, R. and S. Soriani. Intermodality and the changing role of nodes in transport networks. Transportation Planning and Technology,2000.23(3):p.183-197.
    [46]. McCalla, R. J. Global change, local pain:intermodal seaport terminals and their service areas. Journal of Transport Geography,1999.7:p.247-254.
    [47].王薇,何小明.发展集装箱海铁联运 拓展港口腹地.集装箱化,2006(7):p.34-36.
    [48].刘和平.建设合肥集装箱码头 发展内河多式联运.水运工程,2006(12):p.8-11.
    [49].韩要稳,朱晓宁,闫振英.集装箱码头作业环节协调特性生研究.物流科技,2007.30(8):p. 60-63.
    [50].朱晓宁.集装箱多式联运通道的形成与运作机理分析.运筹与管理,2001.10(3):p.69-73.
    [51].金万建.我国铁路开展国际联运及国际通道的发展.铁道运输与经济,2003.25(3):p.4-8.
    [52].Notteboom, T.E., The interdependence between liner shipping networks and intermodal networks, in IAME Panama 2002 'Maritime Economics:setting the foundations for port and shipping policies'.2002:Panama City, Panama.
    [53]. Southworth, F. and B.E. Peterson. Intermodal and international freight network modeling. Transportation Research Part C,2000.8:p.147-166.
    [54].Chang, T.-S. Best routes selection in international intermodal networks. Computers & Operations Research,2007.
    [55]. Taylor, GD., et al. An analysis of intermodal ramp selection methods. Transportation Research Part E-Logistics and Transportation Review,2002.38(2):p.117-134.
    [56].Rizzoli, A.E., N. Fornara, and L.M. Gambardella. A simulation tool for combined rail/road transport in intermodal terminals. Mathematics and Computers in Simulation,2002:p.57-71.
    [57].杨清波.集装箱铁路多式联运箱型及办理站.北京.中国铁道出版社.2008.
    [58].Bontekoning, Y.M. and H. Priemus. Breakthrough innovations in intermodal freight transport. Transportation Planning and Technology,2004.27(5):p.335-345.
    [59].Choong, S.T., M.H. Cole, and E. Kutanoglu. Empty container management for intermodal transportation networks. Transportation Research Part E,2002.38:p.423-438.
    [60].Morlok, E.K. and L.N. Spasovic. Approaches to improving drayage in rail-truck intermodal service. in TransTech Conference. Pacific Rim.1995.
    [61].李渝生.关于铁路系统内组建集装箱拖车运输全国网络的建议.铁道车辆,1995.33(6):p.19-24,18.
    [62].成耀荣,严宝杰.集装箱箱务管理的几个问题.交通运输工程学报,2001.1(4):p.115-118.
    [63].周立新,季令.公铁两用货挂车新一代大陆联运工具.中国铁路,2001(4):p.28-30.
    [64].Morash, E.A., S.J. Hille, and E.R. Bruning. Marketing rail piggyback services. Transportation Journal,1977.17(2):p.40-50.
    [65].Evers, P.T. The occurance of statistical economies of scale in intermodal transportation. Transportation journal,1994.33(4):p.51-63.
    [66]. Harper, D.V. and P.T. Evers. Competitive Issues in Intermodal Railroad-Truck Service. Transportation Journal,1993.32(3):p.31-45.
    [67].Kapros, S. and C. Panou, Coastal Shipping and Intermodality in Greece:The Weak Link, in Research in Transportation Economics.2007. p.323-342.
    [68].Golias, J. and G Yannis. Determinants of combined transport's market share. Transport Logistics,1998.1(4):p.251-264.
    [69]. van Duin, R. and H. van Ham. A three-stage modeling approach for the design and organization of intermodal transportation services, in Systems, Man, and Cybernetics,1998.1998 IEEE International Conference on.1998.
    [70].Qiang, L. and L. Miao. Integration of China's intermodal freight transportation and ITS technologies. in Intelligent Transportation Systems,2003. Proceedings.2003 IEEE.2003.
    [71].丁丁,杨运涛.改善多式联运和物流服务的必要条件.中国物流与采购,2004(22):p.24-27.
    [72].张吉广,招琳樱.业务流程再造(BPR)与集装箱运输管理现代化.交通企业管理,2001(4): p.11-13.
    [73].王云鹏,王占中.基于扩展Petri网的多式联运流程研究.工业技术经济,2005.24(4):p.77-79,82.
    [74].吕达,李海鹰,杨肇夏.国际联运作业系统的设计与实现.铁道运输与经济,2005.27(11):p.71-73.
    [75]. Suelflow, J.E. and S.J. Hille. The Transportation Company:An Economic Argument for Intermodal Ownership. Land Economics,1970.46(3):p.275-286.
    [76].Lieb, R..C. Freight Transportation:A Study of Federal Intermodal Ownership Policy. New York. Praeger Publishers,Inc.1972.
    [77].Zelenika, R. and Z. Zekic. Mega carriers and niche operators of multimodal transport in the kaleidoscope of compatability and complements. Nase more: Journal of marine sciences,1997. 44(5-6):p.243-254.
    [78].Lopez, E. How do ocean carriers organize the empty containers reposition activity in the USA? Maritime Policy & Management,2002.30(4):p.339-355.
    [79].Gouvernal, E. and J. Daydou. Container Railfreight Services in North-west Europe: Diversity of Organizational Forms in a Liberalizing Environment. Transport Reviews,2005.25(5):p.557-571.
    [80].Whitehurst, C.H. MULTIMODAL TRANSPORTATION COMPANIES IN THE 21st CENTURY. 2005.
    [81]. COMMISSION, E., D.-GF.E.A. TRANSPORT, and D.f.M.a. Intermodality, Freight Integrator Action Plan-"Supporting the organisers of intermodal freight transport".2003.
    [82]. Woxenius, J. and F. Barthel, The Organization of the European Intermodal Road/Rail Freight Transport Industry, in International congress on Freight Transport Automation and Multimodality 2002:Delft.
    [83].Zhang, A., et al. Intermodal alliance and rivalry of transport chains:The air cargo market. Transportation Research Part E,2007.43:p.234-246.
    [84].马彩雯,孙光圻.基于multi-agent的多式联运各区段分运承运人选择系统.上海海事大学学报:文理综合版,2006.27(3):p.51-54.
    [85].马彩雯.基于多Agent的多式联运各区段分运承运人选择.哈尔滨工业大学学报,2007.39(12):p.1989-1992.
    [86].陈宇,任建伟.基于遗传算法的集装箱多式联运联盟合作伙伴的选择.铁道运输与经济,2007.29(2):p.79-81.
    [87].唐志英,周德苏,王仕川.基于多式联运的虚拟企业模式研究.铁道运输与经济,2008.30(3):p.75-77.
    [88].Nair, R.V., B.M. Gardner, and R. Banomyong, Theories & Practices ofMultimodal Transport in Europe, in 9th World Conference on Transport Research (WCTR) 2001:Seoul, Korea.
    [89]. Everett, S. Deregulation, Competitive Pressures and the Emergence oflntermodalism. Australian Journal of Public Administration,2002.61(3):p.19-26.
    [90]. Plant, J.F. RAILROAD POLICY AND INTERMODALISM.Policy Choices after Deregulation. The Review of Policy Research,2002.19(2):p.13-32.
    [91].Tsamboulas, D.A. and S. Kapros. Decision-making process in intermodal transportation. Freight Transportation Research,2000(1707):p.86-93.
    [92]. The Study Group on Legal Aspects of Intermodal Transportation of the Maritime Transportation Research Board, D.o.E.-N.R.C. Legal Impediments to International Intermodal Transportation: selected Problem, Options, and Recommended Solutions. Washington, D.C. National Academy of Sciences.1971.
    [93]. Leibson, R. and W. Penner, Legal Issues Associated with Intermodalism.1996, TRANSPORTATION RESEARCH BOARD NATIONAL RESEARCH COUNCIL: Washington,DC.
    [94].Kindred, H.M. and M.R. Brooks. New and Improved?The UNCTAD/ICC Multimodal Rules Reviewed. TRANSPORTATION JOURNAL,1994:p.5-14.
    [95].Dempsey, P.S. THE LAW OF INTERMODAL TRANSPORTATION:WHAT IT WAS, WHAT IT IS, WHAT IT SHOULD BE Transportation Law Journal,2000.20(3):p.367-417.
    [96].杨志刚.多式联运经营人责任形式与赔偿责任之关联.上海海运学院学报,2000.21(2):p.84-89.
    [97].纪荣泰.浅论国际货物多式联运的法律问题.现代财经:天津财经学院学报,2000.20(8):p.20-22.
    [98].贺万忠.国际货物多式联运中货物损害定域问题探析.法商研究,2003.20(5):p.103-110.
    [99].贺万忠,赵萍.多式联运经营人货物损害赔偿责任限制规则的构建——兼评我国《合同法》与《海商法》的相应规定.河北法学,2004.22(3):p.48-52.
    [100].Intermodal Surface Transportation Efficiency Act of 1991.1991, Congress of United States.
    [101].亚当.斯密.国民财富的性质和原因的研究.北京.商务印书馆.1997.1-5
    [102].马克思.资本论(第一卷).北京.人民出版社.2004.374
    [103].马歇尔.经济学原理.北京.商务印书馆.1997.257
    [104]. Coase, R.H. The Nature of the Firm. Economics,1937(4):p.386-405.
    [105].Williamson, O. Hierarchical Control and Optimum Firm Size. Journal of Political Economics, 1967(75):p.123-138.
    [106].Williamson, O. Markets and Hierarchies. New York. The Free Press.1975.
    [107].Alchian, A. and Demsetz, H. Production, Information Costs and Economic Organization. American Economic Review.1972(50):p.777-795.
    [108].Cheung, S. The Structure of a Contract and the Theory of a Non-exclusive Resource. Journal of Law & Economics,1970(13):p.49-70.
    [109].林金忠.企业组织的经济学分析.北京.商务印书馆.2004
    [110].Fama, E. and Jensen, M. Seperation of ownership and control. Journal of Law and Economics, 1983
    [111].Grossman, S. and Hart, O. The Cost and Benefits of Ownership: A Theory of Vertical and Lateral Integration. Journal of Political Economics.1986(94):p.691-719.
    [112].Hart, O. and Moore, J. Property Rights and Nature of the Firm. Journal of Political Economics. 1990(98):p.1119-1158.
    [113].丹尼尔.F.斯普尔伯.市场的微观结构—中间层组织与厂商理论.北京.中国人民大学出版社.2002.1-27.
    [114].杨小凯,黄有光.专业化与经济组织.北京.经济科学出版社.1999.
    [116].Taylor, J. The Theory of Industrial Organization. Cambridge. The MIT Prsee.1989.
    [117].Muller, G. Intermodal Freight Transportation. Washington, DC. Eno Transportation Foundation and Intermodal Association of North America.1999.
    [118].McKenzie, D.R., M.C. North, and D.S. Smith. Intermodal Transportation—The Whole Story. Omaha. Simmons-Boardman Books,Inc.1989.
    [119].Deboer, D. J. Piggyback and Containers: A History of Rail Intermodal on America's Steel Highway. San Marino, California. Golden West Books.1992.
    [120].Levinson, M. The Box: How the Shipping Container Made the World Smaller and the World Economy Bigger.1st ed. Princeton. Princeton University Press.2006.376.
    [121].Slack, B. and A. Fremont. Fifty years of organisational change in container shipping: regional shift and the role of family firms. GeoJournal,2009.74:p.23-34.
    [122].Brooks, M.R. and P. Ritchiel. Mergers and acquisitions in the maritime transport industry 1996-2000. Transportation journal,2006.45(2):p.7-22.
    [123].Fremont, A., Empirical Evidence for Integration and Disintegration of Maritime Shipping, Port and Logistics.2009.
    [124].Notteboom, T. and F. Merckx. Freight Integration in Liner Shipping:A Strategy Serving Global Production Networks. Growth and Change,2006.37(4):p.550-569.
    [125].Taylor, J.C. and GC. Jackson. Conflict, power, and evolution in the intermodal transportation industry's channel of distribution. Transportation Journal,2000.39(3):p.5-17.
    [126].Wang, Y.K. and C.H. Rong. How do Intermediaries Affect the Economic Organization of Intermodal Freight Transport? Ieee/Soli'2008:Proceedings of 2008 Ieee International Conference on Service Operations and Logistics, and Informatics, Vols 1 and 2,2008:p.2269-2272.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700