低等级公路新型廉价支挡结构物开发
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
县乡公路连接着国道、省道、干线公路,是沟通城乡物资、经济、技术及文化交流的桥梁和纽带。建设高质量的县乡公路对推动农村经济发展,实现广大人民群众脱贫致富奔小康具有重要的意义。而支挡结构在很大程度上影响着公路的长期稳定及工程造价,传统的重力式挡土墙或衡重式挡土墙由于其圬工量大、造价高、占地多、施工不便等诸多弊病已无法适应县乡公路建设的需要。因此,为县乡公路提供一种造价低廉、适用性强、施工简便的支挡结构形式势在必行。针对这一问题,综合现有支挡结构形式,本文选用了两种具有较大技术经济优势的支挡结构—加筋土挡土墙和加筋格宾挡土墙,并为了使其更好适应低等级公路建设,对其结构进行了优化设计,并进行了受力变形等方面的研究。
     本文以云南普洱市小碧公路路肩式加筋土支挡结构形式为依据,通过运用ANSYS软件对加筋土挡土墙和加筋格宾挡墙的破裂面产生发展过程、变形特性、不同填土性质对支挡结构变形的作用规律进行了模拟分析和计算,并结合岩土工程软件Plaxis的计算结果对其进行了验证。并通过近年来国内外加筋土工程实例对两种加筋土支挡结构进行了深入地技术经济评价,主要研究成果如下:1、两种加筋土支挡结构的破裂面均不同于传统的0.3H型和朗金-库伦简化破裂面,加筋土挡土墙的破裂面产生于挡墙底部,并在加筋体内呈对数螺旋线式向上发展,而加筋格宾挡墙的破裂面则发生发展于加筋体外的筋带末端附近,说明相比于加筋土挡墙,加筋格宾应加强外部稳定验算;2、通过有限元强度折减计算,发现加筋土挡墙和加筋格宾挡墙的水平位移分布均与传统土压力作用模式有较大差别,墙体中下部土压力较大,呈“两头下,中间大”的分布趋势,同时,加筋对降低土体沉降作用并不理想,需在实际工程中做好预防措施;3、较大的填土弹性模量、粘聚力及内摩擦角对加筋土结构起稳定作用,但相比于弹性模量、粘聚力,填土内摩擦角对挡墙变形的影响作用更大,在今后的加筋土工程中,为达到既稳定又经济的目标,应主要考察作为填料土体的内摩擦角,适当满足粘聚力和弹性模量要求;4、相比于低等级公路中常用的重力式挡土前和衡重式挡土墙,加筋土挡土墙和加筋格宾具有压倒性的技术经济优势,其力学性能更好,施工简便、速度快,对施工人员的技术要求低,质量易于控制,生态环保,造价低廉。同时,在保证稳定的前提下,通过对布筋方式的优化,使加筋土支挡结构较之以往更具稳定性和经济性,节省筋带用量,从而节约工程投资。
As the connection of national highways , provincial highways and trunk highways , the county level highways have linked the rural and urban in means of material exchange , economic exchange , technical exchange and cultural exchange , etc . Tt is of great significance in proving the development of rural economic and achieving the goal of shaking off poverty and seting out on a road to prosperity that how to build a high quality county level highways . The retaining structures largely affected the long-term stabilization and construction cost of the highways . The conventional gravity retaining wall may not meet the requirements of the county level highways for the sake of its features of large masonry , high cost , wasteful of land , construction complex and so on . Therefore , it is required by circumstances that providing a new type of retaining structure with the advantages of low cost , fine applicability , easy maitenance . To address the issue and combine the existing retaining walls , reinfored earth retaining wall and reinforced gabion , which has a advantages of economic and technical , has been chosen for study . The optimization design and stress-deformation study of the two kinds of walls has done so that they can adapt the construction of the county level highways much better.
     This text is based on the shoulder reinforced retaining wall in Pu’er City of Yunnan Province . ANSYS software has been applied to anlyze the reinforced earth retaining wall and reinforced gabion wall , then the anlysis results has been inspected and verified by the calculation of PLAXIS . It has been studied and anlyzed that the two kinds retaining walls’development of fracture plane , deformation characteristics , deformation rule of different filler properties with the use of finite element method . Also the technical and economic evaluation has been anlyzed by the comparison of home and abroad exemples in recent years . The main results can be concluded as follows : 1 The fracture planes of both the reinforced earth retaining wall and reinforced gabion wall are different from traditional“0.3H”and“Rinkine-Kulun”simplified fracture planes . The fracture plane of reinforced earth retaining wall produced at the foot of the wall , and developed upwards asumming a log-spiral posture in the reinforced body ; however , the fracture plane’s development and progression of reinforced gabion wall is on the outside of the reinforced body along the ends of the ribs , which explains that the reinforced gabion wall should strengthen the exterior strain-stress calculation compared to the reinforced earth retaining wall .
     2 It can be revealed by the strength reduction of finite element calculation that the distribution of horizontal deformation of both the two kinds retaining walls are different from the tradional earth pressure binding mode . The larger earth pressure of the walls produced at the lower of the middle part , assuming a case of both the ends being small and the middle being large . And the reinforced measure has a low retarding effect on the subsidence of the structure . 3 The bigger elasticity modulus , cohesive srength , internal frictional angel of the filler can make the structure more steady . Contrast to the elasticity modulus and cohesive strength , the internal fricrional angel of the filler contributes more to the horizontal deformation of walls . So in the future reinforced construction , the internal frictional angle is the primary considering indicator compared with the elastivity modulus and cohesive strength in order to the goal of both steady and economical . 4 Compared to the conventional gravity retaining wall , the reinforced earth retaining wall and reinforced gabion wall overwhelming superiority in technical and economic aspect , which has a better mechanical property , construction easier and faster , lower technique request of the builder , easier to control construction quality , better ecological environmental protected and lower cost features . Besides , on the premise of the stability , the arrangement ways of reinforcement has been optimum designed , so that the walls are more steady and economical than ever , and the dosage of the reinforced ribs has been cut back , which attains the goal of saving costs .
引文
[1] GOURC G.P. . Reinforced embankments on weak soil : Different thoretical approaches[A]. 3rd International Conference on Geotextiles [C]. 1986 , Austria .
    [2]周世良,何光春,王多垠等.澜沧江高变幅水位码头结构型式和装卸工艺[J] .重庆大学学报,2004,27(12):82-85.
    [3] GOODMAN R.F. , TAYLORRL , BREKKE T.L. . A model for the mechanics of jointed rock [J] . Journal of soil Mechanics and Foundation Engineering Division , ASCE ,1968 , 94 (3) : 637-660 .
    [4] CLOUGH G.W. , DUNCAN J.M. . Finite element analysis of retaining wall behavior [J] . Journal of soil Mechanics and Foundation Engineering Division , ASCE , 1971 , 97 (12) : 657-673 .
    [5] DESAI C.S , ZAMAN M.M . Thin layer element for interfaces and joints [J] . International journal for numerical and analytical methods in geomechanics , 1984 , 8 (1) :19-43 .
    [6]陈慧远.摩擦接触单元及其分析方法[J] .水利学报,1985,(4) : 44-50 .
    [7]殷宗泽,朱泓,许国华.土与结构材料的接触面变形及数学模型[J] .岩土工程学报,1994 ,16 (3) : 14-22 .
    [8]张东霁,卢廷浩.土与结构接触面模型的建立与应用[J] .岩土工程学报,1998 , 20(6) : 63-66 .
    [9]卢廷浩,鲍伏波.接触面薄层单元耦合本构模型[J] .水利学报,2000,(2) :71-75 .
    [10]高俊合,于海学.土与混凝土接触面特性的大型单剪试验研究及数值模拟[J] .土木工程学报,2000 , 33(8) : 42-46 .
    [11]安关峰,高大钊.接触面弹粘塑性本构关系[J] .土木工程学报,2001 , 34(1) :88-91 .
    [12]张道宽.土工织物加强软土路基的研究[D] .铁道部科学研究院博士论文,1987 .
    [13]石名磊,姚代禄.加筋土支挡结构数值分析研究[J] .重庆交通学院学报,1994 , 13(4) : 78-84 .
    [14]李艳春,蒋志仁.弹簧元模型用于分析土工格栅受力特性[J] .中国公路学报,1996 , 9(4) : 38-42 .
    [15]张兴强,邓卫东.动荷载作用下土工格栅加筋土计算模型的研究[J] .水利学报,2001,(7) : 91-97 .
    [16]刘华北,Ling H.I. .土工格栅加筋土挡土墙设计参数的弹塑性有限元研究[J] .岩土工程学报,2004 , 26(5) : 668-673 .
    [17] HARRISON W.J.,GERRARD C.M. . Elastic theory applied to reinforced earth[J] . Journal of the Soil Mechanics and Foundation Division , 1972 , 98(12) :1325-1345 .
    [18] ROMSTAD K.M.,HERRMANN L.R.,SHEN C.K..Integrated study of reinforced earth—Ⅰ: Theoretical formulation [J] . Journal of the Geotechnical Engineering Division , 1976 , 102 (5) : 457-451 .
    [19] SHEN C.K.,Romstad K.M., Herrmann L.R..Integrated study of reinforced earth—Ⅱ: Behavior and design[J] . Journal of the Geotechnical Engineering Division , 1976 , 102 (6) : 577-590 .
    [20]乐翠英等.利用土工织物加固油罐的有限元分析.见第二届土工合成材料学术会议论文题要.土工合成材料技术协作网,1989 .
    [21] Di Prisco C., Nova R.. Constitutive model for soil reinforced by continuous threads [J] . Geotextiles and Geomembranes , 1994 , 12(2) : 161-178 .
    [22] SHUKLA S.K., CHANDRA S.. Generalized mechanical model for geosynthetic-reinforced foundation soil [J] . Geotextiles and Geomembranes , 1994 , 13(12) : 813-825 .
    [23] YIN J.H.. Nonlinear model of geosynthetic-reinforced granular fill over soft soil [J] . Geosynthetics International , 1997 , 4(5) : 523-537 .
    [24] CHEN T.C., CHEN R.H., LIN S.S.. A nonlinear homogenized model applicable to reinforced soil analysis [J] . Geotextiles and Geomembranes , 2000 ,18(5) : 349-366 .
    [25] Nejad Ensan M., Shahrour I.. A simplified elastoplastic macroscopic model for the reinforced earth material [J] . Mechanics Research Communications , 2000, 27(1) : 79-86 .
    [26]张孟喜,孙钧.土工合成材料加筋土应变软化特性及弹塑性分析[J] .土木工程学报,2000 , 33(3) :104-107 .
    [27] SAWICKI A., Kazimierowicz-Frankowsak K..Creep behaviour of geosynthetics [J] . Geotextiles and Geomembranes , 1998 , 16(6) : 365-382 .
    [28]介玉新,李广信.纤维加筋土计算的新方法[J] .工程力学,1999 , 16(3) : 81-89 .
    [29]吕文良,闫澍旺.弹塑性有限元在加筋土挡墙中的应用[J] .天津大学学报,35(5) : 596-600 .
    [30] K.D. Eigenbrod and J.G.. Locker . Detemination of Friction Values for the Design of Side Slope Lined or Protected with Geosynthetics . Canadian Geotechnical Journal , 1987 .
    [31] K.D. Williams , etc . Evaluation of Friction Coefficients between Geomembrands Geotextile and Rlated Products . 1986 , 3rd . Int . conf. on geotextile .
    [32] Juran I., Christopher B..Laboratory Model Study on Geosynthetic Reinforced Soil Retaining walls [J] . Geotechnical Engineering Division , ASCE , 1989 , 115(7) : 905-925 .
    [33]姚代禄,张光羽.加筋土挡墙中加筋与土之间的摩擦性质初探[J] .岩土工程学报,1989 , 11(1) .
    [34]赵爱根,盛崇文.土与土工织物界面抗剪强度研究[J] .水利水运科学研究,1987 .
    [35]陈国芳.挡墙与填土间接触面的大型直剪实验[J] .路基工程,1995 , 58(1) :49-55 .
    [36]雷胜友.土与加筋之间摩擦系数的探讨[J] .成都科技大学学报,1996,(3) : 76-81 .
    [37]闫澍旺,Ben Barr .土工格栅与土相互作用的有限元分析[J] .岩土工程学报,1997 , 19(6) .
    [38]吴景海等.土工合成材料与土界面作用特性的研究[J] .岩土工程学报,2001 , 23(1) : 89-93 .
    [39] R.H. Chen and C.C. Chen .土工格栅的拉拔试验研究.见:第五届国际土工合成材料学术会议论文译文选.中国土工合成材料协会,1995 .
    [40] EI-Fermaoui A.. Effect of Confining Pressure on Performance of Geotextiles in soils [A] . 2nd .Inter. Conf. On Geotextiles[C] , 1982 , Las Vegas , USA .
    [41]吴景海,王德群,陈环.土工合成材料加筋砂土三轴试验研究.岩土工程学报,2000 , 22(2) : 199-204 .
    [42]张孟喜.加筋土挡墙模型试验及非线性有限元分析[J] .兰州铁道学院学报,1991,(2) : 31-37 .
    [43] AI-Hussaini M., Peny E.B.. Field Experiment of Reinforced Earth Wall [J] . Geotechnical Engineering Division , ASCE , 1978 , 104(3) : 307-322 .
    [44] Bolton M.D., Pang P.L.R..Collapse Limit States of Reinforced Earth Retaining Walls [M] . Geotechnique , 1982 , 32(4) : 349-367 .
    [45] Konami . T Design and Practice of Web Reinforced Soil Wall-Recent Case Histories 7 of Permanent Geosynthetic-Reinforced Soil Retaining Walls [R] . Tat suoka&Leshchinsky(eds) , 1994 , Balkema Rotterdam: 243-246 .
    [46]张师德,杜鸿梁.土工织物加筋土挡墙形状研究.见:全国第四届土工合成材料学术会议论文集, 1996 .
    [47]黄广军.加筋土挡墙的形状及设计理论研究[D] .铁道部科学研究院博士论文, 1999 .
    [48] P.Di Pietro. Design and construction of soil reinforced structures using composite slopes[C]. Proceedings of 7th International Conference on Geosynthe- tics . France: Nice , 2002 : 221-224 .
    [49] M. Srbulov . Analysis of stability of geogrid reinforced steep slopes and retaining walls [J]. Computers and Geotechnics, 2001 , (28) : 255-268 .
    [50] Rajagopal Karpurapu, Richard J. Bathurst. Behaviour of geosynthetic reinforced soil retaining walls using the finite element method [J]. Computers and Geotechnics, 1995 , (17): 279-299 .
    [51] R. Kerry Rowe , Graeme D. Skinner. Numerical analysis of geosynthetic reinforced retaining wall constructed on a layered soil foundation [J]. Geotexiles and Geomembranes, 2001 , (19): 387-412 .
    [52]陈桂军,何斌.格宾网箱挡土墙在广西高速公路的应用[J] .西部交通科技,2006 , 3(5) : 61-63 .
    [53]顾慰慈.挡士墙土压力计算[A] .北京中国建材工业出版社,200l .
    [54]龚慈,俞建霖,等.绕墙底向外转动刚性挡土墙的土压力计算[J].浙江大学学报(工学版) , 2005 , (11) : 1690-1694 .
    [55]阿尔弗雷德.H.布兰德.石笼与土工格栅[J] .吉林水利, 1993 , (7): 37-39 .
    [56]张波,陶连金,等.石笼挡墙在振压下破坏机理的颗粒流模拟研究[J].公路交通科技, 2009 , 26(10): 48-52 .
    [57]柴贺军,孟云伟,等.柔性石笼挡墙土压力的PFC2D数值模拟[J].公路交通科技, 2007 , 24(5): 48-51 .
    [58]柴贺军,胡元鑫,等.石笼挡墙支挡结构在巫十路的工程应用[J].公路交通科技, 2007 , 24(9): 19-23 .
    [59]贾学明,熊峰,等.柔性石笼挡土墙受力与变形的数值模拟研究[J].公路交通技术, 2008 , 6: 19-22 .
    [60]蒋洋,徐慧,等.石笼单体结构应力-应变特征试验研究[J].技术论坛, 2008 , 2: 94-97 .
    [61]何光春.加筋土工程设计与施工[M] .北京:人民交通出版社, 2000 .
    [62]郑颖人,赵尚毅,宋雅坤.有限元强度折减法研究进展[J] .后勤工程学院学报, 2005 , 3 : 1-6 .
    [63]张鲁渝,郑颖人,赵尚毅,等.有限元强度折减系数法计算土坡稳定安全系数的精度研究[J] .水利学报, 2003 , 1 : 21-27 .
    [64]郑颖人,宋雅坤.土工格栅加筋土挡墙有限元设计方法研究[R].重庆:解放军后勤工程学院.
    [65]杨乃彬.新型绿色加筋格宾挡墙的特点及其在某防护工程中的应用[J].施工技术, 2010 , 70 : 272-274 .
    [66]陈忠达.公路挡土墙设计[M].北京:人民交通出版社, 1999 : 70-92 .
    [67]杜勇立,林伟平.绿色加筋格宾组合结构在市政工程中的应用[J].中国市政工程, 2009 , 6: 18-20 .
    [68]王维,彭勇登,杜勇立,等.加筋格宾组合结构新技术工程应用研究[J].中外公路, 2009, 29(5): 18-22 .
    [69]盛军,李波,郭亚童.罗泾护厂河工程生态石笼的设计探讨[J].水利科技与经济, 2008 , 14(3): 193-196 .

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700