对外贸易与中国地区经济增长差距:机制分析与实证检验
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
中国地区经济增长差距是近些年经济界密切关注的一个热点问题,迄今的研究涉及到地区经济增长差距的演变发展规律、差距构成以及产生原因等多个角度。但是,已有的研究大多从政府政策、地理区位、要素禀赋等因素入手,关于对外贸易与地区经济增长差距的研究尚不多见,且大多着眼于总体分析,忽略了外贸对地区经济增长差距产生影响的作用机制。不可忽视的是,中国最近20多年的高速增长在很大程度上依靠对外开放,其中对外贸易的作用显得尤其重要。同样不可忽视的是,与区域经济增长非均衡相一致的,地区间对外贸易的不平衡发展。具体而言,东部地区与中西部地区在贸易规模、贸易模式等方面均存在较大差异。而且,从时间上来看,中国经济增长差距的扩大与对外贸易的加速发展几乎是完全同步的。中国各地区对外贸易发展差距的现状,以及这种对外贸易发展差距对地区经济增长差距的影响正是本文关注的主题。本文在对现有文献进行梳理的基础上,将研究扩展到作用机制的考察,从总体影响和作用机制双重角度实证分析对外贸易对中国地区经济增长差距的影响。
     本文首先分析了中国对外贸易发展差距的演变趋势、产业和地区结构构成及收敛性。从演变趋势来看,与地区经济发展差距的演变趋势类似,中国对外贸易发展差距的演变基本上处于“U”字型走势之中;从地区结构来看,总体对外贸易发展差异主要是由地区间差异以及东部地区内部差异构成的;从产业结构来看,总体的对外贸易发展差异主要是由制成品贸易上的差异造成的。基于新古典经济理论的收敛性分析表明,总体来说,1978—2005年中国对外贸易发展存在β收敛,但是不存在σ收敛,同时还出现了一定程度的俱乐部收敛特征。
     接下来,本文从总体影响和作用机制双重角度分析了对外贸易对中国地区经济增长差距的影响。综合已有的相关研究,本文对索洛模型作了进一步扩展,在MRW趋同检验方程的基础上增加对外贸易因素,采用趋同核算框架具体分析对外贸易对中国地区经济增长差距的总体影响。实证分析结论表明,从各因素对中国省份劳均GDPσ收敛和β收敛的影响来看,物质资本投资和对外贸易是导致中国省份经济发散的主要因素,而趋同效应和人力资本投资则是促进中国省份经济收敛的主要因素,即对外贸易扩大了中国的地区经济增长差距。
     为了分析对外贸易影响中国地区经济增长差距的机制,本文从前沿生产函数入手,将产出增长分解为投入要素增加、技术进步和效率提升三个部分。进而指出由于各地区对外贸易发展存在差距,其对当地投入要素增加、技术进步和效率提升的作用差异必将对中国地区经济增长差距产生影响。据此,本文将对外贸易影响地区经济增长差距的机制归纳为三个,分别是:资本积累、技术溢出和制度变迁。并且,本文还分别从这三个机制的角度实证分析对外贸易对中国地区经济增长差距的影响。
     从机制角度的实证分析表明,各地区对外贸易发展对资本积累、技术溢出和制度变迁机制的作用均存在较大差异。从资本积累角度来看,“对外贸易——资本积累——经济增长”机制在东部地区和中西部地区存在明显差异,东部地区对外贸易发展通过资本积累对经济增长的影响大于中西部地区对外贸易发展通过资本积累对地区经济增长的影响程度。从技术进步的角度来看,国际R&D溢出对不同地区的影响不同,进口贸易渠道的国际R&D溢出对东部地区的技术进步具有显著的促进作用,但对中西部地区的技术进步却有一定的负面影响。中西部地区未能分享到国际R&D溢出的正面效应,这进一步拉大了东部地区与中西部地区省份的经济增长差距。从制度变迁的角度来看,“对外贸易——制度变迁——经济增长”的作用机制,在不同地区表现不同。大多数东部地区,对外贸易发展通过促进制度变迁而加速了经济增长;而大多数中西部地区,对外贸易仅促进了制度变迁,但尚未对经济增长产生积极作用,或者对外贸易对制度变迁的作用不明显。从经济绩效来看,具备对外贸易通过促进制度变迁而加速经济增长因果关系的省份,经济绩效优于后者。因此,从作用机制角度的实证分析也表明,各地区对外贸易发展对资本积累、技术溢出和制度变迁机制的作用不同,从而扩大了中国的地区经济增长差距。
     基于上述分析,本文最后提出了相应的政策建议,以期能够促进对外贸易增长与中国地区经济的协调发展。
China's regional economic growth disparity has received much attention. Previous studies focus on the evolution law, composition and underlying forces of the regional economic growth disparity. However the forgone studies mentioned much about some factors such as policies, geography position, capital investment, and etc, but paid little attention to foreign trade. There are not many studies on the theme of foreign trade and China's regional economic growth disparity, and they focus on the overall effect but the mechanism. China's fast economic growth in the recent twenty years relies heavily on the opening up, especially international trade. Along side with the imbalanced regional economic growth, regional trade development is uneven. In particular, there is much difference between the East and the Midwest with the respect of trade scale and trade mode. Furthermore, the expansion of Chinese regional economic growth disparity and the fast development of foreign trade are almost synchronous. This dissertation focuses on the present situation of Chinese regional foreign trade development difference and its influence to regional economic growth disparity. Based on the literature review, this dissertation extends the literature to the mechanism analysis and empirically examine of the impact of international trade on the regional economic growth disparity from both overall effect and mechanism.
     This dissertation firstly analyzes the general trend of China's regional foreign trade disparity, as well as the industrial and regional structure and the convergence of China's regional foreign trade disparity. From the general trend of China's provincial foreign trade development difference, it is similar to the evolvement trend of regional economic growth disparity, which is U-type. From the aspect of region structure, the overall difference in international trade disparity results from the distribution difference among regions and the East disparity. From the aspect of industrial structure, the overall difference in international trade disparity results from the final manufacture. Convergence analysis shows that, on the whole, from 1978 to 2005, there isβ- convergence but notσ- convergence, and there is also some characteristics of club convergence.
     The third section analyses the impact of international trade on the regional economic growth disparity from both overall effect and mechanism. Based on previous studies, this dissertation extends the Solow's model and adds the factor of international trade to the MRW convergence equation. Then this dissertation analyzes the impact of international trade on the regional economic growth disparity under the convergence framework. The results show that, from their influence to theσconvergence andβconvergence of GDP per worker, material capital and foreign trade are the main factors which cause Chinese regional economy divergence, while human capital are the main convergence factors. This means foreign trade enlarges China's regional economic growth disparity.
     To analyze the mechanisms through which foreign trade influences China's regional economic growth disparity, this dissertation decomposes the output growth into factors increase, technical progress and efficiency advance according to Frontier Production Function. Due to the regional international trade disparity, this will have different impact on factors increase, technical progress and efficiency advance, which in turn affects the regional economic growth difference. Therefore, this dissertation summarizes the mechanisms through which international trade affects the regional economic growth difference as capital accumulation, technology spillover and institution innovation. And this dissertation further studies the effect of foreign trade on China's regional economic disparity by empirical evidence.
     Empirical results show that the impact of foreign trade on regional capital accumulation, technology spillover and institution innovation between areas differs greatly. From the aspect of capital accumulation, the "foreign trade- capital accumulation - economic growth" mechanism is very different between the East and the Midwest. Through capital accumulation, foreign trade has much greater influence on economic growth in the Ease than in the Midwest. From the aspect of technology spillover, the influence of international R&D spillover varies among areas. International R&D spillover is beneficial to technical progress in the East, but has negative influence in the Midwest. The Midwest can't share the beneficial effect of international R&D spillover, which will unavoidably enlarge the regional economic growth disparity between the East and the Midwest. From the aspect of institution innovation, the "foreign trade- institution innovation - economic growth" mechanism varies among regions. In most East areas, the development of foreign trade promotes institution innovation, and then accelerates economic growth. While in most Central and West areas, foreign trade can only promote institution innovation and has no effect on economic growth, or its effect on institution innovation is not obvious. As to economic performance, provinces possessing the consequence of foreign trade development promoting institution innovation thus accelerating economic growth do better than the latter. Hence, empirical analysis from the three mechanisms also shows that the impact of foreign trade on capital accumulation, technology spillover and institution innovation differs greatly among areas, and this enlargers China's regional economic disparity.
     Based on the above analysis, this dissertation provides some policy suggestions, which will promote China's foreign trade growth and coordinate the regional economic development.
引文
[1]Abramovitz,M.Catching up,Forging Ahead,and Falling Behind[J].Journal of Economic History,1986,46(2):385-406
    [2]Ades,A.& Glaeser,E.Trade and Circuses:Explaining Urban Giants[R].1994,National Bureau of Economic Research,Working Paper,No.4715
    [3]Akita,T.Decomposing Regional Income Inequality in China and Indonesia Using Two-Stage Nested Theil Decomposition Method[J].Annals of Regional Science,2003,37:55-77
    [4]Anderson,E.Openness and Inequality in Developing Countries:A Review of Theory and Recent Evidence[J].World Development,2005,33(7):1045-1063
    [5]Armekatrin,N.& Friso,S.Convergence,Trade and Factor Mobility in the European Union—Implications for Enlargement and Regional Policy[J].Intereconomics,2004,39(3):167-176
    [6]Aroca,P.,Bosch,M.& Maloney,W.F.Spatial Dimensions of Trade Liberalization and Economic Divergence:Mexico 1985-2002[R].2005,World Bank,Working Paper,No.3744
    [7]Arrow,K.J.The Economic Implications of Learning by Doing[J].The Review of Economic Studies.1962,29(3):155-173
    [8]Azzoni,C.R.Economic Growth and Regional Income Inequality in Brazil[J].Annals of regional science,2001,35(1):133-152
    [9]Baekus,D.K.,Kehoe,P.J.International Evidence on the Historical Properties of Business Cycles[J].The American Economic Review.1992,82(4):864-888
    [10]Balassa,B.Exports and Economic Growth:Further Evidence[J].Journal of Development Economics,1978,5:181-189
    [11]Baldwin,R.E.Openness and Growth:What's the Empirical Relationship?[R].2003,National Bureau of Economic Research,Working paper,No.9578.
    [12]Baldwin,R.E.,Martin,P.& Ottaviano,G.Global Income Divergence,Trade,and Industrialization:the Geography of Growth Take-offs[J].Journal of Economic Growth,2001,6:5-37
    [13]Barro,R.& Sala-I-Martin,X.Regional Growth and Migration:a Japan-United States Comparison[J].Journal of the Japanese and International Economies,1992,6:312-346.
    [14]Barro,R.& Sala-I-Martin,X.Convergence[J].The Journal of Political Economy,1997,100(21):223-251
    [15]Barro,R.& Sala-I-Martin,X.Technological Diffusion,Convergence and Growth[J].Journal of Economic Growth,1997,2:1-26
    [16]Barro,R.Human Capital and Growth[J].American Economic Review,2001,91(2):12-17
    [17]Baumol,W.J.Education for Innovation:Entrepreneurial Breakthroughs vs Corporate Incremental Improvements.National Bureau of Economic Research,2004,Working Paper,No.10578
    [18]Baxter,M.& Kouparitsas,M.A.What Determines Bilateral Trade Flows?[R].2005,National Bureau of Economic Research,Working paper,No.12188
    [19]Ben-David,D.Equalizing Exchange:Trade Liberalization and Income Convergence[J].Quarterly Journal of Economics,1993,108(3):653-79
    [20]Ben-David,D.Trade and Convergence among Countries[J].Journal of International Economics,1996,40:279-98.
    [21]Ben-David,D.& Loewy,M.B.Free Trade,Growth,and Convergence[J].Journal of Economic Growth,1998,3:143-70.
    [22]Ben-David,D.Trade,Growth and Disparity among Nations[A].Income Disparity and Poverty,World Trade Organization Special Study 5,Geneva:WTO Publications,2000:11-42
    [23]Ben-David,D.& Kimhi A.Trade and the Rate of Income Convergence[R].National Bureau of Economic Research,Working Paper,2000,No.7642
    [24]Bernard,A.& Jensen,B.Exceptional Exporter Performance:Cause,Effect,or Both?[J].Journal of International Economics,1999,47:1-25
    [25]Bernard,A.B.& Durlauf,S.N.Convergence in International Output[J].Journal of Applied Econometrics,1995,10(2):97-108
    [26]Bernard,A.B.& Jones,C.I.Comparing Apples to Oranges:Productivity Convergence and Measurement Across Industries and Countries[J].American Economic Review,1996:1216-1238
    [27]Breitung,J.Rank Tests for Nonlinear Cointegration[J].Journal of Business &Economic Statistics.1999,19(3)331-340
    [28]Buckley,P.,Clegg J.& Wang C.et al,FDI,Regional Differences and Economic Growth:Panel Data Evidence from China[J].Transnational Corporations,2002,11:1-28
    [29]Cardenas,M.& Ponton,A.Growth and Convergence in Colombia:1950-1990[J].Journal of Development Economics,1995,47:5-37
    [30]Chen,J.& Fleisher R.Regional Income Inequality and Economic Growth in China[J].Journal of Comparative Economics,1996,22:141-164
    [31]Chenery,H.B.& Strout,A.M.Foreign Assistance and Economic Development[J].American Economic Review,1966,56(4):679-733
    [32]Chirmay,T.Grabowski,R.& Sharma,S.C.Exports,Investment,Efficiency and Economic Growth in LDC:an Empirical Investigation[J].Applied Economics,2001,33:689-700
    [33]Christopoulos,D.K.& Tsionas,E.G.Financial Development and Economic Growth:Evidence from Panel Unit Root and Cointegration Tests[J].Journal of Development Economics,2004,73:55-74
    [34]Clerides,S.K.,Lath,S.& Tybout,J.R.Is learning by Exporting Important?Micro-Dynamic Evidence from Colombia,Mexico,and Morocco[J].Quarterly Journal of Economics,1998,113(3):903-947
    [35]Coe,D.& Helpman,E.International R&D Spillovers[J].European Economic Review,1995,39:859-887
    [36]Coe,D.Helpman,E.& Hoffmaister,A.North-South Spillovers[J].Economic Journal,1997,107:134-149
    [37]De Benedictis,L.& Tajoli,L.Openness,Similarity in Trade Structures,and Income Convergence[R].The Conference of Economic Growth and Distribution, 2004
    [38]De La Funente,A.Convergence Equations and Income Dynamics:the Sources of OECD Convergence,1970-1995[J].Economica,2003,70:655-671
    [39]Démurger,S.Infrastructure Development and Economic Growth:an Explanation for Regional Disparities in China?[J].Journal of Comparative Economics,2001,29(1):95-117
    [40]Démurger,S.,Sachs,J.&Woo,W.T.et al The Relative Contributions of Location and Preferential Policies in China's Regional Development:Being in the Right Place and Having the Right Incentives[J].China Economic Review,2002,13:444-465
    [41]Diao,X.,Fan,S.& Zhang,X.China's WTO Accession:Impacts on Regional Agricultural Income—a Multi-Region,General Equilibrium Analysis[J].Journal of Comparative Economics,2003,31:332-351
    [42]Dixit,A.K.& Stiglitz,J.E.Monopolistic Competition and Optimum Product Diversity[J].The American Economic Review,1977,67(3)297-308
    [43]Dollar,D.Outward-Oriented Developing Economies Really do Grow More Rapidly:Evidence from 95 LDCs,1976-85[J].Economic Development and Cultural Change,1992,40:523-44
    [44]Domingo,G.S.International Trade,Technological Diffusion and Convergence [R].CEPR,2003,Discussion Paper,No.1359
    [45]Eaton,J.& Kortum,S.Trade in Ideas:Patenting and Productivity in the OECD[J].Journal of International Economics,1996,40:251-278
    [46]Edwards,S.Openness,Trade Liberalization,and Growth in Developing Countries[J].Journal of Economic Literature,1993,31:1358-93
    [47]Eicher,T.S.Trade,Development and Converging Growth Rates Dynamic Gains from Trade Reconsidered[J].Journal of International Economics,1999,48:179-98
    [48]Elmslie,B.& Criss,A.J.Theories of Convergence and Growth in the Classical Period:the Role of Science,Technology and Trade[J].1999,Economica,66:135-149
    [49]Engle,R.F.& Granger,W.J.Co-Integration and Error Correction:Representation,Estimation and Testing[J].Econometrica,1987,55(2):251-276
    [50]Falvey,R.Foster,N.& Greenaway,D.North-South Trade,Knowledge Spillovers and Growth[J].Journal of Economic Integration,2002,17:650-670
    [51]Fan,C.Of Belts and Ladders:State Policy and Uneven Regional Development in Post-Mao China[J].Annals of the Association of American Geographers,1995,85:421-449
    [52]F(a|¨)re,R.Grosskopf,S.& Norris,M.et al.Productivity Growth,Technical Progress,and Efficiency Change in Industrialized Countries[J].The American Economic Review,1994,84:66-83
    [53]Feder,G.On Exports and Economic Growth[J].Journal of Development Economics,1983,12:59-73
    [54]Ferreira,A.Convergence in Brail:Recent Trends and Long-run Prospects[J].Applied economics,2000,32(4):479-489
    [55]Findlay,R.& Kierzkowski,H.International Trade and Human Capital:a Simple General Equilibrium Model[J].Journal of Political Economy,1983,91(6):957-978
    [56]Fujita,M.& Hu,D.P.Regional Disparity in China 1985-1994:the Effects of Globalization and Economic Liberalization[J].The Annals of Regional Science,2001,35:3-37
    [57]Galor,O.& Mountford,A.Trade,Demographic Patterns,and the Great Divergence:Why are a Third of People Indian and Chinese?[EB/01].http://atar.mscc.huji.ac.il/~melchior/conf-5-03/Oded%20Galor.pdf,2003
    [58]Giannetti,M.The Effects of Integration on Regional Disparities:Convergence,Divergence or Both?[J].European Economic Review,2002,46(3):539-567
    [59]Giles,D.E.& Stroomer,C.N.Does Trade Openness Affect the Speed of Output Convergence? Some Empirical Evidence[R].University of Victoria Working Paper,2005,EWP0509
    [60]Griffith,R.Redding,S.& Van Reenen,J.R&D and Absorptive Capacity:from Theory to Data[M].London:London School of Econnomics:2000:24-36
    [61]Grossman,M.& Helpman,E.Quality Ladders in the Theory of Growth[J].The Review of Economic Studies.1991,58(1):43-61
    [62]Hakura,D.& Jaumote,E The Role of Inter- and Intra- Industry Trade in Technology Diffusion[R].1999,IMF,Working Paper,No.58
    [63]Hall,R.E.& Jones,C.I.Why Do Some Countries Produce So Much More Output Per Worker than Others?[J].The Quarterly Journal of Economics,1999,2:83-118
    [64]Hallward-Driemeier,M.Iasossi,G.& Sokoloff,K.L.Exports and Manufacturing Productivity in East Asia:a Comparative Analysis with Firm-Level Data[R].National Bureau of Economic Research,2002,Working Paper,No.8894
    [65]Hanson,G H.& Harrison,A.E.Trade Lliberalization and Wage Inequality in Mexico[J].Industrial Labor Relations Review,1999,52(2):271-288
    [66]Hanson,G.H.Increasing Returns,Trade and the Regional Structure of Wages[J].Economic Journal,1997,107(440):113-133
    [67]Harris,R.D.F.& Tzavalis,E.Inference for Unit Roots in Dynamic Panels Where the Time Dimension is Fixed[J].Journal of Econometrics,1999,91(2):201-226
    [68]Harrison,A.Openness and Growth:a Time Series,Cross-Country Analysis for Developing Countries[J].Journal of Development Economics,1996,48:419-47
    [69]He,C.F.Information Costs,Agglomeration Economies,and Location of Foreign Direct Investment within China[J].Regional Studies,2002,39:1029-1036
    [70]Henderson,V.Urbanization in Developing Countries[J].The World Bank Research Observer,2002,17(1):89-112
    [71]Hermann-Pillath,C.Kircher,D.& Pan J.C.Disparities in Chinese Economic Development:Approaches on Different Levels of Aggregation[J].Economic Systems,2002,26:31-54
    [72]Hu Dapeng.Trade,Rurual-Urban Migration,and Regional Income Disparity in Developing Countries:a Spatial General Equilibrium Model Inspired by the Case of China[J].Regional Science and Urban Economics,2002,32:311-338
    [73]Im,S.K.,Pesaran,M.H.,Shin,Y.Testing for Unit Roots in Heterogeneous Panels[J].Journal of Econometrics,2003,(115):53-74
    [74]Jian,T.,Sacks,J.D.& Warner,A.M.Trends in Regional Inequality in China[R]. National Bureau of Economic Research,Working Paper,1996,No.5412
    [75]Kanbur,R.& Zhang,X.B.Fifty Years of Regional Inequality in China:a Journey Through Central Planning,Reform and Openness[J].Review of Development Economics,2005,9(1):87-106
    [76]Keller,W.Do Trade Patterns and Technology Flows Affect Productivity Growth[J].World Bank Economic Review,2000,14(1):17-47
    [77]Keller,W.Trade and the Transmission of Technology[J].Journal of Economic Growth,2002,7:5-24
    [78]Krugrnan,P.A Model of Innovation,Technology Transfer,and the World Distribution of Income[J].The Journal of Political Economy,1979,87(2):253-266
    [79]Krugman,P.Trade,Accumulation and Uneven Development[J].Journal of Development Economics,1981,(8):149-161
    [80]Krugman,P.History and Industry Location:the Case of the Manufacturing Belt[J].American Economic Review,1991,81(2):80-83
    [81]Krugman,P.Increasing Returns and Economic Geography[J].Journal of Political Economy,1991,99:183-199
    [82]Krugman,P.On the Relationship Between Trade Theory and Location Theory[J].Review of International Economics[J],1993,1:110-122
    [83]Krugman,P.& Elizondo,R.L.Trade Policy and the Third World Metropolis[J].Journal of Development Economics,1996,49:137-150
    [84]Lichtenberg,F.R.& Potterie,V.P.International R&D Spillovers:A Comment[J].European Economic Review,1998,42(8):p1483-1491
    [85]Lucas,R.On the Mechanics of Economic Development[J].Journal of Monetary Economics,1988,22:3-42
    [86]Lucas,R.Why doesn't Capital Flow from Rich to Poor Countries?[J].AEA Papers and Proceedings,1990,80(2):92-96
    [87]Mankiw N.G.,Romer D.& Weil D.N.A Contribution to the Empirics of Economic Growth[J].Quarterly Journal of Economics,1992,107:407-437
    [88]Martin,R.The New Geographical Turn in Economics:Some Critical Reflections[J].Joumal of Economics,1999,23:65-91
    [89]Matsuyama,K.Why are There Rich and Poor Countries? Symmetry-Breaking in the World Economy[J].Journal of the Japanese and International Economies,1996,10(4):419-439
    [90]Meijl,H.V.Tongeren,F.V.Trade,Technology Spillovers,and Food Production in China[J].Welteirtschaftliches Archiv,1998,134(3):423-449
    [91]Nakajima,T.Catch-up in Turn in a Multi-Country International Trade Model with Learning-by-Doing and Invention[J].Journal of Development Economics,2003,72:117-38
    [92]O'Neil,D.Education and Income Growth Implications for Cross-Country Inequality[J].Journal of political economics,1995,103(6):407-437
    [93]O'Rourke,K.H.& Williamson,J.G Globalization and History[M].Cambridge,MA:The MIT Press.1999:12-35
    [94]O'Rourke,K.H.,Taylor,A.M.& Williamson,J.G Factor Price Convergence in the Late Nineteenth Century[J].International Economic Review.1996,37(3):499-530
    [95]Parikh,A.& Shibata,M.Does Trade Liberalization Accelerate Convergence in per Capita Incomes in Developing Countries[J].Journal of Asian Economics,2004,15:33-48
    [96]Park,D.An Empirical Examination of Income Convergence in the Asia-Pacific Region[J].Journal of Asian Economics,2003,14:497-502
    [97]Pernia,E.M.& Quising P.F.Trade Openness and Regional Development in a Developing Country[J].The Annals of Regional Science,2003,37:391-406
    [98]Persson,J.Convergence Across the Swedish Counties:1911-1993[J].European Economic Reviews,1996,41:1835-1852
    [99]Quah,D.T.Regional Convergence Clusters Across Europe[J].European Economic Reviews,1996,40:951-958
    [100]Raiser M.Subsidizing Inequality:Economic Reforms,Fiscal Transfers and Convergence Across Chinese Provinces[J].Journal of Development Studies,1998,34:1-26
    [101]Ranjan,P.Trade Induced Convergence Through Human Capital Accumulation in Credit-Constrained Economics[J].Journal of Development Economics,2003,72:139-162
    [102]Rassekh,F.The Role of International Trade in the Convergence of Per Capita GDP in the OECD:1950-85[J].International Economic Journal,1992,6(4):1-16
    [103]Rassekh,F.The Interplay of International Trade,Economic Growth and Income Convergence:a Brief Intellectual History of Recent Developments[J].Trade &Economic Development,2004,13(4):371-395
    [104]Rey,S.J.& Montouri,B.D.US Regional Income Convergence:a Spatial Econometric Perspective[J].Regional Studies,1999,33(2):143-156
    [105]Rodrik,D.Subramanian,A.& Trebbi,F.Institutions Rule:the Primacy of Institutions Over Geography and Integration in Economic Development,National Bureau of Economic Research,2002,Working Paper,No.9305
    [106]Rodrik,D.What's so Special about China's Exports?[R].National Bureau of Economic Research,2006,Working paper,No.11947.
    [107]Romer,P.Growth Based on Increasing Returns due to Specialization[J].American Economic Review,1987,77(2):56-62
    [108]Romer,P.Increasing Returns and Long-Run Growth[J].Journal of Political Economy,1986,94(5):1002-1037
    [109]Sachs,J.D.& Warner,A.M.Economic Convergence and Economic Policies[R].National Bureau of Economic Research,1995,Working Paper,No.5039.
    [110]Sachs,J.D.& Warner,A.M.Economic Reform and the Process of Global Integration[J].Brookings Papers on Economic Activity,1995,1:1-118
    [111]Sala-I-Martin,X.Regional Cohesion:Evidence Growth and Convergence[J].European Economic Review and Theories of Regional,1996,40:1325-1352
    [112]Samuelson,P.International Trade and the Equalization of Factor Prices[J].Economic Journal,1948,158:163-184
    [113]Sanchez-Reaza,J.& Rodriguez-Pose,A.The Impact of Trade Liberalization on Regional Disparities in Mexico[J].Growth and Change,2002,33:72-90
    [114]Scully,G.W.The Institutional Frame-work and Economic Development[J]. Journal of Political Economy,1988,96:652-62
    [115]Shorrocks,A.F.Inequality Decomposition by Factor Components[J].Econometrica,1982,50(1):193-211
    [116]Shorrocks,A.F.Inequality Decomposition by Population Subgroups[J].Econometrics,1984,52(6):1369-85
    [117]Silva,J.A.& Leichenko R.M.Regional Income Inequality and International Trade[J].Economic Geography,2004,80(3):261-286
    [118]Sjoholm,F.International Transfer of Knowledge:the Role of International Trade and Geographic Proximity[J].Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv,1996,(132):97-115
    [119]Slaughter,M.J.Per Capita Income Convergence and the Role of International Trade[J].Economic Development and International Trade,1997,87(2):194-199
    [120]Slaughter,M.J.Trade Liberalization and per Capita Income Convergence:a Difference-in-Differences Analysis[J].Journal of International Economics,2001,55:203-228
    [121]Sofronis K.C.& Saul Lach,J.R.Is Learning by Exporting Important?Micro-Dynamic Evidence from Colombia,Mexico,and Morocco Tybout[J].The Quarterly Journal of Economics,1998,113(3):903-947
    [122]Solow,R.A Contribution to the Theory of Economic Growth[J].Quarterly Journal of Economics,1956,70:65-94
    [123]Solow,R.Technical Change and the Aggregate Production Function[J].Review of Economics and Statistics,1957,39:312-320
    [124]Steve,D.& Nguyen D.T.OECD Comparative Economic Growth 1950-1985:Catch-Up and Convergence[J].American Economic Review,1989,79(5):1010-30
    [125]Stokey,N.L.Human Capital,Product Quality,and Growth[J].Quarterly Journal of Economics,1991,106:587-616
    [126]Terrasi M.Convergence and Divergence Across Italian Regions[J].Annals of Regional Science,1999,33:491-510
    [127]Tsui,K.Y.China's Regional Inequalities,1952-1985[J].Journal of Comparative Economics,1991,15:1-21
    [128]Tsui,K.Y.Decomposition of China's Regional Inequalities[J].Journal of Comparative Economics,1993,17:600-627
    [129]Tsui,K.Y.Economic Reform and Inter-Provincial Inequalities in China.Journal of Development Economics,1996,50:353-368
    [130]Venables,A.J.Spatial Disparities in Developing Countries:Cities,Regions,and International Trade[J].Journal of Economic Geography,2005,5(1):3-21
    [131]Walz,U.Transport Costs,Intermediate Goods and Localized Growth[J].Regional Science and Urban Economics,1996,26(6):671-695
    [132]Walz,U.Does an Enlargement of a Common Market Stimulate Growth and Convergence?"[J].Journal of International Economics,1998,45:297-321
    [133]Wei,S.J & Wu,Y.Globalization and Inequality:Evidence from within China[R].National Bureau of Economic Research,2001,Working Paper,No.8611.
    [134]Williamson,J.Regional Inequality and the Process of National Development:a Description of the Patterns[J].Economic Development and Cultural Change,1965,13:3-56
    [135]Winters,L.A.Trade Liberalization and Economic Performance:an Overview[J].The Economic Journal,2004,114(February):4-21
    [136]Xu,B.Multinational Enterprise,Technology Diffusion,and Hose Country Productivity Growth[J].Journal of Development Economics,2000,(62):477-493
    [137]Yao,Y.Provincial Income Convergence,International Trade and Long-run Economic Growth of China 1978-1997:a Panel Data Approach[D].Dissertation for Doctor' Degree,Wolfson College,2000
    [138]Ying,L.G.Understanding China's Recent Growth Experience:a spatial Econometric Perspective[J].The Annals of R Science,2003,37:613-628
    [139]Young A.Learning by Doing and the Dynamic Effects of International Trade[J].Quarterly Journal of Economics,1991,106:369-405
    [140]Young,A.Lessons from the East Asian NICs:a Contrarian View[R].National Bureau of Economic Research,1994,Working Paper,No.4482
    [141]Zhang X.B.& Zhang K.H.How Does Globalization Affect Regional Inequality within a Developing Country? Evidence from China[J].The Journal of Development Studies,2003,39(4):47-67
    [142]保罗·克鲁格曼著.张兆杰译.发展、地理学与经济理论[M].北京:北京大学出版社,2000:37-39
    [143]包群,许和连,赖明勇.出口贸易如何促进经济增长?——基于全要素生产率的实证研究[J].上海经济研究,2003,(3):3-10
    [144]蔡昉,都阳.中国地区经济增长的趋同与趋异—对西部开发战略的启示[J].经济研究,2000,(10):30-37
    [145]陈安平,李国平.中国地区经济增长的收敛性:时间序列的经验分析[J].数量经济技术经济研究,2004,(11):31-35
    [146]陈开军.对外贸易对地区经济差距的影响[D].硕士学位论文,湖南大学,2005
    [147]陈雷,李坤望.区域经济一体化与经济增长收敛性:实证分析[J].南开经济研究,2005,(2):34-39
    [148]陈秀山,徐瑛.中国区域差异影响因素的实证研究[J].中国社会科学,2004,(5):117-130
    [149]陈震和秦慧丽.从制度的角度看外贸对中国经济的影响[J].财贸经济,2001,(11):47-48
    [150]丹尼·罗德瑞克.让开放发挥作用:新的全球经济与发展中国家[M].北京:中国发展出版社:2000:8-19
    [151]董秘刚.技术进步与国际贸易——中国对外贸易增长模式研究[D].博士学位论文,西北大学,2004
    [152]樊纲,王小鲁,张立文等.中国各地区市场化相对进程报告[J].经济研究,2003,3:9-20
    [153]范剑勇,张涛.结构转型与地区收敛:美国的经验及其对中国的启示[J].世界经济,2003,(1):42-48
    [154]范剑勇,朱国林.中国地区差距演变及其结构分解[J].管理世界,2002,(7):37-44
    [155]方希桦、包群和赖明勇.国际技术溢出:基于进口传导机制的实证研究[J].中国软科学.2004,(7):58-64
    [156]傅晓霞、吴利学.制度变迁对中国经济增长贡献的实证分析[J].南开经济研究,2002,(4):70-75
    [157]格罗斯曼G.M.,赫尔普曼E.著.何帆,牛勇平和唐迪译.全球经济中的创新与增长[M].北京:中国人民大学出版社,2002:23-45
    [158]郭庆旺,贾俊雪.中国区域经济趋同与差异的因素贡献分析[J].财贸经济,2006,(2):11-17,89
    [159]郭庆旺、赵志耘、贾俊雪.中国省份经济的全要素生产率分析[J].世界经济,2005,(5):46-54
    [160]贺灿飞,梁进社.中国区域经济差异的时空变化:市场化、全球化与城市化[J].管理世界,2004,(8):8-17
    [161]胡鞍钢,熊义志.我国知识发展的地区差距分析:特定、成因及对策[J].管理世界,2000,(3):5-17
    [162]黄华云.贸易发展与经济增长的影响机制——上海案例研究[J].世界经济研究2004,(11):59-64
    [163]黄少安.关于制度变迁到三个假说及其验证[J].中国社会科学,2000,(4):37-49
    [164]纪宝成,杨瑞龙.中国人民大学中国经济发展报告(2002)[M].北京:中国人民大学出版社,2003:86-87
    [165]金祥荣,朱希伟.“温州模式”变迁与创新——兼对若干转型理论假说的检验[J].经济理论与经济管理,2001,8:70-75
    [166]金雪军,欧朝敏和李杨.全要素生产率、技术进步与R&D投入[J].科学学研究,2006,5:702-705
    [167]金玉国.宏观制度变迁对转型时期中国经济增长的贡献[J].财经科学,2001,(2):24-28
    [168]康继军,张宗益和傅蕴英.经济增长中制度与管理创新的贡献[J].财经科学,2006,(7):57-63
    [169]赖明勇,许和连和包群.出口贸易与中国经济增长理论问题[J].求索,2004,(3):4-8
    [170]赖肖尔.近代日本新观[M].上海:三联书店,1992:8-9
    [171]兰宜生.对外贸易对我国经济增长及地区差异的影响分析[J].数量经济技术经济研究,2002,(7):119-121
    [172]李嘉图.政治经济学及赋税原理[M].北京:商务印书馆,1962:23-35
    [173]李建春.FDI和出口对中国经济增长影响的差异研究[D].博士学位论文,重庆大学,2005
    [174]李平,鲁婧颉.进口贸易对我国各地区全要素生产率增长的实证分析[J].经济问题探索,2006,(2):44-47
    [175]李平,钱利.进口贸易与外国直接投资的技术溢出效应——对中国各地区技术进步的实证研究[J].财贸研究,2005,(6):40-46
    [176]李小平,朱钟棣.国际贸易、R&D溢出和生产率增长[J].经济研究,2006,(2):31-43
    [177]李小平,朱钟棣.国际贸易的技术溢出门槛效应——基于中国各地区面板数据的分析[J].统计研究,2004,(10):27-43
    [178]林毅夫,董先安和殷韦.技术选择、技术扩散与经济收敛[J].财经问题研究,2004,(6):3-10
    [179]林毅夫,刘明兴.中国的经济增长收敛与收入分配[J].世界经济,2003,(8):3-15
    [180]刘力.对外贸易收入分配与区域差距——对中国区域经济差距的贸易成因分析[J].南开经济研究,2005,(4):58-64
    [181]刘木平,舒元.我国地区经济的收敛与增长决定力量:1978-1997[J].中山大学学报(社科版),2000,(5):11-17
    [182]刘乃武.区域收敛与发散理论[J].外国经济与管理,2000,(25):19-24
    [183]刘强.中国经济增长的收敛性分析[J].经济研究,2001,(6):70-77
    [184]刘夏明,魏英琪,李国平.收敛还是发散?—中国区域经济发展争论的文献综述[J].经济研究,2004,(7):70-81
    [185]陆铭,陈钊.城市化、城市倾向的经济政策与城乡收入差距[R].复旦大学就业与社会保障研究中心(ESSRC),2004,工作论文,No.24
    [186]孟健军,川田康治.中国地区经济趋同研究—横断面以及时列分析的统计检验[J].开发研究,2003,(4):12-15
    [187]诺斯.制度变迁与经济绩效[M].上海:上海三联书店、上海人民出版社,1994:22-36
    [188]彭支伟,陈柳钦.转型时期中国经济增长的地区差异与收敛性分析[J].经济研究参考,2006,(3):36-44
    [189]钱雪亚.中国区域经济差异源于FDI?——析二次统计误差的形成[J].统计研究,2007,(3):83-87
    [190]冉光和,李敬,熊德平,温涛.中国金融发展与经济增长关系的区域差距研究——基于面板数据的单位根检验、协整检验与误差纠正模型[R].经济发展论坛,工作论文,2005,No.FC20050081
    [191]沈程翔.中国出口导向型经济增长的实证分析:1977-1998[J].世界经济,1999,(12):26-30
    [192]沈坤荣,李剑.中国贸易发展与经济增长影响机制的经验研究[J].经济研究,2003,(5):32-40,56
    [193]沈坤荣,马俊.中国经济增长的“俱乐部收敛”特征及其成因研究[J].经济研究,2002,(1):33-39
    [194]史晋川.制度变迁与经济发展:“浙江模式”研究[J].浙江社会科学,2005,5:17-22
    [195]覃成林.中国区域经济增长趋同与分异研究[J].人文地理,2004,(3):36-40
    [196]藤田昌久,保罗·克鲁格曼,安东尼·J·维纳布尔斯著.梁琦译.空间经济学——城市、区域与国际贸易[M].北京:中国人民大学出版社,2005:389-408
    [197]涂红.贸易开放、制度变迁与经济增长:基于不同国家规模和发展水平的比较分析[J].南开学报(哲学社会科学版),2006,(3):45-53
    [198]万广华,陆铭和陈钊.全球化与地区间收入差距:来自中国的证据[J].中国社会科学,2005,(3):17-27
    [199]王丽娟.贸易自由化对中国区域经济差距的影响分析[J].世界经济研究,2005,(9):41-47
    [200]王文博,陈昌兵和徐海燕.包含制度因素的中国经济增长模型及实证分析[J].统计研究,2002,(5):3-7
    [201]王小鲁,樊纲.中国地区差距的变动趋势和影响因素[J].经济研究,2004, (1):33-44
    [202]王铮,葛昭攀.中国区域经济发展的多重均衡与转变前兆[J].中国社会科学,2002,(4):31-40
    [203]王志刚.质疑中国经济增长的条件收敛性[J].管理世界,2004,(3):25-30
    [204]魏后凯,外商直接投资对中国区域经济增长的影响[J].经济研究,2002,(4):19-25
    [205]魏后凯.中国地区发展——经济增长、制度变迁与地区差异[M].北京:经济管理出版社,1997:142-168
    [206]吴一丁,毛克贞.我国出口贸易影响经济增长的路径研究[J].国际贸易问题,2006,(2):28-33
    [207]吴玉鸣.中国经济增长与收入分配差距的空间统计研究[D].博士学位论文,华东师范大学,2004
    [208]徐现祥,舒元.物质资本、人力资本与中国地区双峰趋同[J].世界经济,2005,(1):47-57
    [209]许雄奇,张宗益.中国出口发展的地区差异实证研究:1992-2001[J].上海经济研究,2003,(1):3-10
    [210]杨开忠.中国区域经济差异变动研究[J].经济研究,1994,(12):28-32
    [211]杨瑞龙.我国制度变迁方式转换的三阶段论——兼论地方政府的制度创新行为[J].经济研究,1998,(1):3-10
    [212]杨瑞龙.“中间扩散”的制度变迁方式与地方政府的创新行为[A].北京:中国财政经济出版社,1999:121-143
    [213]姚先国,薛强军和黄先海.效率增进、技术创新与GDP增长——基于长三角15城市的实证研究[J].中国工业经济,2007,2:60-66
    [214]易纲,樊纲和李岩.关于中国经济增长与全要素生产率的理论思考[J].经济研究,2003,(8):13-20
    [215]张红霞.外贸出口增长与外资流入的互动机制及启示[J].改革与战略,2005,(11):15-17
    [216]张吉鹏,吴桂英.中国地区差距:度量与成因[J].世界经济文汇,2004,(4):60-81
    [217]张军,吴桂英和张吉鹏.中国省际物质资本存量估算:1952-2000[J].经济研究,2004,(10):35-44
    [218]赵伟.区际开放:左右未来中国区域经济差距的主要因素[J].经济学家,2001,(5):45-50
    [219]赵伟,何莉.中国对外贸易发展地区差异的收敛性分析[J].财贸经济,2006,(9):31-36
    [220]赵伟,何莉.中国对外贸易发展地区差距及其结构分解[J].经济地理,2007,(2):183-189
    [221]赵伟,马瑞永.中国经济增长收敛性的再认识——基于增长收敛微观机制的分析[J].管理世界,2005,(11):12-21
    [222]赵伟,马瑞永,何元庆.全要素生产率变动的分解——基于Malmquist生产力指数的实证分析[J].统计研究,2005,(7):37-42
    [223]赵莹.中国的对外开放和收入差距[J].世界经济文汇,2003,(4):55-70
    [224]钟昌标.国际贸易促进区域经济成长的机制和战略[J].中国软科学,2002,(3):88-91
    [225]朱华友.新经济地理学经济活动空间集聚的机制过程及其意义[J].经济地理,2005,(11):753-756
    [226]庄子银.高级宏观经济学[M].武汉:武汉大学出版社:2004:121-162

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700