摘要
随着国际分工的深化和信息技术的深入发展,国际分工的边界正从产业层次转换为价值链层次,一国的竞争优势也随之不再体现在某个特定产业或某项特定产品上,而是体现为在产业链条中所占据的环节或工序上。在此背景下,我国沿着产品价值链进行的产品内分工逐渐融入了全球分工体系之中,产品内贸易规模不断扩大,贸易结构不断优化,高技术产品比重不断上升。与此相应,附加价值来源逐渐从劳动密集型产业转向技术密集型产业。随着技术水平的提高,中国正处于产业结构更新和升级的过程,深入研究附加价值来源的这种转化,对于我国的产业升级具有重要意义。文章试图将技术进步与产品内分工结合起来,探讨外部性在附加价值来源转化中所起的作用,结合我国产业升级中存在的问题,提出相应的政策建议。
全文分为五个部分。本文的第一部分为导论,介绍了本文的选题意义,对相关文献进行了概括和综述,并阐明了论文的主要内容和创新之处。文章的第二部分界定了附加价值的概念,描述了附加价值来源转化的现状,并从技术进步和产品内分工等几个方面阐述了这种转化发生的原因。在此基础上,文章的第三部分从外部经济、产业集聚和产品内分工入手,对附加价值来源转化的机理进行了理论上的探索。第四部分则是结合苏州外资电子企业集聚对附加价值来源转化的机理进行了实证检验。最后是针对持续发展面临的问题提出对中国产业升级的政策建议。全文形成了一个从理论创新到实证检验,从发现问题到解决问题的相辅相成的有机整体。
With the deepening of international specialization and the development of Information technology, the boundary of international specialization is transforming from the industrial level into the value chain level, the competitive advantage of a country no longer embodies in some specific industrial or some specific product, but embodies in the working procedures and working phases in the product manufacture process. Under this background, the intro-product specialization of our country has integrated in the system of international specialization. It’s characteristic is that the scale of intro-product trade is expanding, the trade structure is optimized and the high-tech product proportion rises. In correspond, the source of added-value gradually transforms from labor-intensive industry into skill-intensive industry. In the course of industrial upgrading, researching the transformation of origin of added-value deeply has huge influence on the industrial upgrading of China. Through connecting the technology advances and intro-product specialization, the paper discusses the externality which is important in the transformation of the origin of added value, and then puts forward the corresponding policy proposal.
The paper is structured in five parts. The first chapter introduces the significance of the topic, reviews the current literatures of relevant topics. Then, the contents and the main findings of this paper are briefly presented. Chapter two begins with defining the concept of added value, described the present situation which the origin of value added transforms, then, the reasons that this kind of transformation occurs are summarized. Chapter Three explores theoretically the mechanisms which the origin of added value transforms on the basis of externality, industrial agglomeration and intra-product specialization. Then,Chapter Four take the electronic agglomeration in Suzhou for example,examines the mechanism above. Finally, According to the above elaborations and discussions, combining the real world situation of China, recommendations are brought about benefit the future development of intra-product specialization and the upgrade of China’s industrial structures. From theoretical innovation to demonstration test,from finding problems to solving problems,the paper form a organic whole.
引文
[1]蔡铂,聂鸣.社会网络对产业集群技术创新的影响[J].科学学与科学技术管理,2003,(7).
[2]陈德球,产品内贸易:理论分析与经验检验[M],兰州商学院,2006.
[3]范剑勇.市场一体化、地区专业化与产业集聚趋势[J].中国社会科学.2004,(6):39-51.
[4]高越,产品内分工与我国加工贸易的结构升级[J],对外经贸实务,2006,(2).
[5]关志雄.从美国市场看"中国制造"的实力--以信息技术产品为中心[J].国际经济评论,2002,4.
[6]郭其友,李宝良,新贸易理论与新地理经济学的发展与融合[J],外国经济与管理,2008,(11).
[7]黄菁.基于垂直专业化分工的加工贸易结构升级研究[D],湖南大学,2005.
[8]梁琦.知识溢出的空间局限性与产业集聚[J],科学学研究,2004,(1).
[9]李春盛,中国产品内贸易现状及其效应研究[M],厦门大学,2007
[10]刘友金,黄鲁成.产业集群的区域创新优势与我国高新区的发展[J].中国工业经济,2001,(2).
[11]卢锋.产品内分工[J].经济学,2004(季刊).
[12]吕文栋,张辉.全球价值链下的地方产业集群战略研究[J].中国社会科学,2005,(2):119-124
[13]梅丽霞,基于全球价值链视角的制造业集群升级研究[M],华中科技大学,2005.
[14]彭中文.知识员工流动、技术溢出与高技术产业聚集[J].财经研究,2005,(4).
[15]裴瑱.陆剑,规模报酬递增和新贸易理论的发展[J].世界经济研究,2006,(9).
[16]田剑英.论企业附加值及其实现途径[J].浙江万里学院学报,2001,(9).
[17]田文.产品内贸易的定义、计量及比较分析[J].财贸经济.2005, (1),77-79.
[18]王缉慈,童昕.地方竞争优势的源泉—论全球化背景下的地方产业群[J].战略与管理,2001,(6):28-36.
[19]王立军.嵌入全球价值链:全球化时代的地方产业集群升级策略[J].特区经济,2004,(10):16-18.
[20]王立平,孙韩,知识外部性与知识溢出[J],科学·经济·社会,2007,(1).
[21]汪永太.从“微笑曲线”下的商品价值观看制造业的“脑体分离”[J].中国集体经济,2007,(4).
[22]魏剑锋,知识溢出、社会网络与产业集群的技术创新[J],北方经济,2008,(8).
[23]温思美,规模经济、垄断竞争与经济活动的空间集聚[J],学术研究,2009,(1).
[24]文嫮,曾刚.全球价值链治理与地方产业网络升级研究——以上海浦东集成电路产业网络为例[J].中国工业经济,2005,(7).
[25]武建强.产业集聚和全球价值链空间重组间的关系研究[J].生产力研究.2008,(24):109-110.
[26]徐康宁,王剑.要素禀赋、地理因素与新国际分工[J].中国社会科学,2006,(6):65-77.
[27]殷德生.报酬递增、动态比较优势与产业内贸易[M],华东师范大学博士论文,2005.
[28]易明,吴金艳.外部经济、企业分工与产业集聚[J],经济探索,2008,(2).
[29]曾铮,张路路.全球生产网络体系下中美贸易利益分配的界定-基于中国制造业贸易附加值的研究[J].世界经济研究,2008,(1).
[30]曾铮,张亚斌.价值链的经济学分析及其政策借鉴[J],中国工业经济,2005,(5).
[31]张辉.全球价值链理论与我国产业发展研究[J].中国工业经济,2004,(5).
[32]张辉.全球价值链动力机制与产业发展策略[J].中国工业经济,2006,(1).
[33]张纪.产品内国际分工中的利益分配[J].中国工业经济,2006,07.
[34]张纪.产品内国际分工:动因、机制与效应研究[M],世界经济研究所,2007.
[35]张明倩,臧燕阳,张琬,传统贸易理论、新贸易理论和新经济地理框架下的产业集聚现象[J],2007,(6).
[36]张文宣.全球价值链理论的经济学分析[J].西北农林科技大学学报,2007,(11):68-72.
[37]赵绪福.产业价值链中不同环节的增值差异与区位选择[J].时代经贸,2006,(7).
[38] Alan V. Deardorff . Gains from Trade and Fragmentation[J] . Paper Prepared for CESifo Workshop Presentation ,2005 ,July18-19.
[39] Sven W. Ardnt. Globalization and the Open Economy[J]. North American Journal of Economics and Finance,1997 ,(1):71-79.
[40]Behrens K.GaignéC.Ottaviano G.I.P. This J-F Inter-regional and International Trade: Seventy Years after Ohlin[J] ,CEPR discussion paper,2003,40-65.
[41] Blien U.Suedekum J.Wolf K Local Employment Growth in West Germany: ADynamic Approach 2004.
[41]Booz-Allen.Hamilton Revitalizing the Korean Economy toward the 21st Century 1997.
[42] Cheng, et al. The Theory of Production[M]. Oxford University Press.2000:99-103.
[43]Deardoff Alan. Fragmentation in Simple Trade Models[J]. University of Michigan, 1998,9(4):23-25.
[44]Dumais G.Ellison G.Glaeser E L Geographic Concentration as A Dynamic Process[J].NBER Working Paper,1997,62-70.
[45] EthierWilfred J. Internationally Decreasing Costs and World Trade[J].Journal of International Economies.1982(9):34-35.
[46]Feenstra,C. Integration of Trade and Disintegration of Production in the Global Economy[J].Journal of Economic Perspective,1998,(4):31-51.
[47] Feldman M P.Audretsch D B Innovation in Cities: Science-based Diversity, Specialization and Localized Competition 1999.
[48]Findlay Ronald, Jones. Input Trade and The Location of Production[J].The American Economic Review.2001,91 (2).
[49]Forslid R.Ottaviano G I P An Analytically Solvable Core-periphery Model 2003
[50]Geriff G. International Trade and Industrial Upgrading in the Apparel Commodity Chain[J].Journal of International Ecnomics,1999.(48).
[51]Geriff G. The Organization of Buyer-Driven Global Commodity Chains: How U.S. Retailers Shape Overseas Production[C].Commodity Chains and Global Capitalism, London: Praege,1994.
[52]Glaeser E H.Scheinkinan J.Shieifer ,A Growth of Cities[M] 1992.
[53] Hummels David, Dana Rapport, Kei-Mu Yi. Vertical Specialization and the Changing Nature of World Trade[J]. Federal Reserve Bank of New York Economic Policy Review, 1998, 4 (2):79-99.
[54]Humphrey and Schmitz. How Does Insertion in Global Value Chains Affect Upgrading in Industrial Clusters?[J].Regional Studies,2002,9.(36).
[55]Ishii, Jun, Kei—Mu Yi. The Nature and Growth of World Trade[M]. Fed-eral Reserve Bank of New York Research Paper, No. 97 18, 1997.
[56]Jones KierzkoWSki. A Framework for Fragmentation[M]. Fragmentation and International Trade, Oxford University Press. 2001(6).
[57] J.Humphrey , H,Schmitz1 Governance in Global Value Chains [J ].IDS Bulletin,2001,32 (3).
[58]Krugman, P. Scale Economies, Product Differentiation, and the Pattern ofTrade[J],American Economic Review,1980,70, 950-959.
[59]Krugman, P., Intra-industry Specialization and the Gains from Trade [J]. Journal of Political Economy,1981,89.
[60]Kwan Chi Hung. The Rise of China and Asia's Flying-Geese Pattern of Economics Development:An Emprical Analysis Based on US Import Statistics[J] 2002.
[61]Kyoung-Hwie Mihn An Analysis of Agglomeration Economies in the Manufacturing Sector of Korea[J].KIET occasional paper,2004,56.
[62]Lall Sanjaya.Albaladejo Manuel China's Competitive Performance: A Threat to East Asian Manufactured Exports [J],2004(9).
[63]Lall Sanjaya.Albaladejo M.Zhang J Mapping fragmentation: electronics and automobiles in East Asia and Latin America[J], 2004(3).
[64]Lall Sanjaya The Technological Structure and Performance of Developing Country Manufactured Exports[J],1985 -1998 2000.
[65]Ottaviano G I P Monopolistic Competition, Trade, and Endogenous Spatial Fluctuations[J].CEPR discussion paper,1996,13-27
[66]Ronald Jones ,Henryk Kierzkowski. International Fragmentation and the New Geography[J] . EIAS Working Paper,2003.
[67]R.C.Feenstra and G.H.Hanson. The Impact of Outsourcing and High-technology Capital on Wages: Estimates for the United states,1979-1990[J].Quarterly Journal of Economics,1999,(3):907-940.
[68]Sanyal Kalyan, Ronald W Jones. The Theory of Trade in Middle Products[J]. American Economic Review. 1982(3):16-31.
1 Sven W. Ardnt. Globalization and the Open Economy[J ] . North American Journal of Economics and Finance ,1997 ,(1) :71 - 79.
1田文.产品内贸易的定义、计量及比较分析[J].财贸经济.2005, (1),77-79
2卢锋.产品内分工(J).经济学,2004(季刊):55-82.
3 Sanyal Kalyan, Ronald W Jones. The Theory of Trade in Middle Products[J]. American Economic Review. 1982 (3) : 16 - 31.
4 Deardoff Alan. Fragmentation in Simple Trade Models[J]. University of Michigan, 1998, 9 (4):23-25.
5 Findlay Ronald, Jones. Input Trade and The Location of Production[J].The American Economic Review. 2001, 91 (2) .
6 Jones Kierzkowski. A Framework for Fragmentation[M]. Fragmentation and International Trade, Oxford University Press. 2001 ( b) : 17 - 34.
1 Ethier Wilfred J. Internationally Decreasing Costs and World Trade[J].Journal of International Economies. 1982 (9) : 34-35.
2 Ishii, Jun, Kei-Mu Yi. The Nature and Growth of World Trade[Z]. Fed-eral Reserve Bank of New York Research Paper, No. 97 18, 1997.
3 Hummels David, Dana Rapport, Kei-Mu Yi. Vertical Specialization and the Changing Nature of World Trade[J]. Federal Reserve Bank of New York Economic Policy Review, 1998, 4 (2):79-99.
4 Jones R.W., Kierzkowskih., Chen L.R. What does evidence tell us about fragmentation and outsourcing [ J ]. International Review of Economics & Finance, 2005,14 (3) : 305 - 316.
5 Cheng, et al. The Theory of Production[M]. Oxford University Press.2000: 99 - 103.
6张纪.产品内国际分工:动因、机制与效应研究[M].上海社会科学院.2007
1 Ronald Jones ,Henryk Kierzkowski. International Fragmentation and the New Geography[J ] . EIAS Working Paper 2003
2 Alan V. Deardorff . Gains from Trade and Fragmentation[J ] . Paper Prepared for CESifo Workshop Presentation,2005,July 18-19
3张纪.产品内国际分工中的利益分配[J].中国工业经济.2006,(7)
1吕文栋,张辉.全球价值链下的地方产业集群战略研究[J].中国社会科学.2005,(2):119-124
2徐康宁,王剑.要素禀赋、地理因素与新国际分工[J].中国社会科学.2006,(6):65-77.
3范剑勇.市场一体化、地区专业化与产业集聚趋势[J].中国社会科学.2004,(6):39-51.
4张文宣.全球价值链理论的经济学分析[J].西北农林科技大学学报.2007,(11):68-72.
5武建强.产业集聚和全球价值链空间重组间的关系研究[J].生产力研究.2008,(24):109-110.
1卢润德.论产品附加值[J].软科学.2003,(3).
2田剑英.论企业附加值及其实现途径[J].浙江万里学院学报.2001,(9)
3汪永太.从“微笑曲线”下的商品价值观看制造业的“脑体分离”[J].中国集体经济,2007,(4).
4赵绪福.产业价值链中不同环节的增值差异与区位选择[J].时代经贸,2006,(7).
5曾铮,张路路.全球生产网络体系下中美贸易利益分配的界定-基于中国制造业贸易附加值的研究[J].世界经济研究,2008,(1).
6曾铮,张亚斌.价值链的经济学分析及其政策借鉴[J].中国工业经济,2005,(6).
1黄菁.基于垂直专业化分工的加工贸易结构升级研究[D].湖南:湖南大学,2005
2资料来源:国家统计局等编,《中国高技术产业统计年鉴》,2007年
1采用BEC分类法,将商品分为原材料、中间产品以及制成品。其中中间产品分为半成品和零部件;制成品分为资本品和消费品
1关志雄从美国市场看"中国制造"的实力--以信息技术产品为中心[J],国际经济评论,2002(4)
2田文.产品内贸易论.经济科学出版社,2006年,P36.
3 Ronald Jones, Henryk Kierzkowski. International Fragmentation and the New Geography[J].EIAS Working Paper,2003.
1 Arndt, Sven W., 1997. "Globalization and the open economy," The North American Journal of Economics and Finance, Elsevier, vol. 8(1)
2 Geriff G. International Trade and Industrial Upgrading in the Apparel Commodity Chain[J].Journal of International Ecnomics,1999.(48).
1《新帕尔格雷夫经济学大辞典》中文本第2卷,P28l-282
2陈琳.外部经济与国际贸易[J].上海经济研究.1997,(12)
1 Marshal.A.,Principles of Economics,8th edn,London Macmillan, 1890.
2 Arrow K. The Economic Implication of Learning By Doing [J].Review of Economic Studies, 1962, 29 (80) : 155-173.
3 Romer PM. Increasing Returns and Long Run Growth[J]. Journal of Political Economy, 1986, 94 (5) : 1002-1037.
4 Lucas R. On the Mechanics of Economic Development[J]. Journal of Monetary Economics, 1988, 22 (1) : 3-42.
5 Jacobs J. The Economy of Cities[M ]. Random House, 1969.
6 Jacobs J. Cities and the Wealth of Nations: Principle of Economic Life[M ]. Viking, London. 1985.
1 Marshal.A.,Principles of Economics,8th edn,London Macmillan, 1890.
2 Viner,J, 1931, Cost Curves and Supply Curves, zeitschrift fiir national ?konomie,3, 23-46, Reprinted in AEA Readings(1952).
3 Myrdal Gunnar, Economic Theory and Under - developed Regions 1957
4 Hirschman, Albert O. ,The Strategy of Economic Development, New Haven, Conn. Yale Univ. Press.
5 Krugman P. Increasing Returns and Economic Geography[J]. Journal of Political Economy, 1991, 99: 183 - 199.
1 Ottaviano G I P. Monopolistic Competition, Trade, and Endogenous Spatial Fluctuations. CEPR discussion paper,1996,No.13-27
2 Dumais G.Ellison G.Glaeser E L Geographic Concentration as A Dynamic Process. NBER Working Paper,1997,62-70
1 Forslid R.Ottaviano G I P An Analytically Solvable Core-periphery Model 2003
2 Behrens K.GaignéC.Ottaviano G I P.Thisse,J-F Inter-regional and International Trade: Seventy Years after Ohlin. CEPR discussion paper,2003,40-65
3梁琦.知识溢出的空间局限性与产业集聚[J].科学学研究.2004,(1)
4 Glaeser E H.Scheinkinan J.Shieifer A Growth of Cities 1992
5 Feldman M P.Audretsch D B Innovation in Cities: Science-based Diversity, Specialization and Localized
Competition 1999
1 Kyoung-Hwie Mihn An Analysis of Agglomeration Economies in the Manufacturing Sector of Korea[KIET occasional paper,2004,56]
2 Blien U.Suedekum J.Wolf K Local Employment Growth in West Germany: A Dynamic Approach 2004
1 Ethier,Wilfred J. National and International Return to Scale in the Modern Theory of International Trade, The American Economic Review, 1982.72,pp.389-405.
2 Ishii Jun and Kei-Mu Yi, The Growth of World Trade, Federal Reserve Bank of New York Research Paper, 1997.No.9718.
1郑海涛等:《走向高端—广东产业集群升级战略研究》,经济科学出版社2006年版,第188页
1王缉慈,童昕.地方竞争优势的源泉-论全球化背景下的地方产业群[J].《战略与管理》,2001,(6):28-36