空间卫星网络自主管理及其协作模型研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
空间卫星网络作为一种新型的无线移动通信网络,与其他通信网络相比独有的特性增加了网络管理的难度,现有的网络管理技术很难应用于空间卫星网络管理。网络自主管理强调分域管理和协作管理,实现自主管理可以满足空间卫星网络管理系统的实时性和抗毁性要求。论文的工作集中在实现空间卫星网络自主管理所需的信息和通信基础、管理域划分算法和协作模型方面,做了以下几个方面的工作:
     1.研究了包括功能模型、信息模型和通信模型的空间卫星网络管理模型
     首先提出包括故障管理、拓扑管理、性能管理、资源与任务管理的空间卫星网络管理功能模型。在故障管理中,提出卫星节点级诊断与卫星载荷级诊断相结合的诊断策略;在拓扑管理中,研究了拓扑轮询机制并分析了网络时延对拓扑信息获取的影响;在性能管理中,给出基于测量的通信链路瓶颈带宽定位方法;在资源与任务管理中,通过定义空间卫星网络的资源给出网络任务的形式化描述并分析了任务的特征。其次提出空间卫星网络管理信息模型SN MIB,采用ASN.1描述语言,利用被管对象的标识符将管理信息以树形的层次化方式组织,利于管理信息的检索与定位,为实现功能模型中的管理功能提供信息基础。最后提出包括域内通信协议IntraDCP和域间通信协议InterDCP的空间卫星网络管理通信模型结构,并详细设计了IntraDCP的协议数据单元。
     2.提出不同空间卫星网络结构中的自主管理域划分算法
     首先在多层空间卫星网络中提出了基于管理分站与被管卫星间通信链路时延的管理域划分算法ABDL,通过分析相关仿真结果,进一步提出了改进划分算法δ-ABDL,提高了管理域的平均稳定时间。其次根据单层空间卫星网络的特征,提出了单层网络管理域划分算法ADSSNMD,并给出了卫星节点选择管理域的算法ASNSM,相关仿真结果表明采用ADSSNMD+ASNSM算法可以提高单层网络管理域的平均稳定时间。从理论上证明了上述算法的唯一性和完备性。
     3.提出基于服务的网络自主管理协作模型
     通过定义服务、管理目标和协作目标,提出了基于服务的网络自主管理协作模型。利用与/或图对该模型进行了描述,并提出了两种协作方案的求解算法AFAMCS和AGCBG。设计了管理分站服务描述语言sMSDL和管理分站间协作交互协议CiCP。最后对自主管理协作模型在空间卫星网络管理功能中的应用进行了研究,其中在故障管理中,研究了协作模型在节点级故障诊断中的应用;在拓扑管理中,研究了协作模型在获取整个网络拓扑信息中的应用;在性能管理中,研究了协作模型在通信链路带宽性能分析中的应用;在资源与任务管理中,研究了协作模型在资源申请、释放以及任务状态获取中的应用。通过上述研究可以看出利用自主管理协作模型可以实现对空间卫星网络的自主管理。
     4.设计了基于HLA/RTI的空间卫星网络自主管理仿真系统SSNAMSS
     在SSNAMSS中卫星节点、星间链路、卫星轨道、管理分站、仿真控制和通信节点路由被划分为功能独立的联邦成员。这种结构具有良好的可扩展性,可适用于不同的空间卫星网络结构,同时可以适应不同的路由策略和各类空间通信链路模型。对空间卫星网络自主管理的故障诊断、拓扑发现、通信链路带宽获取以及资源与任务管理中的资源申请和释放进行了仿真,并对采用地面网管中心管理网络进行了仿真,最后对空间卫星网络自主管理的协议进行了仿真。相关仿真结果表明采用自主管理不仅可以完成各项管理功能,而且能实时的管理网络,解决了采用地面网管中心管理网络时所面临不能实时管理网络的问题;IntraDCP在响应时间和带宽占用率上比SNMP更适合空间卫星网络的管理;对管理分站间协作时产生的通信量进行统计的结果表明管理分站间利用自主管理协作模型进行协作产生的数据量所占比重很小,满足空间卫星网络管理的需求。
Space satellites network is a novel wireless mobile communication network. Comparing with other communication networks, its unique properties increase the difficulties to the network management and current network management technologies can be hardly used in its management. Network autonomous management emphasizes distributed managing network by collaboration and can meet the requirements of real-time managing and anti-destruction ability of space satellites network management system. Focusing on the foundation of information and communication, algorithms of dividing management domains and collaboration model, which are required in the implementation of space satellites network autonomous management, this paper makes following contributions:
     1. Investigate the management model in space satellites network management, which includes function model, information model, and communication model.
     Propose the function model which includes fault management, topology management, performance management, resource and mission management. In fault management, diagnosing policy combining satellite nodes diagnosis and payloads diagnosis is proposed; in topology management, the mechanism of topology polling is researched and the effects of delay of network on collecting topology information are analyzed; in performance management, a method of locating bottleneck of communication links is proposed; in resource and mission management, formal description of mission in satellites network is presented by defining the resources of satellites network and the characteristics of mission are analysed. Propose the information model, SN_MIB, in space satellites network management, which using ASN.1 to organise the management information of managed object in hierarchical tree-type according to the managed object identifier. The indexing and locating the management information can be easily performed. And the information model provides the information basis in the implementation of management function. Propose the architecture of communication model, which includes IntraDCP and InterDCP, and the protocol data units of IntraDCP are designed.
     2. Propose algorithms of dividing management domains in different architectures of satellites networks.
     Firstly a dividing algorithm of management domains, ABDL, is given based on the delay of communication links between the managed satellites and the sub-managers in multiplex-layers space satellites network. An improved algorithm,δ-ABDL, which can increase the average stable time of management domains, is presented with a dividing factorδbased on the analysis of related simulation results. A dividing algorithm of management domains in simplex-layer satellites network, ADSSNMD, is given based on its characteristics and the algorithm of the managed satellites selecting its sub-manager, ASNSM, is also presented. Related simulation results show that algorithm of ADSSNMD+ASNSM can increase the stable time of the management domains. The uniqueness and the completeness of these algorithms are proven in theory.
     3. Present a service-based collaboration model of network autonomous management.
     By defining the service, management goal and collaboration goal, service-based collaboration model is presented. Describe the model with and/or graph and two algorithms of finding collaboration schemes, AFAMCS and AGCBG, are proposed. A service description language, sMSDL, and collaboration inter-communication protocol, CiCP, are designed. Finally research the applications of autonomous management collaboration model in management functions of space satellites network. In fault management, application of collaboration model in nodes diagnosis is researched; in topology management, application of collaboration model in gathering the topology information of entire network is researched; in performance management, application of collaboration model in analyzing the bandwidth performance of the communication links is researched; in resource and mission management, application of collaboration model in applying and releasing resource, gathering status of mission are researched. These researches show that the collaboration model of autonomous management can implement the autonomous management in satellites network.
     4. Design SSNAMSS, a HLA/RTI-based simulation system of space satellites network autonomous management.
     In SSNAMSS, satellite nodes, inter-satellites links, satellite orbits, sub-managers, simulation controlling and communication nodes' routing are divided into function-independent federates. This architecture has a good extensibility and it can be used in different satellite constellations while it is adapted to different routing strategies and types of space communication link models. Simulate the nodes fault diagnosis, topology discovery, obtaining the bandwidth of communication links, applying and releasing the resources in resource and mission management. Meanwhile simulate the managing the satellites network by the ground network management center. Related simulation results indicate that autonomous collaboration model can support sub-managers to fulfill the management tasks of the whole network and that autonomous network management can resolve the problem that ground network center can not manage network in real time. Statistics of simulating IntraDCP and SNMP show that IntraDCP is more suitable for satellites network management than SNMP in respect of the responding time and the ratio of using bandwidth. Statistics of data stream generated by the communication of collaboration among sub-managers show that collaboration model can meet the requirements of satellites network management.
引文
[1]L(u|¨)ders R D.Satellites Networks for Continuous Zonal Coverage.Journal of the American Rocket Society,1961,31:179-184
    [2]Walker J G.Comments on "Rosett Constellation of Earth Satellite".IEEE Trans.on Aerospace and Electronic Systems,1982,18(4):723-724
    [3]Castiel D,Draim J E.The Elliso~(TM) Mobile Satellite System.Proc.of the 4th International Mobile satellite Conference,Ottawa,Canada,1995:409-418
    [4]Lo M W.Satellite-Constellation Design.IEEE Computing in Science and Engineering,1999,1(1):58-67
    [5]Ballard A H.Rosette Constellations of Earth Satellites.IEEE Trans.on Aerospace and Electronic System,1980,16(5):656-673
    [6]Draim J E,Cefola P J,Castiel D.Elliptical Orbit Constellations-A New Paradigm for Higher Efficiency in Space Systems.Proc.of 2000 IEEE Aerospace Conference,Big Sky,Montana,2000:18-25
    [7]Vatalaro F,Corazza G E,Caini C,et al.Analysis of LEO,MEO,and GEO Global Mobile Satellite Systems in the Presence of Interference and Fading.IEEE Journal on Selected Areas In Communications,1995,13(2):291-300
    [8]Clarke A C.Extra-terrestrial Relays.Wireless World,1945,10:305-308
    [9]Farserotu J,Prasad R.IP/ATM 移动卫星网络.谷深远,黄国策等译.北京:电子工业出版社,2003.
    [10]全庆一,胡键栋.卫星移动通信.北京:北京邮电大学出版社,2000.
    [11]甘良才,杨桂文,茹国宝.卫星通信系统.武汉:武汉大学出版社,2002.
    [12]R.J.Leopold and A.Miller.The Iridium Communications System[J],IEEE Potentials,1993,12(2):6-9.
    [13]Sturza M A.Architecture of the Teledesic Satellite System.Proc.of the International Mobile Satellite Conference,Ottawa,Canada,1995:212-218
    [14]Taormina F A.An NGSO Expansion to the Spaceway Global Broadband Satellite System.filing with the US Federal Communications Commission,Hughes Communications,Inc.,1997.
    [15]Elizondo E,Gobbi R,Modelfino A,et al.Evolution of the Astrolink System.Proc.of the 3th Ka-band utilization conference,Sorento,Italy,1997:3-7
    [16]Henderson T R.Networking over Next-Generation Satellite Systems:[dissertation].Berkeley:University of California,1999.
    [17]Lee J,Kang S.Satellite over Satellite(SOS) Network:A Novel Architecture for Satellite Network.Proc.oflEEE INFOCOM,Tel Aviv,Israel,2000,1:315-321
    [18]Hu Y,Li V O K.Satellite-based Internet:A Tutorial.IEEE Communications Magazine,2001,39(3):154-162
    [19]Akyildiz I F,Jeong S.Satellite ATM Networks:A Survey.IEEE Communications Magazine,1997,35(7):30-44
    [20]Wiedeman R A,Viterbi A J.The Globalstar Mobile Satellite System for Worldwide Personal Communications.Proc.of the International Mobile Satellite Conference,Pasadena,California,1993:291-296
    [21]Ghedia L,Smith K,Titzer G.Satellite PCN-the ICO system.International Journal of Satellite Communications,1999,17(4):273-289
    [22]Fitzpatrick E J.Spaceway System Summary.Space Communications,1995,13:7-23
    [23]Fitzpatrick E J.Spaceway:Providing Affordable and Versatile Telecommunication Solutions.Pacific Telecommunications Review,1995,17(1).
    [24]英春,史美林.自主网体系结构研究.通信学报,1999,20(9):47-54
    [25]Akyildiz I F,Ekici E,Bender M D.MLSR:A Novel Routing Algorithm for Multilayered Satellite IP Networks.IEEE/ACM Trans.on Networking,2002,10(3):411-424
    [26]王亮.带有星间链路的卫星网络路由算法研究:学位论文.哈尔滨:哈尔滨工业大学,2003.
    [27]Papapetrou E,Pavlidou F N.QoS Handover Management in LEO/MEO Satellite Systems.International Journal Wireless Personal Communications,2003,24(2):189-204
    [28]Wang C J.Performance Modeling of A Class of Low Earth Orbit Satellite Networks.Proc.of GLOBECOM '93,Piscataway,N J,IEEE,1993,1:569-573
    [29]胡剑浩,吴诗其,李乐民.具有星际链路的卫星移动通信网络性能分析.电子学报,1999,27(11):65-68
    [30]M.Subramanian著,王松,周靖,孟纯城译.网络管理.北京:清华大学出版社,2003.
    [31]郭军.网络管理与控制技术.北京:人民邮电出版社,1999.
    [32]吴继峰,孙波,卫东华.网络故障诊断专家系统的方法研究.计算机应用与软件,2003,20(9):75-77
    [33]刘康平,朱海萍,李增智.告警关联与故障诊断专家系统研究与实现.计算机工程,2002,28(6):11-12,68
    [34]Luo Huawen.Agent-based Network Management System:[dissertation].The University of British Columbia,2002.
    [35]Bieszezad A,Pagurek B,White T.Mobile Agents for Network Management.IEEE Communications Surveys & Tutorials,1998,1(1):2-9
    [36]Zhang J X,Wu J P,Wang J L.A Novel Network Management Architecture Based on CORBA and Intelligent Agent Technology. Proc. of International Conference on Machine Learning and Cybernetics, 2002(3): 1139-1143
    [37] Sekercioglu Y A, Pitsillides A, Vasilakos A V. Computational Intelligence in Management of ATM Networks: A Survey of Current State of Research. Soft Compute, 2001, 5(4): 257-263
    [38] Ascia G, Catania V, Ficili G, et al. A VLSI Fuzzy Expert System for Real-time Traffic Control in ATM Networks. IEEE Trans, on Fuzzy Systems, 1997, 5(1):20-31
    [39] Lee S W, Palmer-Brown D, Roadknight C M. Performance-guided Neural Network for Rapidly Self-Organising Active Network Management.Neurocomputing, Special Issue on Hybrid Neurocomputing, Elsevier Science,Netherlands, 2004,61C: 5-20
    [40] Tennehouse D, Wetherall D. Towards an Active Network Architecture. Proc. of DARPA Active NEtworks Conference and Exposition, San Francisco, 2002:2-15
    [41] Bond A H, Gasser L. An Analysis of Problems and Research in DAI. Readings in Distributed Artificial Intelligence. Morgan Kaufmann Publishers Inc., Los Angeles, 1988:3-35
    [42] Somers F, Evans R, Kerr D, et al. Scalable Low-latency Network Management Using Intelligent Agents. Proc. of World Telecom Congress ISS, Toronto, 1997.
    [43] Luo Z, Bigham J, Cuthbert L.G, et al. Traffic Control and Resource Management Using A Multi-Agent System. Proc. of Conference on Broadband Communications, Hong Kong, 1999.
    [44] Vila P, Marzo J L, Bueno A. Automated Network Management Using a Hybrid Multi-Agent System. Proc. of Artificial Intelligence and Applications, Malaga,2002: 9-12
    [45] Vila P, Marzo J L, Bueno A, et al. Distributed Network Resource Management Using A Multi-Agent System: Scalability Evaluation. Proc. of Symposium on Performance Evaluation of Computer and Telecommunication Systems, San Jose,2004.
    [46] Iraqi Y, Boutaba R. A Multi-agent System for Resource Management in Wireless Mobile Multimedia Networks. Proc. of the 11th IFIP/IEEE International Workshop on Distributed Systems: Operations and Management Services Management in Intelligent Networks, 2000: 218-229
    [47] Li H, Baras J. Intelligent Distributed Fault Management for Communication Networks. Technical Reports of Institute for System Research, University of Maryland, 2000, No. 38
    [48] Boutaba R, Iraqi Y, Mehaoua A. A Multi-Agent Architecture for QoS Management in Multimedia Networks. Journal of Network and Systems Management,2003,11:83-107
    [49]Rallapalli S.Emulation of A Space Based Internet Communication Link:Design and Implementation:[dissertation].Lawrence:University of Kansas,2002.
    [50]Baliga S R.Design of A Space Based Internet Emulation System:[dissertation].Lawrence:University of Kansas,2001.
    [51]Thyagarajan K.Design and Implementation of Data Models and Instrument Scheduling of Satellites in A Space Based Internet Emulation System:[dissertation].Lawrence:University of Kansas,2001.
    [52]段彬,韩潮.卫星星座仿真系统的设计与实现.计算机仿真,2002,19(6):37-38.12
    [53]王鹏,白建军,卢泽新.卫星网络协议的仿真与模拟技术研究.计算机科学与工程,2004,26(5):4-6
    [54]宋娜,刘群.基于OPNET的卫星网络仿真平台设计.计算机工程与应用,2005,41(4):158-160
    [55]李馨,叶明.OPNET Modeler网络建模与仿真.西安:西安电子科技大学出版社,2006.
    [56]王曦爽,孟新.卫星网络仿真系统建模的研究.计算机工程与应用,2004,40(23):142-144
    [57]王永胜,吴德伟.卫星通信网络仿真研究.无线电通信技术,2004,30(4):1-2
    [58]徐雷鸣,庞博,赵耀.NS与网络模拟.北京:人民邮电出版社,2003.
    [59]Zeng B,Li Z T,Wang W.Design for The Simulation of Space Based Information Network.Journal Of Systems Engineering And Electronics,2006,17(2):443-449
    [60]Malakooti B,Endres S,Griffith M,et al.A Space Based Interact Network Emulation for Deep Space Mission Applications.22nd AIAA International Communications Satellite Systems Conference & Exhibit 2004(ICSSC),Monterey:American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics,2004.
    [61]Malakooti,B,Endres,S,Bhasin K,et al.Deep Space Network Emulation.SIW-4:The Fourth Space Internet Workshop,2004.
    [62]吴明巧,钟海荣.基于HLA/RTI的卫星组网联邦原型开发.系统仿真学报,2004,16(6):1292-1295
    [63]苑喆,张军,柳重堪.一种简化的移动卫星网络仿真方案.系统仿真学报,2005,17(1):207-209,222
    [64]Case J,Fedor M,Schoffstall M,et al.A Simple Network Management Protocol (SNMP).RFC 1157,1990.
    [65]Black U.Network Management Standards:SNMP,CMIP,TMN,MIBs,and Object libraries.New York:McGraw-Hill,1995.
    [66]姜月秋,冯永新,赵永翼等.一种新的网络管理协议--多元化网络管理协议原型设计.兵工学报,2003,24(4):472-475
    [67]侯霞.卫星网络故障检测与诊断相关技术的研究:学位论文.北京:中国科学院软件研究所,2005.
    [68]洪志国.基于随机Petri网模型的卫星网络性能分析研究:学位论文.北京:中国科学院软件研究所,2005.
    [69]Olariu S,Todorova P.Resource Management in LEO Satellite Networks.IEEE Potentials,2003,22(2):6-12
    [70]Losquadro G,Podda V,Carducci F.The EuroSkyWay Worldwide System-Providing Broadband Service to Fixed and Mobile End User.Proc.4~(th) Ka Band Utilization Conference,Genova,Italy,1998:33-40
    [71]Blefari-Melazzi N,Reali G.A Resource Management Scheme for Satellite Networks.IEEE Multimedia,1999,6(4):54-63
    [72]http://www.scps.org/html/protocol_standards.html
    [73]McCloghrie K,Rose M.Management Information Base for Network Management of TCP/IP-based internets:MIB-Ⅱ.RFC 1213,1991.
    [74]孟洛明.现代网络管理技术.北京:北京邮电大学出版社,1999.
    [75]Todorova P.Network Management in ATM LEO Satellite Networks.Proc.of the 35th Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences.Hawaii:IEEE Computer Society,2002.
    [76]闻英友,姜月秋,赵建立等.卫星综合信息网的管理体系及管理星簇生成算法.东北大学学报(自然科学版),24(7):651-654
    [77]Jiang Y,Liu Y,Wen Y,et al.A Clustering Algorithm Applied to the Satellite Networks Management.
    [78]冯永新,王光兴,刘治国等.一个应用于移动Ad Hoc网络管理的簇生成算法.软件学报,2003,14(1):132-138
    [79]杨家海,任宪坤,王沛瑜.网络管理原理与实现技术.北京:清华大学出版社,2000.
    [80]Preparata F P,Metze G,Chien R T.On the Connection Assignment Problem of Diagnosable Systems.IEEE Trans.on Electronic Computers.1997,16(6):848-854
    [81]林闯.计算机网络和计算机系统的性能评价.北京:清华大学出版社,2001.
    [82]Allen B.Using Pathchar to Estimate Internet Link Characteristics.Proc.of ACM SIGCOMM99,New York,1999:241-250.
    [83]魏丽红,蔺思涛,丁涌等.资源管理SID建模方法及在网络管理系统中的应用.北京邮电大学学报,2004,27(6):90-96
    [84]王建国,韩冬,李增智等.主动网络中的节点资源管理.计算机工程与应用, 2002,38(3):170-171
    [85]徐云斌,宋鸿升,桂烜等.ASON网络资源管理信息模型设计.电子与信息学报,2005,27(7):1131-1135
    [86]铁伟.浅析网络资源管理与网络管理的关系.电信技术,2004,8:32-34
    [87]闻英友,赵建立,王光兴.卫星网网络管理中资源管理与任务管理的研究.小型微型计算机系统,2005,26(5):757-760
    [88]王红霞,刘治国,潘成胜.分布式网络管理中的任务管理与任务调度的研究.沈阳工业学院学报,2004,23(3):51-53
    [89]姜月秋,闻英友,王光兴.卫星综合信息网中的资源管理和任务调度.小型微型计算机系统,2004,25(11):1899-1903
    [90]ISO/IEC 8824.Information Processing Systems—Open Systems Interconnection(OSI)—Specification of Abstract Syntax Notation One(ASN.1),1992.
    [91]ISO/IEC 10165-4.Guidelines for the Definition of Managed Objects--A standard for defining data models on ASN.1,1992.
    [92]Rose M,McCloghrie K.Structure and Identification of Management Information for TCP/IP-Based Internets.RFC 1155,1990.
    [93]McCloghrie K,Rose M.Management Information Base for Network Management of TCP/IP-Based Internets.RFC 1156,1990.
    [94]严蔚敏,吴伟民.数据结构.北京:清华大学出版社,1997.
    [95]郗晓宁,王威.近地航天器轨道基础.长沙:国防科技大学出版社,2003.
    [96]Axelrod R.The Evolution of Cooperation.New York:Basic Books,1984.
    [97]姚莉,张维明.智能协作信息技术.北京:电子工业出版社,2002.
    [98]于显洋.组织社会学.北京:人民大学出版社,2002.
    [99]马克思.资本论(1)北京:人民出版社,1975a:362
    [100]Schmidt K.Remarks on The complexity of Cooperative Work.RSTI-RAI,2002,16(4):443-483
    [101]史美林,向勇,杨光信.计算机支持的协同工作理论与应用.北京:电子工业出版社,2000.
    [102]Austin J.How to Do Things with Word.Oxford:The Claren-don Press,1962.
    [103]Kuutti K.The Concept of Activity as a Basic Unit for CSCW Research.Proc.of the 2nd ECSCW,Amsterdam,1991:249-264
    [104]Trevor J,Rodden T,Blair G S.COLA:A Lightweight Platform for CSCW.CSCW:An International Journal,1994,3(2):197-224
    [105]Sarit Kraus.Negotiation and Cooperation in Multi-Agent Environments.Artificial Intelligence Journal.Special Issue on Economic Principles of Multi-Agent Systems,1997,94(1):79-98
    [106]Smith R G.The Contract Net Protocol:High Level Communication and Control in a Distributed Problem Solver.IEEE Trans.on Computers,1980,29(12):1104-1113
    [107]王建民,闻立杰.工作流管理——模型方法和系统.北京:清华大学出版社,2004.
    [108]Griss M,Bolcer G,Osterweil L,et al.Agents and Workflow-An Intimate Connection,or Just Friends.TOOLS99,Panel,1999.
    [109]Chen Q,Dayal U,Hsu M,et al.Dynamic Agents,Workflow and XML for E-Commerce Automation.International Conference on E-Commerce and Web-Technology,UK,2000.
    [110]Smith M P,Davis R.Frameworks for Cooperation in Distributed Problem Solving.IEEE Trans.on System,Man and Cybernetics,1981,11(1):61-70
    [111]Lesser V R,Erman L D.Distributed Interpretation:A Model and Experiment.IEEE Trans.on Computers,1980,29(12):1144-1163
    [112]Lesser V R,Corkill D D.Function-Accurate,Cooperative Distributed Systems.IEEE Trans.on System,man and Cybernetics,1981,11(1):81-96
    [113]Hayes-Roth B.BBI:An Architecture for Blackboard Systems That Control,Explain and Learn about Their Own Behavior.Heuristic Programming Project Report,Stanford University,1984.
    [114]Kahan J P,Rapoport A.Theories of Coalition Formation.Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.New Jersey:Hillsdale,1984.
    [115]Wellman M P.A Market-Oriented Programming Environment and Its Application to Distributed Mulitcommodity Flow Problems.Journal of Artificial Intelligence Research,1993(1):1-23
    [116]Wooldridge M,Jennings N R.Towards A Theory of Cooperative Problem Solving.In Proc.of Modelling Autonomous Agent in a Multi-Agent World (MAAMAW-94),Odense,1994,15-26
    [117]Grosz B,Sarit K.Collaborative Plans for Complex Group Actions.Artificial Intelligence,1996,86(2):269-357
    [118]Grosz B,Sarit K.The Evolution of SharedPlans.In Foundations and Theories of Rational Agencies,1999:227-262
    [119]Tambe M.Towards Flexible Teamwork.Journal of Artificial Intelligence Research,1997,7:83-124
    [120]Pynadath D,Tambe M,Chauvat N,et al.Toward Team-Oriented Programming.Proc.of the Agents,Theories,Architectures and Languages(ATAL'99) workshop,Springer Verlag,Intelligent Agents Ⅵ,1999.
    [121]焦文品,史忠植.多主体间的协作过程研究.计算机研究与发展,2000,37(8):904-911
    [122]焦文品.基于进程演算的主体理论及面向主体的软件开发方法研究:学位论文.北京:中国科学院计算研究所,2000.
    [123]Markus Hannebauer.Autonomous Dynamic Reconfiguration in Multi-Agent Systems:Improving the Quality and Efficiency of Collaborative Problem Solving.Berlin:Springer-Verlag,2002.
    [124]Russell S,Norving P.Artificial Intelligence:A modern Approach.Beijing:Person Education North Asia Limited and People's Posts & Telecommunications Press,2002.
    [125]Nilsson N J.Artificial Intelligence:A New Synthesis.Beijing:China Machine Press & Morgan Kaufmann Publishers,1999.
    [126]蔡自兴,徐光祜.人工智能原理及其应用(第三版).北京:清华大学出版社,2003.
    [127]李天庆,张毅,宋靖雁等.与/或图数据库的可达算法和寻根算法.清华大学学报(自然科学版),2001,41(9):81-84
    [128]李天庆,张毅,宋靖雁等.与/或图数据库的关系模式规范化算法。清华大学学报(自然科学版),2001,41(3):89-92
    [129]倪丽娜.一个新的与/或图求解算法.山东科技大学学报(自然科学版),2000,92-94
    [130]http://www.w3.org/TR/Wsdl
    [131]XML中国论坛.XML实用进阶教程.北京:清华大学出版社,2001.
    [132]http://www.w3.org/TR/soap
    [133]周彦.HLA仿真程序设计.北京:电子工业出版社,2002.
    [134]付正军,王永红.计算机仿真中的HLA技术.北京:国防工业出版社,2003.
    [135]DMSO.Modeling and Simulation(M&S) Master Plan[EB/OL].https://www.dmso.mil/public/dod/policy,1995.
    [136]杨颖,王琦.STK在计算机仿真中的应用.北京:国防工业出版社,2005.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700