中国北方古代人群Y染色体遗传多样性研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
中国北方是东亚地区连接北亚、中亚乃至欧洲文明的枢纽地带,它幅员辽阔,自然生态环境多种多样,适合于农耕、游牧、渔猎等多种经济生活方式共存,自古以来就是人类生活的沃土,众多古代族群曾在这里繁衍生息并留下了宝贵的物质文化遗产。该地区的古代先民还先后多次武力夺取政权,大范围的战乱曾在历史上引发北民南移,加速了中国南、北方人群的基因融合。部分古代民族甚至远征欧洲,使其后裔遍布各地,对整个欧亚大陆的人群交流起到促进作用。这些事件使北方人群在人类的迁徙史中占据重要地位。因此,这一地区古代人群的遗传学研究对于追溯华夏民族的原始遗传构成,推测欧亚大陆人群迁徙、融合的具体模式具有重要意义。本研究通过对中国北方13个考古遗址—新疆小河墓地、哈密天山北路墓地、巴里坤黑沟梁墓地、宁夏彭阳墓地、青海西宁陶家寨墓地、山西绛县横北村墓地、河北蔚县三关墓地、庙子沟遗址、牛河梁遗址、哈拉海沟墓地、大甸子遗址、大山前遗址、井沟子墓地—出土的人类遗骸进行父系分子遗传学研究,总结出各古代人群Y染色体单倍型类群的分布规律和特点,并结合相关古代、现代人群的分子遗传学数据,揭示中国北方不同区域古代人群的父系遗传多样性,探讨不同时期古代人群遗传构成的动态变化过程,为阐明北方族群起源、流向及人群间融合分化等问题提供分子遗传学证据。所得结果如下:
     第一、对东北辽西地区5个考古遗址出土的78例男性古代人类遗骸中获得44例样本的Y-DNA结果,分别归属于C、N和O三种单倍型类群。其中单倍型类群N在辽西地区古代人群中长期、广泛的存在,并且占有较大的比例,在距今5500-3000年前,是该地区古代人群父系遗传构成中最主要的成分;根据单倍型类群O在辽西地区古代人群中出现的频率及其所在人群的文化属性与生活方式,并结合相关古代人群的Y-SNP研究结果,我们推测单倍型类群O可能是由中原地区北上,移居到辽西地区的古代农业人群所携带的单倍型类群。而单倍型类群C的出现则可能与南下的北亚的游牧民族有关。以上数据表明辽西地区土著人群的父系遗传结构在保持连续性的同时,融入了古代中原及北亚人群的父系基因成分。
     第二、从64例西北地区男性古代人类遗骸中成功获得46例样本的Y-DNA结果,归属于N、O、Q和R四个单倍型类群。西北地区古代人群的父系遗传构成具有明显的地域特异性,例如最西端的小河人群以西部谱系中的R1a1为主体单倍型类群;毗邻内蒙古地区的彭阳人群中所有个体均可归属于单倍型类群Q,是北亚人群中高频存在的单倍型类群;而临近中原地区的陶家寨人群的父系Y-DNA以东亚单倍型类群O为主,与现代汉族人群相似。综合分析西北地区古代人群的父系遗传结构可知,西北地区各古代人群的父系遗传构成存在显著不同,根据所得遗传学数据推测之所以产生这些不同,主要是由于不同人群有着不同的父系起源,每个人群所接受的祖先人群的基因贡献是不同的,并且从父系方面来看,人群间的交流较少,从而使其自身独特的基因成分得以保留。
     第三、成功从48例华北地区的男性古代人类遗骸中获得29例样本的Y-DNA结果,归属于N、O和Q三种单倍型类群。其中单倍型类群O所占的比重最大,多样性最高,并在华北古代中原地区的两个考古遗址中均有发现;单倍型类群Q高频存在可能是由于山西曾是古代游牧民族“狄人”主要的活动区域;单倍型类群N出现表明中原与辽西地区可能存在人群间的基因交流。综合分析各地区古代人群的Y-DNA研究结果可知,西北与东北地区古代人群中所包含的大多数东亚特异单倍型类群均能在中原地区古代人群中发现,即中原古代人群的父系遗传多样性较高。而中原地区,自商周时期起就是华夏族及其后裔汉族的聚居地,因此华北中原地区古代人群遗传结构的特点从一侧面佐证了汉族的祖先——华夏族的来源是多样的而非单一的,在其形成过程中融合了不同来源的古代人群的基因成分。
     基于以上分析结果可知,中国北方古代人群的父系遗传结构在不同地域具有不同的分布模式:东北辽西地区,在土著人群的父系遗传构成保持连续性的同时,可以看到有外来的基因成分存在于这一地区的人群中,这些外来的基因成分可能来自中原及北亚等地区。并且,在距今3000-2500年左右,外来的基因成分有增加的趋势。西北地区,不同地域范围内的各古代人群间父系遗传构成存在明显的差别。从本研究5个西北古代人群的Y染色体遗传数据来看,产生这些差别的原因可能是由于不同人群有着不同的父系来源,并且不同人群间基因交流较少,从而使得自身固有遗传结构得以保持;华北地区,位于古代中原地区的古代人群的父系遗传结构与现代汉族最为接近,表明其可能是现代汉族主要的父系基因贡献者。
Because of its location as a transportation point, Northern China was a keypoint for culture communication between Central Asia, North Asia and and East Asia.Northern China located in the east end of the northern nomads belt along the GreatWall of China, which was the obvious boundary between Central Plains and frontierfortress. The region played an important role when human beings undergo barbarismto civilization and in the development of Chinese civilization and also in the contactbetween agricultural cultivation and nomadic economy, is one original region ofChinese civilization. Along with the change of environment and climate, thealternation of archaeological cultures, economic lifestyle and composition of theresidents varied before5500-1500years ago. In this study,ancient people from13archaeological sites were analyzed in patrilineal lineage. We have attempted to findout the source and flow of the residents in Northern Chinese. It’s not only helpful tounderstand the relationship of the prehistory residents in this region, but alsoimportant for a thorough study of the complex archeological cultural exchange of theChina and the evolutionary history of the whole Eurasia.
     Firstly,44reproducible Y-DNA results obtained from78ancient West-Liao Riverpeople, and they were attributed to3haplogroups such as C, N and O. The mostfrequency haplogroup in ancient West-Liao River people is haplogroup N. Thehaologroup N, appeared early, distributed extensively, is the chief constituent of thepaternal gene pool in this region. According to archaeological culture research andrelated Y-DNA results, haplogroup O maybe belong to the immigrants whomigration from the central plain. The result of the geography distribution showedthat most of people who carried haplogroup C are Northern Asians or ancient nomads. All the data show that the ancient West-Liao River people keep their geneticcontinuity science Neolithic to Bronze Age, at the same time, we can find adventivecomponents arised in this region, indicating that neighouring populations hadassimilate into West-Liao River people.
     Secondly,46reproducible Y-DAN results were obtained from64ancientNorthwest Chinese, and they were attributed to4haplogroups such as N, O, Q and R.The different populations in Northwest China have distinct paternal genetic structure.Based on the Y-DNA data, we inferred that the most likely reason is that everypopulation had different male origin. And little genetic communicate between humangroups on the paternal side.
     Thirdly,29reproducible Y-DNA results were obtained from46ancient centralplain people, and they were attributed to3haplogroups such as N, O and Q. Theancient central plain people are most close to the Han Chinese in terms of thecompositions of haplogroups O among the ancient populations in this study,indicating the close relationship between central plain people and Han Chinese. Theresults showed that the ancient central plain people contribution to the Han Chinesewas much higher than the other ancient northern populations. Over all, the ancientcentral plain populations were close to the Han Chinese in paternal lineage,indicating a stable paternal genetic structure in Han Chinese since3,000years ago.
引文
[1]张庆玲.中国文明起源研究要览[M].北京:文物出版社2003.
    [2] Zerjal T, Xue Y, Bertorelle G, et al., The genetic legacyof the Mongols[J]. American journal of human genetics.2003;72:717-21.
    [3]罗贤佑.中国民族史纲要[M].北京:中国社会科学出版社2009.
    [4] Du R Yv. Ethnic groups in China[M]. Beijing: SciencePress1993.
    [5]何光岳.炎黄源流史[M].南昌:江西教育出版社1992.
    [6]吕思勉.中华民族源流史[M].北京:九洲出版社2009.
    [7]王玉哲.中华远古史[M].上海:上海人民出版社1995.
    [8]费孝通.中华民族多元一体格局[M].北京:中央民族大学出版社2003.
    [9]张锟.东夷文化的考古学研究[D].北京:中国社会科学院研究生院;2010.
    [10]马兴,春秋时期山西境内北狄的华夏化及其对华夏族的影响[J].贵州民族研究.2005;2:116-21.
    [11]杨东晨,周五龙,北方草原重要古文化区氏族的经济形态[J].阴山学刊.2004;17:75-84.
    [12]丘菊贤,杨东晨,西戎简论[J].西北民族学院学报.1984;4:37-40.
    [13] Ho Sy, Mito-communications[J]. Mitochondrial DNA.2009;20:101-2.
    [14] Giles Re, Blanc H, Cann Hm, et al., Maternal inheritanceof human mitochondrial DNA[J]. Proceedings of the NationalAcademy of Sciences of the United States of America.1980;77:6715-9.
    [15] Torroni A, Schurr Tg, Cabell Mf, et al., Asian affinitiesand continental radiation of the four founding Native AmericanmtDNAs[J]. American journal of human genetics.1993;53:563-90.
    [16] Richards Mb, Macaulay Va, Bandelt Hj, et al.,Phylogeography of mitochondrial DNA in western Europe[J].Annals of human genetics.1998;62:241-60.
    [17] Jobling MaTyler-Smith C, Fathers and sons: the Ychromosome and human evolution[J]. Trends Genet.1995;11:449-56.
    [18] Hughes Jf, Skaletsky H, Pyntikova T, et al., Chimpanzeeand human Y chromosomes are remarkably divergent in structureand gene content[J]. Nature.463:536-9.
    [19] Rozen S Sh, Marszalek Jd,, et al. Abundant geneconversion between arms of palindromes in human and ape Ychromosomes[J]. Nature.2003;423:873-6.
    [20] Underhill Pa, Shen P, Lin Aa, et al., Y chromosomesequence variation and the history of human populations[J].Nature genetics.2000;26:358-61.
    [21] Karafet Tm, Mendez Fl, Meilerman Mb, et al., New binarypolymorphisms reshape and increase resolution of the human Ychromosomal haplogroup tree[J]. Genome research.2008;18:830-8.
    [22] Underhill Pa, Passarino G, Lin Aa, et al., Thephylogeography of Y chromosome binary haplotypes and theorigins of modern human populations[J]. Annals of humangenetics.2001;65:43-62.
    [23] Zhong H, Shi H, Qi Xb, et al., Global distribution ofY-chromosome haplogroup C reveals the prehistoric migrationroutes of African exodus and early settlement in East Asia[J].Journal of human genetics.55:428-35.
    [24] Nonaka I Mk, Takezaki N Y-chromosomal binary haplogroupsin the Japanese population and their relationship to16Y-STRpolymorphisms[J]. Ann Hum Genet.2007;71::480–95.
    [25] Tatiana M. Karafet Lpo, Marina A., High Levels ofY-Chromosome Differentiation among Native SiberianPopulations and the Genetic Signature of a BorealHunter-Gatherer Way of Life[J]. Human Biology.2002;74:761–89.
    [26] Shi H, Zhong H, Peng Y, et al., Y chromosome evidenceof earliest modern human settlement in East Asia and multipleorigins of Tibetan and Japanese populations[J]. BMC biology.2008;6:45.
    [27] Reddy Bm Lb, Kumar V, Nagaraja T, Austro-Asiatic Tribesof Northeast India Provide Hitherto Missing Genetic Linkbetween South and Southeast Asia[J]. PloS one.2007;2.
    [28] Wen B, Xie X, Gao S, et al., Analyses of genetic structureof Tibeto-Burman populations reveals sex-biased admixture insouthern Tibeto-Burmans[J]. American journal of humangenetics.2004;74:856-65.
    [29] Wood Et, Stover Da, Ehret C, et al., Contrasting patternsof Y chromosome and mtDNA variation in Africa: evidence forsex-biased demographic processes[J]. Eur J Hum Genet.2005;13:867-76.
    [30] Semino O, Magri C, Benuzzi G, et al., Origin, diffusion,and differentiation of Y-chromosome haplogroups E and J:inferences on the neolithization of Europe and later migratoryevents in the Mediterranean area[J]. American journal of humangenetics.2004;74:1023-34.
    [31] Berniell-Lee G, Calafell F, Bosch E, et al., Genetic anddemographic implications of the Bantu expansion: insights fromhuman paternal lineages[J]. Molecular biology and evolution.2009;26:1581-9.
    [32] Wells Rs, Yuldasheva N, Ruzibakiev R, et al., TheEurasian heartland: a continental perspective on Y-chromosomediversity[J]. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciencesof the United States of America.2001;98:10244-9.
    [33] Black Ml, Wise Ca, Wang W, et al., Combining geneticsand population history in the study of ethnic diversity in thePeople's Republic of China[J]. Human biology.2006;78:277-93.
    [34] Firasat S, Khaliq S, Mohyuddin A, et al., Y-chromosomalevidence for a limited Greek contribution to the Pathanpopulation of Pakistan[J]. Eur J Hum Genet.2007;15:121-6.
    [35] Nasidze I, Sarkisian T, Kerimov A, et al., Testinghypotheses of language replacement in the Caucasus: evidencefrom the Y-chromosome[J]. Human genetics.2003;112:255-61.
    [36] Karafet Tm, Lansing Js, Redd Aj, et al., BalineseY-chromosome perspective on the peopling of Indonesia: geneticcontributions from pre-neolithic hunter-gatherers,Austronesian farmers, and Indian traders[J]. Human biology.2005;77:93-114.
    [37] Gayden T Ca, Regueiro M, The Himalayas as a directionalbarrier to gene flow[J]. Am J Hum Genet.2007;80:884–94.
    [38] Perici M Ll, Klari Im, Et Al, High-resolutionphylogenetic analysis of southeastern Europe traces majorepisodes of paternal gene flow among Slavic populations[J].Mol Biol Evol.2005;221964-75.
    [39] Clark Pu Da, Shakun Jd, Et Al., The Last GlacialMaximum[J]. Science.2009;325:710-4.
    [40] Di Giacomo F Lf, Popa Lo, Et Al., Y chromosomalhaplogroup J as a signature of the post-neolithic colonizationof Europe[J]. Hum Genet.115357–71.
    [41] Hammer Mf, Behar Dm, Karafet Tm, et al., Extended Ychromosome haplotypes resolve multiple and unique lineages ofthe Jewish priesthood[J]. Human genetics.2009;126:707-17.
    [42] Di Giacomo F, Luca F, Anagnou N, et al., Clinal patternsof human Y chromosomal diversity in continental Italy andGreece are dominated by drift and founder effects[J].Molecular phylogenetics and evolution.2003;28:387-95.
    [43] Kayser M, Choi Y, Van Oven M, et al., The impact of theAustronesian expansion: evidence from mtDNA and Y chromosomediversity in the Admiralty Islands of Melanesia[J]. Molecularbiology and evolution.2008;25:1362-74.
    [44] Scheinfeldt L, Friedlaender F, Friedlaender J, et al.,Unexpected NRY chromosome variation in Northern IslandMelanesia[J]. Molecular biology and evolution.2006;23:1628-41.
    [45] Scozzari R, Cruciani F, Pangrazio A, et al., HumanY-chromosome variation in the western Mediterranean area:implications for the peopling of the region[J]. Humanimmunology.2001;62:871-84.
    [46] Lappalainen T, Laitinen V, Salmela E, et al., Migrationwaves to the Baltic Sea region[J]. Annals of human genetics.2008;72:337-48.
    [47] Rootsi S, Zhivotovsky La, Baldovic M, et al., Acounter-clockwise northern route of the Y-chromosomehaplogroup N from Southeast Asia towards Europe[J]. Eur J HumGenet.2007;15:204-11.
    [48] Derenko M, Malyarchuk B, Denisova G, et al.,Y-chromosome haplogroup N dispersals from south Siberia toEurope[J]. Journal of human genetics.2007;52:763-70.
    [49] Katoh T, Munkhbat B, Tounai K, et al., Genetic featuresof Mongolian ethnic groups revealed by Y-chromosomalanalysis[J]. Gene.2005;346:63-70.
    [50] Wen B, Li H, Lu D, et al., Genetic evidence supports demicdiffusion of Han culture[J]. Nature.2004;431:302-5.
    [51] Xue Y, Male Demography in East Asia: A North–SouthContrast in Human Population Expansion Times[J]. Genetics2006;172:2431-39.
    [52] Su B, Jin L, Underhill P, et al., Polynesian origins:insights from the Y chromosome[J]. Proceedings of the NationalAcademy of Sciences of the United States of America.2000;97:8225-8.
    [53] Su B, Xiao C, Deka R, et al., Y chromosome haplotypesreveal prehistorical migrations to the Himalayas[J]. Humangenetics.2000;107:582-90.
    [54] Rasmussen M, Li Y, Lindgreen S, et al., Ancient humangenome sequence of an extinct Palaeo-Eskimo[J]. Nature.463:757-62.
    [55] Malyarchuk Bd, Miroslava; Denisova, Galina; Maksimov,Arkady; Wozniak, Marcin; Grzybowski, Tomasz; Dambueva, Irina;,Ancient links between Siberians and Native Americans revealedby subtyping the Y chromosome haplogroup Q1a[J]. Journal ofhuman genetics.2011;56:583-8.
    [56] Cinnioglu C, King R, Kivisild T, et al., ExcavatingY-chromosome haplotype strata in Anatolia[J]. Human genetics.2004;114:127-48.
    [57] Rasmussen M Ly, Lindgreen S, Et Al., Ancient humangenome sequence of an extinct Palaeo-Eskimo[J]. Nature.2010;463:757-62.
    [58] Haak W Fp, Bramanti B, Ancient DNA from the firstEuropean farmers in7500-year-old Neolithic sites [J]. Science.2005;310:1016-18.
    [59] Sampietro Ml Lo, Caramelli D, Et Al, Palaeogeneticevidence supports a dual model of Neolithic spreading intoEurope[J]. Proc Biol Sci.2007;1622:2161-67.
    [60] Tomory G, Csanyi B, Bogacsi-Szabo E, et al., Comparisonof maternal lineage and biogeographic analyses of ancient andmodern Hungarian populations[J]. American journal of physicalanthropology.2007;134:354-68.
    [61] Gamba C Fe, Oliver a, Et Al, Population genetics and DNApreservation in ancient human remains from Eastern Spain[J].Forensic science international.2008;Genetics SupplementSeries:1462-64.
    [62] Malhi Rs Kb, Eshleman Ja, Et Al., Mitochondrialhaplogroup Mdiscovered in prehistoric North Americans [J].Journal of Archaeological Science.2007;34:642-48.
    [63] Lertrit P Ps, Thosarat R, Genetic history of SoutheastAsian populations as revealed by ancient and modern humanmitochondrial DNA analysis[J]. Am J Phys Anthropol.2008;137:425-40.
    [64] Keyser C Rm, Bouakaze C, Tracing back ancient southSiberian population history using mitochondrial andY-chromosome SNPs [J]. Forensic Science International,,.2008;Genetics Supplement Series:343-45.
    [65] Ricaut Fx Bm, Lahr Mm., Ancient Mitochondrial DNA FromMalaysian Hair Samples:Some Indications of Southeast AsianPopulation Movements[J]. Am J Hum Biol.2006;18:654-67.
    [66] Lee Hy Yj, Park Mj, Et Al, Genetic characterization andassessment of authenticity of ancient Korean skeletalremains[J]. Hum Biol.2008;80239-50.
    [67] Keyser C Bc, Crubézy E,, Ancient DNA provides newinsights into the history of south Siberian Kurgan people.[J].Human genetics.2009;126:395-410.
    [68] Adachi N Sk, Umetsu K, Kitano T, Matsumura H,Mitochondrial DNA analysis of Hokkaido Jomon skeletons:remnants of archaic maternal lineages at the southwestern edgeof former Beringia.[J]. Am J Phys Anthropol.2011;146:346-60.
    [69] Xu Z, Zhang F, Xu B, et al., Mitochondrial DNA evidencefor a diversified origin of workers building First Emperor ofChina[J]. PloS one.2008;3:e3275.
    [70] Li H, Huang Y, Mustavich Lf, et al., Y chromosomes ofprehistoric people along the Yangtze River[J]. Human genetics.2007;122:383-8.
    [71]蔡大伟,4种古DNA抽提方法效果比较[J].吉林大学学报(医学版).2007;33:13-16.
    [72] Paabo S Ph, Serre D, Et Al, Genetic analyses from ancientDNA[J]. Annu Rev Genet.2004;38:645-79.
    [73] Cooper a Ph, Ancient DNA: do it right or not at all[J].Science2000;289:1139.
    [74] Hofreiter M Sd, Poinar Hn, Et Al., Ancient DNA[J]. NatRev Genet.2001;2:353-9.
    [75] Gilbert Mt Bh, Hofreiter M, Assessing ancient DNAstudies[J]. Trends Ecol Evol.2005;20:541-44.
    [76]张博泉,对辽西发现五千年前文明曙光的历史蠡测[J].辽海文物学刊.1987;96-102.
    [77]苏秉琦.中国文明起源新探[M].三联书店1999.
    [78]中国社会科学院考古研究所,内蒙古自治区文物考古研究所,吉林大学边疆考古研究中心.,内蒙古喀喇沁旗大山前遗址1998年的发掘[J].考古.2004;3:31-39.
    [79]张忠培.,辽宁古遗存的分区、编年及其他--“环渤海考古”学术讨论会上的发言[J].辽海文物学刊.1991;1:8-12.
    [80]张小咏.5000aB.P.以来辽西地区环境演变与人地关系研究
    [D].大连:辽宁师范大学;2003.
    [81]辽宁省文物考古研究所,辽宁牛河梁红山文化“女神庙”与积石冢群发掘简报[J].文物.1986;8:1-17.
    [82]辽宁省文物考古研究所,牛河梁红山文化第二地点一号冢石棺墓的发掘[J].文物.2008.
    [83]张亚强.哈啦海沟墓地发掘及探索[D].长春:吉林大学;2008.
    [84]中国科学院考古研究所辽宁工作队.,敖汉旗大甸子遗址1974年试掘简报[J].考古.1975;2:99-101.
    [85]中国社会科学院考古研究所,.大甸子--夏家店下层文化遗址与墓地发掘报告[M].北京:科学出版社1996.
    [86]中国社会科学院考古研究所,内蒙古自治区文物考古研究所,吉林大学考古系.,内蒙古喀喇沁旗大山前遗址1996年发掘简报[J].考古.1998;9:43-49.
    [87]武志江.井沟子西区墓地及相关问题研究[D].吉林:吉林大学边疆考古研究中心;2005.
    [88]吉林大学边疆考古研究中心,内蒙古文物考古研究所J,.,井沟子遗址西区墓葬发掘纪要[J].考古与文物.2004;1:6-19.
    [89]葛斌文.井沟子古代人群的遗传分析[D].长春:吉林大学;2007.
    [90]赵欣.辽西地区先秦时期居民的体质人类学与分子考古学研究[D].长春:吉林大学;2009.
    [91]李经汉.试论夏家店下层文化的分期和类型[C].中国考古学会第一次年会论文集;1979北京:文物出版社;1979.
    [92]王立新,齐晓光,夏保国.,夏家店下层文化渊源刍论[J].北方文物.1993;5-16.
    [93]乌恩岳斯图.北方草原考古学文化研究--青铜时代至早期铁器时代[M].北京:科学出版社2007.
    [94]王立新.,辽西区夏至战国时期文化格局与经济形态的演进[J].考古学报.2004;3:243-70
    [95]新疆文物考古研究所.新疆考古三十年[M].乌鲁木齐:新疆人民出版社1985.
    [96]韩康信.丝绸之路古代居民种族人类学研究
    [M].新疆人民出版社1993.
    [97]赵汝清.从亚洲腹地到欧洲:四路西段历史研究[M].兰州:甘肃人民出版社2006.
    [98]崔永红,张得祖,杜常顺.青海通史[M].西宁:青海人民出版社1999.
    [99]李春香.小河墓地古代生物遗骸的分子遗传学研究[D].长春:吉林大学;2010.
    [100]高诗珠.中国西北地区三个古代人群的线粒体DNA研究[D].长春:吉林大学;2005.
    [101]王建新,东天山地区早期游牧文化聚落考古研究[J].考古与文物.20091:28-39.
    [102]彭阳王大户墓地浮现的千古之谜[M].华兴时报2007.
    [103]宁夏彭阳县春秋战国墓地浮现历史悬疑[J].2007;[EB/OL].(2007-09-13)http://news.163.com/07/0913/12/3O95HHVT0001124J.html
    [104]许淑珍,西宁陶家寨汉墓清理简报[J].青海考古学会会刊.1984;34.
    [105]张敬雷.青海省西宁市陶家寨汉晋时期墓地人骨研究[D].长春:吉林大学;2008.
    [106] Li Chunxiang Lh, Cui Yinqiu, Evidence that a West-Eastadmixed population lived in the Tarim Basin as early as theearly Bronze Age.[J]. BMC Biol.2010;17:8-15.
    [107] Keyser C Bc, Crubezy E, Et Al., Ancient DNA provides newinsights into the history of south Siberian Kurgan people[J].Human genetics.2009;126:395-410.
    [108] Mair V, The rediscovery and complete excavation of?rdek’s Necropolis[J]. Journal of Indo-European Studies.2006;34:4,273-4,318.
    [109] Regueiro M, Cadenas Am, Gayden T, et al., Iran:tricontinental nexus for Y-chromosome driven migration[J].Human heredity.2006;61:132-43.
    [110]韩康信.丝绸之路古代居民种族人类学研究[M].新疆人民出版社1993.
    [111]李文瑛刘.中国早期青铜文化的起源及其相关问题新探[C].中国边疆考古学术讨论会;2005成都;2005.
    [112]赵永斌.中国汉族北方母系起源的遗传学初探[D].长春:吉林大学;2011.
    [113] Yong LdBo W, Y-Chromosome Evidence of Southern Originof the East Asian–Specific Haplogroup O3-M122[J]. AmericanJournal of Human Genetics2005;77408-19.
    [114]吴枕等.华北地貌及其开发利用[M].石家庄:河北科学技术出版社2010.
    [115]吴忱.华北地貌环境及其形成演化[M].北京:科学出版社2008.
    [116]中国科学院《中国自然地理》编辑委员会,.中国自然地理总论[M].北京:科学出版社1985.
    [117]杨虎.内蒙古中南部新石器时代考古学文化的几个问题[C].内蒙古中南部原始文化研究暨园子沟遗址保护科学论证会;1989;1989. p.25-28.
    [118]张景明,内蒙古中南部地区新石器时代原始经济类型[J].内蒙古文物考古.2005;2:60-65.
    [119]李伯谦.论夏家店下层文化[M].北京:科学出版社1998.
    [120]魏坚,察右前旗庙子沟新石器时代墓地[J].考古文物新发现.1985;101.
    [121]嫦娥.内蒙古长城地带先秦时期人类遗骸的DNA研究[D].长春:吉林大学;2008.
    [122]魏坚,庙子沟与大坝沟有关问题试析[J].113-18.
    [123]张家口考古队,蔚县考古记略[J].考古与文物.1982;4:10-14.
    [124]张家口考古队,蔚县夏商时期考古的主要收获[J].考古与文物.1984;1:40-48.
    [125]山西省考古研究所运,绛县文物局,山西绛县横水西周墓发掘简报[J].文物.2006;8:4-18.
    [126]王明珂.游牧者的抉择[M].广西师范大学出版社出版.
    [127]杜正胜.周秦民族文化“戎狄性”的考察-兼论关中出土的“北方式”青铜器[M].西安:陕西人民出版社,1998.
    [128] Zhong H Hs, Qixb, Zy Duan, Extended Y chromosomeinvestigation suggests postglacial migrations of modernhumans into East Asia via the northern route[J]. Molecularbiology and evolution.2011;28:717-27..
    [129] Boris; M, Miroslava; D, Galina; D, et al., Ancient linksbetween Siberians and Native Americans revealed by subtypingthe Y chromosome haplogroup Q1a[J]. Journal of human genetics.2011;56583-8.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700