城市流域雨水多设施与建成环境一体化系统设计与应用
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
通过城市流域尺度的综合调控、管理实现地表水文生态健康是当前雨水管理研究的发展方向。目前,在流域尺度下对雨水设施的研究多以控制水量为目的,模拟某单一设施的优化数量与规模;水质研究受制于流域尺度的空间复杂性,尚处于管理方法的探索阶段,鲜有对流域综合水质管理效果的研究结果,多设施的空间布局及其与城市建成环境的空间一体化设计研究则更为罕见。为此,本文构建了城市流域雨水多设施与建成环境一体化系统设计(Integrated Stormwater Management,iSWM系统)方法,其主要模块包括:1)雨水多设施优化布局与城市空间规划模块;2)雨水多设施形态与建成环境一体化设计模块(渐进式设计模块); 3)适用于从集水单元至中小流域的雨水水质管理模块。该系统设计被应用于海河次流域内36.77km2的城市流域中,得出了适宜于该流域的多设施系统与优化环境的一体化雨水管理方案。该优化方案以控制流域面源污染为首要目标,使末端集中式雨水设施所处理的流域污染物总负荷最大化;源头分散式雨水设施的占地面积最小化;并合理布局、运用源头分散式设施承担了雨水的空间运移。此外,本文以MUSIC4.0作为水质评价手段,以具体设计单元为案例,对渐进式设计模块进行了详细阐释和应用。设计结果反映了流域建成空间对雨水设施的空间约束。并给出在典型污染物水质处理目标下,在分散式雨水设施汇水区内,若ICR值为80~85%之间,则设施总面积占汇水区面积的约5%~6%;若ICR值为70~80%之间,则设施总面积占汇水区面积的约4%~5%;而对于集中式处理设施间接汇水区,在ICR值为80%的情况下,分散式和集中式设施的总面积至少占汇水区面积的6.5%。由此,最终形成了用于指导不同用地性质的地块建设改造的雨水多设施与环境一体化设计引导。
The watershed-based approach for improving the surface water hydrological condition is the trend of the current stormwater management research. Up to now, compared to the enormous researches focusing on the methods using the optimal quantity and scale of mono-facility to simulate target peak flow, very few concern about the treatment objective in view of the spatial restriction on the urban watershed. Other than the exploration of the regulation frame, there is no further research upon the efficiency of the management program from a watershed scale perspective. None of the design principles for the appropriate facilities have been integrated with the environment layout. This paper describes a watershed model of the optimal integration of the facilities and environment, which contains:1) the general-planning model for the sub-watershed; 2)the definite-design model for the catchmen(titerative-design model); 3)the water quality management model suitable for any scale. The design strategy has been applied to 36.77km2 urban watershed system of Haihe River to optimize facility planning, the objective of which are maximizing the processing capability of concentration facilities and minimizing the land usage of the distributed facilities while utilizing the stormwater transmission feature of the scattered allocation ones. Moreover, taking a specific layout-unit-design as an example, this paper introduces the iterative-design module whose water-quality is valued by MUSIC4.0. The design result not only reflects the constraints on the stormwater facilities, which are enforced by the space of the constructed watershed, but also reveals the ratio of the occupation area to the contributing drainage area of the facilities under the goal of optimizing water quality along the watershed. Eventually, this paper proposes an integrated design guideline capable of directing construction and alteration of environment and stormwater facilities under different land usage type.
引文
[1]Zoltay, V.I,VogelR.M,Kirshen,P.H et al. Integrated Watershed Management Modeling: GenericOptimization Model Applied to the Ipswich River Basin[J].Journal of water resource planning and management,2010,136(5):566-575
    [2]http://iswm.nctcog.org,available at 2010/12/03 16:00
    [3] Platt.R.H. Urban watershed management sustainability, one stream at a time [J] Environment. 2006.48(4):26-42.
    [4]James,L.S. Sustainable solution for water resources: Policies, planning design and implementation [M]Canada: John Wiley&Sons, Inc 2010: 117-118.
    [5] Carle.M.V, Hm2lpin,P.N&Stow,C.A. Patterns of watershed urbanization and impacts water quality [J] Journal of the American Water Resources Association,2005,41,(3):693-708
    [6] Moore,A.A Palmer,M.A. Invertebrate biodiversity in agriculture and urban headwater streams:implications for conservation and management [J] Ecological Application,2005,15,(4):1169-1177
    [7] Schueler,T.R, Fraley-Mcneal, L&Cappiella,K. Is impervious over still important?review of recent research [J] Journal of Hydrologic Engineering,2009,14,(4):309-315
    [8] Leopold, L.B. Hydrology for urban land planning- A guidebook on the hydrologic effects of urban land use [R].Washington,D.C: U.S.Government Printing Office, 1968: 3.
    [9] Arnold CL, Gibbons CJ (1996) Impervious surface coverage—the emergence of a key environmental indicator.
    [10] Paul MJ, Meyer JL (2001) Streams in the urban landscape. [J] Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics, 32:333–365
    [11] Landscapes and river scapes: the influence of land use on stream ecosystems
    [12] US.EPA LID development design strategies: an integrated design approach
    [13] Pratt,C A review of published material on the performance of various SUDS components [R]Coventry: SDUS. Science Group, 2003.
    [14] Wong.T.h.F An overview of water sensitive urban design practices in Australia [J] Water Practice &Technology. 2006.(1)
    [15] McCuen, R.H. A regional approach to urban stormwater detention [J] eophysical Research Letters,1974,1,(7):321-322
    [16] Coff, K.M and Gentry,R.W The influence of watershed and development characteristics on the cumulative impacts of stormwater detention ponds [J] Water Resources Management,2006,(20):829-860
    [17] Sloat,M.S and Hwang,R.B Sensitivity study on detention basins in urbanized watershed [J] Journal of Urban Planning and Developmentt,1989,115(3):135-155
    [18] Are best-management-practice criteria really environmentally friendly?
    [19] Emerson,C.H, ASCE,M, Welty,C. Watershed-Scale Evaluation of a system of storm water detention basins [J] Journal of Hydrologic Engineeringt,2005,10(3):237-242
    [20] Willian.G Watershed management: slogan or solution? [J] Jthe 29th Annual Conference of the American Water Resources Association in Tucson,1993,8(30)
    [21]http://www.gdrc.org/uem/water/watershed/introduction.html
    [22] USEPA1997 State source water assessment and protection programs guidance
    [23] Roy,A.H, Wenger,S.J, Fletcher,T.D Impediments and solution to sustainable,watershed-scale urban storm water management:lessons from Australia and the United States[J] Environment Management,2008, (42):344-359
    [24] Zheng,J.H, Nanbakhsh,H, Scholz,M Case study: design and operation of sustainable urban infiltration ponds treating storm runoff[J] Journal of Urban Planning and Development,2006.132(1):36-41
    [25] Davis,A.P, Shokouhian,M. laboratory study of biological retention for urban stormwater management [J] Water Environment Research 2001,73(5):5-14
    [26] Wu,J, Yu,S.L, Zou,R A water quality-based approach for watershed wide BMP strategy[J] Journal of the American Water Resources Association,2006,42(5):1193-1204
    [27] The natural flow regime :a paradigm for river conservation and restoration
    [28]Zhen,J. Development of a best management practice placement strategy at the watershed scales[C] Watershed Managements,2004:175-186.
    [29] Cohen,M.J Brown,M.T. A model examining hierarchical wetland networks for watershed stormwater management,[J] Ecological Modeling 2007.
    [30] Sahu,M, Gu,R.R Modeling the effects of riparian buffer zone and contour strips on stream water quality,[J] Ecological Engineering 2009.35:1167-1177
    [31] Newbold,S.C A combined hydrologic simulation and landscape design model to prioritize sites for wetlands restoration,[J] Environment Modeling 2005.10:251-263
    [32] Behera,P.K. Optimization of regional storm water management systems, [J] Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management 1999,(2):107-114
    [33] Young,K.D, Kibler,D.F. Application of the analytical hierarchical process for improved selection of stormwater BMPs,[J] Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management 2009.135(4):264-275
    [34] Zhang,G.S Multi objective optimization of Low Impact Development scenarios in anurbanizing watershed,[C] Proceedings of the 2006 award Annual Conference. 2006.
    [35]Zhen,X.Y, Yu,L.S, Lin,J.Y Optional location and sizing of stormwater basins atwatershed scale,[J] Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management 2004,130(4):339-347
    [36] Kaini,P. Artita,K. and Nicklow,J.W. Designing BMPs at watershed-scale using SWAT and a genetic algorithm, [C]World Environmental and Water Resources Congress2008, Ahupua’a 2008:1-10.
    [37]Kaini,P. Artita,K. and Nicklow,J.W. Generating alternative watershed-scale BMP designs with evolutionary algorithm, [C]World Environmental and Water Resources Congress2008, Ahupua’a 2008:1-9.
    [38]Kaini,P. Artita,K. and Nicklow,J.W. Generating different scenarios of BMP design in a watershed scale by combining NSGA-II with SWAT, [C]World Environmental and Water Resources Congress2009:Great Rivers 2009:4885-4893.
    [40]Shoemaker,L. SUSTAIN-a Framework for placement of best management practices in urban watersheds to Protect water quality,[R] United state:Environmental Protection Agency 2009
    [41] Susilo,K.J.Los Angeles county-wide Structural BMP prioritization ethodology[R] Los Angeles:Bureau of Sanitation 2006
    [41] Eichenwald,Z. McGarity,A.E Watershed-based optimal stormwater management: Part1-applicaiotn of StormISWME to little Crum Creek in suburban Philadelphia[C] World Environmental and Water Resources Congress2010:Challenges of Change:2502-2512.
    [42] Watershed-based optimal stormwater management: Part2-Hydrologic modeling of LID/BMP site on little Crum Creek in suburban Philadelphias[C] World Environmental and Water Resources Congress2010:Challenges of Change:2522-2530.
    [43] Hipp,J.A. Ogunseitan,O. Lejano,R. Optimization of stormwater filtration at urban/watershed interface,[J] Environment Science& Technology 2006,40(15):4794-4801
    [44] US.EPA Low impact development a literature review
    [45] Booth,D.B. Hartley,D.H. Jackson,R Forest cover, impervious-surface area,and the mitigation of stormwater impacts,[J] Journal of the American Water Resources Association 2002.38(3):835-845
    [46] Walsh,C.J, Fletcher,T.D and Ladson,A.R. Stream restoration in urban catchments through redesigning stormwater systems:looking to the catchment to save the stream[J] The North American Benthological Society 2005.24(3):690-705
    [47]Dietz,M.E. Clausen,J.C Stormwater runoff and export changes with development in a traditional and low impact subdivision,[J] Journal of Water Resources Association 2008.87(4):560-566
    [48] Brander,K.E, Owen,K.E and Potter,K,W. Medeled impacts of development type on runoff volume and infiltratrion performance,[J] Journal of EnvironmentManagement 2004.40(4):961-969
    [49] Hood,M.J, Clausen,J.C and Warner,G.S. Comparison of stormwater lad times for low impact and traditional residential development,[J] Journal of Water Resources Association, 2007.43(4):1036-1046
    [50] Holman-Dodds,J.K. Bradley,A.A. Potter,K.W. Evaluation of hydrologic benefits of infiltration based urban stormwater management, [J] Journal of the American Water Resources Association, 2003.39(1):205-215
    [51] Gabriele,F, Giorgio,M and Gaspare, V.P.E. Urban stormwater quality management centralized versus control, [J] Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management, 2010,136(2):268-278
    [52] Damodaram,C, Marcia,H.G.C and Khedum,P. Simulation of combination best management practices and low impact development for sustainable stormwater management, [J] Journal of the American Water Resources Association, 2010,.46(5):907-918
    [53] Williams,E.S. ISWMe,W.R. Hydrologic impact of alternative approaches to stormwater management and land development, [J] Journal of the American Water Resources Association, 2006,42(2):443-455
    [54] Lloyd,S.D Wong,T.H.F and Porter,B. The planning and construction of an urban stormwater management scheme [J] Water Science and Technology 2002.45(7):1-10
    [55] Heal,K.V. Bray,R. and Willingale,S.A.J. Medium-term performance and maintenance of SUDS:a case-study of Hopwood Park Motorway Service Area,UK. [J] Water Science and Technology, 2009.59(12):2485-2494
    [56] Lynbrook Estate:a demonstration project in water sensitive urban design
    [57] Lloyd,S.D Wong,T.H.F and Chesterfield,C.J. Water sensitive urban design– a stormwater management
    [58] Grace,B Martens,S and Taylor,M The Wungong urban water project:toward sustainable water management in the urban environment 1st National HYDROPOLIS Conference 2006 Burswood Convention Centre Perth, Western Australia
    [59] Case study- Wungong urban development masterplan[Z]
    [60] Dreiseitl, H, and Grau, D Dieter. New waterscapes: planning, building and designing with water
    [61] Atelier Dreiseitl .Sustainable stormwater management at Fornebu—from an airport to an industrial and residentialarea of the city of Oslo, Norway, [J] Science of the Total Environment, 2004.334(335):239-249
    [62]史贵涛,陈振楼,李海雯.上海城市水环境非点源污染及其控制对策[J]人民长江, 2007,38(1):84-85
    [63]庞靖鹏非点源污染分布式模拟——以密云水库水源地保护为例[D],北京,北京师范大学,2007
    [64]陈骥基于gis的桥墩流域非点源污染BMPs评估[D],北京,清华大学,2009
    [65]龚清宇,王林超,唐运平.中小流域尺度内雨水湿地规模模拟与设计引导[J].建筑学报, 2009, (2):48-51
    [66]闫伟伟,最佳管理措施在办公楼集水区面源污染治理中的应用[D],南昌,南昌大学,2007
    [67]李剑,保护茜坑水库水质的最佳管理措施研究[D],南昌,南昌大学,2006
    [68]周勇华,城市居住小区雨水径流污染的模拟与控制[D],长沙,湖南大学,2007
    [69] Lai,F.H, Dai,T, Zhen,J, Riverson,J. SUSTAIN– an EPA BMP process and placement tool for urban watersheds [C] Proceedings of the Water Environment Federation 2007: 946-968
    [70]唐从国,刘丛强.基于Arch Hydro Tools的流域特征自动提取——以贵州省内乌江流域为例[J]地球与环境, 2006,34(3):30-37
    [71] Maimone,M Marengo,B and Byun,S.A. Tookany/Tacony-Frankford watershed plan: Restoring an urban [C] Managing Watersheds for Human and Natural Impacts: Engineering, Ecological, and Economic Challenges 2005
    [72]张娜,赵乐军,李铁龙.天津城区道路雨水径流水质监测及污染特征分析[J]生态环境学报, 2009,18(6):2127-2130
    [73]Elliott,A.H, Trowsdale,S.A A review of models for low impact urban stormwater drainage[J] Environment Modeling & Software, 2007,22:394-405.
    [74]周婷,李传哲,徐卫红大型城市流域暴雨径流水量水质预测模型研究[J]水力水电快报,2009,30(8):5-11.
    [75]Kadlec,R.H,Wallace,S.D. Treatment wetlands,2nd edition [M]. Boca Raton:CRC press,Florida,2009
    [76]Kadlec,R.H,Knight,R.L Treatment wetlands [M]. Boca Raton:CRC Press, Florida.1996
    [77]Wong T.H.F, Geiger W.F. Adaptation of wastewater surfaceflow wetland formulae for application in constructed stormwaterwetlands[J]. Ecological Engineering,1997, 9(3-4): 187–202
    [78]Wong T.H.F, Fletcher T.D, Duncan H.P et al.Modelling urban stormwater treatment - a unified approach[J].Ecological Engineering,2006, 27(1): 58–70
    [79] Wong,T.H.F Geiger,W.F. Adaptation of wastewater surface flow wetland formulae for application in constructed stormwater wetlands, [J] Ecological Engineering, 1997. (9):187-202
    [80] Mannul
    [81]钟学丽.基于大比例尺覆被统计统计抽样的流域水收支与干旱指数模拟[d].天津,天津大学,2010?
    [82]王林超.结合空间规划的人工湿地在城市河流生态改善中的应用[D],天津,天津大学,2007
    [83]邢可霞,郭怀成,孙延枫等基于HSPF模型的滇池流域非点源污染模拟[J]中国环境科学,2004,24(2):229-232.
    [84]梅立永,赵智杰,黄钱等小流域非点源污染模拟与仿真研究——以HSPF模型在西丽水库流域应用为例[J]农业环境科学学报,2007,26(1):64-70.
    [85]薛亦峰,王晓燕HSPF模型及其在非点源污染研究中的应用[J]首都师范大学学报,2009,30(3):61-65.
    [86]孙全民,胡湛波,李志华等.基于SWMM截留式合流制管网溢流水质水量模拟[J]给水排水,2010,36(7):175-179.
    [87]林镇洋,康世芳,陈彦璋等应用MUSIC模拟BMP之除污效率[J]中华水土保持学报,2007,38(2):105-122.
    [88]林莉峰,李田,李贺上海市城区非透水性地面径流的污染特征研究[J]环境科学,2007,28(7):1430-1434.
    [89]宫莹,阮晓红,胡晓东我国城市地表水环境非点源污染的研究进展[J]中国给水排水,2003,19(3):21-23.
    [90]黄金良,杜鹏飞,欧志丹澳门城市路面地表径流特征分析[J]中国环境科学,2006,26(4):469-473.
    [91]董欣,杜鹏飞,李志一城市降雨屋面、路面径流水文水质特征研究[J]环境科学,2008,29(3):607-612.
    [92]张娜,赵乐军,李铁龙天津城区道路雨水径流水质监测及污染特征分析[J]生态环境学报,2009,18(6):2127-2131.
    [93]张新波,城市雨水资源利用的研究[D],天津,天津大学,2007,36-42
    [94] Collins,K.A, Hirschman,D and Hoffmann,G The runoff reduction method [C] World Environmental and water resources congress 2009:1610-1621.
    [95] Berndtsson,J.C Green roof performance towards management of runoff water quantity and quality:a review [J] Ecological Engineering 2010. (36):351-360
    [96]http://www.training.ewater.com.au/file.php/1/HTML/appendix_g_selecting_appropria.htm,available at 2010/12/05 15:30
    [97]付春平,唐运平,邢国政等.湿地生态修复工程对高盐再生水氮磷去除研究[J].灌溉排水学报.2006,25(4):93-96
    [98]张洪芬,唐运平,张志扬等.再生水景观河道生态修复水体净化效果研究[J].中国环保产业.2006(7):38-40
    [99]李俊奇,向璐璐,毛坤等.雨水花园蓄渗处置屋面径流案例分析[J].中国给水排水,2010,26(10):129-133
    [100]章茹,周文斌,金可礼.深圳茜坑水库生态草沟对非点源污染去除效率的评价[J].南昌大学学报(理科版),2009,33(1):56-60
    [101]http://rpitt.eng.ua.edu/Publications/StormwaterTreatability/Sediment%20transport%20in%20swales%20Nara%20and%20Pitt%20swales%20James%202005.pdf. Available at 2010/12/02 14:30

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700