我国专业教练员胜任特征的模型建构及测评研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
本研究旨在建构我国专业教练员胜任特征模型,编制教练员胜任特征评价量表,了解当前我国专业教练员胜任特征现状。研究基于文献分析,采用行为事件访谈、心理测量学等方法,质性研究与量化研究相结合,对教练员胜任特征模型及测评问题进行了一系列的实证研究,得到的主要结论如下:
     (一)教练员胜任特征模型从理论上概括了教练员的胜任特征,并得到验证。建构的教练员胜任特征模型包括九项特征:知识的获取,创新,团队合作,(与运动员)沟通,权威,关注细节,洞察力,解决问题,分析思考。用自评式测验对这一模型的验证结果表明,该模型恰当地概括了教练员的胜任特征。
     (二)【教练员胜任特征评价量表】在使用上具有良好的信度和效度。该测验包括9个分量表,分别是知识的获取,创新,团队合作,沟通,权威,关注细节,洞察力,解决问题,分析思考,每个分量表包括4个题目。对量表的测量学属性检验结果表明,各分量表的克隆巴赫α系数在.632—.883之间,总体α系数为.924;结构公式模型检验也达到可以接受标准。
     (三)不同级别、不同执教年限以及不同项目教练员的胜任特征存在水平差异和不同特点。目前我国专业教练员胜任特征整体水平较高,在九个分量表的平均分高于5分。不同级别教练员的胜任特征在知识获取、创新、沟通、权威、洞察力、解决问题、分析思考等维度上的差异达到显著水平;不同执教年限的教练员在创新、权威、洞察力、解决问题以及总得分上的差异达到显著水平;体能主导类和技能主导类教练员在创新和关注细节上的差异达到显著水平,且技能主导类教练员的得分高于体能主导类。个人项目和集体项目教练员仅在团队合作这一维度上的差异达到显著水平,并且集体项目教练员的得分高于个人项目教练员。
     (四)教练员的胜任特征与运动员对教练员执教行为满意度之间存在密切关系。在排除人口统计学变量的影响下,教练员胜任特征显著影响运动员对训练与指导、民主行为、个人关怀、策略选择和临场指挥的满意度,但不同部分的影响作用又有不同。在教练员的训练与指导方面,创新、关注细节、分析思考对运动员满意度有显著影响;在民主行为方面,沟通和权威对运动员满意度有显著影响;在个人关怀方面,沟通和关注细节对运动员满意度有显著影响;在策略选择方面,解决问题对运动员满意度有显著影响;在临场指挥方面,关注细节和洞察力对运动员满意度有显著影响。
This research aims at constructing the professional coaches' competency model and developing relative assessment scale in order to comprehend the present conditions and characteristics of their competency in China.This paper,basing on documental analysis,adopts behavior event interview,psychometrics and other methods to carry out a series of empirical studies on the competence model and relative assessment forms of coaches.With the combination of qualitative research and quantitative research,the main results and conclusion are as follows.
     Firstly,competency model of professional coaches summarizes the competency in theory and has been validated.To construct the professional coaches' competency model includes nine characteristics. They are knowledge obtaining,innovation,teamwork,communication with athletes,authority,attention to details,insight,solutions and analysis thinking.It has been validated by self assessment test that this model appropriately summarizes the competency of coaches.
     Secondly,assessment scale of professional coaches' competency gained good reliability and validity in application.This test includes nine subscales which have thirty-six items.The nine subscales are knowledge obtaining,innovation,teamwork,communication with athletes, authority,attention to details,insight,solutions and analysis thinking and each has four items.The result of psychometric properties on the test demonstrates that the Crombachαis between.632 and.883 in each subscale and the totalαis.924.The outcome of the test on the structure model is also acceptable.
     Thirdly,there exists different levels and characteristics between coaches' competency with different grades,coaching experiences and sports events.Currently,the whole level of professional coaches' competency in China is relatively high and the average score of the nine subscales is above five.Coaches with different grades possess separate significant differences in the dimension of knowledge obtain,innovation, communication with athletes,authority,insight,solutions and analysis thinking;coaches with different training experiences greatly differ in innovation,authority,insight,solutions and the whole score;coaches who are physical performance leading and those skill leading ones are extremely unlike in aspects of innovation and attention to details, besides the second category gains a higher score than the first.However, coaches of individual event and group event only go far away in teamwork and the later group gains a higher score.
     Fourthly,there exists close relationship between the coaches' competency and the athlete's satisfaction on the coaches' teaching action.This relationship is significant.In spite of the demographic variables,there is remarkable effect between coaches' competency and athletes' satisfaction on training,guiding,democratic behavior, individual care,strategy selection and on-the-spot conduct,though with different level in every aspect.Innovation,attention to details and analysis thinking influence largely on the athletes' satisfaction in the aspects of coaches' training and guiding;communication with athletes and authority in democratic behavior;communication with athletes and attention to details in individual care;solutions in strategy selection;attention to details and insight in on-the-spot conduct.
引文
[1]David D.Dubois等著,于广涛等译.基于胜任力的人力资源管理[M].北京:中国人民大学出版社,2006.
    [2]波诺马廖夫.共产主义教育辞典.社会科学出版社,1986,4.
    [3]陈向明.质的研究方法与社会科学研究[M].北京:教育科学出版社,2003.
    [4]陈小蓉.创新——高水平教练员必备的能力[J].中国体育科技,1995(1):44.
    [5]陈正.浅谈运动训练过程的组织、控制与管理者—教练员[J].体育科技,1987(3):29.
    [6]董奇.心理与教育研究方法[M].广东教育出版社,1990,P398.
    [7]付哲敏,张萍.排球教练员人格特征与执教效能关系的研究现状和分析[J].沈阳体育学院学报,2004,23(2).
    [8]古维秋.教练员临场指挥应具备的心理素质与能力探析[J].西南师范大学学报(自然科学版),2000,25(3):332-335.
    [9]过家兴.运动训练学[M].北京:北京体院出版社,1991,4.
    [10]韩春利.体育人力资源开发与管理[M].上海:复旦大学出版社,2005.
    [11]胡红.论教练员与运动员的心理距离[J].体育科学,1997,4.
    [12]金瑜.心理测量[M].上海:华东师范大学出版社,2001,8.
    [13]雷纳.马腾斯著,钟秉枢等译.执教成功之道[M].北京:北京体育大学出版社,2007.
    [14]刘大庆.运动训练活动中的整体与细节问题思考[J].北京体育大学学报,2007,30(2).
    [15]刘芳,于希满.教练员成就动机表现研究[J].中国体育教练员,1999(2).
    [16]刘鎏.我国专业体育教练员胜任特征的研究.硕士学位论文.武汉:华中师范大学,2006.
    [17]刘玉金.我国优秀体操教练员人格文化的分析与研究[J].西安体育学院学报,2001,18(3).
    [18]陆璐.中国国家级教练员知识形成途径研究[J].天津体育学院学报,2006,21(5).
    [19]陆升汉,汪康乐,邰崇禧.论创新是竞技体育教练员的核心素质[J].成都体育学院学报,2002,28(6).
    [20]罗双平.从岗位胜任在绩效卓越——能力模型建立操作实务[M].北京:机械工业出版社,2006.
    [21]罗正学,苗丹民,皇甫恩.人格特征对陆军学院学员胜任特征的预测[J].第四军医大学报,2003,24(8):757-759.
    [22]毛志雄.我国部分项目的运动员对兴奋剂的态度和意向:TRA与TPB两个理论模型的检验[D].北京体育大学博士学位论文,2000.
    [23]苗丹民,罗正学,刘旭峰.年轻飞行员胜任特征评价模型[J].中华航空航天医学杂志,2004,15(1):30-34.
    [24]彭逼眉.胜任特征模型及其在人才选拔中的应用.硕士论文.武汉:武汉大学.2004.
    [25]邱焕芬.现代竞技体育教练员应具备的素质[J].中国体育教练员,2002(1).
    [26]时勘,王继承,李超平.企业高层管理者胜任特征模型评价的研究[J].心理学报,2002,34(3):306-311.
    [27]时勘.基于胜任特征模型的人力资源开发[J].心理科学进展,2006,14(4):586-595.
    [28]孙达平.在指导运动训练过程中教练员心理品质的培养[J].内蒙古体育科技,1990,8(41).
    [29]汤剑文,崔鹏.江苏省部分县级业余体校教练员成就动机的调查于分析[J].安徽体育科技,2003,6(24).
    [30]田建全,苗丹民,罗正学等.陆军学院学员胜任特征模型的建立[J].第四军医大学学报,2004,25(5):456-458.
    [31]田麦久.项群训练理论[M].北京:人民体育出版社,1997.
    [32]田麦久等.运动训练科学化探索[M].北京:人民体育出版社,1998.
    [33]汪中求.细节决定成败[M].北京:新华出版社,2004.
    [34]王继承.谁能胜任——胜任模型及使用[M].中国财政经济出版社,2004,5.
    [35]王进.基于胜任特征的企业员工培训研究.硕士论文.江苏:河海大学.2006.
    [36]王新华.教练员领导行为的类型与评价[J].体育科技,1990(3):42.
    [37]魏亚栋,安红.我国教练员个性及其表现特征探讨[J].天津体院学院学报,1995,10(3).
    [38]谢缤.个人项目专业运动员训练比赛满意度的因素结构及对相关变量的预测[D].北京体育大学博士论文,2007.
    [39]徐建平.教师胜任力模型及测评研究[D].博士学位论文.北京:北京师范大学,2004.
    [40]徐芳.研发团队胜任力模型的构建及其对团队绩效的影响[J].管理现代化,2003(2):43-50.
    [41]尹军,于勇,蔡有志.对我国部分项目优秀教练员能力结构的研究[[J].中国体育科技,2001,37(10):44-45.
    [42]尹军.对我国部分项目优秀教练员知识结构的研究[[J].武汉体育学院学报,2000,34(1):41-44.
    [43]袁伟民.我的执教之道[M].北京:人民体育出版社,1991.
    [44]张力为.体育科学研究方法[M].北京:高等教育出版,2002.
    [45]张忠秋.教练员大赛临场指挥应注意把握哪些心理要素.中国体育教练员,2003,3.
    [46]赵杰,唐东生.教练员的性格与指挥风格及其决策能力[J].武汉体育学院学报,2002,36(1):122-123.
    [47]赵映辉.试论篮球教练员的心理素质与临场指挥能力[J].中国体育科技,1998,34(1):33-35.
    [48]郑日昌.心理测量[M].长沙:湖南教育出版社,1987.
    [49]钟日升.我国教练员与运动员关系现状的分析及教练员角色定位与对策[J].武汉体育学院学报,2004,38(6).
    [50]仲理峰.家族企业高层管理者胜任特征模型及其影响作用的研究[D].博士学位论文,北京:中国科学院心理研究所,2002.
    [51]周百之.试论教练员的知识结构[J].体育科技(河南),1998(2):1.
    [52]周西宽,吴亚初等.教练员学[M].四川教育出版社,1993.
    [53]朱淑春.论教练员的作用、类型与素质[J].体育教学与训练,1992(3):56.
    [54]宗棣华.谈影响足球教练员决策能力的心理因素[J].足球世界,1995,22,11.
    [55]Allen M.J.,& Yen W.M.(1979).Introduction to measurement theory.Brooks:Cole Publishing Company.
    [56]Barcelona,B.R.,Craig M.Journal of Park & Recreation Administration,Winter2004,Vol.22Issue 4,p25,18p
    [57]Barcelona,R.J..An analysis of the perceived competencies of recreational sport managers:toward a competency-based model for academic and professional development.Eugene,OR:Microform Publications,University of Oregon.2002.
    [58]Boyatzis,R.E..The competent manager:a model for effective performance[M],John Wiles&Sons,1982:3-10
    [59]Boyatzis,R.E..Clustering Competence in Emotional Intelligence:Insights from the Emotional Competence Inventory(ECI).San Francisco:Jossey-Bass,1999,8.
    [60]Boyatzis,R.E..Core competencies in Coaching Others to Overcome Dysfunctional Behavior [J].Piscataway:Consortium for Research on Emotional Intelligence in Organizations,2002:3-14.
    [61]Browne,M.W.,& Mels,G.(1994).RAMONA user's guide,Columbus Ohio:The Ohio State University,Department of Psychology.
    [62]Carmines,E.G.& Mclver,J.P.(1981).Analyzing models with unobserved variables:Analysis of covariance structures.In G.W.Bohrnstedt&E.F.Borgatta(Eds.),social measurement:Current issues(pp.65-115).Newbury Park,CA:Sage.
    [63]Carron,A.V.,& Bennett,B.B..Compatibility in the coach-athlete dyad,Research Quarterly,1977,48,671-679.
    [64]Case,R..,Branch,J.D..A study to examine the job competencies of sport facility managers.International Sports Journal,Summer 2003:7(2).p.25-38,14p.
    [65]Chelladurai,P.,& Saleh,S.D.(1980).Dimensions of leader behavior in sports:Development of a leadership scale.Journal of Sport Psychology,2,24-35.
    [66]Chelladurai,P.,& Haggerty,T.R..A normative model of decision styles in coaching.Athletic administrator,1978,13,6-9.
    [67]Chelladurai,P.,&.Saleh,S.D..Dimensions of leader behavior in sports:Development of a leadership scale,Journal of sport Psychology,1980,2.
    [68]Dubois,D.D..Competency based performance improvement.Amherst,MA:HRD Press.1993.
    [69]Dwyer,J.M.,Fischer,D.G..Wrestlers' perceptions of coaches' leadership as predictors of satisfaction with leadership.Perceptual and motor skills(Missoula,Mont.),71(2),Oct 1990,511-517,Refs:16.
    [70]Eitington,J.E..Thewinningtrainer(2nd).Houston,Tx:Gulf Publishing Company,1989.
    [71]Fokken,P.M..Construction and validation for competencies of aboard self-assessment questionnaire(BSAQ)for park and recreation board members:a model development[J].Eugene,OR:Kinesiology Publications,University of Oregon.2004:128-133.
    [72]Goslin,A..Human resource management as a fundamental aspect of a sport development strategy in South African communities.Journal of Sport Management,Apr 1996,10(2).p207-217.
    [73]Hemphill,J.K.,& Coons,A.E..Development of the beadier Behavior Description Questionnaire InL.Mstogdill&A.E conns,Leader behavior:Its description andmeasurement.The Ohio-state University,1957.6-38.
    [74]Hendry,L.B..Human factors in sport systems:suggested models for ana-lyzing athlete-coach interaction.Human Factors,1974,16,528-544.
    [75]Horch,H.D.,Schuette,N..Competencies of sport managers in German sport clubs and sport federations[J].London:Managing leisure,2003,8(2):70-84
    [76]Hurd,A.R..Competency Development for Entry Level Public Parks and Recreation Professionals Journal of Park & Recreation Administration,Fall2005,Vol.23 Issue 3,p45,18p
    [77]Hyland,T..Competence,Education and NVQs:Dissenting Perspectives.London.
    [78]Jamieson,L.M..Competency-based approaches to sport management.Journal of Sport Management,Jan 1987,1(1).p.48-56,9p
    [79]Jamieson,L.M..A competency analysis of recreational sports personnel in selected institutional settings.Unpublished doctoral dissertation,Indiana University,Indiana.1980.
    [80]Jeong,K.P..A conceptual model of coaching confidence:Development of a reliable and valid Coaching Confidence Scale.International Journal Sport Psychology.,2004,35:37-59.
    [81]Jowett.,S.,Cockerill.I.M..Olympic medallists'perspective of the athlete-coach relationship[J].Psychology of Sport and Exercise,2003(4):313~331.
    [82]Judd,M.R..A gender comparison of competencies important for success in college athletic administration.Physical Educator,winter 1995:52(1),p8-13.
    [83]Kenow.Z.,Williams J.M..Coach-athlete compatibility and athlete's perception of coaching behaviors[J].Journal of Behavior,1999,22:251-259.
    [84]Kyungro,C,Young,K.K..Competencies for Fitness Club Instructors:Results of a Delphi-study.International Journal of Applied Sports Sciences,2003,Vol.15 Issue 1,p56,9p
    [85]Lambrecht,K.W..An analysis of the competencies of sports and athletic club managers.Journal of Sport Management,Jul 1987:1(2).p.116-128,13p
    [86]Marsh,H.W.,& Balla,J.R..(1994).Goodness-Of-fit indices in confirmatory factor analysis:The effect of sample and model complexity.Quality&Quantity,28,185-217.
    [87]Marshall,P..Why are some people more successful than others?[0L].http://chambana.craigslist.org/ths/93326186.html.1996.
    [88]McClelland,D.C..Testing for Competence rather than for Intelligence[J].Oxford:American Psychologist,1973,28:1-4.
    [89]McLagan,P.A..Competencies:the next generation,Training & Development,May97,Vol.51 Issue5:p40-48.
    [90]Nichelmann,C.Sport manager heute eine empirische analyse theoretischer and Prakischer an forderungen des tatigkeits feldes,in:H.-D.Horch,J.Heydel and A Sierau(eds,Professional is ierung im Sport management,Aachen,Meyer&Meyer,1999,p287-307.
    [91]Nunnally,J.C.(1978).Psychometric theory(2nd ed).New York:Mcgraw-Hill.
    [92]Nunnally,J.C.,& Bernstein,I.H.(1994).A meta-analysis of the relationship between individual and individual performance.Academy of Management Journal,9,712-721.
    [93]Ogilvie,B.C,& Tutko,T.A..Problem athletes and how to handle them.London:Pelham Books,1966.
    [94]Peng,H..Competencies of sport event managers in the United StatesEugene,OR:Microform Publications,University of Oregon.2001.
    [95]Phillip,K.D..Football coach,SCHOLASTIC COACH,August,1988.68-72.
    [96]Prahalad,H..The Core Competence of the Corporation[M].Harvard Business Review,May-June,1990.
    [97]Richard,S..Williams.Performance Management[M],London:International Thomson Business Press,1998:104-105,109-100.
    [98]Sandberg,J..Understanding human competence at work:an interpretative approach.Academy of Management Journal,2000,43(1):9-25.
    [99]Skipper,W.T..Competencies for collegiate sports facility managers:Implications for a facility management curricular model.Unpublished doctoral dissertation,University of Arkansas.1990.
    [100]Smith,R.E.,Smoll,F.L.,& Curtis B.(1978).Coaching behaviors in little league baseball.In F.L.Psychological perspective in youth sports(pp.173-201).Washington,DC:Hemisphere.
    [101]Spencer,L.M.,Spencer,S.M..Competence at Work:Models for Superior Performance[M].New York:John Wiley&Sons.Inc,1993.1-17;222-226.
    [102]Steiger,J.H.(1990).Structure model and evaluation and modification:An interval estimation approach.Multivariate Behavior Research,25,173-180.
    [103]Stevens,J..(1996).Applied multivariate statistics for the social science(3~(rd)ed.).Magwah,NJ:Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
    [104]Support Staff Competency Dictionary(OL).The Department of Labor.http://www.doleta.Gov/jobs/ETA_Employee_Links/c2.cfm
    [105]Tim,O.B.,& Jimmie,M..It's important to establish a basic phi-losophy that will let your players know what to expect from you.SCHOLASTIC COACH,1993(8):57-58.
    [106]Toh,K.L..Constructing and validating Competencies Of Sport Managers(COSM)instrument:a model development.Eugene,Or.:Microform Publications,University of Oregon,1998:56-62.
    [107]Ullman,J.B..Structural equation modeling.In B.G.Tabachnick&L.S.Fidell(Eds.),Using Multivariate Statistics.Third Edition,(pp.709-811).New York:HarperCollins College Publishers.
    [108]Ward,D.G,Sandstedt,S.D.,Cox,R.H.,Beck,N.C..Athlete-Counseling Competencies for U.S.Psychologists Working With Athletes.Sport Psychologist,Sep2005,Vol.19 Issue 3,p318,17p
    [109]Wheaton,B.,Muthen,B.,Alwin,D.F.,& Summers,G.G.(1977).Assessing reliability and stability in panel model.In D.R..Heise(ED.),Sociological methodology,1977(pp.84-136).San Francisco:Jossry-Bass.
    [110]Whiddett,S.,Hollyforde,S..A practical guide to competencies:how to enhance individual and organizational performance[M].London:Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development,2003.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700