城市轨道交通PPP建设模式风险分担研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
在城市轨道交通PPP项目的建设中,风险分担是项目双方争议的焦点,争议的实质是双方对城市轨道交通PPP项目各项关键风险因素认知不同,并认为承担的风险不能真实反映在各自补偿收益上。而这些都与PPP双方的风险分担相关研究不完善有关。
     本研究基于风险分担视角,对影响城市轨道交通PPP项目的风险因素进行系统性研究,利用风险分析理论中的工作结构分解法、德尔菲法和因果图法等识别了影响城市轨道交通PPP项目的风险因素,分析出了其中的关键风险因素;在建立了影响风险分担的理论模型和城市轨道交通PPP项目的风险分担框架后,在其规定下并以“效率优先”为准则对关键风险因素进行了风险分担,研究得到了关键风险因素分担矩阵。
     同时,本文还系统地介绍了PPP模式发展相关内容,并对国内外PPP项目的风险管理现状进行较深入的分析,在此基础上提出研究现状的不足,然后概括地分析了城市轨道交通的基本特征,并针对其采用PPP建设模式的适用性问题展开研究。随后,经过研究完善了风险分担的定义,总结了风险分担的既有理论和既有研究模型,并尝试通过分担效果的界定与影响因素的分析,来构建全新的城市轨道交通PPP项目风险分担理论模型,并同时提出基于风险初次分担与再分担联动的风险分担机制。在此之后,本文又将理论拓展到工程实践,阐述了在实际的城市轨道交通PPP项目中该如何识别风险,分担风险,通过简要介绍各种通用合同文本与各地方政府对风险分担的规定,提出在项目生命周期的不同阶段,城市轨道交通PPP项目的风险分担框架和具体分担安排。最后,本文引入深圳地铁5号线的PPP风险分担案例作为实证分析,较为全面地介绍了其面临的主要困难、采取的应对措施、相应的风险分担机制、实施过程以及风险分担结果,验证了前述城市轨道交通PPP项目风险分担的理论与机制的研究结果。
Risk allocation is the core issue for both negotiators in PPP project concerning urbanrail transit construction,and the essence is the different cognitive towards key riskfactors in the whole project life cycle, as well as the shared risks cannot really reflecton the total income obtained. All these concerns have something to do with thedeficient research on risk allocation for PPP parties, which make our topic necessary.This thesis systematically studies on risk factors which influence the PPP project inthe urban rail transit construction. The paper adopts approaches for risk identificationsuch as WBS, Delphi method, cause and effect diagram, check sheet approach and soon, identifying key risk factors which influence the whole project; then the thesisestablishes the risk allocation theoretical model and distribution framework for urbanrail transit construction with PPP mode. Based on the works above, risk allocation isconducted under the criterion- Efficiency Priority, with the key risk factors allocationmatrix followed.
     At the same time, Firstly, this thesis presents an over-all introduction about PPP modedevelopment, analyzes risk management and control situations at home and abroadand points out the current research limitations. Secondly, it summarizes the basicfeatures of rail transit construction and unfolds mainly research on applicability ofPPP construction mode; Thirdly, the comprehensive definition, existing theories andexisting models of risk allocation are provided, then the thesis tries to build novel riskallocation model for urban rail transit construction according to analysis of riskallocation effect and impact factors; Finally, it propose the allocation mechanismbased on risk allocating and re-allocating linkage.
     Subsequently, this thesis analyzes the PPP project-No.5 subway in Shenzhen,including the sharing of key risks and so on, Since then,this thesis in turn extends tothe engineering practice,expounding to the actual projects of PPP mode in urban railtransit construction about how to identify risks and risk allocation, by brieflyintroducing a variety of general contract and different regulation by local governmentabout risk allocation, it proposes risk allocation framework and specification due todifferent stages in the whole project life cycle.
     At last, this thesis introduce a risk allocation case of No 5 subway in Shenzhen, taking a comprehensive introduction with the main difficulty, responsible measures, riskallocation mechanisms, implementation process and the results of risk allocation. Thetheory and mechanism of risk allocation of PPP mode in urban rail transit constructionare certified.
引文
[1]王健,基础设施建设引入PPP模式的研究[D],山东大学,2010(4)
    [2] E.S.Savas,民营化与公私部门的伙伴关系[M],中国人民大学出版社,北京,2002.P7.P69.P73.P105
    [3]邓小鹏,PPP项目风险分担及决策研究[D],东南大学博士学位论文.2007(l0)
    [4]英国财政部,公司伙伴关系-政府的举措,2000
    [5]欧盟公私伙伴关系与共同体公共合同与特许法律绿皮书,2004(4):3
    [6] International Monetary Fund,Public-Private Partnerships,GovernmentGuarantees,and Fiscal Risk[R], 2006,Wash-ington:International Monetary Fund.
    [7] Ye Sudong,Tiong Robert L.K..The effect of concession period design oncompletion risk management of BOT projects[J], Construction Management andEconomics.v 21, n 5, p 471-482, July/August 2003.
    [8] Ye Sudong,Tiong Robert L.K..Effects of tariff design in risk management ofprivately financed infrastructure projects[J]. Journal of Construction Engineeringand Management.v 129, n 6, p 610-618, November/December 2003.
    [9] Kong Dequan,Tiong Robert L. K.,Cheah Charles Y. J.,Permana Andre,EhrlichMatthias.Assessment of credit risk in project finance[J]. Journal of ConstructionEngineering and Management.v 134, n 11, p 876-884, 2008.
    [10] Bing Li,Akintoye A.,Edwards Peter J.,Hardcastle C..The allocation of risk inPPP/PFI construction projects in the UK[J]. International Journal of ProjectManagement.v 23, n 1, p 25-35, January 2005.
    [11] Li Bing,Akintoye A.,Edwards Peter J.,Hardcastle C..Critical success factors forPPP/PFI projects in the UK construction industry[J]. Construction Managementand Economics.v 23, n 5, p 459-471, June 2005.
    [12] Zhang Xueqing.Criteria for selecting the private-sector partner in public-privatepartnership[J]. Journal of Construction Engineering and Management.v 131, n 6,p 631-644, June 2005.
    [13] Smyth Hedley.The credibility gap in stakeholder management: Ethics andevidence of relationship management[J]. Construction Management andEconomics.v 26, n 6, p 633-643, June 2008.
    [14] Chan Weng Tat,Chen Chuan,Messner John I.,Chua David Kim Huat.Interfacemanagement for China's build-operate-transfer projects[J]. Journal ofConstruction Engineering and Management.v 131, n 6, p 645-655, June 2005.
    [15] Barretta Antonio,Busco Cristiano,Ruggiero Pasquale.Trust in Project Financing:An Italian Health Care Example[J]. Public Money & Management.v 28, i 3, p179-184, 6p, 1 chart, June 2008.
    [16] D.B.Prieto.Information sharing with the private sector: History, challenges,innovation, and prospects[J]. Seeds of Disaster, Roots of Response: How PrivateAction Can Reduce Public Vulnerability, Cambridge University Press, p 404-428,2006.
    [17] E. Frye.Information-sharing hangups: Is antitrust just a cover?[J]. The CIPReport.v 1, n 3, p 6-7, 2003.
    [18] Consoli G.G.S..Conflict and managing consortia in private prison projects inAustralia - Private prison operator responses[J]. International Journal of ProjectManagement.v 24, n 1, p 75-82, January 2006.
    [19] Abednego Martinus P.,Ogunlana Stephen O..Good project governance for properrisk allocation in public-private partnerships in Indonesia[J]. International Journalof Project Management.v 24, n 7, p 622-634, October 2006.
    [20] Tah,J.H.M.,Thor,A.and McCaffer,R.Contractor project risks contingencyallocation using linguistic approximation[J]. Computing System inEngineering,1993,4(2-3),281-93
    [21] Nigal J.Smith,Manging Risk in Constructing project[M],Blackwel,London 1999
    [22] L.Y.Shen project risks Management in Hong Kong Intemational[J]. Journal ofproject Management,Vol.15 No.5.1997:101-105
    [23] Li B.Risk Management of Public/Private Partnership Pro-jects.Un-published PhDThesis[M]. School of the Builtand Natural Environment.Glasgow CaledonianUniversity. Glasgow,Scotland.2003.
    [24] Li Bing,A.Akintoye,Peter J.Edwards,and C.Hardcastle,The allocation of risk inPPP/PFI construction projects in the UK[J]. International Journal of ProjectManagement.2005, Elsevier Ltd,Oxford,OX5 1GB,United Kingdom
    [25] Darrin Grimsey,Mervyn K.Lewis,evaluating the risks of public privatepartnerships for infrastructure projects[J]. International Journal of ProjectManagement,2002
    [26] Li-Yin Shen,Andrew Platten,X.P.Deng Role of publicprivate partnerships tomanage risks in publicsector projects in Hong Kong[J]. International Journal ofProject Manage-ment 24 (2006):587-594
    [27] Martinus P.Abednego,Stephen O.Ogunlana Goodproject governance for properrisk allocation in public pri-vate partnerships in Indonesia[J]. InternationalJournal of Project Management 24(2006)622-634
    [28] Loosemore M,Raftery J,Reilly C,Higgon D.Risk man-agement in projects[J].London: Taylor&Francis,2006
    [29] Wang Shouqing,Tiong Robert L. K.,Ting Seng Kiong,Ashley David. Politicalrisks: Analysis of key contract clauses in China's BOT project[J]. Journal ofConstruction Engineering and Management.v 125, n 3, p 190-197, May/June1999.
    [30] Wang Shouqing,Tiong Robert L.K.,Ting S.K.,Ashley D..Foreign exchange andrevenue risks: Analysis of key contract clauses in China's BOT project[J].Construction Management and Economics.v 18, n 3, p 311-320, April 2000.
    [31]刘新平,王守清.试论PPP项目的风险分配原则与框架[J].建筑经济.2006(2):59-63.
    [32] Ke Yongjian,Liu Xinping,Wang Shouqing.Equitable Financial Evaluation Methodfor Public-Private Partnership Projects[J]. Tsinghua Science and Technology.v 13,n 5, p 702-707, October 2008.
    [33]戴大双,于英慧,韩明杰.BOT项目风险量化方法与应用[J].科技管理研究.2005(2):98-103.
    [34]孙淑云,戴大双,杨卫华.高速公路BOT项目特许定价中的风险分担研究[J].科技管理研究.2006(10):154-157.
    [35] Jinbo Song,Shoudong Han,Dongbo Wang.A decision method of concessionperiod for build-operate-transfer projects of sewage treatment[J]. InternationalConference on Wireless Communications, Networking and Mobile Computing,WiCOM .2008.
    [36]杨宏伟,周晶,何建敏.基于博弈论的交通BOT项目特许权期的决策模型[J].管理工程学报.2003,17(3):93-95.
    [37]杨宏伟,何建敏,周晶.在BOT模式下收费道路定价和投资的博弈决策模型[J].中国管理科学.2003,11(2):30-33.
    [38]邓小鹏,李启明,汪文雄,李枚.PPP模式风险分担原则综述及运用[J].建筑经济.2008(9):32-35.
    [39] Wang Wen-Xiong,Li Qi-Ming,Deng Xiao-Peng,Li Li-Hua,Cai Yuan.Selectingoptimal private-sector partner in infrastructure projects under PPP model[J].Proceedings of 2007 International Conference on Management Science andEngineering, ICMSE'07 (14th).p 2264-2270, 2008.
    [40] Wang Wen-Xiong,Li Qi-Ming,Deng Xiao-Peng,Li Jing-Hua.Critical successfactors of infrastructure projects under PPP model in China[J]. InternationalConference on Wireless Communications, Networking and Mobile Computing,WiCOM.p 4965-4969, 2007.
    [41]张喆,贾明,万迪昉.不完全契约及关系契约视角下的PPP最优控制权配置探讨[J].外国经济与管理.2007,29(8):24-29.
    [42]张喆,贾明,万迪昉.PPP背景下控制权配置及其对合作效率影响的模型研究[J].管理工程学报.2009,23(3):23-29.
    [43] Liu Jicai Cheah,Charles Y.J..Real option application in PPP/PFI projectnegotiation[J]. Construction Management and Economics.v 27, n 4, p 331-342,2009.
    [44] Zhang Shuibo,Yang Qiubo.Contractual arrangements under BOT project deliveryapproach: A behavioral framework[J]. International Conference on WirelessCommunications, Networking and Mobile Computing, WiCOM.2008.
    [45]张水波,高颖.国际BOT项目合同框架分析以及风险防范[J].国际经济合作.2010(1):74-77.
    [46]张水波,孔德泉,何伯森.BOT项目风险管理的担保手段[J].中国软科学.2000(2):73-76.
    [47]陈柳钦.PPP:新型公私合作融资模式[J].建筑经济.2005(3)
    [48]齐艳.我国城市轨道交通吸引民间资本方式研究[J].科技经济市场,2006(7)
    [49]王海生,何德宏.城市轨道交通公私合作投资模式的风险分析[J].城市轨道交通研究2005(3):13-16
    [50]董经纬,来庆泉.城市轨道交通项目公私合作模式的架构和建议[J].都市快轨交通,2006(10):24一25
    [51]张汉卓,聂敏.运用公私合作模式进行城市轨道交通建设融资[J].城市轨道交通研究,2004(5)
    [52]陈伟强,章恒全.PPP与BOT融资模式的比较[J].价值工程,2003(2):4-6.
    [53]王灏.PPP的定义和分类研究[J].都市快轨交通.2004(5)
    [54]李秀辉,张世英.PPP:新型的项目融资方式[J].中国软科学,2002(2):51-54
    [55]李秀辉,张世英.PPP与城市公共基础设施建设[J].城市规划,2002(7):74—76
    [56]王周喜,张勇.PPP融资模式在西部基础设施建设中的可行性分析[J].西北农林科技大学学报
    [57]彭桃花,赖国锦.P即模式的风险分析与对策[J].中国工程咨询.2004.7
    [58]程述,谢丽芳.工程项目风险分担模型探讨[J].工程项目管理,2006,11:93-96
    [59]谢伟东,何雯.公私合作模式融资在我国城市轨道交通项目中的实践[J].城市轨道交通研究,2006(3)
    [60]来庆泉.轨道交通PPP投融资条件与基本框架[J].现代城市轨道交通,2006(2),4-6
    [61]刘江华.项目融资风险分担研究[J].工业技术经济,2006,258
    [62]刘子卫.工程风险及风险分担机制探讨[J].经济论坛,2007,18:59-61
    [63]刘雷.PPP融资方式在基础设施建设中的运用[J].商业时代,2000(3):56一59
    [64]宋志东.BOT融资中的风险分担及合同管理[J].吉林省经济管理干部学院学报,2004,18:28-31
    [65]李永强,苏振民.PPP项目风险分担的博弈分析[J].基建优化,2005,26:16-21
    [66]刘新平?王守清.试论PPP项目的风险分配原则和框架[J].建筑经济,2006,2:59-63
    [67]张曦,俞波.BOT项目经济风险指标及其度量方法[J].福州大学学报,2004(3):325-329
    [68] Yin Yilin,Jiang Jingbo,The Importance of Railway Construction Norm and thePerfecting Ways[J], International Conference on Management and ServiceSciences
    [69] Latham M, Constructing the team: joint review of procurement and contractualarrangements in theUnited Kingdom[M]. construction industry,London: HMSO,1994
    [70] K.C. Lam, D. Wang,Patricia T.K. Lee etc., Modelling risk allocation decision inconstruction contracts[J], International Journal of Project Management,2007,25(5): 485-493
    [71]杜亚灵,尹贻林,公共项目绩效改善研究:风险分配途径[J],科技管理研究,2008,28(05):274-276
    [72] M.P.Abednego,Stephen O.Ogunlana,Good project governance for proper riskallocation in public~private partnership in Indonesia[J], International Journal ofProject Management,2006,(24):622-634
    [73] Uff J.Risk management and procurement in construction[M]. London: Centre ofConstruction Law and Management,1995
    [74] Hoffman,S.L. The law and business of international project finance-A resourcefor governments,sponsors,lenders,lawyers and project particapants[M]. TheHague:Kluwer Law International. 1998
    [75] M.P.Abednego,Stephen O.Ogunlana.Good project governance for proper riskallocation in public~private partnership in Indonesia[J].International Journal ofProject Management ,2006,(24):622~634
    [76]沈显之,论菲迪克(FIDIC)合同条件的编制理念[J],中国工程咨询,2005,(02):31~37
    [77] Qiu Chuang,Risk.Risk–aversion,Incentives and Construction Procurement[M],London: MSc.Course essay
    [78] Jones,D.S.,Philosophies of allocation-the case for foreseeability[J],London: the13th International Construction Law Review,1996
    [79] Smith.Robert J,Allocation of Risk-the Case for Manageability,London :13theInternational Construction Law Review:552
    [80] K.C. Lam, D. Wang,Patricia T.K. Lee,Y.T. Tsang,Modelling risk allocationdecision in construction contracts[J],International Journal of ProjectManagement,2007,25(05): 485-493
    [81] Martinus P. Abednego , Stephen O. Ogunlana, Good project governance forproper risk allocation in public private partnerships in Indonesia[J], InternationalJournal of Project Management, 2006 ,(24) :622-634
    [82] Lam KC,Wang D,Lee PTK and Tsang YT.Modeling risk allocation decision inconstruction contracts[J],International Journal of Project Management,2007,(25):485-493
    [83] BIRNIE J,Risk Allocation to the Construction Firm within a Private FinanceInitiative Project[J],ARCOM Conference,1998,The University of Reading,London: 527-534
    [84]哀夏炜,王延树,成虎,合同风险分配的研究[J],施工企业管理,1997(04):28-29
    [85]朱冰,李启明,工程项目风险分担问题的探讨[J],江苏建筑,2005(03):50-53
    [86]刘子卫,项目风险及风险分担机制探析[J],经济论坛,2007,(18):59-61
    [87] Levitt R.E,Ashley D.B,Logcher R.D. Allocating risk and incentive inconstruction[J], Journal of the Construction Division,ASCE,CO3,1980
    [88]张水波,何伯森,工程项目合同双方风险分担问题的探讨[J],天津大学学报(社会科学版),2003,5(03):257-261
    [89] Grimsey D,Lewis KK,Public private partnerships. Cheltman[M], UK:EdwardElgar, 2004
    [90] ANDI,The importance and allocation of risks in Indonesian constructionprojects[J], Construction Management and Economics,2006,24(1):69-80
    [91] A.Ng,Martin Loosemore,Risk allocation in the private provision of publicinfrastructure[J], International Journal of Project Management,2007,25(1):66-76
    [92] Francesca Medda,A game theory approach for the allocation of risks in transportpublic private partnerships, International Journal of Project Management, 2007,25(03):213-218
    [93]吴艳霞,王雷,殷仲民,基于投资方角度的项目融资风险分配研究[J],重庆建筑大学学报,2006,28(2):115-119
    [94]段文斌,袁帅,风险分担与激励合同:对委托-代理论的进一步检讨[J],南开经济研究,2004,(05):19-25
    [95]周鑫,PPP项目融资风险分担博弈分析[J],合作经济与科技,2009,(07):78-79
    [96]张静,基于效用理论的项目风险评价与投资决策研究:[D],合肥:合肥工业大学,2007
    [97]魏学成,PPP项目的风险分担及收益分配研究[D],重庆:重庆大学,2008
    [98]穆尉鹏,PPP项目融资风险分担机制研究:[D],重庆:重庆大学,2008
    [99]杜亚灵,尹贻林,基于模糊逻辑的公共项目风险分配模型[J],北京理工大学学报(社会科学版),2008,(03):94-98
    [100]程连于,PPP项目融资模式的风险分担优化模型[J],价值工程,2009,(04):142-145
    [101]周运祥,曹国华,项目融资中风险分担的优化模型分析[J],重庆大学学报(自然科学版),2005, 28(10)136-138
    [102]杨萍,BOT项目中风险分担模型研究[J],价值工程,2005,(07):116-118
    [103]范小军,赵一,钟根元,基础项目融资风险的分担比例研究[J],管理工程学报,2007,21(01):98-101
    [104] Vega,Arturo Orsk allocation in infrastructure financing[J], Journal of ProjectFinance,1997,3(2):38-42.
    [105] Frederick A, Entrepreneurial risk allocation in public-private infrastructureprovision in South Africa[J], South African Journal of BusinessManagement,2002,33(4):29-40.
    [106] Arndt,Henry R,Risk allocation in the Melbourne city link project[J],Journal ofProject Finance,1998, 4(3):11-24.
    [107]张水波,王辉,BOT模式项目融资的法律谈判[J],中国软科学,1999:81-84
    [108]刘先涛,杨萍,高军,BOT项目风险分担模式研究[J],科技管理研究,2006(10):185-187
    [109]涂铭,汪霄,PPP组织模式的分类及风险研究[J],商业时代,2007,(32):43-44
    [110]何寿奎,傅鸿源,城市基础设施PPP建设模式挑战与对策[J],生产力研究, 2007,(8): 65-67
    [111]辛欣,吴国蔚,从黄桥电力公司困境看BOT融资方式中风险[J],商场现代化,2006, (11):166-167
    [112]罗春晖,基础设施民间投资项目中的风险分担研究[J],现代管理科学,2001 ,(2):28-29
    [113]严兵,阮南,信用风险:BOT项目融资成败的关键[J],国际经济合作, 2003, (1):46-49
    [114]王秀芹,梁学光,毛伟才,公私伙伴关系PPP模式成功的关键因素分析[J],国际经济合作, 2007,(12):59-62
    [115]刘晓君,张宏,基础设施项目运用BT融资方式的风险管理[J],建筑经济,2005,(1):63-65
    [116]陈瑜,夏光明,民间资本投融资的主要风险及合理分担[J],武汉理工大学学报,2004, 26(6):97-100
    [117]刘新平,王守清,试论PPP项目的风险分配原则和框架[J],建筑经济, 2006,(2):59-63
    [118]何伯森,万彩芸,BOT项目的风险分担与合同管理[J],中国港湾建设,2001,(5):63-65
    [119]谢忠辉,高速公路BOT项目风险分析[J],监控研究,2007,27(2):200-205
    [120]韩传峰,王玉虎,工程建设项目风险分担管理模式系统分析[J],建筑经济,2007,(8): 68-70
    [121]孙玉红,工程量清单计价模式下的工程量变更风险分析[J],建筑经济,2006,(7): 219-221
    [122]李明顺,论公路建设项目风险分担机制[J],工业技术经济,2006,25(1):110-113
    [123]高华,我国BT模式投资建设合同研究:[D],天津,天津大学,2009
    [124]朱宗乾,李艳霞,罗阿维等,ERP项目实施中风险分担影响因素的实证研究[J],工业工程与管理,2010,15(2):98-102
    [125] Martinus P. Abednego,Stephen O. Good project governance for proper riskallocation in public-private partnerships in Indonesia[J], International Journal ofProject Management,2006,(4):622-634.
    [126] United Nations Institute for Training and Research(UNITAR),PPP forSustainable Development, New York,2000
    [127]杨瑞龙,聂辉华.不完全契约理论:一个综述[J],研究经济,2006(2),104-115.
    [128] Li Bing, Risk Management of Construction Public Private Partnership Projects:[D], 2003
    [129]单长亮,EPC/交钥匙工程合同风险审核法律问题研究[D],北京:对外经济贸易大学, 2007,(3):21-23
    [130]于海丰,EPC总承包项目风险管理研究[D],南京:东南大学,2006,(3):55-57
    [131]成虎,工程项目管理[M],南京:东南大学出版社,2009:120-189
    [132]英国土木工程师学会,新工程合同条件(NEC)工程施工合同与使用指南[M],北京:中国建筑工业出版社,1999:11-299
    [133]朱锦林译,FIDIC施工合同条件[M](第1版),北京:机械工业出版社,2002:21-22
    [134]罗凤,向科,英国土木工程师学会NEC合同及其特点[J],四川建筑科学研究,2005, (03):35-39
    [135]胥善林,傅鸿源,NEC与FIDIC合同条件的几点比较,重庆建筑大学学报, 2002,(06): 56-57
    [136]蔡春红,NEC与FIDIC合同条件之比较[J],国际经济合作,2000,(11):27-31
    [137]赵振宇,江伟,黄文杰,FIDIC施工合同条件下承包商风险探析[J],土木工程学报, 2007, (06):76-79
    [138]成虎,建设工程合同管理与索赔[M],南京:东南大学出版社,2008,:81-180
    [139]李启明,土木工程合同管理[M],南京:东南大学出版社,2009,59-278
    [140]哀夏炜,王延树,成虎,合同风险分配的研究[J],施工企业管理,1997,(4):28-29
    [141]雷琥,EPC模式下的项目风险管理:[D],天津:天津大学,2006,(04):51-54
    [142]王建东,建设工程合同典型案例评析[M],杭州:浙江大学出版社,2005:9-198
    [143] Olive D.Hart,Firm,contracts and financial structur[M], Oxford:OxfordUniversity Press,1995
    [144] Wang SQ, Lessons learnt from the PPP practices in China (keynote speech)[J],Asian Infrastructure Congress 2006 ,2006,(11):29-30
    [145]中华环保频道,长春汇津污水处理有限公司诉长春市人民政府案一审结案,http: //www. cctvep. com /news/news1721. html,2008-8-20.
    [146]亚洲开发银行,中国城市水业市场化(PPP)推进过程中遇到的一些重要问题及相关建议,亚洲开发银行技术援助项目-4095:中华人民共和国/政策调整,2005
    [147]沈际勇,王守清,强茂山,中国BOT/PPP项目的政治风险和主权风险:案例分析,华商投资与融资, 2005,1:1-7
    [148]浙商网,谁动了杭州湾跨海大桥的奶酪?,http://www.zjo.lcom.cn/gb/node2/node138665/node257861/node257865/node257874/userob-ject15ai3951216.html,2005-3-2
    [149]中金在线,投资商数亿投资血本无归, http: //news. stock888. net/040804/101,1317, 1009454, 00. shtml,2004-8-4
    [150]新华网,盲目承诺出恶果:港商索赔9亿元,http://news.xinhuanet.com/comments/2004-08/04/content_1708128.shtml,2004-8-4
    [151]赵燕凌,中华发电命系电力改革,竞价上网危及当年BOT承诺,搜狐,转自:财经时报, http: //it. sohu.com /34/12/article209271234. shtml,2003-5-15
    [152]中国水网,中法水务廉江触礁,http://news.h2o-china.com/finance/information/114651029478620_1.shtml,2002-8-16
    [153]新华电信宽频网,广东廉江引资1669万美元建成水厂后空置8年,http: //xnews. xintv. com /html/NEWS/JIUZHOUQUANLIAOWANG/2007/06/19/430016. html ,2007-6-19
    [154]陈庆元,运用BOT方式投资建设刺桐大桥的认识与实践[J],中国投资,2001,6:19-21
    [155]黄全权,吴亮,泉州刺桐大桥连不上高速路[J],中国青年报,2002-9-26
    [156]世界新能源网,武汉汤逊湖污水处理厂BOT项目夭折,http: //www. 86ne. com/Jnhb/200409/Jnhb_38197.html,2004-9-29
    [157]张维然,林慧军,王绥娟,延安东路隧道复线BOT模式之评价[J],中国市政工程,1996,9:48-53
    [158]王亦丁,BOT陷阱[J],环球企业家,2002,2(2)
    [159]姜敬波,尹贻林,国际工程承包商工期索赔管理[J],国际经济合作,2009,(3):78-80
    [160] Jiang Jingbo,Yin Yilin,The study of contractor’s time claim and costclaim[J],International Conference on Management and Service Sciences

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700