风险沟通与公司价值关系研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
企业风险管理已经成为公司经营和发展不可或缺的重要组成部分。特别是度过2008年全球金融危机,进入后危机时代,越来越多的公司开始致力于充分发挥企业风险管理对公司运营的积极效果,同时风险管理经理已经成为公司文化和商业实践的重要角色。但风险管理的有效性与公司高级管理层的期望依然不符,同时受到网路迅速发展的影响,公司价值极易受到信息传递的影响,上市公司表现为股票价格的剧烈、频繁波动。这源于公司对风险沟通缺乏充分的认识和有效的利用。“风险沟通”最早出现在社会学和公共管理学领域,《企业风险管理——整合框架》将其作为要素内容出现在企业风险管理领域。然而,学术界关于企业风险管理的研究主要集中在公司治理、风险评估以及企业文化等方面,风险沟通的作用并没有得到足够的重视,难以对企业的风险管理实施提供足够的支持。在这种情况下,准确概括风险沟通内涵,分析风险沟通对公司价值的作用机理,探究风险沟通方式之间的联系,研究不同市场细分方式下的我国上市公司风险沟通与公司价值关系,为上市公司改善企业风险管理提供建议,已成为一个既有价值又急需解决的课题。
     论文在总结了企业风险管理的定义、目标、要素组成和兼容框架等的基础上,通过综述国内外多位学者的研究成果,对公司治理、内部控制与风险管理进行了比较,并指出风险沟通所处的位置和作用。进而提出了风险沟通涵义,论述了风险沟通发展的历程。论文采用了理论分析与实证分析相结合、实证分析与规范分析相结合的方法来分析风险沟通与公司价值的影响关系。
     论文首先从不对称信息经济学中委托代理模型与信号传递模型引入,以非完全信息模型为基础,通过新的理论假设,推导风险沟通影响公司价值的机理。有效的风险沟通可以减少信息交流中的噪音,影响公司的生产技术参数,通过降低风险暴露系数和公司价值方差,降低公司资本成本、Beta值和影子成本,进而提升公司价值。其次,论文总结了风险沟通的过程,依据过程的四个步骤和信息直观性判断,可以将风险沟通分为隐性与显性两种方式,并分别选取审计师选择和投资者关系管理作为主要指标变量,讨论了实证研究中的计量方法和公司价值的表示方式。
     在以上理论模型推导和实证变量选择的基础上,本文主要从三个方面对风险沟通与公司价值关系进行了具体的实证研究。
     首先,风险沟通的显性方式与隐性方式对公司价值的影响。本文选取我国上市公司的截面数据,运用结构方程实证检验了理论模型的“有效风险沟通可以提升公司价值”的结论,同时结果显示风险沟通显性方式对隐性方式也存在正向影响。为了进一步探讨两者对公司价值的影响差异,使用我国上市公司面板数据,分别从市场价值、盈利能力和股本扩张能力三个角度进行验证,结果表明风险沟通显性方式对公司价值的影响程度要强于隐性方式。
     其次,不同控制权企业的风险沟通与公司价值的关系。选择公司控制程度和控制权性质两个分类标准,采用因子分析处理变量,并重新构建了回归方程,运用我国上市公司面板数据验证了企业目标和股权结构的差异会导致风险沟通的不同效果。控制权越高的公司,显性方式对公司市场价值的影响越显著,而隐性方式只与管理层控制公司的公司价值存在正相关性。地方国有企业的风险沟通显著性较弱,中央国有企业主要受到显性方式的影响。
     再次,不同市场化程度企业的风险沟通与公司价值的关系。将市场化指数、政府干预指数和法治水平指数变量引入实证模型,采用逐步回归的方法进行分析。结果显示在政府干预较少的地区,投资者关系管理不佳的公司倾向于选择高质量审计师;投资者关系管理较好的公司则倾向于选择低质量审计师,分别通过风险沟通的显性和隐性方式向投资者传递公司治理的信号。在市场化程度较高、法制水平较高的地区,良好的财务信息披露更有助于提升投资者关系管理的效果;政府干预较多的地区则起到相反的作用。政府干预是影响公司价值最为显著的市场化因素;在政府干预较少的地区,风险沟通可以作为公司价值提升的传导机制和实现途径。
     论文最后对全文主要研究结论做了总结,提出了研究启示,并进一步分析了研究的局限性和未来研究的方向。
Enterprise risk management has become an important part of the companyoperation and development. Especially through the2008global financial crisis, afterentering the crisis era, more and more companies began to fully implement efficientand effective enterprise risk management programs, while risk managers are playingan important role in the company's culture and business practices. But theeffectiveness of ERM and the company's senior management's expectations on riskmanagement still does not match, meanwhile, influenced by the rapid development ofthe Internet, the value of the company is vulnerable to the impact of informationtransfer, the listed company's stock price performance fluctuates intensely andfrequently. These stem from a lack of full understanding and effective utilizingcompany’s risk communication.‘Risk communication’ first appeared in the field ofsociology and public administration, and then it appeared in the field of enterprise riskmanagement as an element of ‘Enterprise Risk Management-Integrated Framework’.However, academic research on enterprise risk management mainly focuses oncorporate governance, risk assessment and corporate culture, the role of riskcommunication does not get enough attention, so it is difficult to provide adequatesupport for implementation of enterprise risk management. In this case, summarizingthe exact meaning of risk communication, analyzing the mechanism of riskcommunication affecting the value of the company, discussing relationship amongrisk communication methods, studying the relationship between the company valueand risk communication of China’s listed companies under different market segments,offering recommendations about improvement on listed companies’ risk management,have become valuable and urgent issues need to resolve immediately.
     Based on summarizing the basic definition, objectives, elements andcompatible framework of enterprise risk management, this paper compares corporategovernance, internal control and risk management through reviewing the researchresults of a number of scholars at home and abroad, and points out location and roleof risk communication among them. Then put forward the meaning of riskcommunication, and discusses the development process of risk communication. Thispaper uses theoretical analysis and empirical analysis in combination, empirical analysis and normative analysis in combination to analyze the relationship betweenrisk communication and company value.
     This paper introduces the principal-agent model and signal transmissionmodel in the asymmetry information economics at the first step, and then gives thederivation of mechanism that how risk communication affects the company's valuebased on the non-complete information model through assumption modification.Effective risk communication can reduce noise in the exchange of information,change the company's production technology parameters, such as reducing riskexpose coefficient and the variance of company value, in order to reduce thecompany's cost of capital, Beta value and the shadow costs, and thus increase thecompany value. After that, the paper summarizes the process of risk communication.Judging based on four steps of process and information intuition, risk communicationcan be divided into implicit method and explicit method. Then this paper selectsauditor choice and investor relationship management as major indicator variables, anddiscusses measurement and representation method of company value in the empiricalresearch.
     On the basis of theoretical models derivation and empirical variable selectionmentioned above, this paper implements specific empirical research on relationshipbetween risk communication and company value mainly from three aspects.
     Firstly, implicit method and explicit method of risk communication affect thecompany value. Selected cross-section data of listed companies in China, this paperuses the structural equation model to tests the conclusion, which is effective riskcommunication can increase the company value, while empirical research outcomeshows that explicit method has positive effects on implicit method. To furtherinvestigates the difference of effect on company value from implicit method andexplicit method, the paper uses panel data of listed companies in China to study fromthree angles of market value, profitability and capital expansion capabilityrespectively. The result shows that the degree of impact on the company value fromrisk communication explicit method is stronger than implicit method.
     Secondly, the relationship between risk communication and company valueof different control rights companies. Selecting the company control degree andcontrol right nature as classification criteria, using factor analysis to process variables,and re-building the regression equation, the paper verifies the differences betweenbusiness goals and ownership structure will lead to different effects of risk communication by using panel data of China’s listed companies. Results indicates thatthe higher the control of the company, the more significant explicit method impact themarket value of the company, while implicit method positively correlated only withcompany value of company controlled by management. The significance of riskcommunication of local state-owned enterprise is weak relatively. Central state-ownedenterprises are mainly influenced by the explicit method.
     Thirdly, the relationship between risk communication and company value ofdifferent marketization degrees companies. The paper puts marketization index,government intervention index and law index variables into the empirical model, anduses stepwise regression analysis method. The results shows that in the region withless government intervention, companies with poor investor relations managementtend to choose high-quality auditors; companies with good investor relationsmanagement tend to choose low-quality auditors. These actions can pass corporategovernance signal to investors through risk communication implicit method andexplicit method respectively. The higher degree of marketization and the higher levelsof legal areas, the more good financial disclosures can help to improve investorrelations management effectiveness; more regional government intervention makesopposite effect. Government intervention is the most significant impact factor on thecompany value; in the region with less government intervention, risk communicationis the transmission mechanism and implementation approaches of increasing companyvalue.
     The paper gives the main conclusions at the end, meanwhile presents theinsight of the research, analysis of the limitations of the research and directions forfuture research.
引文
2马费成.信息经济学.武汉:武汉大学出版社,1997.
    4张维迎.博弈论与信息经济学.上海:上海人民出版社,2004.
    16我国对上市公司的净资产收益率有硬性要求。2006年施行的《上市公司证券发行管理办法》第十三条提出:向不特定对象公开募集股份(简称“增发”),还应当符合下列规定:(一)三个会计年度加权平均净资产收益率平均不低于百分之六。扣除非经常性损益后的净利润与扣除前的净利润相比,以低者作为加权平均净资产收益率的计算依据;(二)除金融类企业外,期末不存在持有金额较大的交易性金融资产和可供出售的金融资产、借予他人款项、委托理财等财务性投资的情形;(三)发行价格应不低于公告招股意向书前二十个交易日公司股票均价或前一个交易日的均价。
    17根据会计报表,上市公司的每股净资产主要包括股本、资本公积金、盈余公积金和未分配利润四部分内容。根据《公司法》相关规定,股本、资本公积和盈余公积在公司正常经营期内不能随意调整,因此,每股净资产的调整主要是对未分配利润进行调整。
    [1]费方域,企业的产权分析,上海人民出版社,1998。
    [2]严晖,公司治理、公司管理与内部控制——对COSO企业风险管理框架(ERM)的分析,财会通讯,2005年第4期,10‐14页。
    [3]戴文涛,内部控制学科体系构建,审计与经济研究,2010年第2期,80‐86页。
    [4]谢志华,内部控制、公司治理、风险管理:关系与整合,会计研究,2007年第10期,37‐45页。
    [5]李维安,戴文涛,公司治理、内部控制、风险管理的关系框架——基于战略管理视角,审计与经济研究,2013年第4期,3‐12页。
    [6]杨有红,胡燕,试论公司治理与内部控制的对接,会计研究,2004年第10期,14‐18页。
    [7]王东,企业风险管理中的风险沟通机制研究,保险研究,2011年第4期,62‐69页。
    [8]孙铮,曹宇,股权结构与审计需求,审计研究,2004年第3期,7‐14页。
    [9]李明辉,代理成本对审计师选择的影响——基于中国IPO公司的研究,经济科学,2006年第3期,73‐83页。
    [10]王艳艳,陈汉文,于李胜,代理冲突与高质量审计需求——来自中国上市公司的经验数据,经济科学,2006年第2期,72‐82页。
    [11]朱红军,夏立军,陈信元,转型经济中审计市场的需求特征研究,审计研究,2004年第5期,53‐62页。
    [12]陈武朝,郑军,中国注册会计师行业服务需求的特点及其影响的探讨,审计研究,2001年第1期,51‐53页。
    [13]薛祖元,陈靖,陈汉文,审计需求:传统解释与保险假说,审计研究,2004年第5期,20‐25页。
    [14]雷光勇,李书锋,王秀娟,政治关联、审计师选择与公司价值,管理世界,2009年第7期,145‐155页。
    [15]李心丹,肖斌卿,张兵等,投资者关系管理能提升上市公司价值吗,管理世界,2007年第9期,117‐128页。
    [16]汪炜,蒋高峰,信息披露、透明度与资本成本,经济研究,2004年第7期,107‐114页。
    [17]张宗新,郭明新,中国证券市场信用缺失与信用制度重构,经济体制改革,2004年第6期,128‐130页。
    [18]曾颖,陆正飞,信息披露质量与股权融资成本,经济研究,2006年第2期,69‐79页。
    [19]王东,国外风险管理理论研究综述,金融发展研究,2011年第2期,23‐27页。
    [20]王稳,王东,企业风险管理理论的演进与发展,审计研究,2010年第4期,96‐100页。
    [21]李涛,周开国,乔根平,企业增长的决定因素——中国经验,管理世界,2005第12期,116‐172页。
    [22]李心丹,肖斌卿,王树华等,中国上市公司投资者关系管理评价指标体系及其应用研究,管理世界,2006年第9期,117‐128页。
    [23]李心丹,刘玉灿,肖斌卿,中国上市公司投资者关系管理运作机制研究,中国管理科学,2005第13期,79‐83页。
    [24]王鹏,周黎安,控股股东的控制权、所有权与公司绩效:基于中国上市公司的证据,金融研究,2006年第2期,88‐98页。
    [25]希金斯,全球投资者关系最佳案例,北京:机械工业出版社,2002年。
    [26]李维安等,中国上市公司治理指数与治理绩效的实证分析,管理世界,2004年第2期,63‐74页。
    [27]陈冬华,地方政府、公司治理与补贴收入,财经研究,2003年第9期,15‐21页。
    [28]樊纲,王小鲁,中国市场化指数——各地区市场化相对进程2011年报告,北京:经济科学出版社,2012年。
    [29]雷光勇,审计合谋与财务报告舞弊:共生与治理,管理世界,2004第2期,97‐116页。
    [30]漆江娜,陈慧霖,张阳,事务所规模、品牌、价格与审计质量——国际“四大”中国审计市场收费与质量研究,审计研究,2004第3期,59‐65页。
    [31]汪辉,上市公司债务融资、公司治理与市场价值,经济研究,2003年第8期,52‐63页。
    [32]王鹏,周黎安,中国上市公司外部审计的选择及其治理效应,中国会计评论,2006年第2期,321‐344页。
    [33]王咏梅,王鹏,“四大”与“非四大”审计质量市场认同度的差异性研究,审计研究,2006年第5期,49‐56页。
    [34]夏立军,方轶强,政府控制、治理环境与公司价值,经济研究,2005年第5期,40‐51页。
    [35]李树华,审计质量的提高与审计市场的背离,上海:上海三联书店,2000。
    [36]胡奕明,唐松莲,审计、信息透明度与银行贷款利率,审计研究,2007年第6期,74‐84页。
    [37]高强,伍丽娜,大股东资金占用与审计师选择的再检验,审计研究,2007年第5期,84‐90页。
    [38]王霞,张为国,财务重述与独立审计质量,审计研究,2005年第3期,56‐61页。
    [39]蔡春,黄益建,赵莎,关于审计质量对盈余管理影响的实证研究——来自沪市制造业的经验证据,审计研究,2005年第2期,3‐10页。
    [40]洪金明,徐玉德,李亚茹,信息披露质量、控股股东资金占用与审计师选择——来自深市A股上市公司的经验证据,审计研究,2011年第2期,107‐112页。
    [41]赵颖,投资者关系管理与资本成本——来自中国上市公司的实证证据,山西财经大学学报,2010年第4期,85‐92页。
    [42]樊纲,王小鲁,张立文,朱恒鹏,中国各地区市场化相对进程报告,经济研究,2003年第3期,9‐18页。
    [43]孙铮,刘凤委,李增泉,市场化程度、政府干预与企业债务期限结构——来自我国上市公司的经验证据,经济研究,2005年第5期,52‐63页。
    [44]曾学文,施发启,赵少钦,董晓宇,中国市场化指数的测度与评价:1978‐2008,中国延安干部学院学报,2010年第4期,47‐60页。
    [45]蒲自立,公司控制权与公司绩效研究——基于中国上市公司的分析,四川大学博士学位论文,2004年。
    [46]张小茜,汪炜,持股结构、决议机制与上市公司控制权,经济研究,2008年第11期,40‐50页。
    [47]陆瑶,激活公司控制权市场对中国上市公司价值的影响研究,金融研究,2010年第7期,144‐156页。
    [48]王鹏,周黎安,控股股东的控制权、所有权与公司绩效:基于中国上市公司的证据,金融研究,2006年第2期,88‐98页。
    [49]李增泉,孙铮,王志伟,隧道挖掘与所有权安排——来自我国上市公司大股东资金占用的经验证据,会计研究,2004年第12期,3‐13页。
    [50]孙永祥,黄祖辉,上市公司的股权结构与绩效,经济研究,1999年第12期,23‐30页。
    [51]徐晓东,徐小悦,第一股东对上市公司治理、企业绩效的影响分析,经济研究,2003年第2期,64‐74页。
    [52]朱武祥,宋勇,股权结构与企业价值——对家电行业上市公司实证分析,经济研究,2001年第12期,66‐72页。
    [53]施东晖,上市公司控制权价值的实证研究,经济科学,2003年第6期,83‐89页。
    [54]杜兴强,郭剑花,雷宇,大股东资金占用、外部审计与公司治理,经济管理,2010年第1期,111‐117页。
    [55]高强,伍利娜,大股东资金占用与审计师选择的再检验,审计研究,2007年第5期,84‐90页。
    [56]张奇峰,张鸣,公司控制权安排、审计师选择与市场价值——来自中国上市公司的证据,山西财经大学学报,2009年第6期,108‐115页。
    [57]肖小凤,唐红,王善平,企业风险与审计师选择,财经理论与实践,2010年第4期,62‐66页。
    [58]张娟,李虎,王兵,审计师选择、信号传递和资本结构优化调整——基于中国上市公司的实证分析,审计与经济研究,2010年第5期,33‐39页。
    [59]唐跃军,审计质量VS信号显示——终极控制权、大股东治理战略与审计师选择,金融研究,2011年第5期,139‐155页。
    [60]林斌,辛清泉,杨德明,陈念,投资者关系管理及其影响因素分析——基于深圳上市公司的实证检验,会计研究,2005年第9期,32‐38页。
    [61]马连福,卞娜,刘丽颖,中国上市公司投资者关系水平及对公司绩效影响的实证研究,管理评论,2011年第10期,19‐24页。
    [62]RIMS,2013RIMS Enterprise Risk Management(ERM) Survey, Zurich,2013.
    [63]COSO, Enterprise Risk Management–Integrated Framework, COSO of theTreadway Commission,2004.
    [64]COSO, Internal Control–Integrated Framework, COSO of the TreadwayCommission,1992.
    [65]John Frase, Betty J. Simkins, Enterprise Risk Management: Today’s LeadingResearch and Best Practices for Tomorrow’s Executives, John Wiley&Sons, Inc.,2010.
    [66]Elkins, D., Managing risks in global automotive manufacturing operations,Presentation at the University of Virginia, January,2006.
    [67]Adam Smith, The Wealth of Nations, W. Stranhan and T. Cadell, London,1776.
    [68]Coase Ronald,“The Nature of the Firm”, Economica,4(16), pp386-405,1937.
    [69]Hart O., Moore J., The Governance of Exchanges: Members' Cooperatives VersusOutside Ownership, Oxfod Review of Economic Policy,1996.
    [70]Berle A., Means G., The Modern Corporation and Private Property, Harcourt,Brace and World Inc., New York,1932.
    [71]Baumol W J. Business Behavior, Value and Growth, New York,1959.
    [72]Williamson O.,“Corporate Finance and Corporate Governance”, Journal ofFinance,43, pp566-592,1988.
    [73]Galbraith J K., Designing Complex Organizations, Addison Wesley PublishingCompany,1973.
    [74]Shleifer A., Vishny A.,“Large Shareholders and Corporate Control”, Journal ofPolitical Economy,95), pp599-617,1986.
    [75]Dennis Robertson, S. Dennison, Control of Industry, Cambridge University Press,1960.
    [76]Sim Segal, Corporate Value of Enterprise Risk Management, John Wiley&Sons,Inc.,2011.
    [77]Marsiglia E., Falautano I.,“Corporate Social Responsibility and SustainabilityChallenges for a Bancassurance Company”, Geneva Papers on Risk andInsurance-issues and practice,30(3), PP485-497,2005.
    [78]Peter Forstmoser, Nikodemus Herger,“Managing Reputational Risk: AReinsurer’s View”, The Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance-Issues andPractice,31(3), PP409-424,2006.
    [79]Norma L. Nielson, Anne E. Kleffner, Ryan B. Lee,“The Evolution of the Role ofRisk Communication in Effective Risk Management”, Risk Management andInsurance Review, Vol8,2, pp279-289,2005.
    [80]Powell D., W. Leiss, Mad Cows and Mother’s Milk, McGill-Queen’s UniversityPress,1997.
    [81]Deragon J. T., Fourth Generation Risk Management, The Quality InsuranceCongress,1995.
    [82]Colquitt L., R. E. Hoyt, R. B. Lee,“Integrated Risk Management and the Role ofthe Risk Manager”, Risk Management and Insurance Review,2(3), pp43-61,1999.
    [83]Kleffner A. E., R. B. Lee, and W. G. McGannon,“The Effect of CorporateGovernance on the Use of Enterprise Risk Management: Evidence from Canada”,Risk Management and Insurance Review,6(1), pp53-73,2003.
    [84]Wallace W., The Economic Role of the Audit in Free and Regulated Markets. TheTouche Ross and Co. Aid to Education Program,1980.
    [85]Wallace W.,“The Economic Role of the Audit in Free and Regulated Markets: AReview”, Research in Accounting Regulation,1, PP7–34,1987.
    [86]Wallace W.,“Delay in Accounting Harmonization: Evidence on Auditor Selectionand Cost-of-Capital Effects”, Research in Accounting Regulation,15, PP39–68,2002.
    [87]Wallace W.,“The Economic Role of the Audit in Free and Regulated Markets: ALook Back and A Look Forward”, Research in Accounting Regulation,17,PP267–298,2004.
    [88]Jensen M., W. Meckling,“Theory of the Firm: Managerial Behavior, AgencyCosts and Ownership Structure”, Journal of Financial Economics, Vol.3,pp305-360,1976.
    [89]DeFond M. L.,“The Association Between Changes in Client Firm Agency Costsand Auditor Switching”, A Journal of Practice&Theory, Vol.11, pp16-31,1992.
    [90]De Ketelaere, C.,“Type auditor en de verklaring bij de jaarrekening”, Scriptie,pp1-117,2007.
    [91]Beaver W., Financial Reporting: An Accounting Revolution, Prentice-Hall Int.,Inc.,1989.
    [92]Beaver W., P. Kettler, M. Scholes,“The Association between Market Determinedand Accounting-Determined Risk Measures”, The Accounting Review,45,PP654–682,1970.
    [93]Arrow K., The Economics of Agency. Principals and Agents: The Structure ofBusiness, Harvard Business School Press,1985.
    [94]Ng T., H-T. Tan,“Effects of Authoritative Guidance Availability and AuditCommittee Effectiveness on Auditors' Judgments in An Auditor-ClientNegotiation Context”, The Accounting Review,78, PP801-818,2003.
    [95]Chow C.,“The Demand for External Auditing: Size, Debt and OwnershipInfluences”, The Accounting Review,57, PP272–291,1982.
    [96]Hay D., D. Davis,“The Voluntary Choice of An Audit of Any Level of Quality”,A Journal of Practice and Theory, Vol.23, PP37-53,2004.
    [97]Abdel-Khalik R.,“Why Do Private Companies Demand Auditing? A Case forOrganizational Loss of Control”. Journal of Accounting,8, PP31-52,1993.
    [98]Fan J., T. Wong,“Do External Auditors Perform A Corporate Governance Role inEmerging Markets? Evidence from East Asia”. Journal of Accounting Research,43, PP35-72,2005.
    [99]Higson A., Corporate Financial Reporting-Theory&Practice, Sage PublicationsLtd,2003.
    [100] Fama E., A. Laffer,“Information and capital markets”, Journal of Business,44, PP289-298,1971.
    [101] Chen C., X. Su, R. Zhao,“An Emerging Market’s Reaction to InitialModified Audit Opinions: Evidence from the Shanghai Stock Exchange”,Contemporary Accounting Research,17, PP429-455,2000.
    [102] Taffler R., J. Lu, A. Kausar,“In Denial? Stock Market Underreaction toGoing-Concern Audit Report Disclosures”, Journal of Accounting andEconomics,38, PP263-296,2004.
    [103] Menon K., D. Williams,“Auditor Credibility and Initial Public Offerings”,The Accounting Review,66, PP313-332,1991.
    [104] Hogan C.,“Costs and Benefits of Audit Quality in the IPO Market: ASelf-selection Analysis”, The Accounting Review,72, PP67-86,1997.
    [105] Willenborg M.,“Empirical Analysis of the Economic Demand for Auditingin the Initial Public Offerings Market”, Journal of Accounting Research,37,PP225-238,1999.
    [106] O’Reilly, R. Leitch, B. Tuttle,“An Experimental Test of the Interaction of theInsurance and Information-signaling Hypothesis in Auditing”, ContemporaryAccounting Research,23, PP267-289,2006.
    [107] Lennox C.,“Audit Quality and Auditor Size: An Evaluation of Reputationand Deep Pockets Hypotheses”. Journal of Business Finance&Accounting,26,PP779-805,1999.
    [108] Kinney, J. R., L. S. McDaniel,“Characteristics of Firms CorrectingPreviously Reported Quarterly Earnings”, Journal of Accounting and Economics,Vol.11, PP71-93,1989.
    [109] Knechel R., V. Naiker, G. Pacheco,“Does Industry Specialization Matter?Evidence from Market Reaction to Auditor Switches”, Auditing: A Journal ofPractice and Theory,26, PP19-45,2007.
    [110] DeAngelo L.,“Auditor Size and Audit Quality”, Journal of Accounting andEconomics, Vol.3, pp183-199,1981.
    [111] Thornton D. B., G. Moore,“Auditor Choice and Audit Fee Determinants”,Journal of Business Finance&Accounting, Vol.20, PP306-349,1993.
    [112] Simunic D. A.,“The Pricing of Audit Services: Theory and Evidence”,Journal of Accounting Research, Vol.18, PP161-190,1980.
    [113] Francis J., D. Simon,“A Test of Audit Pricing in the Small‐Client Segment ofthe US Audit Market”, Accounting Review, Vol.62, PP145-157,1987.
    [114] Gul F. A.,“Audit Prices, Product Differentiation and Economic Equilibrium”,Auditing: A Journal of Practice&Theory, Vol.18, PP90-100,1999.
    [115] Choi J. H., J-B. Kim, X. Liu, D. A. Simunic,“Audit Pricing, Legal LiabilityRegimes, and Big4Premiums: Theory and Cross‐country Evidence”,Contemporary Accounting Research, Vol.25, PP55-99,2008.
    [116] Simunic D. A., M. T. Stein, Product Differentiation in Auditing: AuditorChoice in the Market for Unseasoned New Issues, Vancouver, BC: The CanadianCertified General Accountants’ Research Foundation,1987
    [117] Moizer P.,“Auditor Reputation: The International Empirical Evidence”,International Journal of Auditing, Vol.1, PP61-74,1997.
    [118] Watts R., J. Zimmerman,“The Demand of and Supply for AccountingTheories”, The Accounting Review,54, PP273-305,1986.
    [119] Brennan M., C. Tamarowski,“Investor Relations, Liquidity, and StockPrices”, Journal of Applied Corporate Finance,12, PP26-37,2000.
    [120] Barry C., S. Brown,“Differential Information and Security MarketEquilibrium”, Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis,20, PP407-422,1985.
    [121] Amihud Y., H. Mendelson,“Asset Pricing and The Bid-ask Spread”, Journalof Financial Economics,17, PP223-249,1986.
    [122] Diamond W., E. Verrecchia,“Disclosure, Liquidity and The Cost of Capital”,Journal of Finance,46, PP1325-1359,1991.
    [123] Verrecchia R.,“Discretionary Disclosure”, Journal of Accounting andEconomics,5, PP179-194,1983.
    [124] Verrecchia R.,“Information Quality and Discretionary Disclosure”, Journalof Accounting and Economics,12, PP365-380,1990.
    [125] Bushee B. J., S. G. Miller, Investor Relations, Firm Visibility, and InvestorFollowing, Working Paper,2006.
    [126] Merton C. R.,“A Simple Model of Capital Market Equilibrium withIncomplete Information”, Journal of Finance,42, PP483-510,1987.
    [127] Bushman R., A. Smith,“Financial Accounting Information and CorporateGovernance”, Journal of Accounting and Economics,32, PP237-333,2001.
    [128] Miller G.,“The Press as A Watchdog for Accounting Fraud”, Journal ofAccounting Research,44, PP1001-1033,2006.
    [129] Yu F.,“Analyst Coverage and Earnings Management”, Journal of FinancialEconomics,88, PP245-271,2008.
    [130] Healy P., K. Palepu,“Information Asymmetry, Corporate Disclosure, and theCapital Markets: A Review of the Empirical Disclosure Literature”, Journal ofAccounting and Economics,31, PP405-440,2001.
    [131] Ball R.,“International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS): Pros and Consfor Investors”, Accounting and Business Research,36, PP5-27,2006.
    [132] Allen C. E.,“Building Mountains in A Flat Landscape: Investor Relations inthe Post-Enron Era”, Corporate Communications,7, PP206-211,2002.
    [133] Holland J.,“Private Voluntary Disclosure, Financial Intermediation andMarket Efficiency”, Journal of Business, Finance and Accounting,25, PP29-68,1998.
    [134] Roberts J., P. Sanderson, R. Barker, and J. Hendry,“In the Mirror of theMarket: The Disciplinary Effects of Company/Fund Manager Meetings”,Accounting, Organizations and Society,31, PP277-294,2006.
    [135] Rao H., K. Sivakumar,“Institutional Sources of Boundary-spanningStructures: the Establishment of Investor Relations Departments in the Fortune500Industrials”, Organization Science,10, PP27-42,1999.
    [136] Lang M., R. Lundholm,“Voluntary Disclosures and Equity Offerings:Reducing Information Asymmetry or Hyping the Stock?”, ContemporaryAccounting Research,17, PP623-662,2000.
    [137] De Jong, D. DeJong, G. Mertens and P. Roosenboom,“Investor Relations,Reputational Bonding, and Corporate Governance: The Case of Royal Ahold”,Journal of Accounting and Public Policy,26, PP328-375,2007.
    [138] Hong H., M. Huang,“Talking Up Liquidity: Insider Trading and InvestorRelations”, Journal of Financial Intermediation,14, PP1-31,2005.
    [139] Lang M., R. Lundholm,“Corporate Disclosure Policy and Analyst Behavior”,Accounting Review,71, PP467-492,1996.
    [140] Healy P., A. Hutton, K. Palepu,“Stock Performance and IntermediationChanges Surrounding Sustained Increases in Disclosure”, ContemporaryAccounting Research,16, PP485-520,1999.
    [141] Farragher E., R. Kleiman, M. Bazaz,“Do Investor Relations Make aDifference?”, Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance,34, PP403-412,1994.
    [142] Botosan C., M. Plumlee,“A Re-examination of Disclosure Level and TheExpected Cost of Equity Capital”, Journal of Accounting Research,40, PP21-40,2002.
    [143] Leuz, C., R. Verrecchia,“The Economic Consequences of IncreasedDisclosure”, Journal of Accounting Research,38, PP91-124,2000.
    [144] Core J.,“A Review of the Empirical Disclosure Literature: A Discussion”,Journal of Accounting and Economics,31, PP441-456,2001.
    [145] Adamos V., Melita C.,“Valuation Effects of Investor Relations Investments”,Accounting and Finance,52, PP941-970,2012
    [146] Stigler G. J.,“The Economics of Information”, Journal of Political Economy,69, PP213-225,1961.
    [147] Akerlof G.,“The Market for Lemons: Quality Uncertainty and MarketMechanism”, Quarterly Journal of Economics,84, PP488-500,1970.
    [148] Spence M., Market Signaling, Harvard University Press,1974.
    [149] Rothschild M.,“Models of Market Organization with Imperfect Information:A Survey”, Journal of Political Economy,81, PP1283-1308.
    [150] Kevin C.W. Chen, Zhihong Chen, K.C. John Wei,“Disclosure, CorporateGovernance, and the Cost of Equity Capital: Evidence from Asia’s EmergingMarkets”, www.ssrn.com,2003.
    [151] John C., Dennis L.,“The Effect of Shareholding Dispersion on the Degree ofControl in British Companies: Theory and Measurement”, The Economic Journal,93, pp351-369,1983.
    [152] Artzner P., F. Delbaen, J.-M. Eber and D. Heath,“Coherent Measures ofRisk”, Mathematical Finance,9, PP203-228,1999.
    [153] Bernstein P. L.,“Risk Management, Financial Markets and Insurance: TheHidden Linkages”, Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance,25, PP629-636,2000.
    [154] Chanes J., M. Daniels,“One Occurrence or Two: How the Courts Decide”,Risk Management,49, PP32-36,2002.
    [155] Ewing L. J., R. B. Lee,“Surviving the Age of Risk: A Call for Ethical RiskManagement”, Risk Management,51, PP56-58,2004.
    [156] DeFond M. L., T. J. Wong, S. H. Li.,“The Impact of Improved AuditorIndependence On Audit Market Concentration in China”, Journal of Accountingand Economics,12, PP269-305,1999.
    [157] Becker C., M. Defond, J. Jiambalvo,“The Effect of Audit Quality onEarnings Management”, Contemporary Accounting Research,15, PP1-21,1998.
    [158] Teoh S. H., T. J. Wong,“Perceived Auditor Quality and the EarningsResponse Coefficient”, The Accounting Review,68, PP346-366,1993.
    [159] Acemoglu D., Johnson S.,“Unbundling Institutions”, Journal of PoliticalEconomy,113, PP949-995,2005.
    [160] Abbott L. J., S. Parker,“Auditor Selection and Audit CommitteeCharacteristics”, Auditing: Journal of Practice and Theory,19, PP47-66,2000.
    [161] Agrawal A., Knoeber C. K.,”Do Some Outside Directors Play a PoliticalRole?”, Journal of Law and Economics,44, PP179-198,2001.
    [162] Baber W., Kumar K., Verghese T.,“Client Security Price Reactions to theLaventhol and Horwath Bankruptcy”, Journal of Accounting Research,33,PP385-395,1995.
    [163] Ball R., Kothari S. P., A. Robin,“The Effect of Institutional Factors onProperties of Accounting Earnings: International Evidence”, Journal ofAccounting and Economics,29, PP1-51,2000.
    [164] Claessems S. S., Djiankov J. Fan, L, Lang,“Disentangling the Incentive andEntrenchment Effects of Large Shareholding”, Journal of Finance,57,PP2741-2771,2002.
    [165] DeAngelo L.,“Auditor Independence, Lowballing and DisclosureRegulation”, Journal of Accounting and Economics,1, PP113-127,1981.
    [166] Defond M., J. Jiambalvo,“Factors Related to Auditor-Client Disagreementsover Income-Increasing Accounting Methods”, Contemporary AccountingResearch,9, PP415-432,1993.
    [167] Fan J. P. H., T.J. Wong, Tianyu Zhang,“Politically Connected CEOs,Corporate Governance and Post-IPO Performance of China’s Newly PartiallyPrivatized Firms”, Journal of Financial Economics,84, PP330-357,2007.
    [168] Fisman R.,“Estimating the Value of Political Connections”, AmericanEconomic Review,91, PP1095-1102,2001.
    [169] Francis J. R., E. R. Wilson,“Auditor Changes: A Joint Test of TheoriesRelating to Agency Costs and Auditor Differentiation”, The Accounting Review,63, PP663-683,1988.
    [170] Francis J. R., I. K. Khurana, R. Pereira,“Investor Protection Laws,Accounting and Auditing Around the World”, Asia Pacific Journal of Accountingand Economics,10, PP1-30,2003.
    [171] Hellman J. S., Jones, G., Kaufmann, D.,“Seize the State, Seize the Day: StateCapture, Corruption and Influence in Transition”, Journal of ComparativeEconomics,31, PP751-733,2003.
    [172] Johnson, W. B., T. Lys,“The Market for Audit Services: Evidence fromVoluntary Auditor Changes”, Journal of Accounting and Economics,12,PP281-308,1990.
    [173] Johnson, S., Mitten, T.,“Cronyism and Capital Controls: Evidence fromMalaysia”, Journal of Financial Economics,67, PP351-382,2003.
    [174] Klapper L., I. Love.“Corporate Governance, Investor Protection andPerformance in Emerging Markets”, Journal of Corporate Finance,10,PP703-728,2004.
    [175] Kothari, Lys, Smith and Watts,“Auditor’s Liability and InformationDisclosure”, Journal of Accounting,Auditing and Finance,3, PP307-339,1988.
    [176] La Porta, R., F. Lopez-de-Silanes and A. Shleifer,“Corporate OwnershipAround the World”, Journal of Finance,54, PP471-517,1999.
    [177] La Porta, R., F. Lopez-de-Silanes and A. Shleifer and R. Vishny,“InvestorProtection and Corporate Valuation”, Journal of Finance,57, PP1147-1170,2002.
    [178] Leuz, C., Flex, Oberholzer-Gee,“Polictical Relationships, Global Financingand Corporate Transparency”, working paper, University of Pennsylvania,2005.
    [179] Li Hongbin, Lingsheng Meng, Qian Wang, Li-An Zhou,“PoliticalConnections and Firm Performance: Evidence from Chinese Private Firms”, CIGWorking Paper Series,2005.
    [180] Palmorse Z.,“An Analysis of Audit or Litigation and Audit Service Quality”,The Accounting Review,63, PP55-73,1988.
    [181] Qian Wang, T. J. Wong, Lijun Xia,“State Ownership, InstitutionalEnvironment and Auditor Choice: Evidence from China”, Working Paper, theChinese University of Hong Kong,2005.
    [182] Roberts B. E.,“A Dead Senator Tells No Lies: Seniority and the Distributionof Federal Benefits”, American Journal of Political Science,34, PP31-58,1990.
    [183] Watts R., J. Zimmerman,“Agency Problems, Auditing and the Theory of theFirm: Some Evidence”, Journal of Law and Economics,26, PP613-633,1983.
    [184] Bai C.E., Q. Liu, J. Loe, F. M. Song and J. X. Zhang,“Corporate Governanceand Corporate Valuation in China”, Journal of Comparative Economics,32,PP599-616,2004.
    [185] Chung Kee H., Stephen W. Pruitt,“A Simple Approximation of Tobin’s q”,Financial Management,23, PP70-74,1994.
    [186] Lemmon M. L., Lins K. V.,“Ownership Structure, Corporate Governanceand Firm Value: Evidence from the East Asia Financial Crisis”, Journal ofFinance,58, PP1445-1468,2003.
    [187] Tobin J,“A General Equilibrium Approach to Monetary Theory”, Journal ofMoney,1, PP15-29,1969.
    [188] Robert M. Morgan, Shelby D. Hunt,“The Commitment-Trust Theory ofRelationship Marketing”, Journal of Marketing,58, PP20-38,1994.
    [189] Ryder N., Regester M., Investor relation, Hutchinson Business Books,1989.
    [190] Myers S. C.,“The Capital Structure Puzzle”, Journal of Finance,39,PP75-92,1984.
    [191] Berle A., Means G., The Modern Corporation and Private Property,Commerce Clearing House,1932.
    [192] Cubbin J., Leech D.,“the Effect of Shareholding Dispersion on the Degree ofControl in British Companies: Theory and Measurement”, Economic Journal,93,PP351-369,1983.
    [193] La Porta R., Lopez-De-Silanes F. and Shleifer A.,“Corporate Ownershiparound the World”, Journal of Finance,57, PP1147-1170,1999.
    [194] Claessens S., Djankov S., Lang L.,“The Separation of Ownership andControl in East Asian Corporations”, Journal of Financial Economics,58, PP81-112,2000.
    [195] Claessens S., Djankov S., Lang L.,“Disentangling the Incentive andEntrenchment Effects of Large Shareholdings”, Journal of Finance,57,PP2741-2771,2002.
    [196] Bertrand, Marianne, Esther Duflo and Sendhil Mullainatha,“How MuchShould We Trust Differences-in-Differences Estimaties?”, Quaterly Journal ofEconomics,119, PP249-275.
    [197] Bertrand, Marianne, Sendhil Mullainatha,“Enjoying the Quiet Life?Corporate Governance and Managerial Preference”, Journal of PoliticalEconomics,111, PP1043-1075,2003.
    [198] Doidge, Craig G., Andrew Karolyi and Rene M. Stulz,“Why Are ForeignFirms Listed in the U. S. Worth More?”, Journal of Financial Economics,71,PP205-238,2004.
    [199] Fama, Eugene F.,“Agency Problems and the Theory of the Firm”, Journal ofPolitical Economics,88, PP288-307,1980.
    [200] Gampers, Paul, Joy Ishii and Andrew Metrick,“Corporate Governance andEquity Prices”, Quarterly Journal of Economics,118, PP107-115,2003.
    [201] Henry, Peter Blair,“Do Stock Market Liberalization Cause InvestmentBooms?”, Journal of Financial Economics,58, PP301-334,2000.
    [202] Hou, Wenxuan, Edward Lee and Konstantinos Stathopoulos,“The Impact ofthe Split Share Structure Reform in China on Executive Pay–performanceSensitivities,” Working paper, www.ssrn.com,2010.
    [203] Jensen, Michael C., and Richard S. Ruback,“The Market for CorporateControl: The Scientific Evidence”, Journal of Financial Economics,11, PP5-50,1983.
    [204] Li, Kai, Tan Wang, Yan-Leung Cheung and Ping Jiang,“Privatization andRisk Sharing: Evidence from the Split Share Structure Reform in China”,Working Paper, www.ssrn.com,2007.
    [205] Lu, Fei, Maria Balatbat and Robert Czernkowski,“The Role ofConsideration in China’s Split Share Structure Reform”, Working Paper,www.ssrn.com,2008.
    [206] Manne, Hentry G.,“Mergers and the Market for Corporate Control”, Journalof Political Economy,73, PP110-120,1965.
    [207] Shleifer, Andrei and Robert W. Vishny,“A Survey of Corporate Governance”,Journal of Finance,52, PP737-783.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700