杉木林土壤肥力变化和长期生产力维持研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
杉木[Cunninghamia lanceolata(Lamb) Hook]是我国南方最重要的用材树种,近几十年来,由于高度的集约经营、并伴随着某些不合理的营林和栽培措施,如树种单纯,全垦整地,大面积皆伐、在同一林地上连续栽杉等,加上杉木自身生物学特性等原因,致使杉木人工林生产力下降和地力衰退现象普遍存在,已严重影响了杉木人工林的持续经营。因此,如何维护和提高杉林土壤肥力,保持人工林持续速生、丰产,使林地能长期持续利用,已成为我国林业建设,尤其是营林生产中急待解决的重大问题之一。
     近年来,虽然有关杉木人工林地力变化及连栽生产力下降的研究较多,然而这些研究都是在不同学科、不同地区范围、不同方面分散进行,学科之间缺乏联系,研究工作缺乏系统性,对不同生长发育时期、不同立地指数杉木人工林的土壤肥力变化和生产力状况缺乏全面、深入的系统研究,加上林业地域上的复杂性,在研究的深度和广度上仍受到一定程度的限制。不同立地指数、不同生长发育时期的杉木人工林是否都存在地力衰退,杉木人工林土壤综合肥力退化发生在林分的什么时期(林龄)尚不十分清楚。鉴于此,本论文通过面上调查和定位观测,全面系统地研究不同栽植代数、不同生长发育时期和不同立地指数杉木人工林的土壤肥力变化和生产力状况,在轮伐期内,炼山、整地等营林措施对杉林土壤养分损耗与功能的影响,以及发展和丰富林下植被、推行林地施肥制度对杉林土壤肥力和长期生产力的影响,为维护和提高杉林土壤肥力,实现林地可持续经营提供科学依据。主要研究结果如下:
     1、随着栽植代数的增加,杉木胸径生长逐代递减,树高生长明显衰退,林分蓄积量逐代下降。不同地位指数的林地,连栽后,杉木生长的降低幅度有所不同,16地位指数级的林地,二代中龄林杉木林平均胸径、树高和蓄积量比一代林分别下降了9.27%、12.56%和22.85%;三代林比一代林分别下降26.90%、15.96%和56.15%;14地位指数的林地,连栽后三代林的胸径和蓄积量降低更为明显。不同立地指数(14和16)林地间杉林平均胸径和蓄积量的差异以三代林最大。连栽对杉林生物量也有明显影响,杉木林平均单株总生物量和各器官生物量均随栽植代数逐代下降,16地位指数的二、三代中龄林平均单株总生
Chinese fir (Cunninghamia lanceolata (Lamb.) Hook) is a most important timber tree in southern China. In the last decades, because of the traditional extensive management and some inappropriate cultivated measures, such as monoculture of a tree species, control burning, over-all site preparation, clear cutting and continuous cropping at the same site, as well as the biological characteristics of Chinese fir itself, the decline of its forest productivity and soil fertility exists in common, which directly affects the sustained-yield management of Chinese fir plantation on site. It is a critical problem nowadays to reveal the' mechanism of productivity decline of Chinese fir plantations after continuous cropping and to explore techniques for long-term maintenance of the forest productivity.In northern Fujian province, the characteristics of tree growth and soil fertility of the Chinese fir plantations with different rounds of continuous cropping, different ages and different site index have been studied through fixed-size plot observations and extensive investigations. Practicable techniques, such as developing undergrowth and fertilization have also been explored for long-term maintenance of the productivity in Chinese fir plantations. The results obtained are as follows:1. Compared with the first planting, D.B.H, height and volume of the tree in the second and the third plantings in the continuous cropping system of Chinese fir decreased. For example, for the site index 16 stands, compared with those of the first planting, the mean tree height, D.B.H and volume of the second planting decreased by 9.27%, 12.56% and 22.85%, and those of the third planting decreased by 26.90%, 15.96% and 56.15%, respectively. The mean individual biomass of site index 16 stands from the second and the third planting of Chinese fir decreased by 18.45% and 42.94% respectively, compared with those of the first planting. The composition of biomass also changed, the ratio of trunk and bark decreased, but the ratio of branches, leaves and roots increased.
    2. The physical properties of soil were greatly influenced by the continuous cropping of Chinese fir. Especially in the mid-age stands, the soil volume weight increased, capillary, non-capillary and total porosity of soil under the second and the third plantings decreased, compared with the first one. Soil permeability also became worse. For example, for the site index 16 stand, capillary, non-capillary and total porosity of surface soil (0-20cm) under the second stand decreased by 23.33%, 22.03% and 23.06%, capillary and total porosity of surface soil under the third stand decreased by 43.91% and 27.8%, respectively. For the young plantation, due to the influences of site preparation and tending, the effects of continuous cropping on soil physical properties were not as clear as those in the mid-age stands.3. The greatest effect of continuous cropping on soil nutrient status occurred upon available P. Continuous cropping resulted in decreasing of available P to all of the stands. For example, for the site-index 14 mid-age stand, the concentration of available P in the surface soil of the second and the third plantings decreased by 35.82% and 7.68% respectively. For the site index 16 mid-age stand, the organic matter, total N and hydrolyzable N in soil under the second also plantation decreased by 43.98%, 15.11% and 28.86% respectively. But for the young Chinese fir plantation, except for the available P, most of the other nutrient concentration was not decreased, some were even increased.4. Total contents of Mn and Zn in this region were all lower than their average contents of the whole country, and those of Fe and Cu were relatively high. The contents of available Mn, Cu and Zn were relatively low, and most of soil in this region lacked the available contents of these microelements Mn, Cu, Zn, Along with the increasing continuous cropping of Chinese fir, these shortage could become more serious.5. Along with the increasing continuous cropping of Chinese fir, the acidity of the rhizophere soil was raised, and for the first and the second plantings, O. M. and total N of the rhizophere soil was relatively enriched. But for the third planting, they were relatively lacking. The available P in all of the rhizophere soil decreased.6. For the mid-age and mature continuous cropping plantation, the quantity of soil microbe decreased obviously. The organic carbon may increase in the soils of some continuous plantations, whereas the humic acid and humification coefficient decreased, i.e. continuous cropping resulted in lessening the complication and worsening the quality of soil humus.7. The long-term maintenance of Chinese fir plantation productivity was greatly influenced by ground clearance. Control burning and site preparation led to the decreasing of soil volume weights and the increasing of capillary porosity and total porosity, as well as to the water retaining capacity and soil permeability. Control burning and site preparation could also increase the quantity of microbes, and the contents of available N, P, K. Control burning might promote the survival rate and
    enhance growth of young Chinese fir trees in a short period. However, owing to the great losses of soil, water and nutrients resulted by control burning, it has been proved that control burning for continuous cropping on the same site is one of the major factors leading to the productivity decline of Chinese fir plantations.8. The type of under growth had clear effects on soil fertility of Chinese fir plantation. Compared with the dicranopteis type undergrowth, the nutrient contents of soil under Chinese fir stand with the pteridophyte type increased. For the same type undergrowth, the more abundant the undergrowth, the higher of nutrient contents in the soil. The contents of available B, Mo, Cu, Zn, in surface soil (0~6cm) under young Chinese fir stand with pteridophyte type undergrowth were higher than those with dicranopteis type undergrowth, but those in subsurface soil (6~30cm) of the former decreased.9. In the northern part of Fujian province, fertilization had some positive effects on the young Chinese fir plantation, but, in general, the effects were not remarkable. P fertilization could increase the biomass of different parts of the tree, In particular, the application of ammonium phosphate in a ditch could increase the amount of laves as well as the total biomass of the tree remarkably. P fertilization could also increase the P concentration and storage in one -year-old leaves and roots. Whether there is fertilization or not, leaf was the major P pool of Chinese fir stands.10. In pot experiment of Chinese fir, P fertilization increased its Fe and N absorption, and N and P associated fertilization increased its Mo absorption, P shortage induced Fe and N shortage, and N shortage induced Mo shortage.11. P utilization percentage by Chinese fir stands in Fujian was much higher than that of the pot experiment in Jiangsu. The highest P utilization percentage occurred with ammonium phosphate, which were 4.06% and 10.04% in pot and field experiment respectively. In the northern part of Fujian province, ammonium phosphate might be the best fertilizer for Chinese fir, and fertilization in a ditch was the best fertilization method.
引文
1 吴中伦,杉木,北京:中国林业出版社,1984
    2 俞新妥主编,杉木栽培学,福州:福建科学技术出版社,1997
    3 俞新妥,杉木,福州:福建科学技术出版社,1982
    4 俞新妥,我国近期杉木资源动态及经营意见,林业科技通讯,1996,(11):24~26
    5 中华人民共和国林业部,1989~1993年全国森林资源统计,1994
    6 徐化成,人工林和天然林的比较评价,世界林业界,1991,4(2)
    7 俞新妥,我国80年代杉木林资源动态及营林对策的思考,福建林学院学报,1990,10(4):411~416
    8 张宪武等,杉木连栽与土壤中毒,杉木人工林生态学研究论文集,中国科学院林业土壤研究所,1980,143~151
    9 方奇,杉木连栽对土壤肥力和林木生长的影响,林业科学,1987,23(4):389~397
    10 陈伦祥,融水县回荣公社杉木连栽对林木生长及与土壤肥力的影响,广西林业勘察设计,1983(1):17~25
    11 邵锦锋,杉木连栽对土壤肥力和林木生长的影响,江西林业科技,1989,(6):1~6
    12 陈楚莹等,改善杉木人工林林地质量和提高生产力的研究,应用生态学报,1990,(2):97~106
    13 张其水等,连栽杉木生长状况的调查研究,福建林学院学报,1992,12(3):334~338
    14 周学金,罗汝英,叶镜中,杉木连栽对土壤养分的影响及其反馈,南京林业大学学报,1991,15(3):44~49
    15 杨承栋等,杉木连栽地土壤组成结构、性质变化及其对杉木生长的影响.林业科学.1996,32(2):175~181
    16 张其水等,杉木连栽林地土壤酶的分布特征研究,福建林学院学报,1990,10(4):377~387
    17 刘有美,杉木营林与土壤退化,中国土壤退化及防治研究论文集,北京:中国林业出版社,1990,32~37
    18 杨玉盛等,论炼山对杉木人工林生态系统影响的利弊及对策,自然资源学报,1997,11(2)
    19 Ding Yingxiang and Chen Jinlin, Effeets of continuous plantation of Chinese fir on soil fertility, Pedosphere, 5(1):57~66
    20 俞元春,姜志林,苏南丘陵杉木人工林营养元素生物循环的研究,南京林业大学学报,1991,15(增刊):20~26
    21 俞元春,阮宏华,费世民,苏南丘陵森林生态系统凋落物量及养分归还量,见:姜志林主编,下蜀森林生态系统定位研究论文集,北京:中国林业出版社,1992,50~55
    22 李昌华,杉木人工林和阔叶杂木林养分元素平衡差异的初步研究,土壤学报,1981,118(3):255~261
    23 沈国舫,对世界造林发展新趋势的几点看法,世界林业研究,1988,1(1):21~27
    24 盛炜彤,我国人工林的土地退化与防治,中国土地退化防治研究,北京:中国科学技术出版社,1990:471~474
    25 盛炜彤,我国人工林地力衰退及防治对策,人工林地力衰退研究,北京:中国科学技术出版社,1992,15~19
    26 徐化成,森林地力的动态特性和人工林地力下降问题,人工林地力衰退研究,北京:中国科学技术出版社,1992:3~10
    27 朱守谦等,人工林地力衰退的原因及解决对策,人工林地力衰退研究,北京:中国科学技术出版社,1992:31~36
    28 姚茂和,人工林地力衰退问题,人工林地力衰退研究,北京:中国科学技术出版社,1992:27~30
    29 何智英等,杉木连栽林地力衰退问题的研究,人工林地力衰退研究,北京:中国科学技术出版社,1992:243~250
    30 马祥庆等,人工林地力衰退研究综述,南京林业大学学报,1997(2):77~82
    31 李贻铨主编,林木施肥与营养专刊,林业科学研究,1996,9卷
    32 李贻铨,林木施肥是短周期工业用材林的基础技术措施,林业科学研究,1992,5(2):214~218
    33 崔国发,人工林地力衰退机理及其防治对策,世界林业研究,1996,(5):61~68
    34 俞新妥,杉木人工林地力衰退和养分循环研究进展,福建林学院学报,1992,12(3):264~275
    35 徐化成,关于人工林的地力衰退问题,世界林业研究,1992(1):66~71
    36 赵其国等,人类活动与土壤退化,中国土地退化防治研究,北京:中国科学出版社,1990:1~6
    37 徐汝佳,安徽杉木林地力衰退原因探讨,安徽林业科技,1987,(1):6~10
    38 李建民,福建省人工林针叶纯林地力衰退与持续发展的对策,浙江林学院学报,1995,12(3):286~292
    39 杨玉盛,杉木林经营模式及可持续利用的研究,南京林业大学博士学位论文,1997
    40 罗汝英,俞元春等,杉林土壤的肥力变化(鉴定材料),南京林业大学,1996
    41 徐化成,林业的目标、原则和发展道路,世界林业研究,1991,4(1),29~34
    42 沈国舫,集约育林—世界林业研究的主要课题,国际林联第十九届世界大会论文集,北京:中国林业出版社,1991,12~19
    43 沈国舫,对发展我国丰产林有关问题的思孝,世界林业研究,1992,5(4):67~74
    44 盛炜彤等,我国人工用材林发展中的生态问题及防治对策,世界林业研究,1995,B(2)
    45 盛炜彤,我国森林培育学发展和战略研究,世界林业研究,1994,7(10):73~78
    46 J. Evans. Long-term Productivity of Forest Plntations-status in 1990, IUFRO, the 19th world congress proceedings. division 1, volume 1, 1990
    47 Yasushi Morikawa. Forest Decline in Japan: Nature Cryptomeria japonica Decline in the kanto-Main. IUFRO, the 19th world congress proceedings, division 1, volume 2,1990
    48 Patrian. Soil degradation in north eastern hill region of India-an overview, Indian For., 1995, 121(4):262~272
    49 Michael T. Physiological, structural, and nutritional parzameters of Norway spruce needles form declining forest stands in Austrila. Can. J. For. Res. 1996,26(10),1769~1780
    50 J. P. Kimmins. Forest Ecology. New York. Macmi Uan Publishing com., 1987
    51 FAO. Land Degradation. Rome, 1971
    52 R. F. Huttle. France and Nordic Countries. Paper Read before the Fertilizer society of London on 11th, December 1986
    53 Weidmann, et al., Trees, 1990, (4):68~74
    54 马祥庆,杉木人工林长期生产力维持研究,南京林业大学博士学位论文,1998
    55 李范五等,德意志民主共和国,捷克斯洛伐克共和国林业考察报告,林业出版社,1958
    56 A. Keeves. Some Evidence of loss of Produtivity with Successive Rotations of Pinus radiato in south east of Austrlia, Australion Forestry, 1996,(30):51~63
    57 R. Boardman. Productivity under Suuessive Rotations of Radiation Pine. Australian Forestry, 1978, 41 (3): 177~179
    58 中国林学会森林生态学分会,杉林人工林集约栽培研究专题组。人工林地力衰退研究,北京:中国科学技术出版社
    59 陈乃全等,落叶松人工林重茬更新效果研究,造林学论文集,北京:中国林业出版社,1990:105~113
    60 陈超凡,广西港口镇海砂地生态耕与木麻黄生质量的研究,热带地理,1990,10(2):125~131
    61 叶功富等,木麻黄连栽林地土壤肥力动态与地力维持,防护林科技(沿海木麻黄防护更新改造技术研究专辑),1996(专):49~53
    62 林平等,柳杉连栽林地土壤各肥力特征,浙江林学院学报,1994,11(2):138~142
    63 沈照仁,人工造林与持续经营,世界林业研究,1994(4)。8~13
    64 林业经济研究(日刊),1991,(11):10~17
    65 林野厅计画课,国森林资源现况会后森林整备方向,林野时报,1992,8:2-4
    66 FAO. Mixed and pure forest plantations in the tropics and subtrpics,1992
    67 Evans J., L wood P. J. The place of plantation in tropical forestry. IFU. 1993, (5):3~5
    68 冯宗炜等,杉木人工林生长发育与环境相互关系的定位研究,杉木人工林生态系统研究论文集,1980:10~30
    69 俞新妥,张其水,杉木连栽林地土壤生化特性及土壤肥力研究,福建林学院学报,1989,9(3):263~271
    70 俞新妥,中国杉木的研究,福建林学院学报,1988,6(37):203~220
    71 俞新妥,杉木林地持续利用问题的研究和看法,世界林业研究,1993,(2):80~85
    72 洪元程,杉木连栽地肥力变化对幼林生长的影响,福建林学院研究生硕士学位论文,1995
    73 YU YUAN-CHUN and ZHANG HUAN-CHAO. Effects of Different Types Chinese Fir Stands on Nutrient Status of Soils. PEDOSPHERE, 1995 5(1):45~55
    74 潘维俦等,杉木人工林养分循环研究,中南林学院学报,1981,1(1):1~15
    75 冯宗炜等,亚热带杉木纯林生态系统中营养元素的积累、分配和循环的研究,植物生态学与地植物学丛刊,1985,9(4):246~253
    76 邓仁坚等,杉木老龄人工林生物产量和营养元素含量分布,生态学杂志,1988,7(1):13~18
    77 熊毅,李庆逵,中国土壤(第二版),北京:科学出版社,1990
    78 马越强等,连栽土壤对杉木幼苗生长影响的研究,生态学杂志,1997,16(6):12~16
    79 叶镜中,邵锦峰,炼山对土壤理化性质的影响,南京林业大学学报,1990,14(1):1~7
    80 马祥庆等,不同林地清理方式对杉木人工林生态系统的影响,生态学报,1997,17(2):176~183
    81 马祥庆等,杉木世行贷款造林水土流失及土壤肥力监测,福建林学院学报,1996,16(1):71~74
    82 孙多,防止杉木林地力衰退的途径—残留物管理育林法,南京林业大学博士学位论文,1996
    83 杨承栋等,发展林下植被是恢复杉木人工林地力的重要途径,林业科学,1995,31(3)
    84 张先仪,邓宗付,李旭明,间伐杉木林下植被演替和水土,保持影响的研究,人工林地力衰退研究,北京:中国科学技术出版社,1992,168~180
    85 张先仪,盛炜彤等,杉木幼林不同培育方法的效果分析,见:盛炜彤主编,杉木建筑材优化栽培模式研究,世界林业研究,1996,9(专集),86~95
    86 孙多,王福升等,“栽杉保阔”育林法的效果分析,见:盛炜彤主编。杉木建筑材优化栽培模式的研究—世界林业研究,1996,9(专集),207~214
    87 张其水等,杉木连栽林地营造混交林后土壤生化特性及土壤肥力的研究,福建林学陆院学报,1990,10(3):197~205
    88 陈炳浩,我国人工林土地退化的现状、原因与防治对策,人工林地力衰退研究,北京:中国科学技术出版社,1992,20~26
    89 杉木施肥试验课题协作组,杉木幼林施肥效应研究,人工林地力衰退研究,北京:中国科 学技术出版社,1992:198~211
    90 杉木施肥试验课题协作组,杉木中龄林施肥效应研究,人工林地力衰退研究,北京:中国科学技术出版社,1992,212~222
    91 杉木施肥试验课题协作组,杉木近熟林施肥效应研究,人工林地力衰退研究,北京:中国科学技术出版社,1992,223~238
    92 陈道东,李贻铨等,花岗岩立地上杉木幼林施肥生长效应研究,林业科学研究,林木施肥与营养专刊,1996,9(MEM):34~40
    93 J库姆斯(丘国维译),生物生产力和光合作用测定技术,北京:科学出版社,1986,21~25
    94 木村允著(姜恕、陈乃全等译)陆地植物群落的生产量测定法,北京:科学出版社,1981
    95 冯宗炜,湖南会同地区马尾松林生物量的研究,林业科学,1982,18(2):127~134
    96 Satoo T.产量法研究综述,植物生态学译丛,1974,(1):26~39
    97 Monsi M.植物群落的数学模型,植物生态学译丛,1974,(1):123~144
    98 叶镜中、姜志林等,福建省洋口林场杉木林生物量的年变化动态,南京林业大学学报,1984,(4):1~9
    99 叶镜中,姜志林,苏南丘陵杉木人工林的生物量结构,生态学报,1983,3(1):7~13.
    100 范少辉,俞新妥等,不同立地条件不同林龄杉木人工林生物量的研究,杉木人工林栽培营养的研究专刊,1996,9(MEM):78~85
    101 福建林学院杉木研究所,尤溪县林业技术推广中心,炼山对杉木人工林生态系统影响的研究,人工林地力衰退研究,北京:中国科学技术出版社,1992,108~129
    102 中国科学院南京土壤研究所,土壤理化分析,上海:上海科学技术出版社,1978
    103 中国土壤学会农业化学专业委员会编,土壤农业化学常规分析方法,北京:科学出版社,1983
    104 刘光崧主编,土壤理化分析与剖面描述,北京:中国标准出版社,1986
    105 国家标准局,森林土壤分析分法,北京:科学出版社,1986
    106 许光辉等,土壤微生物分析方法手册,北京:农业出版社,1986
    107 L.D.贝费尔等著(周传槐译),土壤物理学,北京:科学出版社 1983
    108 罗汝英,森林土壤学(问题与方法),北京:科学出版社,1983
    109 罗汝英主编,土壤学,北京:中国林业出版社,1992
    110 陈恩凤编著,土壤肥力物资基础及其应用调控,北京:科学出版社,1990
    111 李庆逵,中国红壤,北京:科学出版社,1983
    112 Comeau P. G. et al. Above-and-below-ground biomass and production of lodgpole pine on sites with differing soil moisture regimes. Can. J. For. Res., 1989,19:477~454
    113 Persson H. The distribution and productivity of fine roots in boreal forests, plant and Soil 1983, 71:87~101
    114 赵其国等,我国热带亚热带森林凋落物及其对土壤的影响,土壤:1991,23(1):8~15
    115 吴志东等,长白山阔叶红松林细根周转的研究,应用生态学报,1993,4(3):241~245
    116 Lynch, J. M. The Rhizosphere, John wiley, Chichester, 1990
    117 lynch J. M. et. al., Substrate flow in the rhizophere, plant and Soil. 1990,129(1):1~10
    118 Martin R. Contribution of rhizosphere to the maintenance and growth of soil microbial biomass Soil Biol. Biochem, 1990, 22(20):141~147
    119 张福锁主编,土壤与植物营养研究新动态(第三卷)北京:中国农业出版社,1995
    120 蒋秋怡、叶仲节等,杉木根际土壤特性的研究,(Ⅰ)杉木根际与非根际土壤化学性质的比较研究,浙江林学院出版社,1990,7(2):122~126
    121 蒋秋怡、叶仲节等,杉木根际土壤特性的研究,(Ⅱ)杉木根际的生物化学特性,浙江林学院学报,1991,8(4):450~456
    122 姜培坤,蒋秋怡等,杉木檫树根际土壤有机化合物研究,浙江林学院学报,1994,11(3):235~240
    123 周崇莲等,杉木人工林土壤微生物学特性的研究,杉木人工林生态系统研究论文集,1980:128~(4)。
    124 许曼丽等,土壤—根系微区养分状况的研究,Ⅰ.微钾玻璃电极的应用,土壤学报,1982,19(3):367~374
    125 许曼丽等,土壤—根系微区养分状况的研究,Ⅱ.钾离子的富集与亏缺,土壤学报,1983,20(3):295~302
    126 俞元春,曾曙才等,赣东北低山区森林土壤生态系统中的微量元素研究,江西科学,1998,16(2):97~103
    127 俞元春,曾曙才,罗汝英,江南丘陵林区森林土壤微量元素的含量与分布,安徽农业大学学报,1998,25(2),167~173
    128 刘铮,朱其清等,我国缺乏微量元素的土壤及其区域分布,土壤学报,1982,19(3):209~223
    129 杨承栋,屠星南,姚茂和等,杉木林下植被对改良土壤理化、生物特性的效用.人工林地力衰退研究。北京:中国科学技术出版社,1992,276~283
    130 姚茂和,盛炜彤,熊有强等,林下植被对杉木林地力影响的研究,林业科学研究,1991,4(3):246~253
    131 Cajander, A. K.,1926,The Thery of Forest Types, Acla. Fcnn,2(3):1~108
    132 R.H.惠特克,1978,(周纪纶等译,1985)植物群落分类.科学出版社,60~81
    133 姚茂和,盛炜彤,熊有强,杉木人工林林下植被对立地的指示意义。林业科学,1992,28(3):208~212
    134 姚茂和,盛炜彤,熊有强,杉木林下植被及其生物量的研究,林业科学,1991,27(6):644~647
    135 [美]M.亚历山大著(广西农学院农业微生物教研组译)土壤微生物学导论。北京:科学 出版社.1983
    136 许光辉等,长白山北坡自然保护区森林土壤微生物生态分布及其生化特性的研究,生态学报,1984 4(3):207~222
    137 董愚得,潘瑞炽主编,植物生理学,北京高等教育出版社,1984
    138 俞元春等,施磷肥对杉木幼林生物量和P素含量及贮量的影响,林业科学研究,1996 9(Mem):75~80
    139 宇万太、陈欣等,不同施肥杨树主要营养元素内外循环比较研究,应用生态学报,1995,6(4):341~348
    140 Teng Y. and Timmer V. R. Phosphorus-induced micronutrient disorders in hybrid poplar. Plant and Soil, 1990, 126, 19~51.
    141 Van den Driessche, R., Mineral nutrition ofconiferseedlings. CRC Press. 1991, 113~134.
    142 Haase, D. L. and Rose R. 1995, Vector analysis and its use for interpreting plant nutrient shifts in response to silviculture treatments, Forest Solis. 41: 54~66
    143 Timmer, V. R. and Morrow, L. D. 1984, Predicting growth response and nutrient status of Jack pine by foliage diagnosis. In E. L. Stone, ed. Forest Soils and treatment impacts, Proe. 6th North Am. For. Soil Conf. 335~351, Knoxville, TN.
    144 Timmer V. R. and Stone E. L. Comparative foliage analysis of young balsam fir fertilized with nitrogen, phosphorus, potassium and lime, Soil Sci. Am. J. 1978, 42: 125~130.
    145 Timmer, V. R. and Armstrong, G. Diagnosing nutritional status of containerized tree seedlings: comparative plant analysis, Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 1987, 51: 1082~1086.
    146 Weetman, G. F. and Fournier, R. Graphical digagnoses of lodgepole pine response to fertilization, Soil. Sci. Soc. Am. J. 1982
    147 俞元春等,杉木幼林磷肥利用率的研究,南京林业大学学报,1997,21(1):33~36
    148 杨玉盛等,人工阔叶林取代格氏栲天然林后土壤肥力变化的研究,东北林业大学学报,1993,21(5):14~21
    149 范少辉主编,杉木人工林栽培营养的研究专刊.林业科学研究,1996,9卷

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700