病窦综合征人工心脏起搏器植入术围手术期中医证候规律研究
|
摘要
目的:
研究病窦综合征人工心脏起搏器植入术围手术期的中医证型分布规律,分析中医证型与性别、年龄、病程等一般情况之间的关系,分析术前中医证型与原发病之间的关系,分析手术前后中医证型变化规律,分析术前中医证型与术后疗效的关系,从而有助于提高病窦综合征人工心脏起搏器围手术期中医辨证预后判断的准确性和规范性,提高临床治疗效果。
方法:
本课题调查广东省中医院2003年1月到2008年1月住院确诊病窦综合征并行人工心脏起搏器植入术的病人,共128例。所有资料从广东省中医院病案室的病例管理系统中查询得出。所有病例均详细了解病史,从记录的病例资料中于术前采集四诊资料,填写中医证候观察表,进行辨证,术后第三天采集四诊资料,填写中医证候观察表,进行辨证和症状疗效判断。统计128例病窦综合征人工心脏起搏器植入术患者各中医证型的出现频率,分析各种证型与一般情况的关系、与病窦综合征原发病的关系、与植入起搏器的关系,以及各种证型与疗效的关系。数据处理和统计学分析采用PSS13.0统计软件包进行分析,计量资料采用方差检验,计数资料采用卡方检验。
结果:
128例患者中,术前心气不足型30例、脾肾阳虚型28例、心阴亏虚型22例、阳虚瘀阻型28例、痰浊痹阻型20例,术后心气不足型12例、脾肾阳虚型24例、心阴亏虚型33例、阳虚瘀阻型25例、痰浊痹阻型34例。患者术前术后各中医证型组间性别行卡方检验,P＞0.05;患者术前术后各中医证型的平均年龄、平均病程间分别用方差检验,P＞0.05;患者术前的中医证型与原发病因间行卡方检验,P＞0.05;患者术前术后的中医证型之间行卡方检验,P＜0.01;患者术前各中医证型组间术后有效率行卡方检验,P＞0.05,但术前心气不足型、阳虚瘀阻型术后愈显率与术前脾肾阳虚、心阴亏虚、痰浊瘀阻术后愈显率比较经卡方检验,P＜0.05;
结论:
病窦综合征人工心脏起搏器植入术患者的中医证型的分布规律与患者的性别、年龄、病程无关;病窦综合征人工心脏起搏器植入术患者原发病因中以冠心病为主,本研究表明病窦综合征合并冠心病患者术前的中医证型以脾肾阳虚、心气不足、阳虚瘀阻为多,其它病因在本研究中的病例数较少,每个证型中的例数更少,意义不大;术前术后的中医证型比较有显著性差异,术前以心气不足、脾肾阳虚、阳虚瘀阻为主,术后则以心阴亏虚、痰浊痹阻为主,其中以心气不足型较术前明显减少,心阴亏虚型与痰浊痹阻型较术前有所增多,这可能与起搏器所起的作用,相当于中医“鼓舞心阳、补益心气”的作用,故对术后心气不足型明显减少,而气行则血行,故起搏器也能起到“化瘀通脉”的作用,故术后阳虚瘀阻型也有一定的减少;但起搏器相对人体毕竟为异物,且起搏器植入的过程为手术伤津耗气,故术后心阴亏虚型有所增多,加上外邪入侵,外邪引动内邪,故术后痰浊痹阻型有所增多;术前中医证型与术后疗效关系比较,表明术前证型为心气不足型和阳虚瘀阻型的术后愈显率较术前为脾肾阳虚型、心阴亏虚型和痰浊瘀阻型的术后愈显率高,但各术前中医证型与术后总有效率比较无显著性差异,这可能也与起搏器所起的作用,相当于中医的“鼓舞心阳、补益心气”,提高了心主血脉的功能,使脉来迟缓、心悸气短等心气虚的症状得到明显的改善,故对心气不足型疗效最为明显;而气行则血行,故起搏器也能起到“化瘀通脉”的作用,对阳虚瘀阻型的作用也较为明显;本病病位在心,故起搏器起到的鼓舞心阳、补益心气对各种证型导致的心阳、心气亏虚,心脉不通等均有疗效,本研究观察表明起搏器对心阴亏虚型和脾肾阳虚型及痰浊痹阻型也有效,也可能是通过该作用实现的。
Objective:
TO research the rule of perioperative TCM syndrome in the patients with sick sinus syndrome Implanting artificial cardiac pacemaker,and analyse the relationship between perioperative TCM syndrome and gender、age、course of diseases,the TCM syndrome before operation and primary disease,the change rule of TCM syndrome before and after operation,the TCM syndrome before operation and the effect after operation,in order to enhance the veracity and standardization of the clinical TCM analyse and estimating prognosis, and to enhance the clinical cure effect.
Method:
This subject survery the patients in Guangdong Province hospital of TCM from January 2003 to January 2008 diagnosed sick sinus syndrome implantation artificial cardiac pacemaker,a total of 128 cases.All the information get from the case management system in the medical record room of the Guangdong Provincial Chinese medicine hospital.All cases were detailedly realized medical history,collection the four symptom information at one day before surgery,fill out the observation forms of Chinese medicine syndrome, discerning the TCM Syndrome,four day after surgery gathering information to fill in TCM Syndrome Watcblist,discerning the TCM Syndrome and judging the effect.Statistics 128 cases of sick sinus syndrome artificial pacemaker implantation in patients with the TCM-frequency,and the analysis of the various syndromes of the general situation of relations with sick sinus syndrome incidence of the original,with the implantation of pacing The relationship,as well as various cards and the effect of the relationship. Data processing and statistical analysis using SPSS13.0 statistical analysis package,the measurement data used variance test,counting card information using the test.
Result:
In 128 patients,before operation,the deficiency of heart-QI is 30,the spleen kidney yan-deficiency is 28,the heart yin-deficiency is 22,the yan-deficiency blood- Stagnation is 28,the turbid phlegm Stagnation is 20, and after operation,the deficiency of heart-QI is 12,the spleen kidney yan-deficiency is 24,the heart yin-deficiency is 33,yan-deficiency bloodStagnation is 25,the turbid phlegm Stagnation is 34.The result of Chi-square test between the genders in each perioperative TCM syndrome is P＞0.05;The analysis of variance between the age and course of diseases in each perioperative TCM syndrome is P＞0.05;The result of Chi-square test between each TCM syndrome before operation in primary disease is P＞0.05;The result of Chi-square test between the TCM syndrome before and after operation is P＜0.01;The result of Chi-square test between each effective rate in each TCM syndrome is P＞0.05,but the result of Chi-square test between recovery excellence rate of the deficiency of heart-QI、the yan-deficiency blood-Stagnation and the spleen kidney yan-deficiency、the heart yin-deficiency、the turbid phlegm Stagnation is P＜0.05;
Conclusion:
There is no interrelation between the TCM syndrome and gender、age、course of diseases;The patients with sick sinus syndrome Implanting artificial cardiac pacemaker due to coronary heart disease in the main,this study shows that sick sinus syndrome patients with coronary heart disease before operation of the TCM to the spleen kidney yan-deficiency,the deficiency of heart-QI, the yan-deficiency blood-Stagnation,the number of other causes in this study is less,in each card even less,not very meaningful.There is significant difference between the TCM syndrome before and after operation;There is mainly to the deficiency of heart-QI、the spleen kidney yah-deficiency、the yah-deficiency blood-Stagnation before operation;There is mainly to the heart yin-deficiency and the turbid phlegm hinder after operation,While the deficiency of heart-QI is reducely and the heart yin-deficiency、the turbid phlegm Stagnation is increasedly comparing that of before operation,This may be related to the role played by the pacemaker,equivalent the TCM effect of "heart-yan inspired,heart-qi replenishing",so the deficiency of heart-QI after surgery significantly reduce,and the gas lines with the blood lines, pacemaker also have the effect of Huayu Tongmai,so the yah-deficiency blood-Stagnation after operation also difinitely reduce;But the pacemaker is foreign body relative to the human body,the surgery implanting the pacemaker have the effect of Injury-gas consumption,so the heart yin-deficiency after operation definitely manifold,plus waixie intrusion,waixie arose neixie,so the turbid phlegm Stagnation after operation definitely manifold;by compare the curative effect after operation between each TCM syndrome before operation, it is more recovery excellence rate in the deficiency of heart-QI and the heart-yan hinder before operation than that in the spleen kidney yan-deficiency、the heart yin-deficiency and the turbid phlegm hinder before operation,but there is no Significant difference in the effective rate after operation between each TCM syndrome before operation,This may be related to the role played by the pacemaker,equivalent the TCM effect of "heart-yan inspired,heart-qi replenishing",improve the effect of the heart dominating blood,and amend the heart-QI deficiency symptom of blood stream slowing heart-throb breathe hard,So the curative effect of the deficiency of heart-QI is very evidence,and the gas lines with the blood lines,pacemaker also have the effect of Huayu Tongmai,so the effect to the yan-deficiency blood-Stagnation is also obviously evidence;the focus of the disease is in the heart,so the effect of heart-yah inspired,heart-qi replenishing by the pacemaker also have effect to the deficiency of heart-QI and the heart-yan and heart-pluse illogical,This subject make know that pacemaker have effect to the spleen kidney yan-deficiency and the heart yin-deficiency and the turbid phlegm Stagnation,it may be according this effect.
研究病窦综合征人工心脏起搏器植入术围手术期的中医证型分布规律,分析中医证型与性别、年龄、病程等一般情况之间的关系,分析术前中医证型与原发病之间的关系,分析手术前后中医证型变化规律,分析术前中医证型与术后疗效的关系,从而有助于提高病窦综合征人工心脏起搏器围手术期中医辨证预后判断的准确性和规范性,提高临床治疗效果。
方法:
本课题调查广东省中医院2003年1月到2008年1月住院确诊病窦综合征并行人工心脏起搏器植入术的病人,共128例。所有资料从广东省中医院病案室的病例管理系统中查询得出。所有病例均详细了解病史,从记录的病例资料中于术前采集四诊资料,填写中医证候观察表,进行辨证,术后第三天采集四诊资料,填写中医证候观察表,进行辨证和症状疗效判断。统计128例病窦综合征人工心脏起搏器植入术患者各中医证型的出现频率,分析各种证型与一般情况的关系、与病窦综合征原发病的关系、与植入起搏器的关系,以及各种证型与疗效的关系。数据处理和统计学分析采用PSS13.0统计软件包进行分析,计量资料采用方差检验,计数资料采用卡方检验。
结果:
128例患者中,术前心气不足型30例、脾肾阳虚型28例、心阴亏虚型22例、阳虚瘀阻型28例、痰浊痹阻型20例,术后心气不足型12例、脾肾阳虚型24例、心阴亏虚型33例、阳虚瘀阻型25例、痰浊痹阻型34例。患者术前术后各中医证型组间性别行卡方检验,P＞0.05;患者术前术后各中医证型的平均年龄、平均病程间分别用方差检验,P＞0.05;患者术前的中医证型与原发病因间行卡方检验,P＞0.05;患者术前术后的中医证型之间行卡方检验,P＜0.01;患者术前各中医证型组间术后有效率行卡方检验,P＞0.05,但术前心气不足型、阳虚瘀阻型术后愈显率与术前脾肾阳虚、心阴亏虚、痰浊瘀阻术后愈显率比较经卡方检验,P＜0.05;
结论:
病窦综合征人工心脏起搏器植入术患者的中医证型的分布规律与患者的性别、年龄、病程无关;病窦综合征人工心脏起搏器植入术患者原发病因中以冠心病为主,本研究表明病窦综合征合并冠心病患者术前的中医证型以脾肾阳虚、心气不足、阳虚瘀阻为多,其它病因在本研究中的病例数较少,每个证型中的例数更少,意义不大;术前术后的中医证型比较有显著性差异,术前以心气不足、脾肾阳虚、阳虚瘀阻为主,术后则以心阴亏虚、痰浊痹阻为主,其中以心气不足型较术前明显减少,心阴亏虚型与痰浊痹阻型较术前有所增多,这可能与起搏器所起的作用,相当于中医“鼓舞心阳、补益心气”的作用,故对术后心气不足型明显减少,而气行则血行,故起搏器也能起到“化瘀通脉”的作用,故术后阳虚瘀阻型也有一定的减少;但起搏器相对人体毕竟为异物,且起搏器植入的过程为手术伤津耗气,故术后心阴亏虚型有所增多,加上外邪入侵,外邪引动内邪,故术后痰浊痹阻型有所增多;术前中医证型与术后疗效关系比较,表明术前证型为心气不足型和阳虚瘀阻型的术后愈显率较术前为脾肾阳虚型、心阴亏虚型和痰浊瘀阻型的术后愈显率高,但各术前中医证型与术后总有效率比较无显著性差异,这可能也与起搏器所起的作用,相当于中医的“鼓舞心阳、补益心气”,提高了心主血脉的功能,使脉来迟缓、心悸气短等心气虚的症状得到明显的改善,故对心气不足型疗效最为明显;而气行则血行,故起搏器也能起到“化瘀通脉”的作用,对阳虚瘀阻型的作用也较为明显;本病病位在心,故起搏器起到的鼓舞心阳、补益心气对各种证型导致的心阳、心气亏虚,心脉不通等均有疗效,本研究观察表明起搏器对心阴亏虚型和脾肾阳虚型及痰浊痹阻型也有效,也可能是通过该作用实现的。
Objective:
TO research the rule of perioperative TCM syndrome in the patients with sick sinus syndrome Implanting artificial cardiac pacemaker,and analyse the relationship between perioperative TCM syndrome and gender、age、course of diseases,the TCM syndrome before operation and primary disease,the change rule of TCM syndrome before and after operation,the TCM syndrome before operation and the effect after operation,in order to enhance the veracity and standardization of the clinical TCM analyse and estimating prognosis, and to enhance the clinical cure effect.
Method:
This subject survery the patients in Guangdong Province hospital of TCM from January 2003 to January 2008 diagnosed sick sinus syndrome implantation artificial cardiac pacemaker,a total of 128 cases.All the information get from the case management system in the medical record room of the Guangdong Provincial Chinese medicine hospital.All cases were detailedly realized medical history,collection the four symptom information at one day before surgery,fill out the observation forms of Chinese medicine syndrome, discerning the TCM Syndrome,four day after surgery gathering information to fill in TCM Syndrome Watcblist,discerning the TCM Syndrome and judging the effect.Statistics 128 cases of sick sinus syndrome artificial pacemaker implantation in patients with the TCM-frequency,and the analysis of the various syndromes of the general situation of relations with sick sinus syndrome incidence of the original,with the implantation of pacing The relationship,as well as various cards and the effect of the relationship. Data processing and statistical analysis using SPSS13.0 statistical analysis package,the measurement data used variance test,counting card information using the test.
Result:
In 128 patients,before operation,the deficiency of heart-QI is 30,the spleen kidney yan-deficiency is 28,the heart yin-deficiency is 22,the yan-deficiency blood- Stagnation is 28,the turbid phlegm Stagnation is 20, and after operation,the deficiency of heart-QI is 12,the spleen kidney yan-deficiency is 24,the heart yin-deficiency is 33,yan-deficiency bloodStagnation is 25,the turbid phlegm Stagnation is 34.The result of Chi-square test between the genders in each perioperative TCM syndrome is P＞0.05;The analysis of variance between the age and course of diseases in each perioperative TCM syndrome is P＞0.05;The result of Chi-square test between each TCM syndrome before operation in primary disease is P＞0.05;The result of Chi-square test between the TCM syndrome before and after operation is P＜0.01;The result of Chi-square test between each effective rate in each TCM syndrome is P＞0.05,but the result of Chi-square test between recovery excellence rate of the deficiency of heart-QI、the yan-deficiency blood-Stagnation and the spleen kidney yan-deficiency、the heart yin-deficiency、the turbid phlegm Stagnation is P＜0.05;
Conclusion:
There is no interrelation between the TCM syndrome and gender、age、course of diseases;The patients with sick sinus syndrome Implanting artificial cardiac pacemaker due to coronary heart disease in the main,this study shows that sick sinus syndrome patients with coronary heart disease before operation of the TCM to the spleen kidney yan-deficiency,the deficiency of heart-QI, the yan-deficiency blood-Stagnation,the number of other causes in this study is less,in each card even less,not very meaningful.There is significant difference between the TCM syndrome before and after operation;There is mainly to the deficiency of heart-QI、the spleen kidney yah-deficiency、the yah-deficiency blood-Stagnation before operation;There is mainly to the heart yin-deficiency and the turbid phlegm hinder after operation,While the deficiency of heart-QI is reducely and the heart yin-deficiency、the turbid phlegm Stagnation is increasedly comparing that of before operation,This may be related to the role played by the pacemaker,equivalent the TCM effect of "heart-yan inspired,heart-qi replenishing",so the deficiency of heart-QI after surgery significantly reduce,and the gas lines with the blood lines, pacemaker also have the effect of Huayu Tongmai,so the yah-deficiency blood-Stagnation after operation also difinitely reduce;But the pacemaker is foreign body relative to the human body,the surgery implanting the pacemaker have the effect of Injury-gas consumption,so the heart yin-deficiency after operation definitely manifold,plus waixie intrusion,waixie arose neixie,so the turbid phlegm Stagnation after operation definitely manifold;by compare the curative effect after operation between each TCM syndrome before operation, it is more recovery excellence rate in the deficiency of heart-QI and the heart-yan hinder before operation than that in the spleen kidney yan-deficiency、the heart yin-deficiency and the turbid phlegm hinder before operation,but there is no Significant difference in the effective rate after operation between each TCM syndrome before operation,This may be related to the role played by the pacemaker,equivalent the TCM effect of "heart-yan inspired,heart-qi replenishing",improve the effect of the heart dominating blood,and amend the heart-QI deficiency symptom of blood stream slowing heart-throb breathe hard,So the curative effect of the deficiency of heart-QI is very evidence,and the gas lines with the blood lines,pacemaker also have the effect of Huayu Tongmai,so the effect to the yan-deficiency blood-Stagnation is also obviously evidence;the focus of the disease is in the heart,so the effect of heart-yah inspired,heart-qi replenishing by the pacemaker also have effect to the deficiency of heart-QI and the heart-yan and heart-pluse illogical,This subject make know that pacemaker have effect to the spleen kidney yan-deficiency and the heart yin-deficiency and the turbid phlegm Stagnation,it may be according this effect.
引文
[1]陈元禄,黄体钢,王志毅,等.加味炙甘草汤注射液治疗病态窦房结综合征的电生理研究.中国中西医结合急救杂志,2000,7(2):78-81.
[2]席时芳,程薇,施雪筠,等.参仙升脉液十二指肠给药对兔病窦模型作用的实验观察.北京中医药大学学报,1999,22(4):34-36.
[3]霍根红.病窦康口服液治疗病态窦房结综合征的实验研究,河南中医,2002,22(1):27-28.
[4]吴黎明,叶昕涛,蓝玉福,等.兔右冠状动脉缺血预适应对窦房结功能及房室传导有效不应期的影响.中国心脏起搏与心电生理杂志,2000,14(4):257-259.
[5]李永华,宋治远,郭丽萍等,缺血再灌注对在体兔窦房结细胞凋亡影响的研究.中国心脏起搏与心电生理杂志,2002,16(6):456-459.
[6]李永华,宋治远,姚青,等.缺血再灌注对在体兔窦房结电生理功能的损伤研究.第三军医大学学报,2003,25(13):1161-1164.
[7]李永华,宋治远,姚青.缺血再灌注对在体兔窦房结细胞Fas-L Bax Bd-2基因表达的影响.心肺血管病杂志,2003。22(3):163-167.
[8]钟理,宋治远.模拟缺血一再灌注诱导原代培养乳鼠窦房结细胞凋亡的研究[N].第三军医大学学报,2001,23(1):59-61.
[9]张炎,凌凤东.卡托普利对培养大鼠窦房结细胞缺血损伤保护的形态学研究[N].第二军医大学学报,1999,20(3):176-178.
[10]仝识非,宋治远,钟理.模拟缺血一再灌注对窦房结细胞起搏离子流的影响及K -ATP通道开放剂的干预作用[J].中国心脏起搏与心电生理杂志,2002,16(3):205-207.
[11]仝识非,宋治远,钟理.K-ATP通道开放剂对模拟缺血一再灌注时培养乳鼠窦房结细胞的保护作用及机制探讨[J].中国心脏起搏与心电生理杂志,2002,16(5):372-37412.
[12]仝识非,宋治远,ATP敏感性钾通道开放剂对培养乳鼠窦房结细胞模拟缺血时细胞活性的影响[N].第三军医大学学报,2001,23(11):130B-1306.
[13]于苏国,张学俊,施利国,等.大鼠心脏窦房结区降钙素基因相关肽神经的分布及定量研究[N].滨州医学院学报,1997,20(1):7-8.
[14]王蓉,李爽,叶翠飞.降钙素基因相关肽对心脏异位移植大鼠心律的影响[N].首都医科大学学报,1996,17(4):277-279.
[15]钮伟真,高燕丽,刘萍.降钙素基因相关肽在豚鼠冠脉血流量和心脏传导系统作用的比较[N].生理学报,2000,52(3):259-262.
[16]郭连峰,钮伟真,焦晓慧.降钙素基因相关肽对家兔离体窦房结电生理活动的影 响[J].生理学报,2000,52(2):163-166.
[17]汪康平.病态窦房结综合征.心电学杂志,2003,22(5):198-204.
[18]杨承健.病态窦房结综合征94例临床分析.南通医学院学报,1997,17(2):197.
[19]王书来,苏同明,迟帅.病态窦房结综合征.职业与健康,2001年12月,17(2):160-162.
[20]曹冰,陈宇,李雅静.病态窦房结综合征49例临床分析.心血管康复医学杂志,1999,8(3):38-39.
[21]王新春.病窦综合征临床诊疗分析.医药论坛杂志,2006年10月,27(19):87-88.
[22]向春云,申喜莲.JOURNAL OF PRACTICAL ELECTROCARDIOLOGY,2007,16(2):91-92.
[23]申万红,刘子文,熊望琼.阿托品试验对病窦综合征诊断价值的再探讨.JOURNAL OF PRAC11CAL EU CIROCARD10I,2003,12(5):342-343.
[24]钱大为,耿戚,郑义等.阿托品试验对诊断病窦综合征相关性的评定.吉林医学信息,1993,4:7.
[25]陈凯.阿托品试验诊断病态窦房结综合征的价值.河北医学,2006,12(1):20-21.
[26]钱春丽,栗浩,曹东辉.动态心电图诊断病态窦房结综合征的价值.中国误诊学杂志,2007年10月,7(24):5752-5753.
[27]岑梅珠,黄林贤,胡志华.病态窦房结综合征患者的动态心电图特征.实用医学杂志,2007,23(3):401-402.
[28]努尔古丽,赵文丽.食管调搏对病窦综合征诊断的临床意义.心脏杂志,2004,16(4):392.
[29]丁丽,董少红,石丹.39例病窦综合征的食道调搏检查及临床意义.国际医药卫生导报,2003,9(5):33-34.
[30]齐平,田福利,郭继鸿,刘俊琳.心先安治疗病态窦房结综合征疗效观察.JOURNAL OF PRACTICAL ELECTROCARDIOLOGY,2007,16(1):21-22.
[31]张斌,曹波,陈新.心先安治疗病窦综合征34例疗效观察.中国现代医药杂志,2006年7月,8(7):25-26.
[32]陈金良,郭培英,韩凌,刘志明.环磷腺苷葡胺治疗冠心病病态窦房结综合征疗效观察.中国医院药学杂志,2006,26(2):184-185.
[33]陈维敏,谢琴.氨茶碱伍用心先安治疗病态窦房结综合征28例疗效观察.中华医学研究杂志,2006,6(6):625-626.
[34]张佩生,杨建峰,梁雪:起搏治疗对病窦综合征患者预后的影响:实用诊断与治疗杂志 2006年第20卷第10期 734-735
[35]王勇:病态窦房结综合征患者植入起搏器模式:实用医技杂志 2006年2月第13卷第四期
[36]夏平达.AAI和VVI起搏治疗病窦综合征的远期随访.哈尔滨医药 2009年第2D卷第3期:8-9
[37]杨栓锁,张全发,崔长琮.VVI和AAI起搏治疗病窦综合征的远期随访.中华心血管病杂志 2000年2月第28卷第1期.45-46
[38]Lamas GA,Orav EJ,Stambler BS,et al.Quality of life and clinical outcomes in elderly patients treated with ventricular pacing as compared with dual-chamber pacing[J].N Engl J Med,1998,338(16):1097-1104
[39]Lamas GA,Lee KL,Sweeney MD,et al.Ventricular pacing or dual-chamber pacing for sinus node dysfunction[J].N Engl J Med,2002,346(24):1854.1862
[40]Sweeney MO,Hellkamp AS,Ellenbogen KA,et al.Adverse effect of ventricular pacing on heart failure and atrial fibrillation among patients with normal base.line QRS duration in a clinical trial of pacemaker therapy for sinus node dysfunction[J].Circulation,2003,107(23):2932.2937.
[41]Sulke N,Chambers J,Dritsas A.et al.A randomized double,blind crossover comparison offour rate-responsive pacing modes[J].J Am Coil Cardiol,1991,17:696.
[42]Kristensen L,Nielsen JC,Mortensen PT,et al.Incidence of atrial fibrillation and thromboembolism in a randomised trial of atrial versus dual chamber pa.cing in 177 patients with sick sinus syndrome[J]Heart,2004,90(6):661-666
[43]Nielsen JC,Kristensen L,Andersen HR,et al.A randomized comparison of atri.al and dual-chamber pacing in 177 consecutive patients with sick sinus syn.drome:EchOcardiOgr phl and clinical outcome[J].J Am Coil Cardiol.2003.42(4):614 623
[44]崔长琮,王忠,马奕,等.人工心脏起搏的血液动力学研究进展[J].心脏起搏与心电生理杂志,1994,8(4):217
[45]陈德才.病窦灵治疗病窦综合征14例报告[J].南京医科大学学报,1994,14(4):538.
[46]姜燕,吴先奇,韩又云.病态窦房结综合征中医病机探讨[J].中医研究,2001,14(5):2-3.
[47]郑春雷.实用中西医疑难病学[M].北京:中医古籍出版社,2001:69
[48]张丽灵,张刚,郑丽萍,等.诊治病窦综合征经验[J].中国医药学 报,2002,17(3):178.
[49]江佑华.病态窦房结综合征辨证分型治疗[J].中医药学刊,2001,19(5):482.
[50]栾天竹,赵秀琴,韩迪.病态窦房结综合征的临床研究概况.中西医结合心脑血管病杂志 2005年11月第3卷第11期
[51]江佑华.病态窦房结综合征辨证分型治疗[J].中医药学刊,2001,19(5):482
[52]李宜方,杜焱.辨证治疗病态窦房结综合征[J].山东中医杂志,1999,18(6):255-256
[53]杨晓华.病态窦房结综合征辨治一则[J].甘肃中医,2002,15(3):31
[54]张霁生,吴俊贞.中医药治疗病窦综合征65例疗效观察[J].天津中医,2000,17(3):12-13 26
[55]王玉霞.病窦综合征的中医药治疗[J].天津中医,2001,18(3):51-52
[56]李春华,李延.温阳活血法治疗病窦综合征46例[J].中医药信息,2004,21(2):7
[57]张其梅.益气温阳活血法治疗病窦综合征32例[J].中国中医药信息杂志,2003,10(2):43-44
[58]马彪,李启芳.涤痰解毒,宣肃肺气法治疗病窦综舍征[J].吉林中医药,2004,24(8):23
[59]王庆余.复津汤治疗病窦综合征30例[J].山西职工医学院学报,2003,13(1):36
[60]孔令振.麻附细辛汤治疗病窦综合征的疗效观察[J].中国社区医师,2004,20(22):60
[61]刘德桓.通心络胶囊治疗病窦综合征的?临床观察[J]..中国中西医结合杂志,2001,21(11):858-859
[62]王秀琴,杨东,李连涛.温养通心胶囊治疗病窦综合征的机理研究[J].南宁中医药大学学报,2003,19(5):279-280
[63]黄天宫,王巧平.升率散治疗病窦综合征216例[J].辽宁中医杂志,2004,31(5):378-379
[64]范爱勤.复方苦参治疗病窦综合征[J].辽宁中医杂志,2003,30(2):133
[2]席时芳,程薇,施雪筠,等.参仙升脉液十二指肠给药对兔病窦模型作用的实验观察.北京中医药大学学报,1999,22(4):34-36.
[3]霍根红.病窦康口服液治疗病态窦房结综合征的实验研究,河南中医,2002,22(1):27-28.
[4]吴黎明,叶昕涛,蓝玉福,等.兔右冠状动脉缺血预适应对窦房结功能及房室传导有效不应期的影响.中国心脏起搏与心电生理杂志,2000,14(4):257-259.
[5]李永华,宋治远,郭丽萍等,缺血再灌注对在体兔窦房结细胞凋亡影响的研究.中国心脏起搏与心电生理杂志,2002,16(6):456-459.
[6]李永华,宋治远,姚青,等.缺血再灌注对在体兔窦房结电生理功能的损伤研究.第三军医大学学报,2003,25(13):1161-1164.
[7]李永华,宋治远,姚青.缺血再灌注对在体兔窦房结细胞Fas-L Bax Bd-2基因表达的影响.心肺血管病杂志,2003。22(3):163-167.
[8]钟理,宋治远.模拟缺血一再灌注诱导原代培养乳鼠窦房结细胞凋亡的研究[N].第三军医大学学报,2001,23(1):59-61.
[9]张炎,凌凤东.卡托普利对培养大鼠窦房结细胞缺血损伤保护的形态学研究[N].第二军医大学学报,1999,20(3):176-178.
[10]仝识非,宋治远,钟理.模拟缺血一再灌注对窦房结细胞起搏离子流的影响及K -ATP通道开放剂的干预作用[J].中国心脏起搏与心电生理杂志,2002,16(3):205-207.
[11]仝识非,宋治远,钟理.K-ATP通道开放剂对模拟缺血一再灌注时培养乳鼠窦房结细胞的保护作用及机制探讨[J].中国心脏起搏与心电生理杂志,2002,16(5):372-37412.
[12]仝识非,宋治远,ATP敏感性钾通道开放剂对培养乳鼠窦房结细胞模拟缺血时细胞活性的影响[N].第三军医大学学报,2001,23(11):130B-1306.
[13]于苏国,张学俊,施利国,等.大鼠心脏窦房结区降钙素基因相关肽神经的分布及定量研究[N].滨州医学院学报,1997,20(1):7-8.
[14]王蓉,李爽,叶翠飞.降钙素基因相关肽对心脏异位移植大鼠心律的影响[N].首都医科大学学报,1996,17(4):277-279.
[15]钮伟真,高燕丽,刘萍.降钙素基因相关肽在豚鼠冠脉血流量和心脏传导系统作用的比较[N].生理学报,2000,52(3):259-262.
[16]郭连峰,钮伟真,焦晓慧.降钙素基因相关肽对家兔离体窦房结电生理活动的影 响[J].生理学报,2000,52(2):163-166.
[17]汪康平.病态窦房结综合征.心电学杂志,2003,22(5):198-204.
[18]杨承健.病态窦房结综合征94例临床分析.南通医学院学报,1997,17(2):197.
[19]王书来,苏同明,迟帅.病态窦房结综合征.职业与健康,2001年12月,17(2):160-162.
[20]曹冰,陈宇,李雅静.病态窦房结综合征49例临床分析.心血管康复医学杂志,1999,8(3):38-39.
[21]王新春.病窦综合征临床诊疗分析.医药论坛杂志,2006年10月,27(19):87-88.
[22]向春云,申喜莲.JOURNAL OF PRACTICAL ELECTROCARDIOLOGY,2007,16(2):91-92.
[23]申万红,刘子文,熊望琼.阿托品试验对病窦综合征诊断价值的再探讨.JOURNAL OF PRAC11CAL EU CIROCARD10I,2003,12(5):342-343.
[24]钱大为,耿戚,郑义等.阿托品试验对诊断病窦综合征相关性的评定.吉林医学信息,1993,4:7.
[25]陈凯.阿托品试验诊断病态窦房结综合征的价值.河北医学,2006,12(1):20-21.
[26]钱春丽,栗浩,曹东辉.动态心电图诊断病态窦房结综合征的价值.中国误诊学杂志,2007年10月,7(24):5752-5753.
[27]岑梅珠,黄林贤,胡志华.病态窦房结综合征患者的动态心电图特征.实用医学杂志,2007,23(3):401-402.
[28]努尔古丽,赵文丽.食管调搏对病窦综合征诊断的临床意义.心脏杂志,2004,16(4):392.
[29]丁丽,董少红,石丹.39例病窦综合征的食道调搏检查及临床意义.国际医药卫生导报,2003,9(5):33-34.
[30]齐平,田福利,郭继鸿,刘俊琳.心先安治疗病态窦房结综合征疗效观察.JOURNAL OF PRACTICAL ELECTROCARDIOLOGY,2007,16(1):21-22.
[31]张斌,曹波,陈新.心先安治疗病窦综合征34例疗效观察.中国现代医药杂志,2006年7月,8(7):25-26.
[32]陈金良,郭培英,韩凌,刘志明.环磷腺苷葡胺治疗冠心病病态窦房结综合征疗效观察.中国医院药学杂志,2006,26(2):184-185.
[33]陈维敏,谢琴.氨茶碱伍用心先安治疗病态窦房结综合征28例疗效观察.中华医学研究杂志,2006,6(6):625-626.
[34]张佩生,杨建峰,梁雪:起搏治疗对病窦综合征患者预后的影响:实用诊断与治疗杂志 2006年第20卷第10期 734-735
[35]王勇:病态窦房结综合征患者植入起搏器模式:实用医技杂志 2006年2月第13卷第四期
[36]夏平达.AAI和VVI起搏治疗病窦综合征的远期随访.哈尔滨医药 2009年第2D卷第3期:8-9
[37]杨栓锁,张全发,崔长琮.VVI和AAI起搏治疗病窦综合征的远期随访.中华心血管病杂志 2000年2月第28卷第1期.45-46
[38]Lamas GA,Orav EJ,Stambler BS,et al.Quality of life and clinical outcomes in elderly patients treated with ventricular pacing as compared with dual-chamber pacing[J].N Engl J Med,1998,338(16):1097-1104
[39]Lamas GA,Lee KL,Sweeney MD,et al.Ventricular pacing or dual-chamber pacing for sinus node dysfunction[J].N Engl J Med,2002,346(24):1854.1862
[40]Sweeney MO,Hellkamp AS,Ellenbogen KA,et al.Adverse effect of ventricular pacing on heart failure and atrial fibrillation among patients with normal base.line QRS duration in a clinical trial of pacemaker therapy for sinus node dysfunction[J].Circulation,2003,107(23):2932.2937.
[41]Sulke N,Chambers J,Dritsas A.et al.A randomized double,blind crossover comparison offour rate-responsive pacing modes[J].J Am Coil Cardiol,1991,17:696.
[42]Kristensen L,Nielsen JC,Mortensen PT,et al.Incidence of atrial fibrillation and thromboembolism in a randomised trial of atrial versus dual chamber pa.cing in 177 patients with sick sinus syndrome[J]Heart,2004,90(6):661-666
[43]Nielsen JC,Kristensen L,Andersen HR,et al.A randomized comparison of atri.al and dual-chamber pacing in 177 consecutive patients with sick sinus syn.drome:EchOcardiOgr phl and clinical outcome[J].J Am Coil Cardiol.2003.42(4):614 623
[44]崔长琮,王忠,马奕,等.人工心脏起搏的血液动力学研究进展[J].心脏起搏与心电生理杂志,1994,8(4):217
[45]陈德才.病窦灵治疗病窦综合征14例报告[J].南京医科大学学报,1994,14(4):538.
[46]姜燕,吴先奇,韩又云.病态窦房结综合征中医病机探讨[J].中医研究,2001,14(5):2-3.
[47]郑春雷.实用中西医疑难病学[M].北京:中医古籍出版社,2001:69
[48]张丽灵,张刚,郑丽萍,等.诊治病窦综合征经验[J].中国医药学 报,2002,17(3):178.
[49]江佑华.病态窦房结综合征辨证分型治疗[J].中医药学刊,2001,19(5):482.
[50]栾天竹,赵秀琴,韩迪.病态窦房结综合征的临床研究概况.中西医结合心脑血管病杂志 2005年11月第3卷第11期
[51]江佑华.病态窦房结综合征辨证分型治疗[J].中医药学刊,2001,19(5):482
[52]李宜方,杜焱.辨证治疗病态窦房结综合征[J].山东中医杂志,1999,18(6):255-256
[53]杨晓华.病态窦房结综合征辨治一则[J].甘肃中医,2002,15(3):31
[54]张霁生,吴俊贞.中医药治疗病窦综合征65例疗效观察[J].天津中医,2000,17(3):12-13 26
[55]王玉霞.病窦综合征的中医药治疗[J].天津中医,2001,18(3):51-52
[56]李春华,李延.温阳活血法治疗病窦综合征46例[J].中医药信息,2004,21(2):7
[57]张其梅.益气温阳活血法治疗病窦综合征32例[J].中国中医药信息杂志,2003,10(2):43-44
[58]马彪,李启芳.涤痰解毒,宣肃肺气法治疗病窦综舍征[J].吉林中医药,2004,24(8):23
[59]王庆余.复津汤治疗病窦综合征30例[J].山西职工医学院学报,2003,13(1):36
[60]孔令振.麻附细辛汤治疗病窦综合征的疗效观察[J].中国社区医师,2004,20(22):60
[61]刘德桓.通心络胶囊治疗病窦综合征的?临床观察[J]..中国中西医结合杂志,2001,21(11):858-859
[62]王秀琴,杨东,李连涛.温养通心胶囊治疗病窦综合征的机理研究[J].南宁中医药大学学报,2003,19(5):279-280
[63]黄天宫,王巧平.升率散治疗病窦综合征216例[J].辽宁中医杂志,2004,31(5):378-379
[64]范爱勤.复方苦参治疗病窦综合征[J].辽宁中医杂志,2003,30(2):133