专业化劳动力、经济增长与产业升级
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
改革开放30年来,中国走过了快速工业化的过程,保持了长期高速的经济增长,取得了举世瞩目的成就,也付出沉重的代价。尽快实现经济增长方式转变,推动产业升级是当前中国经济发展面临的首要命题。
     深圳市的改革实践似乎为这一命题提供了可行的答案,即通过自主创新、分工深化、产业集聚、专业劳动力培育与升级、大力发展高新技术产业,实现了产业结构升级、经济增长方式转变、经济长期快速稳定增长。这种升级和发展,不是一味模仿,也不是简单的“雁形理论”的跟从,而是依靠创新和专业化分工,实现以简单劳动力静态比较优势为主向以专业化劳动力动态比较优势为主的转变。时至今日,深圳不仅拥有华为、中兴等国际一流的高新技术企业,也有服装、珠宝等产品远销海外的传统优势产业,深圳还培育出了发达的金融服务业,创新的现代物流业,走向全球的文化产业,并创建了国际一流的人居环境。
     本文通过对增长理论的梳理,以增长理论的最新扩展即内生专业化劳动力增长理论为基础,结合实际做了进一步推演,构建了专业化劳动力的升级模型和基于专业化劳动力的产业结构分析模式。并以此为分析框架,选取深圳电子通讯设备制造业、生物基因产业作为高新技术产业的样本,选取深圳黄金珠宝业、服装业作为传统优势产业的样本,对深圳模式进行了系统的案例研究,总结发现了一条发展中国家基于专业化劳动力比较优势实现赶超的可能路径,从而回答了中国经济增长、转型、升级的三大核心问题。
     形成的主要结论如下:1、在信息革命、知识经济、全球化分工的背景下,经济增长的核心源泉来自由分工和专业化形成的、富于创造和创新的专业化劳动力。2、通过促进产业聚集,深化分工,从而增加专业化劳动力的种类和数量,推动专业化劳动力升级,是缩小发展中国家与发达国家经济与技术差距的关键。3、依托专业化劳动力动态比较优势,推进新技术的应用,新产业的开发,新产业的创造,是发展中国家加快长期经济增长速度,拉近甚至赶超发达国家的关键。4、中国可以通过发挥专业化劳动力的动态比较优势,发展高新技术产业,转变经济增长方式;中国可以依托专业化劳动力的升级,实现产业的升级;中国可以借助基于专业化劳动力的创新,推进高新技术产业高级化,巩固和提升优势传统产业,培育壮大新兴战略产业,构建有国际竞争力的现代产业体系,推动中国经济实现长期较快增长。
Over the past 30 years of reform and opening up, China went through a course of rapid industrialization, sustained long-term fast economic growth, and achieved outstanding results, while the cost incurred was heavy. Therefore, it is now a first priority for China to realize the transformation of economic growth model and promote the overall industrial upgrading as soon as possible.
     Shenzhen's reform experience seems to have provided a practical answer to this question. Via proactive innovation, specialization, industrial agglomeration, cultivation and upgrading of specialized labor, promotion of high/new-tech industries, Shenzhen succeeded in realizing industrial upgrading, transforming economic growth model, and sustaining long-term fast economic growth. Such upgrading and growth is neither mere imitation nor simple application of the theory of Flying Geese Pattern. Rather, Shenzhen relied on innovation and specialization to realize the transition from static comparative advantages based on simple labor to dynamic comparative advantages based on specialized labor. Now, Shenzhen boasts of world-leading high/new-tech enterprises such as Huawei and ZTE, as well as traditionally strong industries such as garment and jewelry whose products are being sold.globally. Along with the industrial upgrading, Shenzhen has fostered a strong financial services industry, an innovative modern logistics industry, an outward-looking cultural industry, as well as a world-leading living environment.
     This paper carried out further inference in view of realities through review of the growth theories, based on the latest expansion of growth theories, i.e. the growth theory of organic specialized labor, and built an upgrading model of specialized labor and an industrial structure analysis model based on specialized labor. Taking the abovementioned as analysis framework, we chose Shenzhen's electronic telecommunication equipment manufacturing industry and gene industry as samples of high/new-tech industries, and chose Shenzhen's gold and jewelry industries and garment industry as samples of traditionally strong industries. We conducted systematic case research on the Shenzhen model, and obtained some copiable universal conclusions. We discovered a practicable path for developing countries to rely on comparative advantages created by specialized labor to achieve exceptional growth, thus answered the three core questions as to China's economic growth, transformation, and industrial upgrading.
     Our major conclusions are as follows:1) In the backdrop of IT revolution, knowledge economy and global specialization, the core driver of economic growth is the creative and innovative specialized labor created by free specialization and labor division.2) The key to narrowing the economic and technical gaps between developing countries and developed ones is increasing the types and amounts of specialized labor via promotion of industrial agglomeration and labor division. thereby promoting the upgrading of specialized labor.3) The key for developing countries to accelerate long-term economic growth and get closer to or even outpace developed countries is to reply on dynamic comparative advantages arising from specialized labor to promote the application of new technologies, the development of new industries, and the creation of new industries.4) China can rely on the dynamic comparative advantages arising from specialized labor to develop high/new-tech industries and transform the economic growth model. China can rely on the upgrading of specialized labor to realize industrial upgrading. China can rely on the specialized labor-based innovation to promote the upgrading of high/new-tech industries, to consolidate and upgrade the traditionally strong industries, to foster and strengthen the emerging strategic industries, and to build a modern industry system with international competitiveness, thereby promoting the long-term rapid growth of China's economy.
引文
47 Adrian Wooldridge 《A special report on innovation in emerging markets》—The emerging world, long a source of cheap labour, now rivals the rich countries for business innovation. Economist April 17th-23rd 2010.
    59 Adrian Wooldridge 《A special report on innovation in emerging markets》—The emerging world, long a source of cheap labour, now rivals the rich countries for business innovation. Economist April 17th-23rd 2010.
    60 C. K. Prahalad The Fortune at the Bottom of the Pyramid Wharton School Publishing August 5,2004 ISBN978-0-131-46750-7, The New Age of Innovation. Driving Co-Created Value Through Global Networks. By C.K.Prahalad and M.S. Krishnan (McGraw Hill,2008).
    61 Open Innovation:the new imperative for creating and profiting from technology. Henry William Chesbrough. ISBN:978-1-422102-83-1 2005 227 pages Harvard Business press.
    74 盛斌、马涛《中间产品贸易对另劳动力需求变化的影响:基于工业部门动态面板数据的分析》,《世界经济》2008/3。
    75生产分割的生产率效应》“经济研究”2010/2。刘庆林等《国际
    76吴延兵《自主研发、技术引进与生产率—基于中国地区工业的实证研究》“经济研究,,2008/8。
    77杨汝岱,姚洋《有限赶超与经济增长》“经济研究”2008/8
    84 Kasra Ferdows 《Making the most of foreign factories》,《Harvard Business Review》 March-April 1997, pp97204
    87 "Mobile marvels"《Economist》 Sep.24th,2009.
    91见杨汝岱和姚洋《有限赶超与经济增长》“经济研究”2008/8
    95参见RichardN. Langlois《技术、组织与社会的模块性》康涅狄格大学工作论文,1999年5月。
    96参见《内生制度与制度变迁》国际经济协会2005年世界论坛约稿,《日本经济失去的十年》"Cournot Centre for Economic Studies"(?)工作论文,2007年9月。
    [1][瑞典]伯特尔·俄林.区际贸易与国际贸易.逯宇铎等译.华夏出版社,20088(1)
    [2]梁琦,分工、聚集与增长,商务印书馆,2009
    [3]林毅夫,蔡防,李周.中国的奇迹:发展战略与经济改革.上海三联书店、上海人民出版社,1994.8
    [4][德]马克思.资本论(第1卷).北京:人民出版社,1975
    [5][美]钱纳里,赛尔奎因.发展的型式:1950-1970.1975
    [6][日]青木吕彦,安藤晴彦编著.模块时代——新产业结构的本质.周国荣译.上海远东出版社.2003.4(1)
    [7][美]舒尔茨.论人力资本投资.北京:北京经济学院出版社,1990
    [8][澳]杨小凯.发展经济学——超边际与边际分析.张定胜,张永生译.社会科学文献出版社,2003.12
    [9][澳]杨小凯、黄有光,专业化与经济组织——一种新兴古典微观经济学框架,张玉纲泽,经济科学出版社,1999
    [10]吴敬琏.中国增长模式抉择.上海远东出版社.2009.3
    [11]张其仔,模块化、产业内分工与经济增长方式转变,社会科学院文献出版社,2008
    [1]北京大学中国经济研究中心第二届“中国经济展望论坛”之“新世纪中国经济发展战略”主题圆桌研讨会.重化工业化道路与南北经济转型之辩.世纪经济报道,2005.8
    [2]卜国琴.全球生产网络与中国产业升级研究.暨南大学,2007
    [3]陈娜娜.马克思经济增长理论研究.西安理工大学,2007
    [4]陈永奇.欠发达地区技术转移促进产业结构调整对策研究.山西大学,2006
    [5]陈飞.区域经济增长理论从分化到整合的空间经济学分析.现代财经,2009.3
    [6]曹秋菊.经济增长理论的演进对中国经济可持续发展之启示.经济研究导刊,2009.4
    [7]戴群.关于存在专业化劳动力交易成本的集聚模型.开放导报,2009.4
    [8]戴群.垄断竞争产业升级研究.南开大学,2009
    [9]段建宇.中外银行产业升级比较研究.北京交通大学,2009
    [10]丁宝东.香港经济周期波动研究——兼论香港产业结构调整.武汉大学,2005
    [11]郭岭.现代产业组织模式研究.武汉理工大学,2004
    [12]顾湘.区域产业结构调整与土地集约利用研究.南京农业大学,2007
    [13]国家计委宏观经济研究院课题组.促进我国工业结构调整和产业升级研究——家用电 器和通信设备制造业的启示.管理世界,2001.3
    [14]贺俊.基于内生增长理论的可持续发展研究.中国科学技术大学,2007
    [15]黄晶.产业内垂直分工研究——基于产业组织的视角和中国的实证.暨南大学,2009
    [16]黄日福,陈晓红.FDI与产业结构升级:基于中部地区的理论及实证研究.管理世界,2007.3
    [17]韩慧敏.产业结构调整中的金融支持研究.中共中央党校,2006
    [18]贺青.经济增长理论与模型的发展研究.现代商贸工业,2009.1
    [19]胡昭玲.产品内分工对中国工业生产率的影响分析.中国工业经济,2009.6
    [20]何筠,张波.江西产业结构调整与人力资源开发关系实证研究.中国人口资源与环境,2006.3
    [21]纪玉俊,杨蕙馨.纵向交易治理、分工制度安排与企业边界.山西财经大学学报,2008.5
    [22]姜泽华,白艳.产业结构升级的内涵与影响因素分析.当代经济研究,2006.10
    [23]康胜,彭伟斌.陈丹宇.时代发展与产业集聚因素的历史演进.生产力研究.2009.8
    [24]李胜会.经济集聚与区域经济增长:理论探讨和实证研究.暨南大学,2008
    [25]李想.模块化分工条件下网络状产业链的基本构造与运行机制研究.复口.大学.2008
    [26]李继云.孙良涛.云南产业结构与经济增长关系的实证分析.工业技术经济.2005.8
    [27]李江帆, 曾国军.中国第三产业内部结构升级趋势分析.中国工业经济.2003.3
    [28]陆瑾.产业组织演化研究——从对主流经济理论的批判到基于演化框架的分析.复旦大学,2005
    [29]刘强.区域产业竞争力与产业结构调整研究——以河北省为例.河北工业大学.2007
    [30]郎永清.产业结构调整中的经济增长.西北大学,2005
    [31]梁琦.分工、专业化与集聚.管理科学学报,2006.12
    [32]梁琦.高技术产业集聚的新理论解释.广东社会科学,2004.2
    [33]梁琦,詹亦军.产业集聚、技术进步和产业升级:来自长三角的证据.产业经济评论.2005.12
    [34]林毅夫,任若恩.东亚经济增长模式相关争论的再探讨.经济研究,2007.9
    [35]刘绍坚.承接国际软件外包的技术外溢效应研究.经济研究.2008.5
    [36]刘庆林等.国际生产分割的生产率效应.经济研究,2010.2
    [37]罗勇,曹丽莉.中国制造业集聚程度变动趋势实证研究.经济研究,2005.8
    [38]蓝英, 王代敬.川东北七个地级市产业结构效益比较研究.工业技术经济,2005.8
    [39]罗文标黄照升产业结构与人才结构互动研究科技进步与对策20047
    [40]米娟.中国区域经济增长的要素集聚差异性研究.辽宁大学,2008
    [41]穆岩.基于区域经济发展的京津唐产业结构调整研究.北京交通大学,2007
    [42]马晓国.江苏产业结构调整的计量分析与实证研究.南京航空航天大学,2006
    [43]马凌,游国鑫.信息化背景下产业集聚因素的效力变化研究.管理观察,2009.5
    [44]彭亮.自主创新与中国经济增长.华中科技大学,2008
    [45]彭建娟.区域科技能力及其对产业结构调整和主导产业选择的影响研究.吉林大学,2006
    [46]潘悦.在全球化产业链条中加速升级换代——我国加工贸易的产业升级状况分析.中 国工业经济,2002.6
    [47]钱崇俊.深圳市产业集聚研究.天津大学,2007
    [48]钱学锋,梁琦,分工与集聚的理论渊源.江苏社会科学,2007.2
    [49]史修松.产业集聚及其测度理论研究动态.科技管理研究,2009.9
    [50]宋锦剑.论产业结构优化升级的测度问题.当代经济科学,2000.5
    [51]宋德勇,许广月.演化理论视角下现代经济增长理论的批判与重建.经济学家,2009.1
    [52]盛斌,马涛.中间产品贸易对另劳动力需求变化的影响:基于工业部门动态面板数据的分析.世界经济,2008.3
    [53]陶军锋.劳动分工、专业化人力资本积累与收益递增——内生增长理论研究.中国社会科学院研究生院,2003
    [54]陶拯.钱钢.全球价值链视角下地方电子信息产业升级研究——以苏南为例.工业技术经济,2007.1
    [55]田海宽.基于京津走廊经济发展的廊坊市产业结构调整和空间布局优化研究.武汉理工大学,2009
    [56]王林辉.我国经济增长主要因素的理论研究与实证分析.吉林大学,2007
    [57]王鹏.新经济增长理论与台湾经济增长研究.厦门大学,2006
    [58]王军.产业组织演化理论及实证研究.山东大学,2006
    [59]王盛.分工、协调和产业组织形式演化——基于技术和市场的组织适应性研究.复旦大学,2005
    [60]王建军.分工和产业组织演进与优化的经济学分析.复旦大学,2006
    [61]王恩才.基于产业集群的城市区域经济发展.兰州大学,2007
    [62]王齐.环境管制促进技术创新及产业升级的问题研究.山东大学,2005
    [63]王英.中国对外直接投资的产业结构调整效应研究.南京航空航天大学,2007
    [64]吴志勇.可持续发展导向下的中国山区产业结构调整研究.福建师范大学,2007
    [65]吴延兵.自主研发、技术引进与生产率——基于中国地区工业的实证研究.经济研究,2008.8
    [66]吴敬琏.注重经济增长方式转变,谨防结构调整中出现片面追求重型化的倾向.国务院发展研究中心网站,2004.11
    [67]武晓辉,韩之俊.基于知识集学习的产业组织演化的研究.特区经济,2006.5
    [68]徐小飞.经济增长理论若干问题的研究与实证分析.华侨大学,2000
    [69]谢军.基于国际产业转移的中国电机产业组织创新与产业升级研究.中南大学,2008
    [70]徐桂民,綦建红,鞠磊.劳动力外移、国际贸易与产业结构调整——基于1984—2004年中国数据的协整分析与格兰杰因果检验.中国工业经济,2007.7
    [71]杨依山.经济增长理论的成长.山东大学,2008
    [72]杨丽.模块化对产业组织演进的影响.山东大学,2008
    [73]杨雄年.中国西部地区农业产业升级转化程中政策绩效研究.西北农林科技大学,2005
    [74]杨光辉.中国人口老龄化与产业结构调整的统计研究.厦门大学,2005
    [75]杨汝岱.姚洋.有限赶超与经济增长.经济研究,2008.8
    [76]杨竹莘. 韩国高.黑龙江省产业结构与经济增长关系的实证研究.工业技术经济. 2007.2
    [77]于铭.中国产业集聚与区域经济增长问题研究.辽宁大学,2007
    [78]于凤艳.中国城市经济增长过程中的产业结构变动研究.辽宁大学,2008
    [79]袁春晓.产业组织演化论.四川大学,2002
    [80]阎晓东.沿海地区产业结构升级研究——以广东产业结构调整升级为例.福建师范大学,2005
    [81]余鹏翼, 余鹏芳.泛珠江三角洲区域经济协调与产业结构调整的实证研究.工业技术经济,2005.9
    [82]赵建军.论产业升级的就业效应.中共中央党校,2005
    [83]赵光辉.人才结构与产业结构互动的一般规律研究.商业研究,2008.2
    [84]张琰.模块化分工条件下网络状产业链中知识创新研究.复旦大学,2008
    [85]张伟.模块化组织的形成、演进及运行机理研究.暨南大学,2007
    [86]张梅.中国金融发展的产业升级效应研究.复旦大学,2006
    [87]张爱美.吉林省林业产业发展及产业结构调整研究.北京林业大学,2008
    [88]张雪芹.基于市场主导的建筑业产业结构调整研究.重庆大学.2007
    [89]张燕.姚慧琴.企业边界变动与产业组织演化.西北大学学报(哲学社会科学版)2006.7
    [90]张丽峰.中国产业投资结构与产业结构协整分析.工业技术经济,2006.1
    [91]张辉.全球价值链下地方产业集群升级模式研究.中国工业经济.2005.9
    [92]张哲.区域分工、专业化与产业结构调整机理探讨.财经论丛,2004.7
    [93]张其春,郗永勤.区域人力资本与产业结构调整的互动关系.现代经济探讨.2006.8
    [94]郑军.企业边界变迁的产业组织演化.财经科学,2007.4
    [95]周绍东.分工与专业化:马克思经济学与西方经济学比较研究的一个视角.经济评论.2009.1
    [96]曾世宏,郑江淮.低人力资本回报能否驱动产业结构演化升级——兼论国际金融危机对中国制造业自主创新的影响.财经科学,2009,6
    [1]Adrian Wooldridge 《A special report on innovation in emerging markets》—The emerging world, long a source of cheap labour, now rivals the rich countries for business innovation. Economist April 17th-23rd 2010
    [2]Alberto Bucci. Population growth in a model of economic growth with human capital accumulation and horizontal R&D. Journal of Macroeconomics 30 (2008) 1124-1147
    [3]Alfred Greiner. Human capital formation, public debt and economic growth. Journal of Macroeconomics 30 (2008) 415-427
    [4]Alistair R. Anderson, Claire J. Miller, "Class matters":human and social capital in the entrepreneurial process. Journal of Socio-Economics 32 (2003) 17-36
    [5]Amiti.M.& Wei S.J..,《Service offshore & productivity:Evidence from the United States》, NBER working paper, No 11926 2006.
    [6]Andres Rodriguez-Clare, The division of labor and economic development, Journal of Development Economics, Vol.49 (1996) 3-32
    [7]Bas van Leeuwen and Peter Foldvari. Human Capital and Economic Growth in Asia 1890-2000:A Time-series Analysis. Asian Economic Journal 2008, Vol.22 No.3,225-240
    [8]Becker, G. and Murphy, K., "The Division of Labor, Coordination Costs, and Knowledge", Quarterly Journal of Economics,1992,107,1137-60
    [9]Brian S. Klaas, Malayka Klimchak, Matthew Semadeni, Jeanne Johnson Holmes. The adoption of human capital services by small and medium enterprises:A diffusion of innovation perspective, Journal of Business Venturing.2009
    [10]Charles E. Swanson, The division of labor and the extent of the market. Economics Letters 62 (1999)135-138
    [11]C. K. Prahalad The Fortune at the Bottom of the Pyramid Wharton School Publishing August 5,2004 ISBN978-0-131-46750-7, The New Age of Innovation. Driving Co-Created Value Through Global Networks. By C.K. Prahalad and M.S. Krishnan (McGraw Hill. 2008).
    [12]C.M. Rogerson. J.M. Rogerson, Industrial change in a developing metropolis:The Witwatersrand 1980-1994, Geoforum 30 (1999) 85-99
    [13]Egger, H.& Egger, P.,《International outsourcing under the productivity of low-skilled labor in the EU》Economic Inquiry, Vol.44,pp.980108
    [14]Eiji Yamamura, Dynamics of social trust and human capital in the learning process:The case of the Japan gannent cluster in the period 1968-2005, Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization 72 (2009) 377-389
    [15]Fujita M A monopolistic competition model of spatial agglomeration:differentiated product approach. Regional Science and Urban Economics 1988(18):87-124
    [16]Garett Jones · W. Joel Schneider. Intelligence, human capital, and economic growth:A Bayesian Averaging of Classical Estimates (BACE) approach. JEcon Growth (2006) 11:71-93
    [17]Grossman, G. and Helpman, E., "Comparative Advantage and Long-Run Growth", American Economics Review,1990,80,796-815
    [18]Javier A. Birchenall, Income distribution, human capital and economic growth in Colombia, Journal of Development Economics, Vol.66 2001 271-287
    [19]Jungsoo Park. Dispersion of human capital and economic growth. Journal of Macroeconomics 28 (2006) 520-539
    [20]Ke Li, Transaction cost, corporate governance and division of labor—A general equilibrium analysis of professional managers and its implication to China's practice, Research in International Business and Finance 21(2007) 447-468
    [21]Krugman, Paul, "Increasing Returns, Monopolistic Competition, and International Trade'". Journal of International Economics,1979,9,469-479
    [22]Lewis S. Davis, The division of labor and the growth of government, Journal of Economic Dynamics & Control 27 (2003) 1217-1235
    [23]Mark Montgomery, Terry Johnson, Syed Faisal. What kind of capital do you need to start a business:financial or human? The Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance,45 (2005) 103-122
    [24]Moses O. Oketch. Determinants of human capital formation and economic growth of African countries. Economics of Education Review 25 (2006) 554-564
    [25]Open Innovation:the new imperative for creating and profiting from technology. Henry William Chesbrough. ISBN:978-1-422102-83-1 2005 227 pages Harvard Business press.
    [26]Peter-J. Jost, Matthias Kr" akel, Human capital investments in asymmetric corporate tournaments. Journal of Economics and Business 60 (2008) 312-331
    [27]P.N. Rastogi. Sustaining enterprise competitiveness- is human capital the answer?. Human Systems Management 19 (2000) 193-203
    [28]Romer. P.. "Endogenous Technological Change", Journal of Political Economy.1990. 98.71-102
    [29]Salvador Ortigueira. Equipment prices, human capital and economic growth. Journal of Economic Dynamics & Control 28 (2003) 307-329
    [30]Solow. R.. "A Contribution to the Theory of Economic Growth", Quarterly Journal of Economics,1956,70,65-94
    [31]Suresh Bhagavatula, Tom Elfring, Aad van Tilburg, Gerhard G. van de Bunt. How social and human capital influence opportunity recognition and resource mobilization in India's handloom industry, Journal of Business Venturing,2008
    [32]Thomas Osang, Jayanta Sarkar. Endogenous mortality, human capital and economic growth. Journal of Macroeconomics 30 (2008) 1423-1445
    [33]T.J. Perri, The cost of specialized human capital. Economics of Education Review 22 (2003) 433-438
    [34]Wolfgang Hoeschele, The Wealth of Nations at the Turn of the Millennium:A Classification System Based on the International Division of Labor, Economic Geography, Vol.78, No.2 (Apr.,2002), pp.221-244
    [35]Yan WANG, Yudong YAO. Sources of China's economic growth 1952-1999:incorporating human capital accumulation. China Economic Review 14 (2003) 32-52

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700