摘要
本文利用长期轮作培肥定位试验,并结合2010年对黄土区不同种植年限苜蓿草地的野外调查,对连作不同施肥条件、粮草轮作不同生长年限以及黄土区不同种植年限的苜蓿草地群落特征、多样性及其稳定性变化进行了研究,为黄土区苜蓿人工草地持续高效利用提供科学的依据。主要研究结论如下:
1.不同施肥条件下连作苜蓿草地群落物种多样性和生态优势度指数变化不显著,植被生物量明显增大,苜蓿种群重要值及其产量亦显著增加,施肥可维系群落多样性和稳定性,提高苜蓿草地生产力。
2.施肥后,苜蓿生态位宽度增大,竞争力相对增强;杂类草之间生态位重叠较大且竞争较为激烈,苜蓿和杂类草的竞争相对缓和,施肥可增强苜蓿种群竞争力,缓解种间竞争压力,提高群落的稳定性。不同施肥措施下连作苜蓿草群落物种多样性与生产力的关系发生了一些改变,总体上表现为负二次函数关系。
3.轮作苜蓿草地植被生物量、群落物种多样性和生态优势度指数,苜蓿重要值及其产量随生长年限增加均呈先升后降的变化趋势,物种丰富度指数、杂类草生物量的变化趋势与之相反。人工草地3龄后,随着苜蓿生长时间延长和杂类草入侵,群落生产力稳定性开始显著下降,人工草地呈明显退化态势。
4.轮作苜蓿草地群落物种多样性与生产力关系随种植年限的延长发生了一些改变,这与种间竞争密切相关。轮作草地中苜蓿生态幅(0.60)最宽,附地菜(0.58)等杂类草也具有较宽生态幅,苜蓿与附地菜的重叠值(0.995)最大,且同其它杂类草的重叠程度亦较高,杂类草与苜蓿间竞争激烈,导致草地退化。
5.轮作苜蓿草地群落稳定性在3龄时最大,尔后随草地生产力和生物多样性下降而降低,人工草地很快衰退,苜蓿施肥可适当延缓人工草地的自然演替进程。
6.苜蓿人工草地大约在26年后,其群落开始向长芒草过渡,逐渐被长芒草群落所替代,标志着苜蓿人工草地已经退化。草地演替6龄后,群落物种多样性呈明显增加趋势,群落结构趋向于越复杂化,其生态稳定性相对增大,苜蓿人工草地处于退化演替阶段。
7.苜蓿人工草地群落物种多样性与生产力的关系随演替进程推进发生了一些变化,它们在不同演替时间和生境条件下的总体关系表现为负二次函数关系。人工草地中苜蓿和杂草附地菜间重叠值最大为0.99,竞争最激烈。杂类草与苜蓿之间具有高度重叠生态幅是导致草地退化的一个重要因素。
The changes of the communities characteristics,biodiversity and stability of alfalfa grasslands communities under different fertilizations,different growth age alfalfa grasslands communities in cropping wheat-alfalfa rotation system from the trial of long-term located fertilize.and the investigation of different growth age alfalfa grassland in gully region of the Loess Plateau were analyzed,respectively,to provide the scientific basis for sustainable and efficient use of artificial alfalfa grassland in Loess Region.The results were as follows:
1.The species diversity indexes and ecological dominance index of the continuous cropping alfalfa grassland under different fertilizer treatments did not significantly differ,but the vegetation biomass tended to obviously increase,and the yield and importance value of alfalfa populations also raised significantly.Pmanure could maintain species diversity and stability of communities to some extent,and enhance alfalfa grassland productivity.
2.After fertilizer treatments,niche breadth of alfalfa population increased and the competitiveness relatively strengthened;niche overlaps and competitives between two forbs were the larger and more intense,while the competitives.between Medicago sativa and other species were relative ease.fertilization can enhance the competitive of alfalfa populations, reduced the pressure between two species and improve the stability of communities.Under different fertilizations,the relationship between species diversity and productivity in the continuous cropping alfalfa grassland had been some changes, generally showed a negative quadratic function.
3.The vegetation biomass,species diversity and ecological dominance index of the alfalfa rotation grassland,and the important value and yeild of alfalfa populations with the growth years decreased at first and increased subsquently decreased,but the species richness index and the aboveground biomass of forbs were opposite trends.After artificial grassland 3 years old,the stability of community productivity began to decline significantly,artificial glassland was in significantly degraded situation with the growth years of alfalfa and forbs prolonged invasion.
4.The relationship between species diversity and productivity in alfalfa rotation grassland had undergone some changes with the plant years extension,which is closely related to interspecific competition.In rotation glassland the ecological amplitude (0.60)of alfalfa populations was the most wide,and the ecological amplitude of forbs such as Peduncularis(0.58) were larger , alfalfa and Peduncularis attached to the overlap value(0.995).maximum,and with other forbs also higher degree of overlap,the competitions between Medicago sativa and fors were most intense,which led to the sowing grassland degrade.
5.The stability of alfalfa grassland in rotation was best in 3 years old,and later reduced with the decline in grassland productivity and biological diversity,grassland artificial would soon degrade,fertilization may be appropriate to delay the process of natural succession of artificial glassland.
6.Artificial alfalfa grassland communities began to evolved toward the original vegetation community after about 26 years,was gradually replaced by bungeana community,which marked the alfalfa pasture has been completely degraded.After age 6 of grassland succession,the species diversity increased significantly,the structure of communities tended to be more complex,and its ecological stability relatively increased,showing that the artificial alfalfa grassland was in a stage of regressive succession.
7.The relationship between species diversity and productivity had undergone some changes in alfalfa artificial grassland with the succession process forward,the overall relationship between them was a negative quadratic function under different under different successional time and habitat conditions.Maximum overlap occured between alfalfa and Peduncularis,its value was 0.99,there were the most competitive among alfalfa and forbs.The competitions between forbs and alfalfa for a limited resource is an important factor,which made the sowing grassland more degenerative.
引文
Aarssen L W,Turkington R.1985.Competitive relations among species f rom pastures of differentages.Canadian Journal of Botany.63:2319~2325
Bakelaar R G,Eugene O P.1978.Community and population level responses to fertilization in an old field ecosystem.Ecology,59(4):660~665
Bond E M,Chase J M.2002.Biodiversity and ecosystem functioning at local and regional spatial scales.Ecology Letters,5:467~470
Cherney J H,Duxbury J M.1994.Inorganic nitrogen supply and symbiotic dinitrogen fixation in alfalfa.J Plant Nutrient,17:2053~2067
Clarence L,Tilman D.2000.Biodiversity,stability and productivity in competitive communities Am Nat,156:534~552
Cop J,Korosec J.1994.Composition and herbage yield of grass/while clover mixtures in relation to nitrogen fertilization under cutting.In Mannetie L,Frame J.Grassland and society proceeding of the 15th gener meeting of the European Grassland Federation June 6~9,77~80
Dennis W D,Jane W.1978.The effect of nitrogen in spring on shoot number and leaf area of white clover in mixtures.Grass and Forage Science,42:265~269
Edith B A.1982.Water and nutrient competition between Salsola kali and two native grass species Agropyron smithii and Bouteloua gracilis.Ecology,63(3):732~741
Fridley,Jason D.2002.Resource availability dominates and alters the relationship between species diversity and ecosystem productivity in experimental plant communities.Oecologia,132:271~277
Fridley J D.2003.Diversity effects on production in different light and fertility environments:an experiment with communities of annual plants.Journalof Ecology,9:396~406
Gary G. 2001.What is the observed relation between species richness and productivity.Ecology,82(9): 2381~2396
Grime J P.1997.Biodiversity and ecosystem function:the debate deepens.Science,277:1260~1261
Gross K L,Willig M R,Gough L,Inouye R,Cox S B.2000.Paterns of species diversity and productivity at diferents patials cales in herbaceous plant communities.Oikos,89:417~427
Gufu O.Oler V.Nils C.2001.Relationships betweenbiomass and plant species richness in arid~zonegrazing lands.Journal of Applied Ecology,38:836~845
Guo Q F.Berry W.1998.Species richness and biomass:dissection of the hump~shaped relationships.Ecology,79:2555~2559
Hannaway D B.Shuler P E.1993.Nitrogen fertilization in alfalfa production.J Prod Agric,6:180~85.
Hodgson J.1994.Foraging strategy and plant communities.Proceedings of the International Symposium on Grassland Resources.Beijing,China Agricultural Express,25~96
John,L Gerwig,Gilbert H Ahlgren.1958.The effect of different fertility levels on yield,persistence,and chemical composition of alfalfa.Agron.J,50:291~294
Kassen R,Angus B,Graham B.2000.Diversity peaksat intermediate productivity in a laboratory microcosm Nature,406:508~511
Kvaesth T O.1991.Note on biological diversity,evenness,and homogeneity measures.Oikos,62:123~127
Levins R.Evolution in Changing Environments:ome Theoretical Explorations.Princeton:Princeton University Press,1968.
MacArthur R H.1995.Fluctuations of animal populations and a measure of community stability.Ecology,36:533~536
Matt A Sanderson and Ronald M Jones.1993.Stand dynamics and yield components of alfalfa as affected by phosphorus fertility.Agron.J,85:241~246
Naeem S,Tompson L J,Lawler S P.2001.Declining biodiversity can alter the performance of ecosystem.Nature,1994,Downing A L,The role of biological diversity for the functioning and stability of pond ecosystem.Ph D Thesis,Department of Ecology and Evolution,Chicago:University of Chicago Nuttall W F.1985.Effect of N,P,and S Fertilizers on Alfalfa Grown on Three soils Type in Northeastern Sashatchewan I Yield and Soil Tests.Agron.J,77:41~46
Raun W R,Johnson G V,Phillips S B.1999.Alfalfa yield response to nitrogen applied after each cutting.Soil~Science~Society~of~America~Journal,63(5):1237~1243
Remison S U,Snaydon R W.1980.A companion of root competition and shoot competition between Dactylis glomerata and Holcus lanat us.Grassand Forage Science,35:183~187
S M Hojjati.1978.Nitrogen fertilization in establishing forage legumes.Agron.J,70:429~433
Shugart H H,Bonan G B,Rasteeler E B,1998.Nich etheory and community organization.Can J Bot,66:2634~2639
Steven O L,Harvey B.1995.Response of downy brome to nitrogen and water.Journal of Range Management,48:290~297
Tang H P,Zhang X S.2003.Establishment of optimized eco~productive paradigm in the farming~pastoral zone of northern China.Acta Botanica Sinica,45(10):1166~1173
Thompson K,Gaston K J,Band S R.1969.Range size,dispersal and niche breadth in the herbaceous flora of central England.J Ecol,87:155~158
Tilman D,Knops J,Wedin D.1997.The influence offunctional diversity and composition on ecosystem processes.Science,277:1300~1302
Tilman D,Wedin D,Knop s J.1996.Productivity and sustainability influenced by biodiversity in grassland ecosystem.Nature,379:718~720
Tilman D,Reich P B,Wedin D.2001.Diversity and productivity in along~term grassland expriment.Science,294:843~845
Walker B.1995.Conserving biological diversity through ecosystem resilience.Conservation of Biology,(9):747~752
Wang G H,Zhang X S.2003.Supporting of potential forage production to the herbivore~based pastoral farming industry on the Loess Plateau.Acta Botanica Sinica,45(10):1186~1194
Wilman D,Fisher A.1996.Effects of interval between harvests and application of fertilizer N in springon the growth of perennial ryegrass in a grass/while clover sward.Grass and Forage Science,51:52~57
陈波,周兴民.1995.三种蒿草群落中若干植物种的生态位宽度与重叠分析.植物生态学报.19(2):158~169
陈利顶,傅伯杰.2000.干扰的类型、特征及其生态学意义.生态学报,20(4):581~586
陈亚明,李自珍,杜国祯.2004.施肥对高寒草甸植物多样性和经济类群的影响.西北植物学报,24(3):424~429
陈子萱.2008.人工扰动对玛曲高寒沙化草地植物多样性和生产力的影响[博士学位论文].甘肃兰州:甘肃农业大学
程积民,万惠娥.2003.中国黄土高原植被建设与水土保持.北京:中国林业出版社,275~304
戴国荣.1990.铁卜加弯穗大麦草旱作施肥试验.青海畜牧兽医杂志,20(3):12~13
董全民,,赵新全,马玉寿,李青云,施建军,王彦龙,盛丽,阎明毅.2006..寒小嵩草草甸暖季草场主要植物种群的生态位.生态学杂志,25(11):1323~1327
董世魁,胡自治,龙瑞军,康慕谊,江源.2003.高寒地区多年生禾草混播草地的群落学特征研究.生态学杂志, 22(5):20~25
董世魁,胡自治.2000.人工草地群落稳定性及其调控机制研究现状.草原与草坪,(3):6~12
杜国桢,覃光莲,李自珍,刘正恒,董高生.2003.高寒草甸植物群落中物种丰富度和生产力的关系研究.植物生态学报,27(1):125~132
杜国祯,王刚.1995.甘南亚高山草甸人工草地的演替和质量变化[J].植物学报,37(4):306~313
范玮熠,王孝安.2006年.黄土高原马栏林区主要植物种的生态位研究.西北植物学报,26(1):0157~0164
甘肃省科学技术厅主编.2001.退耕还草与草地农业技术.兰州:甘肃人民出版社
高永革,刘详,李和平.2007.施肥对不同茬次紫花苜蓿生产性能的影响研究.河南省畜牧局饲草饲料站:河南郑州,:52~60
郭克贞.1996.改良退化天然草地综合技术经济效益研究.草业科学,13(2):24~28
郭全邦,刘玉成,李旭光.1997.缙云山森林次生演替序列优势种群生态位.西南师范大学学报(自然科学版),22(1):73~78
韩雪松.1999.不同施肥条件对紫花苜蓿性状及磷元素转化吸收影响的研究[硕士学位论文].北京:中国农业大学
郝明德,张春霞,魏孝荣,王旭刚,高长青.2004.黄土高原地区施肥对苜蓿生产力的影响.草地学报,12(3):195~198
侯扶江,南志标,肖金玉,.2002.重牧退化草地的植被、土壤及其耦合特征.应用生态学报,13(8):915~922
胡良军,邵明安,杨文治.2004.黄土高原土壤水分的空间分异及其与林草布局的关系.草业学报,13(6):14~20
程积明,万惠饿,赵艳云.2006.黄土丘陵区不同立地条件下植物种群生态位研究.草业学报,15(1):29~35
胡自治.2000.人工草地在我国21世纪草业发展和环境治理中的重要意义.草原与草坪(季刊),(1):12~15
黄建辉,白永飞,韩兴国.2001.物种多样性与生态系统功能:影响机制及有关假说.生物多样性,9(1):1~7
姜恕.2003.关于开发中国西部地区退耕还林还草的建议.草地学报,12(1):10~14
蒋文兰.1991.贵州威宁混播草地初级生产力及群落稳定性调控途径的研究[硕士学位论文].兰州:甘肃农业大学草业学院,10~29
寇建村,胡自治.2003.高寒地区多年生禾草混播草地杂草防除研究.草原与草坪,(4):33~35
李凤霞,张德罡.2005.草地退化指标及恢复措施.草原与草坪,(1):24~28
李丽霞,郝明德,张春霞.2005.不同种植方式下苜蓿地上部N、P、K含量的动态变化.干旱地区农业研究,23(1):90~94
李瑞,张克斌,杨晓晖,杨俊杰,乔峰.2006.荒漠化草原人工封育区植物生态位研究.水土保持研究,13(2):213~216
李玉山.2002.苜蓿生产力动态及其水分生态环境效应.土壤学报,39(3):404~411
李裕元,邵明安,上官周平,樊军,王丽梅.2006.黄土高原北部紫花苜蓿草地退化过程与植被演替研究.草业学报,15(2):85~92
李毓堂.2001.草产业是西部经济开发与生态治理的基础产业.中国草地,23(1)1~5
李志华,聂朝阳,陈宝书.1994.氮磷钾肥单施与混施对燕麦生产性能的影响.草业科学,11(4):24~26
李自珍,韩晓卓,李文龙,杜国祯.2004.高寒湿地植物群落的物种多样性保护及生态恢复对策.西北植物学报,24(3):363~369
李晶,上官铁梁,张秋华.2006.山西北部沙棘群落优势种群生态位研究.山西大学学报,29(2):209~214
林丽,赵成章,龙瑞军,王帅,王溪,李以康,张法伟.2009.石羊河上游退化草地植物功能群生态位分异特征.草业科学,26(5):50~55
蔺蕊,蒋平安.2004.苜蓿土壤氮磷钾丰缺指标初步研究.新疆农业大学学报,27(1):23~28
刘锦霞,武高林,马涛.2007.毛乌素沙漠边缘荒漠植物群落生态位特征研究.草业科学,24(12):9~14
刘起.1998.草地与国民经济持续发展.四川草原,13:1~4
罗燕江.2003.施肥刈割对高寒草甸植物群落物种多样性的影响[硕士学位论文].兰州:兰州大学
马金星.2002.高寒地区多年生禾草混播草地动态及氮素效应研究[硕士学位论文].甘肃农业大学.
马孝慧.2005.施肥对苜蓿产量与品质的影响及其经济效益分析[硕士学位论文].乌鲁木齐:新疆农业大学
莫本田,罗天琼,韩永芬.2000.施肥量和施肥方式对混播人工草地产草量的影响.草业科学,17(4):13~16
邱波,罗燕江,杜国祯.2004.施肥梯度对甘南高寒草甸植被特征的影响.草业学报,13(6):65~68(66)
仁青吉,罗燕江,王海洋,刘金梅.2004.青藏高原典型高寒草甸退化草地的恢复—施肥刈割对草地质量的影响。草业学报,13(2):43~49
沈景林,谭刚,乔海龙,张娟华,孟杨.2000.草地改良对高寒退化草地植被影响的研究.草地学报,(5):49~54
沈振西,陈佐忠,周兴民,周华坤.2002.高施氮量对高寒矮嵩草甸主要类群和多样性及质量的影响.草地学报,10(1):7~17
史惠兰,王启基,景增春,王长庭,王杰,王柳英.2005.江河源区人工草地群落特征、多样性及其稳定性分析.草业学报,14(3):25~26
孙海群.2000.混播人工草地退化演替的研究.中国草地,2:8~14
孙建华,王彦荣,余玲.2004.紫花苜蓿生长特性及产量性状相关性研究.草业学报,13(4):80~86
覃光莲,杜国祯,李自珍,杨广云,马建云,娘毛加.2002.高寒草甸植物群落中物种多样性与生产力关系研究.植物生态学报,26(增刊):57~62
覃光莲,杜国祯.2005.高寒草甸植物群落中物种多样性与群落变异性的关系及其机制初探.生态学报杂志,24(11):1303~1307
覃光莲.2003.高寒草甸植物群落中物种多样性与生态系统功能的关系研究[硕士学位论文].兰州:兰州大学
田福平,张自和.2004.关于开发中国西部地区退耕还林还草的建议.草原与草坪(季刊),(4):22~24,32
王长庭,龙瑞军,丁路明,来德珍,李有福.2005.草地生态系统中物种多样性、群落稳定性和生态系统功能的关系.草业科学,22(6):1~7
王长庭,龙瑞军,丁路明.2004b.高寒草甸不同草地类型功能群多样性及组成对植物群落生产力的影响,12(4):403~409
王长庭,王启基,龙瑞军,景增春,史惠兰.2004a.高寒草甸群落植物多样性和初级生产力沿海拔梯度变化的研究.植物生态学报,28(2):240~245
王刚,蒋文兰.1998.人工草地种群生态学研究.兰州:甘肃科学技术出版社
王国宏.2002.再论生物多样性与生态系统的稳定性.生物多样性,10(1):126~134
王鹤龄,牛俊义,郑华平,陈子萱.2008.玛曲高寒沙化草地生态位特征及其施肥改良研究.草业学报,12(3):12~24
王启基,周兴民,沈振西.1995.不同调控策略下退化草地植物群落结构及其多样性分析.高寒草甸生态系统(第4集).北京:科学出版社:269~279
王仁忠.1997.放牧影响下羊草草地主要植物种群生态位宽度与生态位重叠的研究.植物生态学报,21(4):304~311
魏臻武,符昕,曹致中,王晓俊,赵艳,朱铁霞.2007.苜蓿生长特性和产草量关系的研究.草业学报,16(4):1~8
文亦芾,蒋文兰,冉繁军.2001.改良云贵高原退化红壤人工草地的施肥效应研究.草原与草坪,(2):46~48
徐苏凌,方勇,马美蓉,楼月琴.2009.不同施肥处理对苜蓿生长特性的影响研究.牧草科学,2:23~24
徐志伟.2001.退耕坡地紫花苜蓿技术探讨.青海畜牧兽医杂志,31(5):14~15
杨利民,周广胜,李建东2002.松嫩平原草地群落物种多样性与生产力关系的研究.植物生态学报,26(5):589~593
姚骅,陆建华,蔡立群,董博,张仁陟.2009.玛曲退化草地主要植被特征对不同施肥
姚骅.2008.施肥对玛曲退化草地植物群落特征的影响[硕士学位论文].甘肃兰州:甘肃农业大学
鱼小平,师尚礼,龙瑞军,王芳,陈本建.2006.生态条件对种子萌发影响研究进展.草业科学,23(10):44~49
袁建立.2004.生物多样性与生态系统功能关系的实验研究[博士学位论文].兰州:兰州大学
袁志忠,何丙辉.2004.生态位理论及其在植物种群研究中的应用.福建林业科技,(2):123~127
曾庆飞.2005.施肥对紫花苜蓿生产性能和土壤肥力的影响研究[硕士学位论文].陕西杨凌:西北农林科技大学
张大勇,姜新华.1997.群落内物种多样性发生与维持的一个假说.生物多样性,5(3):161~167
张积祥,李松.1990.紫花苜蓿N P肥配施研究.草业科学,(7):70~72
张继义,赵哈林,张铜会,赵学勇.2003.科尔沁沙地植物群落恢复演替系列种群生态位动态特征.生态学报,23(12):2741~2746
张少民.2007.黄土高原沟壑区苜蓿草地生产力及其环境效应研究[硕士学位论文].陕西杨凌:西北农林科技大学
张新时.2000.草地的生态经济功能及其范式.科技导报,8:3~7
张耀生,董新全.2002.高寒牧区中华羊茅人工草地退化演替的数量特征研究.应用生态学报,13(3):285~289
张永亮,郑春芳,胡自治.2004.施肥对无芒雀麦+杂花苜蓿混播草地组分种产量的影响.草原与草坪, 4:33~38
赵永华,雷瑞德,何兴元,贾夏.2004.秦岭锐齿栎林种群生态位特征研究.应用生态学报,15(6),913~918
周国英,陈桂琛,赵以莲,王顺忠,李伟,彭敏.2004.施肥和围栏封育对青海湖地区高寒草原影响的比较研究:I群落特征及其物种多样性.草业学报, 13(1):26~31
周华坤,赵兴全,赵亮,韩发,古松.2007.高山草甸垂穗披碱人工草地群落特征及稳定性研究.中国草地学报,29(2):13~25
周青平,金继运,德科加,徐成体.2005.不同施氮水平对高寒草地牧草增产效益的研究.土壤肥料,(3):29~31.
周志宇,付华,陈亚明,吴彩霞,李雪瑞,朱兴运,甘红军,爱东.2003.阿拉善荒漠草地恢复演替过程中物种多样性与生产力的变化.草业学报,12(1):34~40