博士生科研绩效及其影响因素的实证研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
从上世纪七十年代以来,越来越多的学者开始关注于国家、高等院校和科研工作者的科研产出研究(Dundar and Lewis,1998)。相关研究的关注点主要在国家、高校等组织以及教员等个体科研工作者层面,对博士生科研产出的研究较少(Chung and Petrick,2011),国内学者对该主题的研究还停留在理论论述、思辨的层面上,缺少以数据为支撑的实证研究,因此对一些现象、作用机理、原因和对策的解释力度不足。我国博士生教育有一定的中国特色,将国外的研究成果套用在国内的教育背景下显得有些水土不服,不能适应中国的教育体制,故本文以中国的博士生为研究对象,搜集相关数据,基于实证研究的思路构建博士生科研绩效影响因素模型,找出提升博士生科研绩效的关键因素,进而弥补这一缺口。
     博士生科研绩效是指博士生攻读博士学位时所创造出的科研产出,直接体现为:科研论文、参与研发项目和专利发明,是博士生科研能力的重要反映。笔者认为博士生科研绩效水平能够有效地反映出博士生培养质量的优劣;对影响博士生科研绩效的关键因素进行深入分析,进而发现我国博士教育存在的主要问题,寻找到博士质量提升的关键点和有效途径。本论文在总结现有科研绩效测量方法优劣的基础上,结合我国博士教育的特点,提出根据SCI分区对学术论文质量进行排序分级,并设置相应权重的测量方法。该方法在很大程度上避免了学科差异的影响,使得测量结果可以用于不同学科之间的比较研究。
     本论文对博士生科研绩效的影响因素进行了积极的探索,为了扩展和丰富现有教育理论,试图建立社会资本与博士生科研绩效管理之间的联系。考虑到中国人文化中“关系”这一概念,与西方观念中的"social network"类似(Gold et al.,2002)。国内外学者和实践家普遍将“关系”(guanxi)视为是中国社会中,个体在社会生活、工作等方方面面取得成功的必备要素。因此,本论文将这一概念引入到博士生教育的研究中来,在研究2中初步证实了师生关系对博士生科研绩效有着重要促进作用。进而在研究3中进一步拓展了“关系”的范围,基于社会资本理论,重点探究博士生与导师之间的人际关系,以及与周围同学建立的良好关系对博士生自身科研活动的开展和科研成果的产出的影响机理。因此,本论文的研究工作和研究结果,搭建了运用社会资本理论所诠释的“关系”来探究博士生科研绩效的理论桥梁。
     国外学者普遍认为:个体在创新过程中需要在与外部建立各种接触,因此其个人的社会资源在创新中将发挥重要作用(Amabile,1983; Amabile et al.,1996; Woodman et al.,1993)。基于社会资本理论,导师因素是影响博士生科研绩效社会网络中的一个节点,而同学可以看作是其它节点,这些相互连接的节点构成了博士生科研绩效的社会网络。博士生的科研活动具有显著的创新特征,是一种富有创造性的工作,本论文有理由认为博士生的社会资本对其科研绩效有重要的促进作用。
     本论文拟建立个自身因素、导师因素和社会资本与博士生科研绩效的研究模型,同时引入主观态度和组织氛围作为情境变量,来探究影响我国博士生科研绩效的关键点;采用渐进式研究方法,设计以下三个子研究来逐步开展:
     1)研究1利用二手数据对博士生科研绩效的影响因素进行初步探索;
     2)研究2是基于研究1取得的成果,采用问卷调研方法来深入探究导师对博士生科研绩效的影响;
     3)研究3是基于两个子研究的研究成果,从社会资本的角度,对研究变量进行深度挖掘,分析以同学和导师为重要节点的社会网络对博士生科研绩效的影响;同时进一步检验博士生目标导向和组织氛围等情境变量在社会资本和与博士生科研绩效关系中的调节作用。
     研究结果表明:
     1)相对于其他博士生,本科毕业于“985”院校的博士生倾向于表现出较高的科研绩效水平;
     2)导师是提升博士生科研绩效的关键;
     3)博士生主观的科研兴趣在导师因素和博士生科研绩效之间的关系中起着重要的调节作用;
     4)博士生拥有的社会资本对其科研绩效水平有着显著影响;
     5)博士生目标导向和组织氛围作为情境因素在社会资本与科研绩效之间的关系中起着调节作用。
     研究结果表明提升博士生科研绩效并非是一日之功,需要博士生自身、导师和院校等多主体的协同努力,将质量提升贯穿于博士生培养过程中的各个环节。本文取得的研究成果不仅做出了重要的理论贡献,而且为博士生、教育工作者、培养单位和教育主管部门等提出了一些有价值的建议,具有重要的实践价值。
Since1970s, more and more scholars pay attention to the research performance of states, colleges and individual researcher (Dundar and Lewis,1998). Related researches mainly focus on states,college and individual researcher, but only less focus on the doctoral students (Chung and Petrick,2011). And the domestic research are still on theoticaland qualitative level, which lack of the empirical research based on data, as result, the explaination of phenomenon, mechanism, reason and suggestion are inadequate. In China, the doctoral educationhas unique characteristic, so some foreign research achievements cannot fit the Chineseeducation system very well. Therefore, in order to fix up the gap, this thesis would collect relateddata and build a theoretical model to do empirical research, finally find out the key factors on how to improve doctoral student research performance (DRP).
     DRP refers to the research outcomes of doctoral students in a certain period, such as academic paper, research project and patent, which could reflect the individual research ability.The author concerns that DRP will directly reflected the quality of doctoral education effectively.Therefore, deeply exploring the influential factors of DRP could help us to identify the major problems on doctoral education, further, the key point and effective approach to improve the quality of doctoral education could be obtained. The research object of this thesis is the doctoral students of china, combined with the evaluation of existing performance measurement and the characteristics of the doctoral students of China, according to the SCIto categorize the academic papers, and set the weights of different categories. This method could avoid the difference of disciplines to a large extent, so this measurement could be used for comparative study between different disciplines.
     In order to enlarge existing education theory, this thesis made a great progress in the exploration of influence factors of DRP, at the same time, an relationship between social capital and management of DRP has been build. Take the conception of "guanxi" into consideration in the background of Chinese culture, whichis similar to the concept of social network in west (Gold et al.,2002). Most of scholars thought that "guanxi" is significant to one's success in Chinese society. Therefore, in this thesis, in order to get the influence effect of "guanxi"on DRP,"social capital" would be taken into consideration. In Study2, the initial conclusion has proved that the relationship between doctoral students and their mentor have a significant positive effect on DRP. In Study3, based on social capital theory, the author expands the range of "guanxi", focus on the relations between doctoral students and mentors, and the relations between different doctoral students. Therefore, this thesis could build a bridge for using social theory to study the DRP.
     Some foreign scholars generally suggest that one should build some relationship with externals, and his social capital would play an important role in his innovation process(Amabile,1983; Amabile et al.,1996; Woodman et al.,1993). Based on social capital theory, in doctoral social network, mentor factor is s key node, and his research partners and classmates can be recognized as other nodes, so nodes together with eachother can be regarded as the social network of DRP. The research activitiesof doctoral student haveremarkablecharacteristics of innovation, therefore, we hypothesis that the social capital play an important role in DRP, then do an empirical research.
     This thesis build a research model of DRP, which include individual factor, mentor factor, social capital, and the situational variable (subjective attitude and organizational environment), to explore the influential factors of DRP. Dates can be collected from database and questionnaire, and three sub-studies will develop one by one.
     1)Study lwould initially explore the influence factors of DRP by secondary data.
     2)Based on the results of Study1, Study2would deeply research on the relationship between mentor factors and DRP by survey.
     3) Based on Study1and Study2, from the perspective of social capital, Study3would make a deep excavation in variables, further, we study on how the social capital (including mentor and classmate) influence DRP and the suggestion about how to improve the doctoral education could be obtained. Also, we analysis the moderating effects of the situational variables between social capital and DRP.
     The results show that,
     1) Compare with other students, the doctoral students who finish their undergraduate education in "985" universities have a higher research performance in their doctoral program.
     2) Mentor factor is the key factor in improving DRP.
     3) Relationships between mentor factors and DRP are significantly moderated by doctoral student's research interest.
     4) Social capital positively related to DRP.
     5) Relationships between social capital and DRP are significantly moderated by situational factors, including goal orientation and organizational environment as situational factors have a regulatory effect on the relationship between social capital and DRP.
     The results show that improvement ofDRP could not achieve in one day, individual, mentors and university should make efforts together, and the quality improvement should run through the whole process of doctoral education. This thesis make some theoretical contributions, meanwhile, it also provides guidance for doctoral students, mentors, university and education ministry.
引文
Adler PS., Kwon SW.2002. Social capital:Prospects for a new concept [J]. Academy of Management Review,27(1):17-40.
    Ainley, M.2006. Connecting with learning:Motivation, Affect and Cognition in Interest Process [J]. Education Psychological Review,18(4):391-405.
    Amabile TM.1983. The social psychology of creativity:a componential conceptualization [J]. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,45(2):357-376.
    Amabile TM., Conti R, Coon H.1996. Assessing the work enviornment for creativity [J]. Academy of Management Journal,39(5):1154-1184.
    Amabile TM., Conti R.1999. Changes in the work environment for Creativity during Downsizing [J]. Academy of Management Journal,42(6):630-640.
    Ames C.1992. Classroom:Goals, structures, and student motivation [J]. Journal of Educational Psychology,84:261-271.
    Anderson SE, Williams LJ.1996. Interpersonal, job, and individual factors related to helping processes at work [J]. Journal of Applied Psychology,81(3):282-296.
    AnnMM, Cannella Jr.AA.2004. Social capital and knowledge creation:diminishing returns of the number and strength of exchange relationships [J]. Academy of Management Journal,47(5): 735-746.
    Asmar C.1999. Is there a gendered agenda in academia? The research experience of female and male PhD graduates in Ausrlian universities [J]. Higher Education,38(3):225-273.
    Astin HS.1969. The woman doctorate in America [M]. New York:Russell Sage Fondation.
    Baker WE.1990. Market networks and corporate behavior [J]. American Journal of Sociology, 96(3):589-625.
    Baloch I.2006. Leadership skills and styles [R]//Report of first 6 week training programme on educational leadership and institutional management under elim project. Academy of Educational Planning and Management,139-143. Ministry of Education, Islamabad.
    Barnes BJ, Austin, A.E.2009. The role of doctoral advisors:A look at advising from the advisor's perspective [J]. Innovative Higher Education,33(5):297-315.
    Bayer AE, Dutton J.1977.Career age and research-professional activity of academic scientists [J]. Journal of Higher Education,48(3):259-282.
    Bland CJ, Center BA, Finstad DA., Risebey KR., Justin GJ.2005. A Theoretical, practical,
    predictive model of faculty and department research productivity [J]. Academic Medicine,80(3): 225-237.
    Bornmann L, Daniel HD.2005. Selection of research fellowship recipients by committee peer review. Reliability, fairness and predictive validity of board of trustees'decisions [J]. Scientometrics,63(2):297-320.
    Bourdieu P.1985.The forms of social capital:Handbook of theory and research for the sociology of education [M]. New York:Greenwood Press.
    Braxton JM., Bayer AE.1986. Assessing faculty scholarly performance [M]//In J. W. Creswell (ed.), Measuring Faculty Research Performance. New Directions for Institutional Research. San Francisco:Jossey-Bass.
    Brett JF, VandeWalle D.1999. Goal orientation and goal content as predictors of performance in a training program [J]. Journal of Applied Psychology,84:863-873.
    Brewer GA, Douglas JW, Facer ⅡRL, O'Toole Jr. L.1999. Determinants of graduate research productivity in doctoral programs of public administration [J]. Public Administration Review, 59(5):373-382.
    Brewer GA, Facer R.LⅡ, O'Toole Jr. L, Douglas JW.1999. What's in a Name? Comparing DPA and Ph.D. programs [J]. Journal of Public Affairs Education,5(4):309-317.
    Brusa J, Carter M, Heilman GE.2010. Academic content, research productivity, and tenure [J]. Journal of Economics & Finance,34:46-60.
    Bryk A, Schneider B.2002. Trust in schools:A core resource for improvement [M]. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
    Bucheit S, Collins AB, Collins DL.2001. Intra-institutional factors that influence accounting research productivity [J]. The Journal of Applied Business Research,17(2):17-31.
    Burt RS.1992.Structural Holes:The Social Structure of Competition. Cambridge [M]. MA: Harvard University Press.
    Burt R.1997. The contingent value of social capital [J]. Administrative Science Quarterly,42(2): 339-365.
    Canibano C, Otamendi J, Andujar I.2008. Measuring and assessing researcher mobility from CV analysis:the case of the Ramony Cajal programme in Spain [J]. Research Evaluation,17(1): 17-31.
    Carter CR.2002. Assessing logistics and transportation journals:Alternative perspectives [J]. Transportation Journal,42(2):39-50.
    Chen CC.2008. The of value knowledge created by individual scientists and research groups [J] Journal of Scholarly Publishing, April,274-293.
    Chiaburu DS, Harrison, D.A.2008. Do peers make the place? Conceptual synthesis and meta-analysis of coworker effects on perceptions, attitudes, OCBs, and performance [J]. Journal of Applied Psychology,93(5):1082-1103.
    Chin WW, Marcolin BL, Newsted PR.1996. A partial least squareslatent variable modeling approach for measuring interaction effects:results from a monte carlo simulation study and voice mail emotion/adoption study[C]. Proceedings of the Seventeenth International Conference on Information Systems. Cleveland, Ohio, U.S.21-41.
    Chiu CM. Hsu MH, Wang EG.2006. Understanding knowledge sharing in virtual communities: An integration of social capital and social cognitive theories [J]. Decision Support Systems, 42(3):1872-1888.
    Chung WY, Guinan PJ.1994. Effects of participative management [C]. Proceeding of ACM SIGCPR conference.
    Chung JY, Petrick J.2011. Doctoral students'research productivity:an analysis of publications in tourism and hospitality journals [J]. Journal of Hospitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism Education, 10(1):63-71.
    Cole JR, Singer B.1991. A theory of limited differences:explaining the productivity puzzle in science [M]//In Zuckerman, H., Cole, J.R. and Bruer, J.T. (Eds.), The Outer Circle:women in the scientific community, Chapter 13,227-340. New York:W.W. Nortaon and Co.
    Coleman J.1988. Social capital in the creation of human capital [J]. American Journal of Sociology,94:95-120.
    Coleman JS.1990.Foundations of social theory [M]. Cambridge:Harvard University Press.
    Cook M, Campbell DT.1979. Qusai-experimentation:design & analysis issues for field settings [M]. Houghton Mifflin Boston.
    Cornelius-White J.2007. Learner-centered teacher-student relationships are effective:A meta analysis [J]. Review of Educational Research,77(1):13-143.
    Crompton JL.2005. Issues related to sustaining a long-term research interest in tourism [J]. Journal of Tourism Studies,16(2):34-43.
    Cross R, Borgatti S, Parker A.2002. Making invisible work visible [J]. California Management Review,44(2):25-46.
    Cross R, Cummings J.2004. Tie and network correlates of individual performance in knowledge-intensive work [J]. Academy of Management Journal,47(6):928-937.
    Cummings A, Oldham GR.1997.Enhancing creativity:managing work contexts for the high potential employee [J]. California Management Review,40(1):22-38.
    Dahar MA, Faize FA, Niwaz A, Hussain MA, Zaman A.2010. Relationship between the
    leadership styles and academic achievement at the secondary stage in Punjab [J]. International Journal of Academic Research,2(6):458-461.
    Den BrokP, van Tartwijk J, Wubbels T,Veldman I.2010. The differential effect of the teacher-student interpersonal relationship on student outcomes for students with different ethnic backgrounds. British Journal of Educational Psychology,80(2):199-221.
    Delamont S, Atkinson PA, Parry O.2000. The doctoral experience:success and failure in graduate school [M]. London, Falmer Press.
    Denicolo P.2004. Doctoral supervision of colleagues:Peeling off the veneer of satisfaction and competence [J]. Studies in Higher Education,29(6):693-707.
    Dhanaraj C, Lyles MA, Steensma HK, Tihanyi L.2004. Managing tacit and explicit knowledge transfer in IJVs:the role of relational embeddedness and the impact on performance [J]. Journal of International Business Stuidies,35(5):428-442.
    Dundar H, Lewis DR.1998. Determinants of research productivity in higher education [J]. Research in Higher Education,39(6):607-631.
    Dweck C.1986. Motivational processes affecting learning [J]. American Psychologist,41(10): 1040-1048.
    Dweck C, Leggett E.1988. A social-cognitive approach to motivation and personality [J]. Psychological Review,95(2):256-273.
    Elliot AJ, Dweck CJ.1988. Goal:an approach to motivation and achievement [J]. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,54(1):5-12.
    Ellis EM.2001. The impact of race and gender on graduate school socialization, satisfaction with doctoral study, and commitment to degree completion [J]. The Western Journal of Black Studies, 25(1):30-45.
    Endler NS, Rushton JP, RoedigerⅢ HL.1978. Productivity and scholarly impact of British, Candian and U.S. departments of psychology 1875 [J]. American Psychologist,33(11): 1064-1082.
    Faraj S, Sproull L.2000. Coordinating expertise in software development teams [J]. Management Science,46(2):1554-1568.
    Ferris JM., Stallings RA.1988. Sources of reputation among public administration and public affairs program [J]. American Review of Public Administration,18(3):309-323. Fleming L, Mingo S, Chen D.2007. Collaborative brokerage, generative creativity, and creative success [J]. Administrative Science Quarterly,52(3):443-475.
    Fox MF.1999. Gender, knowledge, and scientific styles [J]. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences,869(1):89-93.
    Fukuyana F.1995.Trust:the social virtues and the creation of prosperity [M]. New York:Free Press.
    Garcia-Aracil A, Gracia AG, et al.2006. Analysis of the evaluation process of the research performance:An empirical case [J]. Scientometrics,67(2):213-230.
    Garfield E.1979. Citation indexing:Its theory and applications in science, technology, and humanities [M]. Free Press, New York.
    George JM. Zhou J.2007. Dual tuning in a supportive context:joint contributions of positive mood, negative mood, and supervisory behaviors to employee creativity [J].Academy of Management Journal,50(3):605-622.
    Gerstner CR, Day DV.1997. Meta-analytic review of leader-member exchange theory:Correlates and construct issues [J]. Journal of Applied Psychology,82(6):827-844.
    Gilson LL, Shalley CE.2004. A little creativity goes a long way:An examination of teams' engagement in creative processes [J]. Journal of Management,30(4):453-470.
    Gold T, Guthrie D, Wank DL.2002. Social connections in china:the institutions, culture and the hanging nature of guanxi [M]. Cambride, UK:Cambridge University Press.
    Graen GB, Uhl-Bien M.1995. Relationship-based approach to leadership:Development of leader-member exchange (LMX) theory of leadership over 25 years:Applying a multi-level
    multi-domain perspective [J]. Leadership Quarterly,6(2):219-247.
    Granovetter MS.1973. The strength of weak ties [J]. American Journal of Sociology, 78(6):1360-1380.
    Greene BA, Miller RB.1996. Influences on achievement:Goals, perceived ability, and cognitive engagement [J]. Contemporary Educational Psychology,21(2):181-192.
    Greene BA, Miller RB, Crowson HM, Duke BL, Akey KL.2004. Predicting high school students' cognitive engagement and achievement:contributions of classroom perceptions and motivation [J]. Contemporary Educational Psychology,29(4):462-482.
    Greve A, Salaff J.2001. The development of corporate social capital in complex innovation processes [J]. Social capital of organizations,18:107-134.
    Gulbrandsen M, Smeby JC.2005. Industry funding and university professors'research performance [J]. Research Policy,34(6):932-950.
    Hair JF, AndersonRE, Tatham RL, Black WC.1988. Multivariate data analysis [M]. Prentice Hall: Englewood Cliffs, NJ.
    Haksever AM, Manisali E.2000. Assessing supervision requirements of PhD students:the case of construction management and engineering in the UK [J]. European Journal of Engineering Education,25(1):19-32.
    Hansen MT.1999. The search-transfer problem:the role of weak ties in sharing knowledge across organization subunits [J]. Administrative Science Quarterly,44(1):82-111.
    Hall BH, Mairesse J, Turner L.2007. Identifying age, cohort, and period effects in scientific research productivity:discussion and illustration using simulated and actual data on French physicists [J]. Economic Innovation and New Technology,16(2):159-177.
    Hamovitch W, Morgenstern RD. 1977.Children and productivity of academic women [J]. Journal of Higher Education,48(6):633-645.
    Harackiewicz JM, Barron KE, Elliot AJ.1998. Rethinking achievement goals:When are they adaptive for college students and why? [J]. Educational Psychologist,33(1):1-21.
    Harackiewicz JM, Barron KE, Pintrich PR, Elliot AJ, Thrash TM.2002. Revision of achievement goal theory:Necessary and illuminating [J]. Journal of Educational Psychology,94(3):638-645.
    Harris G, Kaine G.1994. The determinants of research performance—A study of Australian university economists [J]. Higher Education,27(2):191-201.
    Heath T.2002. A quantitative analysis of PhD students'view of supervision [J]. Higher Education Research & Development,21(1):41-53.
    Hedjazi Y, Behravan J.2011. Study of factors influencing research productivity of agriculture faculty members in Iran [J]. Higher Education,62(5):635-647.
    Hekelman FP, Zyzanski SJ, Flocke SA.1995. Successful and less-successful research performance of junior faculty [J]. Research in Higher Education,36(2):235-255.
    HemlinS, Gustafsson M.1996. Research production in the arts and humanities:A questionnaire study of factors influencing research performance [J]. Scientometrics,37(3):417-432.
    HirschJE.2005. An index to quantify an individual's scientific research output [C]. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America,102(46):16569-16572.
    Hirsch JE.2007. Does the h index have predictive power? [C]. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences,104(49):19193-19198.
    Hogan TD.1981. Faculty Research Activity and the Quality of Graduate Training [J]. Journal of Human Resources,16(3):400-415.
    Isaksen SG, Lauer KJ, Ekvall G.1999. Situational outlook questionnaire:a measure of the climate for creativity and change [J]. Psychological Reports,85(2):665-674.
    Ives G, Rowley G.2005. Supervisor selection or allocation and continuity of supervision:PhD students'progress and outcomes [J]. Studies in Higher Education,30(5):535-555.
    Janssen O, Van Yperen NW.2004. Employees'goal orientations, the quality of leader-member exchange and the outcomes of job performance and job satisfaction [J]. Academy of Management Journal,47(3):368-384.
    Jarvelin K, Persson O.2008. The DCI index:Discounted cumulated impact-based research evaluation [J]. Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology,59(9): 1433-1440.
    John R, Schoermerhorn JR.1975. Determinants of interiorganizational cooperation [J]. Academy of Management Journal,18(4):846-856.
    Kim K, Karau SJ.2010. Working environment and the research productivity of doctoral students in management [J]. Journal of education for business,85(2):101-106.
    Klyver K, Hindle K, Meyer D.2008. Influence of social network structure on entrepreneurship participation:a study of 20 national cultures [J]. International Entrepreneurship Management Journal,4(3):331-347.
    Krackhardt D.1992. The strength of strong ties [M].//In N. Nohria & R.G. Ecccles (Eds.). Networks and organizations:structure, form and action,216-239. Boston:Harvard Business School Press.
    Krause DR, Handfield RB, Beverly BB.2006. The relationships between supplier development, commitment, social capital accumulation and performance improvement [J]. Journal of Operations Management,25(2):528-545.
    Kyvik S.1995. Are big university departments better than small ones? [J]. Higher Education, 30(3):295-304.
    Landry R, Amara N, Lamari M.2002. Does social capital determine innovation? To what extent [J]. Technological Forecasting and Social Change,69(7):681-701.
    Law R, Chon K.2007. Evaluating research performance in tourism and hospitality:the perspective of university program heads [J]. Tourism Management,28(5):1203-1211.
    Lazega E.1999. Generalized exchange and economic performance:Social embeddedness of labor contracts in a corporate law partnership [M].//In R. Leeners & S. Gabbay (Eds.), Corporate social capital and liability,237-265. Boston:Kluwer Academic Publishers.
    Leana C, Pil FK.2006. Social capital and organizational performance:Evidence from urban public schools [J]. Organization Science,17(3):353-366.
    Leana C, Pil FK.2009.Applying organizational research to public school reform:the effects of teacher human and social capital on student performance [J]. Academy of Management Journal, 52(6):1101-1124.
    Lee A.2008. How are doctoral students supervised? Concepts of doctoral research supervision [J]. Studies in Higher Education,33(3):267-281.
    LiCK., Hung CH.2009. The influence of transformational leadership on workplace relationships and job performance [J]. Social Behavior and Personality,37(8):1129-1142.
    Li L.2005. The effects of trust and shared vision on in-ward knowledge transfer in subsidiaries' intra- and inter-organizational relationships [J]. International Business Review,14(1):77-95.
    Li S, Seale, C.2007. Managing criticism in PhD supervision:A qualitative case study [J]. Studies in Higher Education,32(4):511-526.
    Liden RC, Wayne S J, Sparrowe RT.2000. An examination of the mediating role of psychological empowerment on the relations between the job, interpersonal relationships, and work outcomes [J]. Journal of Applied Psychology,85(3):407-416.
    Lin N, Dumin M.1986. Access to occupations through social ties [J]. Social Networks,8(4): 365-385.
    Lin, N.1999.Social networks and status attainment [M].//In J. Hagan & K. Cook (Eds.), Annual review of sociology,25:467-487. Palo Alto, CA:Annual Reviews.
    Lin N.2001.Building a network theory of social capital in social capital theory and research [M]. New York:Aldinede Gruyter Press.
    LinnenbrinkEA.2005. The dilemma of performance-approach goals:The use of multiple goal contexts to promote students' motivation and learning [J]. Journal of Educational Psychology, 97(2):197-213.
    Long RG, Bowers WP, Barnett T, White M.1998. Research productivity of graduates in management:effects of academic origin and academic affiliation [J]. Academy of Management Journal,41(6):704-714.
    Long JS.2001. From scarcity to visibility:Gender differences in the careers of doctoral scientists and engineers [M]. Washington, DC:National Academy Press.
    Ilies R, Nahrgang JD,Morgeson FP.2007. Leader-member exchange and citizenship behaviors:A meta-analysis [J]. Journal of Applied Psychology,92(1):269-277.
    Iqbal M. 2005. Organizational structure, leadership style and physical facilities of public and private secondary schools in Punjab and their effect on school effectiveness [D]:[Ph.D.]. Lahore:University of the Punjab, IER.
    Mainhard T, van der Rijst R, van Tartwijk J, Wubbels T.2009. A model for the supervisor-doctoral student relationship [J]. Higher Education,58(3):359-373.
    Martin-Sempere MJ, Garzon-Garcia B, Rey-Rocha J.2008. Team consolidation, social integration and scientists'research performance:An empirical study in the Biology and Biomedicine field [J]. Scientometrics,76(3):457-482.
    Meho LI, Sonnenwald DH.2000. Citation ranking versus peer evaluation of senior faculty research performance:A case study of Kurdish scholarship [J]. Journal of the American Society for Information Science,51(2):123-138.
    Meyerson E.1994. Human capital, social capital and compensation:The relative contribution of social contacts to managers'incomes [J]. Acta Sociologica,37(4):383-399.
    McAlpine L, Norton J.2006. Reframing out approach to doctoral programs:An integrative framework for action and research [J]. Higher Education Research & Development,25(1):3-17.
    Michaelowa K, Borrmann A.2006. Evaluation bias and incentive structures in bi and multilateral aid agencies [J]. Review of Development Economics,10(2):313-329.
    Milburn LS, Brown RD.2003. The relationship of age, gender, and education to research productivity in landscape architecture faculty in north America [J]. Landscape Journal,22(1): 54-62.
    Moran P.2005. Structural vs relational embeddedness:social capital and managerial performance [J]. Strategic Management Journal,26:1129-1151.
    Mullen MR.1995. Diagnosing measurement equivalence in cross-national research [J]. Journal of International Business Studies,26(3):573-596.
    Nahapiet J, Ghoshal S.1998. Social capital, Intellectual capital, and the organizational advantage [J]. Academy of Management Review,23(2):242-266.
    Ng CH.2006. The role of achievement goals in completing a course assignment:Examining the effects of performance-approach and multiple goals [J]. Open Learning,21(1):33-48.
    Obsfeld D.2005.Social networks, the tertius lungens orientation, and involvement in innovation [J]. Administrative Science Quarterly,50(1):100-130.
    Ogbogu CO.2009.An analysis of female research productivity in Nigerian universities [J]. Journal of Higher Education Policy and Management,31(1):17-22.
    Oldham GR, Cummings A.1996. Employee creativity:personal and contextual factors at work [J]. Academy of Management Journal,39(3):607-634.
    Orr J.1996. Talking about machines:An ethnography of a modern job [M]. Ithaca, NY:Cornell University Press.
    Oxoby R.2009. Understanding social inclusion, social cohesion and social capital [J]. International Journal of Social Economics,36(12):1133-1152.
    Papa M.1990.Communication network patterns and employee performance with a new technology [J]. Communications Research,17(3):344-368.
    Parolia N, Goodman S, Li Y, Jiang JJ.2007. Mediators between coordination and IS project performance [J]. Information & Management,44(7):635-645.
    Pastoriza D, Arino M, Ricart JE.2008. Ethical managerial behavior as an antecedent of organizational social capital [J]. Journal of Business Ethics,78(3):329-341.
    Pastoriza D, Arino M, Ricart JE.2009.Creating an ethical work context:a pathway to generate social capital in the firm [J]. Journal of Business Ethics,88(3):477-489.
    Perry-SmithJE.2006. Social yet creative:the role of social relationships in facilitating individual creativity [J]. Academy of Management Journal,49(1):85-101.
    Pinsonneault A, Kraemer KL.1993. Survey research methodologh in management information systems:An assessment [J]. Journal of Management Information Systems,10(2):75-105.
    Pintrich PR, Garcia T.1991. Student goal orientation and self-regulation in the college classroom [M]//In M. Maehr & P. Pintrich (Eds.), Advances in motivation and achievement 7:371-402. Greenwich, CT:JAI Press.
    Podolny JM, James N.1997. Resources and relationships:social networks and mobility in the workplace [J]. American Sociological Review,62(5):673-693.
    Pogrow S.1998. The effect of age on the attitude and performance of doctoral students at Stanford University [J]. Education,98(1):78-81.
    Portes A.1998. Social capital:its origins and applications in modern sociology [J]. Annual Review of Sociology,24(1):1-24.
    Prpic K.2000. The publication productivity of young scientists:An empirical study [J]. Scientometrics,49(3):453-490.
    Rad AMM, Yarmuhammadian MH.2006. A study of relationship between the managers' leadership style and employees' job satisfaction [J]. Leadership in Health Services,19(2): xi-xxviii.
    Ramsden P.1994. Using research on student learning to enhance educational quality [M]//In G. Gibbs (Ed.), Improving Student Learning-Theory and Practice. Oxford:Oxford Centre for Staff Development.
    Ramsden P, Moses I.1992. Associations between research and teaching in Australian higher education [J]. Higher Education,23(3):273-295.
    Rey-Rocha J, Martin-Sempere MJ, Garzon-Garcia B.2002. Research productivity of scientists in consolidated vs. non-consolidated teams:the case of Spanish University Geologists [J]. Scientometrics,55(1):137-156.
    Rey-Rocha J, Garzon-Garcia B, Martin-Sempere MJ.2007. Exploring social integration as a determinant of research activity, performance and prestige of scientists:Empirical evidence in the Biology and Biomedicine field [J]. Scientometrics,72(1):59-80.
    Rodan S, Galunic C.2004. More than network structure:how knowledge heterogeneity influences managerial performance and innovativeness [J]. Strategic Management Journal,25(6):541-562.
    Rowley T, Behrens D, Krachhardt D.2000. Redundant governance structures:an analysis of structural and relational embeddedness in the steel and semiconductor industries [J]. Strategic Management Journal,21(3):369-386.
    Roy KM, Roberts MC, Stewart PK.2006. Research productivity and academic lineage in clinical psychology:who is training the faculty to do research? [J]. Journal of clinical psychology, 62(7):893-905.
    Schiefele U.1992. Topic interest and levels of textcomprehension [C].//In Renninger KA, Hidi S, Krapp A. (Eds). The role of interest inlearning and development. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Inc.151-181.
    Seers A.1989. Team-member exchange quality:A new construct for role-making research [J]. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,43(1):118-135.
    Settoon RP, Mossholder KW.2002. Relationship quality and relationship context as antecedents of person-and task-focused interpersonal citizenship behavior [J]. Journal of Applied Psychology, 87(2):255-267.
    Shalley CE.1995. Effects of coaction, expected evaluation, and goal setting on creativity and productivity [J]. Academy of Management Journal,38(2):483-503.
    Shalley CE, Glison LL, Blum TC.2000. Matching creativity requirements and the work environment:effects on satisfaction and intentions to leave [J]. Academy of Management Journal 43(2):215-223.
    Sherony KM, Green SG.2002. Coworker exchange:Relationships between coworkers, leader-member exchange, and work attitudes [J]. Journal of Applied Psychology,87(3): 542-548.
    Shih SS.2005a. Role of achievement goals in children's learning in Taiwan [J]. Journal of Educational Research,98(5):310-319.
    Shih SS.2005b. Taiwanese sixth graders'achievement goals and their motivation, strategy use, and grades:An examination of the multiple goal perspective [J]. Elementary School Journal, 106(1):39-58.
    Sias PM, Smith G, Avdeyeva T.2003. Sex and sex-composition differences and similarities in peer workplace friendship development [J]. Communication Studies,54(3):322-340.
    Sias PM.2005. Workplace relationship quality and employee information experience [J]. Communication Studies,56(4):375-395.
    Smeby JC, Try S.2005. Departmental contexts and faculty research activity in Norway [J]. Research in Higher Education,46(6):593-619.
    So CYK.1998. Citation ranking versus expert judgment in evaluating communication scholars: effects of research specialty size and individual prominence [J]. Scientometrics,41(3):325-333.
    Spender J.1996. Organizational knowledge, learning and memory:Three concepts in search of a
    theory [J]. Journal of Organizational Change Management,9(1):63-78.
    Stack S.2004. Gender and scholarly productivity [J]. Sociological Forces,35(3):285-296.
    Straub D, Karahanna E.1998. Knowledge worker communications and recipient availability: Toward a task closure explanation of media choice [J]. Organization Science,9(2):160-175.
    Straub D, Boudreau MC, Gefen D.2004. Validation guide lines for IS positivist research [J]. Communications of the Association for Information Systems.13(1):380-427.
    Subramaniam N, Youndt MA.2005. The influence of intellectual capital on the types of innovative capabilities [J]. Academy of Management Journal,48(3):450-463.
    Sunindijo RY, Hadikusumo BHW, Ogunlana S.2007. Emotional intelligence and leadership styles in construction project management [J]. Journal of Management in Engineering,23(4): 166-170.
    Tsai W, Ghoshal S.1998. Social capital and value creation:the role of intrafirim networks [J]. Academy of Management Journal,41(4):464-476.
    Tasi YC.2006. Effect of social capital and absorptive capacity on innovation in internet marketing [J]. International Journal of Management,23(1):157-166.
    Teodorescu D.2000.Correlates of faculty publication productivity:A cross-national analysis [J]. Higher Education,39(2):201-222.
    Theoharakis V, Hirst A.2002. Perceptual differences of marketing journals:A worldwide perspective [J]. Marketing Letters,13(4):389-402.
    Tien FF.2000. To what degree does the desire for promotion motivate faculty to perform research? Testing the expectancy theory [J]. Research in Higher Education,41(6):723-752.
    Tien FF.2008. What kind of faculty are motivated to perform research by the desire for promotion? [J]. Higher Education,55(1):17-32.
    Tracey TJ.1994. An examination of complementarity of interpersonal behavior [J]. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,67(5):864-878.
    Turner JH. (1999). The Formation of social capital [M].//In P. Dasgupta & Serageldin, I. (Eds.). Social capital:A multifaceted perspective,94-146.Washington DC:World Bank.
    Turner L, Mairesse J.2003. Explaining individual productivity difference in scientific research productivity:How important are institutional and individual determinants?[J].Condensed matter, 1380-1997.
    Urdan TC.1997. Achievement goal theory:Past results, future directions [M]//In M. L. Maehr & P. R. Pintrich (Eds.), Advances in motivation and achievement, Greenwich, CT:JAI Press,10: 99-141.
    VandeWalle D, Cron WL, Slocum JW.2001. The role of goal orientation following performance feedback [J]. Journal of Applied Psychology,86(4):629-640.
    Ventriss C.1995. The rating system:determining what constitutes a quality public administration program [J]. Journal of Public Administration Education,1(2):142-153.
    Wallmark JT, Sedig KG.1986. Quality of research by citation measured method and by peer review-a comparison [C]. IEEE Transitions on Engineering Management, EM-33:218-222.
    Wang P, Walumbwa FO.2007. Family-friendly programs, organizational commitment, and work withdrawal:The moderating role of transformational leadership [J]. Personnel Psychology, 60(2):397-427.
    Wayne SJ, Shore LM, Bommer WH, Tetrick LE.2002. The role of fair treatment and rewards in perceptions of organizational support and leader-member exchange [J]. Journal of Applied Psychology,87(3):590-598.
    Whitely W, Dougherty TW, Dreher GF.1991. Relationship of career mentoring and socioeconomic origin to managers'and professionals'early career progress [J]. Academy of Management Journal,34(2):331-351.
    Wood F.1990. Factors influencing research performance of university academic staff [J]. Higher Education,19(1):81-100.
    Woodman RW, Sawyer JE, Griffin RW.1993. Toward a theory of organizational creativity [J]. Academy of Management Review,18(2):293-321.
    Woolcock M.1998. Social capital and economic development:toward a theoretical synthesis and policy framework [J]. Theory and Society,27(2):151-208.
    Woolcock M, Narayan D.2000. Social capital:implications for development theory, research and policy [J].World Bank Research Observer,15(2):225-249.
    Wubbels Th, Brekelmans M, den Brok P, van Tartwijk J.2006. An interpersonal perspective on classroom management in secondary classrooms in The Netherlands [M]//In C. Evertson & C.S.Weinstein (Eds.), Handbook of classroom management:Research, practice and contemporary issues,1161-1191. New York:Erlbaum.
    Xie Y, Shauman K.1998. Sex differences in research productivity [J]. American Sociological Review,63(6):847-870.
    Yoakum JC.1993. Research productivity of home economic education faculty in public doctorate-granting university [D]:[Ph.D.]. Columbus:The Ohio State University.
    Zheng W.2010. A social capital perspective of innovation from individuals to nations:where is empirical literature directing us? [J]. International Journal of Management Reviews,12(2): 151-183.
    Zhou J, Shin SJ, Brass DJ, Choi J, Zhang Z.2009. Social networks, personal values, and creativity:
    evidence for curvilinear and interaction effects [J]. Journal of Applied Psychology,94(6): 1544-1552.
    边国英.2008.科研过程、科研能力以及科研训练的特征分析[J].教育学术月刊,5:22-25.
    边燕杰,丘海雄.2000.企业的社会资本及其功效[J].中国社会科学,2:87-89.
    蔡启通,高泉登.2004.动机取向、组织创新环境与员工创新行为之关系:Amabile动机综效模型之验证[J].管理学报(中国台湾),21(5):571-592.
    常宏.2011.如何培养创新的兴趣[J].内蒙古民族大学学报,17(4):86-87.
    陈晓萍,徐淑英,樊景立.2008.组织与管理研究的实证方法[M].北京大学出版社,162-174.
    陈珊,王建梁.2006.导师指导频率对博士生培养质量的影响——基于博士生视角的分析和探讨[n清华大学教育研究,27(3):61-64.
    陈晓华,崔琳.2011.培养大学生学习兴趣提高本科教学质量[J].教育探索,3:94-96.
    戴勇,范明.2010.高校基础研究团队有效性及影响因素分析[J].科技进步与对策,27(13):134-137.
    古继宝,田雯,粱樑.2010.学术身份对科研项目申请的影响分析[J].科研管理,29(3):114-120.
    顾琴轩,王莉红.2009.人力资本与社会资本对创新行为的影响——基于科研人员个体的实证研究[J].科学学研究,10:1565-1570.
    顾远东,彭纪生.2010.组织创新氛围对员工创新行为的影响:创新自我效能感的中介作用[J].南开管理评论,13(1):30-41.
    贺天伟,张景林.2001.科研绩效定量评价指标体系的初步设计[J].科技管理研究,6:58-61.
    候杰泰,温忠麟,成子娟.2004.结构方程模型及其应用[M].北京:教育科学出版社.
    胡蓉,魏永祥.2008.谈研究生培养质量影响因素及其改善[J].中国高等教育,40:40-42.
    胡四能.2008.21世纪博士教育的目的及其思考[J].高等工程教育研究,4:89-93.
    黄芳铭.2005.结构方程模式:理论与应用[M].北京:中国税务出版社.
    黄西川,霍丹.1993.科技人员科研绩效评价方法研究[J].南京理工大学学报:自然科学版,6:81-86.
    黄一岚,裘晓华.2009.论建设创新型国家背景下研究生创新能力的培养[J].高教与经济,22(1):33-37.
    李彩丽,缪园.2009.硕士生生源质量与学位论文成绩的相关性分析[J].学位与研究生教育,9:8-11.
    李怀祖.2004.管理研究方法论[M].陕西:西安交通大学出版社.
    李玉萍,许伟波,彭于彪.2003.绩效·剑[M].清华大学出版社.
    李忠.2004.高校科研创新团队建设的几点思考[J].长沙铁道学院学报:社会科学版,5(3): 189-190.
    林筠,刘伟,李随成.2011.企业社会资本对技术创新能力影响的实证研究[J].科研管理,32(1):35-44.
    刘智运.2000.大学学习理论与方法[M].武汉:武汉大学出版社.
    路秋丽,田雨,魏顺平.2008。教育技术研究领导关键者研究[J].电化教育研究,8:26-31.
    马庆国.2002。管理统计:数据获取、统计原理、SPSS工具与应用研究[M].北京:科学出版社,288-322.
    邱皓政.1999.组织创新环境的概念建构与测量工具发展[R].技术创造力研讨会,台北:“国立”政治大学主办.
    沈通.2005。我国博士生培养质量提升的关键点控制研究[D]:[博士].杭州:浙江大学.
    王欢,尤中山.2011.团队创新氛围对成员创新行为影响的跨层次研究:集体效能感的中介作用[J].技术经济,30(7):9-13。
    王蔚虹.2009.博士生质量影响因素权重研究——基于五所学校的调查[J].现代教育管理,2:108-110。
    韦影.2007。企业社会资本与技术创新:基于吸收能力的实证研究[J].中国工业经济,9:119-127。
    吴鸿翔,汪玲.2011.试论高层次创新性人才培养的学科环境——从全国优博论文的“共生效应”谈起[J].研究生教育研究,04:15-20。
    邢春晖,石金涛.2009。目标导向对个人创新行为的影响[J].武汉理工大学学报,31(4):673-680.
    薛玉品。2007.个人创新的影响因素分析:从创造力人格、主管领导型态与组织创新环境的观点探讨[D]。[博士].厦门:厦门大学.
    袁本涛,延建林.2009。我国研究生创新能力现状及其影响因素分析[J].北京大学教育评论,2009,7(2):12-21.
    张方华.2006.知识型企业的社会资本与知识获取的关系研究——基于BP神经网络模型的实证分析[J].科学学研究,24(2):106-111.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700