不同苜蓿品种根系特征及其抗寒性关系的研究
|
摘要
本文对13个不同来源的苜蓿品种于生长当年进行了根颈、根系特征、根部各指标相关性分析、主成分分析、形态学聚类分析、苜蓿的越冬率及苜蓿根颈直径和入土深度与越冬率的关系、苜蓿根系中过氧化物酶(POD)活性与抗寒性关系的研究。研究结果如下:
1不同苜蓿品种间根颈特征差异明显,根颈直径、入土深度以Maverick为最大,供试苜蓿品种间根颈分枝数无明显差异。不同苜蓿品种间根系特征差异明显或显著,主根长度以肇东最大,为16.5cm,主根直径以Maverick最高,达0.63cm,Maverick侧根条数最大,为4.6条,公农1号侧根位置最大,为3.9cm,供试品种中肇东侧根直径最大,为0.33cm,以上各品种(Maverick,肇东,公农1号)在主根长度、主根直径、侧根数、侧根直径、侧根位置等指标上明显或显著高于国内外其它品种。
2对各品种根部指标进行相关性分析表明:根系各指标中,除主根长和侧根位置外,其余各指标(包括根颈直径、主根直径、侧根数、侧根直径)都呈正相关,且达到显著或极显著水平;主根长和侧根位置与其它指标相关性并不显著。对不同苜蓿品种根系指标主成分分析表明:第一成分(根颈直径)的特征贡献率为46.4190%,是分析的主要方面。其次为主根直径和主根长度。特征贡献率分别为20.9041%和17.9611%。苜蓿根系形态学聚类分析表明,第一类根系形态相近的有Maverick和公农1号;第二类根系形态相似的包括草原3号、中苜1号、肇东、克旗黄花、阿勒泰等5个品种;第三类包括润布勒、CUF101、草原2号、直立黄花、Legend等4个品种,第四类仅有准格尔1个品种。
3试验根据越冬率将13个苜蓿品种划分为四个等级,Maverick、草原3号、草原2号均为抗寒性较强的品种,为4级;克旗黄花、公农1号、直立黄花、阿勒泰、润布勒、肇东、Legend为抗寒性中等品种,为3级;中苜1号、准格尔为抗寒性较弱品种,为2级;CUF101为抗寒性最弱的品种,越冬率仅35%,为1级。根颈直径、入土深度与越冬率之间的相关性研究表明,根颈直径与入土深度及越冬率均成正相关,达到显著或极显著水平。
4从13个苜蓿品种低温处理后过氧化物酶活性比较看,克旗黄花过氧化物酶活性明显高于其它品种,说明其抗寒性最强;其次是Maverick、直立黄花、草原2号、草原3号,它们之间存在显著差异;活性最差的是准格尔、CUF101,说明其抗寒性最弱,其次是中苜1号和肇东;其余品种过氧化物酶活性居中,且它们之间差异显著,说明其抗寒性中等。
A study was conducted to determine the crown, root system characteristics , the correlation analysis of index in root system, the principal component analysis, the root system morphology cluster analysis, the winter survival rate, the correlation analysis of index in crown diameter,crown depth and winter survival rate, the frosted symptoms of the over-wintering, POD activity for different alfalfa varieties,etc,of thirteen alfalfa with different origins
1 The reselt indicated that there was significantly difference of the character of crown in cultivars,The crown diameter, crown depth was greatest in Maverick, there was no significantly difference in crown branch. There was significantly difference of the character of root system in cultivars, Zhaodong has the longest tap root(16.5cm)and lateral root diameter(0.33cm), Maverick has the greatest tap root diameter(0.63cm) and lateral root number(4.6), lateral root position was greatest in Gongnong No.1(3.9cm), the indexes in all over the alfalfa cultivars were significantly higher than all of the others.
2 Correlation analysis indicated that,except for the tap root length and lateral root position,other indexes of root including crown diameter, tap root diameter, lateral root number, lateral root diameter was significantly or high significantly positive correlation, the correlation among the tap root length and lateral root position with other indexes was not significant. Principal component analysis indicated that the frist component contribution rate is 46.4190%,it is main aspects,the next is root diameter and tap root length, contribution rate is 20.9041% and 17.9611%. The root system morphology cluster analysis indicated that the frist root system morphology similar,including Maverick and Gongnong No.1,the second including Caoyuan No.3, Zhongmu No.1, Zhaodong, Keqihuanghua, Aletai,the third including Rambler, Caoyuan No.2, Zhilihuanghua, Legend,CUF101,the last one is Zhungeer.
3 Cold_tolerance analysis indicated that the varieties with strong cold resistance were Maverick, Caoyuan No.3, Caoyuan No.2.The varieties with medium cold resistance were Keqihuanghua, Gongnong No.1, Zhilihuanghua, Aletai, Rambler, Zhaodong, Legend.The varieties with weak cold resistance included Zhongmu No.1 and Zhungeer. The varieties with weakest cold resistance was CUF101, winter survival rate was 35%.The correlation analysis of index in crown diameter,crown depth and winter survival rate indicated that the crown diameter,crown depth and winter survival rate was significantly or high significantly positive correlation.
4 The POD activity was significantly different among alfalfa varieties under cold stress.The POD activity of Keqihuanghua was stronger than that of the others, secondly was Maverick, Caoyuan No.3, Zhilihuanghua, Caoyuan No.2. Zhungeer and CUF101,showing their cold resistance were weakest,the others suggesting the medium cold resistance.
1不同苜蓿品种间根颈特征差异明显,根颈直径、入土深度以Maverick为最大,供试苜蓿品种间根颈分枝数无明显差异。不同苜蓿品种间根系特征差异明显或显著,主根长度以肇东最大,为16.5cm,主根直径以Maverick最高,达0.63cm,Maverick侧根条数最大,为4.6条,公农1号侧根位置最大,为3.9cm,供试品种中肇东侧根直径最大,为0.33cm,以上各品种(Maverick,肇东,公农1号)在主根长度、主根直径、侧根数、侧根直径、侧根位置等指标上明显或显著高于国内外其它品种。
2对各品种根部指标进行相关性分析表明:根系各指标中,除主根长和侧根位置外,其余各指标(包括根颈直径、主根直径、侧根数、侧根直径)都呈正相关,且达到显著或极显著水平;主根长和侧根位置与其它指标相关性并不显著。对不同苜蓿品种根系指标主成分分析表明:第一成分(根颈直径)的特征贡献率为46.4190%,是分析的主要方面。其次为主根直径和主根长度。特征贡献率分别为20.9041%和17.9611%。苜蓿根系形态学聚类分析表明,第一类根系形态相近的有Maverick和公农1号;第二类根系形态相似的包括草原3号、中苜1号、肇东、克旗黄花、阿勒泰等5个品种;第三类包括润布勒、CUF101、草原2号、直立黄花、Legend等4个品种,第四类仅有准格尔1个品种。
3试验根据越冬率将13个苜蓿品种划分为四个等级,Maverick、草原3号、草原2号均为抗寒性较强的品种,为4级;克旗黄花、公农1号、直立黄花、阿勒泰、润布勒、肇东、Legend为抗寒性中等品种,为3级;中苜1号、准格尔为抗寒性较弱品种,为2级;CUF101为抗寒性最弱的品种,越冬率仅35%,为1级。根颈直径、入土深度与越冬率之间的相关性研究表明,根颈直径与入土深度及越冬率均成正相关,达到显著或极显著水平。
4从13个苜蓿品种低温处理后过氧化物酶活性比较看,克旗黄花过氧化物酶活性明显高于其它品种,说明其抗寒性最强;其次是Maverick、直立黄花、草原2号、草原3号,它们之间存在显著差异;活性最差的是准格尔、CUF101,说明其抗寒性最弱,其次是中苜1号和肇东;其余品种过氧化物酶活性居中,且它们之间差异显著,说明其抗寒性中等。
A study was conducted to determine the crown, root system characteristics , the correlation analysis of index in root system, the principal component analysis, the root system morphology cluster analysis, the winter survival rate, the correlation analysis of index in crown diameter,crown depth and winter survival rate, the frosted symptoms of the over-wintering, POD activity for different alfalfa varieties,etc,of thirteen alfalfa with different origins
1 The reselt indicated that there was significantly difference of the character of crown in cultivars,The crown diameter, crown depth was greatest in Maverick, there was no significantly difference in crown branch. There was significantly difference of the character of root system in cultivars, Zhaodong has the longest tap root(16.5cm)and lateral root diameter(0.33cm), Maverick has the greatest tap root diameter(0.63cm) and lateral root number(4.6), lateral root position was greatest in Gongnong No.1(3.9cm), the indexes in all over the alfalfa cultivars were significantly higher than all of the others.
2 Correlation analysis indicated that,except for the tap root length and lateral root position,other indexes of root including crown diameter, tap root diameter, lateral root number, lateral root diameter was significantly or high significantly positive correlation, the correlation among the tap root length and lateral root position with other indexes was not significant. Principal component analysis indicated that the frist component contribution rate is 46.4190%,it is main aspects,the next is root diameter and tap root length, contribution rate is 20.9041% and 17.9611%. The root system morphology cluster analysis indicated that the frist root system morphology similar,including Maverick and Gongnong No.1,the second including Caoyuan No.3, Zhongmu No.1, Zhaodong, Keqihuanghua, Aletai,the third including Rambler, Caoyuan No.2, Zhilihuanghua, Legend,CUF101,the last one is Zhungeer.
3 Cold_tolerance analysis indicated that the varieties with strong cold resistance were Maverick, Caoyuan No.3, Caoyuan No.2.The varieties with medium cold resistance were Keqihuanghua, Gongnong No.1, Zhilihuanghua, Aletai, Rambler, Zhaodong, Legend.The varieties with weak cold resistance included Zhongmu No.1 and Zhungeer. The varieties with weakest cold resistance was CUF101, winter survival rate was 35%.The correlation analysis of index in crown diameter,crown depth and winter survival rate indicated that the crown diameter,crown depth and winter survival rate was significantly or high significantly positive correlation.
4 The POD activity was significantly different among alfalfa varieties under cold stress.The POD activity of Keqihuanghua was stronger than that of the others, secondly was Maverick, Caoyuan No.3, Zhilihuanghua, Caoyuan No.2. Zhungeer and CUF101,showing their cold resistance were weakest,the others suggesting the medium cold resistance.
引文
[1]耿华珠.中国苜蓿[M].北京:中国农业出版社,1995.
[2] Perfect E,Miller R D,Burton B. Root morphology and vigor effects on winter heaving of established alfalfa[J].A gron J,1987,79:1061～1067
[3] A vice J C,Ourry A,L emaire G,Volenece J J,Boucand J. Root protein and vegetative storage protein are key to rgainic nutri-ents for alfalfa shoot regrowth [J]. Crop Sci,1997,37:1187～1193
[4] Russel R S.Plant root systems:their function and interaction with the soil[M].London:Mc Graw Hill,1977
[5] Parao F T,Paningbatan E Jr,Yoshida S.Drought resistance of rice varieties in relation to their rootg rowth[J].Philippine J.CropSci,1976,(1):50-55
[6] Misra D K.Relation of root development to drought resistance of plants[J].Indian J.Agron,1956,(1):41-46
[7]马其东,高振生,洪绂曾,王培.滩涂地区苜蓿根系生长发育的研究[J].草业科学,1998,15(1):33-37.
[8]姚爱兴,王槐三,梁祖锋.紫花苜蓿根系生物学特性的研究[J].牧草与饲料,1989,(2):23-26
[9]马其东,高振生,洪绂曾,王培.不同苜蓿地方品种根系发育能力的评价与筛选[J].草业学报,1999, 8(1):42-49
[10]刘志鹏,杨青川,呼天明.侧根型紫花苜蓿遗传基础及其育种研究进展[J].中国草地,2003,25(3):66-71
[11] Song S.P and D.Walton.1951.Interitance of leaflet size and specific leaf weight in alfala Crop Sci.2:271-279
[12] Stout,P.C.,and J.W.Hall.1989.Fall growth and winter survlval of alfala in interior British Columbia.Can.J.Plant Sci.69:491-499
[13] Lamb JFS,Barnes D K,Henjum K I.Gain from two cycle ofdivergent selection for root morphology in afalfa[J].Crop Sci,1999,39:1026-1035.
[14] Saindon G,Michaud R,Pierre C A.Breeding for root yeild in alfalfa [J].Can.J.Plant Sci,1991,71:727-735.
[15] Barea JM,Tobar RM,Azcon_Aguilar C.Effect of genetically modified Rhizobium meliloti inoculant on the development of arbuscular mycorrhizas,root morphology,nutrient uptake and biomass accumlationin Medicago sativa[J].New Phytol,1996,134:361-369.
[16] Chloupek O.Combining ability for growth of young alfalfa as related to size of the root system[J].Z.Planzenzuchtg,1982,88:54-60.
[17] Suzuki M.Effect of stand age onagronomic,morphology and chemical characteristics of alfalfa[J].Can.J.Plant Sci,1991,71:445-452. Saindon G,Michaud R,Pierre C A.Breeding for root yeild in alfalfa [J].Can.J.Plant Sci,1991,71:727-735.
[18]扎西,米玛穷拉.四种豆科牧草根系的观测[J].中国草业科学,1987,4(4):56-57
[19]梁慧敏,曹致中.密度对根根孽型苜蓿根系的影响[J].草业科学,1996,5(4)30-34
[20]潘幸来,孙来虎,王永杰等,黄土高原冬小麦及苜蓿的根系构形特征[J].麦类作物,1997,17(1):32-35
[21]马其东,高振生,洪绂曾,等.不同苜蓿地方品种根系发育能力的评价与筛选[J].草业学报,1999,8(1):42～49
[22]孙启忠,韩建国,桂荣,等.科尔沁沙地苜蓿根系和根颈特性[J].草地学报,2001,9(4):269-276
[23]韩清芳.不同苜蓿(Medicago sativa)品种抗逆性、生产性能及品质特性研究[D].西北农林科技大学,2003届攻读博士学位研究生学位(毕业)论文,2003(6):1-160
[24]吴新卫,韩清芳,贾志宽.不同苜蓿品种根颈和根系形态学特性比较及根系发育能力[J].西北农业学报,2007,16(2):80-86
[25]王海林,公保才让.高寒牧区栽培苜蓿根系的研究[J].草业与畜牧,2007,(8):7-10
[26] Johnson L D,Marquez J J,BarnesD K,et al.Inhetance of root traits in alfalfa[J].Crop Sci,1996,36:1482-1487.
[27] Johnson L D,Marquez J J,LambJFS,et al.Root morphology of alfalfa plant introductions and cultivars[J]Crop Sci,1998,38:497-502.
[28] McIntosh M S,Miller D A. Development of root branching in three alfalfa cultivars[J].Crop Sci,1980,20:807-809.
[29]郭彦军,徐恢仲,张家骅.紫花苜蓿根系形态学研究[J].西南农业大学学报,2002,24(6):484-486
[30]马其东,高振生,洪绂曾,等.滩涂地区苜蓿根系生长发育的研究[J].草业科学,1998,15(1):33-37.
[31]白文明,左强,黄元彷,等.乌兰布和沙区紫花苜蓿根系生长及吸水规律的研究[J].植物生态学报,2001,25(1):35-41.
[32]郭正刚,张自和,肖金玉,等.黄土高原丘陵沟壑区紫花苜蓿品种间根系发育能力的初步研究[J].应用生态学报,2002,13(8):1007-1012
[33]郭正刚,王锁民,张自和.紫花苜蓿品种间根系发育过程分析[J].应用与环境生物学报,2003,9(4):367-371
[34]李存福,韩建国,张志刚,等.紫花苜蓿根系对水分的适应性[J].草业科学增刊,2004:357-363
[35]万素梅,胡守林,黄勤慧,等.不同紫花苜蓿品种根系发育能力的研究[J].西北植物学报,2004,24(11):2048-2052
[36]刘瑞峰,张新全,刘金平,等.3种紫色土对紫花苜蓿根系发育及生物量构成的影响[J].安徽农业科学,2005,33(10):1817-1818,1821
[37]魏飒,任树梅,杨培岭,等.围场地区紫花苜蓿土壤水分动态变化与根系分布状况研究[J].中国农学通报,2006,22(5):448-451
[38]张建波,白史且,张新全,等.紫花苜蓿根系与土壤物理性质的关系[J].安徽农业科学,2006,34(14):3424-3427
[39]孙启忠,桂荣,韩建国,等.赤峰地区敖汉苜蓿冻害及其防御技术[J].草地学报,2001,9(1):50-57.
[40]张宝田,穆春生,李志坚,等.紫花苜蓿受冻害后促进根颈枝条再生方法的研究[J].中国草地,2003,25(5):48-51
[41]殷秀杰,崔国文.北方寒区苜蓿冻害原因及其防御措施[J].饲料博览,2006,(4):31-33
[42] Belanger, G., J.E. Itichards, and R.E. McQueen.1992. Effects of harvesting systems on yield,persistence,and nutritive value of alfalfa. Can. J. Plant Sci.72:7 93-799.
[43] Belanger, G., T. Kunelius, D. McKenzie, Y.Papadopoulos, B. Thomas, K. McRae, S. Fillmore, and B.Christie. 1999. Fall cutting management affects yield and persistence of alfalfa in Atlantic Canada. Can. J.Plant Sci. 79:57-63.
[44] Brink, G.E., and G.C. Marten. 1989. Harvest management of alfalfa nutrient yield vs. forage quality, andrelationship to persistence. J. Prod. Agric. 2:32-36.
[45] Castonguay, Y., and P. Nadeau, P. Lechasseur, and L. Chouinard. 1995. Differential accumulation of carbohydrates in alfalfa cultivars of contrasting winter hardiness. Crop Sci: 35:509-516.
[46] Cunningham, S.M., and J.J. Volenec. 1998. Seasonal carbohydrate and nitrogen metabolism in roots of contrasting alfalfa (Medicago sativa L:) cultivars. J. Plant Physiol. 153:220-225.
[47] Edminsten, K.L., D.D. Wolf, and M. Lentner. 1988. Fall harvest management of alfalfa. I. Date of fall harvest and length of growth period prior to fall harvest. Agron. J. 80:688-693.
[48]郭正刚,刘慧霞,王彦荣.刈割对紫花苜蓿根系生长影响的初步分析[J].西北植物学报,2004,24(2):215-220
[49]刘香萍,李国良,崔国文.紫花苜蓿抗寒性差异评价及晚秋刈割对其抗寒性的影响[J].草业科学增刊,2004:332-338
[50]迟文峰,刘丹丹,李钢,等.刈割次数对紫花苜蓿根系中保护酶活性的影响[J].中国草地学报,2006,28(4):111-114
[51]迟文峰,崔国文.不同刈割次数对紫花苜蓿根系中可溶性糖含量及越冬率影响的研究[J].四川草原,2006,(3):4-6
[52]刘磊,陈立波,田占标,卫智军.晚秋刈割对不同秋眠类型苜蓿根系游离脯氨酸含量的影响[J].中国草地学报,2007,29(3):112-115
[53]高振生,洪绂曾,王培,等.苜蓿根系酯酶及内源激素的变化与根孽发生的研究[J].草地学报,1994,2(2):1-11
[54]马其东,高振生,洪绂曾,等.不同苜蓿品种主根受伤后同工酶变化[J].草地学报,1999,7(4):257-262
[55]马其东,翟志强,刘向新.苜蓿侧根发生与内源激素的变化[J].草地学报,2001,9(1):64-68
[56]罗长寿,左强,李保国,等.盐份胁迫条件下苜蓿根系吸水特性的模拟与分析[J].土壤通报,2001,32:81-84
[57]张治科,张慧茹,徐世才.宁夏区内5种牧草可溶性糖和淀粉含量的研究[J].宁夏大学学报,2004,25(3):268-270
[58]姜义宝,崔国文,杨玉荣.干旱胁迫下不同浓度Ca2+对苜蓿根系活力、脯氨酸含量和过氧化物酶活性的影响[J].东北农业大学学报,2005,36(3):317-319
[59]陈敏.直立型黄花苜蓿的研究[J].中国草地学报,1980(3):38-42
[60]王立群,陈世璜.杂交苜蓿(Medicago varia Martin)根系特性的研究[J].内蒙古草业,2001,(2):22-24
[61] Steponkus, P.L.,1978, Advances in Agronomy.30:51-98.
[62] Levitt,J.,1980, Responses of Plant to Enviroa-mental Stresses. Academic Press.
[63]刘友良,朱根海,刘祖祺.植物抗冻性测定技术的原理和比较[J].植物生理学通讯,1985,(1):40-43
[64]王荣富.植物抗寒性指标的种类及其应用[J].植物生理学通讯,1987(3): 49-55
[65]刘庚长.苜蓿、草木栖、聚合草的抗寒力和防冻栽培法[J].东北师范大学学报,1983(2):39-49
[66] Sulk R M, Albrecht K A. Duke S H. Leakage of intracellular substances as anindicator of freezing injury in alfalfa [J].Crop Sci.,1991,31:430-435.
[67] McKenzie J.S., R. Paquin, and S.H. Duke. 1988. Cold and heat tolerance. P. 259302. In A.A. Hanson et al.(ed.) Alfalfa and alfalfa improvement. Agron. Monogr. 29. ASA, CSSA, Madison, WI.
[68]洪绂曾.苜蓿的根孽类型和根孽型苜蓿的选育[J].牧草与饲料,1987(4):10-15
[69]耿华珠.苜蓿的科学与技术[M].中国草原学会文集,1986
[70] Morley,F.H.W.,H.Daday,and J.W.Peak.Quantitative inheritance in Lucerce(Medicago sativa L.).Inheritance and selection for winter yield[J].Aust.J.Agric.Res,1957,8:635-651
[71] Duke S.H.,Doehlert D.C.Root respiration,nodulation,and enzyme activities in alfalfa during cold acclimation[J].Crop Sci,1981, 21:489-495
[72] Smith D.Root branching of alfalfa varietie sandstrain[J]. Agron.J,1951,43:573-575.
[73] Schwab P M, Barnes D K, Sheaf C C. The relationship between field winter jury and fall growth score for 251 alfalfa cultivars[J].CropSci.1996,36:418-426.
[74] Schwab P M, Barnes D K, Sheaf C C. Factors affecting a laboratory evaluation of alfalfacoldtolerance[J].CropSci.,1996, 36:318-324.
[75]赵宇光,吴渠来,许令妊,彭启乾.冷季紫花苜蓿和黄花苜蓿抗冻性的变化[J].中国草地,1986(4):15-18
[76]周瑞莲,赵哈林.秋季牧草根系中营养含量和酶活性变化及其抗寒性研究[J].植物生态学报,1995,19(4):345-351
[77]梁慧敏,夏阳,梁月香.碳水化合物含量和过氧化物酶酶活性变化与苜蓿抗寒性的关系[J].甘肃农业大学学报,1995,30(4):307-311
[78]梁慧敏,夏阳.苜蓿抗寒性及根蘖性状的表现与过氧化物酶同工酶关系的研究[J].草业学报,1998,12(4):55-60
[79]刘香萍.苜蓿品种间抗寒性能评价及其相关形态学与生理学研究[D].东北农业大学,2001届攻读硕士学位研究生学位(毕业)论文,2004(6):1-53
[80]杨秀娟.紫花苜蓿抗寒性评价及其对秋冬季节低温适应性[D].北京林业大学,2003届攻读硕士学位研究生学位(毕业)论文,2006(6):1-54
[81]杨国柱,宁英林,杨吉云,赵殿智.冷季寒牧系列紫花苜蓿根系内电导率测定[J].草业与畜牧,2007,(1):11-13
[82] Peterson M A,Kendall W A,Hill R R.Effect of divergent selection for root weight on genetic variation for root and shoot characters in alfalfa[J].Crop Sci 1984b,24:570-573.
[83] Peterson M A,Hill R R,Kendall W A.Genetic variability for root characters in alfalfa populations differing in winter hardiness [J].Crop Sci,1984a,24:465-468.
[84]曹致中,贾笃敬,汪玺.根蘖型苜蓿的引种和育种[J].中国草地,1990,(4): 25-30.
[85]洪绂曾.根孽型苜蓿的引种研究[J].中国草业科学,1987(5):1-4
[86] Cunningham,S.M.,J.A.Gana,J.Volenec,and L.R.Teuber.Winter hardiness,root physiology,and gene expression in successive fall dormancy selections from‘Mesilla’and‘CUF101’alfalfa[J].Crop Sci,2001,41:1091-1098
[87] Haagenson D.M.,S.M.Cunningham,and J. Volenec.Root physiology of less fall dormant,winter hardy alfalfa selections[J].CropSci,2003, 43:1441-1447
[88]王晓俊.苜蓿品种间抗寒性能及生产性能评价[D].甘肃农业大学, 2003届攻读硕士学位研究生学位(毕业)论文,2006(6):1-48
[89]刘鸿先.零上低温对不同抗冷力的亚热带植物过氧化物酶与脂酶同工酶的影响[J].植物生理学报,1981,17(4):337-343
[90]汪曼丽.低温处理对籼、粳稻芽鞘呼吸、透性和过氧化物酶同工酶的影响[J].植物生理学通讯,1986,6
[91]梁慧敏,孙吉雄.几种暖季型草坪草过氧化物同工酶分析[J].中国草地,1996,4:40-42
[92]由继红,杨文杰,李淑云.不同品种紫花苜蓿抗寒性研究[J].东北师大学报自然科学版,1995,(2):102-105
[2] Perfect E,Miller R D,Burton B. Root morphology and vigor effects on winter heaving of established alfalfa[J].A gron J,1987,79:1061～1067
[3] A vice J C,Ourry A,L emaire G,Volenece J J,Boucand J. Root protein and vegetative storage protein are key to rgainic nutri-ents for alfalfa shoot regrowth [J]. Crop Sci,1997,37:1187～1193
[4] Russel R S.Plant root systems:their function and interaction with the soil[M].London:Mc Graw Hill,1977
[5] Parao F T,Paningbatan E Jr,Yoshida S.Drought resistance of rice varieties in relation to their rootg rowth[J].Philippine J.CropSci,1976,(1):50-55
[6] Misra D K.Relation of root development to drought resistance of plants[J].Indian J.Agron,1956,(1):41-46
[7]马其东,高振生,洪绂曾,王培.滩涂地区苜蓿根系生长发育的研究[J].草业科学,1998,15(1):33-37.
[8]姚爱兴,王槐三,梁祖锋.紫花苜蓿根系生物学特性的研究[J].牧草与饲料,1989,(2):23-26
[9]马其东,高振生,洪绂曾,王培.不同苜蓿地方品种根系发育能力的评价与筛选[J].草业学报,1999, 8(1):42-49
[10]刘志鹏,杨青川,呼天明.侧根型紫花苜蓿遗传基础及其育种研究进展[J].中国草地,2003,25(3):66-71
[11] Song S.P and D.Walton.1951.Interitance of leaflet size and specific leaf weight in alfala Crop Sci.2:271-279
[12] Stout,P.C.,and J.W.Hall.1989.Fall growth and winter survlval of alfala in interior British Columbia.Can.J.Plant Sci.69:491-499
[13] Lamb JFS,Barnes D K,Henjum K I.Gain from two cycle ofdivergent selection for root morphology in afalfa[J].Crop Sci,1999,39:1026-1035.
[14] Saindon G,Michaud R,Pierre C A.Breeding for root yeild in alfalfa [J].Can.J.Plant Sci,1991,71:727-735.
[15] Barea JM,Tobar RM,Azcon_Aguilar C.Effect of genetically modified Rhizobium meliloti inoculant on the development of arbuscular mycorrhizas,root morphology,nutrient uptake and biomass accumlationin Medicago sativa[J].New Phytol,1996,134:361-369.
[16] Chloupek O.Combining ability for growth of young alfalfa as related to size of the root system[J].Z.Planzenzuchtg,1982,88:54-60.
[17] Suzuki M.Effect of stand age onagronomic,morphology and chemical characteristics of alfalfa[J].Can.J.Plant Sci,1991,71:445-452. Saindon G,Michaud R,Pierre C A.Breeding for root yeild in alfalfa [J].Can.J.Plant Sci,1991,71:727-735.
[18]扎西,米玛穷拉.四种豆科牧草根系的观测[J].中国草业科学,1987,4(4):56-57
[19]梁慧敏,曹致中.密度对根根孽型苜蓿根系的影响[J].草业科学,1996,5(4)30-34
[20]潘幸来,孙来虎,王永杰等,黄土高原冬小麦及苜蓿的根系构形特征[J].麦类作物,1997,17(1):32-35
[21]马其东,高振生,洪绂曾,等.不同苜蓿地方品种根系发育能力的评价与筛选[J].草业学报,1999,8(1):42～49
[22]孙启忠,韩建国,桂荣,等.科尔沁沙地苜蓿根系和根颈特性[J].草地学报,2001,9(4):269-276
[23]韩清芳.不同苜蓿(Medicago sativa)品种抗逆性、生产性能及品质特性研究[D].西北农林科技大学,2003届攻读博士学位研究生学位(毕业)论文,2003(6):1-160
[24]吴新卫,韩清芳,贾志宽.不同苜蓿品种根颈和根系形态学特性比较及根系发育能力[J].西北农业学报,2007,16(2):80-86
[25]王海林,公保才让.高寒牧区栽培苜蓿根系的研究[J].草业与畜牧,2007,(8):7-10
[26] Johnson L D,Marquez J J,BarnesD K,et al.Inhetance of root traits in alfalfa[J].Crop Sci,1996,36:1482-1487.
[27] Johnson L D,Marquez J J,LambJFS,et al.Root morphology of alfalfa plant introductions and cultivars[J]Crop Sci,1998,38:497-502.
[28] McIntosh M S,Miller D A. Development of root branching in three alfalfa cultivars[J].Crop Sci,1980,20:807-809.
[29]郭彦军,徐恢仲,张家骅.紫花苜蓿根系形态学研究[J].西南农业大学学报,2002,24(6):484-486
[30]马其东,高振生,洪绂曾,等.滩涂地区苜蓿根系生长发育的研究[J].草业科学,1998,15(1):33-37.
[31]白文明,左强,黄元彷,等.乌兰布和沙区紫花苜蓿根系生长及吸水规律的研究[J].植物生态学报,2001,25(1):35-41.
[32]郭正刚,张自和,肖金玉,等.黄土高原丘陵沟壑区紫花苜蓿品种间根系发育能力的初步研究[J].应用生态学报,2002,13(8):1007-1012
[33]郭正刚,王锁民,张自和.紫花苜蓿品种间根系发育过程分析[J].应用与环境生物学报,2003,9(4):367-371
[34]李存福,韩建国,张志刚,等.紫花苜蓿根系对水分的适应性[J].草业科学增刊,2004:357-363
[35]万素梅,胡守林,黄勤慧,等.不同紫花苜蓿品种根系发育能力的研究[J].西北植物学报,2004,24(11):2048-2052
[36]刘瑞峰,张新全,刘金平,等.3种紫色土对紫花苜蓿根系发育及生物量构成的影响[J].安徽农业科学,2005,33(10):1817-1818,1821
[37]魏飒,任树梅,杨培岭,等.围场地区紫花苜蓿土壤水分动态变化与根系分布状况研究[J].中国农学通报,2006,22(5):448-451
[38]张建波,白史且,张新全,等.紫花苜蓿根系与土壤物理性质的关系[J].安徽农业科学,2006,34(14):3424-3427
[39]孙启忠,桂荣,韩建国,等.赤峰地区敖汉苜蓿冻害及其防御技术[J].草地学报,2001,9(1):50-57.
[40]张宝田,穆春生,李志坚,等.紫花苜蓿受冻害后促进根颈枝条再生方法的研究[J].中国草地,2003,25(5):48-51
[41]殷秀杰,崔国文.北方寒区苜蓿冻害原因及其防御措施[J].饲料博览,2006,(4):31-33
[42] Belanger, G., J.E. Itichards, and R.E. McQueen.1992. Effects of harvesting systems on yield,persistence,and nutritive value of alfalfa. Can. J. Plant Sci.72:7 93-799.
[43] Belanger, G., T. Kunelius, D. McKenzie, Y.Papadopoulos, B. Thomas, K. McRae, S. Fillmore, and B.Christie. 1999. Fall cutting management affects yield and persistence of alfalfa in Atlantic Canada. Can. J.Plant Sci. 79:57-63.
[44] Brink, G.E., and G.C. Marten. 1989. Harvest management of alfalfa nutrient yield vs. forage quality, andrelationship to persistence. J. Prod. Agric. 2:32-36.
[45] Castonguay, Y., and P. Nadeau, P. Lechasseur, and L. Chouinard. 1995. Differential accumulation of carbohydrates in alfalfa cultivars of contrasting winter hardiness. Crop Sci: 35:509-516.
[46] Cunningham, S.M., and J.J. Volenec. 1998. Seasonal carbohydrate and nitrogen metabolism in roots of contrasting alfalfa (Medicago sativa L:) cultivars. J. Plant Physiol. 153:220-225.
[47] Edminsten, K.L., D.D. Wolf, and M. Lentner. 1988. Fall harvest management of alfalfa. I. Date of fall harvest and length of growth period prior to fall harvest. Agron. J. 80:688-693.
[48]郭正刚,刘慧霞,王彦荣.刈割对紫花苜蓿根系生长影响的初步分析[J].西北植物学报,2004,24(2):215-220
[49]刘香萍,李国良,崔国文.紫花苜蓿抗寒性差异评价及晚秋刈割对其抗寒性的影响[J].草业科学增刊,2004:332-338
[50]迟文峰,刘丹丹,李钢,等.刈割次数对紫花苜蓿根系中保护酶活性的影响[J].中国草地学报,2006,28(4):111-114
[51]迟文峰,崔国文.不同刈割次数对紫花苜蓿根系中可溶性糖含量及越冬率影响的研究[J].四川草原,2006,(3):4-6
[52]刘磊,陈立波,田占标,卫智军.晚秋刈割对不同秋眠类型苜蓿根系游离脯氨酸含量的影响[J].中国草地学报,2007,29(3):112-115
[53]高振生,洪绂曾,王培,等.苜蓿根系酯酶及内源激素的变化与根孽发生的研究[J].草地学报,1994,2(2):1-11
[54]马其东,高振生,洪绂曾,等.不同苜蓿品种主根受伤后同工酶变化[J].草地学报,1999,7(4):257-262
[55]马其东,翟志强,刘向新.苜蓿侧根发生与内源激素的变化[J].草地学报,2001,9(1):64-68
[56]罗长寿,左强,李保国,等.盐份胁迫条件下苜蓿根系吸水特性的模拟与分析[J].土壤通报,2001,32:81-84
[57]张治科,张慧茹,徐世才.宁夏区内5种牧草可溶性糖和淀粉含量的研究[J].宁夏大学学报,2004,25(3):268-270
[58]姜义宝,崔国文,杨玉荣.干旱胁迫下不同浓度Ca2+对苜蓿根系活力、脯氨酸含量和过氧化物酶活性的影响[J].东北农业大学学报,2005,36(3):317-319
[59]陈敏.直立型黄花苜蓿的研究[J].中国草地学报,1980(3):38-42
[60]王立群,陈世璜.杂交苜蓿(Medicago varia Martin)根系特性的研究[J].内蒙古草业,2001,(2):22-24
[61] Steponkus, P.L.,1978, Advances in Agronomy.30:51-98.
[62] Levitt,J.,1980, Responses of Plant to Enviroa-mental Stresses. Academic Press.
[63]刘友良,朱根海,刘祖祺.植物抗冻性测定技术的原理和比较[J].植物生理学通讯,1985,(1):40-43
[64]王荣富.植物抗寒性指标的种类及其应用[J].植物生理学通讯,1987(3): 49-55
[65]刘庚长.苜蓿、草木栖、聚合草的抗寒力和防冻栽培法[J].东北师范大学学报,1983(2):39-49
[66] Sulk R M, Albrecht K A. Duke S H. Leakage of intracellular substances as anindicator of freezing injury in alfalfa [J].Crop Sci.,1991,31:430-435.
[67] McKenzie J.S., R. Paquin, and S.H. Duke. 1988. Cold and heat tolerance. P. 259302. In A.A. Hanson et al.(ed.) Alfalfa and alfalfa improvement. Agron. Monogr. 29. ASA, CSSA, Madison, WI.
[68]洪绂曾.苜蓿的根孽类型和根孽型苜蓿的选育[J].牧草与饲料,1987(4):10-15
[69]耿华珠.苜蓿的科学与技术[M].中国草原学会文集,1986
[70] Morley,F.H.W.,H.Daday,and J.W.Peak.Quantitative inheritance in Lucerce(Medicago sativa L.).Inheritance and selection for winter yield[J].Aust.J.Agric.Res,1957,8:635-651
[71] Duke S.H.,Doehlert D.C.Root respiration,nodulation,and enzyme activities in alfalfa during cold acclimation[J].Crop Sci,1981, 21:489-495
[72] Smith D.Root branching of alfalfa varietie sandstrain[J]. Agron.J,1951,43:573-575.
[73] Schwab P M, Barnes D K, Sheaf C C. The relationship between field winter jury and fall growth score for 251 alfalfa cultivars[J].CropSci.1996,36:418-426.
[74] Schwab P M, Barnes D K, Sheaf C C. Factors affecting a laboratory evaluation of alfalfacoldtolerance[J].CropSci.,1996, 36:318-324.
[75]赵宇光,吴渠来,许令妊,彭启乾.冷季紫花苜蓿和黄花苜蓿抗冻性的变化[J].中国草地,1986(4):15-18
[76]周瑞莲,赵哈林.秋季牧草根系中营养含量和酶活性变化及其抗寒性研究[J].植物生态学报,1995,19(4):345-351
[77]梁慧敏,夏阳,梁月香.碳水化合物含量和过氧化物酶酶活性变化与苜蓿抗寒性的关系[J].甘肃农业大学学报,1995,30(4):307-311
[78]梁慧敏,夏阳.苜蓿抗寒性及根蘖性状的表现与过氧化物酶同工酶关系的研究[J].草业学报,1998,12(4):55-60
[79]刘香萍.苜蓿品种间抗寒性能评价及其相关形态学与生理学研究[D].东北农业大学,2001届攻读硕士学位研究生学位(毕业)论文,2004(6):1-53
[80]杨秀娟.紫花苜蓿抗寒性评价及其对秋冬季节低温适应性[D].北京林业大学,2003届攻读硕士学位研究生学位(毕业)论文,2006(6):1-54
[81]杨国柱,宁英林,杨吉云,赵殿智.冷季寒牧系列紫花苜蓿根系内电导率测定[J].草业与畜牧,2007,(1):11-13
[82] Peterson M A,Kendall W A,Hill R R.Effect of divergent selection for root weight on genetic variation for root and shoot characters in alfalfa[J].Crop Sci 1984b,24:570-573.
[83] Peterson M A,Hill R R,Kendall W A.Genetic variability for root characters in alfalfa populations differing in winter hardiness [J].Crop Sci,1984a,24:465-468.
[84]曹致中,贾笃敬,汪玺.根蘖型苜蓿的引种和育种[J].中国草地,1990,(4): 25-30.
[85]洪绂曾.根孽型苜蓿的引种研究[J].中国草业科学,1987(5):1-4
[86] Cunningham,S.M.,J.A.Gana,J.Volenec,and L.R.Teuber.Winter hardiness,root physiology,and gene expression in successive fall dormancy selections from‘Mesilla’and‘CUF101’alfalfa[J].Crop Sci,2001,41:1091-1098
[87] Haagenson D.M.,S.M.Cunningham,and J. Volenec.Root physiology of less fall dormant,winter hardy alfalfa selections[J].CropSci,2003, 43:1441-1447
[88]王晓俊.苜蓿品种间抗寒性能及生产性能评价[D].甘肃农业大学, 2003届攻读硕士学位研究生学位(毕业)论文,2006(6):1-48
[89]刘鸿先.零上低温对不同抗冷力的亚热带植物过氧化物酶与脂酶同工酶的影响[J].植物生理学报,1981,17(4):337-343
[90]汪曼丽.低温处理对籼、粳稻芽鞘呼吸、透性和过氧化物酶同工酶的影响[J].植物生理学通讯,1986,6
[91]梁慧敏,孙吉雄.几种暖季型草坪草过氧化物同工酶分析[J].中国草地,1996,4:40-42
[92]由继红,杨文杰,李淑云.不同品种紫花苜蓿抗寒性研究[J].东北师大学报自然科学版,1995,(2):102-105