供应链知识共享环境下的知识产权风险研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
随着科学技术的发展和市场竞争的加剧,通过共享供应链上的知识资源,可以有效提高供应链的整体竞争力。然而,知识共享却使供应链企业不可避免地要面临知识产权风险。因此,研究供应链知识共享环境下的知识产权风险防范问题无论是对提高供应链的整体运作效率,还是对供应链企业谋求进一步发展都具有非常重要的、深远的意义。
     本文首先分析了加强知识产权风险防范研究的理论意义和实践意义;之后,对国内外现有相关研究文献做全面、系统的综述研究,从而明确本文的研究领域和研究方法。
     文章在对供应链知识共享的动因从四个方面进行分析的基础上,指出供应链知识共享的合理性与必然性;并且,从演化博弈论的视角定量分析了企业知识共享的策略选择,从而弥补了以往研究中对于知识共享动因多为描述性的解释以及对知识共享策略选择条件未加定量研究的不足;在对演化博弈模型结果的进一步分析中,识别供应链知识共享的影响因素,并有针对性地研究了供应链知识共享的实现途径。
     供应链知识共享的实现无法避免知识产权风险的发生,因此文章进一步对供应链知识共享环境下的知识产权风险的存在从知识外部性的视角进行了经济学机理研究,并且通过构建完全信息动态博弈模型和完全信息监督博弈模型,指出了知识产权风险的触发条件;在此基础上,构建了知识产权风险的模糊综合评价模型,从而弥补了以往研究中将知识产权侵权视为前提条件而并未加以研究的缺憾。
     最后,文章针对我国目前知识产权环境中存在的问题提出了政策建议以及构建国家信用治理机制必要性和可行措施;通过建立基于信号博弈的知识共享伙伴选择模型给出了供应链知识共享伙伴选择的对策措施;文章最后建立了一个供应链知识共享收益分配契约设计模型,从而为规避知识产权风险提供可资借鉴的契约设计思路。
With the development of science and technology and the market competition becoming fiercer, the knowledge sharing among can significantly improve the competence of the whole supply chain. However, supply chain members have to face the intellectual property risks under the environment of knowledge sharing in supply chain. So, it is meaningful to the improvement of supply chain operation efficiency and to the further development of supply chain members to explore the intellectual property risks in knowledge sharing in supply cahin.
     First of all, the theoretical and practical significance of strengthening the research of intellectual property risks prevention system was analyzed, and then a comprehensive and systematic review of related domestic and foreign papers was presented. Based on the above analysis, the research areas and methods of this paper were identified.
     After that, the knowledge sharing drivers among supply chain members were investigated from four aspects, and the rationality and necessities were presented. Then, the knowledge sharing strategies of the supply chain members were quantitatively analyzed by using evolutionary game theory. The research results provided valuable supplements to the previous related studies, which focused on descriptive explanation of the knowledge sharing drivers, and overcame the shortcomings of no quantitative analyses were conducted in previous reaearches. Based on the further analysis of the evolution game model, the influence factors were identified and pertinent methods were provided to realize the knowledge sharing in supply chain.
     The knowledge sharing in supply chain cannot guarantee the avoidance of intellectual property risks, so the existence mechanism of intellectual property risks under the knowledge sharing in supply chain was further analyzed from the perspective of the externality of the knowledge. Based on the above analysis, the trigger conditions of intellectual property risks were quantitatively explored by establishing complete information dynamic game model and complete information supervising game model. Furthermore, a fuzzy comprehensive evaluation model was established to quantitatively assess the intellectual property risks. The study can make up the previous research pitfalls that no concrete investigation was conducted to explore the trigger conditions of intellectual property risks. In the last part of this paper, policy suggestions were presented according to the current intellectual property environment in China, and the necessities of constructing state integrity governance mechanisms were investigated and feasible measures to the integrity governance were presented. A message game model was used to identify the knowledge sharing partners in supply chain, and some counter measures were also provided. A revenue allocation contract model of knowledge sharing in supply chain was designed, the model can be used as a reference for contract design in practice to avoid intellectual property risks.
引文
[1]赵道致,方淼,基于MICK-4FI网络化制造模式的资源运作研究,现代财经,2004,24(12):12~16
    [2]彼得?德鲁克,从资本主义到知识社会(樊春良,冷民译),珠海:珠海出版社,1998,34
    [3]纳霍安安V.K.,技术战略与创新—竞争优势的源泉(程源,高建,杨湘玉译),北京:电子工业出版社,2002,238~244
    [4]Kraljic Peter,Purchasing must become supply management,Harvard Business Review,1983,61(5):109~117
    [5]Shapiro Roy D.,Get leverage from logistics,Harvard Business Review,1984,62(3):119~127
    [6]沈厚才,陶青,供应链管理理论与方法,中国管理科学,2000,8(1):1~9
    [7]陈安,刘鲁,供应链管理问题的研究现状及挑战,系统工程学报,2000,15(2):179~186
    [8]迈克尔·波特,竞争战略(陈小悦译),北京:华夏出版社,1997,2~32
    [9]马士华,王一凡,林勇,供应链管理对传统制造模式的挑战,华中理工大学学报(社会科学版)1998,(2):65~68
    [10]陈国权,供应链管理,中国软科学,1999,(10):101~104
    [11]Davis Tom,Efective supply chain management,Sloan Management Review,1993,(2):35~46
    [12]Arntzen B.C.,Brown G G,Harrison T P,Global supply chain management at Digital Equipment Corporation,Interfaces,1995,25(1):69~93
    [13]Dyer Jefrey H.,How chrysler created an American keiretsu,Harvard Business Review,1996,(4):42~56
    [14]Andel Tom,Auto makers may teach you a lesson,Transportation&Distribution,1998,(8):45~49
    [15]Fisher Marshall L.,What is the right supply chain for your product?A simple framework can help you figure out the answer,Harvard Business Review,1997,(2):105~116
    [16]Magretta Joan,Fast,global,and entrepreneurial:Supply chain management,Hong Kong style,an interview with Victor Fund,Harvard Business Review,1998,(5):103~114
    [17]Magretta Joan,The Power of Virtual Integration:An Interview with Dell Computer's Michael Dell,Harvard Business Review,1998,76(2):74~84
    [18]Francis J. Quinn,Re-engineering The Supply Chain:An Interview With Michael Hammer,Supply Chain Management Review,1999,3(1):20~26
    [19]Clark,K.B.,Project scope and project performance:The efect of part strategy and supplier involvement on project development,Management Science,1989,35(4):1247~1263
    [20]Seichi Kawasaki,McMillan John,The design of contracts:Evidence from Japanese subcontracting,Journal of the Japanese and International Economics,1987,1(4):327~349
    [21]McMillan John,Managing suppliers:Incentive systems in Japanese and US industry,California Management Review,1990,(4):38~55
    [22]Womack J.P.,Jones D T,Roos D.The Machine That Changed the World,New York:Rawson Associates,1990,98~145
    [23]Dyer Jefrey H.,Ouchi,William G.,Japanese-style partnerships:Giving companies a competitive edge,Sloan Management Review,1993,(3):51~63
    [24]赵先得,谢金星,现代供应链管理的几个基本概念,南开管理评论,1999,2(1):62~66
    [25]陈菊红,王能民,杨彤,供应链中的知识管理,科研管理,2002,23(1):98~102
    [26]G. Hamel , Competition for competence and interpartner learning within international strategic alliances,Strategic Management Journal,1991,12(1):83~103
    [27]I. Nonaka,H. Takeuchi,The Knowledge-Creating Company,Harvard Business Review,1991,69(6):96~104
    [28]Paul Hong,William J. Doll,Abraham Y. Nahm,Xiao Li,Knowledge sharing in integrated product development,European Journal of Innovation Management,2004,7(2):102~112
    [29]P. Hendriks,why sharing knowledge?The influence of ICT on the motivation for knowledge sharing,Knowledge and Process Management,1999,6(2):91~100
    [30]鲁若愚,陈力,企业知识管理中的分享与整合,研究与发展管理,2003,15(1):16~20
    [31]比尔·盖茨,未来时速:数字神经系统与商务新思维(蒋显璟译),北京:北京大学出版社,1999,241~262
    [32]P. Quintas,P. Lefrere,G. Jones,Knowledge Management:A Strategic Agenda,Long Range Planning,1997,30(3):385~391
    [33]E.C. Osterberg,A primer on IP risk management and insurance,the Licensing Journal,2003,(11-12):1~10
    [34]T.K. Das,B.S. Teng,Trust control risk in strategic alliances:an integrated framework,Organization studies,2001,22(2):251~284
    [35]Edvinsson Leif,Sullivan Patrik,Developing a Model for Managing Intellectual Capital,European Management Journa1,1996,14(4):356~364
    [36]http://www.customs.gov.cn/YWStaticPage/2453/74dffb77.htm
    [37]李璐,知识产权与核心竞争力,企业改革与管理,2002,(12):22~23
    [38]Corbin R.M.,Managing risk and protecting intellectual property,Ivey Business Journal,2002,66(3):11~14
    [39]Jeffrey H. Dyer,Nile W Hatch,Using supplier networks to learn faster,MIT Sloan Management Review,2004,45(3):57~64
    [40]Chinho Lin,Hsiang Chin Hung,June-Yie Wu,A knowledge management architecture in collaborative supply chain,The Journal of Computer Information system,2002,42(5):83~94
    [41]R. Hall,Pierpaolo,Andriani,Analysing intangible resources and managing knowledge in a supply chain context,European Management Journal,1998,16(6):685~697
    [42]Done Adrian,M. Frohlich,An empirical study of the impact upon performance of upstream and downstream knowledge in the supply chain,San Diego,CA:Proceedings of Decision Sciences Institute,2002,23~26
    [43]Melissa M. Appleyard,How does knowledge flow?Inter-firm patterns in the semiconductor industry,Strategic Management Journal,1996,(17):137~l55
    [44]Bartol K.M.,Srivastava,A Encouraging knowledge sharing:the role of organizational reward systems,Journal of Leadership and Organization Studies,2002,9(1):64~76
    [45]Connelly C.E.,Kelloway E.I.,Predictors of employees’perceptions of knowledge sharing culture,Leadership&Organization Development Journal,2003,24(3):294~301
    [46]Hooff,Bart van den,Ridder,Jan A. de,Knowledge sharing in context:the influence of organizational commitment,communication climate and CMC use on knowledge sharing,Journal of Knowledge Management,2004,8(6):117~130
    [47]Ipe M.,Knowledge sharing on organizations:A conceptual framework,Human Resource Development Review,2003,2(4):337~359
    [48]单雪韩,改善知识共享的组织因素分析,企业经济,2003,(1):45~46
    [49]Ki-Chan Kim,The effects of electronic supply chain design(e-SCD)on coordination and knowledge sharing:An empirical investigation,Hawaii:Proceedings of the 35th Annual Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences,2002,2149~2158
    [50]彼得·圣吉,第五项修炼—学习型组织的艺术与实务(郭进隆译),上海:上海三联书店,1998,421~422
    [51]Nancy M.D.,Common knowledge:how companies thrive on sharing what they know,Boston:Harvard University Press,2000:30~32
    [52]周敏,李宏,占铭,基于市场交易的跨组织知识共享模型研究,现代管理科学,2007,6:73~74
    [53]Zhuge H.,A knowledge flow model for peer-to-peer team knowledge sharing and management,Expert Systems with Applications,2002,23(1):23~30
    [54]I. Nonaka,H. Takeuchi,The Knowledge-Creating Company:How Japanese Companies Create the Dynamics of Innovation,New York:Oxford University Press,1995,3~19
    [55]D. Teece,Technology transfer by multinational firms:the resource costs of transferring technological know-how,The Economic Journal,1977,(87):242~261
    [56]G. Szulanski,Exploring internal stickiness:Impediments to the transfer of best practice within the firm,Strategic Management Journal,1996,(17):27~43
    [57]Zander Udo,Bruce Kogut,Knowledge of the firm,combinative capabilifies,and the replication of technology,1992,3(3):383~397
    [58]Galbraith C.S. , Transferring Core Manufacturing Technologies in High Technology Firms,California Management Review,1990,32(4):56~70
    [59]刘南,李玉民,供应链中知识转移与扩散机制研究,技术经济与管理研究,2003,(6):92~93
    [60]I. Nonaka,H. Takeuchi,The Knowledge-Creating Company:How Japanese Companies Create the Dynamics of Innovation,New York:Oxford University Press,1995,65~89
    [61]I. Nonaka,H. Takeuchi,The Concept of“Ba”:Building a Foundation for Knowledge Creation,California Management Review,1998,40(3):40~54
    [62]G. Hedlund,A Model of Knowledge Management and the N-Form Corporation,Strategic Management Journal,1994,(15),73~90
    [63]Myrna Gilbert,Martyn Cordey-Hayes,Understanding the process of knowledge transfer to achieve successful technological innovation,Technovation,1996,16(6):301~312
    [64]Vito Albino,Claudio Garavelli A,Giovanni Schiuma,Knowledge transfer and inter-firm relationships in industrial districts : The role of the leader firm ,Technovation,1999,(19):53~63
    [65]徐金发,许强,顾惊雷,企业知识转移的情境分析模型,科研管理,2003,(2):54~60
    [66]Argote L,Ingram P.,Knowledge transfer:A basis for competitive advantage in firms,Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,2000,82(1):150~169
    [67]Jeffery Cummings,B.S. Teng,Transferring R&D knowledge:the key factors affecting knowledge transfer success,Journal of Engineering and Technology Management,2003,(20):39~68
    [68]W.M. Cohen,D.A. Levinthal,Absorptive capacity:A new perspective of learning and innovation,Administrative Science Quarterly,1990,(35):128~152
    [69]P. Chanvarasuth,T. Ravichandran,Absorptive capacity and strategic alliances in the supply chain context,New York:Proceedings of IEEE International Engineering Management Conference,2003,340~344
    [70]Ki-Chan Kim,The effects of electronic supply chain design(e-SCD)on coordination and knowledge sharing:An empirical investigation,Hawaii:Proceedings of the 35th Annual Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences,2002,2149~2158
    [71]Batenburg R,Rutten R,Managing innovation in regional supply networks:A Dutch case of knowledge industry clustering,Supply Chain Management,2003,8(3/4):263~270
    [72]Glisby M,Holden N,Applying knowledge management concepts to the supply chain:How a Danish firm achieved a remarkable breakthrough in Japan,The Academy of Management Executive,2005,19(2):85~89
    [73]A.Smirnov,C.Chandra,Ontology-based knowledge management for cooperative supply chain configuration,In Proceedings of the 2000 AAAI Spring Symposium,California Stanford:AAAI Press,2000,85~92
    [74]Peter E.D,Love A.G,Learning alliances:A customer-supplier focus for continuous improvement in manufacturing,Industrial and Commercial Training,1999,31(3):88~96
    [75]Spekman R.E,Spear J,Kamauf J,Supply chain competency:Learning as a key component,Supply Chain Management,2002,7(1):41~55
    [76]Collins R,Dunne T,O'Keefe M,The locus of value:A hallmark of chains that learn,Supply Chain Management,2002,7(5):318~321
    [77]Hult G.T.M,Ketchen D.J,Nichols E.L,Organizational learning as a strategic resource in supply management,Journal of Operations Management,2003,21(5):541~556
    [78]张玉蓉,张旭梅,供应链中核心企业与供应商知识共享的分析与启示—丰田企业案例研究,科学管理研究,2006,24(2):117~120
    [79]de Vries E.J,Brijder H.G,Knowledge management in hybrid supply channels:A case study,International Journal of Technology Management,2000,20(5-8):569~587
    [80]Mahesh S.R,Laura L.M,Strategic decisions in supply-chain intelligence using knowledge management:An analytic work process framework,Supply Chain Management,2005,10(2):114~121
    [81]李惠杰,基于供应链的知识管理系统的开发,工业技术经济,2005,24(1):92~93
    [82]Wu D.J,Software agents for knowledge management:Coordination in multiagent supply chains and auctions,Expert systems with Applications,2001,20(1):51~64
    [83]Chandra C,Kamrani A.K,Knowledge management for consumer-focused product design,Journal of Intelligent Manufacturing,2003,14(6):557~580
    [84]Lau H.C.W,Ning A,Pun K.F,A knowledge-based system to support procurement decision,Journal of knowledge Management,2005,9(1):87~100
    [85]杨敏才,凌超,王槐林,供应链的知识管理系统,研究与发展管理,2004,16(1):44~48
    [86]刘蓉,张毕西,供应链中知识管理的实施,价值工程,2005,(2):46~48
    [87]Fitzgerald M,At risk offshore:U.S. companies’s outsourcing their software development offshore can get stung by industrial espionage and poor intellectual property safeguards,CIO,2003,17(4):1~13
    [88]Lochner S.J,Risk minimization strategies in licensing intellectual property from entities that are,or might become,financially troubled,Intellectual property & technology law journal,2002,14(6):7~11
    [89]Cieri R.M,Morgan M.M,Licensing intellectual property and technology from the financially troubled or startup company,The business Lawyer,2000,55(4):16~49
    [90]Cauthorn,K.K,Managing Intellectual Property Risk:Because Knowledge Is A Company’s Greatest Asset,Intellectual Asset Management Practice,2004,(1),1~20
    [91]Hamel G,Doz Y,Prahalad C K,Collaborate with Your Competitors and Win,Harvard Business Review,1989,67(1):133~139
    [92]Baughn C.C,Denekamp J.G,Stevens J.H,Osborn R.N,Protecting Intellectual Capital in International Alliances,Journal of World Business,1997,32(2):103~117
    [93]Bresser R.K , Matching Collective and Competitive Strategies , Strategic Management Journal,1988,9(4):375~385
    [94]Amit R ,Shoemaker P.J.H,Strategic Assets and Organizational Rent,Strategic Management Journal,1993,14(1):33~46
    [95]Patricia M Norman,Protecting Knowledge in Strategic Alliances Resource and Relational Characteristic,Journal of High Technology Management Research,2002,13(2):177~202
    [96]Das T.K and Teng B,Risk Types and Inter-Firm Alliance Structures,Journal of Management Studies,1996,33(6):827~843
    [97]Kaufman A,Wood C,Thayel G,Collaboration and Technology Linkages:A Strategic Supplier Typology,Strategic Management Journal,2000,21(6):649~663
    [98]Khanna T,Gulati R,Nohria N,The Dynamics of Learning Alliances:Competition,Cooperation,and Relative Scope,Strategic Management Journal,1998,19(3):193~210
    [99]Si S.X,Bruton G.D,Knowledge Transfer in International Joint Ventures in Transition Economies:the China Experience,Academy of Management Executive,1999,13(1):83~90
    [100]刘新学,虚拟企业知识共享风险产生机理研究,商业研究,2006,(18):13~16
    [101]M. Sakakibara,Knowledge sharing in cooperative research and development,Managerial and Decision Economics,2003,24(2):117~132
    [102]刘新学,虚拟企业知识共享风险的控制与防范,商业时代,2006,(32):31~32,38
    [103]苏世彬,黄瑞华,合作联盟知识产权专有性与知识共享性的冲突研究,研究与发展管理,2005,17(5):69~74,86
    [104]余光胜,一种新的企业理论—企业知识理论,外国经济与管理,2000,(2):8~13
    [105]Granovetter M , Economic Action and Social Structure : A theory of Embeddedness,American Journal of Sociology,1985,91(3):481~510
    [106]黄泰岩,牛飞亮,西方企业网络理论评述,经济学动态,1999,(4):63~67
    [107]施琴芬,郭强,崔志明,隐性知识主体风险态度的经济学分析,科学学研究,2003,21(1):80~82
    [108]钟惠波,雷家骕,连建辉,知识经济学范式:一个演进的视点,科学学与科学技术管理,2005,(7):16~21
    [109]汪丁丁,知识沿时间和空间的互补性以及相关的经济学,经济研究,1997,(6):70~77
    [110]Chung,S.,Singh,H.,Lee,K.,Complementarity,Status Similarity and Social Capital as Drivers of Alliance Formation, Strategic Management Journal,2000,(21):1~22
    [111]李九鑫,郑绍濂,管理的社会网络嵌入性视角,外国经济与管理,2002,(6):2~6
    [112]Gulati R,Alliances and networks,Strategic Management Journal,1998,(19):293~317
    [113]乔治·旺·科鲁夫,知识创新—价值的源泉(北乔译),北京,经济管理出版社,2003,
    [114]肖条军,博弈论及其应用,上海:上海三联书店,2004,445~448
    [115]Friderman D,Evolutionary games in economics,Econometrica,1991,59(3):637~666
    [116]M. Marilyn,Knowledge management at HP consulting,Journal of knowledge management,1998,2(2),71~77
    [117]Preffer J.,Robert L. S.,Knowing What to do is not enough:turning knowledge into action,California Management Review,1999,42(l):83~108
    [118]许淑君,马士华,供应链企业间的信任机制研究,工业工程与管理,2000,(6):5~8
    [119]申学武,聂规划,沈凌,科技型动态联盟中知识共享的激励机制与对策研究,科学学与科学技术管理,2007,(6):94~97
    [120]祁红梅,黄瑞华,动态联盟形成阶段知识产权冲突及激励对策研究,研究与发展管理,2004,16(4):70~76
    [121]王谢春,知识产权侵害赔偿,北京:中国经济出版社,1997,4~5
    [122]Y·巴泽尔,产权的经济分析(费方域,段毅才译),上海:上海三联书店,上海人民出版社,1997,2~4
    [123]H·德姆塞茨,陈昕,财产权利与制度变迁一产权学派与新制度学派译文集,上海:上海三联书店,上海人民出版社,1994,96~113
    [124]Rowe W D,Understanding uncertainty,Risk Analysis,1994,(14):743~750
    [125]曹洪医,汪定伟,动态联盟中的项目风险优化模型,系统工程理论方法应用,2001,10(1):56~59
    [126]冯蔚东,陈剑,赵纯均,虚拟企业中的风险管理与控制研究,管理科学学报,2001,4(3):1~8
    [127]高晚欣,刘希宋,虚拟企业风险研究,哈尔滨工程大学学报,2004,25(1):118~123
    [128]Ring P.S , Van De Ven A , Developmental processes of cooperative inter-organizational relationships,Academy of Management Review,2003,19(1):90~118
    [129]J.Y. Lee,E. Mansfield,Intellectual Property Protection and US Foreign Direct Investment,Review of Economics and Statistics,1996,78(2):86~101
    [130]M.V Cannicea,Roger Chen,J.D Daniels,Managing international technology transfer risk:A case analysis of US high-technology firms in Asia,Journal of High Technology Management Research,2003,14(2):171~187
    [131] G.Walker,Strategic Sourcing,Vertical Integration,and Transaction Costs,Interfaces,1988,18(3):64~87
    [132]K.K Cauthorn,Managing intellectual property risk:Because knowledge is a company’s greatest asset,Intellectual Asset Management Practice,2004,(1):1~20
    [133]H.W. Chesbrough,D.J. Teece,When is virtual virtuous?Organizing for Innovation,Harvard Business Review,1996,74(1):65~73
    [134]W. Barnett , The organizational ecology of a technological system ,Administrative Science Quarterly,1990,35(1):31~60
    [135]Zander Udo,Bruce Kogut,Knowledge and the Speed of the Transfer and Imitation of Organizational Capabilities:An Empirical Test,OrganizationScience,1995,6(1):76~92
    [136]David. Teece , Strategies for Capturing the Financial Benefits from Technological Innovation,In Nathan Rosenberg, et al.,eds,Technology and the Wealth of Nations,Stanford:Stanford University Press, 1992, 175~205
    [137]J. Hagedoorn,Understanding the rationale of strategic technology partnering:Interorganizational modes of cooperation and sectoral differences , Strategic Management Journal,1993,14(5):371~385
    [138]G. Hamel,Competition for Competence and Inter-Partner Learning Within International Strategic Alliances,Strategic Management Journal,1991,(12):83~104
    [139]Frank Jurgen Richter,Lai Vettel,Successful Joint Ventures in Japan:Transferring Knowledge Through Organizational Learning,Long Range planning,1995,28(3):37~45
    [140]G.P.Piscano,Using equity participation to support exchange:evidence from the biotechnology industry,Journal of Law,Economics,and Organization,1989,5(1):109~126
    [141]J.E. Oxley,Appropriability hazards and governance in strategic alliances:a transaction cost approach,Journal of Law,Economics,and Organization,1997,13(3):387~409
    [142]程民选,信誉与产权制度,成都:西南财经大学出版社,2006,94~95
    [143]康芒斯,制度经济学(下)(于树生译),北京:商务印书馆,2006,212
    [144]王冰,杨虎涛,自发信誉机制与社会强制信誉机制,江汉论坛,2003,(3):45~47
    [145]何宇,市场交易风险及其治理机制—兼论我国信用体系建设,经济与管理论丛,2004,(4):87~88
    [146]郑文红,李健,产品市场中的诚信及对市场交易的影响,经济与管理研究,2002,(3): 20~21,34
    [147]杜金岷,朱小明,周鑫,市场经济中社会信用行为的博弈分析,南方金融,2001,(7):13~15
    [148]冯晓青,企业知识产权战略,北京:知识产权出版社,2001,40~42

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700