中国矿业城市可持续发展力指数研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
矿业城市为我国经济建设做出了巨大贡献,但由于历史原因和现行政策的缺陷,矿业城市发展也面临很多问题。在这样的背景下,我国学者对矿业城市的四矿问题、经济转型问题和可持续发展问题进行了大量研究。但由于在进行综合评价研究时采用的多元统计方法本身的缺陷,导致综合评价结果缺乏物理意义,难以实现序列研究和截面研究结果的相互借鉴和比较。故作者以矿业城市可持续发展力指数这一综合概念为研究对象,通过一系列方法力图构造出物理意义明确的综合指数,这将有助于深入进行矿业城市可持续发展战略分析。
     本文从系统论出发,结合可持续发展理论、技术创新理论和循环经济理论,提出了经济、资源、环境、社会和智力5大系统,并分别就每个系统的指标作了分类设计。在充分考虑了不同方法的优劣之后,本文结合主成分构权方法、层次分析构权方法和模糊综合法将原矿业城市可持续发展力指标体系转换成分层的指数体系,为进一步进行战略分析打下基础。
     为了深入反映不同类型矿业城市可持续发展力结构差异和现状,本文在矿业城市可持续发展力指数体系的基础上,分析了各种城市在不同指数均数水平上的差异,得到的基本结论包括:①不同矿种矿业城市在五大子系统上表现存在差异;②能源类矿城可持续发展能力较好;③整体水平有待提高。
     为了更好地分析矿业城市发展中存在的特点,本文在矿业城市可持续发展力指数体系的基础上,采用系统聚类法对矿业城市进行了聚类分析,按照矿业城市表现出的内在相似性将矿业城市分为6类,它们分别是:“富资源型城市”、“新兴可持续型城市”、“资源需求型城市”、“煤炭主导型城市”、“转型需求型矿业城市”和“欠可持续发展型城市”。
     另外,在矿业城市可持续发展力指数体系的基础上,采用单因素方差分析探讨了矿业城市可持续发展力的演变规律。得到的基本结论包括:①矿业城市可持续发展力在地理位置上有显著差异;②发展阶段、城市规模和矿产资源上除城市规模的环境可持续发展力指数上有显著差异外,其余因素均无显著差异;③矿业城市演变规律有一定共性,这便于制定具有相对普适性的战略体系。
     最后,在现状分析、聚类分析和演变规律分析的基础上,本文提出了基于EVS理论的矿业城市可持续发展战略体系。这些战略内容包括:科技主导战略、循环经济战略、接替产业战略、资源储备战略和比较优势战略。
Mining cities have made great contribution to our country’s national economic development, but owing to historical reasons and the defects of the current policies, the mining cities have confronted many problems. Under such a background, Chinese scholars have done many studies on comprehensive issues in the mining industry, economy transition and the sustainable development of mining cities. Because the multivariate statistical methods have some defects, the result of the analysis have no physical meaning, and then it is difficult for cross-section analysis or sequential analysis. Therefore, the author made the sustainable development index framework of mining cities as the research core; this will help in-depth analysis of the sustainable development strategies of mining cities.
     In order to get the scientific and rational index system of mining cities, this paper constructed index system that based on the system theory, sustainable development theory, technical innovation theory, the circular economy theory. The index system has 5 subsystems which included economy, resources, environment, social and intellectual, and then this paper made a classification design of indexes for each system. After full considering the quality of different methods, the author integrated principal component weight method, hierarchical analysis weight method and fuzzy comprehensive method for transforming the normal index system to the sustainable development index framework. The sustainable development index framework is the base of strategies analysis.
     In order to deeply expound the differents of structural and status between all types of mining cities, this paper compared the levels of index meanings. After the analysis, this paper drew the conclsions that concluded:①there are significant differences in different mineral cities;②energy mining cities have stronger power of sustainable development;③the meaning level in every index is not high.
     In order to better analyze the development characteristics of mining cities, based on the sustainable development index framework, using hierarchical clustering analysis, the mining cities were divided into 6 types. They are“rich resources cities”,“emerging sustainable cities”,“resources demand cities”,“coal leading cities”,“transformation demand cities”,“owe sustainable cities”.
     Based on the sustainable development index framework, using Onaway ANOVA, this paper discussed the evolution rules of the geographical position, stage of development, urban scale and mineral resources type. In this part, the paper drew the conclsions that concluded:①there are significant differences in the geographical position factor;②except of the environment sustainable development index in different urban scales, there is no significant differences in the other factors;③there are many commonness in mining cities, it’s helpful for formulating relatively universal strategies.
     At last, based on the status analysis, hierarchical clustering analysis and Onaway ANOVA, this paper put forward“EVS Strategy Model”. The strategies include: science and technology leading strategy, circulation economic strategy, replace industrial strategy, resources reserve strategy and comparative advantage strategy.
引文
Aschmann, H. The Natural History of a Mine. Economic Geography. 1970(46): 172-189
    Avila-Pires, F. D. The Concept of Sustainable Development Revisited. Foundations on Science. 2000(5): 261-268
    Barbier, E. B. Economic, Natural Resources Scarcity and Environment. London: Earthcan. 1985
    Barbier, E. B. The Concepts of sustainable development, Environment. Conservation. 1987(14): 101-110
    Bradbury, J. H. Towards an Alternative Theory of Resource~based Town Development. Economic Geography. 1979. 55(2): 147-166
    Bradbury, J. H. The Impact of Industrial Cycles in Themining Secter. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research. 1984. 8(3): 311-331
    Bradbury, J. H. International Movements and Crises in Resource Oriented Companies. Economic Geography. 1985. 61(2): 129-143
    Bradbury, J. H. Resource Communities:Settlement and Workforce Issues. Australia: CSIRO. 1988:3-19
    Bradbury, J. H. and I. S. Martin. Winding Down in a Qubic Town: a Case Study of Schefferville. The Canadian Geographer. 1983. 27(2): 128-144
    Carbon, B. Sustainable Development and the Evolving Agenda for Environmental Protection in the Mining Industry. Industry and Environment. 1997. 20(4): 10-13
    Chenery and B. Hollis. Patterns of Industrial Growth. The American Economic Review. 1960(50): 624-654
    Chiaro, P. S. Rio Tinto Borax Commits to Sustainable Development. Mining Engineering. 2001. 53(9): 33-35
    Colker and James. Transformation of an Industrial City: High-tech Comes to Pittsburgh. Management Review. 1985. 74(5): 48-52
    Daly, H. E. and J. J. Cobb. For the Common Good: Redirecting the Economy Toward Community. Boston: Beacon Press. 1989
    Dasgupta, P. and G. M. Heal. Economic Theory and Exhaustible Resources. London: Cambridge University Press. 1979
    Eggert, R. Sustainable Development and the Future of Mineral Investment. Nairobi: UNEP. 2000
    Forman, R. T. T. Ecologically Sustainable Landscape. The Role of Spatial Configuration. 1990(6): 101-121
    Gill, A. M. Enhancing Social Interaction in New Resource Towns: Planning Perspectives. Journal of Economic and Social Geography(JESG). 1990. 81(5): 348-363
    Grabher, G. The Embedded Firm: on the Socioeconomics of Industrial Networks, London and NewYork:Routledge. 1993
    Hayter, R. and T. J. Barnes. Labor Market Segmentation, Flexibility and Recession: A British Colombian Case Study. Environment and Planning. 1992. 10333-353
    Hennings, G. and K. R. Kunzmann. Global Challenge and Local Response,London and New York:Mansell. 1990
    Hilson, G. Sustainable Development Polieies in Canada`s Mining Sector:An Overview of Government and Industry Efforts. Envoronment Science Policy. 2003(3): 110
    Houghton, D. S. Long-distamce Commuting:a New Approach to Mining in Australia. Geographical Journal. 1993. 159(3): 281-290
    Innis, H. A. The Fur Trade in Canada. Toronto: University of Toronto Press. 1930
    Islam, S. M. N. Economic modeling in sustainability Science: Issue, Methodology, and Implication. Environment, Development and Sustainability. 2005. 7(3): 377-400
    Jackson, R. T. Commuter Mining and the Kidston Gold Mine:Goodbye to Mining Town. GeograPhy. 1987. 72162-165
    James, P. M. The Miner and Sustainable Development. Mining Engineering. 1999. 51(6): 89-92
    Keana, J. H. APCG Yearbook: University of Hawai'i Press. 2000
    Kumah, A. sustainability and Gold Mining in the Developing World. Cleaner Prod. 2006(14): 315-323
    Kuznets and Simon. National Income and Industrial Structure. Econometrica. 1949(17): 205-241
    Labonne, B. The Mining Industry and The Community: Joining Forces for Sustainable Social Development. Natural Resources Forum. 1999(23): 315-322
    Leadbeater, D. Single-Industry Resource Communities and the New Crisis of Economic Development:Lessons of Elliot Lake. ELTAS Analysis Series. 1998#1A15
    Leadbeater, D. The Development of Elliot Lake,"Uranium Capital of the World":A Background tothe Layoffs of 1990-1996. ELTAS Analysis Series. 1998#1A19
    Leadbeater, D. Training,Mass Layoffs,and Single Industry Communities:Lessons of Elliot Lake. ELTAS Analysis Series. 1998#1A15
    Learmont, D. R. Mining Must Show It Is Sustainable. Mining Engineering. 1997(1): 36-50
    Lucas, R. A. Minetown,Milltown,Railtown:Life in Canadian Communities of Single Industry. Toronto: University of Toronto Press. 1971
    Marsh, B. Continuity and Decline in the Anthracite Towns of Pennsylvanian. Annals of the Association of American Geographers. 1987. 77(3): 337-352
    Melanie, J. and T. Gleeson, et al. The Energetic North: Development Gains and Growing Pains. ABARE conference paper. 2009(4):
    Miller, C. G. Mining and Sustainable Development: Environment Policies and Programmes of Mining Industry Associations. Industry and Environment. 1997. 20(4): 14-17
    Millward, H. A. A Model of Coalfield Development: Six Stages Exemplified by the Sydney Field. The Canadian Geographer. 1985. 29(3): 234-248
    Mortison, L. Reshaping the Minerals and Metals Industry. Mining Engineering. 2002. 54(8): 20-21
    O`Fairchealleigh, C. Economic Base and Employment Structure 1957 in Northern Territory Mining Towns. CSIRO. 1988. 29(1): 221-236
    Pearce, D. Sustainable Development, Economic and monetary Environment in the Third World. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing Ltd. 1990
    Pezzey, J. World Bank Environment Paper. 1992
    Randall, J. E. and R. G. Ironside. Communities on the Edge:an Economic Geography of Resource-dependent Communities in Canada. The Canadian Geography. 1996. 40(1): 17-35
    Robinson, I. M. Muriel Driver Memorial Lecture 1981: the mists of time. Canadian journal of occupational therapy. 1962. 48(4): 145-152
    Spooner, D. Mining and regional development. Oxford: Oxford University Press. 1981:8-9
    Wackemagel, M. and L. Onisto. Analyses National Natural Capital Accounting with the Ecological Footprinit Concept. Ecological Economics. 1999. 29(1): 375-390
    Wackemagel, M. and W. E. Rees: New Society Publishers. 1996
    Warren, R. L. The Community in America. Chicago: Rand Mcnally College Publishing. 1963
    Yearley. Sustainable Development for the Global Mining and Metals Industry. Mining Enginerring. 2003. 55(8): 45-48
    鲍寿柏,胡兆量,焦华富.专业性工矿城市发展模式.北京:科学出版社, 2000
    程绪平.建立资源型工矿城市发展的综合导向机制.国土与自然资源研究, 1994(03): 1-4
    邓念祖.工矿城市规划结构的探讨.城市规划汇刊, 1990(5): 57-62
    迪特尔·格罗塞尔,晏小宝.德意志联邦共和国经济政策及实践.上海:上海翻译出版公司, 1992
    丁磊,施祖麟.资源型城市经济转型——以太原为例.清华大学学报(哲学社会科学版), 2000(01): 52-56+79
    段汉明.中小煤炭城市主导产业的可持续发展对策--以陕西韩城为例.经济地理, 2000(4): 55-59
    樊杰.我国煤矿城市产业结构转换问题研究.地理学报, 1993(03): 218-226
    方觉曙.淮北市发展战略与区域整治问题--兼论两淮煤炭基地发展方向.地理学与国土研究, 1986(增刊): 41-46
    顾培亮.系统分析与协调.天津:天津大学出版社, 1998
    关凤峻.四矿问题.资源·产业, 2002(6): 86-88
    韩丽红,雷涯邻.矿业城市转型中的几个战略性问题.中国国土资源经济, 2008(05): 24-25+34+47
    贺艳,刘勇.关于资源性城市的可持续发展与再城市化问题.中国人口、资源与环境, 2000, 10(3): 54-56
    蒋建权.东北区煤矿城市可持续发展问题探讨.地理科学, 2000(3): 241-245
    蒋少华关凤峻胡小平.矿业城市的持续发展,关键在结构调整.中国地质矿产经济, 1999(08): 17-20+24
    焦华富,路建涛,韩世君.德国鲁尔区工矿城市经济结构的转变.经济地理, 1997, 17(2): 104-107
    柯文.鲁尔工业区的振兴及其启示.管理世界, 1992(2): 128-131
    孔令曦,韩传峰.我国矿业城市综合竞争力评价方法.同济大学学报(自然科学版), 2005, 33(2): 280-284
    李建华.资源型城市可持续发展研究.北京:社会科学文献出版社, 2007
    李晶.城市可持续发展指标体系及评价方法研究-以资源枯竭型城市为例.财经问题研究,2005(6): 52-56
    李堂军,曹靖字.矿区可持续发展评价指标体系与方法.山东矿业学院学报(社会科学版), 1999(6): 48-51
    李堂军,刘金辉,孙承爱.矿区可持续发展能力的实证分析与对策研究.中国软科学, 2003(10): 124-128
    李堂军,孙承爱,顾洪利.矿区可持续发展分层模糊综合评价方法研究.矿冶工程, 2001, 21(3): 15-17
    李文彦.煤矿城市的工业发展与城市规划问题.地理学报, 1978(1): 63-77
    李文彦.我国工业地理学研究的回顾与展望.地理学报, 1986(4): 370-379
    梁仁彩.试论能源基地的类型及其综合发展.地理研究, 1985(2): 9-17
    梁亚红.平顶山市工业可持续发展途径探讨.长江流域资源与环境, 1998(4): 323-327
    刘洪,杨伟民.关于煤炭工业城市产业结构调整的几个问题.中国工业经济研究, 1992(08): 48-52+33
    刘家顺.资源型城市工业结构高度化的目标模式.中国工业经济研究, 1992(6): 64-68
    刘力钢,罗元文.资源型城市可持续发展战略.北京:经济管理出版社, 2006
    刘伟科,雒爱萍.从铜川市看煤矿城市发展规划问题.经济地理, 1990(02): 50-54+59
    刘祥.论矿业城市可持续发展能力的综合测定.煤炭经济研究, 2004(5): 11-13
    刘易斯.芒德福.城市发展史-起源、演变、前景.北京:中国建筑工业出版社, 1989:334
    刘云刚.大庆市资源型产业结构转型对策研究.经济地理, 2000(05): 26-29
    龙如银.中国矿业城市可持续发展:理论与方法研究.北京:中国矿业大学出版社, 2005
    龙如银,何颜.矿业城市综合实力的评价与比较研究.中国矿业, 2005, 14(5): 26-29
    龙如银,汪飞.基于系统观的资源型城市经济转型初探.管理学报, 2008(5): 5
    路建涛.工矿城市发展模式比较研究.经济地理, 1997(3): 50-54
    罗树清.资源型城市的改革与发展.经济日报: 1997-08-18
    骆正山.矿产资源可持续开发评价指标体系的研究.金属矿山, 2005(4): 1-3
    马传栋.我国煤炭城巾的可持续发展.中国工业经济, 1999(2):
    马清裕.关于矿区城镇合理布局问题的探讨.城市规划, 1981(4): 20-31
    马清裕.城市与工业布局的区域研究.北京:科学出版社, 1986:1-28
    潘锡辉,雷涯邻.矿业城市的城市经营问题探讨.资源·产业, 2003(06): 88-90
    齐建珍.资源型城市转型学.北京:人民出版社, 2004
    钱勇,于左.东北资源型城市产业转型难题与破解.东北财经大学学报, 2008(1): 36-39
    沙景华,李刚.矿业城市经济转型的模式路径及经验研究——以吉林省辽源市为例.中国矿业, 2005, 14(12): 22-25
    沙景华,刘刚.资源型城市产业结构优化问题研究——以山西省大同市为例.中国矿业, 2005, 14(1): 90-93
    沙景华,欧玲.矿业循环经济评价指标体系研究.环境保护, 2008(04): 33-36
    邵晖,陈红枫.资源型城市经济转型分析--以宁夏石嘴山市为例.经济问题探索, 2008(6): 41-44
    沈镭.新亚欧大陆桥沿线矿业城市发展与矿业扶贫初探.宁夏大学学报(自然科学版), 1999(02): 5-8+19
    沈镭,程静.大同市煤炭型矿业城市可持续发展优化研究.自然资源学报, 1998(01): 52-57
    沈镭,程静.论矿业城市经济发展中的优势转换战略.经济地理, 1998(02): 41-45
    沈镭,程静.矿业城市可持续发展的机理初探.资源科学, 1999(01): 46-52
    宋冬林,汤吉军.沉淀成本与资源型城市转型分析.中国工业经济, 2004(6): 58-64
    宋玉祥.资源枯竭型城市经济转型与可持续发展研讨会论文集, 2004:92
    苏为华.综合评价学.北京:中国市场出版社, 2005
    孙盘寿.辽宁省中部地区城市发展的主要因素和城市类型.经济地理, 1981(02): 52-55
    孙盘寿,李海金.地区生产结构的确定.地理研究, 1986(01): 105
    汤建影,周德群.基于DEA模型的矿业城市经济发展效率评价.煤炭学报, 2003, 28(4): 342-347
    汤万金,高林,吴刚等.矿区可持续发展系统动力学模拟与调控.生态学报, 2000, 20(1): 20-27
    田霍卿.资源型城市可持续发展的思考.北京:人民出版社, 2000
    田苗,武友德.资源枯竭型城市产业转型实证研究.经济地理, 2006(4): 585-588
    汪安佑,雷涯邻.矿业城市经济转型与发展模式.北京:地质出版社, 2007
    汪安佑,余际从.矿业城市经济转型的“高新技术产业化模式”研究.中国矿业, 2005, 14(10): 22-25
    汪安佑,余际从.矿业城市经济转型的“高新技术产业化模式”研究--以白银市为例.中国矿业, 2005(10): 22-25
    王国栋.实现可持续发展--以辽源为例.中国改革报: 2001-09-05
    王厚伟,胡玉才,刘献琛.煤炭城市产业结构调整与发展研究.能源基地建设, 1996(03): 21-25
    王慧敏.流域可持续发展系统理论与方法.南京:河海大学出版社, 2000
    韦朝阳,赵桂久.我国煤矿区生态环境现状及综合整治对策.地理学报, 1997, 52(4): 300-307
    魏心镇.矿业资源区域组合类型与地域工业综合体.地理学报, 1981(4): 358-368
    吴萍等.产业演进机制与资源型老工业城市--个旧产业结构调整的定位分析.经济问题探索, 2004(1): 124-127
    夏永祥,沈滨.我国资源开发性企业和城市可持续发展的问题与对策.中国软科学, 1998(07): 115-120
    项泾渭.矿业城市产业结构调整模式的实证分析.煤炭经济研究, 2010, 30(8): 40-44
    项泾渭.矿业城市可持续发展力指数研究.中国煤炭, 2010(12): 28-30
    项泾渭,瞿春林.基于EVS模型的资源枯竭矿业城市经济转型潜力研究.中国煤炭, 2010(2): 28-32
    谢长青.白银市发展研究——对一个不发达地区的剖析.经济地理, 1988(04): 267-269
    徐向国.黑龙江省资源型城市转型进程与测度体系的研究:[博士学位论文].哈尔滨:东北林业大学, 2006
    许光洪.我国矿业城市的产业结构调整及其发展途径.中国人口.资源与环境, 1998(01): 29-33
    杨昌明,洪水峰.焦点问题法——建立矿产资源可持续发展指标体系方法探讨.地球科学——中国地质大学学报, 2001, 26(2): 213-216
    杨铁良.煤矿城市的国土整治问题.国土与自然资源研究, 1993(2): 8-13
    姚建华.大陆桥上干旱区工矿资源型城市发展研究--镍都金昌的发展分析.干旱区资源与环境, 1998(1): 88-93
    姚睿,胡兆量.北美澳洲工矿城镇发展研究.城市发展研究, 1997(01): 43-46
    于秀林,任雪松.多元统计分析.北京:中国统计出版社, 1999
    余际从.矿业城市界定及可持续发展能力研究.北京:地质出版社, 2009
    余敬,高谋艳.矿业城市矿产资源可持续力比较评价.地球科学——中国地质大学学报, 2007, 32(1): 123-129
    余敬,苏顺华,张忠俊等.矿产资源可持续力.北京:中国地质大学出版社, 2009
    臧淑英.资源型城市持续发展对策探讨--以鸡西市为例.资源科学, 1999(1): 51-56
    张秉福.资源枯竭型城市:问题与对策.国际技术经济研究, 2006, 9(2): 47-49
    张凤武.煤炭城市发展非煤产业的原则、类型与模式.能源基地建设, 1998(1): 28-29
    张红.从城市体系看甘肃省矿业城市的持续发展.兰州商学院学报, 1999(4): 27-30
    张米尔,武春友.资源型城市产业转型障碍与对策研究.经济理论与经济管理, 2001(2): 35-38
    张团结等.基于产业契合度的资源型城市产业转型效果评价模型研究.资源与产业, 2008(1): 1-3
    张秀生,陈先勇.论中国资源型城市产业发展的现状、困境与对策.经济评论, 2001(6): 96-99
    张耀军.矿业城市类型及发展现状比较研究.人文地理, 2005(06): 83-87
    张以诚.矿业城市分类及其发展模式.中国矿业报: 1997-10-10
    张以诚.我国矿业城市现状和可持续发展对策.中国矿业大学学报(社会科学版), 1999(01): 75-80
    赵景海.我国资源型城市空间发展研究:[博士学位论文].长春:东北师范大学, 2007
    赵景海,俞滨洋.资源型城市空间可持续发展战略初探—兼论大庆市城市空间重组.城市规划, 1999, 23(8): 55-56
    赵西君.成熟期资源型城市产业转型发展模式研究--以济宁市为例.地理与地理信息科学, 2007(6): 87-91
    赵宇空.中国矿业城市:持续发展与结构调整.长春:吉林科学技术出版社, 1995
    郑伯红.资源型城市可持续发展优化及案例研究.云南地理环境研究, 1999(3): 51-56
    中国大百科全书总编辑委员会.中国大百科全书·城市规划卷.北京:中国大百科全书出版社, 1990
    周德群,汤建影,程东全.中国矿业城市研究--结构、演变与发展.徐州:中国矿业大学出版社, 2002
    周海林.资源型城市可持续发展评价指标体系研究.地域研究与开发, 2000(3): 12-16
    朱关鑫,吴勤学.区域支柱产业的选择、优化和转换——兼论山西省产业结构的转换.中国工业经济研究, 1990(04): 49-55+14
    朱洪瑞等.资源型城市产业转型度的评价及案例.河北理工大学学报(社会科学版), 2008(2): 58-61,64
    朱训.矿业城市的可持续发展.国土资源, 2003(1): 4-7

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700