基于Kalman滤波和BP神经网络的财务危机动态预警模型研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
自2007年末,以美国次贷危机引发的全球性金融危机正横扫世界,各国均在寻求医治这一危机的良方,各种救市方案、救援措施纷纷出台。虽然财务危机预警源于公司财务的实证研究领域,但从目前研究成果和应用需求的发展来看,财务危机预警是一种复杂、综合性的动态管理过程,其理论和实践涉及到预警理论、过程控制理论、动态信息技术、数理工具以及模拟技术等多学科知识。
     企业的财务状况具有持续性特点和累积效应,公司出现财务危机是有一个逐渐演变的过程;并且企业财务状况暂时的偏离正常值不应被归为危机公司。而传统的静态财务危机预警模型以单期截面数据预测财务危机,忽略了历史的时间序列数据对结果的影响,以及建模方法中的固有缺陷致使其难于在公司财务管理中推广应用。因此,我们有必要对财务危机预警的机理作深入的研究,建立适用于实际情况的预警模型,就企业的财务状况进行跟踪、监控和预警,及早发现财务危机信号,预测企业可能的财务失败,避免和减少对企业的破坏程度。
     本文从上市公司发生财务危机是财务状况、经营质量和治理效能共同作用的结果入手,归纳出包括财务指标,经营质量指标和治理指标三个方面的综合预警指标体系。并且考察公司绩效的动态过程,侦测出公司由好向坏转变,由轻至重的两个阈值分割点,由此建立了基于Kalman滤波的财务危机动态预警模型,观测到公司财务状况由健康运营、到财务风险、财务危机、直到企业破产等一系列企业失败的过程演变的轨迹。同时,本文根据公司治理指标的静态性特点,建立了基于BP神经网络的财务危机预警模型,从而在时间序列和横截面两个维度完善了对财务危机预警问题的研究,突显出纳入了公司治理指标的预警模型的优越性,检验了“公司治理因素变量能够帮助企业预测财务危机”这样一个问题。本文采用大样本、多变量、长时间序列的数据进行实证研究,两种预警模型都显示出了良好的稳健性和预测能力。
     首先,上市公司财务危机动态预警理论的研究。通过分析企业发生财务危机的动态性特征,梳理出动态预警的相关理论,指出财务状况恶化是导致财务危机的直接动因,经营不善是引发财务危机的内在基础,而公司治理的弱化是发生财务危机的内生动力。由此从财务状况、经营质量和公司治理三个维度分析对上市公司发生财务危机的影响,初步选取了30个财务指标和11个公司治理指标,建立了基于上市公司这一微观层面的财务危机动态预警综合指标体系,着重解决了建立财务危机预警指标体系的理论依据和完整性的问题。
     其次,上市公司财务危机预警数据的分析与检验。本文从CCER数据库中选取264家危机公司和健康公司作为研究样本,包括41个综合预警指标,时间跨度为1994-2008年,合计2874个年度观测数据进行截面和时序的分析与检验。通过对样本数据的描述性统计和噪声预处理、非参数检验、相关性分析、标准正态性转换和全局主成分分析,以此克服了国内外截面分析中存在的逻辑问题,简明扼要地把握了定量数据的持续性变化和累积效果的动态规律。
     然后,基于Kalman滤波构建企业财务危机动态预警模型。通过对Kalman滤波在财务危机预警中的适用性进行分析,建立了随机滤波模型,以企业连续多年的观测量作为滤波器的输入,以企业的状态或估计参数作为滤波器的输出,由计算机实现实时递推算法,通过对误差与数据间的处理把时间更新和观测更新算法联系在一起,不断更正模型参数,组建出最优滤波方程。本研究应用MATLAB编写M程序,实现财务危机预警的Kalman滤波器的计算及可视化。并应用极大似然估计对模型进行参数辨识,得出最合适的参数集。同时,根据企业绩效的动态过程,把企业的财务状况分为三个阶段,提取出公司由好向坏转变,由轻至重的两个阈值分割点。把应用滤波模型所得到的预测结果与真实状态值进行比较,从预测精度、敏感性和专一性等几个角度识别模型的检验能力。实证结果表明,基于Kalman滤波的动态预警模型具有良好的远期预测能力和动态校正的功能,是优于现有判别技术的预警模型。
     最后,公司治理视角下的BP神经网络的财务危机预警模型的研究。时间序列和横截面作为研究财务危机预警问题的两个客观维度,可以弥补彼此的不足。由于动态预警模型所需的时间序列数据非常大,并且公司治理数据的趋势性并不明显,但考虑到作为引发财务危机的深层次原因,由此建立了基于BP神经网络的财务危机预警模型,它由两组是否纳入公司治理变量的样本所组成。通过构建的22个输入节点、3个输出节点的13层神经网络,并且对其加以训练和仿真,通过对模型的学习和仿真,得到了纳入公司治理变量的综合模型正确率达到了99.18%的理想效果,突显出纳入了公司治理变量的预警模型的优越性和模型本身在分类识别能力上的精确性能。
     本文对企业财务危机预警的理论和模型方法的研究,拓广了财务危机动态预警评价的理论,是一个十分重要的决策辅助工具,能够为上市公司、证券市场和相关利益人提供理论指导和技术支持,具有重要的理论和实际意义。
The global financial crisis triggered by the United States sub-prime crisis has been swep the world since the end of 2007.Countries were seeking remedy to cure this crisis and various rescue measures have been proposed. While the financial distress (FD) early-warning is from the company's financial empirical research, the FD early-warning is a complex, integrated dynamic management process from the current research and applications development, and its theory and practice related to early-warning theory, progress control, dynamic science tools, simulation technology and many other academic knowledge.
     The companies’financial state is of an ongoing character and has the cumulative effect. It is a gradual process of evolution that company has a financial distress. Also a temporary deviation from the normal should not be classified as a crisis company. The traditional static financial distress early-warning model is based on one-period cross-sectional data and predicts the financial distress, which ignored the historical time series data’s the impact on the results, as well as the inherent flaws to the modeling approach resulted that the methodology is hard to promote the use of financial management. Therefore, we need research on the financial distress early-warning mechanism deeply, and develop an early-warning model attempt to the actual financial state which can track, control and early warning, also predict financial distress signals, and prevent or reduce the damage to the business.
     In this paper, we conclude that a listed company occurs a financial distress is the outcome of financial state, management quality and governance performance. Hence the comprehensive early warning indicator system includes financial indicators, management quality indicators and governance indicators. And we detect that the dynamic process of corporate performance, and observe the company’s changes from good to bad, from light to heavy two-point threshold. Thus we establish a financial distress dynamic early warning model based on Kalman filtering. At the same time, we established financial distress static early warning model based on BP neural network since corporate governance indicators has static characteristics. Hence we improved the financial distress early warning research from two dimensions including time-series and cross-sectional. It highlights the superiority of early-warning model including corporate governance indicators. In this empirical research we use large sample, multi-variate, time series data, and both early-warning models have shown good stability and predictability.
     First of all, the research on the theory of the listed companies' financial distress early-warning indicators. Through deep analysis of the characteristics and causes of financial distress, we conclude that the deteriorating financial situation led to the financial distress is its immediate causes; its poor management is the internal basis triggered by financial distress, also the weakened corporate governance is the endogenous motivation which makes financial distress occurred. We selected 30 fiancial ratios and 11 corporate governance ratios to build a comprehensive indictor system, which can solve the theoretical basis and integrity issues of the financial distress early-warning indicator system.
     Second, we analyse and test the listed companies’financial distress early-waring data. We use CCER database and select 264 China listed companies as study samples. We chose 30 financial ratios from 1994 to 2008, including 2727 year-observation data to empirical study. Though descriptive statistics, noise pre-processing, non-parametric tests, correlation analysis, the standard normality conversion and principal component analysis, it can overcome the logic problems of.the existing domestic and international cross-section analysis.
     Then, we build a financial distress dynamic early-warning model based on Kalman filtering. Through its applicability for financial distress early-warning, stochastic filter model is established, which is real-time recursive algorithm by computer. The companies’observation data is as filter input and the companies’real state and parameters is as filter output. It links the time series update and observation update algorithm, and correct the model parameters, finanly formate the optimal filtering equation. In this study, MATLAB M program is used to achieve financial distress dynamic early warning model for Kalman filtering calculation and visualization. Maximum likelihood estimation is used for parameter identification. Meanwhile, according to the dynamic process of companies’performance, the financial state of a company is divided into three phases, we extract the company's transformation from good to bad, from light to heavy two-point thresholds. Comparing the real state and prediction, we identify the model’ability though prediction accuracy, sensitivity and specificity. The empirical results showed that the dynamics early-warning model based on Kalman filtering has long-term early warning capacities and dynamic correction function, which is superior to the existing financial distress early-warning models.
     Finally, we research on financial distress static early warning model based on BP neural network. Time-series and cross-sectional studies are as the two objective dimensions on research financial distress early warning, which can make up for each other's deficiencies. As the dynamic early-warning model require large time series data, and the trend of corporate governance data is not obvious, but as a deep reason trigger the financial distress, thus we establish a BP neural network model to predict financial distress early-warning, which consists of two sets of variables, whether include corporate governance measurement system. By building the 22 input nodes, 3 output nodes of the 13-layer neural network, its training and simulation, it concluded that the model’correct rate of 99.18% including corporate governance variables, which highlights the superiority of having corporate governance variables and model itself on the ability to identify the exact static performance.
引文
1陈磊.任若恩.时间序列判别分析技术和指数加权移动平均控制图模型在公司财务危机预警中的应用.系统管理学报.2009, (4): 241~251
    2 Charles H. Gibson, Patricia A. Frishkoff, Financial Statement Ananlysis.中国财政经济出版社. 1990:461~470
    3 Altman E. I. Financial Ratios, Discriminant Analysis, and the Prediction of Corporate Bankruptcy. Journal of Finance. 1968:589~609
    4 Deakin E. A Dicreminant Analysis of Predictors of Business Failure. Journal of Accounting Research. 1972:214~230
    5 Casey J.R.Using Operating Cash Flow Data to Predict Financial Distress: Some Extensions. Journal of Accounting Research. 1985: 140~149
    6 Gentry J. A., P. Newbold, D.T. Whitford. Classifying Bankrupt Firms with Funds Flow Components. Jounal of Accounting Research. 1985 ,(1):376~392
    7 Murugan Anandarajan, Picheng Lee, Asokan Anandarajan. Firms: an Examination of The Predictive Accuracy of Artificial Neural Networks. International Journal of Intelligent Systems in Accounting, Finance & Management. 2001,(10): 69~81
    8 Julio Pindado, Luis Rodrigues, Chabela de la Torre, Estimating Financial Distress Likelihood, Journal of Business Research. 2008,(9):995~1003
    9 Beaver W. H. Financial Ratios as Predictors of Failure, Empirical Research in Accounting: Selected study.Journal of Accounting Research. 1966,(5): 23~41
    10 Carmichael S. H., C. Zopounidis. A Survey of Business Failures with an Emphasis on Prediction Methods and Industrial Applications. European Journal of Operational Research. 1972,(29):487~513
    11 Scott J. The Probability of Bankruptcy: a Comparison of Empirical Predication and Theoretical Medel.Journal of Banking and Finance. 1981,(12):317~344
    12 Paul P. M. Jan Bilderbeek, Bankruptcy Prediction: the Influence of the Year Prior to Failure Selected for Model Building and the Effects in a Perid of Economic Decline.Intelligent Systems in Accounting, Finance and Management. 1992,(13):95~112
    13 Ross Neophytou, Andreas Charitou, Predicting Corporate Failure: Empirical Evidence for the UK.Corporate Finance. 2000,(9):457~471
    14张玲.财务危机预警分析判别模型及应用.预测. 2000,(6):38~40
    15孙星,邱苑华.企业财务危机预警双基点距离比值法.管理工程学报. 2005, (3): 106~111
    16王宗平,张淑慧.关于几种财务危机预警模型的比较.企业经济. 2006,(4): 136~137
    17阎娟娟,孙红梅,刘金花.支持向量机的上市公司财务危机预警模型.统计与决策. 2006,(12):158~159
    18郭晓顺.企业财务危机及其预警研究.武汉理工大学学报. 2007,(3):93~95
    19吴世农,卢贤义.我国上市公司财务困境的预测模型研究.经济研究. 2001,(6):46~57
    20邓晓岚,王宗军,李红侠,杨忠诚.非财务视角下的财务困境预警——对中国上市公司的实证研究.管理科学. 2006,(3):71~81
    21黄善东,杨淑娥.公司治理与财务困境预测.预测. 2007,(2):63~68
    22陈静.上市公司财务恶化预测的实证分析.会计研究. 1999,(4):31~39
    23申嫦娥.我国困境企业财务恶化趋势的实证分析.当代经济科学. 2005, (6):81~87
    24朱其俊,郜燕.基于多元统计分析的上市公司财务危机预警模型的研究.现代管理科学. 2007,(5):78~80
    25刘胜伟,周盛.上市公司财务危机预警模型的实证研究.金融经济. 2007, (10): 121~122
    26赵健梅,王春莉.财务危机预警在我国上市公司的实证分析.数量经济技术经济研究. 2003,(7):134~139
    27朱发根,刘拓,傅毓维.公司治理与会计信息视角下上市公司财务危机预警研究——理论依据、模型与实证.现代管理科学.2009,(6):60~61
    28彭韶兵,邢精平.公司财务危机论.清华大学出版社. 2005,(9):50~62
    29 Stewart Thornhill, Raphael Amit. Learning about Failure: Bankruptcy, Firm Age, and the Resource-based View, Organization Science. 2003,(9~10): 497~ 509
    30 Paul P.M.Pompe, Jan Bilderbeek. The Prediction of Bankruptcy of Small and Medium-sized Industrial Firms. Journal of Business Venturing, 2005, (20): 847~868
    31 Po-Chang Kong, Ping-Chen Lin. An Evolution-based Approach with Modularized Evaluations to Forecast Financial Distress. Knowledge– based Systems. 2006,(19):64~91
    32 Zhongsheng Hua, Yu Wang, Xiaoyan Xu, Bin Zhang and Liang Liang. Predicting Corporate Financial Distress Based on Integration of Support Vector Machine and Logistic Regression. Expert Systems with Applications. 2007,(33): 434~440
    33 Jie Sun, Hui Li. Listed Companies’Financial Distress Prediction Based on Weighted Majority Voting Combination of Multiple Classifiers. Expert Systems with Applications. 2007,(9):1~10
    34 Stewart Jones. David A. Hensher.Modelling Corporate Failure: A Multinomial Nested Logit Analysis for Unordered Outcomes.The British Accounting Review. 2007,(39):89~107
    35 Malcolm J. Beynon. Michael J. Peel. Variable Precision Rough Set Theory and Data Discretisation: an Application to Corporate Failure Prediction. Omega. 2001, (29):561~576
    36 Tzong-Huei Lin, A Cross Model Study of Corporate Financial Distress Prediction in Taiwan: Multiple Discriminant Analysis, Logit, Probit and Neural Networks Models.Neurocomputing. 2009,(6):1~10
    37 Steve R. Letza. Issues in Assessing MDA Models of Corporate Failure: A Supporting Research Note. The British Accounting Review.1994,(26): 281~286
    38 Teppo Martikainen, Timo Ankelo. On the Instability of Financial Patterns of Failed Firms and The Predictability of Corporate Failure. Economics Letters. 1991,(35):209~214
    39佘廉.企业预警管理理论.河北科学技术出版社. 1999:39~45
    40 Chi-Bin Cheng, Ching-Lung Chen. Chung-Jen. Financial Distress Prediction by a Radial Basis Function Network with Logit Analysis Learning. Computers & Mathematics with Applications. 2006,(2):579~588
    41 Xiaoyan Xu, Yu Wang, Financial Failure Prediction Using Efficiency as A Predictor. Expert System with Applications. 2009,(1): 366~373
    42 Raymond F. Mikesell. Comparative Analysis and Economic Policies with Special Reference to Financial Crises. Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis. 2000,(4):127~133
    43 Jia-Jane Shuai, Han-Lin Li. Using Rough Set and Worst Practice DEA in Business Failure Prediction. Lecture Notes in Computer Science. 2005,(10): 503~510
    44 Michael Nwogugu.Decision-making, Risk and Corporate Governance: ACritique of Methodological Issues in Bankruptcy/Recovery Prediction Models. Applied Mathematics and Computation. 2007,(2): 178~196
    45 Chih-Hung Wu, Gwo-Hshiung Tzeng, Yeong-Jia Goo and Wen-Chang Fang. A Real-valued Genetic Algorithm to Optimize the Parameters of Support Vector Machine for Predicting Bankruptcy.Expert Systems with Applications. 2007,(2):397~408
    46 Paul P.M. Pompe, Jan Bilderbeek. The Prediction of Bankruptcy of Small- and Medium-sized Industrial Firms. Journal of Business Venturing, 2005, (11): 847~868
    47 Parag C. Pendharkar. A threshold-Varying Artificial Neural Network Approach for Classification and its Application to Bankruptcy Prediction Problem, Computers & Operations Research. 2005,(10): 2561~ 2582
    48 Cheol-Soo Park, Ingoo Han. A case-Based Reasoning with The Feature Weights Derived by Analytic Hierarchy Process for Bankruptcy Prediction. Expert Systems with Applications. 2002,(10):255~264
    49 Michael Nwogugu, Decision-making, Risk and Corporate Governance: A Critique of Methodological Issues in Bankruptcy Prediction Models. Applied Mathematics and Computation. 2007,(2):178~196
    50 Fitzpatrick P.J.A Comparison of Ratios of Successful Industrial Enterprises with Those of Failed Firms, Certified Public Accountant. 1932,(2):589~605
    51 Smith R.F,A.H. Winakor.Changes in the Financial Structure of Unsuccessful Corporations.Urbana. University of Illinois, Bureau of Business Research. 1935,(10):57~69
    52 Merwin, C.L.Financial Small Corporations: In Five Manufacturing Industries. National Bureau of Economic Research. 1942: 1926~1936
    53 Beaver,W.H. Financial Ratios as Predictors of Failure, Empirical Research in Accounting: Selected Study.Journal of Accounting Research. 1966,(5):47~59
    54 Dambolena I.G., S.J.Khoury. Ratio Stability and Corporate Failure. Journal of Finance. 1980,(35):1017~1026
    55 Laitimen E.K.Financial Predictors for Different Phases of the Failure Process.Omega. 1993,(21):215~228
    56 Theodossiou A.W. LPM Versus Discriminant Analysis: A Specification Test and Application to Corporate Bankruptcies. Journal of Econometrics. 1991,(31): 151~178
    57 Meyer, P. A., H. W. Pifer. Prediction of Bank Failures.Journal of Finance. 1970, (9):853~868
    58 Laitimen, E.K. Financial Predictors for Different Phases of the Failure Process. Omega. 1993,(21):215~228
    59 Anja Cielen, Ludo Peeters, Koen Vanhoof.Bankruptcy Prediction Using a Data Envelopment Analysis. European Journal of Operational Research. 2004,(154): 526~532
    60 Marieke Quant, Peter Borm, Ruud Hendrickx, Peter Zwikker.Compromise Solutions Based on Bankruptcy Mathematical Social sciences. 2006, (51): 247~256
    61 George Mavrotas, Dmitri Vinogradov. Financial Sector Structure and Financial Crisis Burden. Journal of Financial Stability. 2007,(6): 45~50
    62 Silvia Muzzioli, Huguette Reynaerts. The Solution of Fuzzy Linear Systems by Non-linear Programming: a Financial Application. European Journal of Operational Research. 2007,(3):1218~1231
    63 Martin, D.Early Warning of Bank Failure.Journal of Banking and Finance. 1977,(1):249~276
    64 Ohlson. James A. Financial Ratios and the Probabilistic Prediction of Bankruptcy.Journal of Accounting Research. 1980,(18): 109~131
    65 Zavgren C. The Prediction of Corporate Failure: the State of The Art. Journal of Accounting Literature. 2007,(8): 434~440
    66 Sung-Hwan Min, Jumin Lee, Ingoo Han. Hybrid Genetic Algorithms and Support Vector Machines for Bankruptcy Prediction. Expert Systems with Applications. 2006,(10): 652~660
    67 Sjur Westgaard, Nico van der Wijst.Default Probabilities in a Corporate Bank Portfolio: A Logistic Model Approach.European Journal of Operational Research. 2001,(12):338~349
    68 Erkki K. Laitinen,Teija Laitinen. Bankruptcy Prediction: Application of the Taylor's Expansion in Logistic Regression. International Review of Financial Analysis. 2000,(9):327~349
    69 Odom Renaud. Sharda F. Murtagh. A Bank Failure Early Warning System Based on a Novel Localized Pattern Learning and Semantically Associative Fuzzy Neural Network.Expert Systems with Applications. 1990,(12):139~154
    70 Jain Bharat A., Barin N. Nag.Performance Evaluation of Neural NetworkDecision Models. Journal of Management Information Systems. 1997,(14): 201~216
    71 Arzum Erken Celik,Yalcin Karatepe.Evaluating and Forecasting Banking Crises through Neural Network Models: An Application for TURKISH Banking Sector. Expert Systems with Applications. 2007,(11): 809~815
    72 Luis J. de Miguel, Elena Revilla, J. Miguel Rodríguez, J. Manuel Cano. Application Of The Fuzzy ARTMAP Neural Network Architecture To Bank Failure Predictions.New Trends in Neural Computation. 1993 ,(10): 720~725
    73 Abir Jaafar Hussain, Adam Knowles, Paulo J.G. Lisboa. Wael El-Deredy. Financial Time Series Prediction Using Polynomial Pipelined Neural Networks. Expert Systems with Applications. 2007,(8):1~32
    74 Chih-Fong Tsai. Jhen-Wei Wu. Using Neural Network Ensembles for Bankruptcy Prediction and Credit Scoring. Expert Systems with Applications. 2007,(5):34~40
    75彭静.欧阳令南.国内外财务危机预警研究综述.科技进步与对策. 2007,(6):191~196
    76 Varetto F, Genetic Algorithms Applications in the Analysis of Insolvency risk, Journal of Banking and Finance. 1998,(22):1421~1439
    77 Shin K S, Lee Y J, A Genetic Algorithm Application in Bankruptcy Prediction Modeling, Expert Systems with Applications. 2002,(23):321~328
    78 Hyunchui Ahn, Kyoung-jae Kim, Bankruptcy Prediction Modeling with Hybrid Case-reasoning and Genetic Algorithm Approach, Applied Soft Computin. 2009,(3): 599~607
    79 Pawlak Z, Rough Sets, International Journal of Information and Computer Sciences. 1982,(11): 341~356
    80 Dimitras A I, Slowinski R, Susmaga R et al, Business Failure Prediction Using Rough Sets, European Journal of Operational Research. 1999,(114): 263~280
    81 Jingtao Yao. Joseph P. Herbert. Financial Time-series Analysis with Rough Sets, Applied Soft Computing. 2009,(9):1000~1007
    82 Hongkyu J, Han I, Lee H, Bankruptcy Prediction Using Case-based Reasoning, Neural Networks, and Discriminate Analysis, Expert Systems with Applications. 1997,(13):97~108
    83 Cheol-Soo P, Ingoo H, A Case-based Reasoning with the Feature Weights Derived by Analytic Process for Bankruptcy Prediction, Expert System withApplications. 2002,(23): 255~264
    84 Fan A. Palaniswami M. Selecting Bankruptcy Predictors Using a Support Vector Machine Approach Proceeding of the International Joint Conference on Neural Networks. 2000,(6):354~359
    85 Kyung-Shik Shin, Taik Soo Lee, Hyun-jung Kim, An Application of Support Vector Machines in Bankruptcy Prediction Model, Expert Systems with Applications. 2005,(28):127~135
    86王今,韩文秀.财务危机预警中财务比率的选择研究.数学的实践与认识. 2003, (8):36~41
    87刘红霞,韩嫄.董事会对经理层治理风险预警模型构建研究.天津财经学院学报. 2005, (12):43~46
    88 Platt, H. D., Marjorie B. Platt. Predicting Corporate Financial Distress: Reflections on Choice-based Sample Bias. Journal of Economics and Finance, 2002,(5):134~140
    89 Gentry J A. Newbold P, Whitford D T. Funds Flow Components, Financial ratios, and Bankruptcy. Journal of Business Finance and Accounting. 1987,(4):595~606
    90 Aziz A., D. Emanuel and G. Lawson. Bank Prediction: an Investigation of Cash Flow Based Models. Journal of Management Studies.1988,(25):1~33
    91周首华,杨济华,王平.论财务危机的预警分析——F分数模式.会计研究. 1996,(8):8~11
    92王自强,范贻昌,陈旭.基于可拓方法的ST公司财务危机预警模型研究.数学的实践与认识. 2006,(8):44~52
    93 Sanjai Bhagat, Brian Bolton.Corporate governance and firm performance. Journal of Corpotate Finance. 2008,(14):257~273
    94 W. Gary Simpson, Anne E.Gleason. Board structure, ownership, and financial distress in banking firms. International Review of Economics and Finance. 1999, (8):281~292
    95 Jae-Seung Baek, Jun-Koo Kang. Corporate governance and firm value: evidence from the Korean financial crisis. Journal of Financial Econmics. 2004,(71):265~313
    96 Todd Mitton. A cross-firm analysis of the impact of corporate governance on the East Asian financial crisis. Journal of Financial Economics. 2002,(64): 215~241
    97姜秀华,孙铮.治理弱化与财务危机:一个预测模型.南开管理评论. 2001, (5): 18~21
    98江向才,林玓.公司治理于财务困难公司效果之研究.南开管理评论. 2006, (1): 91~97
    99陈燕,廖冠民.大股东行为、公司治理与财务危机.当代财经. 2006, (5): 111~115
    100 Altman E. I., Corporate Financial Distress: a Complete Guide to Prediction, Avoiding and Dealing with Bankruptcy. First Edition. New York:Wiley. 1983,(2):1001~1016
    101 Goudie A.W., Fprecasting Corporate Failure: the Use of Discriminant Analysis Within a Disaggregated Model of The Corporate Sector. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society.1987,(1):69~81
    102 Goudie A. W. Meeks, G., The Exchange Rate and Company Failure in a Macro-micro Model of the UK Company Sector. Economic Journal. 1991,(10): 444~457
    103 Cout P.W., Radoff, S.E. A Two-stage Model for The Prediction of Corporate Failure in South Africa. Investment Analyst’s Journal.1993,(38):9~19
    104 Darayseh M.. Waples E., Tsoukalas D.Corporate Failure for Manufacturing Industries Using Firms Specifics and Economic Environment with Logit Analysis. Managerial Finance. 2003,(8):23~36
    105 Liu J. Macroeconomic Determinants of Corporate Failures: Evidence from the UK. Applied Economics. 2004,(36):939~945
    106章之旺,吴世农.经济困境、财务困境与公司业绩——基于A股上市公司的实证研究.财经研究. 2005,(5):112~122
    107 Viral V. Acharya, Sreedhar T. Bharath, Anand Srinivasan. Does Industry-wide Distress Affect Defaulted Firms? Evidence from Creditor Recoveries. Journal of Financial Economics. 2007,(9):366~380
    108 Benson Wier, James Hunton, Hassan R. Hassab Elnaby. Enterprise Resource Planning Systems and Non-financial Performance Incentive: the Joint Impact on Corporate Performance.International Journal of Accounting Information Systems.2007,(9):165~190
    109 Paul Hughes, Robert E. Morgan. A Resource-advantage Perspective of Product-market Strategy Performance & Strategic Capital in High Technology Firms. Industrial Marketing Management. 2007,(5):503~517
    110 Michael Hertzel, Zhi Li, Micah S., Inter-firm Linkages and The Wealth Effects of Financial Distress Along the Supply Chain.Journal of Financial Economics. 2008,(2):374~387
    111 John L. Teall. Shareholder Control and Financial Distress in the Thrift Industry. Journal of Business Research. 1993,(2):161~170
    112熊剑,陈凯凡.财务困境实证研究中的配对问题探讨.商业研究. 2004, (22):107~108
    113 M. E. Zmijewski. Methodological Issues Related to the Estimation of Financial Distress Prediction Models. Journal of Accounting Research. 1984, (22): 59~ 82
    114 H. Entorf, P. Winker. Investigating The Drugs–crime Channel in Economics of Crizme Models: Empirical Evidence from Panel Data of the German States. International Review of Law and Economics. 2008,(3):8~22
    115 William R. Leonard, Ricardo Godoy.Tsimane’Amazonian Panel Study ,(TAPS): The First 5 Years ,(2002–2006) of Socioeconomic, Demographic, and Anthropometric Data Available To The Public.Economics & Human Biology. 2008,(7):299~301
    116刘莉亚.银行危机早期预警模型的比较分析.当代经济管理. 2005,(5): 141~144
    117廖正华.郑少锋.高德山.我国上市公司财务危机预警系统构架新探.中国管理信息化. 2006,(11):65~66
    118邹友华.企业财务危机的防范与化解.经营与管理. 2008, (5):36~37
    119殷彦辉.财务危机预警系统与企业发展辨析.现代审计与会计. 2006,(2):20
    120刑精平.企业财务危机预警分析.博士论文.西南财经大学. 2003
    121方军雄.公司治理视角下的企业持续经营研究.博士论文.复旦大学. 2004
    122 Alves V. Ravi. Bankruptcy Prediction in Banks and Firms Via Statistical and Intelligent Techniques-A Review.European Journal of Operational Research. 1978,(3): 1~28
    123顾晓安.公司财务预警系统的构建.财经论丛. 2000,(4): 65~71
    124蔡岩松.基于企业生命周期的现金流量预测研究.博士论文.哈尔滨工业大学. 2007
    125 Blum, Mark P. Failing Company Discriminant Analysis. Journal of Accounting Research. 1974
    126韩福荣,徐艳梅.对中外合营企业稳定性的分析及评价.中国软科学. 2000,(6):54~59
    127 Assaf Eisdorfer. The Importance of Cash-flow News for Financially Distressed Firms. Financial Management. 2007,(9):33~48
    128原红旗.上市公司资产重组财务会计问题研究.会计研究. 1998,(10):1~10
    129孙铮,王跃堂.会计改革与会计信息质量——来自中国证券市场的经验证据.会计研究. 2001,(7):16~27
    130戴娜. ST公司的资产重组和盈余管理.证券市场导报. 2001,(1):1~5
    131 Bei Ye, Jianguo Yuan. Firm Value, Managerial Confidence, and Investments: the Case of China. Journal of Leadership Studies. 2008,(3):26~36
    132吴敬琏.现代公司与企业改革.天津:天津人民出版社. 1994
    133刘浩然.基于公司治理的企业战略失败问题研究.上海交通大学博士论文. 2007
    134曹德芳,夏好琴.基于股权结构的财务危机预警模型构建.南开管理评论. 2005, (4): 85~90
    135宾国强,舒元.股权分割、公司业绩与投资者保护.管理世界. 2003,(6): 101~107
    136 Sanford J. Grossman, Oliver D. Hart. One Share-One Vote and The Market For Corporate Control. Journal of Financial Economics. 1980, 20(1~3):175~202
    137 Andrei Shleifer, Robert W. Vishny. Management Entrenchment:The Case Of Manager-Specific Investments.Journal of Financial Economic. 1989,25(11): 123~139
    138 Mike Burkart, Fausto Panunzi.Agency Conflicts, Ownership Concentration, And Legal Shareholder Protection. Journal of Financial Intermediation. 2006,15(1):1~31
    139 Rafael La Porta, Florencio Lopez-de-Silanes, Andrei Shleifer, Robert Vishny. Investor Protection And Corporate Governance.Journal of Financial Economics. 2000,58(1~2):3~27
    140 Simon Johnson, Peter Boone, Alasdair Breach, Eric Friedman. Corporate Governance In The Asian Financial Crisis. Journal of Financial Economics. 2000,58(1~2):141~186
    141 Elloumi Stuart C., Gilson Gueyié. Bankruptcy, Boards, Banks, and Blockholders: Evidence on Changes in Corporate Ownership and Control When Firms Default.Journal of Financial Economics. 2001,27(10): 355~387
    142 Susan Parker. Gary F. Peters. Howard F. Turetsky. Corporate Governance andCorporate Failure: A Survival Analysis. Corporate Governance. 2002,(2):4~12
    143 Tsun-Siou, Lee Yin-Hua Yeh. Corporate Governance and Financial Distress: Evidence from Taiwan, NTU International Conference on Finance. 2004: 1473~1480
    144 Xiaonian Xu, Yan Wang. Ownership Structure, Corporate Governance and Firms’Performance: the Case of Chinese Stock Companies. World Bank, Policy Working paper. 1997:1794
    145吴超鹏,吴世农.基于价值创造和公司治理的财务状态分析与预测模型研究.经济研究. 2005,(11):99~110
    146李豫湘.胡新良.公司治理结构与财务危机关系研究综述.财会通讯.2007,(11):94~98
    147高明华,马守莉.独立董事制度与公司绩效关系的实证分析——兼论中国独立董事有效分权的制度环境.南开经济评论. 2002,(2):64~68
    148 Shivdasani, D Yermack. CEO Involvement in the Selection of New Board Members: An Empirical Analysis. Journal of Finance.1996,(54):1829~1854
    149 Judge W. Q., Zeithaml C.P. Instritutional and Strategic Choice Perspectives on Board Involvement in The Strategic Decision Process. Academy of Management Journal. 1992, 35(4):766~794
    150 Goodstein J. Gautam K, Boeker W. The Effects of Board Size and Diversity on Strategic Change. Strategic Management Journal. 1994,15(3):241~250
    151 Pfeffer J.Size, Composition and Function of Hospital Boards of Directors: A Study of Organization-environment Linkage. Administrative Science Quarterly. 1972,(17): 218~228
    152 Chaganti. R.S. MahajanV. Sharma S. Corporate Board Size, Composition and Corporate Failure in Retailing Industry. Journal of Management Studies. 1985,22(4):400~417
    153 E. F. Fama, M. C. Jensen. Separation of Ownership and Control. Journal of Law and Economics. 1983,(27):301~325
    154 M.C. Jensen. The Modern Industrial Revolution, Exit and the Failure of Internal Control Systems. Journal of Finance.199348,(3):831~880
    155白重恩,刘俏,陆洲.中国上市公司治理结构的实证研究.经济研究. 2005, (2): 81~91
    156石洪斌.汤美芳.国土规划综合评价指标体系的构建.资料通讯. 2004, (4): 17~21
    157 Stickney Clyde P.财务报告与报表分析.中信出版社. 2004: 32~40
    158付梦印,邓志红,张继伟. Kalman滤波理论及其在导航系统中的应用.科学出版社. 2003:1~5
    159 Klman R.E. A New Approach to Linear Filtering and Prediction Problems, Jounal of Basic Engineering.1961,83D: 95~101
    160 Agnieszka Krok,Zenon Waszczyszyn.Kalman Filtering for Neural Prediction of Response Spectra from Mining Tremors. Computers & Structures. 2007,(8): 1257~1263
    161 S. Deng,Y. Hwang.Solution of Inverse heat Conduction Problems Using Kalman Filter-enhanced Bayesian Back Propagation Neural Network Data Fusion. International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer. 2007,(6): 2089~2100
    162 Brian R. Hunt, Eric J. Kostelich and Istvan Szunyogh.Efficient Data Assimilation for Spatiotemporal Chaos: A Local Ensemble Transform Kalman Filter. Physica D: Nonlinear Phenomena. 2007,(6):112~126
    163 Brendan M. Quine.A Derivative-free Implementation of the Extended Kalman Filter.Automatica. 2006,(11):1927~1934
    164 Michael Dueker.Kalman Filtering with Truncated Normal State Variables for Bayesian Estimation of Macroeconomic Models.Economics Letters. 2006,(10): 58~62
    165 Abdüsselam Altunkaynak, Mehmet ?zger, Sevin? S?rda? and Ahmet Duran ?ahin.Artificial Neural Network-Kalman Filtering Approach for Solar Irradiation Estimation.2006,(9):1529~1541
    166 Hongwei Bian, Zhihua Jin and Weifeng Tian.IAE-adaptive Kalman Filter for INS/GPS Integrated Navigation System.Journal of Systems Engineering and Electronics. 2006,(9):502~508
    167 Wang Wenbin.An Inspection Model for a Process with Two Types of Inspections and Repairs. Reliability Engineering and System Safety. 2009, (94):526~533
    168 Deng Zili, Xu YAN, Shi Ying and Sun Shuli. Unified Fast Suboptimal Fixed-interval White Noise Wiener Smoothing Alqorithm, Autovntica Sinica. 2004,(2):239~243
    169 Julier S. J. Ulman J. K. A new extension of Kalman Filter to Nonlinear System. The 11th International symp. On Aerospace/Defence Sensing, Simulation and Control. 1997:182~193
    170 Doucet. B. A History of Particle Filter-PF Navigation. Journal of Navigation. 1999, (42): 109~164
    171 Branko Ristic. Philippe Smets. Kalman Filter and Joint Tracking and Classification Based on Belief Functions in the TBM Framework. Information Fusion. 2007, (1): 16~27
    172 Hopfiled H. Brunke. Two-quartic Tropospheric Refractivity Profile for Correcting Satellite Data. Journal of Geophysical Research. 2008,(18): 30 ~45
    173 A. H-D Cheng. K. EI Harrouni. Aquifer Parameter Estimation by Extended Kalman Filtering and Boundary Elements. Engineering Analysis with Boundary Elements. 1997, (4):231~237
    174 Jia Li, Dongbin Xiu. A generalized Polynomial Chaos Based Ensemble Kalman Filter with High Accuracy. Journal of Computational Physics. 2009,(8): 5454~ 5469
    175唐晓彬. Markov机制转换的状态空间模型及其在我国经济周期中的应用研究.统计研究. 2010, (2):94~99
    176王春峰,吴启权,李晗虹.仿射期限结构下贴现债券衍生工具定价研究.管理工程学报. 2008,(8):105~113
    177岳金桂,武琳.基于KALMAN滤波方法的全要素生产率估算.水利经济.2007(7):16~22
    178李晴.基于卡尔曼滤波的中美贸易收支分析.国际贸易问题. 2007(7):3~10
    179高宇明.齐中英.基于时变参数的我国全要素生产率估计.数量经济技术经济研究. 2008(2):100~111
    180杨卡林.卡尔曼滤波在经济预测中应用的探讨.重庆工商大学学报. 2008(9): 103~108
    181谢太峰,王子博.论中国宏观经济走势:基于产出缺口与AD-AS模型的分析.金融理论与实践. 2009(1):43~48
    182高铁梅,康书隆.外商直接投资对中国经济影响的动态分析.世界经济. 2006(4): 22~31
    183张德鸿,李向军.一般状态空间模型和东亚股票指数的波动.西安文理学院学报.2007(7):18~20
    184董长虹. Matlab神经网络与应用.北京:国防工业出版社. 2005: 26~49

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700