亚洲新兴经济体国际资本流动管理研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
国际资本流动管理是当前国际经济领域研究的热点问题,但关注点始终局限于某一具体政策,尤其是资本管制。但实际上,国际资本流动管理是一个系统性工作,除资本管制外,还涉及宏观领域和金融领域,即世界上并没有一项政策能够单独成为应对资本流入激增的灵丹妙药。本文选择国际资本流动管理的政策框架作为新视角,结合亚洲各国的具体情况,分别从宏观经济政策调整、金融体系改革以及资本管制等几个方面,考察了1997年金融危机后亚洲各国的国际资本流动管理措施,以期为亚洲以及我国在未来制定国际资本流动管理政策提供借鉴。
     首先,国际资本流动管理是有其理论支撑的,那便是对国际资本流动的影响机制以及产生的风险的认识。国际资本流入对东道国经济的影响机制包括汇率机制、资产价格机制、财富效应机制、声誉机制和政策效应机制。国际资本流入在给东道国带来各种经济利益的同时,也会给东道国宏观经济和金融稳定带来诸多风险。如果风险没有得到恰当管理,那么经济体系的风险会不断积聚,一旦外部冲击到来或者仅仅是由于预期的突然改变,积累于经济体系内的风险会集中释放,最终引发系统性的金融危机。
     其次,结合亚洲各国的具体情况,分别从宏观经济政策调整、金融体系改革以及资本管制等几个方面,考察了1997年金融危机后亚洲各国的国际资本流动管理措施,并着重探讨了各项治理措施的成效。在国际资本大规模流入时,各国短期内都优先采用冲销干预,长期依靠推行更有弹性的汇率制度、加强宏观经济政策和完善金融体系等。但由于冲销干预的成本会不断攀升,且容易陷入内外均衡的两难选择—选择稳定利率还是选择稳定汇率,而汇率制度、完善金融体系等改革往往需要较长的时期才能收到效果,因此,各国会在中短期内使用资本管制措施弥补以上两种措施的不足。亚洲新兴经济体的经验表明,资本流动管理并没有“放之四海而皆准”的且一成不变的固定模式,而且几乎每一项资本流动管理政策都有其局限性。资本流动管理要想达到预期效果,就必须要根据各国具体情况(包括政策目标、资本流入的原因和持续性、资本流动管理工具使用的政治及其他局限性)进行适当权衡,以决定应对资本流入的合适的政策体系。亚洲新兴经济体的经验还告诉我们,资本流动管理要想达到预期效果不仅仅需要对各种政策工具的开发和利用,更需要政策制定者的智慧与勇气。
     最后,本文对全球金融危机后国际资本流动管理的挑战及其未来努力方向做出了分析。全球金融危机对亚洲进出口贸易造成冲击,进而影响其经济增长,再加上外部经济条件的不确定性给亚洲国际资本流动管理提出挑战。亚洲各国除继续强化前期措施外,还应积极利用财政政策和努力推动经济增长,在全球和区域层面推动集体合作。
The management of international capital flows is a key issue of internationaleconomic. But the studies are limited in certain policy, especially in capital controls. Infact, the management of international capital flows is a system. Besides the capitalcontrols, it refers to the macroeconomic and the finance. So it is impossible to find asingle policy to manage the surge of the capital inflows effectively. Based on the policyframework of the management of international capital flows, the thesis, which considersthe specific situation of Asian countries, focuses on the management measures ofinternational capital flows after1997financial crisis among the Asian countries. It refersto the adjustment of macroeconomic policy, the reform of financial system and capitalcontrols. The thesis tries to provide some references on Capital Flow measures to Chinaand the whole Asia.
     Firstly, there are theories on the management of international capital flows, whichare the influence mechanism of the international capital flows and the understanding ofits risk. The influence mechanism includes the exchange rate mechanism, the asset pricemechanism, the wealth effect mechanism, the reputation mechanism and the policy effectmechanism. The international capital inflow brings host countries not only the economicbenefits, but also the risks of the macroeconomic and financial stable. If the risks are notmanaged appropriately, the risk of the economy will be accumulated. Once the externalshocks or the sudden change of the expectation, the accumulated risks of the economywill release, which may lead to systemic financial crisis.
     Secondly, considering the specific situation of Asian countries, the thesis focuses onthe management measures of international capital flows after1997financial crisis amongthe Asian countries, especially the effect of the measures. When the international capitalinflows are massive, each country may sterilize in short term; and in long-term, they willcarry out flexible exchange rate regime, enhance the macroeconomic policies and perfectfinancial system. But as the cost of sterilization will increase, it is easy to have thedilemma—to keep stable interest rate or stable exchange rate. However, the reform ofexchange rate and perfecting financial system needs a long-term to see the effect, so each country may use capital control measures in short and medium term to make up theshortfall of the two measures. The experience of Asian emerging economies shows thatthere are no such capital flow managements that fit all and fix a certain form, and nearlyall the policies have their limitation. To achieve the desired result, the capital flowmanagements should be adjusted according to the specific situation of the country,including policy objectives, the cause and persistent of the capital inflow, the politicalenvironment of the capital flow management and some other limitations. At the sametime, the experience of Asian emerging economies indicates that it is important todevelop and apply the policy tools, and the intelligence and courage of the policy makersare also vital for achieving the expected results.
     Finally, the thesis gives analysis to the challenges and future of the internationalcapital flow management after the global financial crisis. The financial crisis has greatimpact on Asian import and export trade, and it also affects the economic growth. Withthe uncertainty of the external economic conditions, the management of internationalcapital flows in Asia confronts many challenges. In addition doing more of what has beentried before, Asian countries ought to apply fiscal policy more actively and try topromote economic growth. What’s more, they ought to improve the cooperation in theregion and the whole world.
引文
①International Monetary Fund (IMF).Managing Capital Inflows: What Tools to Use?[R].IMF Discussion Note,2011
    ①江帆,朱浩珉,周恺锴.资产价格已成为通胀先行指标[N].上海证券报,2009-06-08:A06
    ①马勇,杨栋,陈雨露.信贷扩张、监管错配与金融危机:跨国实证[J].经济研究,2009(12):93-105
    ②曹荣湘.风险与金融安排[M].北京:社会科学文献出版社,2004:14
    ①Jorge Chan-Lau. The Impact of Corporate Governance Structures on the Agency Cost of Debt[R]. IMF WorkingPapers,2001
    ②鄂志寰.资本流动与金融稳定相关关系研究[J].金融研究,2000(7):80-87
    ①鄂志寰.资本流动与金融稳定相关关系研究[J].金融研究,2000(7):80-87
    ②窦祥胜,陈天慈.国际资本流动与泡沫经济简析[J].金融与经济,2002(01):28-30
    ①王喜平.国际资本流动与宏观经济稳定[D].博士学位论文,天津大学,2005
    ①Calvo. The Perils of Sterilization[R].IMF Staff Papers,1991(4):921-926
    ②叶辅靖.新兴市场国家对资本流动的监管[J].经济研究参考,2002(57)28-37
    ①王喜平.国际资本流动与宏观经济稳定[D].博士学位论文,天津大学,2005
    ①Jorge Chan-Lau.The Impact of Corporate Governance Structures on the Agency Cost of Debt[R]. IMF WorkingPapers,2001
    ①Claudia Dziobek. Market-Based Policy Instruments for Systemic Bank Restructuring[R]. IMF Working Paper,1998
    ①Gurnain Kaur Pasricha.Recent trends in measures to manage capital flows in emerging economies[J]. The NorthAmerican Journal of Economics and Finance,2012,vol.23,issue3,286-309
    ②Gurnain Kaur Pasricha.Recent trends in measures to manage capital flows in emerging economies[J]. The NorthAmerican Journal of Economics and Finance,2012,vol.23,issue3,286-309
    ②Chinn,M.D.&H. Ito.The Chinn-Ito Index: A De Jure Measure of Financial Openness[EB/01].http://web.pdx.edu/~ito/Chinn-Ito_website.htm.(Accessed:29August2009.)
    ③Lane,P. R.&G. M. Milesi-Ferretti.The External Wealth of Nations Mark II: Revised and Extended Estimates ofForeign Assets and Liabilities,1970–2004[R]. IMF Working Paper No.06/69,2006.
    ①项卫星,王达.国际资本流动格局的变化对新兴市场国家的冲击[J].国际金融研究,2011(7):51-58
    ①Masahiro Kawai, Mario B. Lamberte.Managing Capital Flows: The Search for a Framework[M]. AsianDevelopment Bank Institute,2010
    ①Jean-Marc Suret, Cameron Morrill, Janet Morrill.Availability and Accuracy of Accounting and Financial Data inEmerging Markets:The Case of Malaysia[R].CIRANO Working Paper,1997
    ①Soyoung Kim,Doo Yong Yan“Managing Capital Flows:The Case of the Republic of Korea” ADB InstituteDiscussion Paper No.882008
    ②Ooi Sang Kuang. Capital flows and financial assets in emergingmarkets:determinants,consequences and challengesfor central banks:the Malaysian experience[R]. BIS Papers No44
    ①Philip Turner. ARE BANKING SYSTEMS IN EAST ASIA STRONGER[J]. Asian Economic Policy Review.2007(1):75–95
    ①M S Mohanty and Philip Turner. Banks and financial intermediation in emerging Asia:reforms and new risks[R].BIS Working Papers,2010
    ①M S Mohanty and Philip Turner. Banks and financial intermediation in emerging Asia:reforms and new risks[R].BIS Working Papers,2010
    ①Philip Turner. ARE BANKING SYSTEMS IN EAST ASIA STRONGER[R]. Asian Economic Policy Review,2007(1):75–95
    ①Lena Suchanek&Garima Vasishtha. The Evolution of Capital Flows to Emerging-Market Economies[J]. BANK OFCANADA REVIEW,2009–2010(WINTER):15-27
    ①Lena Suchanek&Garima Vasishtha. The Evolution of Capital Flows to Emerging-Market Economies[J]. BANK OFCANADA REVIEW,2009–2010(WINTER):15-27
    ①刘仁伍.东南亚经济发展地图[M].北京:社会科学文献出版社,2007:22
    ②Maria Socorro Gochoco-Bautista&Eli M. Remolona. Going Regional:How to Deepen ASEAN’s FinancialMarkets[R].ADB Economics Working Paper Series No.300,2012
    ①唐珏岚.无息准备金:管理短期资本流动的重要工具[J].上海经济研究,2008(5):18-26
    ①Yunyong Thaicharoen&Nasha Ananchotiku. Thailand’s experiences with rising capital flows:recent challenges andpolicy responses [R]. BIS Papers,2008:441.
    ①Maria Socorro Gochoco-Bautista, Juthathip Jongwanich&Jong-Wha Lee.How Effective are Capital Controls inAsia?[R]. ADB Working Paper,2010
    ①Susan Schadler. Managing Large Capital Inflows:Taking Stock of International Experiences[R]. ADB InstituteDiscussion Paper No.97,2008(3)
    ①黄益平.亚洲汇率波动及政策挑战[J].国际金融研究,2009(5):39-45
    ①Hayashi,M.Structural changes in Indonesian industry and trade:an input–output analysis[J].The DevelopingEconomies,2005
    ①Asian Development Bank.Asia Capital Markets Monitor[R].2010(5)
    ①Masahiro Kawai, Mario B. Lamberte.Managing Capital Flows:The Search for a Framework[M].A JOINTPUBLICATION OF THE ASIAN DEVELOPMENT BANK INSTITUTE AND EDWARD ELGAR PUBLISHING,2010
    ④Robert E. Lipsey,Robert C. Feenstra,Carl H. Hahn&George N. Hatsopoulos. The Role of Foreign DirectInvestment in International Capital Flows[R]. National Bureau of Economic Research,Inc,1999
    ①河合正弘,马里奥·兰伯特和高木伸二.资本流动管理:亚洲新兴经济体近期的经验教训[J].国际经济评论,2012(5):85-94
    ①黄益平.亚洲汇率波动及政策挑战[J].国际金融研究,2009(5):39-45
    ①Gurnain Kaur Pasricha.Recent trends in measures to manage capital flows in emerging economies[J]. The NorthAmerican Journal of Economics and Finance,2012,vol.23,issue3,286-309
    ②Jonathan D. Ostry, Atish R. Ghosh, Karl Habermeier, Marcos Chamon,Mahvash S. Qureshi, and Dennis B.S.Reinhardt.Capital Inflows:The Role of Controls[R].IMF Staff Position Note,2010
    ③Jonathan D. Ostry, Atish R. Ghosh, Karl Habermeier, Marcos Chamon,Mahvash S. Qureshi, and Dennis B.S.Reinhardt.Capital Inflows:The Role of Controls[R].IMF Staff Position Note,2010
    ④Nicolas E. Magud, Carmen M. Reinhart, Kenneth S. Rogoff. Capital Controls: Myth and Reality-A PortfolioBalance Approach[R].NBER Working Paper,2011
    ②Masahiro Kawai, Mario B. Lamberte.Managing Capital Flows:The Search for a Framework[M].A JOINTPUBLICATION OF THE ASIAN DEVELOPMENT BANK INSTITUTE AND EDWARD ELGAR PUBLISHING,2010
    ①Masahiro Kawai Mario&B. Lamberte.Managing capital flows:emerging Asia’s experiences,policy issues andchallenges[R]. ADB Institute Discussion Paper,2008
    ②Robert N. McCauley.Managing Recent Hot Money Inflows in Asia[R].ADB Institute Discussion Paper,2008
    ③Susan Schadler.Managing large capital inflows:taking stock of international experiences[R].ADB InstituteDiscussion Paper,2008
    ①Masahiro Kawai Mario&B. Lamberte.Managing capital flows:emerging Asia’s experiences,policy issues andchallenges[R]. ADB Institute Discussion Paper,2008
    ①Ocampo,J.A.&M.L.Chiappe.Counter-Cyclical Prudential and CapitalAccount Regulations in DevelopingCountries[J]Stockholm:Almqvist&Wiksell International,2003
    ②Kawai,M..Toward a Regional Exchange Rate Regime in East Asia[J].Pacific Economic Review,2008.
    ③河合正弘,马里奥·兰伯特,高木伸二.资本流动管理:亚洲新兴经济体近期的经验教训[J].国际经济评论,2012(5):85-94
    [1] Ashoka Mody, Antu Panini Murshid. Growth from International Capital Flows:TheRole of Volatility Regimes[R].IMF Working Paper WP/11/90,2011(4)
    [2] Benedict Clements&Herman Kamil. Are Capital Controls Effective in the21stCentury? The Recent Experience ofColombia[R].IMF Woring Paper,2009
    [3] Bernardo S. de M. Carvalho1&Márcio G.P.Garcia. INEFFECTIVE CONTROLSON CAPITAL INFLOWS UNDER SOPHISTICATED FINANCIAL MARKETS:BRAZIL IN THE NINETIES[M].University of Chicago Press,2006
    [4] Bruno Coelho&Kevin P. Gallagher.Capital Controls and21st Century FinancialCrises:Evidence from Colombia and Thailand[R]. PERIWorking Paper,2010
    [5] Chikako Baba&Annamaria Kokenyne. Effectiveness of Capital Controls inSelected Emerging Markets in the2000s[R].IMF Working Paper,2011
    [6] Coelho, B.and K.P. Gallagher.Capital Controls and21st Century Financial Crises:Evidence from Colombia and Thailand[R].PERI Working Paper No.213,PoliticalEconomy Research Institute, University of Massachusetts, Amherst,2010
    [7] D. Filiz Unsal.Capital Flows and Financial Stability:Monetary Policy andMacroprudential Responses [R]. IMFWorking Paper,2011
    [8] Dennis Reinhardt, Luca Antonio Ricci&Thierry Tressel. International CapitalFlows and Development:Financial Openness Matters[R]. IMF Working PaperWP/10/235,2010(10)
    [9] Eduardo Levy Yeyati, Sergio L. Schmukler, Neeltje Van Horen.Internationalfinancial integration through the law of one price:The role of liquidity and capitalcontrols[R]. Journal of Financial Intermediation,2009(3):432-463
    [10]Eduardo Levy Yeyati, Sergio L. Schmukler, Neeltje Van Horen.Crises, CapitalControls, and Financial Integration[R]. World Bank Policy Research Working PaperNo.4770,2008
    [11]ELIAN CARDOSO&ILAN GOLDFAJNA.Capital Flows To Brazil:TheEndogeneity of Capital Controls[R]. IMF STAFF DISCUSSION NOTE,1998
    [12]Enrico Perotti, Lev Ratnovski&Razvan Vlahu.Capital Regulation and Tail Risk[R].IMFWorking Paper,2011
    [13]Francisco Gallego, Leonardo Hernández, Klaus Schmidt-Hebbel.CAPITALCONTROLS IN CHILE:EFFECTIVE? EFFICIENT?[R].Central Bank of ChileWorking Papers,1999
    [14]Graciela Laura Kaminsky, Carmen M. Reinhart. Financial Crises in Asia and LatinAmerica:Then and Now[J]. American Economic Review,1998(2):444-448
    [15]Guillermo A. Calvo. The Perils of Sterilization[R].IMF Staff Papers,1991(4):921-926
    [16]Guillermo Le Fort V.&Carlos Budnevich L.Capital Account Regulation andMacroeconomic Policy:Two Latin American Experiences[R]. Levy EconomicsInstitute Working Paper,1996
    [17]Gurnain Kaur Pasricha. Recent trends in measures to manage capital flows inemerging economies[J]. The North American Journal of Economics andFinance,2012,vol.23,issue3,286-309
    [18]Hwee Kwan Chow.Managing Capital Flows:The Case of Singapore [R]. ADBInstitute Discussion Paper No.6,2008(2)
    [19]International Monetary Fund (IMF).Recent Experiences in Managing CapitalInflows—Cross-Cutting Themes and Possible Guidelines[R].IMF Policy Paper,2011(2)
    [20]International Monetary Fund (IMF). Global Financial Stability Report:Meeting NewChallenges to Stability and Building a Safer System[R]. IMF Policy Paper,2010(4)
    [21]Ira S. Titiheruw, Raymond Atje.Managing Capital Flows:The Case of Indonesia[R].ADB Institute Discussion Paper No.9,2008(03)
    [22]International Monetary Fund (IMF).Macroprudential Policy:An OrganizingFramework[R]. IMF Policy Paper,2011(3)
    [23]Jean-Louis Combes, Tidiane Kinda,&Patrick Plane.Capital Flows, Exchange RateFlexibility, and the Real Exchange Rate[R]. IMFWorking Paper,2011
    [24]Jean-Marc Suret, Cameron Morrill, Janet Morrill.Availability and Accuracy ofAccounting and Financial Data in Emerging Markets:The Case ofMalaysia[R].CIRANO Working Paper,1997
    [25]Jonathan D. Ostry, Atish R. Ghosh, Karl Habermeier, Luc Laeven, Marcos Chamon,Mahvash S. Qureshi&Annamaria Kokenyne.Managing Capital Inflows:What Toolsto Use?[R]. IMF STAFF DISCUSSION NOTE,2011
    [26]Jonathan D. Ostry, Atish R. Ghosh, Karl Habermeier, Marcos Chamon, Mahvash S.Qureshi&Dennis B.S. Reinhardt.Capital Inflows:The Role of Controls[R].IMFSTAFF DISCUSSION NOTE,2010
    [27]José Antonio Cordero&Juan Antonio Montecino.Capital Controls and MonetaryPolicy in Developing Countries[R].cepr,2010
    [28]José Antonio Cordero&Juan Antonio Montecino. Capital Controls and MonetaryPolicy in Developing Countries[R].CEPR,2010
    [29]Erlend W. Nier, Jacek Osiński, Luis I. Jácome&Pamela Madrid. Towards EffectiveMacroprudential Policy Frameworks: An Assessment of Stylized InstitutionalModels[R]. IMF Working Paper,2011
    [30]José De Gregorio. Tackling the capital inflow challenge[z]. BIS Review,2010(72)
    [31]Josef T. Yap. Managing Capital Flows:The Case of the Philippines[R]. ADBInstitute Discussion Paper No.91,2008(2)
    [32]Joshua Aizenman.Trilemma and Financial Stability Configurations in Asia[R].ADBI Working Paper Series,2011
    [33]Jürgen von Hagen, Iulia Siedschlag. Managing Capital Flows:Experiences fromCentral and Eastern Europe[R]. ADB Institute Discussion Paper No.103,2008(4)
    [34]K. K. Foong.Managing Capital Flows:The Case of Malaysia[R]. ADB InstituteDiscussion Paper No.93,2008(3)
    [35]Kanit Sangsubhan. Managing Capital Flows:The Case of Thailand[R]. ADB InstituteDiscussion Paper No.95,2008(03)
    [36]Kawai,M. Toward a Regional Exchange Rate Regime in East Asia[R]. PacificEconomic Review,2008(13):83-103
    [37]Karl Habermeier, Annamaria Kokenyne&Chikako Baba.The Effectiveness ofCapital Controls and Prudential Policies in Managing Large inflows[R].IMF STAFFDISCUSSION NOTE,2002
    [38]M S Mohanty&Philip Turner. Banks and financial intermediation in emergingAsia:reforms and new risks [R].BIS Working Papers No313.
    [39]M S Mohanty&Philip Turner. Banks and financial intermediation in emergingAsia:reforms and new risks [R].BIS Working Papers,2010
    [40]Lane,P.R. and G.M.Milesi-Ferretti.The External Wealth of Nations Mark II: Revisedand Extended Estimates of Foreign Assets and Liabilities,1970–2004[R].IMFWorking Paper No.06/69,2006
    [41]Mahir Binici, Michael Hutchison&Martin Schindler. Controlling Capital? LegalRestrictions and the Asset Composition of International Financial Flows[R].IMFWorking Paper,2009
    [42]Mahmood Pradhan, Ravi Balakrishnan, Reza Baqir, Geoffrey Heenan, SylwiaNowak, Ceyda Oner&Sanjaya Panth.Policy Responses to Capital Flows inEmerging Markets[R].IMF STAFF DISCUSSION NOTE,2011
    [43]Mahmood Pradhan,Ravi Balakrishnan, Reza Baqir, Geoffrey Heenan, Sylwia Nowak,Ceyda Oner&Sanjaya Panth. Policy Responses to Capital Flows in EmergingMarkets[R]. IMF STAFF DISCUSSION NOTE SDN/11/10,2011(4)
    [44]Maria Socorro Gochoco-Bautista, Juthathip Jongwanich&Jong-Wha Lee.HowEffective are Capital Controls in Asia?[R]. ADB Working Paper,2010
    [45]MARTIN SCHINDLER.Measuring Financial Integration:A New Data Set[R].IMFStaff Papers,2009
    [46]Mary Kathryn Campion, Rebecca M. Neumann.Compositional effects of capitalcontrols:evidence from Latin America[J].North American Journal of Economics andFinance2004(5):161–178
    [47]Masahiro Kawai, Mario B. Lamberte.Managing Capital Flows:The Search for aFramework[M].A JOINT PUBLICATION OF THE ASIAN DEVELOPMENTBANK INSTITUTE AND EDWARD ELGAR PUBLISHING,2010
    [48]Masahiro Kawai, Shinji Takagi.A Survey of the Literature on Managing CapitalInflows[R]. ADB Institute Discussion Paper No.100,2008
    [49]Mike Kennedy, Angel Palerm, Charles Pigott, Flavia Terribile.Asset Prices andMonetary Policy[R]. OECD Economics Department Working Papers No.188,1998
    [50]Murtaza Syed&Jinsook Lee.Japan’s Quest for Growth:Exploring the Role ofCapital and Innovation[R]. IMFWorking Paper,2010
    [51]Norman Loayza, Romain Ranciere.FINANCIAL DEVELOPMENT, FINANCIALFRAGILITY, AND GROWTH[R]. Central Bank of Chile Working Papers,2002
    [52]Olivier Blanchard, Giovanni Dell’Ariccia&Paolo Mauro.RethinkingMacroeconomic Policy [R]. IMF STAFF POSITION NOTE,2010
    [53]osé De Gregorio, Sebastian Edwards, Rodrigo O. Valdés.CONTROLS ONCAPITAL INFLOWS:DO THEY WORK?[J]. Journal of Development Economics,2000(1):59-83
    [54]Philip Suttle, Catalina Krauss. Capital Flows to Emerging Market Economies[J]. TheInstitute of International FinanceRESEARCH NOTE,2010(1):1-22
    [55]Philip Turner.ARE BANKING SYSTEMS IN EAST ASIA STRONGER?[J]. AsianEconomic Policy Review.20072(1):75-95
    [56]Pritha Mitra.Capital Flows to EU New Member States:Does Sector DestinationMatter?[R]. IMFWorking Paper,2011
    [57]Punam Chuhan, Stijn Claessens.Equity and bond flows to Latin America andAsia:the role of global and country factors[J].Journal of Development Economics,1998(2):439-463
    [58]Rakesh Mohan&Muneesh Kapur.Liberalization and Regulation of CapitalFlows:Lessons for Emerging Market Economies[R]. ADBI Working PaperSerie.2010
    [59]Reinhart, Carmen&Magud, Nicolas.Capital controls:An evaluation[R]. NBERWorking Paper,2006
    [60]Reinhart, Carmen&Montiel, Pete.Do capital controls influence the volume andcomposition of capital flows?Evidence from the1990s[R].MPRA,1999
    [61]Reinhart,Carmen&Smith,R.Todd.Too much of a good thing:The macroeconomiceffects of taxing capital inflows[R].MPRA,1998
    [62]Reuven Glick&Michael Hutchison.Stopping “Hot Money” or Signaling Bad Policy?Capital Controls and the Onset of Currency Crises[EB/OL]. http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.202.3623&rep=rep1&type=pdf,2006.06.15
    [63]Reuven Glick, Michael Hutchison. The Illusive Quest:Do International CapitalControls Contribute to Currency Stability?”[R]. FEDERAL RESERVE BANK OFSAN FRANCISCO WORKING PAPER SERIES,2010
    [64]Robert N. McCauley.Managing Recent Hot Money Inflows in Asia[R].ADBInstitute Discussion Paper No.99,2008(3)
    [65]Sebastian Edwards a, Roberto Rigobon.Capital controls on inflows, exchange ratevolatility and external vulnerability [J]. Journal of International Economics,2009(2):256-267
    [66]Sebastian Edwards. Capital controls, exchange rates, and monetary policy in theworld economy[M].Cambridge Univ. Press,1995
    [67]Soyoung Kim, Doo Yong Yang.Managing Capital Flows:The Case of the Republicof Korea[R]. ADB Institute Discussion Paper No.88,2008
    [68]Stiglitz, J.Capital market liberalization, economic growth and instability[J].WorldDevelopment,2000(28):1075–1086.
    [69]Susan Schadler. Managing Large Capital Inflows:Taking Stock of InternationalExperiences[R]. ADB Institute Discussion Paper No.97,2008(3)
    [70]Sushil Bikhchandani&Sunil Sharma. Herd Behavior in Financial Markets[R]. IMFStaff Papers,2001
    [71]Wei, S.&Z.Zhang.Collateral damage:exchange controls and internationaltrade[R].IMFWorking Paper,2007(07/08).
    [72]Yunyong Thaicharoen&Nasha Ananchotiku. Thailand’s experiences with risingcapital flows:recent challenges and policy responses[R]. BIS Papers,2008
    [73][日]高安健一.东亚的银行改革[J].南洋资料译丛,2007(04):1-6
    [74][日]高安健一.东亚银行市场结构的变化[J].南洋资料译丛,2006(01):1-6
    [75]白晓燕,王培杰.资本管制有效性与中国汇率制度改革[J].数量经济技术经济研究,2008(09):65-76
    [76]曹荣湘.风险与金融安排[M].北京:社会科学文献出版社,2004
    [77]陈璐.新兴市场国家银行并购重组的经验[J].西安金融,2005(07):18-22
    [78]陈旭峰.亚洲债券市场发展研究[D].硕士学位论文,外交学院,2012
    [79]程正军.论资本管制和实现资本账户可兑换[J].人文杂志,1998(01):56-61
    [80]程祖伟.资本管制与蒙代尔—弗莱明模型[J].经济经纬,2003(06):12-15
    [81]丁志杰.价格型资本管制方法的比较分析[J].对外经济贸易大学学报,2005(03):29-33
    [82]鄂志寰.资本流动与金融稳定相关关系研究[J].金融研究,2000(7):80-87
    [83]冯晓明.资本管制能抵御金融危机吗?——评智力模式的资本管制[J].国际经济评论,2001(4):47-51
    [84]傅强,孙章杰.央行最优目标、资本管制与均衡汇率[J].经济科学,2012(6):59-67
    [85]贺慧.中国资本管制有效性研究[D].硕士学位论文,湖南大学,2008
    [86]黄玲.资本管制是防范金融危机的有效手段吗?[J].经济学(季刊),2011(02):457-476
    [87]黄玲.综合考量资本管制效果和代价[J].中国金融,2011(06):79-80
    [88]黄志龙.20世纪90年代以来巴西资本项目开放与资本管制有效性研究[J].拉丁美洲研究,2009(03):14-23
    [89]黄志龙.哥伦比亚资本项目开放与1993—1998年资本管制有效性研究[J].拉丁美洲研究,2009(04):21-26
    [90]江时学.论资本管制[J].太平洋学报,2002(01):34-45
    [91]江时学.托宾税和资本管制异曲同工[J].中国改革,2002(03):59
    [92]金荦,李子奈.中国资本管制有效性分析[J].世界经济,2005(8):22-31
    [93]金荦.中国资本管制强度研究[J].金融研究,2004(12):9-23
    [94]李凌波,汪阳寿.资本管制及其对中国金融市场发展的影响分析[J].国际技术经济研究,2004(2):42-47
    [95]刘莉亚,程天笑.资本管制对资本流动波动性的影响分析[J].国际金融研究,2013(2):37-47
    [96]刘仁伍.东南亚经济发展地图[M].北京:社会科学文献出版社,2007
    [97]刘卫东.中国资本管制有效性实证分析[J].中山大学学报论丛,2004(06):199-203
    [98]刘文.关于资本管制的反思——IMF对资本管制的态度似有松动[J].国际金融研究,2000(03):62-63
    [99]马超.马来西亚的资本管制效果分析[J].国际金融研究,2000(2):62-63
    [100]莫易娴.国际资本管制的启示[J].特区经济,2004(02):30-33
    [101]莫易娴.资本项目自由化进程中的资本管制[D].硕士学位论文,广西大学,2003
    [102]倪克勤,尹宇明.资本管制与宏观经济政策的配合[J].财经科学,2003(05):1-5
    [103]裴平.国际金融学[M].南京:南京大学出版社,1999
    [104]綦建红,鞠磊.关于资本管制有效性的理论与经验分析[J].东岳论丛,2008(1):168-172
    [105]钱荣堑.国际金融[M].成都:四川人民出版社,1994
    [106]桑飒.中国资本管制的有效性研究[D].博士学位论文,厦门大学,2007
    [107]佘晓叶.试论马来西亚的资本账户自由化与资本管制及其启示[D].博士学位论文,上海外国语大学,2009
    [108]盛斌,陈镜宇.亚太新兴经济体资本流动与资本管制政策的新动向——兼论对APEC金融合作的启示[J].亚太经济,2013(4):21-25
    [109]宋林峰.1991—1998年智利资本管制的经验[J].拉丁美洲研究,2001(12):51-54,60
    [110]宋林峰.20世纪90年代巴西资本管制的经验与启示[J].拉丁美洲研究,2002(6):15-19
    [111]孙立坚,孙立行.资本管理的有效性和政策的配套性[J].金融研究,2003(1):18-27
    [112]孙鲁军.从国际经验看资本管制的有效性[J].中国货币市场,2008(05):8-11
    [113]王晋斌,袁忆秋.资本管制能够起到防火墙的作用吗?——来自新兴经济体跨国面板数据的证据[J].安徽大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2013(3):136-142
    [114]王礼红.中国资本管制研究——管制程度和有效性分析[D].博士学位论文,苏州大学,2005
    [115]王信.中国资本管制有效性辨析[J].国际金融研究,2008(08):66-71
    [116]吴俊杰.资本管制研究:国际经验与中国实践[D].硕士学位论文,浙江工商大学,2007
    [117]向文华.资本账户自由化进程中的适应性资本管制[J].湖南师范大学社会科学学报,2004(05):94-98
    [118]项卫星,王达.国际资本流动格局的变化对新兴市场国家的冲击[J].国际金融研究,2011(7):51-58
    [119]肖凤娟.1978年以来我国的外汇管理体制改革与资本管制政策[J].中央财经大学学报,2011(05):35-39
    [120]邢毓静.掌控大规模流入资本——智利资本流入管制政策的反思[J].国际贸易,2000(10):49-53
    [121]徐明东,解学成.中国资本管制有效性动态研究:1982—2008[J].财经研究,2009(06):29-41
    [122]杨海珍,石昊.资本管制有效性实证研究述评[J].管理评论,2007(4):10-16
    [123]姚莉.论发展中国家实施资本管制的制度基础[J].南开经济研究,2001(03):43-45
    [124]叶春明,许新亚.资本管制与金融危机——智利模式与中国实践的分析[J].经济社会体制比较,2005(2):120-124
    [125]叶辅靖.新兴市场国家对资本流动的监管[J].经济研究参考,2002(57):28-37
    [126]余永定,张明.资本管制和资本项目自由化的国际新动向[J].国际经济评论,2012(5):68-74
    [127]张斌.如何评价资本管制有效性——兼评中国过去的资本管制效率[J].世界经济,2003(3):64-67
    [128]张斌.增进中国资本管制有效性的研究——从宏观经济稳定视角出发[J].管理世界,2002(12):6-10,41
    [129]张纯威.汇率浮动后的资本管制策略[J].郑州大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2006(01):60-63
    [130]张立文.管制与放松管制:从亚洲金融危机看中国政府关于国际资本流动的政策取向[J].世界经济,2000(12):45-51
    [131]张明,郑英.透视新一轮资本管制浪潮[J].中国金融,2011(09):78-80
    [132]张明.从泰国金融动荡看资本管制和汇率政策[J].中国外汇,2007(01):18-51
    [133]张婷.亚洲发展中国家的资本管制对经济发展与金融稳定的影响分析[D].博士学位论文,吉林大学,2009
    [134]张旭欣.汇率波动与国际资本流动结构[D].硕士学位论文,复旦大学,2012
    [135]张莹.资本管制经济效应的对比分析与当今国际资本管制的突出问题[J].辽宁经济,2009(09):51
    [136]周超.中国资本管制有效性分析与政策思考[D].博士学位论文,福州大学,2006
    [137]周平剑.论资本管制阻止资本外逃的效力[J].中国软科学,2003(2):58-61
    [138]朱蕾.我国资本项目可兑换进程中的资本管制研究[D].博士学位论文,郑州大学,2007

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700