基于精益六西格玛建造的工程项目优化研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
工程项目的优化问题不是一个新问题,但到目前为止仍是一个需要深入研究的问题。现有的优化方法仅靠其自身解决实际工程优化问题的能力很有限,需要对这些研究进行合理的整合来改善优化效果。近年来兴起的精益和六西格玛管理,尤其是将两者有机结合起来的精益六西格玛管理,为各行各业的管理问题提供了新的管理文化和思想。本文正是将精益六西格玛管理方法和思想运用到建筑行业的一次尝试,并将它与系统分析的思想结合起来运用到工程项目的优化问题中,希望从理论上丰富这一领域的研究,从实践上更好的解决工程项目的优化问题。本文的研究成果概括如下:
     (1)运用系统分析思想,建立基于精益六西格玛建造的工程项目优化系统。提出精益六西格玛建造的概念,建立基于精益六西格玛建造的工程项目优化系统,包括三个子系统:工序流程优化子系统、多目标优化子系统、绩效保证子系统。三个子系统有机结合,互相促进,能够最大限度的实现对工程项目的优化。
     (2)建立基于精益六西格玛建造理论的工程项目多目标优化模型。作用是在第一个子系统对每个工序、流程、服务优化的基础上,进行工程质量、工期、成本、服务等多目标的组合优化,最大限度、最合理的满足顾客对这些目标的要求,提高顾客对建设项目的满意度。
     (3)为了适应多目标优化模型的求解,在优化技术与方法方面,通过对微粒群(PSO)算法进行改进,引入多目标微粒群(MOPSO)算法,并对所建模型进行计算机编程运算。通过与遗传算法(GA)、演化规划(EP)以及其它基于梯度的优化算法比较,发现PSO是一种在搜索性能上更有优、实际操作上更加方便的算法,更加适合本文模型的求解。
     (4)为了解决工程项目优化方案在实际操作过程中效果不明显的问题,建立了基于六西格玛计分卡的绩效保证子系统。采用六西格玛记分卡的指标体系对工程项目的优化从执行层面进行绩效和保证。
     实例研究证明本文给出的优化系统可以产生很好的优化效果。
Project optimization problem is not a new problem, but so far is still a problem for further study. Although had all kinds of research to this question, the ability of the existing optimized method are very limited to solve the actual project optimized question only depends on its own. In order to enhance the optimized effect of the engineering project, we need to integrate the research rationally. In recent years the rise of lean and Six Sigma management, in particular the combination of the Lean and Six Sigma management, provides the management of our businesses a new management culture and ideas. Of course, it will also affect the construction industry.
     This article is the first attempt to apply Six Sigma management methods and thinking to the construction industry. The article apply the lean six sigma management and the thinking of system analysis to the project multi-objective optimization problems, with the hope that enrich the research in the field in theory, and solve project optimization problem better in practice. This article research results can be summarized as follows:
     (1)After analyzing the superiority of lean six sigma management and the necessity and feasibility of lean six sigma management used to construction industry, the article proposed the concept of lean six sigma construction. Using the thinking of system analysis, the article built up the system of the optimization of construction project based on Lean and Six Sigma construction. The system includes three subsystems, named: process optimization subsystem, multi-objective optimization subsystems, performance guarantee subsystem. Organic combination and mutual promotion of the three subsystems can maximize the optimization of the project.
     (2)After analyzing the goals of the lean six sigma construction, the article established multi-objective optimization model which have the goals of the quality, the time, the cost, the service. The model function is multi-objective combination optimizations of the project quality, the time, the cost, the service based on the first subsystem witch have optimized each working procedure, the flow, the service. The model can meet customer requirements of these goals to maximum, then to improve customer satisfaction.
     (3)In order to adapt the solution of the multi-objective optimization model, the article introduces the multi-objective Particle Swarm Optimization (MOPSO) in the optimization techniques and the method aspect and carries on the computer programming operation to the model. Comparing with genetic algorithms (GA), evolved Programming (EP), as well as other gradient-based optimization algorithm, we found that PSO is a kind of algorithms more gifted in the search ability, more convenient in the actual operation than others, so more suitable for solving the model in the article.
     (4)In order to solve the problem of not obvious effect in the actual operation process of optimization, the article established the achievements guarantee subsystem based on six sigma Scorecard. Using Six Sigma scorecard indicators system, we ensure the performance of projects optimization from the implementation levels. Measurement indicators of Six Sigma Scorecard metrics are more process-oriented rather than function level. The article chooses an appropriate set of indicators from the large number of indicators to ensure optimization activities.
     Case study proves that the optimization system in this paper can produce a good effect.
引文
[1] Koskela.L, Application of the New Production Philosophy to Construction, technical report #27 of Center for Integrated Facility Engineering,USA: Stanford University,1992.
    [2] Liker. J, The Toyota Way:14 Management Principles From The World's Greatest Manufacturer: McGraw-Hill, 2004:65~86
    [3] James Womack. Daniel Jones. Daniel Roos, The Machine That Changed the World, New York: MacMillan Publishing, 1990:32~57
    [4] Button. G, Sharrock, W. W, Operating the Production Calculus: Ordering a Production System in the Print Industry, British Journal of Sociology, 2008 53(2):275~290.
    [5] Chi. M. T. H, Commonsense Conceptions of Emergent Processes: Why Some Misconceptions Are Robust, The Journal of the Learning Sciences, 2005 14(2):161~199.
    [6] Rummler. G. A, Brache. A. P, Improving Performance: How to manage the white space on the organisation chart (second edition), San Francisco:Jossey-Bass, 1995:32~51
    [7] Santos. A, Application of Flow Principles in the Production Management of Construction Sites: [PhD Thesis], Salford-UK: University of Salford, 1999
    [8] Seymour.D, Shammas-Toma. M, Clark.L, Limitations of the use of tolerances for communicating design requirements to site, Engineering, Construction & Architectural Management, 2007, 4(1):3~23
    [9] Schmidt.K, Wagner.I, Ordering systems: coordinative practices and artefacts in architectural design and planning, Computer Supported Cooperative Work, 2004, 13(5-6):349~408.
    [10] Sacks. R, Harel. M, An Economic Game Theory Model of Subcontractor Resource Allocation Behaviour, Construction Management and Economics, 2006(24): 869~881
    [11] Jaikumar. R., Bohn. R. E, A dynamic approach to operations management: An alternative to static optimization, International Journal of Production Economics, 1992(27): 265~282.
    [12] Parkan. B, A Process-Ontological Account of Work, Axiomathes, 2004 (14): 219~235.
    [13] Koskela. L, Howell. G., The Underlying Theory of Project Management is Obsolete, Proceedings of the PMI Research Conference, 2007: 293~302
    [14] Ballard. G, Howell. G, Competing Construction Management Paradigms, Lean Construction Journal, 2004, 1(1):1~13
    [15] Arbulu. R., Tommelein. I, Value stream analysis of a re-engineered construction supply chain. Building Research and Information, 2003, 31(2): 161~171.
    [16] Tang. S, Aoieong. R., Ahmed. S, The use of Process Cost Model (PCM) for measuring quality costs of construction projects: model testing, Construction Management and Economics, 2004 (22): 263~275.
    [17] Ballard. G, Howell. G, Lean Project Management, Building Research & Information, 2008, 31 (2): 119~133.
    [18] Howell. G, Alexander. L, Ballard. G, Interaction between subcycles–One key to improved methods, Journal of Construction Engineering and Management, ASCE, 1993, 119 (4): 714~728
    [19] Howell. G, Ballard. G, Design of Construction Operations, Lean Construction Institute White Paper #4, Available at http://www.leanconstruction.org/,1999
    [20] Tommelein. I.D, Pull-driven Scheduling for Pipe-Spool Installation: Simulation of Lean Construction Technique, Journal of Construction Engineering and Management, ASCE, 1998, 124 (4): 279~288.
    [21] Tsao. Cynthia, Use of Work Structuring to Increase Performance of Project-Based Production Systems: [PhD Thesis], Berkeley: University of California, 2005
    [22] Andy Neely, Mike Kennerley, Chris Adams, Performance Management in Construction, Journal of Management in Engineering, 2006 (21): 42~50
    [23] Formoso. C. T, Lantelme. E.M.V, A performance measurement system for construction companies in Brazil, International Project Management Journal, 2000(6): 54~60.
    [24] Robert. F. C, Raja R. A, Dar Ahrens, Management’s Perception of Key Performance Indicators for Construction, Journal of Construction Engineering and Management, 2003(129): 142~151.
    [25] Ballard. G, The last planner system of production control: [PhD Thesis], Birmingham: University of Birmingham, 2000
    [26] Bryde.D.J, Brown. D, The influence of a project performance measurement system on the success of a contract for maintaining motorways and trunk roads, Project Management Journal, 2004, 35 (4): 57~65.
    [27] Ballard. G, Howell. G, Shielding Production: An Essential Step in Production Control, Journal of Construction Engineering in Management, ASCE, 1998, 124 (1): 18~24.
    [28] Baik. J, Kim. J, Implementing Knowledge Management (KM) for a competitive enhancement in Construction Company, Journal of Architectural Institute of Korea, 2003, 19(3): 23~30
    [29] Egbu. C. O, Botterill. K, Information technologies for knowledge management: their usage and effectiveness, Electronic Journal of Information technology in Construction, 2006, 7 (1): 125~137.
    [30] Bertelsen. S, Lean Construction: Where are we and how to proceed, Lean Construction Journal, 2004, 1 (1): 46~69.
    [31] Cheng. E, Li. H, Development of a Practical Model of Partnering for Construction Projects, Construction Engineering and Management, 2004, 130 (6): 790~798.
    [32] Lichtig. W. A, Sutter Health: Developing a Contracting Model to Support Lean Project Delivery, Lean Construction Journal, 2005,2(1):21~29
    [33] Ballard. G., Zabelle. T. R, Lean Design: Process, Tools, & Techniques, Lean Construction Institute White Paper #10, 2000
    [34] Chase. K.W, Parkinson. A.R, A Survey of Research in the Application of Tolerance Analysis to the Design of Mechanical Assemblies, Research in Engineering Design, 1991(3): 23~17.
    [35] Thornton. A, Tata.M, Use of graphic displays of process capability data to facilitate productibility analyses, U.K: Cambridge University Press, 2000: 181~192.
    [36] Freire. J, Alarcón. L, Achieving Lean Design Process: Improvement Methodology, Journal of Construction Engineering and Management, 2007,128 (3): 248~256.
    [37] Green. S, May. S, Lean Construction: Arenas of Enactment, Models of Diffusion and the Meaning of‘Leanness’, Building Research & Information, 2008, 34(6): 498~511.
    [38] Koskela. L, Moving-on– Beyond Lean Thinking, Lean Construction Journal, 2004, 1 (1): 24~37.
    [39] Low. S.P, Mok. S.H, The Application of JIT Philosophy to Construction: a Case Study in Site Layout, Construction Management and Economics, 1999(17): 657~668.
    [40] Matthews. O, Howell. G, Integrated Project Delivery an Example of Relational Contracting, Lean Construction Journal, 2005, 2 (1): 46~61.
    [41] Naim. M, Barlow. J, An Innovative Supply Chain Strategy for Customized Housing, Construction Management and Economics, 2003, 21 (6): 593~602.
    [42] Oliver. N., Delbridge. R, Lowe. J, Lean Production Practices: International Comparisons in the Auto Components Industry, British Journal of Management, 1996(7): 529~544.
    [43] Rischmoller. L., Alarcón. L, Koskela. L, Improving Value Generation in the Design Process of Industrial Projects Using CAVT, Journal of Management in Engineering, 2006, 22 (2): 52~60.
    [44] Stehn. L, Bergstr?m. M, Integrated Design and Production of Multi-Storey Timber Frame Houses, International Journal of Production Economics, 2002 (77): 259~269.
    [45] Tsao. C, Tommelein. I., Swanlund. E, Howell. G, Work Structuring to Achieve Integrated Product-Process Design, Construction Engineering and Management, 2004, 130 (6): 780~789.
    [46] Medute. I, Comparative Analysis of the Definitions of Logistics Centres, Transport, 2005, 20(3): 106~110.
    [47] Walsh. K.D., Hershauer. J.C, Tommelein. I.D., Walsh. T.A, Strategic Positioning of Inventory to Match Demand in a Capital Projects Supply Chain, Journal of Construction Engineering and Management, ASCE, 2004, 130 (6): 818~826.
    [48] Vrijhoef. R., Koskela. L, The four roles of supply chain management in construction, European Journal of Purchasing and Supply Management, 2000, 4 (6): 169~178.
    [49] Fredriksson. P, Mechanisms and Rationales for the Coordination of a Modular Assembly System– The case of Volvo cars, International Journal of Operations and production Management, 2006, 26 (4): 350~370.
    [50] Eric Johansen1, Lorenz Walter,Lean Construction: Prospects for the German construction industry,Lean Construction Journal,2007,3(1): 19~32
    [51] Alves. T.C.L., Tommelein. I.D., Ballard. G, Simulation as a Tool for Production System Design in Construction. Proc, Fourteenth Annual Conference of the International Group for Lean Construction (IGLC-14), 2006:341~353.
    [52] Calvano. C.N, John. P, Systems Engineering in an Age of Complexity, IEEE Engineering Management Review, 2004, 32(4): 29~38.
    [53] Seymour. D.E, Rooke. J, Construction Management Research and the Attempt to Build a Social Science, Journal of Construction Procurement, 1998, l4 (1): 59~73.
    [54] O. Salem, J. Solomon, A. Genaidy, M. Luegring, Site Implementation and Assessment of Lean Construction Techniques, Lean Construction Journal, 2005, 2 (2): 1~21.
    [55] Richard Bayfield, Paul Roberts, Contract or Co-Operation? Insights From Beyond Construction: Collaboration– The Honda Experience, Lean Construction Journal, 2005, 2(2): 22~50.
    [56] Chehayeb. N, Abourizk S. M, Simulation-based Scheduling with Continuous Activity Relationships, Journal of Construction Engineering and Management, 1998(124): 107~115.
    [57] Khalil. M, Assaf. S, Faraj. T, Darweesh. A, Measuring Effectiveness of Materials Management for Industrial Projects, Journal of Management in Engineering, 2004, 20(3): 82~87.
    [58] Brynjolsson. E.; Hitt. L, Beyond Computation: Information Technology, Organizational Transformation and Business Performance, Journal of Economics Perspectives, 2000, 14(4): 23~48.
    [59] Dai. Q, Kauffmann. R, Business Models for Internet-Based B2B Electronic Markets, International Journal on Electronic Commerce, 2002, 6(4): 41~72.
    [60] Issa. R, Flood. I, Caglasin. G, A survey of e-business implementation in the US construction industry, Electronic Journal of Information Technology in Construction, 2003(8): 15~28.
    [61] Rivard. H, Froese. T, Waugh. L, El-Diraby T, Mora. R, Torres H, Gill. S, Reilly. T, Case studies on the use of information technology in the Canadian construction industry, Electronic Journal of Information Technology in Construction, 2004(9): 267~279.
    [62] Thomas. R., Sanvido. V., Sanders. R, Impact of Material Management on Productivity– A Case Study, Journal of Construction and Management, 1989, 115(3): 370~384.
    [63] Abudayyech. O., Fredericks. T., But. S, Shaar. A., An Investigation of Management’s Commitment to Construction Safety, International Journal of Project Management, 2006(22): 167~174.
    [64] Fung. I., Tam. C., Tung. K, Man. A, Safety Cultural Divergences Among Management, Supervisory and Worker Groups in Hong Kong Construction Industry, International Journal of Project Management, 2005(23): 504~512.
    [65] Hinze. J, Gambatese. J, Factors That Influence Safety Performance of Specialty Contractors, Journal of Construction Engineering and Management, 2003, 129 (2): 159~164.
    [66] Huang X, Hinze J, The Owner′s Role in Construction Safety, Journal of Construction Engineering and Management, 2006, 132 (2): 164~173.
    [67] Sawacha. E., Naoum. S, Fong. D, Factors Affecting Safety Performance on Construction Sites, International Journal of Project Management, 1999, 17(5): 309~315.
    [68] Dunham. R, Self-Generated competitive innovation with the language-action approach, Centre for Quality of Management Journal, 1997, 6(2): 49~67.
    [69] Koskela. L, L. Vrijohf, Is the current theory of construction a hindrance to innovation?, Build Research Information., 2008, 29(3): 197~207.
    [70] Dainty. A. R. J., Cheng. M, Moore. D. R, Competency-based model for construction project managers’performance, ASCE, Journal of Construction Engineering and Management, 2005, 21(1): 2~9.
    [71] Edum-Fotwe. F. T, Mccaffer.R, Developing project management competency: perspectives from the construction industry, International Journal of Project Management, 2000(18): 111~124.
    [72] Odusami. K. T, Perceptions of construction professionals concerning important skills of effective project leader, Journal of Management in Engineering, 2002, 18(2): 61~67.
    [73] Price. A. D. F, Chahal. K, A strategic framework for change management, Construction Management and Economics, 2006(24): 237~251.
    [74] Raz, Tevi, Globerson, Shlomo, Effective Sizing and Content Definition of Work Packages, Project Management Journal, 1998(12): 17~23.
    [75] MacPherson. S.J., Kelly. J.R., Webb. R.S, How designs develop: Insights from case studies in building engineering services, Construction Management and Economics, 1993(11): 475~485.
    [76]何桢,施亮星,生静, 6 ?质量计划与连续质量改进,工业工程,2001,4(4):13~17.
    [77]何桢,魏明,周善忠,我国企业推广六西格玛应注意的关键问题,工程机械, 2004,35(12): 34~37.
    [78]曾凤章,焦明朋,六西格玛管理-提高企业核心竞争力的战略选择,四川兵工学报, 2003,24(1): 3~5.
    [79]杨世元,苏海涛,赵永涛,基于系统工程方法的6SIGMA管理理论及应用研究,现代管理科学,2004,(10): 20~22.
    [80]胡志萍,王斌会, 6Sigma的统计含义与过程性能,科技管理研究, 2004,24(5):78~80.
    [81] Wilfred H, Roudebush, Inclusion of lean construction in construction education, Proceedings IGLC-15, Michigan, 2007: 254~259.
    [82]张彦玲, 6西格玛与精益方法,中国质量, 2003, (6):33~34.
    [83]何桢,张志红,精益与6?的比较研究,工业工程, 2006,9(1): 1~4.
    [84]顾青峰,有效地结合六西格玛和精益,中国质量,2005,(9): 49~51.
    [85]张丽红,曾凤章,精益生产与六西格玛管理整合的探讨,中国质量,2005,(6):25~28.
    [86]何桢,车建国,精益六西格玛:新竞争优势的来源,天津大学学报(社会科学版), 2005,7(5): 321~325.
    [87]刘成,薛松,凌小言,精益六西格玛实战,上海:学林出版社,2007: 65~98
    [88]沙玛(Sharna A.),完美动力精益与西格玛的无缝整合企业以更少的资源满足市场、在新经济竞争中取胜的要决,北京:机械工业出版社,2005: 126~158
    [89]迈克尔.乔治,精益六西格玛服务,北京:中国财政经济出版社,2005: 24~94
    [90] Amir Azaron , Reza Tavakkoli-Moghaddam, Multi-objective Time-cost Trade-off in Dynamic PERT Networks Using an Interactive Approach, European Journal of Operational Research, 2007(180): 1186~1200.
    [91] Harmed R, Tareghian,Hassan Taheri, An Application of Randomized Minimum Cut to the Project Time/Cost Tradeoff Problem, Applied Mathematics and Computation, 2006(173): 1200~1207.
    [92] Harmed R, Tareghian,Hassan Taheri, On the Discrete Time, Cost and Quality Trade-off Problem, Applied Mathematics and Computation, 2006(181): 1305~1312.
    [93] Hsing-Pei Kao , BrainWang , James Dong and Kuo-cheng Ku, An Even-driven Approach with Makespan/Cost Tradeoff Analysis for Project Portfolio Scheduling, Computers in Industry, 2006(57): 379~397.
    [94]王首续,周学林,遗传算法优化施工网络计划的多种资源均衡,重庆交通学院学报,2001, 20(2):39~45.
    [95]骆刚,刘尔烈,王健,遗传算法在网络计划资源优化中的应用,天津大学学报,2004,37(2):179~183.
    [96] Schafer J D, Multiple Objective Optimization with Vector Evaluated Genetic Algorithms, Proceeding of the First International Conference on Genetic Algorithms,Mahwah,USA:Lawrence Erlbaum, 1985:93~100.
    [97] Carlos C, H.Borges, Helio J.C, Barbosa. A, Non-generational Genetic Algorithm for Multiobjective Optimization, Congress on Evolutionary Computation:San Diego,Califomia.2000: 172~173.
    [98]王黎怡,林江,建筑工程施工的多目标多层次模糊评价模型,黑龙江工程学院学报(自然科学版),2005,19(4): 31~34.
    [99] K.C. Tan, C.K. Goh, A.A. Mamun, E.Z. Ei, An Evolutionary Artificial Immune System For Multi-objective Optimization, European Journal of Operational Research, 2008(187): 371~392.
    [100] Kennedy J,Eberhart R, Particle Swarm Optimization, Proc IEEE Int Conf on Neural Networks, Perth,1995: 1942~1948.
    [101] Eberhart R,Shi Yuhui, Particle Swarm Optimization : Developments,applications and resources, Proc IEEE Int Conf on Evolutionary computation, Seoul,2001: 81~86.
    [102] Clerc M, Kennedy J, The Particle Swarm:Explosion Stability and Convergence in a Multi-dimensional Complex Space,IEEE Trans Evolution Computation, 2002(6): 58~73.
    [103] Bin Jiao,Zhigang Lian,Xiangsheng Gu, A Dynamic Inertia Weight Particle Swarm Optimization Algorithm,Chaos Solitons &Fractals,2006(1):12~16
    [104] Shi XH,Liang YC,Lee HP,Lu C,Wang LM, An Improved GA and a Novel PSO-GA-based Hybrid Algorithm,Inform process Lett, 2005(93): 255~261.
    [105]高鹰,谢胜利,免疫粒子群优化算法,计算机工程与应用,2004, 40(6):4~6.
    [106]詹姆斯·沃迈克,丹尼尔·琼斯,精益思想,北京:商务印书馆, 1999:98~114
    [107] Sharma U, Implementing lean principles with the Six Sigma advantage: how a battery company realized significant improvements, Journal of Organizational Excellence,2003, 22(3): 43~52.
    [108]何桢,黑带计划与连续质量改进,中国质量,1999 (9):29~32.
    [109] Harry M, Schroeder R, Six Sigma:the Breakthrough Management Strategy Revolutionizing the World’s Top Corporations, New York: Currency, 2000
    [110] BreyfogleⅢF W, Cupello J M, Meadows B, Managing Six Sigma, New York: John Wiley and Sons, 2001.
    [111] De Mast J, Quality improvement from the viewpoint of statistical method, Quality and Reliability Engineering International, 2003, 19(4):255~264.
    [112] Byrne G, Ensuring optimal success with Six Sigma implementations, Journal of Organizational Excellence, 2003, 22(2):43~50.
    [113] Goh T N, A strategic assessment of Six Sigma, Quality and Reliability Engineering International, 2002,18(5): 403~410.
    [114] Robert B, Pojasek, Lean, Six Sigma, and the systems approach: management initiatives for Process improvement, Environmental Quality Management, 2003,13(2): 85~92.
    [115]史蒂夫·纽恩多夫,六西格玛在项目管理中的应用,北京:机械工业出版社, 2006:124~132
    [116]约瑟夫·A·德菲欧,威廉·W·巴纳德,朱兰研究院论六西格玛,北京:中国人民大学出版社, 2005: 26~65
    [117]普利文.古塔著;方海萍,魏青江译,六西格玛计分卡,北京:机械工业出版社,2005: 53~116
    [118]邓可祥,邓辉,王雪红,建筑行业的资源浪费现象分析,行业发展论坛, 2006(4):17~19
    [119]黄定轩,王继安,建筑施工企业顾客满意度模型实证分析,工业工程与管理,2007(1):68~72
    [120]杨湘,张连营,工程项目工期——成本综合模糊优化,土木工程学报,2003,36(3):46~50.
    [121]周树发,刘丽,工程网络中的多目标优化问题,华东交通大学学报,2004,21(2):10~13.
    [122]刘尔烈,张艳海,建筑施工项目进度、成本和质量目标的综合优化,天津理工学院学报,2001,17(2):90~93.
    [123]周驰,高海兵,高亮,章万国,粒子群优化算法概述,计算机应用研究,2003 (12):7~11
    [124]杨维,李歧强,粒子群算法综述,中国工程科学, 2004,6(5):87~95
    [125] R.C.Eberhart, Y Shi, Comparing inertia weights and constriction factors inparticle swarm optimization, Proc IEEE Int Conf on Evolutionary computation, La Jolla, 2000: 84~88.
    [126] Shi Yuhui,Eberhart R, Fuzzy adaptive particle swarm optimization, Proc IEEE Int Conf on Evolutionary computation, Seoul, 2001: 101~106
    [127] Shi Yuhui,Eberhart R, Convergence study of particle swarm optimization, I.C. Trelea /information Processing Leters 85, 2003: 317~325
    [128] Eberhart R., Kennedy J, A new optimizer using particle swarm opmization theory, Proc.Of the 6th International Symposium on Micro Machine and Human Science, Nagoya, Japan, 1995:39~43
    [129] Lovbjerg M.,Rasmussen T.K, Hybird particle swarm optimizer with breeding and subpopulations, Proc.Of the 3rd Genetic and Evolutionary Computation Conference (GECCO), San Francisco,USA, 2001
    [130] Van den Bergh F,Engelbrecht A .p.,Training product unit networks using cooperative particle swarm optimizers, Proc.Of the 3rd Genetic and Evolutionary Computation Conference (GECCO), San Francisco ,USA, 2001
    [131] Van den Bergh F,Engelbrecht A .p.,Efects of swarm size on cooperative particle swarm optimizers, Proc.Of the 3rd Genetic and Evolutionary Computation Conference (GECCO), San Francisco ,USA, 2001
    [132]曾建朝,崔志华,一种保证全局收敛的粒子群优化算法,计算机研究与发展,2004,41 (8):1333~1339
    [133]秦杨勇,平衡计分卡与战略管理,北京:中国经济出版社,2007:56~68

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700