建筑业企业盈利系统动态模型及其应用研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
随着经济全球化进程的加快、信息技术的发展以及建筑市场竞争的日益激烈,建筑行业发生了很大的变化。在这种新形势下,中国建筑业企业的处境将更加艰难。为了摆脱效益持续不佳的局面,中国建筑业企业迫切需要对其经营绩效进行有效管理,以提升自身的核心竞争力和企业价值。然而,传统的管理理论难以满足建筑业企业的这一需求,因此,需要不断地创新现有的理论和方法。
     作为一种新的尝试和探索,本文将系统科学理论应用于建筑业企业的业绩管理,提出了一个具有过程性、系统性、动态性和复杂适应性的建筑业企业盈利系统,并利用系统动力学方法构建了盈利系统的模型,以分析建筑业企业的盈利能力。该模型以建筑业企业的利润链为核心,包括了企业组织内部各个基本单位以及企业外部的部分利益主体,这些单位和主体相互影响、相互作用,并且从多个方面与利润链发生联系,从而影响到企业利润的形成和盈利能力的强弱。
     以一家典型的中型建筑总承包企业作为模拟对象,本文重点研究了盈利系统中的投标子系统、现金管理子系统和物资供应子系统。通过对投标子系统的动力学模型进行模拟,其结果显示,目前中国的建筑业企业采取“薄利多销”策略能够对盈利能力产生正面的影响,投标系统还具有路径依赖的特征,系统初始状态下随机产生的扰动会被该系统不断放大直到对企业盈利能力行为产生重要的影响,此外,由于承包商在承包工程项目时通常需要出具投标担保和履约担保,因此,担保能力的制约会使建筑业企业的盈利能力下降。然而,投标系统中的投标代理人Agent能够通过学习机制来调整投标报价策略进而提升企业的盈利能力。通过现金管理子系统模型的模拟定量地分析了工程拖欠款问题给建筑承包商的盈利能力造成的影响。虽然承包商可以以继续拖欠工资和材料款的方式缓解自身资金紧张,但由此损失的材料现金折扣可能会使其得不偿失。通过一种改进的遗传算法对项目进度计划进行优化,能够提高项目盈利。在多项目现金管理系统中,采用“现金耕耘”策略能够节约资金使用成本,提高企业整体盈利水平。基于物资供应子系统的动力学模型所进行的仿真结果表明,建筑业企业的物资供应系统不稳定会导致供应成本的增加,从而削弱企业的盈利能力,因此,物资供应系统的稳定性管理对于提升建筑业企业的盈利能力非常重要。在该系统中,可以利用动态存储模型进行库存管理优化,从而给建筑业企业带来库存成本的节约和盈利的增加。
The construction industry has changed significantly due to accelerating ofglobalization, development of information technology and increased marketcompetition. China construction companies are harder to operate in the newsurroundings. In order to improve profit margin, they urgently demand to manage theirperformance more effectively to enhance competitiveness and increase company value.However, traditional management theory cannot meet the needs and constructioncompanies require innovative theory and method.
     As an attempt and exploration this study applies a new theory of system science toperformance management of construction firm, and proposes a process-based, systemic,dynamic, complex and adaptive profitability system. And this study develops a modelof the profitability system by System Dynamics to analyze the profitability ofconstruction firms. With profit chain as the core, this model includes basic units ofconstruction organization and several interest subjects. These units and subjects areinteractive and related to profit chain from many aspects, and thus have impact onrealization of profit and profitability of construction firm.
     With a typical medium contractor as simulating object, this study is mainlyconcentrated bidding, cash management and supply sub-systems in the profitabilitysystem. Based on the bidding system model, the simulation results indicate thatcurrently strategy of small profit but quick turnover for China construction firmactively influences the profitability. Path dependency exists in the bidding system, andstochastic disturbance in initial condition is amplified until it plays a significant impacton behavior of the profitability system. In addition, contractor generally needs toprovide tender bond and performance bond, therefore bond capacity limit lead toprofitability decrease. However, bidding agent can adjust bid pricing strategy bylearning to improve profitability. The outcomes of simulating cash management systemdemonstrate that the longer construction owner delay payment to contractor, theheavier contractor suffer financial loss. Though contractor can relieve the lack of cashby delay payment to labor and supplier, the loss brought by material discount may beheavy. Optimizing project schedule using an kind of improved genetic algorithm helpto increase project profit. Cash farming in multi-project cash management system isbenefit to save use cost of capital and raise the whole profitability of construction firm. As for supply system, simulation results show that instability of supply system cause toincrease of supply cost and weaken profitability, so stability management of supplysystem is very important for improving firm profitability. Optimization of inventorycontrol with dynamic storage model help construction firm to decrease inventory costand raise profit.
引文
陈超,饶育蕾.中国上市公司资本结构、企业特征与绩效[J].管理工程学报.2003(1):70-74
    陈明珍.(2003)第一价格密封招标博弈分析[J].江西财经大学学报,(6):37-38.
    崔所芝.(2011)当前建筑施工企业项目绩效管理存在的问题及对策[J].经营管理者,(14):373-374
    戴若林,陈可.建筑市场信用系统的演进动力与因果关系分析[J].科技进步与对策,2011,(7):18-20
    冯·贝塔朗菲.1987.一般系统论:基础、发展和应用.林康义,魏宏森等译[M].清华大学出版社.
    郝生跃,刘玉明.我国工程建设领域拖欠工程款问题对策研究[J].中国软科学.2005,(5):83-88
    金碚,李钢.中国企业盈利能力与竞争力[J].中国工业经济,2007,(11):5-14
    金吾伦,郭元林.复杂性管理与复杂性科学[J].复杂系统与复杂性科学,2004,(2):25-31.
    雷荣军,毕星.系统动力学在建设项目管理中的应用[J].哈尔滨理工大学学报,2004,(6):72-75
    李先光,李启明,刘颖, Khalfan Malik MA.施工总承包模式下建筑供应链成本管理优化决策模型研究[J].华中科技大学学报(城市科学版).2009,(3):79-84
    李晓荣,王宪良.因子分析在上市公司盈利能力分析中的应用[J].财经科学2002,(s1):218-220
    李雄诒,许卫华.基于改进BP神经网络的企业盈利能力测评模型及应用[J].工业技术经济,2006(06):
    刘炳胜,王雪青,曹琳剑.(2010)基于SEM与SD组合的中国建筑产业竞争力动态形成机理仿真[J].系统工程理论与实践,2010,(11):2063-2070.
    陆静,孟卫东,廖刚.上市公司会计盈利、现金流量与股票价格的实证研究[J].经济科学.2002,(5):36-42
    吕炜,任玉珑,季玉华.基于一级密封的工程量清单投标报价的博弈模型[J].管理工程学报,2007,(1):122-126.
    吕文学.我国大型建筑企业竞争一力及其提升途径研究[D].天津大学博士学位论文.2003年.
    莫生红,李明伟.上市公司盈利能力综合评价模型的构建[J].财会通讯(学术版):2007(1):41-43
    牟美宇.建筑企业供应链稳定性管理研究[M].重庆大学硕士学位论文.2007.
    钱闪光,徐兴卫,曹亮,姚激.工程投标报价的策略分析与方法[J],建筑经济,2007(12):26-28
    任宏,祝连波.工程投标中串标行为的信号博弈分析[J].土木工程学报,2007,(7):100-103.
    杨太华,郑庆华.信号博弈模型在工程建设项目招投标过程中的应用研究[J].工业技术经济,2008,(3):105-106.
    王家远,袁红平.基于系统动力学的建筑废料管理模型[J].系统工程理论与实践,2009,(7):173-180
    王丽娟.建筑企业的供应链成本管理研究[M].天津大学硕士学位论文.2008年
    王孟钧,彭彪,陈辉华.基于系统动力学的建筑市场信用系统[J].系统工程理论方法应用,2006,(5):409-411.
    王明亮.关于建设领域工程款拖欠问题的分析.建筑经济,2003,(5):6-9
    王其藩.系统动力学(修订版)[M].北京:清华大学出版社,1994.
    王艳萍.上市公司盈利质量与未来盈利能力分析[J],财会研究,2005,(06):51.
    王毅,吴贵生.基于复杂理论的企业动态核心能力研究[J],管理科学学报,2007,(1):18-28.
    许国志.系统科学[M],上海:上海教育科技出版社,2000年9月
    约翰·霍兰.隐秩序——适应性造就复杂性[M].周晓牧,韩晖,译.上海:上海科技教育出版社,2000.
    约翰·霍兰.涌现——从混沌到有序[M].陈禹,等译.上海:上海科学技术出版社,2001.
    钟永光,贾晓菁,李旭等编著,系统动力学[M],科学出版社,2009
    朱爱平,吴育华.试论复杂适应系统与企业管理研究的创新发展[J],.科学管理研究,2003,(4):63-66.
    朱美燕,梁方楚.多因素层次模糊综合评价法在上市公司盈利能力评价中的应用[J].技术经济与管理研究.2001(5):65-66.
    Abido M.A. and Elazouni A.M.(2011) Multiobjective evolutionary finance-based scheduling: Entireprojects’ portfolio [J]. Journal of Computing in Civil Engineering,25(1):85-97.
    Afshar A. and Fathi H.(2009) Fuzzy multi-objective optimization of finance-based scheduling forconstruction projects with uncertainties in cost [J], Engineering Optimization,41(11):1063-1080.
    Agapiou A., Flanagan R., Norman G. and Notman D.(1998) The changing role of buildersmerchants in the construction supply chain [J]. Construction Management and Economics,16:351-361.
    Akintoye A. and Skitmore M.(1991) The profitability of UK construction contractors [J].Construction Management and Economics,(9):311-325.
    Ammar A.I.(2001) Profitability of electrical contractors using financial and economical data: theeffect of company's size [M]. Ph.D Dissertation of Wisconsin-Madison University.
    Anderson P.(1999) Complexity theory and organization science [J]. OrganizationScience,10(3):216-232.
    Asenso H.O. and Fellows R.F.(1987) Profitability and the size of U.K. contractors [J]. BuildingTechnology and Management,(1):19-20.
    Barney B.J.(1991) Firm resources and sustained competitive advantage [J]. Journal of Management,(17):99-120.
    Betts M. and Ofori, G.(1994) Strategic planning for competitive advantage in construction: theinstitutions. Construction Management and Economics,12(6):203-17
    Betts M. and Ofori G.(1992) Strategic planning for competitive advantage [J]. ConstructionManagement and Economics,10(6):511-532.
    Boussabaine A.H. and Kaka A.P.(1998) A neural networks approach for cash-flow forecasting [J].Construction Management and Economics,16(4):471-479.
    Brucker P., Drexl A., Moehring R., Neumann K., and Pesch E.(1999). Resource-constrained projectscheduling: Notation, classification, models, and methods [J]. European Journal ofOperational Research,112(1):3-41.
    Carr R.I.(1982) General bidding model [J], Journal of Construction Division,108:639-650.
    Cheah C.Y.J., Kang J. and Chew D.A.S.(2007) Strategic analysis of large local construction firmsin China [J]. Construction Management and Economics,1(25):25-38.
    Chen H., O’Brien W.J. andHerbsman Z.J.(2005) Assessing the accuracy of cash flow models: thesignificance of payment conditions [J], Journal of Construction Engineering andManagement,131(6):669-676.
    Conner K.R.(1991) A historical comparison of resources based theory and five schools of thoughtwithin industrial organization economics: do we have a new theory of the firm [J] Journal ofManagement,17(1):121-54.
    Crowley L.G. and Hancher D.E.(1995) Evaluation of competitive bids [J]. ASCE Journal ofConstruction Engineering and Management,121(2):238-245.
    Cui Q.(2005) A dynamic model for profitability analysis of construction firms: towards complexity,learning, and uncertainty [M]. Ph.D. Dissertation. Purdue University, West Lafayette,Indiana
    Dooley K. J. and Van de Ven (1999) Explaining complex organizational dynamic [J]. OrganizationScience,10(3):358-372.
    Drew D.S. and Skitmore R.M.(1992) Competitiveness in bidding; a consultant’s perspective [J].Construction Management and Economics,10(3):227–247.
    Egan J.(1998). Rethinking Construction [R]. The Report of Construction Task Force, UK
    Elazouni A.(2009) Heuristic method for multi-project finance-based scheduling [J]. ConstructionManagement and Economics,27(2):199-211.
    Elazouni A. and Abido M.(2011) Multiobjective evolutionary finance-based scheduling: Individualprojects within a portfolio [J], Automation in Construction,20(7):755-766.
    Elazouni A.M. and Metwally F.G.(2005) Finance-based scheduling: Tool to maximize projectprofit using improved genetic algorithms [J], Journal of Construction Engineering andManagement,131(4):400-412.
    Fathi H. and Afshar A.(2010) GA-based multi-objective optimization of finance-based constructionproject scheduling [J], KSCE Journal of Civil Engineering,14(5):627-638.
    Flanagan R., Lu W., Shen L. and Jewell C.,(2007) Competitiveness in construction: a critical reviewof research [J]. Construction Management and Economics,25(9):989-1000
    Goldberg D.E.(1989) Genetic Algorithms in Search, Optimization, and Machine Learning [M].Addison Wesley: Reading, U.S.
    Haan J.D., Voordijk H. and Joostern J.(2002), strategies and core capabilities in the buildingindustry[J], Construction Management and Economics,20(2):109-118.
    Holland J.H.(1975) Adaption in Natural and Artificial Systems [M]. The University of MichiganPress, U.S.
    Ian P., Tsinopoulos C. and Allen P.(2006) New product development as a complex adaptive systemof decision[J]. The Journal of Product Innovation Management,23:437-456.
    IMD (2004), World Competitiveness Yearbook,2003, Lausanne, Switzerland: IMD.
    Isidore L.J. and Back W.E.(2002) Multiple Simulation Analysis for Probabilistic Cost and ScheduleIntegration [J]. Journal of Construction Engineering and Management,128(3):211-219.
    Ivanhoe E.(1999). The determinants of firm profitability in Australian manufacturing economicrecord [R]. Economic Society of Australia, Australia
    Jaafari A.(2000). Construction business competitiveness and global benchmarking [J], Journal ofManagement in Engineering,16(6):43-53.
    Kaka A. and Lewis J.(2003) Development of a company-level dynamic cash flow forecasting model[J]. Construction Management and Economics,21(7):693-705.
    Kale S. and Arditi D.(2002), Competitive positioning in United States construction industry [J],Journal of Construction Engineering and Management ASCE,128(3):238-247.
    Kangari R., Farid F. and Elgharib H. M.(1992) Financial performance analysis for constructionindustry [J]. Journal of Construction Engineering and Management,118(2):349-361.
    Kawal D.E.(1970) A system model of a construction firm [M]. Ph.D. Dissertation. Iowa StateUniversity, Ames, Iowa
    Kenley R.(1999) Cash farming in building and construction: a stochastic analysis [J], ConstructionManagement and Economics,17(4):393-401.
    Kenley R.(2003) Financing construction: cash flows and cash farming [M], Spon Press, New York.
    King M. and Mercer A.(1990) Optimum markup when bidding with uncertain costs [J]. EuropeanJournal of Operational Research.47(3):348-363.
    Korkmaz S. and Messner J.I.(2008) Competitive positioning and continuity of construction firms ininternational markets [J]. Journal of Management in Engineering,24(4):207-216.
    Kululanga G.K., McCaffer R.(2001) Measuring knowledge management for constructionorganizations engineering [J], Construction and Architectural Management,8(3):346-354.
    Lai K.K., Liu S.L. and Wang S.Y.(2002) Bid markup selection models by use of multiple criteria.IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management.49(2):155-160.
    Leu S.S., Yang C.H., and Huang J.C.(2000) Resource leveling in construction by geneticalgorithm-based optimization and its decision support system application”, Automation inconstruction,10(1):27-41.
    Liu M., and Ling Y.,(2005) Modeling a contractor’s markup estimation [J] Journal of CivilEngineering Management,131:391-399.
    Liu S.S. and Wang C.J.(2008) Resource-constrained construction project scheduling model forprofit maximization considering cash flow [J], Automation in Construction,17(8):966-974.
    Liu Shixin (2006) Project Schedulling: Theory and Methods [M], China Machine Press, Beijing,China.
    Lyneis J.M. Cooper K.G. and Els S.A.(2001). Strategic management of complex projects: a casestudy using system dynamics [J]. System Dynamics Review,17(3):237-260
    Mochtar K., and Arditi D.(2001) Pricing strategy in the U.S. construction industry [J], ConstructionManagement and Economics,19:405-15.
    Mohamed S. and Chinda T.(2011) System dynamics modeling of construction safety culture [J],Engineering, Construction and Architectural Management,18(3):266-281
    Nasirzadeh F., Afshar A., Khanzadi M. and Howick S.(2008) Integrating system dynamics andfuzzy logic modeling for construction risk management [J]. Construction Management andEconomics,26(11):1197-1212.
    Navon R.(1996) Company-level cash flow management [J], Journal of Construction Engineeringand Management,122(1):22-29.
    O’Brien W., Fischer M.and Jucher J.(1995) An economic view of project coordination [J].Construction Management and Economics,13(5):393-400.
    O'Brien W.(1998). Capacity costing approaches for construction supply-chain management [M],Ph.D. Dissertation, Stanford University, CA
    Ogunlana S.O., Li, H., and Sukhera F.(2003) System dynamics approach to exploring performanceenhancement in a construction organization [J]. Journal of Construction Engineering andManagement,129(5):528-536
    Park M. and Pena-Mora F.(2003) Dynamic change management for construction: introducing thechange cycle into model-based project management. System Dynamics Review,19(3):213-242
    Porter M.E.(1980) Competitive Strategy: Techniques for analyzing industries and competitors [M].Free Press, New York/Collier Macmillan, London.
    Porter M.E.(1985), Competitive Advantage: creating and sustaining superior performance [M], FreePress, New York/Collier Macmillan, London.
    Prahalad C.K. and Hamel G.(1990) The core competence of the corporation [J]. Harvard BusinessReview,68(3):79-91.
    Proverbs D.G. and Faniran, O.O.(2001). International construction performance comparisons: astudy of 'European' and Australian contractors [J]. Engineering Construction&Architectural Management,8(4):284-291
    Ross S.A., Westerfield R.W. and Jaffe J.(2002). Corporate Finance [M]. McGraw-Hill Companies,New York.
    Ruuhela, R., Salmi, T., Luoma, M., and Laakkonen, A.(1982), Direct estimation of the internal rateof return from published financial statement [J], Finnish Journal of Business Economics4:329-345.
    Salamon, G. L.(1985) Accounting rates of return [J]. American Economic Review.75(3):495-504.
    Salmi T. and Virtanen I.(1997) Measuring the long-run profitability of the firm: a simulationevaluation of the financial statement based irr estimation methods [R]. Acta Wasaensia, No.54,(http://www.uwasa.fi/-tslsmuclsmuc.html, last visit on Jan30,2009)
    Sanders, S.R and Cooper, T. E.(1991), Analyzing construction company profitability [J], CostEngineering,1991:7-14
    Seydel J. and Olson D.(1990) Bids considering multiple criteria [J], Journal of ConstructionEngineering and Management,116(4):609-623
    Shash A.A.(1993) Factors considered in tending decisions by top UK contractors, ConstructionManagement and Economics,(11):111-118
    Shen L.Y, Li Q.M., Drew, D., and Shen Q.P.(2004), Awarding construction contracts onmulticriteria basis in China [J]. Journal of Construction Engineering and Management.130(3):385-393.
    Shuman C.A (1992) Managing for Profit [J]. Civil Engineering Noverber1992,72-73
    Silberman E M.(1993). Bid pricing Strategy-optimal profit margin [J]. Cost Engineering. AACE,35(5)
    Skitmore M., and Pemberton J.(1994) A multivariate approach to construction contract biddingmarkup strategies [J]. Journal of Operational Research Society,45:1263-1272.
    Smith-Daniels D.E., Padman R., and Smith-Daniels V.L.(1996) Heuristic scheduling of capitalconstrained projects [J]. Journal of Operations Management,14(3):241-254.
    Sterman John D.(2002) Business dynamics: system thinking and modeling for a complex world [M].Boston: McGraw Hill.
    Tung A. and C. Hendrickson (1986) Profit measures for construction projects, Journal ofConstruction Engineering and Management,112(2):273-286.
    Tvorik S.J. and McGivern M.H.(1997) Determinants of organizational performance [J].Management Decision,35(6):417-435
    Venegas P.C. and Alarcon L.F.(1997) Selecting long-term strategies for construction firms [J].Journal of Construction Engineering and Management,123(4):388-398.
    Warszawski A.(1996) Strategic planning in construction companies [J]. Journal of ConstructionEngineering and Management,122(2):133-140.
    Wernerfelt B.(1984) Resource-based view of the Firm [J]. Strategic Management Journal,5(2):171-180.
    Wu J., Kumaraswamy M.M., and Soo G.K.L.(2011) Dubious benefits from future exchange: anexplanation of payment arrears from ‘continuing clients’ in mainland China [J].Construction Management and Economics,29(1):15-23.
    Yee C. Y. and Cheah C. Y.J.(2006) Fundamental analysis of profitability of large engineering andconstruction firms [J]. Journal of Management in Engineering,22(4):203-210
    Zheng D.X.M., Ng S.T., and Kumaraswamy M.M.(2005) Applying pareto ranking and nicheformation to genetic algorithm-based multiobjective time-cost optimization”, Journal ofConstruction Engineering and Management,131(1):81-91.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700