二元经济结构下外商直接投资与农村剩余劳动力转移研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
对于不同时期的宏观经济学家来说,探索如何实现充分就业或降低失业率成为一个经久不衰的话题。考虑到二元经济结构的现实国情,农村剩余劳动力在城乡间或跨地区的转移就业构成现阶段中国就业增长的主要内容,如何加快推进农村剩余劳动力转移就业和保持就业局势稳定成为政府宏观调控的重要目标之一。改革开放30多年来,凭借劳动力成本优势和巨大的市场潜力,中国通过吸引外资迅速成为世界制造业的加工生产基地,外资的持续流入极大缓解了农村剩余劳动力转移就业的压力。但在国内产业结构升级浪潮的倒逼机制作用下,外资资本有机构成的变化使得其对农村剩余劳动力转移的影响不再是单一的积极效应,而是呈现出较为复杂的动态变化特征。与此同时,外资流入和农村剩余劳动力转移在地区间的不平衡性较为突出,这在很大程度上已影响到区域经济的健康协调发展和社会的公平安定,相对平衡的外资区位分布、稳定的就业水平和区域劳动力市场协调发展的实现已经迫在眉睫。本文利用中国1996~2011年的省际面板数据和2003-2010年282个地级以上城市的面板数据,就外商直接投资对农村剩余劳动力转移的影响效应从理论和实证角度进行深入研究。
     针对已有文献缺乏相关理论机制分析且并未将研究细化到农村剩余劳动力层面的问题,本文借鉴大推动理论构建了一个简单的理论模型,来详细阐释外商直接投资对中国农村剩余劳动力转移的理论传导机制。理论研究结果发现,外商直接投资对农村剩余劳动力转移的影响主要通过提供就业机会和支付更高的工资溢价两种渠道产生。就提供就业机会而言,二者在生产要素层面上表现为资本和劳动力要素互相匹配的过程,而在空间流动层面上表现为劳动力追逐资本流动和就业机会的过程。就支付更高的工资溢价而言,外资企业不仅可以支付农村剩余劳动力在城乡间的工资溢价,而且其比大多数内资企业具备更强的技术手段和更高的工资水平。同时,由于中国具有明显的大国转型经济体特征,巨大的消费市场可以吸引外资的持续大量流入和确保外资企业具有足够的溢价支付能力,这也具备了大推动模型得以实现的前提条件。虽然在外商直接投资流入的不同阶段,其对农村剩余劳动力转移的影响效应具有一定的差异,但其对农村剩余劳动力向城市非农产业转移就业的重要作用已经毋庸置疑。
     在理论研究的基础上,本文对外商直接投资影响农村剩余劳动力转移过程中的非线性门槛特征进行了实证研究。以实际外商直接投资存量为门槛变量的估计结果表明,外商直接投资对农村剩余劳动力转移的影响显著存在于FDI的双门槛效应。在外商直接投资流入的不同阶段,其对农村剩余劳动力转移的影响存在显著差异。随着门槛值的不断增加,外商直接投资对农村剩余劳动力转移的正向影响效应呈现逐渐递减的趋势。以城乡实际收入差距为门槛变量的估计结果表明,外商直接投资对农村剩余劳动力转移的影响显著存在于城乡收入差距的双门槛效应,其对农村剩余劳动力转移的正向影响效应随着城乡收入差距的变大而逐渐降低。不同分组变量下各省份空间分布的统计分析结果表明,外商直接投资与农村剩余劳动力转移在地域空间分布上基本保持一致,外商直接投资量和农村剩余劳动力转移量最小的5个省份均来自于西部地区,而最大的11个省份中有7个省份来自发达的东部沿海地区。而且,外商直接投资对农村剩余劳动力转移的影响存在明显的分阶段非线性关系和“门槛效应”特征。
     由于省域之间的空间联系对外资区位分布和农村剩余劳动力转移将产生重要影响,所以本文对外商直接投资对农村剩余劳动力转移空间集聚的影响效应进行了实证检验。实证结果分析发现,各省份农村剩余劳动力转移存在明显的空间依赖特征,周边省份对本省份存在正向的空间溢出效应,农村剩余劳动力转移的空间集聚具有明显的“马太效应”特征。东部和中西部地区农村剩余劳动力转移均存在明显的空间集聚和空间溢出效应,但中西部地区农村剩余劳动力转移的空间集聚效应要强于东部地区。同时,为了进一步详细刻画相邻省份重要解释变量的变动对本省份农村剩余劳动力转移的影响效应,本文建立空间计量模型实证分析了外商直接投资对农村剩余劳动力转移集聚的影响及其“第三方效应”。探索性空间数据分析结果发现,外商直接投资与农村剩余劳动力转移的空间形态呈现从沿海到内陆依次递减的阶梯状分布,在地理空间上则形成以东部沿海地区为集聚中心的“核心—外围”格局,空间近邻效应十分明显。空间计量检验结果表明,由于外资产业集聚和本地市场效应形成的累积循环机制,农村剩余劳动力转移高-高集聚和低-低集聚区域分布上具有高凝固性和高集聚性特征。
     同时,考虑到转型经济体中政府的地位凸显以及财政体制改革在现阶段农村剩余劳动力向城市迁移中的重要作用,本文在研究外商直接投资对农村剩余劳动力转移的影响效应时加入了财政分权变量。实证研究结果发现,外商直接投资对农村剩余劳动力转移具有持续显著的正向影响,财政分权对农村剩余劳动力的影响效应具有明显的“倒U型”曲线特征。中西部地区外商直接投资对农村剩余劳动力转移的促进作用要明显大于东部地区,但其财政收入和支出分权对农村剩余劳动力向城市转移的促进作用要明显小于东部地区。进一步的,本文通过设定特定临界值构建“多值”离散型的“适度财政分权指数”,并对财政分权不足、适度分权以及分权过度比例进行了统计。分权不足的比例仍占绝大多数表明省级以下的分税制改革很不彻底,其已成为困扰地市政府财政自给能力提高的主要障碍,财权和事权的严重不匹配造成了地市级政府缺乏为农村剩余劳动力在城市定居提供所需公共服务的能力,这将对农村剩余劳动力向城市的转移形成负向影响。最后,本文基于上述主要研究结论,提出了相应的政策建议。
For the different periods of macroeconomists, exploring how to achieve full employment or reduce unemployment rate has become a timeless topic. At the present stage, taking into account the actual situation in the dual-economy structure, the transfer of redundant rural labor force employment in the city-rural or across-region areas constitute the main content of the employment growth in China, how to accelerate the transfer of redundant rural labor employment and maintaining stable employment situation are becoming one of the important goals in government regulation. Over the past30years of reform and opening up, depending on the advantage of cheap labor force and the huge development potential of Chinese economic market, China has rapidly become the world's production base in manufacturing industry through attracting foreign investment, and the continued inflow of foreign capital greatly ease the pressure on the transfer of redundant rural labor force. However, the domestic industrial structure upgrading wave under the "Forced" mechanism effect, together with the changes of organic composition of foreign capital, making the impact on the transfer of redundant rural labor force is no longer a single positive effect, but showing a more complex dynamic characteristics. At the same time, the regions'imbalance inflow of foreign capital and the transfer of redundant rural labor force are more prominent, which has largely affected not only the healthy and coordinated development of regional economic, but also the fair and stabile society. It is imminent to achieve relatively balanced geographical distribution of foreign investment, stabile employment levels and the coordinated development of regional labor markets. This paper uses the1996to2011China's provincial panel data, and the2003to2010panel data with more than282prefecture-level cities, deeply research the effect of FDI on the transfer of redundant rural labor from the theoretical and empirical perspective.
     For existing literature lacking of theoretical mechanism analysis and studying down to the level of redundant rural labor force problem, this paper construct a simple theoretical model drawing lessons from the big push theory, to elaborate the theoretical transmission mechanism about the impact of FDI on the transfer of redundant rural labor force in China. Theoretical study found that, the impact of FDI on the transfer of redundant rural labor force mainly through two channels of providing employment opportunities and paying higher wage premium. In terms of the provision of employment opportunities, the two channels behaving as the process of capital and labor elements matching each other from the level of production factors. On the mobile space dimension, the two channels behaving as the movement of labor force chasing capital and achievement employment opportunities. From the level of paying higher wage premium, foreign companies can not only pay the wage premium of redundant rural labor force, but also have stronger technical level and higher wages than most domestic enterprises. Meanwhile, China has obvious power characteristics of transition economies, and huge consumer market can attract large inflows of foreign capital continuously, which can make sure the foreign-funded enterprises have the ability to pay wage premium and provide a prerequisite to realize the big push model. Although at different stages of the inflow of foreign direct investment, it has some different effect on the transfer of redundant rural labor force, but it is no doubt that the flow of foreign direct investment plays an important role on transference employment of redundant rural labor force from rural to urban non-agricultural.
     On the basis of theoretical research, the paper makes empirical research about FDI on the impact of redundant rural labor force transference considering nonlinear threshold characteristics. Using actual foreign direct investment stock as the threshold variable, the estimation results show that, the impact of FDI on the transfer of redundant rural labor force is significantly present in the double threshold effect of FDI. At different stages of the inflow of foreign direct investment, there are significant differences in the impact on the transference of redundant rural labor force. As the increasing of thresholds, the positive impact of FDI on the effect of the redundant rural labor force transference shows a gradual decreasing trend. Using the real income gap between urban and rural areas as the threshold variable, the estimation results indicate that, the impact of FDI on the transfer of redundant rural labor force exists in a significant income gap between urban and rural dual threshold effect. As the expansion of income gap between urban and rural areas, the positive effect on the redundant rural labor force transference gradually becomes decreased. The statistical analysis results of the provinces'spatial distribution of the different grouping variable shows that, the foreign direct investment and the transfer of redundant rural labor force remain the same geographical spatial distribution, the smallest five provinces of foreign direct investment and redundant rural labor force from the western region, and the biggest seven provinces in11provinces from developed eastern coastal areas. Moreover, the impact of FDI on the transfer of redundant rural labor force exits in obvious nonlinear relationship and the "threshold effect" feature.
     Because of the connection between different provinces having an important impact on the foreign distribution and the transfer of redundant rural labor force, this paper makes the space gathering empirical test about the impact of FDI on the transference of redundant rural labor force. Empirical results found that, the transfer of redundant rural labor force in different provinces exits in obvious spatial dependence characteristics, there is a positive spatial spillover effect between surrounding provinces, while spatial agglomeration in the transfer of redundant rural labor force has obvious "Matthew Effect" feature. The transfer of redundant rural labor force in eastern and Midwest regions present obvious spatial concentration and spatial spillover effects, but the spatial concentration effect of redundant rural labor force transference in Midwest is stronger than the eastern region. Meanwhile, in order to particularly characterize the changes of important explanatory variables in the neighboring province that affecting the province's redundant rural labor force transfer, this paper establishes spatial econometric model to make empirical analysis on the spatial agglomeration effect and "Third-Province" effect of FDI on the transference of redundant rural labor force. Exploratory spatial data analysis results find that, the spatial form of foreign direct investment and the transfer of redundant rural labor force step in descending order distribution from the east coast to the inland areas, which forms a gathering center for the eastern coastal areas of the "core-periphery" pattern, space neighbor effect is very obvious. Spatial econometric test results show that, as cumulative cycle mechanism on industrial agglomeration of FDI and local market effects, the transference of redundant rural labor force has high concentration and coagulation features in high-high and low-low concentration region.
     At the same time, considering the position of the government in the transition economies is highlighting, and fiscal system reform plays an important role of the transference of redundant rural labor force at this stage, this paper join in the fiscal decentralization variables in researching the impact of FDI on the transference of redundant rural labor force. Empirical study find that, foreign direct investment has continued significant positive impact on the transference of redundant rural labor force, fiscal decentralization has obvious "inverted U-shaped" curve characteristics on the effect of redundant rural labor force. The impact of foreign direct investment on the transfer of redundant rural labor force in central and western regions of is significantly larger than the eastern region, but the promoting role of financial income and expenditure decentralization on the transference of redundant rural labor force is significantly less than the eastern region. Further, this paper constructs a "multi-valued" discrete "appropriate fiscal decentralization index" by setting a specific threshold, and statistics the following three fiscal decentralization aspects, such as lack of decentralization, appropriate decentralization and over decentralization. Lacking of decentralization still occupying vast majority indicate that, the reform tax system is still incomplete, which has become the main obstacle for government to increase financial self-sufficiency ability. Moreover, Chinese municipal governments lack the capacity to provide the necessary public services for redundant rural labor force because the mismatch between intergovernmental financial authorities, which will form the negative impact for the transference of redundant rural labor force. Finally, this paper put forward the corresponding policy recommendations based on the main conclusions on the above.
引文
[1]许和连,赵德昭.外商投资梯度转移促劳动力市场一体化[N].中国社会科学报,2012-02-06
    [2]Lewis, W. A. Economic Development with Unlimited Supply of Labor [J].The Manchester School of Economic and Social Studies,1954,22(5):139-191
    [3]程名望,史清华.经济增长、产业结构与农村劳动力转移—基于中国1978-2004年数据的实证分析[J].经济学家,2007,(5):49-54
    [4]蔡昉.中国经济增长如何转向全要素生产率驱动型[J].中国社会科学,2013,(1):56-71
    [5]高培勇.“十二五”时期财税改革面临空前挑战[J].财贸经济,2010,(11):5-6
    [6]朱金生.FDI与区域就业转移:一个新的分析框架[J].国际贸易问题,2005,(6):114-119
    [7]Dunning, John. Industrial Development, Globalization and Multinational Enterprises:New Realities for Developing Countries [J]. Oxford Development Studies,2000,28(2):142-167
    [8]小岛清.对外贸易论[M].周宝廉译.天津:南开大学出版社,1987,67-69
    [9]Borenszteina E., J. De Gregorio, J-W. Lee. How Does Foreign Direct Investment Affect Economic Growth? [J]. Journal of International Economics,1998,45(1): 115-135
    [10]Fu, X. L., Balasubramanyam V. N. Exports, Foreign Direct Investment and Employment:the Case of China [C]. FED Working Papers Series, NO. FE20050035,2005
    [11]Karoly Fazekas. Effects of FDI Inflows on Regional Labour Market Differences In Hungary [J]. Economie Internationale,2005, (2):83-105
    [12]任志成.外国直接投资与中国二元就业结构转型[J].对外经济贸易大学报,2006,(3):67-71
    [13]赵德昭,许和连.FDI、农业技术进步与农村剩余劳动力转移—基于“合力模型”的理论与实证研究[J].科学学研究,2012,30(9):1342-1353
    [14]许和连,赵德昭.外商直接投资、劳动力异质性与农村剩余劳动力转移——基于新古典一般均衡拓展模型的分析[J].财贸经济,2013,(1):82-92
    [15]Misun J., Tomsk V. Does Foreign Direct Investment Crowd in or Crowd out :38-56
    [16]Rhys Jenkins. Globalization, FDI and Employment in Viet Nam[J].Transnational Corporations,2006,15(1):115-142
    [17]金碧,陈仲常.中国外商直接投资就业效应传导渠道研究[J].人口与经济,2007,(1):36-40
    [18]Lewis W. Arthur. Unemployment in Developing Countries [J]. The World Today, 1967,23(1):13-22
    [19]Zhao Y.H. Earnings Differentials between State and Non-State Enterprises in Urban China [J]. Pacific Economic Review,2002,7(1):181-197
    [20]许和连,亓朋,李海峥.外商直接投资、劳动力市场与工资溢出效应[J].管理世界,2009,(9):53-68
    [21]Lipsey, R., and Sjoholm, F. Foreign Direct Investment, Education and Wages in Indonesian Manufacturing [J]. Journal of Development Economics,2004,73(1): 415-422
    [22]Dong X. Y., Bowles P. Segmentation and Discrimination in China's Emerging Industrial Labor Market[J]. China Economic Review,2002,13(2):170-196
    [23]陈弋,Sylvie Demurger, Martin Fournier.中国企业的工资差异和所有制结构[J].世界经济文汇,2005,(6):11-31
    [24]UNCTAD. World Investment Report 1994:Transnational Corporations, Employment and the Workplace [R]. New York and Geneva, United Nations publication,1994:112
    [25]蔡昉,王德文.外商直接投资与就业—一个人力资本分析框架[J].财经论丛,2004,(1):1-14
    [26]王燕飞,曾国平.FDI、就业结构及产业结构变迁[J].世界经济研究,2006,(7):51-57
    [27]Xiao Wei Zang. Labor Market Segmentation and Income Inequality In Urban China [J]. The Sociological Quarterly,2002,43(1):27-44
    [28]杨云彦.中国人口迁移的规模测算与强度分析[J].中国社会科学,2003,(6):97-107
    [29]赵德昭,许和连.外商直接投资、适度财政分权与农村剩余劳动力转移—基于经济因素和体制变革的双重合力视角[J].金融研究,2013,(5):194-206
    [30]刘建民,贺彩银.外资对农业剩余劳动力部门间转移的实证研究[J].求索,2007,(12):35-36
    [31]郭克莎.外商直接投资对我国产业结构的影响研究[J].管理世界,2000,(2):34-45
    [32]王剑.外国直接投资对中国就业效应的测算[J].统计研究,2005,(3):29-32
    [33]刘维林,胡晓鹏.论跨国公司的就业效应[J].世界经济研究,2005,(12):64-68
    [34]凌海生.外商直接投资对我国就业效应的分析[J].华东经济管理,2005,19(10):34-37
    [35]张二震,任志成.FDI与中国就业结构的演进[J].经济理沦与经济管理,2005,(5):5-10
    [36]颜伟,刘冬荣.外商直接投资加剧我国经济结构失衡的实证分析[J].管理世界,2010,(5):167-168
    [37]田素华.外资对上海就业效应的实证分析[J].财经研究,2004,(3):122-132
    [38]黄华民.外商直接投资与我国实质经济关系的实证分析[J].南开经济研究,2005,(5):46-51
    [39]刘辉群,卢进勇.国际直接投资的就业结构效应研究—基于东道国视角[J].国际贸易问题,2009,(9):74-79
    [40]Koi N. W., Tuck C. T. Foreign Direct Investment and Employment in Manufacturing And Services Sectors [J]. Journal of Economic Studies,2011, 38(3):313-330
    [41]李海舰.利用外商直接投资成效分析[J].中国外资,2000,(3):27-30
    [42]熊焰.跨国公司对华FDI就业效应研究[J].中南民族大学学报(自然科学版),2004,(12):106-109
    [43]王根军.中国失业问题现状及外商直接投资的就业增长效应分析[J].云南财贸学院学报(社会科学版),2004,19(2):19-20
    [44]邱晓明.外商直接投资的就业效应变迁分析[J].中国软科学,2004,(3):55-58
    [45]霍倩佳,罗良文.外商直接投资的就业效应分析[J].理论月刊,2005,(1):53-55
    [46]孙倩,桑百川.外商直接投资在我国产生的就业效应分析[J].企业活力,2005,(7):22-23
    [47]钟辉.FDI对中国就业影响的动态分析[J].世界经济研究,2005,(12):11-15
    [48]牟俊霖.外商投资对中国就业影响的实证分析[J].经济与管理,2007,(4):33-37
    [49]桑百川.外商直接投资企业对我国的就业贡献[J].开放导报,1999,(4):31-32
    [50]赵景华.跨国公司在华子公司成长与发展的战略角色及演变趋势[J].中国工业经济,2001,(12):61-66
    [51]胡峰.跨国公司并购我国上市公可问题研究[J].改革,2002,(6):41-46
    [52]David Williams. Explaining Employment Changes in Foreign Manufacturing-Investment in the-UK[J].International Business Review,2003,12(4):479-497
    [53]Christoph Ernst. The FDI-employment Link in a Globalizing World:The Case of Argentina, Brazil and Mexico [J]. Employment Strategy Papers No.2005/17, 2005
    [54]毛日昇.出口、外商直接投资与中国制造业就业[J].经济研究,2009,(11):105-117
    [55]杨云彦,徐映梅,向书坚.就业替代与劳动力流动:一个新的分析框架[J].经济研究,2003,(8):70-75
    [56]万欣荣,史卫,方小军.外国直接投资的就业效应实证分析[J].南开管理评论,2005,8(2):100-106
    [57]易苗,周申.经济开放对国内劳动力流动影响的新经济地理学解析[J].现代财经:天津财经学院学报,2011(3):6-14
    [58]赵德昭.FDI影响我国农村剩余劳动力转移效应的实证研究[D]:[湖南大学硕士学位论文].长沙:湖南大学,2010,3-4
    [59]罗良文,刘辉.外商直接投资的就业效应分析[J].华中农业大学学报:社会科学版,2003(4):13-17
    [60]Chan, K.W., L. Zhang. The Hukou System and Rural-urban Migration in China: Processes and Changes [J]. China Quarterly,1999,16(2):818-855
    [61]Edward M. Graham, Erika Wada. Foreign Direct Investment in China:Effect on Growth and Economic Performance [C]. Experience of Transitional Economies in East Asia,2001
    [62]郑月明,董登新.外商直接投资对我国就业的区域差异与动态效应—基于动态面板数据模型的分析[J].数量经济技术经济研究,2008,(5):104-113
    [63]Ranis G, Fei J C H. A Theory of Economic Development[J]. The American Economic Review,1961,51(4):533-565
    [64]Harris W F. The Dispiration:A Distinct New Crystal Defect of the Weingarten-volterra Type [J]. Philosophical Magazine,1970,22(179):949-952
    [65]李迅雷.跨国公司与发展中国家经济的调整[J].世界经济文汇,1991(4):14-18
    [66]Coughlin Cletus C., Eran Segev. Foreign Direct Investment in China:A Spatial Econometric Study [J]. The World Economy,2000,23(1):1-23
    [67]Kumar K. P. Foreign Direct Investment:Importance, Growth & Employment Opportunities in India [J]. Asian Journal of Research in Business Economics and Management,2013,3(2):190-197
    [68]Bridge G. Global Production Networks and the Extractive Sector:Governing Resource-based Development [J]. Journal of Economic Geography,2008,8(3): 389-419
    [69]Salami, A.O., Oyewale, I.O. Impact of Foreign Direct Investment on Employment Generation in Nigeria [J]. International Journal of Economic Development Research and Investment,2013,4(1):64-75
    [70]Azariadisa C, Christopher A. P. Unemployment Dynamics with International Capital Mobility [J]. European Economic Review,2007,51(1):27-48
    [71]Liu L. FDI and Employment by Industry:A Co-Integration Study [J]. Modern Economy,2012,3(1):16-22
    [72]刘宏,李述晟.FDI对我国经济增长、就业影响研究—基于VAR模型[J].国际贸易问题,2013,(4):105-114
    [73]赵德昭,许和连.FDI流入影响了农村剩余劳动力转移的收敛性吗—来自中国282个地级城市的经验证据[J].山西财经大学学报,2013,(6):21-31
    [74]Hansson Par. Skill Upgrading and Production Transfer within Swedish Multinationals [J]. The Scandinavian Journal of Economics,2005,107(4): 673-692
    [75]Radosevic S., Varblane U., Mickiewicz T. Foreign Direct Investment and Its Effect on Employment in Central Europe [J]. Transnational Corporations,2003, 12(1):53-90
    [76]Liu W., Nunnenkamp P. Domestic Repercussions of Different Types of FDI: Firm-Level Evidence for Taiwanese Manufacturing [J]. World Development, 2011,39(5):808-823
    [77]Molnar M., Pain N., Taglioni D. Globalisation and employment in the OECD [J]. OECD Journal:Economic Studies,2008, (1):1-34
    [78]Karlsson S., Lundin N., Sjoholm F., He P. Foreign Firms and Chinese Employment [J]. The World Economy,2009,32(1):178-201
    [79]Florian B. Z., Schwens C, Kabst R. Foreign Direct Investments and Domestic Employment of German SMEs:The Moderating Effect of Owner Management [J]. Journal of Small Business Management,2013,51(4):1-26
    [80]马述忠,吕淼.外商直接投资与农业产业安全—基于国内投资与就业挤出效应视角的实证研究[J].国际贸易问题,2012,(4):125-136
    [81]曾铮.“不均质”大国的理论框架及其经济学界定[J].中国工业经济,2008,(6):25-34
    [82]贺胜兵,杨文虎.FDI对我国进出口贸易的非线性效应研究—基于面板平滑转换模型[J].数量经济技术经济研究,2008,(10):44-55
    [83]Hansen Bruce E. Threshold-Effects in Non-dynamic Panels:Estimation, Testing, and Inference [J]. Journal of Econometrics,1999,93(2):345-368
    [84]Rosenstein-Rodan P. N. Problems of Industrialisation of Eastern and South-Eastern Europe [J]. The Economic Journal,1943,53(210/211):202-211.
    [85]Lucas, Robert E., Jr. On the Mechanics of Economic Development [J]. Journal of Monetary Economics,1988,22(1):3-42
    [86]罗长远.FDI与国内资本:挤出还是挤入[J].经济学(季刊),2007,6(2):381-400
    [87]Leonard K. Chenga, Yum K. Kwan. What are the Determinants of the Location of Foreign Direct Investment? The Chinese Experience [J]. Journal of International Economics,2000,51(2):379-400
    [88]Eichhorst W., Marx P. Reforming German Labour Market Institutions:A Dual Path to Flexibility [J]. Journal of European Social Policy February,2011,21(1): 73-87
    [89]沈坤荣,张璟.中国农村公共支出及其绩效分析—基于农民收入增长和城乡收入差距的经验研究[J].管理世界,2007,(1):30-40
    [90]吴忠民.转型经济下中国的城市失业及劳动力流动[J].经济学(季刊),2003,2(4):857-874
    [91]Lu M., Chen Z. Urbanization, Urban-Biased Policies and Urban-Rural Inequality in China:1987-2001 [J]. Chinese Economy,2006,39(3):42-63
    [92]孙宁华,堵溢,洪永淼.劳动力市场扭曲、效率差异与城乡收入差距[J].管理世界,2009,(9):44-52
    [93]Zhang, J., Y. Zhao, A. Park, and X. Song. Economic Returns to Schooling in Urban China:1988-2001 [J]. Journal of Comparative Economics,2005,33(4): 730-752
    [94]Zhao, Yaohui. Labor Mobility and Migration and Returns to Rural Education in China [J]. American Journal of Agricultural Economics,1997,79(4):1278-1287
    [95]赵伟,李芬.异质性劳动力流动与区域收入差距:新经济地理学模型的扩展分析[J].中国人口科学,2007,(1):27-35
    [96]Guido De Blasio, Sabrina Di Addario. Labor Market Pooling [J]. IMF Working Paper,2002, (2121):1-37
    [97]Anderson J.E., Wincoop E. Gravity with Gravitas:A Solution to the Border Puzzle [J]. American Economic Review,2003,93(1):170-192
    [98]Krugman, Paul R. Increasing Returns and Economic Geography [J] Journal of Political Economy,1991,99(3):483-499
    [99]刘修岩,殷醒民,贺小海.市场潜能与制造业空间集聚:基于中国地级城市面板数据的经验研究[J].世界经济,2007,(11):56-63
    [100]孙军.地区市场潜能、出口开放与我国工业集聚效应研究[J].数量经济技术经济研究,2009,(7):47-60
    [101]Bagoulla C., Nicolas Peridy. Market Access and the Other Determinants of North-South Manufacturing Location Choice:An Application to the Euro-Mediterranean Area [J]. Economic Systems,2011,35(4):537-561
    [102]Crozet M. Do Migrants Follow Market Potentials:An Estimation of a New Economic Geography Model [J]. Journal of Economic Geography,2004,4(4): 439-458
    [103]Paluzie E., Jordi Pons, Javier Silvestre, Daniel A. Tirado. Migrants and Market Potential in Spain Over the Twentieth Century:A test of the New Economic Geography [J]. Spanish Economic Review,2009,11(4):243-265
    [104]何兴强,王利霞.中国FDI区位分布的空间效应研究[J].经济研究,2008,(11):137-150
    [105]Ledyaeva S. Spatial Econometric Analysis of Foreign Direct Investment Determinants in Russian Regions [J]. The World Economy,2009,32(4):643-666.
    [106]Andreas Waldkircha, Peter Nunnenkamp, Jose Eduardo Alatorre Bremont. Employment Effects of FDI in Mexico's Non-Maquiladora Manufacturing [J]. Journal of Development Studies,2009,45(7):1165-1183
    [107]魏浩,王宸.中国对外贸易空间集聚效应及其影响因素分析[J].数量经济技术经济研究,2011,(11):66-82
    [108]Anselin. Spatial Econometrics:Methods and Models [M]. Dordrecht:Kluwer Academic Publishers,1988
    [109]Elhorst J. P. Specification and Estimation of Spatial Panel Data Models [J]. International Regional Science Review,2003,26(3):244-268
    [110]Blonigen B. A., Ronald B. Davies, Glen R. Waddell, Helen T. Naughton. FDI in Space:Spatial Autoregressive Relationships in Foreign Direct Investment [J]. European Economic Review,2007,51(5):1303-1325
    [111]何江,张馨之.中国区域经济增长及其收敛性:空间面板数据分析[J].南方经济,2006,(5):44-52
    [112]王德文,蔡昉,张国庆.农村迁移劳动力就业与工资决定:教育与培训的重要性[J].经济学(季刊),2008,7(4):1131-1148
    [113]Paul Flaim. Discouraged Workers:How Strong Are Their Links to the Job Market?[J]. Monthty Labor Review,1984,(8):8-11
    [114]江霈,冷静.劳动力流动替代资本流动的辨析与展望[J].财经科学,2008,(12):105-113
    [115]Kojima K. The "Flying Geese" Model of Asian Economic Development:Origin, Theoretical Extensions, and Regional Policy Implications [J]. Journal of Asian Economics,2000,11(4):375-401
    [116]曲玥,蔡昉,张晓波.“飞雁模式”发生了吗?—对1998-2008年中国制造业的分析[J].经济学(季刊),2013,12(3):757-776
    [117]蔡昉,王德文,曲玥.中国产业升级的大国雁阵模型分析[J].经济研究,2009,(9):4-14
    [118]Kravis, I.B., Lipsey R.E. The Effect of Multinational Firms Foreign Operations On Domestic Employment [J]. NBER Working Paper, No.2760,1993
    [119]Lipsey R.E., E Ramstetter, M Blomstrom. Outward FDI and Parent Exports and Employment:Japan, the United States, and Sweden [J]. Global Economy Quarterly,2000,1(4):1524-5861
    [120]Andersen P.S., Hainant P. Foreign Direct Investment and Employment in the Industrial Countries [J]. BIS Working Paper No.61,1998
    [121]Greenwood Michael J., Gary L. Hunt, Dan S. Rickman and George I. Treyz. Migration, Regional Equilibrium, and the Estimation of Compensating Differentials [J]. The American Economic Review,1991,81(5):1382-1390
    [122]Debaere, Peter, Lee, Hongshik and Lee, Joonhyung. It Matters Where You Go: Outward Foreign Direct Investment and Multinational Employment Growth at Home [J]. Journal of Development Economics,2010,91(2):301-309
    [123]Lin P., Zhuomin Liu, Yifan Zhang. Do Chinese Domestic Firms Benefit From FDI Inflow?:Evidence of Horizontal and Vertical Spillovers [J]. China Economic Review,2009,20(4):677-691
    [124]Santos-Paulino, Amelia U, Guanghua Wan. Special Section:FDI, Employment, and Growth in China and India [J]. Review of Development Economics,2009, 13(4):737-739
    [125]Helpman E. A Simple Theory of International Trade with Multinational Corporations [J]. Journal of Political Economy,1984,92(3):451-471
    [126]Mickiewicz T., S Radosevic, U Varblane. The Value of Diversity:Foreign Direct Investment and Employment in Central Europe During Economic Recovery [J]. University of Tartu-Faculty of Economics and Business Administration Working Paper Series 2,2000
    [127]Cheng, L.K., Kwan, Y.K. What Are the Determinants of the Location of Foreign Direct Investment? The Chinese Experience [J]. Journal of International Economics,2000,51(2):379-400
    [128]Helpman, E., Krugman, P. R. Market Structure and International Trade [M]. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA,1985
    [129]Carr David L., James R. Markusen and Keith E. Maskus. Estimating the Knowledge-Capital Model of the Multinational Enterprise [J]. The American Economic Review,2001,91(3):693-708
    [130]Zhao Y.H. Leaving the Countryside:Rural-To-Urban Migration Decisions in China [J]. The American Economic Review,1999,89(2):281-286
    [131]郭剑雄.人力资本、生育率与城乡收入差距的收敛[J].中国社会科学,2005,(3):27-37
    [132]Terry Sicular, Yue Ximing, Bjorn Gustafsson, Li Shi. The Urban-Rural Income Gap and Inequality in China [J]. Review of Income and Wealth,2007,53(1): 93-126
    [133]Sylvie Demurger, Martin Fournier,李实,魏众.中国经济转型中城镇劳动力市场分割问题—不同部门职工工资收入差距的分析[J].管理世界,2009,(3):55-71
    [134]杨海生,聂海峰,徐现祥.我国FDI区位选择中的“第三方效应”—基于空间面板数据的实证研究[J].数量经济技术经济研究,2010,(4):122-147
    [135]Egger, P., Larch, M., Pfaffermayr, M. Multilateral Trade and Investment Liberalization:Effects on Welfare and GDP per Capita Convergence [J]. Economics Letters,2004,84(1):133-140
    [136]Grossman, G. M., Helpman, E., Szeidl, A. Optimal Integration Strategies for the Multinational Firm [J]. Journal of International Economics,2006,70(1):216-238
    [137]Ekholm K., Forslid R., Markusen J R. Export-Platform Foreign Direct Investment [J]. Journal of the European Economic Association,2007,5(4): 776-795
    [138]Yeaple, S.R. The Complex Integration Strategies of Multinational Firms and Cross Country Dependencies in the Structure of Foreign Direct Investment[J]. Journal of International Economics,2003,60(2):293-314
    [139]Baltagi B.H., Peter Egger, Michael Pfaffermayr. Estimating models of complex FDI:Are there third-country effects? [J]. Journal of Econometrics,2007,140(1): 260-281
    [140]Brainard, L.S. An Empirical Assessment of the Proximity-Concentration Trade-off between Multinational Sales and Trade [J]. American Economic Review,1997,87(4):520-544
    [141]BLonigen B.A., Davies,R.B., Head,K.Estimating the Knowledge-capital Model of the Multinational Enterprise:Comment [J]. American Economic Review,2003, 93(3):980-994
    [142]Ledyaeva S. Determinants of Economic Growth:Empirical Evidence from Russian Regions [J]. The European Journal of Comparative Economics,2008, 5(1):87-105
    [143]Garretsen H., Jolanda Peeters. FDI and the Relevance of Spatial Linkages:Do Third-country Effects Matter for Dutch FDI? [J]. Review of World Economics, 2009,145(2):319-338
    [144]Rey S. J. Spatial Empirics for Economic Growth and Convergence [J]. Geographical Analysis,2001,33(3):195-214
    [145]Moran P. Notes on Continuous Stochastic Phenomena [J]. Biometrika,1950, 37(1/2):17-23
    [146]Kim T. J., Gerrit Knaap. The Spatial Dispersion of Economic Activities and Development Trends in China:1952-1985 [J]. The Annals of Regional Science, 2001,35(1):39-57
    [147]Wen M. Relocation and Agglomeration of Chinese Industry [J]. Journal of Development Economics,2004,73(1):329-347
    [148]Hsiao, C. Analysis of Panel Data [M]. Cambridge University Press,2003
    [149]Wheeler D., Mody A. International Investment Location Decisions:The Case of U. S. Firms [J]. Journal of International Economics,1992,33(1-2):57-76
    [150]Hu J. Intersectional Migration of Agricultural Labor and Business Cycles in Developing Countries [J]. Stanford Center for International Development, Working Paper No.402,2009
    [151]刘志忠,贺彩银,王耀中.基于拉尼斯—费模型的民营部门出口贸易对农业剩余劳动力转移影响的实证分析[J].中国农村经济,2007,(10):40-45
    [152]Zhang K.H. Does Foreign Direct Investment Promote Economic Growth? Evidence from East Asia and Latin America [J]. Contemporary Economic Policy, 2001,19(2):175-185
    [153]Marika Karanassou, Dennis J. Snower. How Labour Market Flexibility Affects Unemployment:Long-Term Implications of the Chain Reaction Theory [J]. The Economic Journal,1998,108(448):832-849
    [154]Alfred Kleinknecht. Is Labour Market Flexibility Harmful to Innovation? [J]. Cambridge Journal of Economics,1998,22(3):387-396
    [155]Michie J., Sheehan M. Business Strategy, Human Resources, Labour Market Flexibility and Competitive Advantage [J]. The International Journal of Human Resource Management,2005,16(3):445-464
    [156]Louis Kuijs, Tao Wang. China's Pattern of Growth:Moving to Sustainability and Reducing Inequality [J]. China & World Economy,2006,14(1):1-14
    [157]Du Y., Albert Park, Sangui Wang. Migration and rural poverty in China [J]. Journal of Comparative Economics,2005,33(4):688-709
    [158]Roberts Kenneth D. China's "Tidal Wave" of Migrant Labor:What Can We Learn from Mexican Undocumented Migration to the United States? [J]. International Migration Review,1997,31(2):249-293
    [159]周黎安.中国地方官员的晋升锦标赛模式研究[J].经济研究,2007,(7):36-50
    [160]Todaro M. P. A Model of Labor Migration and Urban Unemployment in Less Developed Countries [J]. The American Economic Review,1969,59(1):138-148
    [161]Brooks R., Tao, Ran. China's Labor Market Performance and Challenges [J]. IMF Working Paper No.03/210,2003
    [162]Gustafsson, Bjorn, Li, Shi. The Anatomy of Rising Earnings Inequality in Urban China [J]. Journal of Comparative Economics,2001,29(1):118-135
    [163]Parish W. L., Xiaoye Zhe, Fang Li. Nonfarm Work and Marketization of the Chinese Countryside [J]. The China Quarterly,1995, (143):697-730
    [164]Xu J. X., Ying Tan. Robust Optimal Design and Convergence Properties Analysis of Iterative Learning Control Approaches [J]. Automatica,2002,38(11): 1867-1880
    [165]王业强,魏后凯.产业特征、空间竞争与制造业地理集中—来自中国的经验证据[J].管理世界,2007,(4):68-77
    [166]Zanella, Giulio. Discrete Choice with Social Interactions and Endogenous Memberships [J]. Journal of the European Economic Association,2007,5(1): 122-153
    [167]蔡防.中国人口流动方式与途径[M].社会科学文献出版社,2001
    [168]Moffitt, Robert. Policy Interventions, Low-Level Equilibria, and Social Interactions [M]. In Steven N. Durlauf, H. Peyton Young, (ed.), Social Dynamics MIT Press,2001
    [169]Feenstra, Hanson. Foreign Direct Investment and Relative Wages:Evidence from Mexico's Maquiladoras [J]. Journal of International Economics 1997,3(42): 371-393
    [170]贺宇.农村劳动力转移中的利益冲突:一个社会博弈的视角[J].学术研究,2008,(4):71-80
    [171]赵文哲.财政分权与前沿技术进步、技术效率关系研究[J].管理世界,2008, (7):34-44
    [172]Zhuravskaya, Ekaterina, V. Incentives to Provide Local Public Goods:Fiscal Federalism, Russian Style [J]. Journal of Public Economics,2000,76(3): 337-368
    [173]马拴友,于红霞.转移支付与地区经济收敛[J].经济研究,2003,(3):26-33
    [174]蔡防.刘易斯转折点与公共政策方向的转变—关于中国社会保障的若干特征性事实[J].中国社会科学,2010,(6):125-137
    [175]Tiebout, C. A Pure Theory of Local Expenditures [J]. Journal of Political Economy,1956,64 (5):416-424
    [176]Oates, W. E. Fiscal Federalism [M]. NY:Harcourt Brace Jovanovich,1972
    [177]Qian, Y., and B. R. Weingast. Federalism as a Commitment to Preserving Market Incentives [J]. Journal of Economic Perspectives,1997,11(4):83-92
    [178]Shleifer, Andrei and Robert W. Vishny, The Grabbing Hand:Government Pathologies and Their Cures [M]. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA, 1998
    [179]Treisman, Danie. Decentralization and the Quality of Government[J]. Manuscript, Department of Political Science, University of California, Los Angeles,2000
    [180]Roland, G., Politics, Markets, and Firms:Transition and Economics[M]. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA,2000
    [181]Yasusada Murate. Rural-urban Interdependence and Industrialization [J]. Journal of Development Economics,2002,68(1):1-34
    [182]Inman, Robert P. and Rubinfeld, Daniel L. Rethinking Federalism [J]. Journal of Economic Perspectives,1997,11(4):43-64
    [183]Buchanan, J. M. An Economic Theory of Clubs [J]. Economica,1965,32(125): 1-14
    [184]Oates, Wallace E. Toward a Second-Generation Theory of Fiscal Federalism [J]. International Tax and Public Finance,2005,12(4):349-373
    [185]Besley, Timothy, and Stephen Coate. Centralized versus Decentralized Provision of Local Public Goods:a Political Economy Approach [J]. Journal of Public Economics,2003,87(12):2611-2637
    [186]Faguet, Jean Paul. Does Decentralization Increase Government Responsiveness to Local Needs? Evidence from Bolivia [J]. Journal of Public of Economics, 2004,88(3):867-893
    [187]Kappeler, Andreas and Timo Vlil. Fiscal Federalism and the Composition of Public Investment in Europe [J]. European Journal of Political Economy,2008, 24(3):562-570
    [188]Dabla-Norris, E. and Wade, P. The Challenge of Fiscal Decentralization in Transition Countries [J]. International Monetary Fund Working Paper,2002, No.103
    [189]Weingast, Barry R. Second Generation Fiscal Federalism:Implications for Decentralized Democratic Governance and Economic Development [J].Working Paper, Hoover Institution, and Department of Political Science, Stanford University,2006
    [190]张军,周黎安编.为增长而竞争:中国增长的政治经济学[M].上海:上海人民出版社,2008
    [191]Musgrave, Robert A. The Theory of Public Finance:A Study in Political Economy [M]. New York:Mcgraw-Hill,1959
    [192]Barro, R. Government Spending in a Simple Model of Endogenous Growth[J]. Journal of Political Economy,1990, (98):S103-S125
    [193]Davoodi, H. and H. Zou. Fiscal Decentralization and Economic Growth:A Cross-Country Study [J]. Journal of Urban Economics,1998,43(2):244-257
    [194]Zhang, T., and H. Zou. Fiscal decentralization, public spending, and economic growth in China [J]. Journal of Public Economics,1998,67(2):221-240
    [195]Zhang,T., and H. Zou. The growth impact of intersectoral and intergovernmental allocation of public expenditure:with applications to China and India [J]. China Economic Review,2001,12(1):58-81
    [196]Lin, J. Y., and Z. Liu. Fiscal Decentralization and Economic Growth in China [J]. Economic Development and Cultural Change,2000,49(1):1-23
    [197]王永钦,张晏,章元,陈钊,陆铭.中国的大国发展道路—论分权式改革的得失[J].经济研究,2007,(1):4-16
    [198]范子英,张军.财政分权与中国经济增长的效率—基于非期望产出模型的分析[J].管理世界,2009,(7):15-25
    [199]国务院研究室课题组.中国农民工调研报告[R].北京:中国言实出版社,2006
    [200]Li, J., Qiu, L. D., Sun, Q. Y., Forthcoming, Interregional Protection:Implications of Fiscal Decentralization and Trade Liberalization [J]. China Economic Review
    [201]严冀,陆铭.分权与区域经济发展:面向一个最优分权程度的理论[J].世界经济文汇,2003,(3):55-66
    [202]龚锋,卢洪友.公共支出结构、偏好匹配与财政分权[J].管理世界,2009,(1):10-21
    [203]Demurger, Sylvie, Infrastructure Development and Economic Growth:An Explanation for Regional Disparities in China? [J]. Journal of Comparative Economics,2001,29(1):95-117
    [204]蔡防.农村劳动力剩余及其相关事实的重新考察—一个反事实的应用[J].中国农村经济,2007,(10):4-12
    [205]黄乾.农村劳动力转移就业问题性质的根本转变与社会政策选择[J].人口研究,2007,31(4):70-76
    [206]Y. Qian. The Process of China's Market Transition (1978-1998):The Evolutionary, Historical, and Comparative Perspectives [J]. Journal of Institutional and Theoretical Economics,2000, (156):151-171
    [207]谷成.中国财政分权的轨迹变迁及其演进特征[J].中国经济史研究,2009,(2):43-51
    [208]金太军,汪波.经济转型与中国中央—地方关系制度变迁[J].管理世界,2003,(6):43-51
    [209]张恒龙,陈宪.财政竞争对地方公共支出结构的影响—以中国的招商引资竞争为例[J].经济社会体制比较,2006,(6):57-64
    [210]孙红玲.候鸟型农民工问题的财政体制求解[J].中国工业经济,2011,(1):15-26
    [211]Li, Hong-bin and Li An-Zhou. Political Turnover and Economic Performance: The Incentive Role of Personnel Control in China [J]. Journal of Public Economics,2005,89(9):1743-1762
    [212]Roodman, D. How to do xtabond2:An Introduction to'Difference'and'System' GMM in Stata [J].Center for Global Development Working Paper 103,2007
    [213]Bond, S. Dynamic panel data models:A guide to micro data methods and practice, Working Paper 09/02, Institute for Fiscal Studies, London,2002
    [214]Jin, J., and Zou, Heng-fu. How Does Fiscal Decentralization Affect Aggregate, National, and Subnational Government Size? [J]. Journal of Urban Economics, 2002,52(2):270-293
    [215]许和连,赵德昭.农村剩余劳动力转移的收敛性分析[J].农业技术经济,2012,(2):109-121

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700