摘要
建立一支相对稳定的知识型员工团队对企业的生存和发展至关重要。本文以知识型员工的流动为对象,从员工和企业两个角度对员工流动进行研究。全文的研究内容和结果如下:
1)员工主动流动受多种因素影响,因素之间的相互影响导致难以确定不同因素对员工流动的影响程度。本文在国内外研究的基础上,建立员工离职路径模型。通过问卷调查,获得了384份知识型员工流动调查问卷,根据问卷调查的结果,利用聚类分析和主成分分析,获得影响因素的共同性并解决因素间的多重共线性问题,最后通过结构方程模型确定了不同因素对员工主动流动的影响程度。
员工主动离职影响因素按照影响程度依次是成就与发展类因素、安全与保障类因素、兴趣与能力类因素、流动成本类因素、生活质量因素、流动难度因素和家庭与责任因素。
2)员工择业是流动过程中的重要步骤,国内外对此研究相对较少。针对择业评价过程中存在的不完全信息,包括模糊权重、语言评价值、不确定信息的特点,本文建立了不完全信息多准则评价模型,并用算例对模型进行了说明。算例表明,员工的个性特点、对工作机会信息的掌握程度都会对员工的流动决策产生影响。
3)本文在现有人力资本理论、剩余价值理论、绩效理论等的基础上,考虑到企业所处的日新月异的经营环境和频繁的人员流动,提出对员工价值评价不仅要考虑当前绩效,还要考虑潜能和忠诚度等因素。在此基础上建立了员工价值评价模型。为解决传统评价方法过多依赖于专家主观评价的问题,本文提出了基于粗糙集理论的员工价值评价模型。通过案例分析,验证了该评价方法的有效性。
4)在员工价值评价的基础上,建立了基于员工价值的员工离职预警模型,考虑到有效性和实用性的要求,本文提取了员工忠诚度、敬业精神等四个指标作为员工流动的预警指标,并通过粗糙集理论确定了四个指标的权重。针对常用员工流动评价重“出”不重“入”,重“量”不重“质”的问题,本文建立了基于员工价值的员工流动评价体系。本章最后通过案例对这两个模型进行说明和验证。
As the origin of the corporation key competency, building and sustaining a relative stable knowledge worker team act an important role for the corporation to survive and develop in the drastic competition. Take the turnover of the knowledge worker (KM) as object, the dissertation researches the turnover of the KM from both the worker and the corporation sides. The content and conclusion are as followed.
1. The voluntary turnover of the KM is influenced by lots of factors, and the interaction of the factors makes it difficult to quantity the relation of these factors and KM turnover. Based on the researches oversea and inland, the turnover path model is build. By Classify Analysis and Principal Analysis, the influence factors are classified and the multiple-interaction question is solved. The relation of the factors and KM turnover is gotten by Structure Equation Model (SEM). Achievement factors, work and life security factors, interesting and ability factors rank the top three among factors influence KM turnover, followed by turnover cost factors, life quality factors, turnover difficulty factors and family obligation factors.
2. There are relative little research on how the KM appraisal and choose a job. Focus on the fuzzy value, language value, uncertain value and utterly ignorant information among the job hunting and appraisal process, a MCDM model with incomplete information is set up. To illustrate the model, an example is input, which improves that both the attitude to the risk and other characteristics of the job-hunter, together with the information he has have will influence his appraisal result.
3. Take the frequent turnover of the KM and dynamic operation environment into consideration, a KM value appraisal model, which consider the performance, the potential, the loyalty of the KM is set up based on human capital theory, surplus value theory, performance theory, supply and demand theory, surplus value theory. To eliminate the influence of subjective factors, Rough Set (RS) theory is introduced. A case study is also used which improve the effectiveness of the model.
4. Based on the result of KM value appraisal, KM turnover forecast mechanism is build up. Take accuracy with practicability, four index are integrated to forecast the turnover of the KM, and the weight of the four index are determined by Rough Set Theory. The dissertation also research how to appraisal the turnover of the KM for the ordinary appraisal index, such as turnover rate, can only tell how many workers quit but not who quits. Based on the worker’s value, a new appraisal system is build up. By this appraisal system, the corporation can monitor not only how many workers turnover, but also the effect of the turnover. The system also shows how many workers is hired while the conventional appraisal index, such as worker turnover rate can only show the output of the worker’s turnover. At the end of this chapter, a case is used to illustrate the application of the KM turnover forecast system and turnover appraisal index system. The validity of the forecasting system is also been approved by the case.
引文
[1] 蒋春燕,赵曙明,知识型员工流动的特点、原因与对策,中国软科学,2001,2:85-88
[2] 中国教育在线,http://www.eol.cn/kuai_xun_4343/20060911/t20060911_195752.shtml
[3] 中华英才网,http://info.800hr.com/topic/070124/index9.php
[4] 李庆,转型时期中国企业人才流失成因分析及其应对策略,华东师范大学硕士论文,2003
[5] Daft,R.L.,Organization Theory&Design,South-Western College Publishing,1997
[6] 刘青山,知识型员工流失原因初探,经济论坛,2004,11:82-83
[7] J.Bruce Tracy,Michael J Tews,Training Effectiveness:Accounting for Individual Characteristics and the Work Environment,Cornell Hotel and Restaurant Administration Quarterly,1995,12:36-42
[8] Barbara L.Rau,Gary A.Adams,Attracting retirees to apply:desired organizational characteristics of bridge employment,Journal of Organizational Behavior 2005,26(6):649-695
[9] Douglas C,Maynard,Todd J,Thorsteinson,Natalya M,Parfyonova,Reasons for working part-time:Subgroup differences in job attitudes and turnover intentions,Career Development International,2006,11(2):145
[10] Jeann Marie Hiltrop,The Quest for the Best:Human Resource Practices to Attract and Retain Talent,European Management Journal,1999,8:422 -429
[11] Christine M,Todd,Deanna M,Decry-Schmitt,Factors Affecting Turnover Among Family Child Care Providers:A Longitudinal Study,Early Childhood Research Quarterly,1996,11:351-376
[12] Dyuti S,Banerjee,Noel Gaston,Labour market signaling and job turnover revisited,Labour Economics,2004,11:599-622
[13] Wanous,J.P,Organizational Entry,Menlo Park,CA:Addison-Wesley,1992
[14] Price. J. L,Reflections of the determinants of voluntary turnover,Journal of International Manpower,2001,22(7):600-624
[15] 叶仁荪,郭耀煌,企业员工离职的博弈分析模型,系统工程,2003,21(3):87-90
[16] 崔勋,员工个人特性对组织承诺与离职意愿的影响研究,南开管理评论,2003,(4):4-11
[17] 张勉,张德,李树茁,IT 企业技术员工离职意图路径模型实证研究,南开管理评论,2003,(4):12-20
[18] 姜秀丽,石岩.员工流动管理,济南:山东人民出版社,2004.6
[19] 吴忠吉,高雄加工出口区离职率之再研究:1972 年至 1978 年的实证分析,台北:经济论文丛刊,1988,11
[20] 黄正雄,人力资源管理措施—价值观契合与员工效能之关系,台湾大学商学研究所博士论文,1998
[21] 邓桂枝,国外学者论降低员工流动率,外国经济与管理,2001,23(6):25-27
[22] 周涛,陈荣秋,员工流动成本计算模型,科技进步与决策,2003,6:119-120
[23] Sheehan,T,Joseph,Moral Judgment as a Predictor of Clinical Performance,San Francisco,California:Eval Health Prof,1980
[24] Morrison,E.W.,Robinson,S.L.,When employees feel betrayed,academy of management rview,1997,22(1):226-256
[25] Iverson,R. D.,“An event history analysis of employee turnover:The case of hospital employees in Australia.”,Human Resource Management Review,1999,9(4):397-418
[26] Lawrence,M.,Brown,J.,Bellm,D,Helping family day care providers stay in the business:Retention strategies from the California child care initiative,San Francisco:California Child Care Resource and Referral Network,1989
[27] Mark Harris,Kam-Ki Tang,Yi-Ping Tseng,Optimal Employee Turnover Rate:Theory and Evidence,Melbourne Institute Working Paper,2002,10:1-24
[28] 张亚莉,杨乃定,人员流动风险分析与控制,航空科学技术,2000,3:26-28
[29] Claudio Fernandez Araoz,Hiring Without Firing,Harvard Business Review,1999,7-8:133
[30] Margaret A. Deery,An Exploratory Analysis of Turnover Culture in the Hotel Industry in Australia,International Journal of Hospitality Management,1997,(4):375-392
[31] 李志,李星敏,企业高忠诚度知识型员工特征的实证研究,科技管理研究,2005,6:75-77
[32] Jean Marie Hiltrop,The Quest for the Best:Human Resource Practices to Attract and Retain Talent,European Management Journal,1999,8:422-429
[33] Melenie J. Lankau,Beth G. Chung,Mentoring for Line Level Employees,Cornell Hotel and Restaurant Administration Quarterly,1998,12:14-19
[34] 史振磊,知识员工的劳动特点及其管理策略,北方交通大学学报(社会科学版),2003,2(3):47-50
[35] 张望军,彭剑锋,中国企业知识型员工激励机制实证分析,科研管理,2001,22(6):90-97
[36] 程贯平,激励知识型员工的整体薪酬,中国人力资源开发,2003,8:26-28
[37] Timothy Butler,James Waldroop,Job Sculpting:The Art of Retaining Your Best People,Harvard Business Review,1999,9 (10) :144 -152
[38] 斯蒂芬?P?罗宾斯,管理学(第四版),北京:中国人民大学出版社,2000
[39] Peter.F.Druck,The Landmarks of Tomorrow,New York:Harper & Row,1959
[40] Peter?Drucker,The future that has already happened,New Yourk:The Futurist,1998
[41] Future Work (1994)转引自安盛咨询公司的研究报告:Workforce of the 21st Century[R],1998
[42] 黄英忠,人力资源管理,台北:三民书局,1997
[43] Mobley,W. H,Employee Turnover,Reading:Addison-Wesley,1982
[44] Muchinsky,P.M.,Tuttle,J,M,"Employee absenteeism:A review of the literature",Journal of Vocational Behavior,1979,10:316-334
[45] Mobley,W .H .,Griffeth,R.W.,Hand,H .H .,Meglino,B .M,"Review and conceptual analysis of the employee turnover process",Psychological Bulletin,1979,86:493-522
[46] Rodger W.Griffeth,Peter W. Hom.,Retaining Valued Employees,London:Sage Publications,2001
[47] Boudreau,J.W.,Berger,C.J,Decision-theoretic utility analysis applied to employee separations and aquisitions,Journal of Applied Psychology,1985,70:581-612
[48] Lewin,Field theory in social science,New York:Harper & Brothers,1951
[49] Jovanovic,B,“Job matching and the theory of turnover.”,Journal of Political Economy,1979,87(5):972-990
[50] Burdett,K, “A theory of employee job search and quit rates.”,American Economic Review,1978,68(1):212-220
[51] Ahn,S,“Firm dynamics and productivity growth:A review of micro evidence from OECD countries.”,OECD Economic Department Working Paper,2001:297
[52] Rousseau,D,R. Cooke,Behaviors norms and expectations:a quantitative approach to the assessment of organizational culture,Group and Organizational Studies,1988,13:245-273
[53] Richard,G.N.,James,S.B.,Daryl,O.M.,Robert,M,An Investigation Into the Antecedents of Organizational Citizenship Behaviors in a Personal Selling Context. Journal of Marketing,1997,61:85-98
[54] Bowen,D.,Ledford,G. Jr,Nathan,B,Hiring for the organization not the job,Academy of Management Executive,1991,5:35-51
[55] Chatman,matching people and organization:selection and socialization in public accounting firms,Academy of management review,1989,36:459-484
[56] Bretz,R. Jr.,Judge,T.,Person-organization fit and the theory of work adjustment:Implications for satisfaction,tenure,and career success ,Journal of Vocational Behavior,1994,44:32-54
[57] 谢晋宇,王英.企业雇员流失-原因、后果与控制,北京:经济管理出版社,1999:186-187
[58] Daniel Katz,Robert l. kahn,The social psychology of organizations,New York:John Wiley & Sons,1966
[59] James W.walker,人力资源战略,北京:中国人民大学出版社,2001
[60] 保罗?萨缪尔森,威廉?诺德豪斯著,萧琛译,经济学(第十六版),北京:华夏出版社,1999
[61] 赵忠令,周荣华,成本收益分析:探视道德行为的新视角,苏州大学学报,2000,(2):32-33
[62] 杨东红,孙晓春,人才流动的决策模型及对策,大庆石油学院学报,2004,28(3):81-84
[63] 赵涛,人力资源开发与管理,天津:天津大学出版社,2005,11
[64] 周俊波,大学生就业成本的一个实证研究,北大教育经济研究(电子季刊),2003,1(1):1-13
[65] Blau,D. M,P. K. Robins,Job Search,Wage Offers,and Unemployment Insurance. Journal of Public Economics,1986,29:173-97
[66] 赵曙明,人力资源管理研究,北京:中国人民大学出版社,2001
[67] James D. Werbel,Relationship among Career Exploration,Job Search Intensity,and Job Search Effectiveness in Graduating College Students,Journal of Vocational Behavior,2000,57:379-394
[68] Cees Gorter; Guyonne R. J. Kalb,Estimating the Effect of Counseling and Monitoring the Unemployed Using a Job Search Model,The Journal of Human Resources,1996,31:590-610
[69] 刘明,华瑛,大学生求职行为的序列寻访模型分析,法制与社会,2006,7:173-174
[70] 赵延东,求职者的社会网络与就业保留工资,社会学研究,2003,(4):51-60
[71] 王黎萤,丁卫明,马万里,高新技术企业知识型员工流动的实证研究和对策分析,科技管理研究,2004,5:36-38
[72] Mobley.W.H.,"Intermediate Linkages in the Relationship Between Job Satisfaction and Employee Turnover.",Journal of Applied Psychology,1977,62(2):237-239
[73] Netemeyer RG,Boles JS,McKee DO,McMurrian R. an investigation into the antecedents of organizational citizenship behaviors in a personal selling context,J Mark 1997,61(3):85-98
[74] J. G. March,H. A. Simon,Organizations,New York:Wiley,1958
[75] LEE T W,MITCHELL T R,An alternative approach:the unfolding model of voluntary employee turnover,academy of management review,1994,19(1):51-89
[76] 张玉静,中国员工多路径离职模型的实证研究,武汉大学硕士论文,2004.5
[77] 杨东红,于舒杰,知识型员工流动分析与对策,齐齐哈尔大学学报,2003,19,2:80-84
[78] Abraham Pizam,Steven W,Thornburg,Absenteeism and voluntary turnover in Central Florida hotels:a pilot study,Hospitality Management,2000,19:211-217
[79] Grusky,D.,Career Mobility and Organizational Commitment,Administrative science quarterly,1966
[80] Marleen Godthelp,Ursula Glunk,Turnover at the Top:Demographic Diversity as a Determinant of Executive Turnover in The Netherlands,European Management Journal,2003,21(5):614–625
[81] 叶仁荪,国有企业员工离职动因分析,西南交通大学博士论文,2005
[82] 夏功成,胡斌,张金隆,基于定性模拟的员工离职行为预测,管理科学学报,2006,9(4):81-94
[83] Jack K,Ito,Céleste M,Brotheridge,Does Supporting Employees’Career Adaptability Lead to Commitment,Turnover,or Both?,Human Resource Management,2005,44(1):5-19
[84] Szilagyi,AD.,"Keeping Employee's Turnover under Control.",The Management of People at Work,1979,6:42-55
[85] 林盛,基于 PLS 结构方程模型的服务行业顾客满意度测评方法及应用研究,天津大学博士论文,2002
[86] 王重鸣,陈民科,管理胜任力特征分析:结构方程模型检验,心理科学,2002,5:513-517
[87] 侯杰泰,温忠麟,成子娟,结构方程模型及其应用,北京:教育科学出版社,2004.7
[88] WeinsteinC.E,GoetzE.T,Alexander. P.A.(Eds.),Learning and study strategies:Issues in assessment,instruction and evaluation,NewYork:AcademicPress,1998
[89] 刘朝杰,问卷的信度和效度,中国慢性病预防和控制,1997,5(4):174-177
[90] 吴明隆,SPSS 统计应用实务,北京:科学出版社,2003
[91] 周晓彬,张东峰,张健,死亡水平影响因素的通径分析,青岛医学院学报,1995,31(3):214
[92] 曾武,黄子杰,用线性结构方程模型对居民两周患病与就诊影响因素的分析,福建医科大学学报(社会科学版),2001,2(1):76-79
[93] Foorence Berger,Ajay Ghei,Employment Tests:A Facet of Hospitality Hiring,Cornell Hotel and Restaurant Administration Quarterly,1995,(12):28-35
[94] 中国广播网,http://www.chinahrd.net/zhi_sk/article.asp?articleID=112747
[95] 智联招聘网,http://www.boraid.com/darticle3/articleread.asp?id=70653&page=2
[96] 中华英才网,http://www.tyfo.com/career/seek/block/html/2003042100037.html
[97] Becker,Gary S.,The Economic Approach to Human Behavior,Chicago:The University of Chicago Press,1976
[98] 科尔曼著,邓方译,社会理论的基础,北京:社会科学文献出版社,1990
[99] 关培兰,瞿伟,工作寻访理论与人才择业,中国人才.2002,7:55-56
[100] Patrick Chang,Boon Lee,Turnover of information technology professionals:a contextual model,Accting.,Mgmt,& Info,Tech,2000,10:101–124
[101] John T,Addison,Pedro Portugal,Job search methods and outcomes,IZA Discussion Paper,No1349,2001,8
[102] Narendranathan. W. S,J Nickell,Modeling the process of job search,Quarterly Journal of Economics,1985,28:29-49
[103] Zadeh L A,Fuzzy set,Information and Control,1965,8:339-353
[104] Bellman R E,Zadeh L A,Decision-making in a fuzzy environment,Management Science,1970,17:141-164
[105] 李荣钧,模糊多准则决策理论与应用,北京:科学出版社,2002
[106] Bortolan G,Degani R,Willems J L,ECG classification with neural networks and cluster analysis,IEEE Comput Soc Proc Computers in Cardiology,Venice,Italy:IEEE Comput Soc Press,1991:177-180
[107] K Nakamura,Preference relations on a set of fuzzy utilities as a basis for decision making.Fuzzy Sets and Systems,1986,20:147~162
[108] Lee. E. S., R. J. Li,"Comparison of fuzzy number based on the probability measure of fuzzy events,",Computers Math,Applic.,1988,15(10):887-896
[109] J. F. Bladwin,N. C. F. Guild,Feasible algorithmas for approximate reasoning using fuzzy logic,Fuzzy Sets and Systems,1980,3:225-252
[110] Chang P L,Chen Y C,A fuzzy multi-criteria decision making method for technology transfer strategy selection in biotechnology,Fuzzy Sets and Systems,1994,63:131-139
[111] Adamopoulos. G. I,C. P. Pappis,"A fuzzy-linguistic approach to a multi-criteria sequencing problem,",European Journal of Operational Research,1996,92:628-636
[112] 陈通,宏微观经济学,天津:天津大学出版社, 2003
[113] 齐寅峰,多准则决策引论,北京:兵器工业出版社,1989
[114] 杨剑波,多目标决策方法与应用,长沙:湖南出版社,1996
[115] 潘介人,决策分析中的效用理论,上海:上海交通大学出版社,2000
[116] 成盛超,谢如贤,吴健中效用理论的历史与现状,系统工程理论与实践,1994,12:16-21
[117] Keun Tae Cho,Multi-criteria Decision Methods:An Atempt to Evaluate and Unify,Mathematical and Comp uter Modelling,2003,37:1099-1119
[118] 杜纲,管理数学基础--理论与应用,天津:天津大学出版社,2003
[119] 杨伦标,高英仪,模糊数学原理及应用,广州:华南理工大学出版社, 1993
[120] Eric Flamholtz,Human Resource Accounting(second edition),Jossey-Bass Publishers,Cambridge:MIT Press,1985
[121] 李耘涛,企业高层管理人员人力资本定价模型研究,天津大学博士论文,2007
[122] 西奥多?W?舒尔茨,论人力资本投资,北京:北京经济学院出版社,1990:1~27
[123] 加里?贝克尔,人类行为的经济分析,上海:上海人民出版杜,1995:81~82
[124] 焦俊龙,人力资源、人力资本和知识资本,山西财经大学学报,1999,21(4):15-16
[125] 陆胤,王坤,居茜,有效控制员工培训后跳槽,中国劳动,2006,3:54-55
[126] 张文贤,人力资源会计,上海:上海立信会计出版社,2001
[127] 韩忠春,人力资源价值的计量方法的分析与计算,科技与管理:2004,3:148-150
[128] 王丽,稀缺人力资源是企业核心竞争力的源泉,科技创业月刊,2006,19(10):121-122
[129] 邓先宏,傅军胜,毛立言,对劳动和劳动价值理论几个问题的思考,经济研究,2002,5:3-13
[130] 李永壮,基于个体的绩效管理体系研究,天津大学博士论文,2006
[131] 刘欢,基于知识员工的 KPI 设定原则探讨,企业技术开发,2005,7:24
[132] 郭多祚,多目标经济决策,长春:吉林大学出版社,1998,8
[133] 王庆,知识型企业知识型员工任务指派及调度决策问题研究,天津大学博士论文,2006
[134] 赵涛,管理学常用方法,天津:天津大学出版社,2006.7
[135] 达仁,胡清华,鲍文,融合粗糙集和模糊聚类的连续数据知识发现,中国电机工程学报,2004,24(6):205-210
[136] 王珏,王任,苗夺谦,基于 Rough Set 理论的“数据浓缩”,计算机学报,1998,21(5):393-400
[137] 梁霖,徐光华,基于克隆选择的粗糙集属性约简方法,西安交通大学学报,2005,39(11):1231-1235
[138] 石峰,娄臻亮,张永清,一种改进的粗糙集属性约简启发式算法,上海交通大学学报,2002,36(4):478-481
[139] B. Walczak,DL Massart,Rough sets theory,Chemometrics and Intelligent Laboratory Systems,1999,47(1):1~16
[140] 吴隽,张剑英,任丽娟,基于证据推理与粗集理论的供应链合作伙伴选择方法研究,中国软科学,2005,3:130-134
[141] 曾黄麟,粗集理论及其应用(二)──知识的简化及数据的依赖性,四川轻化工学院学报,1996,9(2):1-8
[142] Kiechel III,W.,The art of the exit interview,Fortune,1990,122 (4):114-115
[143] Lefkowitz,J.,Katz,M.L.,Validity of exit interviews,Personnel Psychology,1969,22:445-455.
[144] Hinrichs,J.R,Measurement of reasons for resignation of professionals:questionnaire vs company and consultant exit interview,Journal of Applied Psychology,1975,60:530
[145] Richard A,Feinberg,Nina Jeppeson,Validity of exit interviews in retailing,Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services,2000,(7):123-127
[146] Hoppock,R.,"Job Satisfaction.",New York:Haper & Row,1935
[147] Porter.,"Organizational Work and Personal Factors in Employee Turnover and Absenteeism.",Psychological Bulletin,1973,80:151-176
[148] Porter,Commitment to Organization and Occupations:Extension and Test of a Three-Component Conceptualization.Journal of Applied Psychology,1993,78(6):538-551
[149] Becker,H.S,Notes on the concept of commitment,American Journal of sociology,1960,66:32-40
[150] Morris,James H.,L.D.Sherman,"Generalizability of an Organizational Commitment Model.",Academy of Management Journal,1981,24(3):516
[151] Radinowitz. S,Hall. D. T.,"Organizational Research on Job Involvement ",Psychological Bulletin,1977,84(2):265-288
[152] McEvoy. G.M.,Cascio.W.F.,"Strategies for Reducing Employee Turnover:A Meta-analysis.",Journal of Applied Psychology,1985,70:342-353
[153] Farris,G,F.,"A Predictive Study of Turnover.",Personnel Psychology,1971,24:311-328
[154] Steers,R.M. , "Antecedents and Outcomes of Organizational Commitment" ,Administrative Science Quarterly,1977,22:46-54
[155] Kraut,A.I,"Predicting Turnover of Employees from Measured Job Attitudes.",Organizational Behavior and Human Performance,1975,13:233-243
[156] Meyer,J.P,Allen,N.J.& Smith,C.A.,Commitment to organizations and occupations:extension of a test of a three-component conceptualization,Journal of Applied Psychology,1993,78:538-551
[157] Mobley W H.,Homer S.O.,Hollingworth A T,"An Evaluation of Precursors of Hospital Employee Turnover.",Journal of Applied Psychology,1978,63(4):408-414
[158] Michaels,C.E.,Spector,P E.,"Cause of Employee Turnover:A Test of The Mobley Griffeth,Hand,and Meglino Model.",Journal of Applied Psychology,1982,67(1):53-59
[159] Atchison,Thomas,The Myths of Employee Satisfaction,Healthecare Executive,1999,14(2):18-23
[160] Mowday. R. T,Steers. R. M.,Porter. L. W,The Measurement of Organizational Commitment,Journal of Vocational Behavior,1979,14(3):224-247
[161] 谢玉华,曹建,曾铮,基于忠诚度的知识型员工流失预警管理研究,财经理论与实践,2006,27(2):104-106
[162] 杨伟国,战略人力资源审计,上海:复旦大学出版社,2004
[163] P.J.Harkins,L.Kurtz,The Real Cost of Employee Turnover,World Executive’s Digest,1991,XII(10):87