内外失衡下的流动性供给、资产价格及货币政策选择
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
上个世纪三十年代,崇尚“看不见的手”调节市场的国家遭遇了一场前所未有的经济危机,当人们从大萧条的阴影中走出时,开始反思政府在市场经济中的角色,于是强调政府干预的凯恩斯主义应运而生。同时经济学家也设想,假如时光倒流,中央银行是不是能在危机到来之前采取某种相应的货币政策使经济免于动荡,或者在泡沫崩溃之后能采取某种措施将危机损害尽量降低并加快复苏速度。
     如果说大萧条时期人们担心的主要问题是“需求不足和流动性不足”的话,那么在接踵而至的1990年代日本金融危机和1998年东南亚金融危机中困扰发达国家和新兴市场经济体的问题反而变成了“流动性过剩”。进入21世纪,世界最大经济体美国又接连遭遇金融危机,危机的典型特征是经济失衡下流动性过剩导致了资产泡沫膨胀,泡沫最终破裂引发金融动荡。
     分析每一次金融动荡,我们都会发现全球化过程中经济失衡是近年来历次危机的主要背景,而“流动性”和“资产泡沫”是危机的主要线索。于是,笔者希望通过研究,厘清经济内外失衡、流动性和资产价格之间的关系,以及中央银行采取何种货币政策中介目标更能有助于预防危机的发生和在危机之后促进经济尽快复苏。
     消费不足和储蓄过度的内因加上不合理国际产业分工体系的外因造成了我国经济的内外失衡,这种失衡将会在今后较长时期内成为我国经济发展的主要背景,而不合理的国际货币体系导致的全球流动性过剩也时刻威胁着我国的金融安全。
     如何应对流动性问题是研究的主线,本文首先分析流动性和流动性过剩,指出由于受到诸多因素干扰,流动性过剩在理论和实践上都难以明确界定和计量,因为谁也无法准确预测人类在贪婪与恐惧的本性下做出的对资产风险与收益的评估,央行自然也不例外。即使央行判断出流动性过剩也往往为时已晚,长期投资过热可能已经催生了资产泡沫,此时是否刺破泡沫又是一个艰难选择。那么对于金融稳定,央行能做的到底是什么呢?央行应当专注于自身的流动性供给状况,关注流动性供给与资产期限调整的关系进而与金融稳定的关系。当出现异常的短期与长期资产之间的替代时,央行应当相机运用利率、货币供给量等手段时刻影响公众的预期,通过影响公众的预期来抑制资产替代过程中的过分投机,从而有效避免金融动荡。可见央行的作用不在于判断出存在流动性过剩后采取何种对策,而是时刻相机调整流动性供给,旨在通过以警示和诱导改变公众预期的方法来有效地预先防止资产泡沫出现。
     本文通过向量自回归模型(VAR)详细分析了对代表流动性的M1、金融机构贷款总额;代表通胀情况的CPI、PPI;代表资产价格的上证指数SHI、中房综合景气指数ZEI等六个变量,辨明各变量之间的相关性和Granger因果关系。单位根检验显示六个水平变量之间没有明显的协整关系,但每个变量都是一阶单整I(1),说明取差分之后的变量变得平稳,变量之间出现了稳定的协整关系。六变量之间的Granger因果关系分析表明:房产指数与金融机构信贷总量及M1都有双向因果关系,上证指数和M1也有双向因果关系,这就意味着货币供给和信贷规模都与股市和房地产等资产价格有很大的相关性。M1和房产景气指数领先于CPI,意味着资产价格膨胀最终会通过刺激需求引致通胀加剧。
     计量结果表明,货币供给、信贷总额、资产价格、通胀指标之间存在着复杂的单向和双向关系,所以文章认为试图通过控制单一货币政策中介目标来避免“流动性过剩”和“流动性黑洞”,确保资产价格不背离其基础价值似乎是个无法完成的任务,因为人们至今未能给出一个判断资产价格泡沫的恰当标准,更不用说通过政策变量来控制泡沫了。所以盯紧和控制多个货币政策中介目标,相机抉择调控流动性供给不失为现阶段我国中央银行的理性选择。
     当经济紧缩时中央银行应及时注入流动性,经济过热危及金融稳定时相机运用利率杠杆和控制信贷规模和货币供给。从计量结果我们发现,M1、信贷总量都与资产价格高度相关,货币投放超量和金融过度支持都会使流动性过剩,继而引发资产泡沫形成。因此现阶段对货币供应量的控制仍然十分必要,同时也要盯紧金融机构的信贷量。既然货币政策的真正作用在于晴雨表式的引导和未雨绸缪的预警和威慑,那么中央银行最需要维护的就是自身信誉和政策执行效率。
In the 1930’s the market economic countries, which advocate“invisible hands”encountered with a severe economic crisis. When recovered from this recession, the Keynesianism, which emphasizes on government interventions, has become the mainstream after rethink profoundly on government’s function upon the market economics. Meanwhile, economists were assuming, could the crisis be avoided if the government had applied some monetary policy before the crisis, or could the damage be reduced and recovery speeded up if the government had taken some more immediate action after the collapse down.
     If the major concern of the Great Depression was lack of“liquidity or short in demand”, the financial crisis in Japanese and South-east Asia occurred in the 1990s’was a result of“excessive liquidity”. Also, the United States which suffers from the financial crisis is also a victim of continuous expansion and final burst of asset bubbles due to the liquidity excess.
     When we analyze the above financial turbulence, we can easily find out the background of the crisis is always the economic imbalance during the economic globalization. The thread of the financial turbulence is always the“liquidity”and“asset bubbles”. Therefore, the author is trying to discover the relationship among economic imbalance, liquidity and asset price as well as which kind of Monetary Policy the central bank takes is more helpful to prevent the crisis and promote recovery from the economic crisis.
     Insufficient consuming and excessive saving has become the internal factor for China’s economic imbalance, so as the irrational international industry separation system as the external factor. This internal and external imbalance will affect the financial security of China’s economic system.
     How to deal with the liquidity has become the main thread of this essay. First of all, the essay defines liquidity and excess liquidity, conclude that the excess liquidity is hard to quantify neither in theory nor in practice. The reason is that: Since no one can predict the exact risk and return of assets in long-term under the natural sense of greed and dread, the central banks are also hard to make quick decisions. When finally the excess liquidity is determined by the central bank, long-term investment may have been overheated and formed a lot of asset bubbles. It would be too late for central banks to make decisions whether to eliminate the bubbles. After all, what can be done for the central banks to stabilize the finance market? The author believe that central bank should focus themselves more on their own liquidity supply, focus on the relationship between asset term adjustment, finance stability and liquidity supply. Whenever abnormal long and short term asset turnover shows up, central banks should make take good control over various monetary tools like interest rate, currency supply to influence the public expectation in order to restrain excessive speculation and avoid financial turbulence. From the above mentioned, it can be conclude that: The central bank should not take action until the excess liquidity is judged, but modify the liquidity supply from time to time, in order to warn and lead the public expectation and thus avoid the form of asset bubbles.
     By using the vector auto regression model(VAR), the essay analyzes the following 6 variables and identifies their correlation Granger cause relation. M1 and total loans of financial institutions, which stands for the liquidity; CPI and PPI, which stands for inflation; Shanghai Security Index (SHI), which stands for asset prices; China housing Index (ZEI)
     The Unit root test of stationarity shows that every variable is first-order cointegration I(1), it becomes stationary after difference process. There exists a stationery cointegration relationship between each variable. While the Granger cause relation analysis shows that the China housing Index (ZEI) has two way Granger cause relationship with total loans of financial institutions and M1; the Shanghai Security Index (SHI) also has two way Granger cause relationship M1. This result shows that the monetary supply and total loan amount has great correlation with asset prices such as stock price and housing price. The M1 and housing index are leading the CPI, which means the raise of asset prices will stimulate consuming and at last cause the deepening of inflation.
     The Econometric method shows that, there is a complex one-way or two-way relationship among variables of monetary supply, total loan amount, asset price and inflation. Thus, author believes it is impossible to avoid“excessive liquidity”and“liquidity black holes”as well as maintain asset price stable by controlling a single monetary policy intermediate goal. Up to now, we can yet judge an appropriate level of asset bubbles, not to say controlling of them. Therefore, by taking into considerate a number of monetary policy intermediate goals and control accordingly has become the rational choice of China’s Central Bank.
     When economy is moving towards recession, the central bank should provide adequate liquidity, while the economy is heated or stable, the central bank should tighten the monetary supply by controlling loan amount as well as using the interest rate leverage. The Econometric method shows the M1 and total loan amount are highly related with asset bubbles, while the excessive monetary supply and financial support will lead to excessive liquidity and thus cause asset bubbles. Therefore, it is of great significance to control monetary supply and keep an eye on loan amount of financial institutions. Since the real effect of monetary policy is to guide or warn the market, thus the credibility and efficiency has currently become what central bank need to maintain most.
引文
1刘春航、张新,“繁华预期”、流动性变化和资产价格,金融研究,2007.6.
    2朱一鸿,我国流动性过剩问题的根源及治理对策评价,宁波大学学报,2008.1.
    
    1后格林斯潘时代的美联储货币政策展望,经济科学出版社,2008.9:P122~124
    1姜波克,国际金融新论,复旦大学出版社,1997.12:P72
    1姜波克,国际金融学,高等教育出版社,1999.8:P202~215
    1“Excesss liquidity”refers to a positive deviation of the actual money stock,while a“liquidity shortfall”is a negative deviation ECB MB(Europeon Central bank,Monthly Bulletion),May 2001.
    1张勇,《论中国货币政策传导机制的不确定性》,2006.11,P122-123.
    1 [英]克里斯·布鲁克斯(Chris Brooks )金融计量经济学导论,西南财经大学出版社,2005.6,P347
    1金德尔伯格:《经济过热、经济恐慌及经济崩演—金融危机史》,北京大学出版社,2001年版:P23、P63。
    1成家军,资产价格与货币政策,社会科学文献出版社,2004.12:P155~158,部分数据经整理。
    1向松祚、邵智宾,伯南克的货币理论和政策哲学,北京大学出版社,2008.1:P250
    [1] Allen.F·and D·Gale.(2000).“Bubbles and Crises.”The Economic Journal.January.
    [2] Alchain.1973.“On a Correct Measure of Inflation”.Journal of Money.Credit and Banking.Vol5:173-91.
    [3] Allen.F·(2002).Understanding Financial Crises.Course Note.NYU.
    [4]Arminio Fraga , AndréMinella , Iian Goldfain . 2003 October . NBER working paper No.w10019.“Inflation targeting in emerging market economies”.
    [5] Benartzi,S.Excessive extrapolation and the allocation of 401(k)accounts to company stock.Journal of Finance,2001,56(5):1747-1764.
    [6] Banerjee,A.A Simple Model of Herd Behavior.Quarterly Journal of Economics,1992,107(3):797-817.
    [7] Bernanke.Ben S.Mark Gertler.and Simon Gilchrist.1996.The Financial Accelerator and the Flight to Qualit.Review of Economics and Statistics. vol.78.No 1.February:1-15.
    [8] Bernanke.Ben S. Mark Gertler.and Simon Gilchrist.The Financial Accelerator in a Quantitative Business Cycle Framework.in J.B.Taylor and M.Woodford.eds.Handbook of Macroeconomics.Amsterdam:North-Holland.
    [9] Bernanke.B.M.Gertler.1983.“Non-Monetary Effects of the Financial Crisis in the Propagation of the Great Depression”.American Economic Review.Vol.73.No.3.June.
    [10] Bernanke.B.M.Gertler and S.Gilchrist.1996.“The Financial Accelerator and Flight to Quality”.The Review of Economics and Statistic Vol.78. [11 ] Bernanke.B.and M.Gertler.1999.“Monetary Policy and Asset Prices Volatility”.Economic Review.4thQuarter.Fed of Kansas.
    [12] Bernanke B.and Mark Gertler.1999:“Monetary Policy and As-set Price Volatility”NBER Working Paper[R].59-61.
    [13]Blanchard . O , Backward and Forward Solution for Economics with Rational Expectations.American Economic Review,Papers and Proceedings,1979,(69):114-118.
    [14] Blanchard. O,Speculative Bubbles,Crashes and Rational Expectations.Economic.Letters,1979,3(4):387-389.
    [15] Camerer,Colin.Bubbles and Fads in Asset Prices.Journal of Economic Surveys,1989,3(1):3-41.
    [16] Camerer,Colin.Market Efficiency of Bubbles.Journal of Psychology and Financial Markets,2002,3(1):29-36. [17 ] Campbell.J·(2000).“Asset Pricing at the Millennium”.the Journal of Finance.Vol·LV(4).
    [18] Capie.F.and G.Wood.1997.Asset Prices and Real Economy.Macmillan Press.[ ] [19 ] Coley.T,1999,“Should the Fed Take Deliberate Steps to Defeat Asset Bubbles”. FRBSF. Economic Review.No.1.
    [20] Coval,J.D,Moskowitz,T.J.The geography of investment:informed trading and asset prices,Journal of Political Economy,2001,109(4):811-841.
    [21] De Long J·A·Shleifer.L·Summers. and M·Waldman.(1990).Noise Trader Risk in Financial Markets.Journal of Political Economy.98.
    [22] De Long,J.Bradford,Andrei Shleifer.The Stock Market Bubble of 1929:Evidence from Closed-end Mutual Funds.Journal of Economic History,1991,51(3):675-700.
    [23] Diba,B.H.Grossman.Rational Inflationary Bubbles.Journal of Monetary Economics,1998,21(1):35-46.
    [24] Diba,B,H,Grossman.The Theory of Rational Bubbles in Stock Prices.Economic Journal,1988,98(392):746-754.
    [25] Dupor, Bill 2001 Investment and Interest Rate Policy Journal of Economic Theory 98,85-113.
    [26] Feldstein,Martin 1996 The Costs and Benefits of Going from Low Inflation to Price Stability NBER WP5469.
    [27] Field,Alexander J.1984 Asset Exchanges and the Transactions Demand for Money, 1919-29 American Economic Review Vo1.74 No.1.
    [28] Fisher.L.The Debt-Deflation Theory of Great Depression.1993(1) .
    [29] Fisher.I.1933“The Debt-Deflation Theory of Great Depression”.Econometrica.Nol.1.
    [30] Frederic S. Mishkin. 2004 July. NBER working paper 10646.“Can inflation targeting work in emerging market countries?”
    [31] Friedman,B.1990 Targets and Instruments of Monetary Policy in Handbook of Monetary Economics.Vol II ed.B.M.Friedman and F.H.Hahn North-Holland.
    [32] Friedman.B. the Role of Judgment and Discretion in the Conduct of Monetary Policy:Consequences of Changing Financial Markets. MBER WP 1993.
    [33] Galbraith.J·(1988).The Great Crash:1929.Houghton Mifflin Company.Boston.
    [34] Garber,Peter.M.Famous First Bubbles.The Journal of Economic Perspectives,1990,4(2):35-54.
    [35] Gay,Gerald,Jayant Kale,Robert Kolb,Thomas Noe.Fads in Asset Price:Evidence from the Future Market.Journal of Futures Markets,1994,(14):637-659.
    [36] Goodhart.C.the implication of Shifting Frontiers in Financial Market.In the Central Bank and the Financial System.MIT Press.1995a.
    [37] Goodhart.C.Financial Globalization.Derivatives.Volatility.and the Challenge for the Policiesof Central Banks. in Monetary Policy in an Integrated World Economy.ed.by H.Siebert.institute Welt wirts chaff and er University Kie1.1995c.
    [38] Goodhart.C.Price Stability and Financial Fragility.in the Central Bank and the Financial System.MIT Press.1995.6.
    [39] Garber.P·(1989). Tulipmania.Journal of Political Economy.97(3).
    [40] Garber,Peter.,M.Famous First Bubbles.The Journal of Economic Perspectives,1990,4(2):35-54.
    [41] Garber.P·(1990). Famous First Bubbles.Journal of Economic Perspectives.4(2).
    [42] Gerlach,S.,Svensson,L.E.O.(2003).Money and Inflation in the Euro zero:A case for Monetary Indictors?Journal of Monetary Economics 50,1649-1670.
    [43] Goodhart.C.1995b.“Financial Globalization.Derivatives.Volatility.and the Challenge for the Policies of Central Banks”.in Monetary Policy an Integrated World Economy.ed.by H.Sibert. Institute Welt wirts chaff an der Universitat Kie.
    [44] Granger C.W.J.,Swanson N.R.An Introduction to Stochastic Unit-root Processes.Journal of Econometrics,1997,80(1):35-62.
    [45] Granger,C,N.Swanson.An Introduction to Stochastic Unit Root Process..Journal of Econometrics,1997,80(1):35-62.
    [46]Greenspan.A. New Challenges for Monetary Policy. opening remarks at a Symposium.Fed of Kansas city.1999.
    [47]Grinblatt,M,Keloharju,M.How distance,language and culture influence stock holdings and trades.Journal of Finance,2001,56(3):1053-1073.
    [48]Grinblatt.M,Keloharju.M.What makes investors trade? Journal of Finance.2001,56(2):589-616.
    [49]Grossman,Sanford J.,Joseph E,Stiglitz.On the Impossibility of Informational Efficient Markets.American Economic Review,1980,70(3),393-408.
    [50]Grossman,Sanford J.On the Efficiency of Competitive Stock Markets Where Traders Have Diverse Information.Journal of Finance,1976,31(2):573-585.
    [51] Hallman,J.J.,Porter ,R.D.,Small,D.H.(1991),Is the Price Level Tide to the M2 Monetary Aggregate in the Long run?American Economic Review,Vol.81,No.4:841-858.
    [52] Hayes,R.M.The Impact of Trading Commission Incentives on Analysts’Stock Coverage Decisions and Earnings Forecast.Journal of Accounting Research,1998,36(2):299-320.
    [53] IM.Asset Prices and the Business Cycle. World Economic Outlook.Chp3.April.2000.
    [54] IMF.2000.“Asset Prices and the Business Cycle”.World Economic Outlook.Chp3.April.
    [55] John Taylor Discretion versus Policy Rules in Practice[C].Carnegie-Roeheste.Conference Series on Public Policy.December 1993.39:195-214.
    [56] Jonung.L.and J·tymne.The Great Regime Shift: Asset Markets and Economic Activity in Sweden. 1985-93. in Asset Prices and Real Economy. Ed By Capio & Wood. Macmillan Press.
    [57] Joseph E.Stiglitz.Symposium on Bubbles.The Journal of economic Perspectives,1990,4(2):13-18.
    [58] Karl E.Case,Robert J.Shiller[J].Is There a Bubble in the Housing Market?An Analysis[J].Prepared for the Brookings Panel on Economic Activity,2003,(9):4-5.
    [59] Kent.C.and P.Lowe.1997.“Asset-price Bubbles and Monetary Policy”.Research Discussion Paper.No.9707.Reserve Bank of Australia.
    [60] Kent Daniel,David Hirshleifer,Siew Hong Teoh.Investor psychology in capital markets:evidence and policy implications.Journal of Monetary Economics,2002,49(1):139–209.
    [61]Kindberg.C.(1996) .Manias.Panics and Crashes-a History of Financial Crises.3rd·Macmillan Ltd.
    [62] Lars E.O.Stvensson.Inflation Targeting as a Monetary Policy Rule.Journal of Monetary Economics,43(1999).
    [63] Lim.T.Rationality and Analysts’Forecast Bias[J].Journal of Finance,2001,56(1):369-385.
    [64] Lippman,&McCall,1986,An Operational Measure of Liquidity.American Economic Review.Vol.76,No.1:43-55.
    [65] Lo,Andrew W.,A.Craig MacKinla.Stock Market Prices do not Follow Random Walks:Evidence from a Simple Specification Test.Review of Financial Studies,1988,1(1):41-66.
    [66] Ludvigson.S.and C.Steindel.1999.“How Important Is the Stock Market Effect on Consumption?”.Economic Policy Review.Vol.5.No.July.fed of NewYork.
    [67] Matsumoto,D[J].Management’s incentives to avoid negative earnings surprises[J].The Accounting Review,2002,77(3):483-514.
    [68] Meltzer.Allen H(1995).Money.Credit(and Other)Transmission Processes:A Monetarist Perspective.The Journal of Economic Perspective 4:49-72.
    [69] Michael D.Bordo.Olivier Jeanne.2002 June.NBER working paper 8966.“Boom-bust in asset prices. economic instability.and monetary policy”.
    [70] Minsky.H·(1992).The Financial Instability Hypothesis.WP74.The Jerome Levy Economics Institute of Bard College.
    [71]“Monopoly Power over Money”[J]The Economics .November20 .1999:141-142.[ ]
    [72] Noreus.M.1999.The Swedish Banking Crisis:A Regulatory Perspective.DEEP.[ ]
    [73] Olivier J.Blanchard,Stanley Fischer.Lectures on Macroeconomics.London:The MIT Press,1989,213-244.
    [74] Patel,Jayendu,Rechard Zeckhanser,and Darry Hendricks.The Rationality Struggle:Illustrations from Finaneial Markets,American Economic Review81.1991:232-236.
    [75] Phelps,E,1961,TheGolden Rule of Accumulation,American Economic Review,Vol 51:638-643.
    [76] Pindyek,R.1984.Risk Inflation and the Stock Market,American Economic Review.Vol74,335-346.
    [77] Polleit,Thorsten and Dieter Gerdesmeier,2005.Measures of Excess liquitdy.HfB-Business School of Finance & Management Working Paper No.65.
    [78] Robert Mundell.The Theory of optimum Currency Areas[J] .American Economic Review, 51,September1961:717-725.
    [79] Shiller,Robert J.Discussion[of Mankiw,Romer,and Shapiro(1985)].Journal of Finance,1985,(40):688-689.
    [80]Summers,Lawrence H.Does the Stock Market Rationally Reflect Fundamental Values?.Journal of Finance,1986,41(3):591-601.
    [81] Sylvain Gouteron and Daniel Szpiro,2005.Excess Monetary Liquidity and Asset Prices.[ ]
    [82] Tirole,J.Asset Bubbles and Overlapping Generations.Econometrica,1985,53(6):1499-1528.
    [83] Tirole,J.On the Possibility of Speculation under Rational Expectations.Econometrica,1982,50(5):1163-1181.
    [84] Tsang Shui-Ki.2001.“Inflation Targeting in China?”working paper submitted to Conference on Monetary and Financial Issues in Asia.
    [85] Walsh,C.E.,Monetary theory and Policy,the MIT Press,1998
    [86] White. E.(1990a). Crashes and Panics: The Lessons From History. Dow Jones-Irwin.
    [87]Wilson,J.,R.SyllaandC.Jones(1990),“Finaneial Market Paniesand Volatility in the Long Run,1830~1988”,in Crashes and Panies editedby E.White,Illinois:Dow-JonesIrwin:85-125.
    [88] Wolff,EdwardN.,Recent Trend sin the Size Distribution of Househol Wealth[J]Journal of Eeonomic Perspeetives 1998.12(3)131-50.
    [89] Xia Bin and Liao Qiang. 2001.“Monetary supply is no more suit-able to be taken as an intermediary goal of monetary policy in pre-sent China”. Economic Research Journal.Aug.
    [90]包祖明.中国货币供应规划及其方法研究[M] .东北财经大学出版社,2004.5:174-177.
    [91]巴曙松.中国货币政策有效性的经济学分析[M].北京:经济科学出版社,2000:21-45.
    [92]本杰明-M-弗里德曼.弗兰克-H-哈恩.货币经济学手册[M].北京:经济科学出版社.2002.
    [93]蔡辉明,金融加速器与中国经济波动,[D],北京,北京大学中国经济研究中心,2004,7.
    [94] [美]查理斯J.P.金德尔伯格.经济过热、经济恐慌及经济崩溃——金融危机史[M].朱隽等译[J].第1版.北京:北京大学出版社,2000:275.
    [95]陈南光,徐之强.资产价格与中央银行政策[D] .中央银行季刊,2002,24(1):28-36.
    [96]陈飞,赵听东,高铁梅.我国货币政策工具变量效应的实证分析[J].金融研究,2002,(10):25-30.
    [97]陈蓉.资本市场的货币政策效应[M].上海财经大学出版社,2003.9:145-147.
    [98]陈守东,王鲁非.VAR与其他风险度量指标的比较.21世纪数量经济学[C] .汪同三,张守一,吴承业.中国金融出版社.2003.6:324-328.
    [99]高铁梅.计量经济分析方法与建模[M].清华大学出版社.2006.1.
    [100]宫崎义一.泡沫经济的经济对策[M].北京:中国人民大学出版社.2000.
    [101]苟文均.资本市场的发展与货币政策的变革[D].中国社会科学院财贸经济研究所博士后研究报告.2000.
    [102]黄达.宏观调控与货币供给[M].北京:中国人民大学出版社.1999.
    [103]胡海鸥.货币理论与货币政策[M].上海:上海人民出版社.2004.10.
    [104]黄昌利,任若恩.我国(1996~2003年)货币政策低效性及原因分析[J].中国管理科学, 2004,12(3):38-43.
    [105]黄孝武.略论西方资产价格泡沫理论研究的两种趋向[J]国外社会科学,2005,(1):24-30.
    [106]黄强.货币政策与中国经济增长[M].西安:陕西人民出版社,1994.272-280.
    [107]侯慧君,我国金融信用的缺失与监管问题研究[J] .上海金融.2006(8):36-37.
    [108]姜波克.开放经济下的政策搭配[M].上海:复旦大学出版社,1999:20-27.
    [109]匡小平.开放经济下的财政货币政策协调简论[M].北京:中国财政经济出版社,2002.3-31.
    [110]李斌.中国货币政策有效性的实证研究[]J.金融研究.2001,(7):11-17.
    [111]李方.金融泡沫论.第1版[J].上海:立信会计出版社,1998,11-39.
    [112]李木祥.中国房地产泡沫研究[M].中国金融出版社.2007.4.
    [113]李善民,欧阳桃花.财政与税收[M].广州中山大学出版社,2000.12-16.
    [114]李文博主编.中国宏观经济分析与预测(2007年)——全球化背景下的中国流动性过剩[M].经济科学出版社.2008.5:41-47.
    [115]李玉萍.货币供应量作为货币政策中间目标的终结.生产力研究.2005.2.
    [116]李元媛,肖冬荣,赵妍.混沌理论在股票市场分析上的应用[J].微计算机信息,2006,(9):148-150.
    [117]刘鸿儒.总结经验,探索规律[J]金融研究.98,(5):109.
    [118]刘溶沧.中国财政政策货币政策理论与实践[M].北京:中国金融出版社,2001.121-150.
    [119]刘溶沧,杨之刚.财政学论纲[M].北京:经济科学出版社,1998.437-476.
    [120]连建辉,翁洪琴.银行流动性过剩--当前金融运行中面临的突出问题[J]财经科学.2006
    [121]蒙丽珍,李星华..财政与金融[M].大连:东北财经大学出版社2001.5-8.
    [122]米建国,宋光茂.财政政策与货币政策协调配合的问题及对策[]J.管理世界,1996(5):23-28.
    [123]钱小安.资产价格变化对货币政策的影响[J].经济研究.1998(1).
    [124]钱小安.中国货币政策的形成和发展[M].上海:上海人民出版社2000.
    [125]瞿强.通货紧缩:理论与历史.中国人民大学金融与证券研究所工作论文.2000(1).
    [126]瞿强(2001).“资产价格与货币政策”[J].《经济研究》.2001.7.
    [127]苏平贵.汇率制度选择与货币政策效应分析——蒙代尔—弗莱明模型在我国的适用性、改进及应用[J].国际金融研究.2003.5.
    [128]孙漩.我国财政政策的效应评价[J].财会研究,2004(9):8-10.
    [129]唐旭.论稳健的货币政策[N].人民日报(理论版),2005-4-15(5).
    [130]王广谦.中央银行学[M].北京:高等教育出版社,2000:218-223.
    [131]王建.中国货币流动性的过剩之迷[J].中国金融.2007.3.
    [132]王煌.中国货币政策趋势[M].北京:中国金融出版社,2000.2.
    [133]王树清.缓解流动性过剩须标本兼治[N].上海证券报.2007-03-21.
    [134]王振营.资产价格对货币政策目标的影响仁.中国货币市场[J].2004(3):13-15.
    [135]王志强.我国金融政策时滞测算[J]预测.2000,(3):41-44、48.
    [136]王少平,李子奈.我国货币需求的协整分析及其货币政策建议[J] .经济研究.2004.7:38-39.
    [137]翁邦雄、白川方明、白冢重典.2000.“资产价格泡沫与金融政策:1980年代后期日本的经验与教训”.《金融研究》.日本银行金融研究所.No12.
    [138]吴军.稳健货币政策的理论思考[J] .金融研究,2002(1):12-19.
    [139]夏南新.基于分形R/S技术的中国股市非规则周期性研究[J].统计研究,2006.(2):28-31.
    [140]小川一夫·北坂真一.1998.《资产市场与景气变动》.日本经济评论社.
    [141]谢平,罗雄.泰勒规则及其在中国货币政策中的检验[J] [J].经济研究[J].2002(3):3-12.
    [142]谢平,焦瑾璞.中国货币政策争论[M].北京:中国金融出版社,2002.1-18.
    [143]谢平.新世纪中国货币政策的挑战[J]金融研究,2001,(1):1-10.
    [144]徐龙炳.货币政策效果的度量—中国货币政策效果的定量评价[M]上海:复旦大学出版社,
    [145]姚长辉.货币银行学[M].北京:北京大学出版社,2001:120-121.
    [146]易定红.美联储实施货币政策的经验及其借鉴意义[M] .北京:中国人民大学出版社,2004.1:253-255.
    [147]易刚.中国货币政策走向间接调控[M].资本市场杂志,1999,(10):6-11.
    [148]余永定.中国双顺差根源:根源及对策[J] .中国金融.2006(19):25.
    [149]余明.资产价格、金融稳定与货币政策[M].中国金融出版社.2003.10.
    [150]于洪波.中国资本市场发展中的货币政策抉择.东北财经大学出版社.2004.1:78-83.
    [151]于俊年.计量经济学软件—EViews的使用[M].对外经济贸易大学出版社.2006.5.
    [152]袁志刚,樊潇彦.房地产市场理性泡沫分析[J] .经济研究.2003,(3):34.
    [153] [日]野口悠纪雄.泡沫经济学[M].曾寅初译.第1版.北京:生活.读书.新知三联书店,2005:59.
    [154]张锐.非均衡增长的全球经济[M.北京:中国社会科学出版社.2007.7.
    [155]张馨.比较财政学[M] .北京:中国人民大学出版社,2004.287-304.
    [156]张晓峒.计量经济学软件Eviews使用指南[M].天津:南开大学出版社,2003.8-32.
    [157]张雪春.流动性过剩余:现状分析与对策建议[J] .金融研究,2007(8):10-12.
    [158]张晓蓉.资产价格泡沫[D] .上海:复旦大学,2004:64.
    [159]赵华,潘长风,在协整分析中如何处理截距和趋势[J]数量经济技术经济研究,2004,(1):106-109.
    [160]张勇.论中国货币政策传导机制的不确定性[M].人民出版社2006.11.
    [161]周春生,杨云红.中国股市的理性泡沫[J]经济研究.2002,(7):33-40.
    [162]周英章,蒋振声.货币渠道、信用渠道与货币政策有效性的实证分析[D]金融研究,2002, (9):34-43.
    [163]郑伟.有效市场、混沌市场与经典投资流派及其投资战略[J] .国际金融研究,2000,(9):72-75.
    [164]朱庆.解读当前市场流动性过剩.[J]上海经济研究,2006(1):13. [165 ]邹新.世界流动性过剩挥之不去[J] .银行家.2006(9):66-68. [166 ]左小蕾.调整结构方能治本[J].了望.2007(15).

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700