中国房地产价格周期波动与成因研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
20世纪80年代以来,全球房地产市场接连发生了膨胀与紧缩的巨大波动。我国房地产市场以1987年为起点,1998年才完全实现市场化分配,短短的二十几年间房价在波动中急剧膨胀。尤其是2003年以后,大部分城市房价持续高涨,引发了对房地产泡沫的巨大争论。2008年国际金融危机前后,房价短期经历了大涨大跌的剧烈波动,与之相伴随的是对房地产价格一系列调控政策的出台。从一些发达国家的历史经验来看,房价的波动给宏观经济稳定带来了巨大的威胁,甚至导致了长时间经济萧条,这对市场调控与监管提出更高的要求。我国的市场调控经验表明,仅仅使用货币政策的市场效果不明显,不得不采取直接行政干预措施。而这些措施的合理性一直是理论界争论不休的问题。
     论文通过房地产价格周期测度与解读、与国外房地产周期比较、分析房地产周期与宏观经济、股市周期和通货膨胀周期的关系,对房地产价格周期波动特征做出具体的刻画,归纳了关于房价周期波动特征的典型事实。结果表明,我国房价周期波动频率高、波动幅度大。房价中期具有上涨刚性,不存在明显的中周期。房价周期、消费物价周期和股价周期之间存在一定的领先滞后关系。在宏观经济中的行业定位、政策导向与房价之间也存在显著的相关性。
     论文分析了我国房价周期增长和波动的成因。房地产价格的持续上涨主要受到体制创新、经济增长、工业化和城市化进程、流动性过剩几方面因素的影响。
     基于房地产定价模型,论文提出实现房价周期波动的三个假设:假设一:消费者根据房地产市场价格和理论价格之间的权衡进行购房决策,市场价格与理论价格之间存在互动关系,导致房价周期性波动;假设二:信贷的扩张与紧缩对房地产业与非房地产业投资的影响产生周期波动;假设三:金融自由化进程中伴随着增长过快的货币供给,加速了房价上涨趋势,也为市场带来不确定性。
     从实证结果来看,利率变化对房价的影响很小,无法与理论分析相一致,房价周期波动的利率调整机制失灵;银行信贷与价格周期存在稳定的一致性,银行信贷对价格周期的影响小于货币供给。货币供给弹性在1998年最高,到2005年达到最低值,2005年以后货币供给对房价增长的推动作用增强。货币供给对价格的影响大于对投资的影响,说明资金通过房地产开发投资之外的途径直接对价格产生影响。
     本文认为,1998年以前,市场环境不稳定是周期波动频繁的主要原因;1999年至2005年利率稳定、供求关系平衡,市场处于短暂的过渡期;2005年以后房价周期波动频繁而剧烈,周期表现出明显的外生性,论文重点分析了这个阶段房价周期的原因。
     2005年以后,购房者购房动机发生了由居住到投资的转变,对于市场行为的解释需要突破房地产供给需求局部均衡的框架,在与宏观经济结构相关的一般均衡框架内分析。在低利率的条件下,购房者具有强烈的购房动机,房价具有上涨刚性,由市场价格与理论价格之间动态变化形成的价格周期性下行的机制无法实现;利率失灵加剧了实体经济和房地产价格趋势的背离,使房地产与实体经济的结构性失衡恶化,二者之间相对价格的变化机制无法实现;中国特色的货币政策传导渠道使房价周期产生强烈的政策性或者外生性,在房价上涨阶段银行自主信贷约束动机弱化,房价周期无法以银行信用自住紧缩为内在机制形成;2005年以后的价格波动频繁,是由于在利率失灵条件下,房价变化对利率的弹性减少,对广义货币量的弹性增加,市场稳定性降低,价格容易受到流动性冲击。
     房价在缺乏利率弹性前提下的上涨产生两个重要的后果:首先导致无房者的福利相对下降;其次是银行风险积累。
     论文回顾和评价了房地产市场调控的历程。低利率和流动性问题外生于房地产行业,与货币政策和宏观经济环境密切联系,却成为影响房价正常波动的重要的内在原因。在这样的情况下,如果仅仅着眼于针对房地产行业的局部调控,问题根本却出在经济全局,短期行政措施也难以产生长期持续的效果。在现阶段,稳定预期是主要的房地产调控政策。对房地产周期波动,主要控制由于银行信贷带来的金融风险。
     最后提出主要结论和政策建议。长期而言,构建具有合理定价机制的房地产市场是我国房地产业发展的必然选择,制度建设是长期稳定发展的基础。提出推进金融体系改革和利率市场化、发展和完善房地产市场、增加金融供给稳定长期投资、推进房产税改革等几个方面的政策含义。
Since the1980s, the global real estate market has been a spate of large fluctuations of theexpansion and contraction. China's real estate market started in1987and finished themarket-oriented distribution in1998. In a short period of twenty years house prices expandedrapidly in the fluctuations. Especially after2003, most urban housing prices continued to rise,triggering a huge debate on the real estate bubble. During the2008financial crisis, pricesexperienced short-term volatility fluctuation,in hand with a series of regulatory policies on realestate prices in China. From the historical experience of some developed countries, the volatility ofhouse prices brought about a huge threat to macroeconomic stability and even leaded to a prolongedrecession. This put higher demands on market regulation and supervision. China's experience inmarket regulation shows that the effect of mere use of monetary policy on the market is not obvious.The government had to take direct administrative interventions. The rationality of these measureshas been the vexed issue of the theoretical circle.
     Focusing on China's real Prices estate cycle, the thesis analyzes the theoretical and empiricalintrinsic links between these phenomena.
     The thesis measured and interpretated the real estate price cycles, compared with foreign realestate cycle, analyzed the relationship between real estate cycle, macroeconomic, stock marketcycles and inflation cycle, made specific characterization of the characteristics of fluctuations in thereal estate price cycles, summarized typical facts on the characteristics of price cycles fluctuations.The results show that China's housing prices have high frequency of cyclical fluctuations. Pricesrises rigidly, the mid-cycle does not exist., There are leading and lag relationships between the Pricecycles, consumer price cycles and the stock price cycles. There is a significant correlation betweenthe positioning of the real estate in the macroeconomic policy and prices.
     The paper analyzes the causes of growth and volatility of China's housing prices cycle. Realestate prices continue to rise by institutional innovation, economic growth, industrialization andurbanization, excess liquidity factors. The paper established a general equilibrium-cycle model withconsumption habit formation and capital adjustment costs, explained that the price fluctuations arecaused by the mechanism of micro-investment and consumer behavior. Higher real estateconsumption habit formation makes the representative family transforms smaller fluctuations of themarginal utility of real estate into larger price fluctuations. Due to the presence of adjustment costs,investment fluctuations lead to price fluctuations. When the total output changes, the representationfamily tends to change it into the variation in investment rather than current consumption changes.
     Interest rates, credit growth, money supply have an important influence on the fluctuations inthe price cycle. They also lead to cyclical fluctuations of the real estate industry in recent years. On the basis of theoretical analysis, the paper established a varying parameter model to analyze theinteraction between interest rates the credit, investment and money supply and real estate pricecycles in the different stages. From the empirical results, the impact of changes in interest rates onhouse prices is very small. This isn’t consistent with the theoretical analysis. The interest rateadjustment mechanism in prices cycle fluctuations failure. There is a stable consistency betweenbank credit and price cycles. The impact of bank credit to the price cycle is less than the moneysupply. Elasticity of money supply is the highest in1998and reached the lowest value in2005.After2005the money supply played enhanced role in promoting the growth in house prices. Moneysupply’s impact on prices is greater than the impact on investment funds by way outside of the realestate investment.
     Therefore, we believe that our long-term real interest rates are low and this brought strongupward momentum to house prices. Under low interest rates, the bank's real estate allocation ofcredit resources lacks of capital cost constraints. The dynamic adjustment mechanism between thereal estate industry and other industries lack bank credit as an intermediary. The small changes ofinterest rates at a low level make too small changes to investor decisions to make a substantial turnin the market so that fluctuations mechanism in the price cycle can not be achieved. This is why thereal estate regulation adopted direct administrative control measures. If the interest rate under thelong-term control can not reach the equilibrium interest rate where the money supply and demandare equal, the price fluctuations will lose stable base. Price fluctuations after2005is, the results ofthe liquidity shock in the interest rate failure conditions. Currency by resident investments, hotmoney and bank credit channels put impact on the real estate market led to a substantial increasein short-term fluctuations.
     High prices under the lack of interest rate elasticity have two important consequences. First,this led to the welfare of those without housing relatively declined. Due to the price continued torise rapidly with lack of interest rate elasticity, the behavior of buyers lacked the cost constraints,the initial allocation of housing wealth and income-determined housing affordability are the mainconstraints of the housing investment decisions. Rising house prices cycle resulted in the therelative welfare gap between housing and no housing continued to widen. The bank risk isaccumulated. Weakening of the investment cost constraints, the credit risk of banks is difficult toaccurately assess. Once the real interest rates rise, the cost of capital constraints of borrowersstrengthened, the potential risks of the bank exposure and may pose a threat to financial stability.The paper reviewed and evaluated the course of the real estate market regulation. With the lack offlexibility of real estate price changes, the market is in serious lack of stability and vulnerable to theimpact of the potential supply of money under certain conditions. In this context, the response of the real estate market for short-term government intervention is often excessive, The price either rosetoo fast or falled back too excessively. Stable expectation is the main real estate control policyoptions at this stage. With regard to fluctuations in the real estate cycle, the policy should mainlycontrol the financial risks due to bank credit.
     Finally, the paper put forward the main conclusions and policy recommendations. In the longrun, building a real estate market with a reasonable pricing mechanism is the inevitable choice ofChina's real estate development. Institution building is a long-term and stable basis for thedevelopment. We should push forward the development of financial system reform and interest ratemarkets, improve the real estate market, increase the financial supply, stabilize long-terminvestment, and promote property tax reform as the main institution construction measures.
引文
[1]顾建发.上海房地产周期波动分析[M].上海三联书店,2008:10
    [2] Phyrr S., RoulacS.,Born W.L. Real estate cycles and their strategic implications forinvestors and portfolio managers in the global economy[J].Journal of Real Estate Research,1999,18(1):7-68.
    [1] Ramón Adalid,Carsten Detken.Liquidity Shocks and Asset Price Boom/Bust Cycles[R].Working Paper Series, The European central bank2007,2,No.732:78.
    [2] Mitchell, W. C. Business Cycles: The Problem and Its Setting[M]. National Bureau ofEconomic Research, New York,1927
    [3] Burns, A. F. and W. C. Mitchell. Measuring Business Cycles[M]. New York, NationalBureau of Economic Research,1946.
    [4] Dauten, C. A. and L. M. Valentine. Business Cycles and Forecasting[M]. Cincinnati, OH:South-Western Publishing Co.,1974.
    [5] Klein, R. and W. Wolman. The Beat Inflation Strategy[M]. New York, NY: Simon andSchuster,1975.
    [6] Rabinowitz, A. The Real Estate Gamble[M]. New York, NY: AMACOM–A Division of theAmerican Management Association,1980:238.
    [7] Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors (RICS) Report. Understanding the PropertyCycle[R]. Main Report: Economic Cycles and Property Cycles, London: The Royal Institution ofChartered Surveyors, May1994:127.
    [8] Bradford Case, William Goetzmann, K. Geert Rouwenhorst. Global Real Estate Markets--Cycles and Fundamentals[R]. Yale International Center for Finance,Working Paper,1999-03.
    [9] Witkiewicz,W. The use of the HP-filter in constructing real estate cycle indicators[J]. Journalof Real Estate Research,2002,23(1):65-87.
    [10]Pritchett PC.Forecasting the Impact of Real Estate Cycles on Investment[J]. Real EstateReview,1984,13(4):85-89.
    [11]Wheaton CW.The Cyclic Behavior of the National Office Market[J].AreueaJournal,1987,15(4):281-99.
    [12]Witten GR.Riding the Real Esate Cycle[J].Real Estate Today,1987(8):42-28.
    [13]Freneh,K.,J.Poterba.Investor Diversification and Intemational Equity Markets[J]. AmericanEconomic Review,1991(2):222-226.
    [14]Atash,Farhad.Loeal Land Use Regulations in the USA:A Study of Their Impacts onHousing Cost[J].Land Use policy,1999(7):231-242.
    [15]Phyrr,S., Roulac,S.,Born,W.L. Real estate cycles and their strategic implications forinvestors and portfolio managers in the global economy[J].Journal of Real Estate Research,1999,18(1):7-68.
    [16]Hodrick,R.,Prescott,E. Post-war US business cycle: an empirical investigation [R].workingpaper,Carnegie Mellon University,Pittsburgh,PA.1980.
    [17]薛薇.SPSS统计分析及应用[M].北京,电子工业出版社,2004:417.
    [18]Wilson,P.,Okunev,J. Spectral analysis of real estate and financial assets markets[J]. Journalof Property Investment&Finance,1999,17(1):61-74.
    [19]Baen,J.S. Synchronicity and Indexing Theory of Real Estate Cycles: A World PropertyOverview[C].Paper presented at the American Real Estate Society Annual Meeting,SantaBarbara,CA.April14,1994:68-78
    [20]Baen,J.S. Synchronicity and Indexing Theory of Real Estate Cycles: A Proposal for a WorldProperty Index and Standard Data Collection Methodology and Reporting[J].Real Estate FinanceJournal,1996(2):69-79.
    [21]Addae-Dapaah,K.,Choo,B. International diversification of property stock–a Singaporeaninvestor’s viewpoint[J].Real Estate Finance,1996,13(3):54-66.
    [22]Lu,K.,Mei,J. The return distributions of property shares in emerging markets[J].Journal ofReal Estate Portfolio Management,1999,5(2):145-60.
    [23]Liow,K.,Sim,M. The risk and return of Asian real estate stocks[R].workingpaper,Department of Real Estate,National University of Singapore, Singapore.2005:42-65
    [24]Liow,K.,Webb,J. Common factors in international securitized property markets[R].workingpaper,National University of Singapore,Singapore,Cleveland State University, Cleveland, OH.2005:143-157
    [25]Matej Blasko, Joseph F. Sinkey Jr. Bank asset structure, real-estate lending, andrisk-taking[J].The Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance,2006,46(1):53-81
    [26]Barry Falk. Predictable excess returns in real estate markets: A study of farmland values[J].Journal of Housing Economics,1992(2):84-105
    [27]John M. Quigley.Real Estate and the Asian Crisis[J].Journal of Housing Economics,2001(10):129-161
    [28]Kosuke Aoki, James Proudman, Gertjan Vlieghe. House prices, consumption, and monetarypolicy: a financial accelerator approach[J].Journal of Financial Intermediation,2004(13):414-435
    [29]祝晓峰,刘卫江.美国股价泡沫与货币政策——从哈耶克的货币经济周期理论出发的一个解释[J].财经理论与实践,2003(5):56-58
    [30]巴曙松,栾雪剑.经济周期的系统动力学研究[J].系统工程,2009(11):67-78
    [31]Jermann,U. Asset pricing in production economies[J].Journal of Monetary Economics,Elsevier.1998,41(2):257-275
    [32]Cochrane,J. Financial Markets and the Real Economy[Z]. manuscript, University ofChicago.2006:34-56
    [33]Ivan Jaccard. House Prices, Real Estate Returns, and the Business Cycle[R]. Swiss FinanceInstitute Research Paper Series,April9,2007:78-89
    [34]张玉喜.货币与经济周期:理论发展及其评述[J].当代经济研究,2010(5):45-49
    [35]Nelson,E. The Future of Monetary Aggregates in Monetary Policy Analysis[J]. Journal ofMonetary Economics,2003(50):1048
    [36]Bernanke,B.,M. Gertler. Should Central Banks Respond to Movements in AssetPrices?[J].American Economic Review Papers and Proceedings,2001(91):253-257
    [37]Christiano,L.,R.Motto,M.Rostagno.The Great Depression and the Friedman-SchwartzHypothesis[J].Journal of Money Credit and Banking,2003,35(6):1119-1197.
    [38]Allen,F.,D.Gale. Bubbles and Crises[J].The Economic Journal,2000,110(460):236-255.
    [39]Illing,G. Financial Fragility Bubbles and Monetary Policy[R].CESifo WorkingPaper,2001(449):156-167
    [40]Herring,R.,S.Wachter. Bubbles in Real Estate Markets. Asset Price Bubbles: TheImplications for Monetary, Regulatory, and International Policies[M]. MIT Press,2003,Chapter14:217
    [41]Rajan,R. Has Financial Development Made the World Riskier?[R].NBER WorkingPaper,2005,No.11728:127-131
    [42]Rajan,R. Monetary Policy and Incentives[Z].Address given at Central Banks in the21stCentury Conference,Bank of Spain.2006:28-31
    [43]Abraham,J.M.,and P.H.Hendershott.1994.“Bubbles in Metropolitan HousingMarkets.”NBER Working Paper4774:43-59
    [44]Abmed Gala,Omar Razzaz. Reforming Land and Real Estate Markets[R]. The World BankPrivate Provision of Public Services Group Private Sector Advisory Services,June2001:9-15
    [45]Moore, G. H., Business Cycles, Inflation, and Forecasting[M], Second Edition, NationalBureau of Economic Research Studies in Business Cycles, No.24, New York, NY: BallingerPublishingCo.,1983:76-98
    [46]Bertrand Renaud. The1985-94Global Real Estate Cycle[R]. The World Bank FinancialSector Development Department, Policy Research Working Paper,1452,May1995:60-74
    [47]Born, W. L. and S. A. Pyhrr, Real Estate Valuation: The Effect of Market and PropertyCycles[J].The Journal of Real Estate Research,1994,9(4):55–85
    [48]Phyrr, S. A. and W. L. Born. Real Estate Cycles: The Body of Knowledge[C], Paperpresented at the American Real Estate Annual Meeting, Tampa, Florida, April1999:78-81
    [49]Cross Donald,Christine Whitehead. Development and Planning1994[M], U.ofCamnbridge,Departmnent of Land Economy,1994:127
    [50]L. Randall Wray. The Commodities Market Bubble-Money Manager Capitalism and TheFinancialization Of Commodities[R]. Public Policy Brief, The Levy Economics Institute Of BardCollege,2008(96):70-96
    [51]Borio, Claudio, Philip Lowe. Asset Price, Financial and Monetary Stability: Exploring theNexus[R]. Bank of International SettlementsWorking Paper,2002(114):59-67
    [52]White, William R. Making Macroprudential Concerns Operationa[Z]. Speech Delivered atthe Financial Stability Symposium Sponsored by the Netherlands Bank, Amsterdam, October25-26,2004:48-61
    [53]Cecchetti, S., H. Genberg, J. L ipsky, S.W adhwan.i. Asset Prices and Central BankPolicy[R]. Geneva Reports on the World Economy2,2000:109-123
    [54]Bernanke, B., M. Gertler. Monetary Policy and Asset Price Volatility[R]. NBER WorkingPaper,2000,559:1-74
    [55]Kent, Christopher, and Philips Lowe. Asset Price Bubbles and Monetary Policy[R]. ReserveBank of Australia Research Discussion Paper1997(9709):34-67
    [56]Bordo, M.D., and O. Jeanne. Boom-bust in Asset Prices, Economic Instability, andMonetary Policy[R]. NBER Working Paper.2002(8966):21-37
    [57]Gruen, D., M. Plumb, and A. Stone. How Should Monetary Policy Respond to AssetPriceBubbles?[J]. International Journal of Central Banking,2005,1(3):1-31
    [58]Kontonikas, A., C. Ioannidis. Should Monetary Policy Respond to Asset PriceMisalignments[J]. Economic Modelling,2005,22(6):1105-1121.
    [59]Posen, Adam S. Why Central Banks Should Not Burst Bubbles[BD/OL]. Available athttp://www. iie. com/publications/wp/w p06-1. pd.f,2006:35-39
    [60]Kohn, Donald. Monetary Policy and Asset Prices[Z]. Speech Delivered at Monetary Policy:A Journey from Theory to Practice. A European Centra l Bank Colloquium Held in Honor ofOtmar Issing, Frankfurt, March16,2006:76-81
    [61]陈刚.房地产经济周期波动预测与研究[J].中国经贸导刊,2010(2):29-36
    [62]吴璟,刘洪玉.基于灰色-马尔可夫模型的房地产周期研究[J].统计与决策,2009(6):45-61
    [63]张红,谢娜.基于主成分分析与谱分析的房地产市场周期研究[J].清华大学学报(自然科学版),2008,48(9):-109-128
    [64]张晓晶,孙涛.中国房地产周期与金融稳定经济研究[J].Economic Research Journal,2006(01):121-134
    [65]邱强,万海远.我国房地产业的周期运行特征[J].统计与决策,2007(22):78-81
    [66]邱兆祥,王涛.我国房地产经济周期划分研究(1950~2008年)[J].经济研究参考,2009(71):23-28
    [67]梁云芳,高铁梅.中国房地产价格波动区域差异的实证分析[J].经济研究,2007(8):133-142
    [68]崔光灿.房地产价格与宏观经济互动关系实证研究——基于我国31个省份面板数据分析[J].经济理论与经济管理,2009,(1):57
    [69]宋勃,刘建江.房价与地价关系的理论分析与中国经验的实证检验:1998—2007[J].中央财经大学学报,2009,(9):60-66.
    [70]张海蔚.中国房地产价格决定机制研究[J].上海金融,2009,(6):89
    [71]唐志军,徐会军,巴曙松.中国房地产周期波动研究[J].科学决策,2009(6):67-69
    [1] Bertrand Renaud. The1985-94Global Real Estate Cycle[R]. The World Bank FinancialSector Development Department, Policy Research Working Paper,1452, May1995:178-181
    [2] Patrick J.Wilson,John Okunev. Long-Term Dependencies and Long Run Non-PeriodicCo-Cycles:Real Estate and Stock Markets[J].Journal Of Real Estate Research,1999,18(2):257-259.
    [3] Kim Hiang Liow.Cycles and common cycles in real estate markets[J]. International Journalof Managerial Finance,2007,3(3):287-305
    [4] Stephen A.Pyhrr,Stephen E.Roulac,Waldo L.Born. Real Estate Cycles and Their StrategicImplications for Investors and Portfolio Managers in the Global Economy[J]. Journal of RealEstate Research,1999,18(1):14
    [1]罗斯巴德默.美国大萧条[M].上海:上海人民出版社,2009:132-136
    [2] Allen,F.,D.Gale. Bubbles and Crises[J].The Economic Journal,2000,110(460):236-255.
    [3]罗纳德麦金农.经济发展中的货币与资本[M].上海:上海三联书店,1997:67-78
    [4]爱德华肖.经济发展中的金融深化[M].上海:上海三联书店,1988:142-155
    [5] Bertrand Renaud. The1985-94Global Real Estate Cycle[R]. The World Bank FinancialSector Development Department, Policy Research Working Paper,1452,May1995:98-103
    [6]王宋涛,杨薇,吴超林.中国国民总效用函数的构建与估计[J].统计研究,2011,28(4):34
    [1] Shiller, Robert J. Investor Behavior in Stock market crash: Survey Evidence[R].CambridgMeass,National Bureau of Economic Research Working paper, No.2446, November,2005.
    [2] Leamer,E.E. Housing Is the Business Cycle[R].Working Paper No.13428, Washington, D.C.:National Bureau of Economic Research,September,2007.
    [3]宋勃.房地产市场财富效应的理论分析和中国经验的实证检验:1998~2006[J].经济科学,2007(5):41-53.
    [4]王子龙,许箫迪,徐浩然.房地产市场财富效应理论与实证研究[J].财贸经济,2008(12):116-123.
    [5] Alexander Ludwig,Torsten Slk. The Impact of Stock Prices and House Prices onConsumption in OECD Countries[R]. IMF Working Paper,2001.
    [6] Richard J.Herring,Susan Wachter. Real Estate Booms and Banking Busts: An InternationalPerspective[R].The Wharton Financial Institutions Center Working Paper Series,1999-27
    [1] Richard J.Herring,Susan Wachter. Real Estate Booms and Banking Busts: An InternationalPerspective[R].The Wharton Financial Institutions Center Working Paper Series,1999-27
    [1] Abmed Gala,Omar Razzaz. Reforming Land and Real Estate Markets[R]. The World BankPrivate Provision of Public Services Group Private Sector Advisory Services,June2001:9-15.
    [2] Addae-Dapaah,K.,Choo,B. International diversification of property stock–a Singaporeaninvestor’s viewpoint[J].Real Estate Finance,1996,13(3):54-66.
    [3] Alexander Ludwig,Torsten Slk. The Impact of Stock Prices and House Prices onConsumption in OECD Countries[R]. IMF Working Paper,2001:38-42.
    [4] Allen,F.,D.Gale. Bubbles and Crises[J].The Economic Journal,2000,110(460):236-255.
    [5] Armen Albert Alchian, William Richard Allen. Exchange and production: competition,coordination, and control[M]. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth Pub. Co.1964:178-182.
    [7] Arrow.K.J,G..Debreu,MeKenzie.L.W. On the Existence of Equilibrium for A CompetitiveEeonomy[J] Eeonometrica,1954(22):265-290
    [6] Backus,D.K.,P. J. Kehoe. International Evidence on the Historical Properties of BusinessCycles[J],American Economic Review,1992,82(4):64–88.
    [7] Baen,J.S. Synchronicity and Indexing Theory of Real Estate Cycles: A World PropertyOverview[C].Paper presented at the American Real Estate Society Annual Meeting,SantaBarbara,CA.April14,1994:38-55.
    [8] Baen,J.S. Synchronicity and Indexing Theory of Real Estate Cycles: A Proposal for a WorldProperty Index and Standard Data Collection Methodology and Reporting[J].Real EstateFinance Journal,1996(2):69-79.
    [9] Bario,D. Skadden Lawyer Delves Into the “Dark Pools” of the Oil Boom [BD/OL].June19,2008,http://www.law.com/jsp/LawArticleFriendlyjsp?id=1202422384461.
    [10]Baxter M.,Crucini M. Explaining Saving-Investment Correlations[J].The AmericanEconomic Review,1993,83(3):416-436.
    [11]Bernanke, B., M. Gertler. Monetary Policy and Asset Price Volatility[R]. NBER WorkingPaper,2000,559:1-74.
    [12]Bernanke,B.,M. Gertler. Should Central Banks Respond to Movements in AssetPrices?[J].American Economic Review Papers and Proceedings,2001(91):253-257.
    [13]Bertrand Renaud. The1985-94Global Real Estate Cycle[R]. The World Bank FinancialSector Development Department, Policy Research Working Paper,1452, May1995:128-133.
    [14]Bordo, M.D., and O. Jeanne. Boom-bust in Asset Prices, Economic Instability, andMonetary Policy[R]. NBER Working Paper.2002(8966):83-99.
    [15]Borio, Claudio, Philip Lowe. Asset Price, Financial and Monetary Stability: Exploring theNexus[R]. Bank of International SettlementsWorking Paper,2002(114):122-149.
    [16]Born W.L., S.A.Pyhrr. Real Estate Valuation: The Effect of Market and PropertyCycles[J].The Journal of Real Estate Research,1994,9(4):55–85.
    [17]Bradford Case, William Goetzmann, K. Geert Rouwenhorst. Global Real Estate Markets--Cycles and Fundamentals[R]. Yale International Center for Finance,WorkingPaper,1999-03:167-181.
    [18]Buckley, Robert. Housing Finance in Developing Countries[M]. Oxford: Oxford UniversityPress,1996:137-145.
    [19]Burns, A. F. and W. C. Mitchell. Measuring Business Cycles[M]. New York, NationalBureau of Economic Research,1946:21-38.
    [20]Calomiris,Charles W., Charles Himmelberg, Paul Wachtel. Conmnercial Paper,CorporateFinance, and The Business Cycle-a Microeconomic Perspecive[R].Nber Working Paper No.4848, September,1994:178-193.
    [21]Canova F. Detrending and Business Cycle Facts[J].Journal of MonetaryEconomics,1998(41):475–512.
    [22]Cecchetti, S., H. Genberg, J. L ipsky, S.W adhwan.i. Asset Prices and Central BankPolicy[R]. Geneva Reports on the World Economy2,2000:201-233.
    [23]Christiano,L.,R.Motto,M.Rostagno.The Great Depression and the Friedman-SchwartzHypothesis[J].Journal of Money Credit and Banking,2003,35(6):1119-1197.
    [24]Cochrane,J. Financial Markets and the Real Economy[Z]. manuscript, University ofChicago.2006:49-88.
    [25]Cooley T.F.,L.E.Ohanian. The Cyclical Behaviour of Prices[J].Journal of MonetaryEconomics,1991(28):25–60.
    [26]Cross Donald,Christine Whitehead. Development and Planning1994[M], U.ofCamnbridge,Departmnent of Land Economy,1994:127.
    [27]Dauten, C. A. and L. M. Valentine. Business Cycles and Forecasting[M]. Cincinnati, OH:South-Western Publishing Co.,1974:89-102.
    [28]Edward L. Glaeser,Joseph Gyourko,Albert Saiz. Housing Supply And Housing Bubbles[R].NBER Working Paper Series(National Bureau Of Economic Research), July2008:116-127.
    [29]Gruen, D., M. Plumb, and A. Stone. How Should Monetary Policy Respond to AssetPriceBubbles?[J]. International Journal of Central Banking,2005,1(3):1-31.
    [30]Herring,R.,S.Wachter. Bubbles in Real Estate Markets. Asset Price Bubbles: TheImplications for Monetary, Regulatory, and International Policies[M]. MIT Press,2003,Chapter14:217.
    [31]Hodrick,R.,Prescott,E. Post-war US business cycle: an empirical investigation [R].workingpaper,Carnegie Mellon University,Pittsburgh,PA.1980:137-144.
    [32]Illing,G. Financial Fragility Bubbles and Monetary Policy[R].CESifo WorkingPaper,2001(449):178-199.
    [33]Ivan Jaccard. House Prices, Real Estate Returns, and the Business Cycle[R]. Swiss FinanceInstitute Research Paper Series,April9,2007:22-61.
    [34]Jermann,U. Asset pricing in production economies[J].Journal of MonetaryEconomics,Elsevier.1998,41(2):257-275.
    [35]Kent, Christopher, and Philips Lowe. Asset Price Bubbles and Monetary Policy[R]. ReserveBank of Australia Research Discussion Paper1997(9709):99-122.
    [36]Kim Hiang Liow.Cycles and common cycles in real estate markets[J]. International Journalof Managerial Finance,2007,3(3):287-305.
    [37]Klein, R. and W. Wolman. The Beat Inflation Strategy[M]. New York, NY: Simon andSchuster,1975:205-221.
    [38]Koencker,R. Quantile Regression. Econometric Society Monographs[M]. CambridgeUniversity Press. London,2005:141-166.
    [39]Kohn, Donald. Monetary Policy and Asset Prices[Z]. Speech Delivered at Monetary Policy:A Journey from Theory to Practice. A European Centra l Bank Colloquium Held in Honor ofOtmar Issing, Frankfurt, March16,2006:133-161.
    [40]Kontonikas, A., C. Ioannidis. Should Monetary Policy Respond to Asset PriceMisalignments[J]. Economic Modelling,2005,22(6):1105-1121.
    [41]Leamer,E.E. Housing Is the Business Cycle[R].Working Paper No.13428, Washington, D.C.:National Bureau of Economic Research,September,2007:145-161.
    [42]Liow,K.,Sim,M. The risk and return of Asian real estate stocks[R].workingpaper,Department of Real Estate,National University of Singapore, Singapore.2005:41-55.
    [43]Liow,K.,Webb,J. Common factors in international securitized property markets[R].workingpaper,National University of Singapore,Singapore,Cleveland State University, Cleveland,OH.2005:36-77.
    [44]L. Randall Wray. The Commodities Market Bubble-Money Manager Capitalism and TheFinancialization Of Commodities[R]. Public Policy Brief, The Levy Economics Institute OfBard College,2008(96):199-231.
    [45]Lu,K.,Mei,J. The return distributions of property shares in emerging markets[J].Journal ofReal Estate Portfolio Management,1999,5(2):45-60.
    [46]Mankiw N.Gregory,David N.Weil. The Baby Boom,the Baby Bust,and the HousingMarket[R].National Bureau of Economic Research,Working Paper,1988,2794:182-194.
    [47]Mitchell, W. C. Business Cycles: The Problem and Its Setting[M]. National Bureau ofEconomic Research, New York,1927:121-145.
    [48]Moore, G. H., Business Cycles, Inflation, and Forecasting[M], Second Edition, NationalBureau of Economic Research Studies in Business Cycles, No.24, New York, NY: BallingerPublishingCo.,1983:229-241.
    [49]Nelson,E. The Future of Monetary Aggregates in Monetary Policy Analysis[J]. Journal ofMonetary Economics,2003(50):1048.
    [50]Park G. The Role of Detrending Methods in a Model of Real Business Cycles[J]. Journal ofMacroeconomics,1996,18(3):479–501.
    [51]Patrick J.Wilson,John Okunev. Long-Term Dependencies and Long Run Non-PeriodicCo-Cycles:Real Estate and Stock Markets[J].Journal Of Real Estate Research,1999,18(2):257-259.
    [52]Phyrr,S.,Roulac,S.,Born,W.L. Real estate cycles and their strategic implications for investorsand portfolio managers in the global economy[J].Journal of Real Estate Research,1999,18(1):7-68.
    [53]Phyrr, S. A.,W. L. Born. Real Estate Cycles: The Body of Knowledge[C], Paper presented atthe American Real Estate Annual Meeting, Tampa, Florida, April1999:45-51.
    [54]Posen, Adam S. Why Central Banks Should Not Burst Bubbles. Available at http://www. iie.com/publications/wp/w p06-1. pd.f,2006:210.
    [55]Pritchett PC.Forecasting the Impact of Real Estate Cycles on Investment[J]. Real EstateReview,1984,13(4):85-89.
    [56]Rabinowitz, A. The Real Estate Gamble[M]. New York, NY: AMACOM–A Division of theAmerican Management Association,1980:238.
    [57]Rajan,R. Has Financial Development Made the World Riskier?[R].NBER WorkingPaper,2005,No.11728:189.
    [58]Rajan,R. Monetary Policy and Incentives[Z].Address given at Central Banks in the21stCentury Conference,Bank of Spain.2006:131-155.
    [59]Ramón Adalid,Carsten Detken.Liquidity Shocks and Asset Price Boom/Bust Cycles[R].Working Paper Series, The European central bank2007,2,No.732:78.
    [60]Ravn M.O.,H.Uhlig. On Adjusting the HP-filter for the Frequency of Observations
    [Z].Discussion paper50, Tilburg University, Center for Economic Research,1997(5):301.
    [61]Richard J.Herring,Susan Wachter. Real Estate Booms and Banking Busts: An InternationalPerspective[R].The Wharton Financial Institutions Center Working Paper Series,1999:27.
    [62]Ronald W. Kaiser. The Long Cycle in Real Estate[J]. Journal Of Real Estate Research,1997,14(3):234-240.
    [63]Roulac,S.E.,D.E.Sobolik. Real Estate Tax Reform: Historic Perspective and EconomicImplications[J].Real Estate Finance,1985,2(2):13–24.
    [64]Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors (RICS) Report. Understanding the PropertyCycle[R]. Main Report: Economic Cycles and Property Cycles, London: The RoyalInstitution of Chartered Surveyors, May1994:127.
    [65]Shiller, Robert J. Investor Behavior in Stock market crash: Survey Evidence[R].CambridgMeass,National Bureau of Economic Research Working paper, No.2446,November,2005:34-59.
    [66]Stephen A. Pyhrr,Stephen E. Roulac,Waldo L. Born. Real Estate Cycles and Their StrategicImplications for Investors and Portfolio Managers in the Global Economy[J]. Journal ofReal Estate Research,1999,18(1):8-15
    [67]Stoken, D. The Great Cycle: Predicting and Profiting from Crowd Behavior, the KondratieffWave and Long-Term Cycles [M], Revised Edition, Chicago, IL: Probus PublishingCompany,1993:83–84.
    [68]Wheaton,W.C. The Cyclic Behavior of the National Office Market[J].Journal of theAmerican Real Estate and Urban Economics Association,1987,15(4):81–99.
    [69]White, William R. Making Macroprudential Concerns Operationa[Z]. Speech Delivered atthe Financial Stability Symposium Sponsored by the Netherlands Bank, Amsterdam,October2004:25-26.
    [70]Wilson,P.,Okunev,J. Spectral analysis of real estate and financial assets markets[J].Journal ofProperty Investment&Finance,1999,17(1):61-74.
    [71]Witkiewicz,W. The use of the HP-filter in constructing real estate cycle indicators[J]. Journalof Real Estate Research,2002,23(1):65-87.
    [72]Witten GR.Riding the Real Esate Cycle[J].Real Estate Today,1987(8):2-28.
    [73]巴曙松,栾雪剑.经济周期的系统动力学研究[J].系统工程,2009(11):67-88.
    [74]陈刚.房地产经济周期波动预测与研究[J].中国经贸导刊,2010(2):91-101.
    [75]崔光灿.房地产价格与宏观经济互动关系实证研究——基于我国31个省份面板数据分析[J].经济理论与经济管理,2009,(1):57.
    [76]戴国海.人口结构变化对房地产周期性波动的影响[J].金融发展研究,2011(7):25.
    [77]段忠东.房地产价格、抵押制度与货币政策传导[J].广东金融学院学报,2010(1):77-80.
    [78]段忠东,曾令华.房价冲击、利率波动与货币供求[J].世界经济,2008(12):165-176.
    [79]段忠东,朱孟楠.不确定性下的房地产价格波动与货币政策反应:一个文献综述[J].经济评论,2011(1):135-139.
    [80]高铁梅,王金明,陈飞,梁云芳.中国转轨时期的经济周期波动-理论、方法及实证分析[M].北京,科学出版社,2009:199.
    [81]龚曙明.宏观经济统计分析-理论、方法与实务[M].北京,中国水利水电出版社,2010:278.
    [82]顾建发.上海房地产周期波动分析[M].上海三联书店,2008:10.
    [83]韩冬梅,屠梅曾,曹坤.房地产价格泡沫与货币政策调控[J].中国软科学,2007(6):49-52.
    [84]贺云松.基于引入习惯形成的RBC模型的中国经济波动分析[J].统计与决策,2010(16):105.
    [85]侯瑜.理解变迁的方法:社会核算矩阵及CGE模型[M].东北财经大学出版社,大连,2006:104-121.
    [86]李成,王彬,马文涛.资产价格、汇率波动与最优利率规则[J].经济研究,2010(3):189-191.
    [87]李亮.资产价格波动与货币政策应对[J].上海经济研究,2010(4):78-85.
    [88]李强.资产价格波动的政策涵义:经验检验与指数构建[J].世界经济,2009(10):149-155.
    [89]梁云芳,高铁梅.中国房地产价格波动区域差异的实证分析[J].经济研究,2007(8):133-142.
    [90]陆晓明.中央银行在控制资产价格膨胀中的作用[J].国际金融研究,2010(2):165.
    [91](美)罗伯特J.巴罗,哈维尔.萨拉伊马丁.经济增长[M].北京:中国社会科学出版社,2000:205.
    [92]苗文龙.货币政策是否应关注资产价格——基于货币稳定的视角[J].当代财经,2010(7):134-149.
    [93]邱强,万海远.我国房地产业的周期运行特征[J].统计与决策,2007(22):156-163.
    [94]邱兆祥,王涛.我国房地产经济周期划分研究(1950~2008年)[J].经济研究参考,2009(71):89-97.
    [8](美)斯塔尔(Starr,R.M.)著.一般均衡理论[M].上海:上海财经大学出版社,2003:78-96
    [95]宋勃.房地产市场财富效应的理论分析和中国经验的实证检验:1998~2006[J].经济科学,2007(5):41-53.
    [96]宋勃,刘建江.房价与地价关系的理论分析与中国经验的实证检验:1998—2007[J].中央财经大学学报,2009,(9):60-66.
    [97]唐齐鸣,熊洁敏.中国资产价格与货币政策反应函数模拟[J].数量经济技术经济研究,2009(11):145-163.
    [98]唐志军,徐会军,巴曙松.中国房地产周期波动研究[J].科学决策,2009(6):89-94
    [99]许经勇.高房价、高地价与房产税的深层思考[J].南通大学学报·社会科学版,2011,27(2):107.
    [100]王德文,蔡昉.人口红利的获得与丧失[R].中国人口与劳动问题报告NO7:人口转变的社会经济后果,社会科学文献出版社,2006:189.
    [101]王宋涛,杨薇,吴超林.中国国民总效用函数的构建与估计[J].统计研究,2011,28(4):34.
    [102]王晓明,施海松.资产价格波动形势下货币政策工具的宏观调控效应比较研究[J].上海金融,2008(11):92-100.
    [103]王玉宝,杜两省.资产价格波动与货币政策[J].东北财经大学学报,2004(3):178-186.
    [104]王子龙,许箫迪,徐浩然.房地产市场财富效应理论与实证研究[J].财贸经济,2008(12):116-123.
    [105]吴晓求.实体经济与资产价格变动的相关性分析[J].中国社会科学,2006(6):45-59.
    [106]薛薇.SPSS统计分析及应用[M].北京,电子工业出版社,2004:417.
    [107]叶檀.中国房地产战争[M].山西人民出版社,2009:135.
    [108]张海蔚.中国房地产价格决定机制研究[J].上海金融,2009,(6):89.
    [109]张红,谢娜.基于主成分分析与谱分析的房地产市场周期研究[J].清华大学学报(自然科学版),2008,48(9):177-186.
    [110]张玉喜.货币与经济周期:理论发展及其评述[J].当代经济研究,2010(5):156.
    [111]张昭,陈兀梧.人口因素对中国房地产行业波动的影响及预测分析[J].金融经济,2009(08):114-123.
    [112]赵进文,高辉.资产价格波动对中国货币政策的影响[J].中国社会科学,2009(2):198-201.
    [113]赵君丽.人口变化与房地产需求—人口结构变化与房地产周期相关性研究[J].城市开发,2002(8):159-166.
    [114]赵昕东.中国房地产价格波动与宏观经济[J].经济评论,2010(1):80-87.
    [115]中国经济年鉴社.中国经济年鉴1987年~2010年,北京,1987~2010.
    [116]中国人民银行沈阳分行课题组.中央银行如何关注资产价格?——一个基于流动性螺旋识别的宏观调控优化思路[J].国际金融研究,2010(2):163-171.
    [117]周晖,王擎.货币政策与资产价格波动:理论模型与中国的经验分析[J].经济研究,2009(10):78-86.
    [118]祝晓峰,刘卫江.美国股价泡沫与货币政策——从哈耶克的货币经济周期理论出发的一个解释[J].财经理论与实践,2003(5):67-73.
    [119]吴璟,刘洪玉.基于灰色-马尔可夫模型的房地产周期研究[J].统计与决策,2009(6):168.
    [120]张海蔚.中国房地产价格决定机制研究[J].上海金融,2009,(6):89.
    [121]张红,谢娜.基于主成分分析与谱分析的房地产市场周期研究[J].清华大学学报(自然科学版),2008,48(9):172-181.
    [122]张晓晶,孙涛.中国房地产周期与金融稳定经济研究[J].Economic Research Journal,2006(1):189-192.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700