中国粮食双轨制度的政治经济学分析
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
双轨制度是中国从计划经济向市场经济过渡所采取的制度安排。与
    “大爆炸”改革模式相比,它具有渐进性、边际性、路径依赖性和可逆
    性等改革特征,同时,这种制度变迁过程也是政府、生产者、消费者三
    者之间权利和义务相互交易的过程。虽然它具有较高的实施成本,但
    是,通过帕雷托改进方式减少了摩擦成本,从而使中国的改革“小步快
    走”顺利而成功。
     双轨制度曾广泛地存在于中国经济各个领域。在工业领域,最为突
    出代表的是钢材、电力、天然气等生产资料生产和流通领域的双轨存
    在。在农业领域,最为突出的代表为粮食生产和流通领域的双轨存在。
    经历20多年的市场化改革之后,中国所有工业品和绝大多数农产品的市
    场已经全部放开,但是,粮食领域双轨制度的依然存在。这种存在不仅
    反应出粮食流通体制改革的复杂性,而且也说明了粮食流通体制改革的
    特殊性。可是,相关的理论分析和实证分析不仅很少,而且有关双轨制
    度对粮食生产的影响也存在着不同看法。这种现象不仅无法帮助人们对
    这一制度变迁过程形成正确地认识,而且也不利于为深化粮食流通体制
    改革提供理论参考和政策建议。
     本文以粮食生产和流通领域的双轨制度为研究对象,着重分析了双
    轨制度下的粮食定购数量分配、农户的粮食供给反应和市场干预政策效
    果等。全文共分八章。第一章简要介绍了本文的选题背景、选题依据、
    研究范围与主要目标等。第二章在简要回顾统购统销制度之后,对粮食
    双轨制度的产生与发展进行了全面阐述。同时,对用于本文的资料进行
    了处理和统计描述。第三章对有关文献进行了综述和评价。第四章阐述
    了不同层次的政府部门在粮食双轨制度中的地位和作用,并通过建立和
    运用粮食定购数量分配模型探讨了影响粮食定购数量分配的决定因素及
    其与政策目标之间的关系。第五章构造了双轨制度下的农户价格预期模
    型和粮食供给反应模型,并利用调查数据对模型中的假设进行了检验。
    第六章通过建立和运用双轨制度下粮食市场干预模型,分析了市场干预
    的效果和得失,并与有关国家进行了比较。第七章分析了双轨制度的终
    结条件、过渡方案和过渡时间,并对当前的粮食政策和农业政策进行了
    评价。第八章是全文总结,并简要说明了需要进一步深入研究的方向。
     通过利用了3省(浙江省、江苏省、四川省)25个主产水稻的样本县
    的县级时间序列资料(1971-97年)进行实证分析,本文得出如下结论:
     1、中央、省、县等不同层次的政府部门在粮食定购中的地位和作用
    是不同的。一般而言,粮食定购数量和定购价格是由中央政府制定,然
    后由上向下分解。粮食的定购数量在县与县之间是存在着极大差异,而
    定购价格在县与县之间差别不大。这说明,在定购数量和定购价格省级
    
     工级微 岸两粮食双轨款级酸缓缓缓缓攀分级
    水平确定之后。省级赋府通常缓择定购数设分困作为主要政策工具来实
    $%$@&$M#。
     2、1$M$T$%$$$$kgh&@,@$$$$g%$&#A
    本。在赣够赚象严翻翻缓缓缓、城市赠箱净赚瑰荣个方级湖级确。
     入级食定购政策在执行过程中具有以下几个特点;翡》魂簸净确实
    将缓纷效率放净赚摄像嵌 在粮食定购数设分配过程中将教少的定购数
    设分配给工业比较发达的要 将较多的定购数设分配给具有波自生产比
    较镜势的县 仅是。赔年代由于政策决警中给予够促安会较大的权重
    这求效率方援的考虑似乎被削弱了。脂》对审缓缓缓和湖摩方镇级籍学够
    权级要大子对摩签方镇的缓t 城市人级规模和城市居民签入收入水平
    确实影响到粮食定的数设分级 赋策选择给予了贫困输区关注;并镇过
    99 tta@% @$k$ff&t%k&$$&$K$&。$$kffi。$#@
    土地资源禀赋对粮食定购数摄分配也存在签影响,但是。耕地级公似乎
    对粮食定购数设分配不起作用。侣》函我的对效缓个级残破廖瀚级”
    我及分以有廖款龄你用 但是。防科时问的缓移 由于城市居民收入水
    平的较快增长。以及部减财政负祖的压力。这种正向作盾在钢年代我来
    基本上不存在了。
     4、$$$t$k$娥$飘 s#$#&$#ai$$。$N&$
    对粮食产出的边际形响在认洲左右g 粮假定购数设对级食产出的边际影
    响大约在认@到汉③之问 定购数设和定购价格对农户的供给的影响大
    致有三个方面;一是非演际生产放废 阈定购数设对粮食产出的彩揭是
    通过影湖粮食播种面积和单产来实现减 定购数计对粮食播种厚积有正
    向作用g 对粮食单产有负向作用。二是破策信号的导向作用。定购价格
    和定购数付通过影响邀户的价格预期对俄签产生正做作用。三是收入效
    应。定购价签和定购欧援通过读响农户的收入从而对农户的粮食生产和
    消费产生作用。
     S。@级粮食定湖和发价敢戴银困缓缓免于缓乔产和我输的方式并
    我有输舞镇定粮食审级够缓缓困g相反;级税翻腾安排有可赚存在放
    大市场价接波动的可能往 从图际经验角度看。革体实和印度尼西亚两
    国通过函后于预市输的方式确实这到了稳发市场的效展 认真总结两国
Double-track system is an institutional arrangement adopted by China during its
     transition from planned economy to market economy. Compared with the 揃ig Bang?
     reforming model, it has the characteristics of gradualism, marginality, path-
     dependence and reversibility. This process of institutional change is an exchange of
     rights and obligations between government, producers, and consumers. Although the
     implementing costs were high, it reduced friction costs through Pareto Improvement
     and therefore brought about a successful and smooth economic growth in China.
     Double-track system widely existed in every sector of China抯 economy. The
     most typical ones in the industrial sector were in the production and marketing fields
     of means of production such as steel, electricity and natural gas. The most typical one
     in the agricultural sector was in the production and marketing fields of grains. After
     over 20 years of market-oriented reform, the markets of all industrial products and
     most agricultural products have been totally opened. The double-track system
     survived, however, in the production and marketing fields of grains, which reflects the
     complexity and uniqueness of this reform. Unfortunately, relevant theoretical and
     empirical studies on this topic were rarely done, and there have always been debates
     on the effects of double-track system on grain production, which made it difficult to
     correctly understand this process of institutional change, not to mention to put forward
     theoretical reference and policy recommendation for deepening the reform of grain
     marketing system.
     This paper focuses on the double-track system in the fields of grain production
     and marketing, and analyses quota allocation, farmers?grain supply response and the
     effects of market intervention. There are, all together, eight chapters. Chapter 1
     briefly introduces the background, scope and objectives of this paper. Chapter 2
     comprehensively reviews the emergence and evolution of the double-track system in
     grain marketing. Moreover, it describes data resource and statistical analysis.
     Chapter 3 reviews and evaluates relevant articles. Chapter 4 describes different roles
     of government departments at different levels in the grain double-track system, and
     explores the determinants of quota allocation and their relationship with policy
     objectives by the construction and implementation of a grain quota allocation model.
     Chapter 5 analyses farmers?grains supply response under the double-track system by
     way of a supply response model incorporated with price expectation. Chapter 6
     examines the effects of market intervention by the construction and implementation of
     a grain market intervention model and compares them with relevant countries.
     Chapter 7 analyses the ending conditions, transitional proposals and periods of the
     double-track system, as well as makes comment on current grain and agricultural
     policies. Chapter 8 presents the conclusion of this paper, and briefly points out the
     directions for further studies.
    
    
    
     151
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
     Using the panel data from 25 rice-growing counties in 3 provinces (Zhejiang,
     Jiangsu and Sichuan), the empirical studies show the following findings:
     I. Central and local governments play different roles in the grain double-track
     system. Generally speaking, quota quantity and quota price were set by the central
     government, and allocated top-down. Great differences exist between counties in
     quota quantity, whereas the difference of quota price bet
引文
北京农业大学等编,1983:《经济大辞典·农业经济卷》,上海辞书出版社,上海;农业出版社,北京.
    陈巅,1989:《粮食购销体制与粮食市场价格》,《发展研究通讯》,总第128期.
    陈云,1995:《陈云文选》(第二卷,第三卷),人民出版社,1995年第二版,北京.
    陈锡文,1993:《中国农村改革:回顾与展望》,天津人民出版社,天津.
    ……,2000:《粮食供求形势转折和农业结构调整》,《国务院发展研究中心调查研究报告》(内部资料),第9号(总1187号).
    崔晓黎,1999:《粮食安全的双重目标政策宜分不宜合》,《国务院发展研究中心调查研究报告》(内部资料),第95号(总1077号).
    戴园晨,1986:《经济体制模式转换过程中的双重价格》,《经济研究》,第1期.
    《当代中国的粮食工作》编辑委员会,1988:《当代中国的粮食工作》,中国社会科学出版社,北京.
    《当代中国的农业》编辑委员会,1992:《当代中国的农业》,当代中国出版社,北京.
    [美] 道·诺斯,1995:《制度变迁理论纲要》,《改革》,第3期.
    刁新申,1989:《中国双轨制经济分析》,《发展与改革》,第2期.
    杜润生,1995:《经济转换时期的中国农业》,《改革》,第4期.
    杜鹰,1999:《如何正确认识农业和农村经济结构调整问题》,《农村工作通讯》,第8期.
    ……,2000:《关于农业和农村经济结构调整问题》,手稿.
    杜鹰等,1999:《阶段性过剩与战略性调整——关于粮食总量调控问题的对策研究》,农业部产业政策与法规司调研报告.
    杜为长,科尔曼,1997:《中国农作物播种面积对价格变化反应的实证分析》,《中国农村观察》,第2期.
    段应碧,1988:《也谈农村第二步改革的中心任务是什么》,《农村问题论坛》,第10期.
    发展研究所综合课题组,1988:《农民、市场和制度创新——包产到户后农村发展面临的深层改革》,载于《改革面临制度创新》,上海三联书店,上海.
    樊纲,1990:《寻求改革的稳定形式》,载于《中国经济论坛—1990 年学术论文集》,上海三联书店,上海.
    樊胜根,1999:《政府开支与农村发展》,北京大学中国经济研究中心简报,1999 年第 6 期(总第86期).
    高小蒙,宋国青,1987:《中国粮食问题研究》,经济管理出版社,北京.
    高小蒙,向宁,1992:《中国农业价格政策分析》,浙江人民出版社,杭州.
    国务院农研中心试验区办公室,1990:《改革思考录》,中国卓越出版公司,北京.
    国务院研究室课题组,1996:《粮食地区平衡与省长负责制》,中国言实出版社,北京.
    国务院研究室农村司,2000:《湖北省粮改进展情况调查及建议》,调查报告,未发表.
    韩喜玲,邹凤羽,1998:《粮食经济与政策》,中国商业出版社,北京.
    
    
    韩志荣,冯亚凡等,1992:《新中国农产品价格40年》,水利电力出版社,北京.
    皓若素,马国南,1992:《中国粮食研究报告》(蔡方,李周译),北京农业大学出版社,北京.
    何宇鹏,王德文,1996:《1995:化肥产销政策的执行与评价》,《中国农村观察》,第2期.
    胡汝银,1992:《中国改革的政治经济学》,《经济发展研究》,第4期.
    华生,何家成,张学军,罗小朋,边勇壮,1986:《经济运行模式的转换—试论中国进一步改革的问题和思路》,《经济研究》,第2期.
    黄益平,1994,《中国粮食政策的选择—兼论立足自给与自由贸易策略》,会议材料.
    黄季焜 1999:《WTO与中国农业》,手稿.
    金和辉,1990:《计划与市场条件下的中国农户粮食的供给反映》,《经济研究》,第9期.
    柯柄生,1992:《再论我国粮食市场上的价格问题》,《中国农村经济》,第六期.
    ……,1991:《我国粮食市场上的价格信号问题》,《中国农村经济》,第六期.
    (美)科林·卡特,钟甫宁,蔡昉,1999:《经济改革进程中的中国农业》,中国财政经济出版社.
    林毅夫,蔡昉,1988:《论粮食的优质化政策》,《发展研究通讯》,总第90期.
    林毅夫,蔡晐,李周,1993:《论中国经济改革的渐进式道路》,《经济研究》,第6期.
    ……,1994:《中国的奇迹:发展战略与经济改革》,上海三联书店,上海人民出版社,上海.
    林毅夫,1994:《制度、技术与中国农业发展》,上海三联书店,上海人民出版社,上海.
    ……,1995:《中国的经济改革与经济学的发展》,载北京大学中国经济研究中心编《经济学与中国经济改革》,上海人民出版社,上海.
    卢锋,1999:《粮食是否具有外部性》,北京大学中国经济研究中心简报,1999年第1期(总第81期).
    ……,1999:《粮食问题上“泛政治化”认识误区》,北京大学中国经济研究中心简报,1999 年第2期 (总第82期).
    ……,1999:《应当实事求是地认识粮食过剩问题》,北京大学中国经济研究中心简报,1999 年第7期(总第87期).
    卢迈,1997:《实行“保量保价’的双轨制》》,《改革》,第3期.
    陆文强,肖俊彦,曾琼锐,2000:《1999 年粮、棉流通体制改革》,《国务院发展研究中心调查研究报告》(内部资料),第11号(总1189号).
    马凯,1996:《如何认识现行粮食购销政策》,《改革》,第2期.
    苗壮,1992:《制度变迁中的改革战略选择问题》,《经济研究》,第10期.
    农业部农村改革试验区办公室,1992:《粮食购销体制改革》(资料汇编,未出版)
    农业部农村改革试验区办公室,1997:《认识与实践的对话——中国农村改革试验区十年历程》,中国农业出版社,北京.
    农村固定观察点办公室,2000:《1999年我国农户经济运行的主要特征和基本判断》,内部资料.
    彭显智,1988:《购改税:走出粮食困境—关于粮食购销体制改革的一种思考》,《农村问题论坛》,第10期.
    乔刚,陈共炎,1991:《关于价格改革思路的几个问题》,《经济研究》,第3期.
    盛洪,1991:《寻求改革的稳定形式》,《经济研究》,第1期.
    ……,1992:《市场化的条件、限度和形式》,《经济研究》,笫11期.
    宋国青,1987:《从统购统销到土地税》,载于高小蒙和宋国青编:《中国粮食问题研究》,经济管理出版社,北京.
    ……,1988:《联合交换理论简析》,《中国:发展与改革》,第3期.
    ……,1988:《双轨体制下的货币政策》,《经济研究》,第8期.
    
    
    宋洪远,1997:《“米袋子”省长负责制及其对粮食生产、流通和宏观调控的影响》,《中国农村观察》,第2期.
    唐仁健,1993:《粮食购销:从计划体制向市场体制的演进》,载于游守宏和谢鸿光编的《市场经济下的农业政策》:174-190,中国统计出版社,北京.
    ……,1997:《中国粮食流通体制改革:现状、目标和思路》,《改革》,第3期.
    王德文,1995:《现阶段农村微观经营体制改革:动向与判断》,《经济理论与经济管理》,第6期.
    ……,1997:《家庭经营与农户劳动力配置:1986—1996),《中国农村观察》,第6期.
    王德文等,1998:《主要农产品供求形势与政策选择》,《中国农村经济》,第6期.
    魏凯,卢迈,1993:《价格:经由双轨制的转变》,载沃尔特·加勒森编《中国经济改革》,社会科学文献出版社,北京.
    吴敬琏,1995:《路径依赖与中国改革》,《改革》,第3期.
    谢扬,1997:《九七话”粮改“》,《改革》,第3期.
    杨圣明,1991:《价格双轨制的历史地位与命运》,《经济研究》,第4期.
    张五常,1999:《科斯定量的谬误》,北京大学中国经济研究中心简报,1999 年第33期(总第133期).
    张曙光,1995:《放开粮价 取消粮票》,《中国社会科学季刊》(香港),冬季卷,总第 13 期.
    郑毓盛,曾澍基,陈文鸿,1993:《中国农业生产在双轨制下的价格反应》,《经济研究》,第1期.
    赵人伟,1986:《我国经济改革过程中的双重体制问题》,《经济研究》,第9期.
    周其仁,1994:《中国农村改革:国家和所有权关系的变化》,《中国社会科学季刊》,第 3 卷总第8期。
    周章跃,陈良彪,1995:《从“保量放价”到“提价定购”》,《改革》,第五期.
    中国农村发展问题研究组,1987:《国民经济新成长阶段与农村发展》,浙江人民出版社,杭州.
    《中国商业年鉴》,中国商业年鉴出版社,1988-93年,北京.
    《中国国内贸易年鉴》,中国国内贸易出版社,1994-99年,北京.
    《中国统计年鉴》,中国统计出版社,1980-99年,北京.
    Ash, F. Robert, 1991. The Peasant and the State, The China Quarterly, September (127): 493-526.
    Byrd, William A., 1987, The Impact of the Two-tier Plan/Market System in Chinese Industry, Journal of Comparative Economics, 11: 295-308.
    Byrd, William A., 1989, Plan and Market in the Chinese Economy: A Simple General Equilibrium Model, Journal of Comparative Economics, 13: 177-204.
    Carter, C., F. Zboag, 1991. China's Past and Future Role in Grain Trade, Economic Development and Culture Change 39: 791-814.
    Carter, C., Jing Chen and Scott Rozelle, 1997, China's State Trading in Grains: An Institutional Overview, Paper Presented at WCC-101 Conference, University of llawaii, January 1997.
    
    
    Chang, Gene Hsin, Wen J. Guanzhong, 1997. Communal Dining and the Chinese Famine of 1958-1961, Economic Development and Cultural Change, Vol. 46: 1-34.
    Chen, Jing, Scott Rozelle, and Colin Carter, 1999, Grain Price Stability and Farmer Decision Making In China, Paper Presented in AAEA Annual Meeting, Nashville, Tennessee, August 8-11, 1999.
    Cheng, Yuk-Shing, Tsang Shu-ki, 1994. The Changing Grain Marketing System in China, The China Quarterly, December (140) : 1080-1104.
    Choe, Chongwoo, 1996. Incentive to Work versus Disincentive to Invest: The Case of China's Rural Reform, 1979-1984, Journal of Comparative Economics 22: 242-266.
    Choi, Jung-Sup, Peter G. Helmberger, 1993. Acreage Response, Expected Price Functions, and Endogenous Price Expectations, Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics, 18(1) : 37-46.
    Edwards, Clark, 1976. The Political Economy of Rural Development: Theoretical Perspectives, American Journal of Agricultural Economics, December: 914-20.
    Engle, F. Robert, C. W. J. Granger, 1987. Co-Integration and Error Correction: Representation, Estimation, and Testing, Econometrica, Vol. 55, Issue 2: 251-276.
    Fan, Shenggen, 1997, Production and Productivity Growth in Chinese Agriculture: New Measurement and Evidence, Food Policy, 22, no. 3: 213-229.
    Gardner, L. Bruce, 1976, Futures Prices in Supply Analysis, American Journal of Agricultural Economics, February: 82-84.
    Griffin C. Ronald, John M. Montgomery, and M. Edward Rister, 1987. Selecting Functional Form in Production Function Analysis, Western Journal of Agricultural Economics, 12(2) : 216-27.
    Holton, H. Richard, Terry Sicular, 1991. Economic Reform of the Distribution Sector In China, The American Economic Review, Vol. 81, Issue 2, Papers and Proceedings of the Hundred and Third Annual Meeting of the American Economic Association: 212-217.
    Houck, P. James, Paul W. Gallagher, 1976. The Price Responsiveness of U.S. Corn Yields, American Journal of Agricultural Economics, November: 731-34.
    Huang, C-H, 1992, Effects of Government Program on Rice Acreage Decisions under Rational Expectations: The Case of Taiwan, American Journal of Agricultural Economics.
    Huang, K., Scott Rozelle, 1996. Technological Change: Rediscovering the Engine of Productivity Growth in China's Rural Economy, Journal of Development Econmics 49: 337-49.
    Inderjit Sing, Lyn Square, and John Strauss, 1986, Agricultural household model: extension, application, and policy, A World Bank Publication, The Johns Hopkins University Press.
    Johnson, D. Gale, 1950. The Nature of the Supply Function for Agricultural Products, The American Economic Review, Vol. 40, Issue 4: 539-564.
    --, 1997. Agriculture and the Wealth of Nations, American Economic Review, Vol. 87, No. 1, March.
    --, 1999. Agricultural Adjustment in China: Problems and Prospects, Working Paper, The University of Chicago, No. 99. 01.
    --, 1999. Agricultural Adjustment in China: The Taiwan Experience and Its Implications, Working Paper, The University of Chicago, No. 99. 02.
    
    
    Lau, Lawrence, Yingyi Qian, and Gerard Roland, 1996, Gain without Pain: An Interpretation of China's Dual-Track Approach to Transition, mimeo, Stanford University. Lau, Lawrence, Yingyi Qian, and Gerard Roland, 1997, Pareto-Improving Economic Reforms through Dual-Track Liberalization, Forthcoming, Economics Letters.
    --, 1998, Reform without Losers: An Interpretation of China's Dual-Track Approach to Transition, Forthcoming, Journal of Political Economy.
    Li, Qing-Zeng, 1991. Government Control of Grain Production in China, Working Paper, Chinese Economy Research Unit, The University of Adelaide, 1991.
    Lin, Justin Yifu, 1992, Rural Reforms and Agricultural Growth in China, American Economic Review 82, No. 1: 34-51.
    --, 1992, Government procurement price and rice supply response in China: a Preliminary Study, Prepared for the Planning Workshop on Projections and Policy Implications of Medium and Long Term Rice Demand and Supply on March 25-27, 1992.
    --, 1993, Government procurement price and rice supply response in China, Prepared for the Rice Demand and Supply Workshop to Be Held in IRRI on March 22-24 1993.
    --, 1997, Dual-Track Price and Supply Response: Theory and Empirical Evidence from Chinese Agriculture, Unpublished Manuscript.
    --, 1997, Institutional Reforms and Dynamics of Agricultural Growth in China, Food Policy, 22, no. 3: 201-212.
    Lin, Justin Yifu, Guanzhong James Wen, 1995. China's Regional Grain Self-Sufficiency Policy and Its Effect on Land Productivity, Journal of Comparative Economics 21: 187-206.
    Lucas, E. Robert, Jr., 1967. Adjust Costs and the Theory of Supply, The Journal of Political Economy, Vol. 75, Issue 4, Part 1 (Aug., 1967) : 321-334.
    Oury, B. 1965. Allowing for Weather in Crop Production Model Building, J. Farm Econ. 47: 271-83.
    Park, Albert, 1993, Do Grain Quotas Matter? , Food Research Institute, Standford University, 1993(mimo).
    Park, Albert, Scott Rozelle and Cai Fang, 1994. China's Grain Policy Reform: Implications for Equity, Stabilization, and Efficiency, China Economic Review 5(1) : 15-34.
    Putterman, Louis, 1993. Continuity and Change in China's Rural Development, New York: Oxford.
    --,1992. Dualism and Reform in China, Economic Development and Cultural Change 40(3) : 467-493.
    Muth, F. John, Ration Expectations and the Theory of Price Movements, Econometrica 29: 315-35.
    Nerlove, Marc, 1956. Estimates of the Elasticities of Supply of Selected Agricultural Commodities, Journal of Farm Economics, 38: 496-509.
    North, C Douglass, 1981, Structure and Change in Economic History, W.W. Norton & Company, Inc., New York.
    Nigel Key, 1996, Transactions Costs in the Agricultural Household Model: Implications for Price Response and Estimation, Paper Presented at AAEA Annual Meeting, San Antonio, July, 1996.
    
    
    Randolph, Barker, Yujiro llayami, 1976. Price Support versus Input Subsidy for Food Self-Sufficiency in Development Countries, American Journal of Agricultural Economics, November: 617-28.
    Rozelle, Scott, Mark W. Rosgrant, 1997, China's Past, Present, and Future Food Economy: Can China Continue to Meet the Challenges?, Food Policy, 22, no. 3:191-200.
    Rozelle, Scott, Albert Park, Hehui Jin, and Jikun Huang, 1998, Market Emergence and Transition: Arbitrage, Transaction Cost, and Autarky in China's Grain Markets, Working Paper, University of California, Davis, 1998.
    Rozelle, Scott, Albert Park, Jikun Huang, and Hehui Jin, 1996, Dilemmas in Reforming State-Market Relations in China's Grain Economy, Working Paper, University of California, Davis, 1996.
    --, 1998, Bureaucrat to Entrepreneur: The Changing Role of the State in China's Grain Economy, Working Paper, University of California, Davis, 1998.
    Rozelle, Scott, and Richard N.Boisvert, 1993. Grain Policy in Chinese Villages: Yield Response to Pricing, Procurement, and Load Policies, Amer. J. Agr. Econ. 75: 339-349
    Sicular, Terry, 1988, Plan and market in China's agricultural commerce, Journal of Political Economy 96, No. 2: 283-305.
    --, 1995, Why quibble about quota? The effects of planning in rural China,Unpublished Manuscript.
    --, 1995. Redefining State, Plan and market: China's Reform in Agricultural Commerce, The China Quarterly, December (144) : 1020-1046.
    Stalling, J. L., 1960. Weather Indexes, J. Farm Econ. 42:181-87.
    Tang, M. Anthony, 1980. Trend, Policy Cycle, and Weather Disturbance in Chinese Agriculture, 1952-1978, American Journal of Agricultural Economics, May: 339-347.
    Waston, Christopter, 1998, Grain Market Reform In China: Global Implications, ACIAR Technical Reports, and no. 43.
    Wen, J. Guanzhong, 1993. Total Factor Productivity Change in China's Farming Sector: 1952-1989, Economic Development and Cultural Change, Vol. 42: 1-41.
    Zhang, Bing, Colin A. Carter. 1997, Reforms, the Weather, and Productivity Growth in China's Grain Sector, American Journal of Agricultural Economics 79: 1266-1277

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700