中国股票市场主要参与者行为特征研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
中国股票市场成立于我国由计划经济向市场经济转轨时期,三十多年来,我国股票市场发展迅速,在短短时期内快速发展为世界上第三大股票市场。当前我国股票市场的总体状况是大而不强,尽管市场规模处于世界前列,但是,股票市场运行效率总体低下。
     我国股票市场运行效率低下的原因主要是由于我国股票市场运行机制存在缺陷,股票市场运行存在着来自于股票市场内部和外部的各种约束,市场机制难以充分发挥作用。影响股票市场正常运转的内部约束主要是指维系股票市场正常运转所需的各种规则、制度存在缺失或者不够健全,外部约束则主要是指政府的过度行政干预、法律法规不健全、社会诚信体系欠缺等方面。
     运行机制由市场上的相关参与者行为共同决定,研究运行机制离不开对决定运行机制的参与人行为特征的分析。本文从研究我国股票市场参与者行为特征的角度,运用博弈论方法,通过研究股票市场上各参与者行为特征的历史沿革和现实表现、我国股票市场参与者与理想股票市场相应参与者行为特征之间存在的差异、以及我国股票市场上各参与者行为之间的相互影响,深入揭示我国股票市场运行机制中存在的问题,探寻我国股票市场运行效率低下的根源,进而提出改进我国股票市场运行效率的政策建议。
     本文分析了我国股票市场上三个主要参与者(上市公司、投资者和政府)的行为特征及其历史沿革,在深入分析各参与者行为特征的基础上,通过建立博弈模型,对各参与者之间的相互作用方式进行了分析,探寻隐藏在我国股票市场主要参与者表面行为下的内在作用机理,在对作用机理进行分析的基础上,结合我国实际情况,对我国股票市场总体运行状况进行了评价。
     通过研究本文发现,造成我国股票市场效率低下的原因,既有政府行为变异的影响,也有投资者和上市公司参与股票市场非理性化行为的影响,这三个方面交互影响、相互作用,共同使得我国股票市场运行效率低下。
     我国股票市场并不存在独特特征,其运行与世界上其它国家股票市场之间并非存在根本不同。我国股票市场之所以存在一些与发达国家股票市场不同的表现,主要原因在于同发达国家股票市场相比,我国股票市场上上市公司、投资者和政府行为存在变异,这些变异使得我国股票市场运行机制难以健全,对我国股票市场正常运转带来严重的制约。这些制约因素或者产生于股票市场内部,或者由外部强加给股票市场,它们犹如落入运转中齿轮间的沙子、或者是捆绑于巨人身上的绳索,严重束缚着我国股票市场正常运转,对我国股票市场运行效率发挥着重大的不利影响。
China stock market has been developing rapidly and now is the third largest market in the world since it was established more than30years ago when china was then carrying out the policy of transformation of the planned economy to the market economy. Although among the largest stock market throughout the world, China stock market still runs inefficiently, it is big but not strong.
     The reason why China stock market runs inefficiently lies in that there are kinds of deficiencies both from inside and outside of China stock market that restrain it from an efficient operation. The restraints from the inside are the lack of kinds of rules that a stock market depends on them to run efficiently, and the restraints from the outside refer to the over-intervention of the government into the stock market, the imperfectness of the laws and regulations and the lack of social credit system etc..
     How does a market operate depends on the participants'behaviors in it, it is necessary to study the participants'behaviors when one wants to have a better understanding of the efficiency of a stock market. This essay tries to study China stock market's operating mechanism by analyzing its participants'behaviors with the method of game theory. Through the study of both past and present characteristics of the participants'behaviors in China stock market and the interaction among them, comparing them to the counterparts of ideal stock market, the essay wants to reveal what's the real problem in China's stock market, and the reason why China stock market run inefficiently.
     This paper has analyzed the behavioral characteristics of three main participants, these are listing Corporations, investors and the government, in China stock market and their historical evolution. Based on in-depth analysis of the behavioral characteristics, through the establishment of game models, the interactions between the participants were analyzed, the mechanism underlying the participants'behaviors are explored, and the operating status of China stock market is evaluated.
     The study found that the reasons why China stock market operates inefficiently are due to inefficient governmental behavior, irrational behavior of listing corporations and investors, and the interactions among these three participants.
     China stock market is not unique comparing to the stock markets in other countries around the world, there is no fundamental difference between China stock market and other countries'stock markets. The reason why China stock market performs differently with that of other countries is only due to the fact that the three participants in China stock market don't behave in a rational and efficient way, this in turn makes the improvement of efficiency of China stock market impossible. There are many restraints both from the outside and the inside of the stock market that prevent market mechanism operating efficiently, those restraints hold back the fluent operation of China stock market and make China stock market an inefficient stock market, just like the sands that fall into the running toothed gears or the ropes that tie on a giant tightly.
引文
[1]陈筱宇: 《中国证券市场运行效率探析》[J],经济研究,2009.8。
    [2]李勇:《我国股票市场资本配置效率实证分析》[J],山西财经大学学报,2009.2。
    [3]冉茂盛、张宗益:《运用R/S方法研究中国股票市场有效性》[J],重庆大学学报,2001.6。
    [4]孙淑红:《中国资本市场效率与监管研究》[M],北京:清华大学出版社,2006。
    [5]谭加劲:《资本市场有效理论的演变和发展》[J],金融教学与研究,2002.1。
    [6]吴世农:《我国证券市场效率的分析》[J],经济研究,1996.4。
    [7]武晓春:《中国股票市场效率研究》[D].南京农业大学博士学位论文,2005。
    [8]张晓恫:《计量经济学软件Eviews使用指南》[M],天津:南开大学出版社,2003。
    [9]周宏:《资本市场效率:理论和经验研究》[M],大连:东北财经大学出版社,2005。
    [10]张兵、李晓明:《中国股票市场的渐进有效性研究》[J],经济研究,2003.1。
    [11]郑学军:《中国股市的结构与变迁》[M],北京:人民出版社,2002。
    [12]吴晓求:《中国上市公司:资本结构与公司治理》[M],北京:中国人民大学出版社,2003。
    [13]施东晖:《中国股市微观行为理论与实证》[M],上海:上海远东出版社,2002。
    [14]刘逛:《证券市场微观结构理论与实践》[M],上海:复旦大学出版社,2002。
    [15]刘鸿儒:《探索中国资本市场发展之谜》[M],北京:中国金融出版社,2003。
    [16]李心丹:《行为金融学—理论及中国的证据》[M],上海:上海三联书店,2004。
    [17]李国正:《证券投资基金投资行为对证券市场波动性影响研》,北京:中国证券业协会研究报告2003。
    [18]高潮生:《破解股市迷思》[J],财经,2002.12。陈浪南、姚正春:《我国股利政策信号传递作用的实证研究》[J],金融研究,2000.10。
    [19]杨朝军、蔡明超、洪泳:《上海股票市场弱式有效性实证分析》[J],上海交通大学学报,1998.3。
    [20]许香存、李平、曾勇:《中国股票市场开放式集合竞价对波动性影响的实证研究》[J],金融研究,2007.7。
    [21]谢百三:《证券市场的国际比较——从国际比较看中国证券市场的根本性缺陷及其矫正》[M],北京:清华大学出版社,2003。
    [22]王美今、孙建军:《中国股市收益波动与投资者情绪》[J],经济研究,2004.10。
    [23]宋颂兴、金伟根:《上海股票市场有效性实证研究》[J],经济学家,1995.4。
    [24]史代敏:《股票市场波动性的政策影响效应》[J],管理世界,2002.8。
    [25]李建国:《中国证券市场信息不对称研究》[J],财贸经济2001.12。
    [26]赫什.舍夫林著、王闻译:《资产定价的行为方法》[M],北京:中国人民大学出版社,2007。
    [27]高铁梅:《计量经济分析方法与建模》[M],北京:清华大学出版社,2007。
    [28]陈保华:《市场微观结构理论研究综述》[J],经济学动态,2003.1。
    [29]朱科敏:《我国证券公司股权结构理论分析》[M],上海:上海财经大学出版社,2006:80。
    [30]陈工孟、高宁:《中国股票一级市场发行抑价的程度与原因》[J],金融研究,2000.8。
    [31]黄少安、张岗:《中国上市公司股权融资偏好分析》[J],经济研究,2001.11。
    [32]刘湿辉、熊鹏:《股权分置!政府管制和中国IPO抑价》[J],经济研究,2005.5。
    [33]乔桂明:《中国股票市场政策市之博弈分析》[J],经济科学,2004.2。
    [34]夏建英:《我国上市公司融资偏好及原因分析》[J],西南金融:证券经纬,2006.4。
    [35]罗永明、杨丹:《IPO的相关理论观点及实践证据综述》[J],武汉金融,2004.6。
    [36]任喜萍:《我国企业上市制度变迁的思考明》[J],企业活力,2004.5。
    [37]赵迎琳:《中国企业上市成本分析》[J],山西财经大学学报,2000.2。
    [38]任有泉、韩泽县:《中国股票市场理性的实证分析》[J],哈尔滨工业大学学报,2005.9。
    [39]杨丹:《约束条件下新股首次公开发行决策分析明》[J],金融研究,2004.10。
    [40]林国春、段文斌:《行为金融学及博弈论应用》[M],第1版.南开大学出版社,2006。
    [41]彭作样:《金融时间序列建模分析》[M],第1版.西南财经大学出版社,2006。
    [42]陈东琪:《新政府干预论》[M],首都经贸大学出版社,1999。
    [43]哈罗德.德姆塞茨(美),段毅才等译《所有权、控制与企业论经济活动的组织》[M],第1版.经济科学出版社,1999。
    [44]陈凌:《从公共选择理论看如何改进我国证券监管体制》[J],企业经济,2004年第7期。
    [45]弗朗茨:《效率:理论、论据和应用》[M],上海译文出版社,1993。
    [46]何诚颖:《中国股市市盈率分布特征及国际比较研究》[J],经济研究,2003.9。
    [47]祁光华:《论我国证券市场监管中的政策失败》[J],北京行政学院学报,2003.1。
    [48]冉茂盛、张宗益、陈梅:《中国股票市场与经济增长的因果关系检验》[J],重庆大学学报,2003.4。
    [49]斯蒂格利茨: 《政府为什么干预经济》[M],北京:中国物资出版社,1998。
    [50]谈儒勇:《中国金融发展和经济增长关系的实证研究》[J],经济研究,1999.10。
    [51]许均华:《宏观政策对我国股市影响的实证研究》[J],经济研究,2001.9。
    [52]赵锡金: 《论证券监管》[M],北京:中国人民大学出版社,2000。
    [53]钱颖一:《政府与法制比较》[M],北京:中信出版社2003.3。
    [54]孔爱国、李哲: 《IPO定价的信号模型:信息披露有效性检验》[J],复旦学报2003.10第787—793页。
    [55]吴世农:《我国证券市场效率的分析》[J],经济研究1996.4。
    [56]龙小波等:《证券市场有效性理论与中国证券市场有效性实证研究》[J],金融研究1999.3。
    [57]张兆国等:《深圳股票市场有效性实证研究》[J],武汉大学学1999.6。
    [58]黄少安、张岗:《中国上市公司股权融资偏好分析》[J],经济研究,2001.11。
    [59]黄山:《中国股票市场有效性研究的文献综述》[J],价值工程,2006.4。》[J],金融研究,2007.7。
    [60]刘胜军:《股价操纵与反操纵监管》[J],证券市场导报,2001.7。
    [61]李广众、王美今:《市场操纵与证券市场弱有效性检验》[J],中山大 学学报(社会科学版),2003.5。
    [62]青木昌彦著、周黎安译:比较制度分析[M],上海远东出版社,2001。策,2001.9。
    [63]许均华、李启亚等:《宏观经济对我国股市影响的实证研究》[J],经济研究,2001.9。
    [64]宋玉臣、王巍、姚玥悦:《股票市场失灵的政府行为选择与博弈分析》[J],吉林大学社会科学学报,2009.9。
    [65]张维迎:《博弈论与信息经济学》[M],上海:上海出版社,1996。
    [66]Daniel K. D., Hirshleifer D., Subrahmanyam A. "Investor psychology and security market under-and verreactions" [J]. Journal of Finance,1998,53-59.
    [67]Fama, E. F. "Efficient Capital Markets:A Review of Theory and Empirical Work", The Journal of Finance,1970:383-417.
    [68]Fama, E. French, K. " Permanent and temporary components of stock prices". [J]. Journal of Political Economy,1988,96:246-273.
    [69]Fama, E. F. "Efficient Capital Markets" [J], The Journal of Finance Dec.,1991,46 (5):1575-1617.
    [70]Grossman, S., Stiglitz, F. " On the impossibility of informationally efficient markets".American Economics Review,1980,70: 393-408.
    [71]Lo, A. W., MacKinlay, A. C. " Stock prices do not follow random walks:Evidence from a simple specification test" [J]. Review of Financial Studies,1988, (1):41-66.
    [72]Stigler, G. J. "the theory of economic regulation", Bell, [J], Journal of Eeonomies,1971
    [73]Joseph E. Stiglitz, "The Role of the State in Financial Markets", Proceedings of the World Bank Annual Conference on Development.1993, PP20-21.
    [74]George J. Stigler, "Public Regulation of the Securities Markets", [J], Journal of Business of the University of Chicago,1964, Vol 37, No.2, April.
    [75]Bruce C. Greenwald, Meir Kohn, and Joseph E Stiglitz, "Financial Market Imperfections and Productivity Growth", [J], Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization,1990, Vol.13, No.3, PP321-345.
    [76]Bikhchandani, Sushil, David Hirshleifer, and Ivo Welch. " A theory of fads, fashion, custom and culture change asinformational cascades". Journal of Politics.1992.
    [77]Krasker, W. S. "Stock price movements in response to stock issues under asymmetric information". The Journal of Finance.1986.
    [78]Loughran, T. and J. Ritter. "The New Issues Puzzles". The Journal of Finance.1995.
    [79]Ibboston, R. G. "Price Performance of Common Stock Issues" The Journal of Finance.1975.
    [80]Jay. R. Ritter, Ivo Welch. "A review of IPO activity, pricing, and allocations". The Journal of Finance.2002.
    [81]Markowitz, Harry M. "Portfolio Selection". The Journal of Finance.1952.
    [82]Ritter, Jay R. "The "Hot Issue" Market of 1980". Journal of Business.1984.
    [83]Barberis, Nicholas, Andrei Shleifer, and Robert Vishny. "A Model of Investor Sentiment". The Journal of Finance.1996.
    [84]McGuinness Paul. "Market Valuation of IPOs in Hong Kong". Applied Financial Economics.1993.
    [85]Tian Lihui. "Regulatory Underpricing:Determinants of Chinese Extreme IPO Returns". Journal of Empirical Finance.2011.
    [86]Krigman Laurie, Wayne H. Shaw, Kent L. Womack. "The Persistence of IPO Mispricing and the Predictive Power of Flipping". The Journal of Finance.1999.
    [87]Ritter Jay R, Ivo Welch. "A review of IPO activity, pricing and allocations". Journal of Finance,2002.
    [88]Shen, Yang-Pin; Wei, Peihwang; "Why Do Companies Choose to Go IPOs? New Results Using Data from Taiwan".Journal of Economics and Finance, Fall 2007, v.31, iss.3, pp.359-67
    [89]Fonseka, M. M.; Samarakoon, Lalith P.; Tian, Gao-Liang. "Equity financing capacity and stock returns:Evidence from China". Journal of International Financial Markets, Institutions & Money. Dec2012, Vol.22 Issue 5, p1277-1291.15p.
    [90]Hopp, C..Dreher, A. "Do differences in institutional and legal environments explain cross-country variations in IPO underpricing?", Applied Economics. Feb2013, Vol.45 Issue 4, p435-454.20p.
    [91]Ghosh, Arvin. "The IPO phenomenon in the 1990s". Social Science Journal.2006, Vol.43 Issue 3, p487-495.9p.
    [92]Martens, Martin L. "IPO effects:Corporate restructuring when a firm goes public". Journal of Public Affairs. May2004, Vol.4 Issue 2, p155-169.15p.
    [93]Reuer, Jeffrey J.; Ragozzino, Roberto. "Adverse selection and M&A design:The roles of alliances and IPOs". Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization. May2008, Vol.66 Issue 2, p195-212.18p.
    [94]Chang, Eddy; Chen, Chao; Chi, Jing; Young, Martin. "IPO underpricing in China:New evidence from the primary and secondary markets". Emerging Markets Review. Mar2008, Vol.9 Issue 1, p1-16.16p.
    [95]Borensztein, Eduardo R., Gelos, R. Gaston. "Leaders and followers:emerging market fund behavior during tranquil and turbulent times". Emerging Markets Review. Mar2003, Vol.4 Issue 1, p25.14p.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700