摘要
生态收益会计计量之所以出现,第一是收益会计发挥产权保护作用的需要,第二是会计收益计量发展的需要。由于有限理性的存在,人们对产权保护的内容和形式的认知,是不断发展的。会计收益计量是会计产权保护的重要内容,这决定了会计收益计量必须不断发展。会计收益计量的历史表明:一方面,会计收益计量的内容和形式随产权保护内容的发展而演进。企业生态产权的形成和生态需求市场的出现,既决定了产权权能实现形式的丰富,也决定了生态收益的计量成为建设生态友好社会的重要推动力量,这也是会计发挥产权保护作用的具体体现。由于现行的资产计价和收益计量制度在反映企业生态收益时的内在缺陷,进行相关会计制度改革势在必然。另一方面,随着可持续发展理念的日益深入,生态环境作为企业利益相关方的观点逐步形成,保护生态产权的观点开始成为人们的共识。产权保护的需要和会计收益计量对产权保护作用领域认识的发展,推动了企业生态收益计量会计的产生。
历史上,为推动企业生态绩效的计量,生态效率与环境收益观应运而生。生态效率强调更少的投入获得更多的产出,因此生态效率在企业的运用,一定程度上可以缓解资源、环境问题的困境。但是,生态效率的过程理性特点和以人为生态系统中心的世界观,直接影响了生态效率理论作用的发挥。同时,生态效率的理论基础仍然是经济人假设,与可持续发展的理念存在一定的冲突。再加上,生态效率指标以相对数而不是以绝对数的形式来反映企业的生态绩效,更可能的是掩盖本已存在的问题。而企业生态收益指标既包含了生态效率的过程理性的特点,同时又兼顾了企业作为经济人重视结果理性的特点,是从过程理性和结果理性相结合的角度出发,因而生态收益指标是生态效率指标的进化,更能促进企业生态行为的规范。
从环境收益的角度分析,环境收益的基础是环境经济学,环境经济学的基础依然是经济人假设。同时,从各国的实务分析,环境收益强调从成本和负债的角度,对企业的行为规范进行激励,权责的不对等直接导致其在实务中对企业环境行为规范效力的不足。另外,从系统学的角度分析,环境收益只是生态收益的组成部分。因此,生态收益和环境收益分别代表不同的世界观,生态收益观的出现,表明企业已经将自己看做生态环境的有机组成部分,人是生态经济人,按生态规律从事生产经营活动成为企业的选择。然而遗憾的是,在现实中,仍然有许多观点把环境和生态环境等同,没有无生态的环境,也没有无环境的生态。但是,由于支撑环境观、生态观背后的哲学观和理论基础存在根本区别,实际上二者代表着不同的认识观和方法论。
就企业的生态收益而言,企业生态收益主要可以分为产出生态收益、功能生态收益和声誉生态收益。产出生态收益与企业的生产过程相联系,产品功能生态收益既指企业的生态化生产过程相连如企业利用残余物进行产品的生产而使生态环境好转形成的收益,也指产品在消费使用环节因具有生态友好功能而获得的收益:声誉生态收益是指可持续发展企业由于其持续不断的生态改进行为,使得部分生态友好企业同类存货与其他生态友好企业相比,有更高的产品价格、更广的市场容量或者资本市场上更高的价值等等而形成的收益。
三种形式的生态收益互相联系又互相区别,形成可持续发展背景下企业的核心竞争力。
在此基础上,我们进行了案例分析和统计研究。对大唐湘潭电厂的案例分析告诉我们,传统的污染密集型企业也可以通过生产过程的生态化获得生态收益。其中,树立正确的资源观是企业获取生态收益的前提,延长产业链条,促使企业生产经营过程生态化是企业获取生态收益的基本途径,而相关生态消费市场的形成以及政府制定的一系列激励企业采用清洁生产技术、传统企业产业生态化布局的经济激励措施,则是企业获取生态收益的制度保障机制。
除了收益激励作用外,来自相关生态环境领域的机会成本的对企业生态行为的规制同样重要。由于在我国企业生态行为的机会成本和机会收益的不对称分布,损害生态环境的行为成为我国相当一部分公司生态行为的主流。中海油康菲公司的案例技师证明。而来自我国证券市场的实证检验更是证明了这一点。发生生态事故的样本公司与没发生生态事故的配对样本公司相比,主营业务收入的增长速度对比,不具明显差别,而净利润的增长,样本公司显著高于配对样本公司。说明在我国,采取措施,使生态因素成为企业的核心竞争因素,以规范企业生态行为,任重而道远。
同时,对企业进行生态审计,既有助于防止生态消费市场上出现柠檬市场,也而为企业的生态行为规范提供外部保障机制。
The reason why ecological income accounting measurement come into being, thefirst is the role which income accounting intends to play in the fields of property rights,the second is because of the existence of bounded rationality, the knowledge ofpeople’s understanding on the property protection, is in the continuous development,from form to content. The measurement of accounting income’s plays the major role inthe protection of the property rights, the history of accounting income measurementshows: on one hand, accounting income measurement evolve with the content and formof the protection of property right.The form of companies’ ecological property rightand the appearance of ecological market, lead to the complex realization form of theproperty rights. And proves that the measurement of Eco-income play a important rolein the construction of an ecological sound society. This also is the embodiment ofproperty rights protection which role accounting play. As the shortcoming exist inpresent asset pricing and measurement of income, it can’t reflect ecological income ofcompanies, to reform the existing relevant accounting system is undoubtedly. On theother hand, along with the spread of the concept of sustainable development, the viewto take the ecological environment as company’s stakeholder gradually formed, and thenecessity to protect the ecological property is beginning to become the consensus ofpeople. The needs for property rights protection and the development in themeasurement of accounting income promote the generation of ecological income.
In order to measure the enterprise’s sustainable performance, ecological efficiencyand environmental gains has been developed to come into being as a representative of aseries of measures.
Because ecological efficiency’s emphasis is to get more output with less input, sowith the popular of ecological efficiency in the companies, the plight of resources andenvironment problems can ease to a certain extent. But, ecological efficiency works asprocess rational and is thought to be people-centered, limits its use in enterprise. Atthe same time, the theoretical basis of ecological efficiency is still the hypothesis ofEconomic-man, still exist certain conflicts with the concepts of sustainabledevelopment, at the same time, take the form of relative does not reflect the enterpriseecological performance actually while the absolute form can do, and thus can’t solvethe already existing problems. Ecological income is the development of ecological efficiency ideas, not only including that of the view of process rational, as well as butalso including the view of result rational as well, thus can make economic man paytheir attention to eco-environment, and promote enterprise ecological behaviorstandard.
From the perspective of the environment income, the theory foundation of theenvironmental income is the environment economics, the basic of environmentaleconomics is still the hypos is of Economic man. At the same time, from the practice ofthe countries, environmental incomes emphasis on the cost and debt, so as to beincentive for the regulation of the companies’ behavior, the unequal between the powerand the responsibility directly leads to the companies’ environment behavior doesn’tmeet the regulation. From the perspective of systematic, environmental income is justpart of the ecological incomes. Second, the ecological income and environmentalincome is based on behalf of the different views of the world. As the coming into beingof the concept of ecological income, which shows that the companies have regardhimself as an organic part of the ecological environment, man is ecological economicman, to operate according to the ecological law in the production and businessoperation activities become the companies’ choice. Unfortunately, in reality, there arestill many ideas take the concept of environment and ecological environment as equal,although there are kinds of contact between them, there is no environment withoutecological, and no ecological without environment. However, because of thefundamental different between the philosophy and the theoretical foundation, either ofthem actually represents different understanding and methodology of the world.
The companies’ ecological income can be divided into output ecological income,functional ecology income and reputation ecological income. The output income isthat the enterprise gain its ecological income in the operating process,
Function ecology income is from the result of industrial ecology which can makeecology turn better through the use of waste,or when we consume different goods ofthe same goods or similar goods, the product whose quality is better and more securityto user or its disposal costs is lower etc.
Reputation eco-income comes from the continuous improvement in ecoenvironment of sustainable company. Because its behavior in ecological environmentcompared with other companies, it has a higher price, a broader market capacity or ahigher value on capital market, and so on.
Company ecological income which results from the enterprise ecological friendlybehavior, is the internalization of the enterprise’s positive externalities.In this paper, we find because the Datang-xiangtan power plant does well in source management,get’s off dust and desulfurization, thus enhance the coal quality and improve powerefficiency of coal quality management, extend the enterprise production chain, enjoysgood ecological income and economic income as well. Based on this empiricalevidence, we find importance of the economic incentives for the regulation ofenterprise’s ecological behavior, and the gain of the enterprise ecological income,passes through each step in enterprise production management as well.
At the same time, our research tells us: though enterprise ecological income playsan incentive role for companies, it is also the same important for the regulation ofopportunity cost in the field of Eco-environment. The asymmetric distribution ofopportunity cost and opportunity revenue, directly led to oil leakage accident in BohaiSea and the forming of unsound eco-behavior. At last, our empirical test finds that thecompanies which do harm to Eco-environment have no significant difference both inthe growth of main sale and the growth of net income as well. We suggest, if we can’tseriously punish the firm whose behavior does harm to the Eco-system, to make rightsmatches responsibilities at the same time, identify it and measures it in time, report it inthe annual report, the companies will not become ecological friendly.
Therefore, perform ecological audit, can help to prevent the emergence of lemonmarket in ecological consumption market, thus provide an external securitymechanism for the regulation of companies’ ecological behavior.
引文
②转引自程宏伟、冯茜颖、王艳《自然契约、生态利润与企业可持续发展》,中国工业经济2010年第5期p88。
①引自李金昌《自然资源核算》(M),北京,中国环境科学出版社出版,1990年
①转引自Jong Gong Yong. An empirical study of impact of a preventive environmental strategy onenvironmental and organizational performance[D],University of Nebraska,1997
[1]岳书敬,刘富华.环境约束下的经济增长效率及其影响因素,数量经济技术经济研究,2009,(5):94-106
[2]姚蕾.构建和谐社会发展循环经济.北方经济,2006,13(3):79~80
[3]郭朝先.中国二氧化碳排放增长因素分析.中国工业经济,2010,(12):47-56
[4]牛文元.绿色GDP与中国环境会计制度.会计研究,2002,(1):9-13
[5] Herman E. Daly,John B. Cobb. For the common good: redirecting the economytoward the community, the environment and a sustainable future. Beacon Press,1989,35-40
[6]世界银行.1995年世界发展报告.北京:中国财政经济出版社,1996,99-100
[7] Wackernagel M, Rees W E.Our ecological footprint: reducing human impact onthe earth. Gabriola Island: New Society Publishers,1996,112-115
[8] Espen Sjaastad et al. what is environmental income? Journal of ecologicaleconomics,2005,(55):37-46
[9] SEEA2003,丁言强,王艳等译,国民核算手册:环境经济综合核算2003.北京,中国经济出版社,2004.
[10] Beams F A, Fertig, P E.Pollution control through social cost conversion. Journalof accountancy,1971,(141):37-42
[11] Marlin J T.Accounting problem of pollution. journal of accountancy,1973,(2):33-39
[12] Burke, R C.Decision making in complex times; The contribution of a socialaccounting information system. The society of management accountant ofCanada, Toronto,1984
[13] Brook, J L.Canadian corporate social performance. The society of managementaccountant of Canada, Toronto,1986
[14] Mathews, M R.A suggested classification for social accounting research.Journal of accounting and public policy,1984,(3):199-221
[15] Parker, L D.Polemical themes in social accounting: a scenario for setting.Advances in public interest accounting,1986,(1):67-93
[16] Gray, R H.Corporate social reporting: emerging trends in accountability and thecontracts. Accounting in Auditing and accountability,1988,(1):6-20
[17] Donaldson, T.Corporate morality, Prentice hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ.1982
[18] Elkington, J.The environment audit: A green filter for company policies, plants,processes and products. London:World wide fund for nature,1990,22-30
[19] Gray, R.H.Accounting and environmentalism: an exploration of the challenge ofgently accounting for accountability,transparency and sustainability. Accounting,organization and society,1990,(5):399-425
[20] Schaltegger, Stefan, Kasper Muller et al.Corporate environment accounting.John Wiley&sons, West Sussex, England,1996,100-300
[21] Atkinson,Giles, Hamilton.Accounting for Progress: Indicators for SustainableDevelopment. Environment,1996,(9):16-20
[22] Atkinson,Giles.Measuring Corporate Sustainability.Journal of environmentalplanning and management,2000,(5):235
[23] Environmental Protection Agency.1997Toxics Release Inventory, WashingtonD.C: Office of pollution prevention and toxics,1999
[24] EPA.An introduction to environmental accounting as a business tool: KeyConcepts and terms. United States Environmental Agency, Washington DC,1995a
[25] EPA.Environmental Cost Accounting for Capital Budgeting: a BenchmarkSurvey of Management accounts. United States Environmental Agency,Washington D.C.,1995b
[26] EPA.Environmental accounting case studies: Green accounting at At&t,UnitedStates Environmental Protection Agency, Washington D.C.,1995,89-95
[27] FASB. Sfas. No5, Accounting for contingencies. Financial Accounting andStandards Board, Stamford.1975,33-66
[28] FASB.Interpretation of FASB Statement No.5, Interpretation No.14, ReasonableEstimation of amount of loss. FASB,1976,25-33
[29] EITF (89-3). Accounting for the cost of asbestos removal. Stamford, FASB,1989
[30] EITF (90-8). Capitalization of costs to treat environment contamination.Stamford, FASB,1990
[31] EITF (93-5).Accounting for environment liabilities. Stamford,1993
[32] FASB. FAS143, Accounting for asset retirement obligations, FASB,2001
[33] FASB.FIN47, accounting for conditional asset retirement obligations. Stamford,FASB,2005
[34] AICPA. AICPA statement of position (SOP)96-Environmental remediationliabilities. AICPA,1996
[35] CICA. Environment cost and liabilities, a problem of accounting and financialreporting. CICA, Toronto,1993
[36] Stone D. No longer at the end of the pipe, but still s long way fromsustainability: a look at management accounting for the environment andsustainability in the United States. Accounting forum,1995,(19):95-110
[37] CICA.Environment auditing and the role of accounting profession. CICA,Toronto,1992
[38] CICA.Reporting on environmental performance. CICA, Toronto,1994,19-25
[39] Japanese environment agency. Q&A for understanding environmentalaccounting guidelines. Japanese environment agency,2002,77-89
[40] Ministry of the environment. Japan environmental accounting guidelines2005.Ministry of the environment,2005,33
[41] Elkington J.Cannibals with forks: the triple bottom line of21stcentury business.Oxford: Capstone Publishing1997
[42] Schaltegger S, Bennet M, Burrit R.Sustainability accounting and reporting.Eco-efficiency in industry and science. Dordrecht: spring,2006,25-36
[43] Schaltegger S, Wagner M.Managing the business case for sustainability, theintegration of social, environmental and economical performance. Sheffield:Greenleaf publishing,2006,13-17
[44] Jean-Francois Henri, Marc Journeault.Eco-conntrol:The influence ofmanagement Control system on environmental and economic performance.Accounting, Organization and society,2010,(35):63-80
[45] Menon A and A Menon. Enviropreneurial marketing strategy: the emergence ofcorporate environmentalism as market strategy.Journal of Marketing,1997,(1):51-67
[46] Handelman J M and S Arnold. The role of marketing actions with a socialdimension: Appeals to the institutional environment, Journal of marketing,1999,63(3):33-48
[47] Belkaoui.The impact of disclosure of the environmental effects oforganizational behavior on the market. Financial management,1976,(12):26-32
[48] Banerjee S B, E S Iyer, and R K Kashyap.Corporate environmentalism:Antecedents and influence of industry type. Journal of marketing,2003,(2):106-112
[49] Hart S L.A natural based view of the firm.Academy of management review,1995,20(4):986-1014
[50] Mohr, L R, and D J.Webb. The effect of corporate social responsibility and priceon consumers’ response. Journal of consumers’ affairs,2005,39(1):121-147
[51] Alan Murray et al.Do financial markets care about social and environmentaldisclosure? Accounting, Auditing and Accountability Journal,2006,(19):228-255
[52] Anne Y Ilinitch,Naomi S Soderstrom.Measuring corporate environmentalperformance. Journal of Accounting and public policy,1998,(6):77-90
[53] Rob Gray. Is accounting for sustainability actually accounting for sustainability,and how would we know? An exploration of narratives of organization andplanet. Accounting Organizations and Society,2010,(35):47-62
[54] Beets,S D, and C C Souther. Corporate environmental reports: The need forstandards and Environmental assurance service. Accounting Horizon,1999,13(2):129-145
[55] Gorte, J F. Corporate Social Responsibility: close to victory. Journal ofinvesting,2005,14(3):140
[56] Lydenberg S. Social and environmental data as new tools. Journal of investing2005,14(3):40-46
[57]唐晓华,王广凤,马小平.基于生态效益的产业链研究.中国工业经济,2007,(11):121-127
[58]孟凡利.论环境会计信息的披露及其相关的理论问题.会计研究,1999,(4):16-25
[59]王凤羽.浅谈绿色会计的确认、计量和报告.财会月刊,2001,(14):33-40
[60]孙兴华.绿色会计的计量与报告研究.会计研究,2002,(3):7-10
[61]谢诗芬.公允价值计量:中国引入绿色GDP理念和环境会计审计的前提.财经理论与实践,2004,(4):33-40
[62]乔世震.试论环境成本.广西会计,2001,(5):22-25
[63]花爱梅.环境成本会计探微.财会月刊,2001,(20):18-21
[64]姜星明.环境负债及其处理的会计研究.上海会计,(1):22-24
[65]肖序.环境成本论.北京,中国财政经济出版社,2002,66-79
[66]谢德仁.企业绿色经营系统与环境会计.会计研究,2002,(1):11-17
[67]林汉川,王莉,王分棉.环境绩效、企业责任与产品价值再造.管理世界,2007,(5):155-157
[68]徐立青.试论污染物排放的总量控制、排污交易与环境评比.化工技术经济,2001,(3):11-14
[69]成金华.中国工业化进程中的环境问题与环境成本内化发展模式.管理世界,2007,(1):33-36
[70]王立彦.环境管理体系认证的成本效益——对企业实施国际标准ISO14000s的调研,山西财经大学学报,2004,(5):11-15
[71]许家林.环境会计核算中的环境资产确认问题.会计研究,2006,(1):25-30
[72]戴波,周鸿.生态资产评估理论与方法.经济问题探索,2004,(9):66-69
[73]朱文泉等.中国陆地生态系统生态资产测量及其动态变化分析.应用生态学报,2007,(6):3-9
[74]朱纪红,企业环境成本与收益的确认及其对经营成果的影响.审计与经济研究,2006,(5):22-26
[75]许家林,资源会计学的基本理论问题研究.上海:立信会计出版社,2004,77-90
[76]李海舰,冯丽.企业价值来源及其理论研究.中国工业经济,2004,(3):33-40
[77] Freeman, M A.The Economics of Environmental Policy. New York:John Wiley&Sons,1973,22-33
[78]郭道扬.论产权会计观与产权会计变革.会计研究,2004,(2):8-17
[79]哈罗德·德姆塞茨.所有权、控制与企业——论经济活动的组织.北京:经济科学出版社,1999,172-200
[80]阿尔钦等著.陈昕译.财产权利与制度变迁.上海:上海人民出版社,2002,59-87
[81] A. C. Littleton. Structure of Accounting Theory. AAA.1958.35-100
[82] William H. Beaver. Financial Reporting:An Accounting Revolution.(Thirdedition), Prentice-Hall International Inc.1998.
[83]马歇尔著,彭逸林等译.经济学原理.北京:人民日报出版社,2009,421-445
[84] Irving Fisher. The nature of capital and income. London,The Macmillancompany,1906,227-256
[85]希克斯著,薛蕃康译.价值与资本.北京:商务印书馆,1982,234-260
[86] Johnson S, MicMillan J, Woodruf C. Property rights, Finance and Entrepreneurship,CESifo Working paper Series,1999. No.212:23-24
[87]李彦龙.生态经济人——生态文明的建设主体.经济研究导刊,2010,(5):143-145
[88]钟茂初.可持续发展经济学.北京:经济科学出版社,2006,80-86
[89] Qianghua Ling. Competitive strategy, voluntary environmental disclosurestrategy, and voluntary environmental disclosure quality.[Dissertation]:Oklahoma state university,2007,65-78
[90] Buchholz R. Principles of environmental management. The greening of business.Prentice-hall Engle-cliffs. NJ,1993.29-46
[91] Welford R J. Case in environmental management and Business trategy, London:Pitman,1994
[92] Hamilton. J. Pollution as news: media and stock reaction to the toxic releaseinventory data. Journal of environmental economics and management,1995,(28):98-113
[93] Marcus A.Business and society.Ethic,strategy,and the global economy.Irwin:Chicago IL,1996,9-15
[94] WBCSD. Environmental performance and shareholder value.WBCSD.Geneva,1997,11-13
[95][美]莱斯特·R·布朗著,林自新等译.生态经济.北京:东方出版社,2002,1-4
[96]张长江,彭思瑶.生态收益的确认问题探索.绿色财会,2009,(10):3-7
[97]葛家澍,窦佳春,陈朝琳.财务会计计量模式的必然选择:双重计量.会计研究,2010,(2):7-13
[98]曹越,伍中信.产权保护、公允价值与会计改革.会计研究,2009.(02):11-15
[99]查特菲尔德著,文硕等译.会计思想史.北京:中国商业出版社,1989.145-146
[100]伍中信,曹越.产权保护、三域秩序与审计信息真实性.会计研究,2007,(12):82-88
[101] Douglas S Beets, Christopher C. and Souther. Corporate EnvironmentalReports:The Need for Standards and an Environmental Assurance Service,Accounting Horizon,1999,19(2):129-145
[102] Tanya M Lee and Paul D Hutchison. The Decision to Disclose EnvironmentalInformation: A research Review and Agenda. Advance in Accounting,2005.Vol21,83-111
[103]阿兰·斯密德著,刘灿等译.制度与行为经济学.北京:中国人民大学出版社出版,2002,235-236
[104] Bebbington J, Gray R. An account of sustainability: Failure, success and areconceptualisation. Critical Perspectives on Accounting,2001.12(5),557–605.
[105] Owen, D L. Green reporting: Accountancy and the challenge of the nineties.Melbourne: Chapman and Hall.1992
[106] Cook, A. Emission rights: From costless activity to market operations.Accounting, Organizations and Society,2009.34(3–4):456-468.
[107] Sio Nyquist. Accounting theory and environmental reports. Eco-management&Auditing,2000,(7):178-185
[108] John A.Mathew, Hao Tan. Progress toward a circular economy. Journal ofIndustrial Ecology,2011,(3):435-457
[109] McIntyre, R.J, Thornton, J R. On the environmental efficiency of economicsystems. Soviet Studies,1978,(30):173–192
[110] Schaltegger S, Sturm, A. Environmental rationality. Die Unternehmung1990,(4),117–131
[111] United Nations Conference on Trade and Development. IntegratingEnvironmental and Financial Performance at the Enterprise level: A Methodologyfor standardizing Eco-efficiency Indicators. United Nations Publication,2003,29-30
[112] Hoffren J. Measureing the Eco-efficiency of Walfare Generation in a nationalEconomy, The Case of Finland. Research Reports233, Statistic Finland,Helsinki2001
[113] Stigson B. A Road to Sustainable Industry: How to Promote Resource Efficiencyin Companies. Dusseldor:World Business Council for Sustainable Development(WBCSD), A Speech in Second Conference on Eco-efficiency,2001,88-90
[114] Schaltegger, S, Burritt, R. Contemporary Environmental Accounting-Issues.Concepts and Practice. Sheffield: Greenleaf Publishing,2000,77-90
[115]孙铮,吴茜.经济增加值:盛誉下的思考.会计研究,2003(8):7-13
[116] World Business Council for Sustainable Development (WBCSD). MeasuringEco-efficiency: A Guide to Reporting Company Performance. WBCSD,2000,65
[117] Huppes, G, Ishikawa, M. Eco-efficiency and its terminology. Journal ofIndustrial Ecology,2005,(4):43–46.
[118] Blank, H, Daniel, W.The Eco-efficiency Anomaly. New York:QED International,2002,18-29
[119] Ekins, P. Eco-efficiency motives, drivers, and economic implications. Journal ofIndustrial Ecology,2005,(4):12–14.
[120] Helminen. Eco-efficiency in Finnish and Swedish Pulp and Paper Industry.Actapolytechnica Scandinavica, Mathematics Computing and Management inEngineering Series,1998,No90
[121] Hukkinen J. From groundless universalism to grounded genersalism:Improvingecological economic indicators of human-environmental interaction. EcologicalEconomics,2003,(44):11-27
[122] Jukka Hoffren, Eeva-Lotta Apajalahti. Emergent Eco-Efficiency Paradigm inCorporate Environmental Management. Sustainable development.2008,(6):1-11
[123] Timo Kllosmanen, Mika Kortelainen. Measuring Eco-efficiency of Productionwith Data Envelopment Analysis. Journal of Industrial Ecology,2005,(4):59-72
[124] William Young, Fiona Tilley. Can Businesses Move Beyond Efficiency? TheShift toward Effectiveness and Equity in the Corporate Sustainability Debate.Business Strategy and the Environment,2006,1(5):402-415
[125] Gray R, Bebbington J. Environmental accounting, managerialism andsustainability: is the planet safe in the hands of business and accounting?Advances in Environmental Accounting and Management,2000,(11):145-150
[126] Jaggi, B, Freedman, M. An analysis of the informational content of pollutiondisclosures. Financial Review,1982,(9):142–152
[127] Jaggi, B, Freedman, M. An examination of the impact of pollution performanceon economic and market performance: Pulp and paper firms. Journal ofBusiness Finance and Accounting,1992,(9):697–713.
[128] Stevens, W. Market reaction to corporate environmental performance. Advancesin Accounting,1984,(1):41–61
[129] Klassen, R, Mclaughlin, C.The impact of environmental management on firmperformance. Management Science,1996,(8):1199–1214
[130] Berthelot, S, Comier, D, Magnan, M. Environmental disclosure research:Review and synthesis. Journalof Accounting Literature,2003,(22):1–44.
[131] Hassel, L, Nilsson, H, Nyquist, S.The value relevance of environmentalperformance. European Accounting Review,2005,14(5):41–61.
[132] Welford R. Hijacking Environmentalism. Corporate Responses to SustainableDevelopment. Earthscan: London.1997,11-23
[133]崔兆杰,张凯等:循环经济理论与方法.北京:科学出版社,2008,12-89
[134] Jukka Hoffren, Eeva-Lotta Apajalahti. Emergent Eco-Efficiency Paradigm inCorporate Environmental Management. Sustainable Development.2008,(6):1-11
[135]亚当斯密.国民财富的性质和原因的研究.北京:商务印书馆,2005,77-200
[136]肖淑芳,胡伟.我国企业环境信息披露体系的建设.会计研究,2005,(5):33-40
[137] Gray,R, D L Owen and C Adams. Accounting and accountability: changes andchallenges in corporate social and environmental reporting. Prentice hall,1996
[138]辞海,上海:上海辞书出版社出版.1981,第4版,1287-1289
[139]袁广达.环境会计与管理路径研究.北京.经济科学出版社,2010,12-13
[140]沈满洪.生态经济学.北京:中国环境科学出版社,2008,33-170
[141]王孟本.生态环境概念的起源与内涵.生态学报,2009,(9):21-24
[142] Espen Sjaastad et al.What is environmental income? Ecological Economics,2005,(55):37-46
[143]杨世忠,曹梅梅.宏观环境会计核算体系框架构想.会计研究,2010,(8):9-15
[144]李建发,肖华.我国企业环境报告:现状、需求与未来.会计研究,2002,(4):42-50
[145]肖序.环境会计理论与实务研究.大连:东北财经大学出版社,2007,22-90
[146] Bringer R P, Benforage,D M.Pollution prevention and total qualityenvironmental management In Kolluru, Environmental Strategies Handbook: Aguide Effective policies and Practices,New York:McGraw-Hill,1994,165-188
[147] Makower J.The E Factor: The bottom-line Approach to EnvironmentallyResponsible Business. New York:Random House,1993,33-48
[148] Craig,E. Reaching for customer satisfaction through environmental programs.Corporate quality environmental management II.Global Environmentalmanagement Initiative, Washington D C,1992
[149] Hall,J R. Recycling Waste into profit. In Alster,J. Brothers,T.(Eds),Business:Championing the Global Environment, The conference Board, New York,1992,11-13
[150]肖序.建立环境会计的探讨,会计研究,2003,(11):46-54
[151] Gollop F M, Robert M J. Environmental Regulations and Productivity growth:the case of fossiled-fuel electric power generation. Journal of PoliticalEconomy,1983,91(4):654-674
[152] Dufour C,Lanoie.P, Party.M. Regulation and Productivity in the Quebecmanufacturing sector. Journal of Productivity,1998.(9):233-240
[153] Berman E, Bui L.Environment regulation and Productivity: Evidence from oi1Refineries. The review of economics and statistic,2001,88(3):498-510
[154] Cole E J, Brozovsky and K Kubin.Disclosure of environmental liabilities in theUSA; A research note. Proceeding of the Midatlantic AAA Regionalmeeting,1994,41-42
[155]傅京燕.环境成本内部化与产业国际竞争力.中国工业经济,2002,(6):37-44
[156]肖序.环境会计理论与实务研究.大连:东北财经大学出版社,2007,99-100
[157]程宏伟,冯茜颖,王艳.自然契约、生态利润与企业可持续发展.中国工业经济,2010,(5):88-96
[158]刘思华.刘思华可持续经济发展文集.北京:中国财政经济出版社,2007,3-100
[159] Ning DT. An assement of the economic loses resulting from various forms of theenvironmental degradation in China. Available online,http://www. Library.utoronto.ca/pcs/state/chinaeco/grass/.htm,2005
[160] Georgescu-Roegen,N. Energy and economic myths.Southern Economic journal,1975,(41):347-381
[161] Anna Straton.A complex system approach to the value of ecological resources.Ecological Economics,2006,(56):402-411
[162] Frank Boons, Marcus Wagner. Assessing the relationship between economic andecological performance: Distinguishing levels and the role of innovation.Ecological Economics,2009,(02):1-7
[163]张长江.生态效益外部性会计信息披露模式研究.财会通讯(综合版),2010,(3):27-29
[164]哈耶克,邓正来编译.哈耶克论文集.北京:首都经济贸易大学出版社,2001,9-200
[165]谢诗芬.高级财务会计问题研究.成都:西南财经大学出版社,2000,66-100
[166]玛丽E巴斯.将对未来的估计包含在今天的财务报表中.会计研究,2007,(9):3-12.
[167]刘梅娟.试论环境会计对会计理论的贡献.林业财务与会计,2004,(6):4-5
[168]王兴元,于伟,Fuan li.栖息地特征、市场分布结构及其与企业经营绩效关系实证研究.中国工业经济,2010,(1):22-30
[169] Desrochers, P. Industrial Symbiosis: The Case for Market Coordination. Journalof Cleaner Production,2004,(12);24-38
[170] Heeresa et al. Eco-industrial Park Initiatives in the USA and the Netherlands:FirstLessons. Journal of Cleaner Production,2004,(12):8-12.
[171] Bennet, S, Freierman, R, and George, S.Corporate realities and environmenttruth: Strategies for leading your business in the environmental era. New York:John Wiley&Sons, Inc,1993,112-320
[172] Denton, D K. Enviro-management: How smart companies turn environmentalcosts into profits. New jersey:Engle-wood Cliffs, Prentice hall,1994,100-126
[173] Jackson, T.nClean production strategies: Developing preventive environmentalmanagement in the industrial economy. Bocaraton:Lewis publishers,1993,27-89
[174] McInerny, F and White S.The total Quality Corporation: How10majorcompanies turning quality and environmental challenge to competitiveadvantage in the1990’s. New york:Penguin Books,1995,44-87
[175] Schrivastava, P. Environmental technologies and competitive advantages.Strategic management Journal,1995,16,(2):183-200
[176] Schmidheiny S. Changing course: A global Business perspective. Camprdige:MIT press,1992,35-40
[177] Poduska R, Forbes R and Bober M. Toward a new conception of theenvironmentn competitiveness relationship. New york:Penguin Books,1992,12
[178] Sarkis J and Rasheed A. Greening the manufacturing function. Businesshorizon,1995,38(5):17-27
[179] Epstein M J and Wisner P S. Managing and controlling environmentalperformance: evidence from Mexico. Advance in management accounting,2005,(14):115-137
[180] Wisner P S, Epstein M J, Bagozzi R P. Organizational antecedents andconsequences of environmental performance. Advance in environmentalaccounting and management,2006,(3):143-167
[181]黄兴文,陈百明.中国生态资产区划的理论与应用.生态学报,1999,(5):602-606
[182]王健民,王如松.中国生态资产概论.南京:江苏科学技术出版社,2001,7-8
[183]胡聃.从生产资产到生态资产:资产—资本完备性.生态学报,2004,(2):289-295
[184]温作民.森林生态会计研究.北京.科学出版社,2008
[185]夏光,周新,高彤编著.中日环境政策比较研究.北京,中国环境科学出版社,1999,59-60
[186]蔡都阳,王美艳.经济发展方式转变与节能减排内在动力,经济研究,2008(6)
[187] Frosch,D, Gallopoulos, N. Strategies for manufacturing. Scientific American261,1989,-102
[188]赵忠令,周荣华.成本-效益分析:探视道德行为的新视角.苏州大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2004,(2)3-7。
[189]中国社会科学院工业经济研究所课题组.中国工业绿色转型研究.中国工业经济,2011,(04):5-14。
[190] Dufour C,Lanoie P, Party M. Regulation and productivity in the Quebecmanufacturing sector. Journal of Productivity,1998,(09):233-240.
[191] Lanen W N.Waste minimization at3M Company: A field study in nonfinancialperformance measurement.Journal of Management Accounting Research,1999,(11):29–43.
[192] Zetlin, M. The greening of corporate America.Management Review,1990,l79(6):10-17
[193] Klassen. The implication of environment management strategy formanufacturing performance.[dissertation]:University of North Carolina atchapel hill,1995,89-91
[194] Stead, E and Stead, J. An empirical investigation of sustainability strategyimplementation in industry organization in post JE, Research in corporate socialperformance and policy.JAI press, Greenwich. Ct.1995,43-66,
[195] Jaffe,Peterson,Portney.Environmental regulation and the competiveness of U.Smanufacturing.what does the evidence tells us. Journal of economic literature,1995,133(6):132-163
[196]黄德春,陈洁.垂直合约与产业环境贸易政策——环境成本内部化及中国的策略选择.中国工业经济,2007,(07):72-79。
[197]杜龙政,汪延明,李石.产业链治理架构及其基本模式研究.中国工业经济.2010,(3):108-117
[198]吴玉萍.环境经济学与生态经济学学科体系比较.林业经济,2001(10):16-18
[199] Dunn B C, Steinemann A. Industrial ecology for sustainable communities.Journal of Environmental Planning and Management,1998,41(6):661–672
[200] Henriques I, Sadorsky,P. The determinants of firm that formulate environmentplans,in post JE(ed), Research in corporate performance(66-97),JAE pressInc,CT,1995,66-97
[201] Gladwin,Kennelly,Krame T. Shifting paradigm for sustainable development:Implication for management theory and research.Academy of managementreview.1995,20(4):874-907
[202] Hart S L. A natural based view of the firm.Academy of management review,1995,20(12):986-1014
[203] Shrivastava P. The role of corporation in achieving ecological sustainability.Academy of management review,1995,20(4):934-960
[204] Reinhardt F L. Environmental product differential: Implication for corporatestrategy. California management Review,1998,40(4):43-73
[205] Stefan Schaltegger, Frank Figge. Environmental shareholder value: Economicsuccess with corporate environmental management. Eco-Management andAuditing,2000,(7):29-42
[206] Buchholz R. Principles of environmental management. The greening of business.Prentice-hall Engle-cliffs. NJ,1993,124-165
[207] Welford R J.Case in environmental management and businessstrategy.Pitman,london,1994,110-150
[208] Searcy C,McCartney D,&Karapetrovic, S. Identifying priorities for action incorporate sustainable development indicator programs.Business Strategy and theEnvironment,2008,(17):137–148.
[209] Carol A Adams, Geoffrey R. Frost. Integrating Sustainability reporting intomanagement practices. Accounting Forum,2008,(32):288-302
[210] Cohen-Rosenthal E. What is eco-industrial development? In Eco-IndustrialStrategies: Unleashing the Synergy between Economic Development and theEnvironment, Cohen-Rosenthal E, Musnikow J (Eds). Sheffield: Greenleaf,2003.14–29.
[211] Niutanen V, Korhonen J. Towards a regional management system–wastemanagement scenarios in the Satakunta Region, Finland. International Journalof Environmental Technology and Management,2003,3(2):131–156.
[212] Hart S L. Beyond Greening: Strategies for a Sustainable World. HarvardBusiness Review,1997,(1):67-76
[213] Nicole Darnall,Inshik Seol and Joseph Sarkis. Perceived Stakeholder Influencesand Organizations’ use of Environmental Audits. Accounting, Organization andSociety,2009,(34):170-187
[214] Waddock, S A,&Graves, S. B. Finding the link between stakeholder relationsand quality of management. Journal of Investing,1997,(6):20–24.
[215] Tilley, F. Small-firm environmental strategy: The UK experience. GreenerManagement International,1999,(25):1–14.
[216] Zutshi, A.&Sohal, A. S. Adoption and maintenance of environmentalmanagement systems: Critical success factors. Management of EnvironmentalQuality: An International Journal,2004,(15):399–419.
[217] Cordano, M and Frieze, I H. Pollution reductionpreferences of USenvironmental managers: Applying Ajzen’s theory of planned behavior.Academy of Management Journal,2000,(43):627–641.
[218] Stefan Schaltegger. Information cost, quality of information and stakeholderinvolvement: The necessity of international standards of Ecological accounting.Eco-Management and auditing,1997,(7):81-97
[219] Freeman, R E. Management: A stakeholder approach.Boston, MA: Pitman.1984,22-30
[220] Fineman, S, and Clarke, K. Green stakeholders: Industry interpretations andresponse. Journal of Management Studies,1996,(33):715–730.
[221] Khanna M and D Zilberman. Incentives, PrecisionT echnologya ndEnvironmental Protection. Ecological Economics,1997,(23):25-43.
[222] Altman, M. When Green Isn't Meaning: Economic Theory and the Heuristics ofthe Impact of Environmental Regulations on Competitiveness and OpportunityCost.Eco-logical Economics,2001,(36):31-44.
[223]徐祥民.美国水污染法的调控机制.环境保护,2005,(12):70-73
[224]虞磊珉,王刚.美国“超级基金”中环境法律责任分析及实践应对.环境保护,2004,(7):59-62
[225] Robert Costanza et al. Value of the world:ecosystems service and capital. Nature,1997,38(7):253-260.
[226] Ytterhus B E, Sjaker. O C. Grip barometeret”98”; enkartlegging av miljetilpasningI, result from the Nordic environmental barometer. Eco-management andauditing,1998,(3):30-36
[227] Hollander.E. Maste det Forbli segt?GRI Repport1998;2-6
[228] Neu D, Warsame H, Pedwell K. Managing public impressions: environmentaldisclosures in annual reports. Accounting Organization and society.1998,23(3):265-282
[229] Azzone G, Noci G, Manzini R, Welford R. Young W. Defining EnvironmentalPerformance Indicators: An Integrated Framework. Business Strategy and theEnvironmental1996,5(2):69-80
[230] Young W, Welford R. An Environmental performance Measurement Frameworkfor Business. GMI1998.21(spring):30-49
[231] Ingram R, Fraizer K. Environmental performance and corporate disclosure.Journal of Accounting Research,1980,8(2):21-28
[232] Lorraine, N H J,Collison D J, Power D M. An analysis of the stock marketimpact of environmental performance information. Accounting Forum,2004,(28):7-26
[233] Shane, P B, and Spicer, B H. Market response to environmental informationproduced outside the firm.The Accounting Review,1983,(18):521–538
[234] Spicer, B H. Investors, corporate social performance and information disclosure:An empirical study.The Accounting Review,1978,(13):94–111.
[235] Spicer, B H. Market risk, accounting data and companies’ pollution controlrecords. Journal of Business Finance and Accounting,1978,(5):67–83.
[236] Chen K H,&Metcalf, R W. The relationship between pollution control recordand financial indicators revisited. The Accounting Review,1980,(15):168–177.
[237] Stevens W. Market reaction to corporate environmental performance. Advancesin Accounting,1984,(1):41–61.
[238] Blacconiere, W&Patten, D. Environmental disclosures, regulatory costs, andchanges in firm value.Journal of Accounting and Economics,1994,(18):357–377
[239] Hughes II K E. The value relevance of nonfinancial measures of air pollution inthe electricity utility industry. Accounting Review,2000,(75):209–228.
[240]周一虹等.中国上市公司环境信息披露的实证分析——以2004年沪市A股827家上市公司为例.南京审计学院学报,2006,(4):22-25.
[241]汤亚莉等.我国上市公司环境信息披露现状及其影响因素的研究.管理世界,2006,(1):158-159
[242]肖淑芳等.我国上市公司环境信息披露现状研究.北京理工大学学报,2004,(5):69-72
[243]李建发,肖华.我国企业环境报告:现状、需求与未来.会计研究,2002,(4):42-50
[244]肖华,张国青.公共压力与公司环境信息披露.会计研究,2008.(5):15-23
[245]龚光明,陈若华.收益计量、产权保护与会计制度改革.会计研究,2012,(7):7-14
[246] Kathleen Hertz Rupley, Darrell Brown, R. Scott Marshall.Governance,mediaand the quality of environmental disclosure.Journal of accounting and publicpolicy,2013,(1):610-840
[247] Seong Y Cho, Cheol Lee and Ray J. Pfeiffer Jr. Corporate responsibilityperformance and information asymmetry,Journal of account and public policy,2013,(32):71-83
[248] Cho, C and Patten, D. The Role of Environmental Disclosures as Tools ofLegitimacy: a Research Note. Accounting, Organization and Society,2007,(32):639-647
[249]陈若华,龚光明.企业生态收益:过程控制与效率.云南财经大学学报,2012,(6):154-160
[250]龚光明,陈若华.生态收益:企业履行生态责任的前提.软科学,2013,(2):99-103
[251]袁亿军,耿殿贺.环境政策传导机制与中国环保产业发展.中国工业经济,2010,(10):22-31
[252]温素彬.企业三重绩效的层次变权综合模型——基于可持续发展战略的视角.会计研究,2007,(10):82-87
[253] INTOSAI Working Group on Environmental Auditing. Results of the FirstQuestionnaire on Environmental Auditing,1993,7-25
[254] International Chamber of Commerce, An ICC Guide to Effective EnvironmentalAuditing.ICC Publishing, Paris,1991,3-5
[255] Environmental management systems. ISO14001, International Organisation forStandardization,1996.56-57
[256]李学柔等.国际审计,北京:中国时代经济出版社,2001,11-36
[257] Thomson R P,Simpson T E,Grand C H. Environmental auditing. The InternalAuditor,1993,50(2):18-22.
[258] Thompson D,Wilson M J.Environmental auditing: theory and applications.Environmental Management,1994,18(4):605-615.
[259] Black R.A new leaf in environmental auditing.Internal Auditor,1998,55(3):24-27.
[260] Matthew Lloyd, Emerging Opportunities in environmental Auditing.[dissertation],The University of Calgary,2001,22-35
[261]张以宽.论环境审计.中国审计信息与方法,1997,(1):17-19
[262]陈正兴.环境审计.北京:中国审计出版社,2001,7-35
[263]陈思维.环境审计.北京:经济管理出版社,l998,22-100
[264]包强.论环境审计概念结构.审计与经济研究,1999.(4):15-18
[265]李雪,杨智慧.对环境审计定义的再认识.审计研究,2004,(2):22-30
[266]刘长翠.企业环境审计研究.北京:中国人民大学出版社,2005,10-25
[267]黄道国,邵云帆.多元环境审计构建格局研究.审计研究,2011,(3):31-36
[268] Elkington J T. Towards the sustainable corporation: Win-win-win businessstrategies for sustainable development. California management review,1994.36,No.36(2):90-100
[269] Jong Gong Yong. An empirical study of impact of a preventive environmentalstrategy on environmental and organizational performance:[dissertation].University of Nebraska,1997,89-91