基于债权终止风险的可违约债券定价研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
随着我国公司债券、商业票据等市场的快速发展,重点研究可违约债券的定价是投资活动实践以及政府管理工作的客观要求,也是现有理论成果发展的需要。可违约债券市场的流动性风险比较突出,然而现有的定价模型却无法有效地体现流动性风险及其与违约风险的相关性对可违约债券定价的影响。
     本文指出,可违约债券的流动性风险与违约风险具有相同的经济属性,它们都是由事件驱动的风险,可以在“债权终止风险”的框架下统一地表述。债权终止事件是指能够导致可违约债券投资者所享有的债权权利终止的事件,而在债权终止事件发生时会遭受损失的风险就是债权终止风险。债权终止风险包含了违约风险、流动性风险以及二者的风险相关性三方面信息,因此研究可违约债券定价实际上就是研究债权终止风险的定价。
     对可违约债券定价的研究从两个层面上展开:第一,从总体债权终止风险的层面,研究债权终止风险的度量,并基于此讨论可违约债券的定价;第二,从各分项风险的层面上,分别讨论驱动债权终止风险的三个要素对债券定价的影响,具体包括:投资者行为及其结构、债务人的违约决策信息、风险相关性。
     从总体债权终止风险的层面上来看,债权终止风险的大小受到违约时间、出售时间的分布,以及违约时间与出售时间的联合分布影响。提高违约风险与流动性风险的相关性有助于提高债权生存概率,也即降低债权终止概率,从而降低债权终止风险。在此基础上,本文推导了全面包含违约风险、流动性风险以及风险相关性的可违约债券定价模型。可以证明,Duffie和Singleton(1999)模型是本文基于债权终止风险的定价模型在不考虑风险相关性以及投资者行为下的特例。
     从各分项风险的层面上来看,主要有如下结论:
     (1)从流动性风险的视角来看,投资者结构的异质性以及投资者的资产配置行为都会对债权终止风险和债券定价产生影响。研究发现同种类型投资者之间的投资策略的差异越小,具有配置需求的资金量占市场比例越高,两个种类投资者之间的投资策略差异越大,则市场流动性越好。投资者的资产配置效应主导了中国公司债券利差的变动,这与国外以信用风险变化主导的模式有所区别。
     (2)从违约风险的视角来看,债务人的主动违约决策选择会对债权终止风险和债券定价产生影响。债务人从自身的价值最大化角度出发,因避免违约而继续持有公司股票的行为会增进其享有的股东价值,从而在一定环境下会改变其违约决策。以流通期权度量这种价值增值,结果发现在结构化模型中引入流通期权后,新的模型更加稳定,适应噪音信息的能力也更强。
     (3)从风险相关性的角度来看,数值算例和基于中国公司债券市场数据的实证检验凸显了风险相关性对可违约债券定价的影响。发现相关性增强有助于降低投资者总体上承担的债权终止风险,从而提高债券价格。短期内,下尾相关性增强能更加有效地提高债券价格;长期内,上尾相关性更加有效;中期内,尾部相关性对债券价格的影响并不明显。
     提出债权终止风险是本文的一大创新,在此基础上分别从两个层面上考虑了可违约债券的定价。与以往的研究相比,基于债权终止风险建立的定价模型适用范围更广,运算更加灵活。并且充分地考虑了投资者结构及其行为、债务人的违约决策、流动性与违约风险的相关性对可违约债券定价的影响,是对以往研究的发展。
With the rapid growth of coporate bond and commercial notes market inChina, the research on defaultable bond pricing becomes more and moreimportant for both theoritical development and investment application. Theliquidity condition is worse in defaultable bond market than other financialmarkets; however the existing theoritical models cannot effectively involvethe liquidity risk and the correlation between liquidity risk and default risk.
     In this thesis I indicate that liquidity risk and default risk are of the sameattribute as event driven risk. I propose a uniform framework of claimtermination risk to express the both risk. The claim termination risk refers tothe risk that causes bond investors suffer potential loss when their credit claimis terminated, where the events terminate investors’ claim are called claimtermination events. Generally, lot kinds of events could be claim terminationevents, but in this thesis I focus on the most important two events, which aredefault event and sale event. So the claim termination risk in this thesiscontains the information of the following three aspects: default, sale and thecorrelation between default and sale. And the work of pricing of defaultablebond is just to make clear the price of claim termination risk.
     I begin the pricing work at two different levels: first, from the viewpoint of the whole claim termination risk, explain the definition of claimtermination risk and find the measure of this risk, and furthermore propose thepricing formula based on this risk; second, from the viewpoint of sub-riskincluding default risk, liquidity risk and the correlation between these two risk,and then discuss the effect on defaultable bond pricing of the driven factorsbehind these sub-risk, such as investors’ behavior, debtor’s default decisionand risk correlation.
     At the whole risk level, I find that the claim termination risk is affectedby the distributions of default time and sales time and also the jointdistribution of them. The increase of correlation between default time andsales time could help increase the survival probability of the creditor claim,and therefore decrease the claim termination risk. Based on this result Ipropose the analytical pricing formula of defaultable bond considering acomprehensive scope of risk, including default risk, liquidity risk and thecorrelation between them. It can be proved that the pricing model under theframework of claim termination risk is an extension of the classical model inDuffie and Singleton (1999) which is proved to be speciality of my model notconsidering risk correlation and investor’s behavior.
     At the sub-risk level, I find the following main results:
     (1) The investors’ heterogenerity and asset allocation will affect the priceof defaultable bond and the market liquidity. The less the heterogenerityamong the investors of the same class, the more the investors with allocationdemand, the more heterogenerity among the investors of different class, thebetter the bond market liquidity. The spread of defaultable bond in China is dominated by the effect of asset allocation but not credit quality, which isquite different from foreign market, such as American and Eurpean market.
     (2) The debtor’s default decision could be affected by his behavior ofkeeping shareholder status to maximize his value. I propose to measure thiskind of value added with the so called marketability option. I introduce thisoption and extend the traditional structural models to consider the debtor’sactive default choice. Finally I find the extended models are more stable andadaptive to noise information than before.
     (3) The numerical example and empirical results based on Chinesecorporate bond market show that the risk correlation is quite important for thepricing of defaultable bond. The increase of correlation can help decrease thetotal claim termination risk and therefore decrease the bond price. In short run,the lower tail correlation can increase bond price; while the upper tailcorrelation in the long run and nothing in the medium term.
     The main contributions of this thesis are proposition of claim terminationrisk and therefore unify the liquidity risk and default risk. Compared with theexisting research, the pricing model in this thesis is more comprehensive withthe information of investors’ behavior, active default choice and riskcorrelation.
引文
[1] Alexander G, Edwards A, Ferri M.2000. The determinants of trading volume of high-yieldcorporate bonds, Journal of Financial Markets [J],65(3):177–204.
    [2] Almeida H, Campello M, Laranjeira B, Weisbenner S.2009. Corporate debt maturity and the realeffect of the2007credit crisis [J], NBER Working paper No.14990.
    [3] Altman E, Kishore V.1996. Almost Everything You Wanted to Know about Recoveries onDefaulted Bonds [J], Financial Analysts Journal,52(6):57-64.
    [4] Altman E.1968. Financial Ratios, Discriminant Analysis and Prediction of Corporate Bankruptcy[J], Journal of Finance,18(1):109-131.
    [5] Amato J, Remolona E.2003. The credit spread puzzle [J], BIS Quarterly Review.
    [6] Amihud Y, Mendelson H.1991. Liquidity, maturity, and the yields on US Treasury securities [J],Journal of Finance,46(4):1411–1425.
    [7] Amihud Y.2002. Illiquidity and Stock Returns: Cross-Section and Time‐Series Effects [J].Journal of Financial Markets,5(1):31–56.
    [8] Amman M.2001. Credit valuation: methods, models and applications,2nd edition [M], SpringerPress.
    [9] Avramov D, Jostova G, Philipov A.2007. Understanding changes in corporate credit spreads [J],Financial Analysts Journal,63(2):90-105.
    [10] Barbedo C, Lemgruber E.2009. A down-and-out exchange option model with jumps to evaluatefirms' default probabilities in Brazil [J], Emerging Markets Review,10:179-190.
    [11] Barnhill W, Maxwell W.2002. Modeling Correlated Interest Rate, Spread Risk, and Credit Riskfor Fixed Income Portfolios [J], Journal of Banking and Finance,26(2):347-374.
    [12] Baxter M.2006. Dynamic Modeling of Single-name Credits and CDO Tranches [J], NomuraFixed Income Quant Group working paper.
    [13] Beber A, Brandt M, Kavajecz K.2009. Flight-to-Quality or Flight-to-Liquidity? Evidence fromthe Euro-Area Bond Market [J], Review of Financial Studies,22(3):925-957.
    [14] Bedendo M, Cathcart L, EL-Jahel L.2007. The slope of the term structure of credit spreads: anempirical investigation [J], The Journal of Financial Research,2:237-257.
    [15] Berg J, Candelon B, Urbain J.2008. A cautious note on the use of panel models to predictfinancial crises, Economics Letters,101:80–83.
    [16] Bernardo E, Welch I.2004. Liquidity and Financial Market Runs [J], Quarterly Journal ofEconomics,119(1):135-158.
    [17] Bhamra S, Kuehn A, Strebulaev I.2010. The Levered Equity Risk Premium and Credit Spreads:A Unified Framework [J], Review of Financial Studies,23:645-703.
    [18] Black F, Cox R.1976. Valuing Corporate Securities: Some Effects of Bond Indenture Provisions[]J, Journal of Finance,31:351-367.
    [19] Bohn H, Schwartz M.2002. Stochastical jump and default correlation [J], Journal of financialeconomics,21:156-178.
    [20] Bohn H.2004. The cyclical feature of default probability [J], BIS working paper.
    [21] Brennan J, Schwartz S.1979. A Continuous Time Approach to Pricing Bonds [J], Journal ofBanking and Finance,3:133-155.
    [22] Brockman P, Turtle H.2003. A barrier option frameworkfor corporate security valuation [J],Journal of Financial Economics,67:511-529.
    [23] Briys, Varenne.1997. Valuing Risky Fixed Rate Debt: An Extension, The Journal of Financialand Quantitative Analysis,32(2):239-248
    [24] Brunnermeier M, Pedersen L.2009. Market Liquidity and Funding Liquidity [J], The Review ofFinancial Studies,22(6):2201-2238.
    [25] Bushman L, Vasvari A.2010. Implied Bond Liquidity, working paper
    [26] Carey M..1998. Credit Risk in Private Debt Portfolios, Journal of Finance,1363-1387
    [27] Caruana J. Kodres L.2007. Liquidity in Global Markets, Financial Stability Review [J], Specialissue on liquidity, Banque de France,2007,11.
    [28] Cassard, Marcel, Folkerts,1997. Risk Management of Sovereign Assets and Liabilities. IMFWorking Paper
    [29] Chamon M, Manasse P, Prati A,2007. Can We Predict the Next Capital Account Crisis? IMFStaff Papers,2007,54(2):270-305
    [30] Chang R, Velasco A,2000. Banks, debt maturity and financial crises, Journal of InternationalEconomics,51:169-194.
    [31] Chen H,2010. Macroeconomic Conditions and the Puzzles of Credit Spreads and CapitalStructure [J], Journal of Finance,65(6):2171-2212.
    [32] Chen L, Collin-Dufresne P, Goldstein R,2009. On the Relation Between the Credit Spread Puzzleand the Equity Premium Puzzle [J], Review of Financial Studies,22(6):3367-3409.
    [33] Chen L, Lesmond D, Wei J,2007. Corporate yields spreads and bond liquidity [J], The Journal offinance,62(1):119-149.
    [34] Chen N, Kou S,2009. Credit spreads, optimal structures, and implied volatility with endogenousdefault and jump risk [J], Mathematical Finance,19(3):343-378.
    [35] Cherubini U, Lunga G,2001. Liquidity and Credit Risk [J], Applied Mathematical Finance,8:2,79-95.
    [36] Chowdhry B. Nanda V.1998. Leverage and Market Stability: The Role of Margin Rules and PriceLimits [J], The Journal of Business,71(2):179-210.
    [37] Collin-Dufresne P, Goldstein R, Martin J,2001. The Determinants of Credit Spread Changes [J],The Journal of Finance,56(6):2177-2207.
    [38] Cornett M, McNutt J, Strahan P, Tehranian H.2011. Liquidity risk management and credit supplyin the financial crisis [J], Journal of Financial Economics,101(2):297-312.
    [39] Cox C, Ingersoll E, Ross A.1985. An Intertemporal General Equilibrium Model of Asset Process,Economitrica,53:363-384.
    [40] Dai Q, Singleton K.2003. Term Structure Dynamics in Theory and Reality, Review of FinancialStudies,16:631-78
    [41] Duffie D, Lando D.2001. Term Structures of Credit Spreads with Incomplete AccountingInformation, Econometrica,69(3):633-664.
    [42] Duffie D.1999. Dynamic asset pricing theory [M], Princeton University Press
    [43] Duffie D.1995. What explain the spread of corporate bonds in the US?, Journal of Banking andFinance,16:1359-1378.
    [44] Shimko D, Tejima N, Deventer D.1993. The pricing of risky debt when interest rates arestochastic, The Journal of Fixed Income,3(2):58-65.
    [45] Davies A.2008. Credit Spread Determinants: An85Year Perspective [J]. Journal of FinancialMarkets,11:180-197.
    [46] De-Jong F, Driessen J,2006. Liquidity Risk Premia in Corporate Bond Markets, WorkingPaper.
    [47] Delianedis G, Geske R.2001. The Components of Corporate Credit Spreads: Default, Recovery,Tax, Jumps, Liquidity, and Market Factors, working paper.
    [48] Dick-Nielsen J, Feldhutter P, Lando D.2012. Corporate bond liquidity before and after the onsetof the subprime crisis [J], Journal of Financial Economics,103(2):471-492.
    [49] Driessen J.2005. Is Default Event Risk Priced in Corporate Bonds?, The Review of FinancialStudies,18(1):
    [50] Duffie D, Lando D.2001. Term Structures of Credit Spreads with Incomplete AccountingInformation [J], Econometrica,69:663-664.
    [51] Duffie D, Singleton K.1999. Modeling Term Structures of Defaultable Bonds, Review ofFinancial Stuldies,12:687-720
    [52] Duffie D, Singleton K.1998. Simulating Correlated Defaults, Paper presented at the Bank ofEngland Conference on Credit Risk Modeling and Regulatory Implications, London,21-22.
    [53] Elton E, Gruber M, Agrawal D, Mann C.2001. Explaining the Rate Spread on Corporate Bonds[J], The Journal of Finance,56(1):247-277.
    [54] Ericsson J, Renault O,2006. Liquidity and Credit risk [J], The Journal of Finance,61(5):2219-2250.
    [55] Fama E.1986. Term Premiums and Default Premiums in Money Markets, Journal of FinancialEconomics,17(1):175-196
    [56] Fan Y.2005. Accounting transparency and the term structure of credit spreads [J], Journal ofFinancial Economics,75:53–84.
    [57] Fisher L,1959. Determinants of the risk premiums on corporate bonds. Journal of PoliticalEconomy67:217–237
    [58] Gehr K, Martell F.1992. Pricing efficiency in the secondary market for investment-gradecorporate bonds, Journal of Fixed Income,2(3):24–38.
    [59] Gersbach H, Lipponer A.2000. The Correlation Effect”, University of Heidelberg working paper.
    [60] Geske R, Johnson H.1984. The Valuation of Corporate Liabilities as Compound Options: ACorrection, The Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis,19(2):231-232.
    [61] Geske R.1977. The Valuation of Corporate Liabilities as The Valuation of Corporate Liabilitiesas Compound Options, The Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis,12(4):541-552
    [62] Giesecke,2004. Correlated Default with Incomplete Information, Journal of Banking and Finance,28:1521–1545
    [63] Hibbert A, Pavlova I, Barber J, Dandapani K,2011. Credit spread changes and equity volatility:evidence from daily data [J], Financial Review,46(3):357-383.
    [64] Ho T, Lee S,1986. Term Structure Movements and Pricing Interest Rate Contingent Claims,Journal of Finance,41:1011-29
    [65] Ho T, Singer R.1984. Bond indenture provisions and the risk of corporate debt. Journal ofFinance,41:375-406
    [66] Ho T, Lee S.2004. The Oxford Guide to Financial Modeling: Applications for Capital Markets,Corporate Finance, Risk Management and Financial Institutions [M], Oxford University Press,first edition.
    [67] Houweling P, Vorst A.2002. An Empirical Comparison of Default Swap Pricing Models, ErimReport Series Research in Management, ERS
    [68] Houweling P, Mentink A, Vorst T.2005. Comparing possible proxies of corporate bond liquidity,Journal of Banking&Finance,29:1331-1358.
    [69] Hu L.2002. Essays in Econometrics with applications in Macroeconomic and FinancialModeling:[D]. Yale University
    [70] Huang J, Huang M,2002. How Much of the Corporate-Treasury Yield Spread is Due to CreditRisk?[J], Working Paper.
    [71] Hull and White,2001. Valuing Credit Default Swaps II: Modeling Default Correlations, Journalof Derivatives,8:12-22.
    [72] Ivashina V, Scharfstein D,2010. Bank lending during the financial crisis of2008, Journal offinancial economics,97:319-338.
    [73] Jacoby and Roberts,2003. Default-and call-adjusted duration for corporate bonds, Journal ofBanking&Finance27:2297–2321.
    [74] Jankowitsch R, Mosenbacher H, Pichler S.2002. Measuring the liquidity impact on EMUgovernment bond prices, Working Paper, Vienna University, CCEFM and Bank Austria
    [75] Janosi T, Jarrow R,2002. Yildrim Y, Estimating expected losses and liquidity discounts implicitin debt prices [J], The Journal of Risk,5(1):1-39.
    [76] Jarrow R, Turnbull M,1995. Pricing Derivatives on Financial Securities Subject to Credit Risk,The Journal of Finance,50(1):53-85.
    [77] Jarrow R, Lando D, Turnbull M,1997. A Markov Model for the Term Structure of Credit RiskSpreads, The Review of Financial Studies,10(2):481-523
    [78] Jarrow R, Yu F.2001. Counterparty Risk and the Pricing of Defaultable Securities, Journal ofFinance,56:1765–1799
    [79] Jarrow, R.,2001. Default Parameter Estimation Using Market Prices [J]. Financial AnalystsJournal,57(5):75-92.
    [80] Jeanblanc M. Rutkowski M..2001. Default Risk and Hazard Process [J], working paper
    [81] Jones P, Mason S, Rosenfeld E,1984. Contingent Claims Analysis of Corporate CapitalStructures: An Empirical Investigation, The Journal of Finance,39(3):
    [82] Kim, Ramaswamy, Sundaresan,1993. Does Default Risk in Coupons Affect the Valuation ofCorporate Bonds?: A Contingent Claims Model, Financial Management,22(3):117-131
    [83] Krishnamurthy A,2009. How debt markets have malfunctioned in the crisis [J], NBER Workingpaper, No.15542
    [84] Leland E, Toft B,1996. Optimal capital structure, endogenous bankruptcy, and the term structureof credit spread [J], Journal of Finance,51:987-1019.
    [85] Longstaff F, Schwartz E,1995. A Simple Approach to Valuing Risky Fixed and Floating RateDebt [J], The Journal of Finance,50(3):789-819
    [86] Longstaff F, Mithal S, Neis E,2005. Corporate yield spread: default risk or liquidity risk? Newevidence from the credit default swap market [J], The Journal of finance,60(5):2213-2253.
    [87] Longstaff F,2010. The subprime credit crisis and contagion in financial markets [J], Journal ofFinancial Economics,97(3):436-450.
    [88] Longstaff F, Schwartz M,1995. Valuing Risky Debt: A New Approach, Journal of Finance,789-820.
    [89] Madan and Unal,1998. Pricing the Risks of Default, Review of Derivative Research,121-160
    [90] Mahanti S, Nashikkar A, Marti S, Chacko G, Mallik G,2008. Latent liquidity: A new measure ofliquidity, with an application to corporate bonds, Journal of Financial Economics88:272–298.
    [91] McGinty L.2001. Issue size versus liquidity in credit, J.P. Morgan Fixed Income Research.
    [92] Merton R, Samulson P.1990. Continuous Time Finance [M], Blackwell,298-300
    [93] Merton R,1974. On the Pricing of Corporate Debt: The Risk Structure of Interest Rates [J], TheJournal of Finance,29(2):449-470.
    [94] Nielsen L, Saa-Requejo J, Santa-Clara P.1993. Default Risk and Interest Rate Risk: The TermStructure of Default Spreads, Working Paper, INSEAD
    [95] Perraudin W, Taylor A.2003. Liquidity and Bond Market Spreads, Working Paper
    [96] Persuad A,2002. Liquidity Black Holes and And Why Modern Financial Regulation inDeveloped Countries is making Short-Term Capital Flows to Developing Countries Even MoreVolatile, working papers
    [97] Protter P.1990. Stochastic Integration and Differential Equations [M], Springer-Verlag, NewYork.
    [98] Pye G,1974. Gauging the Default Premium [J], Financial Analysts Journal,30(1):49-52
    [99] Sarig, Warga.1989. Bond price data and bond market liquidity. Journal of Financial andQuantitative Analysis,24(3),367–378
    [100] Tang Y, Yan H,2010. Market conditions, default risk and credit spreads [J], Journal of Bankingand Finance,34(4):743-753.
    [101] Tirole D.2008. Liquidity shortage: theoretical underpinnings [J], Special issue on liquidityBanque de France
    [102] Tychon P, Vannetelbosch V.2005. A model of Corporate Bond Pricing with Liquidity andMarketability Risk [J]. working paper
    [103] Van-der-Voort M.2006. An Implied Loss Model, ABN AMRO Bank and Erasmus UniversityRotterdam working pape
    [104] Xie Y, Liu S, Wu C, Anderson B,2009. The effects of default and call risk on bond duration [J],Journal of Banking&Finance,33(4):1700-1708.
    [105] Xiong W. Yan H.2006,“Heterogeneous Expectations and Bond Markets”, NBER Working Paper.
    [106] Zhang B, Zhou H, Zhu H,2009. Explaining credit default swap spreads with the equity volatilityand jump risks of individual firms [J], The Review of Financial Studies,22:5099-5131.
    [107] Zhou C,2001. The term structure of credit spreads with jump risk [J], Journal of Banking&Finance,2001(25):11,2015-2040.
    [108]曾志坚、罗长青,2008,《股票与债券市场流动性联动的实证研究》,《财经理论与实践》第7期,45-49。
    [109]程功、张维,2008,信息噪音、结构化模型与银行客户风险限额管理,中国管理科学,16(2):30-36.
    [110]程功、张维、熊熊,2007,信息噪音、结构化模型与银行违约概率度量[J],管理科学学报,10(4):38-48.
    [111]冯宗宪、郭伟健、孙克,2009,企业债的信用价差及其动态过程研究[J],金融研究,345(3):54-71.
    [112]李鹏、任兆璋,2006,考虑流动性风险的信用债券定价模型,统计与决策,01
    [113]李鹏、任兆璋,2006,流动性风险对信用债券信用利差期限结构的影响,系统工程理论方法应用,05
    [114]吕素香、周宁东,2009,我国银行间债券市场流动性分析,中南财经政法大学学报,01
    [115]闵晓平、严武、桂荷发、王磊,2009,公司债券流动性溢价研究进展[J].经济学动态,6:103-108.
    [116]时文朝、张强,2009,基于结构突变理论的中国银行间债券市场流动性的长期趋势分析,世界经济,01
    [117]孙克,2010,企业债信用价差动态过程的影响因素研究[J],证券市场导报,07:24-31.
    [118]唐毅亭、韩冬、卢宇荣,2006,公开信息与流动性——基于银行间债券市场的研究,金融研究,09
    [119]吴冲锋、王柱、冯芸,2008,基于资产链的资产定价问题的思考[J],管理科学学报,11(1):1-11.
    [120]张丽芳、刘海龙,2008,机构投资者和中小投资者的博弈均衡分析,系统工程理论与实践2,1-9
    [121]朱世武、许凯,2004,银行间债券市场流动性研究,统计研究,11:41-46

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700