基于模态参数识别的海洋平台结构模型修正技术研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
海洋平台结构长期服役在恶劣的海洋环境中,其安全性和耐久性极其重要,一旦发生事故,不仅造成巨大的经济损失和人员伤亡,而且造成环境污染、生态破坏等不良后果。为了保障海洋平台结构的安全服役,避免重大的恶性事故发生,必须对海洋平台结构在服役期内进行安全与寿命评估。
     一个反映实际结构的评估模型是进行海洋平台结构安全评估的基础,但是按照原始设计资料建立的模型与现役结构之间往往存在误差,解决这一问题的常用手段是模型修正技术。然而传统的模型修正方法多存在一些缺点(如矩阵型方法无法保持系统矩阵的对称性、稀疏性和正定性,使得修正后模型缺乏物理意义;而基于灵敏度的设计参数型方法多需要进行迭代求解,计算负担较重),很难应用于大型的海洋平台结构中。而交叉模型交叉模态(CMCM)方法不仅能弥补传统方法的不足,且具有其它诸多优点,因此更有希望应用于海洋平台结构的模型修正中。
     海洋工程结构通常比较复杂,建模的不确定性较多,但受测试条件的限制,实测信息往往非常有限,且受到噪声的干扰,这使得模型修正方法在实际工程中的应用受到了很大的限制,其中亟待解决的问题有:1)修正参数的选择;2)模型修正病态系统的求解;3)节点及边界条件的修正等。而CMCM方法要推向实际应用也面临着以上难题。
     本文结合海洋平台结构的特点,在国内外有关研究成果的基础上对CMCM方法在实际应用中所面临的难点问题进行了较为深入的研究,具体包括以下内容:
     1.从灵敏度分析的角度,研究了修正参数的优化选择问题,提出了一个基于灵敏度分级的多阶段模型修正方法。通过对初选修正参数进行灵敏度分析,并排序分级,可以优选修正参数,一定程度上改善了修正方程的病态性;通过对排列分级的修正参数逐级求解,可以提高低灵敏度参数修正求解的精度。通过一导管架平台结构数值算例验证了该方法的可行性。
     2.大型结构的模型修正求解问题多呈现不同程度的病态,实测数据的微小误差都会造成解的振荡。本文研究了测量噪声影响下模型修正病态系统的求解问题。将数学上常用的正则化方法引入到了CMCM方法的求解中,并通过数值算例探讨了正则化求解的适用性;通过得出的适用性条件研究了CMCM方法的噪声鲁棒性。结果显示,适当的正则化方法可以有效的解决模型修正病态系统的求解问题,但需要判断其可解条件——离散Picard条件;另外,在满足修正目的条件下,较少的CMCM方程将呈现更好的噪声鲁棒性。
     3.将CMCM方法发展到了约束边界和桩基边界这两种典型边界条件的模型修正中。对于通常没有任何振型信息的边界单元,提出仅用频率信息对其进行修正,避免了上部结构的振型误差对边界处修正结果的影响;并采用本文提出的多阶段模型修正方法实现了对上部结构和边界条件的整体修正,从而避免了同时修正中的病态问题。数值算例和试验算例验证了该方法的可行性。
     4.通过一导管架平台缩尺模型试验验证了本文提出的基于灵敏度分级的多阶段模型修正方法和基于正则化求解的CMCM方法具有一定的工程实用性。
     本文的研究成果在一定程度上解决了模型修正技术在实际工程应用中的难点问题,将CMCM方法从理论层面向工程应用层面推进了一步。另外,所提出的基于灵敏度分级的多阶段模型修正方法同样适用于其它模型修正方法,具有广泛的应用意义。
Offshore platform structures always serve in the harsh marine environment. Theirsafety and durability are extremely important. Once the incident occured, not only causedenormous economic losses and casualties, but also caused environmental pollution,ecological damage and other adverse consequences. To protect the safety and to preventthe occurrence of major accidents, the safety assessment is necessary for the offshoreplatform structures during the service.
     An assessment model reflecting the actual structure is the basics for the safetyassessment of the offshore platform structure. But disagreements often exist between themodel and actual structure. Model updating is a common method to improve it. However,the traditional model updating methods more or less have some defects, which limit theirapplication in the large offshore platform structures. In contrast, Cross Model Cross Mode(CMCM) method is more promising to applicate in it because of its advantages.
     Because of the complexity of offshore platform structures, there are manyuncertainties in modeling. However, measured data is very limited and containing noise,which limits the practical application of the model updating methods. Problems to besolved contains:1) the selection of updating parameters,2) ill-conditioned problems ofmodel updating,3) model updating of boundaries, etc. While CMCM method is alsofaced with the ablve problems in practical application.
     Considering the characters of offshore platform structures, the difficult problems ofCMCM method faced in the practical applicating are researched based on those existingin the literature. Major contend in this thesis are summarized as follows:
     1. The selection of updating parameters is researched from the angle of sensitivityanalysis. A multi-steps model updating method based on sensitivity grading is proposedin this thesis. In the method, parameters can be properly selected by sensitivity analysisand grading, which can also improve the ill-condition of model updating equations. Basedon the sensitivity grading results, the selected paramenters can be updated step by step,which can improve the solving accuracy of the low sensitivity parameters. A numericalexample of a jacket structure verified the feasibility of the method.
     2. Model updating equations of large structures always presents ill-condition. Smallerrors in the measured data will cause oscillation of the solutions. In this thesis, thesolution of ill-conditioned problems with noisy data is researched. Regularization methods commonly used in mathematics are introduced to CMCM method. Theapplicability is verified through a numerical example, and then the noise robustness ofCMCM method is discussed based on the application conditions. Results indicate thatproper regularization can solve the ill-conditioned model updating problems, but need tojudge the solvability conditions: discrete Picard conditions. In addition, for the sameupdating object, less CMCM equations will have better robustness.
     3. This thesis extends the CMCM method to update the boundary conditions ofconstraint and piles. Because of the lack of modal shapes near the boundary, onlyfrequencies are used in the updating procedure, which can avoid the influence of shapeerrors of the upper nodes. And also, multi-steps mehod is used to update the wholestructre (including the boundary and the superstructure), which can avoid theill-conditioned problem. Numerical and experimental examples verified the feasibility ofthe method.
     4. Experimental study of a steel jacket scale model is conducted. Model updatingresults verified the practicability of the methods proposed in the thesis.
     To some extent, this thesis solved the difficult problems of model updating faced inthe practical applicating and advanced the CMCM method form the theory level to theenginering applicating level. The multi-steps updating method based on sensitivitygrading presented in this thesis is also applicable to other method and has greatersignificance.
引文
[1]王俊荣.海洋平台结构物损伤检测与模型修正方法研究.[博士学位论文].青岛:中国海洋大学,2009
    [2]杜青,蔡美峰,张献民,李晓会.钢筋混凝土桥梁结构动力有限元模型修正.公路交通科技,2006,23(1):60~62
    [3]邓苗毅,任伟新.基于实验挠度、转角和曲率的细长梁分段抗弯刚度识别研究.实验力学,2007,22(5):483~488
    [4] Gravity S I. An analytical procedure for orthgonalization of experimentally measured modes.JAS,1958,25(11):721~722
    [5] Rodden W P. A method for deriving structural influence coefficient from ground vibration tests.AIAAJ,1967,5(5):991~1000
    [6] Mc-Grew J. Orthogonalization of measured modes and calculation of influence coefficients.AIAA J,1969,7:774~776
    [7] R.L.Fox, M.P.Kapoor. Rate of change of eigenvalues and eigenvectors. AIAAJ,1968,12(6):2426~2429
    [8] Friswell M I, Mottershead J E. Finite Element Model Updating in Structural Dynamics. KluwerAcademic Publishers,1995
    [9] Berman A. Mass matrix correction using an incomplete set of measured models. AIAAJ,1979,17(10):1147~1148
    [10] Baruch M. Optimal correction of mass stiffness matrix using measured modes. AIAAJ,1982,20(11):1623~1626
    [11] Dai H, Lancaster P. Linear matrix equation from an inverse problem of vibration theory. LinearAlgebra Appl,1996,246:31~47
    [12] Wei F S. Analytical dynamic model improvement using vibration test data. AIAAJ,1990,28(1):175~177
    [13]魏来生.结构有限元动态模型修正方法综述.振动与冲击,1998,17(3):43~46
    [14]张德文,魏阜旋,张欧骐.实用完备模态空间中的相容修正模型.振动工程学报,1989,2(4):33~40
    [15] Zhang D W, Zhang L M. Matrix transformation method for updating dynamic model. AIAAJ,1992,30(5):1440~1443
    [16]朱安文,曲广吉,高耀南.结构模型修正技术的发展.力学进展,2002,32(3):337~346
    [17] Kabe A M. Stiffness matrix adjustment using mode data. AIAAJ,1985,23(9):1431~1436
    [18] Smith S W, Beattie C A. Secant-method adjustment for structural models. AIAA J,1991,29(1):119~126
    [19]李书,卓家寿,任青文.广义逆特征值方法在动力模型修正中的应用.振动与冲击,1998,17(2):63~66
    [20]张德文,李应明.一种普遍性的元素型修正法——排列方程法.强度与环境,1989,6:9~15
    [21]张德文,Wei F S,李应明.修正动力分析模型的最优元素型摄动法.振动工程学报,1988,1(4):97~105
    [22] Natke H G, Cottin N. Updating mathematical models on the bases of vibration and model testresults—a review of experience. Proc.of4th IMAC,1986
    [23]夏益霖.基于试验模态参数的结构有限元模型修正.振动与冲击,1993,12(1):61~65
    [24]李书,冯太华,范绪箕.动力模型修正中的逆特征值问题的数值解法.计算结构力学及其应用,1995,12(3):276~279
    [25]李书,冯太华,范绪箕.静力模型修正的逆特征值方法.工程力学,1996,13(2):92~96
    [26] Schedlinski C. Computational model updating of large scale finite element models. Proc.Of18th IMAC,2000
    [27] Caesar B. Updating system matrices using modal test data. Proc.Of5th IMAC,1987
    [28] Hu, S.-L.J., Li, H., and Wang, S. Cross-model cross-mode method for dynamic systems.Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing,2007,21(4):1690~1703
    [29] Huajun Li, Junrong Wang, Sau-Lon James Hu. Using incomplete modal data for damagedetection in offshore jacket structures. Ocean Engineering,2008,25:1793~1799
    [30] Hu, S.-L.J., Li, H. Simultaneous mass, damping, and stiffness updating for dynamic systems.AIAAJ,2007,45(10):2529~2537
    [31]刘东,廖日东,左正兴.分析/实验模型相关及技术若干问题.强度与环境,2003,30(1):23~30
    [32] Titurus B, Friswell M I, Starek L. Damage detection using generic element:Part II damagedetection. Computer and Structures,2003,81:2287~2299
    [33] Collins J D, et al. Statistical identification of structures. AIAAJ,1974,12(2):185~190
    [34] Chen J C, Garba J A. Analytical model improvement using modal test results. AIAAJ,1980,18(6):684~690
    [35] Blakely K D. Selection of measurement and parameter uncertainties for finite element models.Proc.of2th IMAC,1984
    [36] Friswell M I. The adjustment of structural parameters using a minimum variance Estimator.Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing,1989,3(2):143~155
    [37] Mottershead J E, Friswell M I, Ng G H T, Brandon J A. Geometric parameters for finite elementmodel updating of joints and constraints. Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing,1996,10(2):171~182
    [38] Zhang Q, Lallement G. A complete procedure for the adjustment of a mathematical modal fromthe identified complex modes. Proc.of5th IMAC,1987
    [39]宋汉文,王丽炜,王文亮.有限元模型修正中若干重要问题.振动与冲击,2003,22(4):68~79
    [40] Friswe U M I, Mottershead J E, Ahmadian H. Finite-element model updating usingexperimental test data: parametrization and regu1arization. Phil. Trans.R.Soc. Lond.2001,359:169~186
    [41] H.Ahmadian, J.E. Mottershead and M.I. Friswell. Regularisation methods for finite elementmodel updating. Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing,1998,12(1),47~64
    [42]吴颉尔.正则化方法及其在模型修正中的应用.[博士毕业论文].南京:南京航空航天大学,2007
    [43]王振杰.大地测量中不适定问题的正则化解法研究.[博士学位论文].北京:中国科学院测量与地球物理研究所.2003
    [44] Tikhonov A N. Solution of incorrectly formulated problems and the regularization method.Soviet Math, Dokl,1963,4:1035~1038
    [45] L.D.Phillips. A technique for the numerical solution of certain integral equations of the firstkind. Journal of the Association of Computational Machining,1962,9:84~97
    [46] J.M. Varah. Pitfalls in solution of linear ill-posed problems. Journal of Scientific and StatisticalComputation,1983,4:164~176
    [47] Ahmadian H, Mottershead J E, Friswell M I. Regularization methods for finite updating.Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing,1998,12(1):47~64
    [48] Mares C, Friswell M I, Mpttershwad J E. Model updating using robust estimation. MechanicalSystems and Signal Processing,2002,16(1):169~183
    [49] Calvetti D, Reichel L, Sgallari F and Spaletta G. A regularizing lanczos iteration method forunderdetermined linear systems. Journal of Computational and Applied Mathematics,2000,115:101~120
    [50] Golub G.H, Heath M T, Wahba G. Generalized cross-validation as a method for choosing agood ridge parameter. Technometrics,1979,21:215~223
    [51] Hansen P C. Analysis of discrete ill-posed problems by means of the L-curve. SIAM Review,1992, l(34):561~580
    [52] J.L. Zapico, M.P. Gonzalez, M.I. Friswell, C.A. Taylar, A.J. Crewe. Finite element modelupdating of a small scale bridge. Journal of sound and vibration.2003,268:993~1012
    [53] J.R.Wu, Q.S.Li. Finite element model updating for a high-rise structure based on ambientvibration measurements. Engineering Structures,26(2004),979~990
    [54] J.R.Wu, Q.S.Li. Structural paramenter identification and damage detection for a steel structureusing a two-stage finite element model updating method. Journal of constructional steelresearch,2006,62:231~239
    [55] Bijaya Jaishi, Hyo-Jin Kim, Moon Kyum Kim, Wei-Xin Ren, Sang-Ho Lee. Finite elementmodel updating of concrete-filled steel tubular arch bridge under operational condition usingmodal flexibility. Mechanical systems and signal processing,2007,21:2406-2426
    [56] T.Aoki, D.Sabia, D.Rivella. Influence of experimental data and FE model on updating results ofa brick chimney. Advances in engineering software,2008,39:327~335
    [57] Ricardo Perera, Antonio Ruiz. A multistage FE updating procedure for damage identification inlarge-scale structures based on multiobjective evolutionary optimization. Mechanical Systemsand Signal Processing.2008,22:970~991
    [58] S.R.Shiradhonkar, Manish Shrikhande. Seismic damage detection in building frame via finiteelement model updating. Computers and Structures.2011,89:2425~2438
    [59] A. Mojtahedi, M.A. Lotfollahi Yaghin, Y. Hassanzadeh, M.M. Ettefagh, M.H. Aminfar, A.B.Aghdam. Developing a robust SHM method for offshore jacket platform using model updatingand fuzzy logic system. Applied Ocean Research,2011,33:398~411
    [60] Dora Foti, Mariella Diaferio, Nicola Ivan Giannoccaro, Michele Mongelli. Ambient vibrationtesting, dynamic identification and model updating of a historic tower. NDT&International,2012,47:89-95
    [61]方志,唐盛华,张国刚,陈素君,董优.基于多状态下静动态测试数据的斜拉桥模型修正.中国公路学报,2011,24(1):34~41
    [62]夏品奇.斜拉桥有限元建模与模型修正.振动工程学报,2003,16(2):219~223
    [63]韩万水,王涛,李永庆,李彦伟,黄平明.大跨钢桁架悬索桥有限元模型实用修正方法.交通运输工程学报,2003,16(2):219~223
    [64]周星德,陈国荣.动态有限元模型修正的一种新方法.振动与冲击.2005,24(2):50~53
    [65]张连振,黄侨.基于优化设计理论的桥梁有限元模型修正.哈尔滨工业大学学报,2008,40(2):246~249
    [66] Masoud Sanayei, Jennifer A.S. McClain. Parameter estimation incorporating modal data andboundary conditions. Journal of Structural Engineering,1999,9:1048~1055
    [67]张敏.固定式海洋结构模型转换与动力特性研究.[博士学位论文].青岛:中国海洋大学,2010
    [68]刘福顺.非比例阻尼条件下海洋平台模型修正与损伤诊断方法研究.[博士学位论文].青岛:中国海洋大学,2008
    [1]王勖成,邵敏.有限单元法基本理论与数值方法.北京:清华大学出版社,2006
    [2]商跃进.有限元原理与ANSYS应用指南.北京:清华大学出版社,2005
    [3] Cook, R.D., Malkus, D.S. and Plesha, M.E. Concepts and Application of Finite ElementAnalysis. John Wiley and Sons, New York, USA,1989
    [4]顾培英,邓昌,吴福生.结构模态分析及其损伤诊断.南京:东南大学出版社,2008
    [5] Guyan, R.j. Reduction of Stiffness and Mass Matrices. AIAAJ.1965,3(2),380
    [6]张德文.模型修正与破损诊断.北京:科学出版社,1999
    [7] Allemang, R.J. and Brown,D.L.. A Correclation Coefficient for Modal Vector Analysis.1stInternational Modal Analysis Conference,1989,17~21.
    [8]吉洪诺夫A.N.不适定问题的解法.北京:地质出版社,1979
    [9]吴颉尔.正则化方法及其在模型修正中的应用.[博士毕业论文].南京:南京航空航天大学,2007
    [10]王振杰.大地测量中不适定问题的正则化解法研究.[博士学位论文].北京:中国科学院测量与地球物理研究所.2003
    [11] Hoerl,A.E., Kennard,R.W. Ridge regression: Biased estimation for non orthogonal problems.Technometrics,1970,12(1):55~67
    [1]吴颉尔.正则化方法及其在模型修正中的应用.[博士毕业论文].南京:南京航空航天大学,2007
    [2] Hu, S.-L.J., Li, H., and Wang, S. Cross-model cross-mode method for model updating.Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing,2007,21(4):1690~1703
    [3] Huajun Li, Junrong Wang, Sau-Lon James Hu. Using incomplete modal data for damagedetection in offshore jacket structures. Ocean Engineering,2008,25:1793~1799
    [4] Hu, S.-L.J., Li, H. Simultaneous mass, damping, and stiffness updating for dynamic systems.AIAA Journal,2007,45(10):2529~2537
    [5] Junrong Wang, Huajun Li, Ping Li, S.-L James Hu. Using Modal Frequencies for DamageAssessment in Offshore Jacket Structures. ISOPE-2010. Beijing
    [6]王俊荣.海洋平台结构物损伤检测与模型修正方法研究.[博士学位论文].青岛:中国海洋大学,2009
    [7]刘福顺.非比例阻尼条件下海洋平台模型修正与损伤诊断方法研究.[博士学位论文].青岛:中国海洋大学,2008
    [8]张敏.固定式海洋结构模型转换与动力特性研究.[博士学位论文].青岛:中国海洋大学,2010
    [1] Friswell M I, Mottershead J E. Finite Element Model Updating in Structural Dynamics. KluwerAcademic Publishers,1995
    [2] Y. Zou, L. Tong, G.P. Steven. Vibration-based model-dependent damage (delamination)identification and health monitoring for composite structures—a review. Journal of Sound andVibration,2(2000):357~378
    [3] N. Stubbs, J.T. Kim, K. Topole. An efficient and robust algorithm for damage localization inoffshore platforms. in: Proceedings of the ASCE10th Structures Congress,1992,543~546
    [4] N. Stubbs, J.T. Kim, C.R. Farrar. Field verification of a non-destructive damage localization andseverity estimation algorithm. in: Proceedings of the13th International Modal AnalysisConference,1995,210~218
    [5] Z.Y. Shi, S.S. Law, L.M. Zhang. Structural damage localization from modal strain energychange. Journal of Sound and Vibration,1998,218(5)):825~844
    [6] Z.Y. Shi, S.S. Law, L.M. Zhang. Structural damage detection from modal strain energy change.Journal of Engineering Mechanics,2000,126(12):1216~1223
    [7] Z.Y. Shi, S.S. Law, L.M. Zhang. Improved damage quantification from elemental modal strainenergy change. Journal of Engineering Mechanics,2002,128(5):521~529
    [8] M. Link, O. Flores-Santiago. Updating and localizing structural errors based on minimisation ofequationerrors. Proceedings of the International Conference on Spacecraft Structures andMechanical Testing,92-9092-126-9, European Space Agency, Noordwijk, The Netherlands(1991) ESASP-321
    [9]朱安文,曲广吉,高耀南,魏震松.结构动力模型修正技术的发展.力学进展,2002,32(3),337~348
    [10]杨琪武,刘祖亭,顾建祖.结构摄动分析和动力修改及其程序的研制.第四届全国振动理论及应用学术会议论文集.郑州:1990.392~399
    [11] Rade D A, Silva L A da, Ment G L. A strategy for the enrichment of experimental data asapplied to an inverse eigen sensitivity-based FE model updating method. Bethel C T ed.Proceedings of the14th International Modal Analysis Conference, Society for experimentalmechanics, Inc.,1996.1078~1085
    [12]于荀宗,彭泽民.运用自由度凝聚进行有限元模型修正.第九届结构动力学学术会议论文集,1995.116~121
    [13] Fox, R.L., and Kapoor, M.P. Rates of change of eigenvalues and eigenvectors. AIAAJ.,1988,6(12),2426~2429
    [14]王振杰.大地测量中不适定问题的正则化解法研究.[博士学位论文].北京:中国科学院测量与地球物理研究所.2003
    [15]陈希孺,王松桂.近代回归分析——原理方法及应用.合肥:安徽教育出版社,1987
    [16]卢秀山.病态系统分析理论及其在测量中的应用.[博士学位论文].武汉:中国科学院测量与地球物理研究所,1999
    [17]郭建峰.测量平差系统病态性的诊断与处理.[硕士论文].郑州:中国人民解放军信息工程大学,2002
    [18]王俊荣.海洋平台结构物损伤检测与模型修正方法研究.[博士学位论文].青岛:中国海洋大学,2009
    [1]吴颉尔.正则化方法及其在模型修正中的应用.[博士毕业论文].南京:南京航空航天大学,2007
    [2] Alvin K F. Finite element model update via Bayesian estimation and minimization of dynamicresiduals. AIAAJ,1997,35(5):879~886
    [3] Hansen P C. The discrete picard condition for ill-posed problems. BIT,1990,30:658~672
    [4] Hansen P. C, Rank-defcient and discrete ill-posed problems. SIAM, Philadelphia,1998
    [5] Calvetti D, Reichel L, Sgallari F and Spaletta G. A regularizing lanczos iteration meathod forunderdetermined linear systems. Journal of Computational and Applied Mathematic,2000,115:101~120
    [6] Tikhonov A N. Solution of incorrectly formulated problems and the regularization method.Soviet Math, Dokl,1963,4:1035~1038
    [7]吉洪诺夫A.N.不适定问题的解法.北京:地质出版社,1979
    [8] Tikhonov A.N, Arsenin V.Y. Solution of ill-posed problems. Wiley, New York,1977
    [9] Friswe U.M.I, Mottershead J.E., Ahmadian H. Finite-element model updating usingexperimental test data: parametrization and regu1arization. Phil. Trans. R.Soc.Lond.2001,359:169~186
    [10] Ahmadian H, Mottershead J.E., Friswell M.I. Regularization methods for finite element modelupdating. Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing,1998,12(1):47~64
    [11] Mares C, Friswell M.I., Mottershead J.E. Model updating using robust estimation. MechanicalSystems and Signal Processing,2002,16(1):169-183
    [12] Hansen P.C.. Truncated SVD solutions to discrete ill-posed problems with ill-determinednumerical rank, SIAM J Sci Statist Comput,1990,11:503~518.
    [13] Hansen P.C. Analysis of discrete ill-posed problems by means of the L-curve. SIAM Review,1992, l (34):561~580
    [14]王振杰.大地测量中不适定问题的正则化解法研究.[博士学位论文].北京:中国科学院测量与地球物理研究所.2003
    [1]张连振,黄侨.基于优化设计理论的桥梁有限元模型修正.哈尔滨工业大学学报,2008,40(2):246~249
    [2] Friswell, M.I.,and Mottershead, J.E..Finite Element Model Updating in Structure Dynamics.Kluwer Academic, Norwell, MA,1995
    [3] Masoud Sanayei, Jennifer A.S. McClain. Parameter estimation incorporating modal data andboundary conditions. Journal of Structural Engineering,1999,9:1048~1055
    [4] Mottershead J E, Friswell M I, Ng H T, et al. Geomtric parameters for finite element modelupdating of joints and constraints. Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing,1996,10(2):171~182
    [5]刘洋,段忠东,周道成.利用一种混合梁单元修正结构半刚性节点及边界条件.振动与冲击,2009,28(9):39~47
    [6] Law S. S, Wu D, Shi Z Y. Model updating of semi-rigid jointed structure using genericparameters. Journal of Engineering Mechnism,2001:1174~1183
    [7] API RP2A-WSD (2000), Recommended Practice for Planning, Designing and ConstructingFixed Offshore Platforms-Working Stress Design,21st ed., American Petroleum Institute
    [8] Gornsheyn, I. Parameter identification of structures using selected modal measurements, MSthesis no.4340, Tufts University, Medford, Mass,1992
    [9]孔德森,栾茂田,杨庆.桩土相互作用分析中的动力Winkler模型研究评述.世界地震工程,2005,21(1):12~17
    [10] M.B.Zaaijer. Foundation modeling to assess dynamic behavior of offshore wind turbines.Applied Ocean Research,2006,Vol28, No2006, pp45-57.
    [11]包兴先.基于模型定阶和信号消噪的海洋平台结构模态参数识别研究.[博士学位论文].青岛:中国海洋大学,2010
    [12]王俊荣.海洋平台结构物损伤检测与模型修正方法研究.[博士学位论文].青岛:中国海洋大学,2009

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700