中国股市噪音成分及其影响因素研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
“噪音”这一概念最初是由包括Kyle在内的有效市场理论的支持者们从物理学界引入金融学界,并首次被界定为“信号”的对立概念。两者间都包含了信息:“信号”中包含的是反映了标的资产基本面或宏观经济政策等指标改变等真实信息;“噪音”中包含的是错误的信息或者无信息。但是,这些最初的研究并没有充分考虑“噪音”对标的风险资产交易价格的影响。随后,面对有效市场理论与现实金融市场大量的显著不符,新兴的行为金融学理论利用了这个概念建立起了噪音理论,认为由于噪音交易行为将噪音成分注入到交易价格中,因此该价格同时反映了“信息”和“噪音”。而基于噪音成分的交易导致市场套利有限,难以达到有效状态。根据噪音成分的形成机制和市场表现,本文将噪音的本质定义为:在金融市场中,一切引起投资者对标的资产现在或未来价值产生误判,并按照错误的定价进行交易的所有因素的总和。“噪音”不仅影响市场上的交易价格,也影响标的资产的交易数量。而且,基于“噪音”的交易包含于成交的每一笔交易之中。围绕着这一概念,本文分别从形成机制、具体表现、度量方法和影响因素检验等方面展开了较为深入的讨论。
     在所有的金融市场中,宏观经济政策、公司基本面改变、信息不对称程度和投资者情绪等因素都在影响着噪音交易的多少,和交易价格中噪音成分的大小,区别只是影响程度的不同而已。
     在中国股票市场上,沪、深两市总市值随经济总量的增加而上涨,但当前阶段中国股票市场上的投资者主要还是由中小投资者构成,虽然机构投资者比例有不断上升趋势。利用EGARCH模型,我们发现两市代表性股指收益率存在明显聚类效应。“利空”消息比“利好”消息会给市场收益率的条件方差产生更大的冲击,存在不对称效应。短期的“羊群效应”和“动量效应”以及长期的“反转效应”显著存在。
     在噪音成分的度量上,本文分别比较分析了以交易价差法和行为资产定价法为代表的直接度量方法和以Jensen'sα、R-S分形法以及Variance-Ratio模型为代表的间接度量方法。我们还对传统的Variance-Ratio模型进行了修正,根据金融市场的实际经验,加入了单位标的风险资产波动对组合或整个市场噪音成分波动的影响权重的考虑,建立了平均方差比(AVR)模型及其检验方法。
     利用R-S分析法以及AVR模型所计算得到的噪音成分指标,结合动态面板模型和系统GMM估计方法,本文比较和检验了不同持有期限两市噪音成分的大小以及影响因素对噪音成分的冲击。发现代表了上市公司基本面的各变量对噪音成分的解释力度较低,而且随着持有期限的加长,无论是影响力度还是系数的显著性都出现了下降的态势。宏观变量对噪音成分的解释力度次之,在长期持续显著。投资者情绪和不对称信息程度对噪音成分的影响最大,长期显著。
     最后,根据全文分析结果,我们对监管当局提出了一定的政策建议,期望能够促进中国证券市场健康发展。
The concept "noise" was firstly introduced into the field of finance from physics by supporters of efficient market theory, including Kyle, and was defined as the opposite of the "signal". Both of these two things involve information, but "signal" contains true information which reflects the change of the foundation of the object or the fluctuation of the macroeconomics situation. On the contrary, "noise" covers wrong or non information. These original researchers did not give enough attention about the impact of the noise to the trading prices of the risky assets. Then, concerning the obvious unconformity between the efficient market theory and the market realities, new emerging behavior financial theory builds up noise trading theory and believes the investors'trading put the noise into the trading prices which reflect both the noise and the information, and then lead to the limitation of arbitrage and make the market hard to be efficient. According to the forming institution and expression of the noise in the market, we define the nature of the noise as the summation of all the factors that result to the investors'mispricing to the objective risky asset and its biased estimation of the future value. "Noise" affects not only the trading prices but also the trading volume in the market, and is involved in every individual trading. Based on this concept, this article makes research and examination from the angles of founding institution, representation, measuring methods, and impacting factors.
     In the financial markets of various countries, macroeconomics situation, foundation of the firms, information asymmetric, and the investors'emotion influence the volume of the noise trading and the noise component involved in the trading prices, and the difference is only about the extent.
     In both Shanghai and Shenzhen stock market, the total market value increased with the economic growth, but most part of the investors are middle and small ones, although the ratio of the institutional investors has a trend of increasing. By means of EGARCH model, we find the yield of the representative portfolio in two markets tend to be clustering. And "bad" information brings more strike to the conditional variance of the portfolio than "good" news, which means the impacts of these two kinds are dissymmetric. In the markets, herding and momentum effect in short run and reversal effect in long run are obvious.
     When measuring the noise, we introduce the direct methods, which include bid-ask spread and behavior asset pricing model, and indirect methods, which include Jensen's a, R-S model and Variance-Ratio model. And we also make amendment about the traditional variance-ratio mode, and build up AVR model and its corresponding examining method.
     By use of the computed noise index from R-S model and AVR model, we analyze and examine the volume and the impact of some variables to the noise of different holding periods, through dynamic panel-data model and system GMM estimation method. We find the explanation from the variables representing the foundation of the firms to the noise is weak and decreasing with the time going, the explanation from the macroeconomic variables is better and obvious in the long run, and the investors' emotion and the information asymmetry have the strongest explanation to the noise and also obvious in the long run.
     Finally, according to the conclusion of this paper, we bring forward some suggestion to those who are in charge of the operation of the China stock market to guarantee the healthy growth of the market.
引文
①根据美国心理学家奈瑟1967年出版的《认知心理学》中观点。该理论主要是研究人们获取信息,处理信息,并作出决策的机制。
    ①数据来源:新浪财经数据库
    ②数据来源:赵丽琼,我国财务困境公司长期绩效研究,2009
    ①Debondt, Werner, Thaler,1985, Does the stock market overreact?, Journal of Finance, pp.793-805.
    ②本章中所涉及的各种股市噪音的表现将在下一章中给出具体说明
    ③此处不考虑信息的时效性以及不同投资者是在不同的时间获得相同的新信息。
    ①引自武任恒,徐冬梅,曾莹,风险投资中的羊群效应的心理学分析,2010.6
    [1]Ariel, R.. A monthly effect in stock returns[J]. Journal of Financial Econmics,1987, 18(2):161-174.
    [2]Albert S. Kyle. Continuous Auctions and Insider Trading[J]. Econometrica, 1985(6):1315-1335.
    [3]Bailey, W., Chung, P., Kang, J. K.. Foreign ownership restrictions and equity price premiums:What drives the demand for cross-border investments?[J]. Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis,1999,34(4):489-511.
    [4]Ball, R (1990), "What Do We Know About Market Efficiency?", The University of New South Wales School of Banking and Finance Working Paper Series No31.
    [5]Banz, R.. The Relation between Return and Market Value of Common Stocks[J]. Journal of Financial Economics,1981,9(1):3-18.
    [6]Barber B. M., Odean T., Zhu N.. Do Noise Traders Move Markets. Working Paper, www. ssrn. com,2006,9.
    [7]Barberis, N., Shleifer, A., Wurgler, J.. Comovement[J]. Journal of Financial Economics,2005,75(2):283-317
    [8]Bhushan, Brown, Mello. Do Noise Traders'Create Their Own Space'?[J]. Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis,1997,32(1):25-45.
    [9]Black. F., Noise[J]. Journal of Finance,1986(41):529-543.
    [10]Brad M. Barber, Terrance Odean, Ning Zhu. Systematic noise[J]. Journal of Financial Market.2009(12):547-569.
    [11]Brett Trueman, A Theory of Noise Trading in Securities Markets[J]. The Journal of Finance.1988(3):83-95.
    [12]Borgers, Sarin. Naive Reinforcement Learning with Endogenous Aspirations[R]. Discussion Paper, University college, London,1995.
    [13]Brown. Volatility, Sentiment, And Noise Traders[J]. Finacial Analysts Journal of Empirical Finance.2004(11):1-27
    [14]Campbell, J. Y., Kyle A. S., Smart Money. Noise Trading, And Stock Price Behavior[J]. Review of Economic Studies,1993, (60):1-34.
    [15]Campbell, JY, AW Lo and AC MacKinlay (1997), The Econometrics of Financial Market, Princeton University Press, Princeton, New Jersey.
    [16]Chakravarty, S., Sarkar, A., Wu, L. F.. Information Asymmetry, Market Segmentation and Pricing Cross-listed Shares:Theory and Evidence from Chinese A and B-share[J]. Journal of international Financial Markets, Institutions and Money,1998,8(3):325-356.
    [17]De Long, J, A Shleifer, LH Summers and R Waldman (1990), "Noise Trader Risk in Financial Markets", Journal of Political Economy,98(4),703-738.
    [18]De Long, J. Bradford, A. Shleifer, L. Summers, R. Waldmann. The Survival of Noise Traders in Financial Market[J], Journal of Business,1991,64(1):1-19.
    [19]Domowitz, I., Glen, J., Madhavan, A.. Market segmentation and stock prices: Evidences from an emerging market[J]. Journal of Finance,1997,52(3): 1059-1085.
    [20]F. Albert Wang. Informed Arbitrage With Speculative Noise Trading. [J]. Journal of Banking&Finance 2010(34):304-313.
    [21]Fama E. F.. The Behavior of Stock-Market Prices[M]. Journal of Business,1965, 38(1):34-105.
    [22]Fama, EF (1970), "Efficient Capital Markets:a Review of Theory and Empirical Work", Journal of Finance,25(1), pp383-417.
    [23]Fama, EF (1991), "Efficient Capital Markets:Ⅱ", Journal of Finance,46(5), 1575-1617.
    [24]Fama, E., French, K.. The Cross-Section of Expected Stock Returns[J]. Journal of Finance,1992,47(2):427-465.
    [25]Fama, EF (1998), "Market Efficiency, Long-term Returns and Behavioral Finance", Journal of Financial Economics,49,283-306.
    [26]Fama, French (2008), "Dissecting Anomalies", Journal of Finance,48(4), 1653-1677
    [27]Friedman M.. Essays in Positive Economics "The Case for Flexible Exchange Rates" [M], Chicago, USA:University of Chicago Press,1953.
    [28]Froot K. and E. Dabora. How are Stock Prices Affected by the Location of Trade?[J]. Journal of Financial Economics,1999(53):189-216.
    [29]Grossman, S. J., Stiglitz, J. E.. On the impossibility of informationally efficient markets. American Economic Review,1980,70(3):393-408.
    [30]Hafiz A.A.B. Hoque, Jae H. Kim, Chong Soo Pyun, A comparison of variance ratio tests of random walk:A case of Asian emerging stock markets [J]. International Rrview of Economics and Finance,2007(16):488-502.
    [31]Hans R. Stoll. Friction. [J]. The Journal of Finance. Vol. LV, No. August 2000: 1479-1514
    [32]Herbert A. Simon, Rationality in Psychology and Economics[J]. The Journal of Business,1986(10):5209-5224.
    [33]Holden, C. W., Subrahmanyam, A.. Long-lived private information and imperfect competition. Journal of Finance,1992,47(1):247-270.
    [34]Jonathan B. Berk (2007), "A Critique of the Efficient Market Hypothesis", working paper
    [35]John H. Cochrance (2007), "Efficient Market Today", working paper
    [36]John H. Cochrance (2010), "Discount Rate",working paper
    [37]Karolyi, A. G, Li, L. F. A.. Resolution of the Chinese Discount Puzzle[J]. Review of Financial Studies,2002,21:156-169.
    [38]K. Geert Rouwenhorst. Inernational Momentum Strategies[J]. The Journal of Finance,1998(2):267-284.
    [39]Kogan L., Ross S. A., Wang Jiang, Westerfield M.. The Price Impact and Survival of Irrational Traders, MIT Sloan School of Management, Working Paper 4293-03. 2003.
    [40]Kyle, A. S.. Continuous auctions and insider trading[J]. Econometrica,1985,53(6): 1315-1335.
    [41]Longsta, F. A.. Optimal portfolio choice and the valuation of illiquid securities [J]. Review of Financial Studies,2001,14(2):407-431.
    [42]Lo, Andrew and C. MacKinlay. Stock Market Prices Do Not Follow Random Walks:Evidence from a Simple Specification Test [J]. Review of Financial Studies, 1988,1(1)41-66.
    [43]Lo, Andrew and C. MacKinlay. The Size and Power of the Variance Ratio Test in Finite Samples:A Monte Carlo Investigation [J]. Journal of Econometrics, 1989(40):203-2381
    [44]Markowitz, H M.. Portfolio Selection[J]. Journal of Finance,1952,7(3):77-91.
    [45]Meredith Beechey, David Gruen and James Vikery (2000), "The Efficient Market Hypothesis:A Survey", research discussion paper
    [46]Merton, R.. Continuous Time Finance (2nd Edition) [M]. Cambridge, Massachusetts (USA):Blackwell Publishers,1992.
    [47]Narasimhan Jegadeesh, Sheridan Titman. Returns to Buying Winners and Selling Losers:Implications for Stock Market Efficiency [J].The Journal of Finance, 1993(1):65-91.
    [48]Pennam, S.. The distribution of earnings news over time and seasonalities in aggregate stock returns[J]. Journal of Financial Econmics,1987,18(2):199-228.
    [49]Rahul Verma, Priti Verma. Noise trading and stock market volatility[J]. Journal of Multinational Financial Management 2007(17):231-243.
    [50]Rajesh K. Aggarw, Guojun Wu.Stock Market Manipulations[J]. Journal of Business 2006(4):1915-1953.
    [51]Robin Hanson, Ryan Oprean(2004)."Manipulators Increase Information Market Accuracy." working paper.
    [52]R., Stulz.. A Model of International Asset Pricing[J]. Journal of Financial Economics,1981,9(4):383-403.
    [53]Scowcroft, James Sefton. Understanding Momentum[J]. Financial Analysts Journal, 2010(5):64-82.
    [54]Shleifer, A. J., Vishny R. W.. The limits of arbitrage[J]. Journal of Finance,1997, (52):35-55.
    [55]Shefrin, H., Statman, M.. Behavioral Capital Asset Pricing Theory[J]. Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis,1994,29(3):323-349.
    [56]Shefrin, H., Statman, M.. Behavioral Portfolio Theory[J]. Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis,2000,35(2):127-151.
    [57]Shing-yang Hu. A simple estimate of noise and its determinant in a call auction market[J]. International Review of Financial Analysis 2006,15:348-362
    [58]Smirlock, M. Starks, L.. Day-of-the-week and intraday effects in stock returns [J]. Journal of Financial Econmics,1986,17(1):197-210.
    [59]Scruggs J. T.. Noise trader risk:Evidence from the Siamese twins[J]. Journal of Financial Markets,2007,10(1):76-105.
    [60]Stulz, R. M., Wasserfallen, W.. Foreign equity investment restrictions, capital flight, and shareholder wealth maximization:theory and evidence[J]. Review of Financial Studies,1995,8(4):1019-1057.
    [61]Sun, Q., Tong, W. H. S.. The Effect of market segmentation on stock prices:The China syndrome[J]. Journal of Banking&Finance,2000,24(12):1875-1902.
    [62]Thaler J. S.. The End of Behavioral Finance[J]. Financial Analysts Journal,1999, (6):12-17.
    [63]Vayanos, D.. Strategic trading in a dynamic noisy market[J]. Journal of Finance, 2001,56(1):131-171.
    [64]Vihang Errunza, Etienne Losq. International Asset Pricing under Mild Segmentation: Theory and Test[J]. The Journal of Finance,1985,40(1):105-124.
    [65]Wang Jiang. A model of competitive stock trading volume[J]. Journal of Political Economy,1994,(102):127-168.
    [66]Wang Jiang. The term structure of interest rates in a pure exchange economy with heterogeneous investors[J]. Journal of Financial Economics,1996, (41):75-110.
    [67]Xiong Wei. Imperfect arbitrage with wealth effects, Working paper, www. ssrn. com, 1999.
    [68]Xiong Wei. Convergence trading with wealth effects:an amplification mechanism in financial markets[J]. Journal of Financial Economics,2001, (46):247-292.
    [69]孔东民.基于NCT指标的股市噪音成分研究:以七个亚洲市场为例[J].中国管理科学,2005,13(6):6-10.
    [70]骆颖,何小峰.中国股市政策市中的正反馈交易机制[J].经济经纬,2005(2):144-147.
    [71]唐齐鸣,叶俊.噪声交易下证券市场参加主体的最优决策模型[J].数量经济技 术经济研究,2003(3):11-15.
    [72]王明涛.基于真实信息的股票市场操纵与市场过度反应[J].经济经纬,2007(1):144-147.
    [73]王志强,齐佩金,孙刚.动量效应的最新研究进展[J]世界经济,2006(2):82-92.
    [74]沃尔特·恩德斯.应用计量经济学[M].杜江,谢志超译.北京:高等教育出版社,2006.
    [75]许林,宋光辉,郭文伟.基于R/S分析的股市风格分形特征研究[J].商业研究.2011(1):153-158.
    [76]徐元栋,刘思峰.动量效应研究的最新研究[J].财贸研究,2007(1):93-97.
    [77]易丹辉.数据分析与Eviews应用[M].北京:中国统计出版社,2002.
    [78]阮青松,吕大永.沪深300指数羊群效应研究[J].商业研究,2010(8):153-156.
    [79]邹平.金融计量学[M].上海:上海财经大学出版社,2005.
    [80]赵鹏,唐齐鸣.Markov区制转换模型在行业CAPM分析中的应用[J]数量经济技术经济研究,2008(10):87-97.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700