基于分布估计的人机结合演化设计方法研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
卫星舱空间布局设计对缩短卫星设计周期、节约成本、提高性能等方面有着重要作用,是卫星总体设计的关键技术之一。该问题在数学上属于混合(离散与连续)组合最优化问题和NP-难(NP-hard)或NP-完全(NP-complete)问题,在工程上属于方案设计和复杂工程系统问题,其求解面临的主要困难是既要解决数学上的组合爆炸问题,又要解决工程系统复杂性问题。
     本论文以委托项目“航天器布局优化设计平台研究与开发”为应用背景,在国家自然科学基金资助下,研究该类布局空间结构本质,研究统计学习技术以及人机结合设计策略在演化计算中的应用,用于一类以改善卫星舱质量特性为目标的空间布局设计问题的求解。
     本文主要工作包括以下几个方面:
     1.给出一种基于主元分析(Principle Components Analysis,简称PCA)的分布估计算法(PCA-EDA)。分布估计算法(Estimation of Distribution Algorithms,简称EDAs)是一类比较新的演化算法,用以解决遗传算法求解变量耦合问题时算法运行效率不高的问题。PCA-EDA算法将主元分析的变量相关性分析功能与高斯分布概率模型相结合,在获得概率模型的学习精度与效率的相对平衡的同时,实现了设计变量间内在关联关系的学习及演化,可有效解决变量耦合问题:同时提出自适应控制主元变量的方差收敛的机制,解决分布估计算法的早熟问题。函数优化算例及布局仿真实验表明,PCA-EDA算法求解性能优于遗传算法及常规分布估计算法。
     2.给出一种多阶段贪心聚类机制,用于PCA-EDA算法,利用贪心期望最大化算法实现解群体自适应的聚类操作,实现算法对问题解空间的空间结构分析,以有效改进PCA-EDA算法对复杂布局问题的综合求解性能。本文对装填布局问题的空间结构进行了分析,指出其具有的一些复杂特点。在此基础上,提出利用高斯混合模型(GaussianMixture Model,简称GMM),将基于聚类的空间结构分析技术引入到PCA-EDA算法中,具有三方面的作用:(1)实现解空间的分解,将高性能解聚集的区域更精确地提取出来,这对于设计者深入了解设计问题,对于提高算法求解的效率都有明显的促进作用:(2)用多个高斯分布来更精确地逼近多峰值解空间,使基于单高斯分布的线性EDA算法非线性化,更适合求解具有复杂空间结构的设计问题;(3)本质上实现了一种具有多个独立群体的演化算法,有助于保持群体多样化。
     3.给出一种针对PCA-EDA算法的人机结合策略,最终形成基于分布估计的人机结合演化设计方法。本文从设计知识提取的层面,深入分析了PCA-EDA算法的内在运行机制,实现利用变量相关关系的学习将原问题分解为若干子问题,并分析了主元变量方差与载入系数矩阵在原始变量相关性分析中的应用,以及变量相关性与搜索空间的形态之间的关系。通过对布局仿真实验的求解表明,应用该策略可使设计者能以更有效的方式将设计思想传递给算法。此外,为解决人机结合过程中如何有效获取关键信息的问题,在对可视化技术以及演化算法可视化进行综述的基础上,本文从构成演化算法结构要素特征的可视化以及问题的解空间结构可视化两个方面,提出几种新的演化算法可视化交互界面,用于人机结合演化设计方法的多层面多角度可视化。
     综上所述,本文分别从变量相关性分析,可视化及定性与定量分析相结合、解空间结构分析三个方面展开研究,并结合演化计算的特点,充分利用概率统计及机器学习领域中相关技术,使三方面的研究内容既能各有侧重,又能有机统一,最终实现一种基于分布估计的人机结合的演化设计方法。通过对返回式卫星舱和通讯卫星舱的布局优化设计的实例验证,验证了本文方法的可行性和有效性。本文工作期望在理论上可有助于机器学习与演化算法相结合研究,以及人机结合演化设计和航天器布局设计理论研究进展,在实践上可有助于一类航天器布局设计问题的求解,并可望推广应用于其它复杂布局设计问题。
The layout design of satellite module is one of the key issues in the global design of satellite,which has an important impact upon reducing the design period,saving the cost,improving the performance for the satellite.It is known as a hybrid combinatorial optimization and NP-hard problem in mathematics,and a scheme design and complex system problem in engineering.There exist two primary challenges in the layout problem, which are the combinatorial explosion in mathematics and the complexity in engineering system.
     A project of Research and Development of a Software Platform for Layout Design of Spacecraft from a research institute of China Aerospace Science and Technology corporation (CAST) is taken as a background.The work aims to improve the global mass properties of a satellite by adjusting the locations and orientations of given components. Moreover,it is supported by the National Nature Science Foundation of China.
     The main contributions of this work are as follows.
     1.A new PCA-EDA algorithm which combines Principle Component Analysis(PCA), a classical statistical technique,and Gaussian probabilistic model is given.EDAs are population-based search algorithms based on probabilistic modeling of promising solutions in combination with the simulation of the induced models to guide their searching. The probability factorization can be employed to encode the conditional(in)dependencies among different variables and overcome the linkage problem.But there are still some problems such as premature convergence and complex model learning which limit the class of problems that EDAs can solve reliably and efficiently.PCA-EDA is aimed to keep the balance of accuracy and efficiency of model learning,as well as to avoid premature convergence by easy variance control.
     2.The thesis explores the landscape of packing problem and supposes that it is characterized as the complex mixture of big-valley and symmetry structure.It has been shown that for any optimization algorithm to be successful when solving a certain problem, the structure of the problem needs to match the bias of the algorithm.So it is necessary to introduce landscape analysis method based clustering into PCA-EDA.Caussian Mixture Model(GMM) is used in the work which would improve the algorithm in three ways:(1) splitting the solution space and extracting the high performance region to help user to understand the problem and make the algorithm more efficient;(2) modeling the complex landscape of packing problem more accurately than single peak probabihty distribution; (3) equivalent to a EA with multiple populations that is help to keep diversity.To make the fusion of GMM and PCA-EDA more effectively,the thesis presents a multi-stage greedy clustering strategy inspired by the similarity of working manners of EA and Greedy EM.
     3.PCA-EDA's inner working way is analyzed from the point of view of design knowledge extraction.The design knowledge inducted by PCA-EDA is the variable correlation model which can be used to decompose the large-scale layout design problem into individual sub-problems in order to help designer to understand how the algorithm work.Then the relations between the variances of principle components,the correlation of original variables and the structure of landscape of the problem are studied in order to provide a more effective interaction manner from human to computer.Moreover,to help designers to capture key information during Human Computer Cooperation,four new interactive interfaces are presented after the survey of the state of software visualization for EAs. These interfaces can be used to gain insight into the state and the course of the algorithm and the landscape of the problem,which impact the performance of HCC heavily.
     Summarizing,the work focuses on variable correlation,visualizing and cooperation of qualitative analysis and quantitative analysis,and landscape structure.By considering and utilizing the characteristics of the EAs and the layout problem,the three aspects of the strategy of layout problem solving are unified closely to construct a human computer cooperative evolutionary design based on statistical learning techniques,e.g.distribution estimation.From the results of numerical experiments for the satellite module it is showed that the proposed method is feasible and effective for the layout design of satellite module. This work is expected to advance the theories of HCC evolutionary design for the complex system and layout design for satellite module in theory,and is also likely to benefit the research and development of practical methods and techniques for a layout design problem of satellite module.Finally,the main contributions of this research are likely to be applied to other complex layout problems.
引文
[1]滕弘飞,孙守林,葛文海等.旋转体舱中圆柱体和长方体群布局优化.大连理工大学学报,1993,33(3):303-309.
    [2]曲广吉.航天器动力学工程.北京:中国科学技术出版社,2000.
    [3]韩祖南.再入飞行仿真的几个力学问题.力学季刊,2003,24(1):103-107.
    [4]陈春鸿,王丽萍,邱飞岳.集成电路自动布局和布线研究新进展.浙江工业大学学报,1997,25(1):57-64.
    [5]Dowsland K A,Dowsland W B.Packing Problems.European Journal of Operational Research,1992,56:2-14.
    [6]Sweeney P E,Paternoster E R.Cutting and packing problems:a categorized,application-orientated research.Journal of Operation Research Society.1992.43(7):691-706.
    [7]铁军.卫具有性能约束的三维布局优化的理论及算法:(博士学位论文).大连:大连理工大学,2007.
    [8]Cagan J,Shimada K,Yin S.A survey of computational approaches to three-dimensional layout problems.Computer-Aided Design,2002,34(8):597-611.
    [9]Bosman P A N,Grahl J.Matching inductive search bias and problem structure in continuous estimation - of - distribution algorithms.European Journal of Operational Research,2008,185(3):1246-1264.
    [10]刘占伟,滕弘飞.基于人智-图形-计算的布局设计方法及其在布局中的应用.大连理工大学学报,2006,46(2):228-234.
    [11]Lenat D B,Feigenbanm E A.On the thresholds of knowledge.In Proceedings of the International Workshop on Artificial Intelligence for Industrial Applications,Oakland,1988:291-300.
    [12]Michalek J J,Papalambros P Y.Interactive design optimization of architecture layout.Engineering Optimization,2002,24(5):485-501.
    [13]Parmee I C.Exploring the design potential of evolutionary search,exploration and optimisation.In:Bentley P J,ed.Evolutionary Design by Computers,London:Academic Press Ltd.,1999.
    [14]Parmee I C,Cvetkovic D,Watson A H,Bonham C R.Multiobjective Satisfaction within an Interactive Evolutionary Design Environment.Evolutionary Computation,2000,8(2):197-222.
    [15]Parmee I C,Bonham C R.Towards the support of innovative conceptual design through interactive designer/evolutionary computing strategies.Artificial Intelligence for Engineering Design Analysis and Manufacturing,2000,14:3-16.
    [16]Kafiq M Y,Beck M A,Packham I,Denham S.Evolutionary computation and visualisation as decision support tools for conceptual building design.In:Topping B H V,ed.Innovation in Civil and Structural Engineering,London:Saxe-Coburg Publications,2005,49-74.
    [17]Hsu W,Woon I M Y.Current research in the conceptual design of mechanical products.Computer-Aided Design,1998,30(5):377-389.
    [18]Dyckhoff H.A typology of cutting and packing problems.European Journal of Operational Research,1990,44(1-2):145-159.
    [19]Schnecke V,Vornberger O.An adaptive parallel genetic algorithm for VLSI-Layout optimization.In the 4th International Conference on Parallel Problem Solving from Nature,Berlin,Germany,1996:22-27.
    [20]Yang T,Kuo C.A hierarchical AHP/DEA methodology for the facihties layout design problem.European Journal of Operational Research,2003,147(1):128-136.
    [21]Michalek J J,Choudhary R,Papalambros P Y.Architecture layout design optimization. Engineering Optimization,2002,24(5):461-484.
    [22]Cagan J,Degentesh D,Yin S A.A simulated annealing based algorithm using hierarchical models for general three-dimensional component layout.Computer-Aided Design,1998,30(10):781-790.
    [23]Lee K Y,Han S N,Rob M I.Optimal compartment layout design for a naval ship using an improved genetic algorithm.Marine Technology,2002,39(11):159-169.
    [24]Kleinhans J M,Sigl G Johannes F M,et al.GORDIAN:VLSI placement by quadratic programming and slicing optimization.IEEE Transactions On CAD,1991,10(10):356-365.
    [25]Maziasz R L,Hayes J P.Layout optimization of static CMOS function cell.IEEE Transactions On CAD,1990,9(7):708-719.
    [26]El-Said M G,Fischer G,Gamael-Din S A,et al.ADDI:A tool for automating the design visual interfaces.Computers and Graphics,1997,21(1):79-87.
    [27]Foley J,Kim W C,Kovacevic S,et al.UIDE-an intelligent user interface design environment.In Intelligent User Interfaces,USA,1991:339-384.
    [28]Schwarz A,Berry D M,Shaviv E.Representing and solving the automated building design problem.Computer Aided Design,1994,26(9):689-698.
    [29]Tompkins J A,White J,Bozer Y A,et al.Facilities planning.New York:John Wiley,2002.
    [30]Ferebee M J,Allen C L.Optimization of payload placement on an arbitrary spacecraft.Journal of Spacecraft and Rockets,1991,28(5):612-614.
    [31]Taura T,Nagusaka I.Adaptive-growth-type 3D representation for configuration design.Artificial Intelligence for Engineering Design,Analysis and Manufacturing,1999,13(3):171-184.
    [32]Kamran D,Maziar A,Hossein S F."FARAGAM" algorithm in satellite layout.In Proceedings of 6th Asia-Pacific Conference on Multilateral Cooperation in Space Technology and Application,Beijing,China,2001:120-127.
    [33]Teng H F,Sun S L,Lin D Q,et al.Layout optimization for the objects located within a rotating veasel-a three-dimensional packing problem with behavioral constraints.Computers & Operation Research,2001,28(6):521-535.
    [34]Sun Z G,Teng H F.Optimal layout design of a satellite module.Engineering Optimization,2003,35(5):513-529.
    [35]Grignon P M,Fadel G M.A GA based configuration design optimization method.Journal of Mechanical Design,2004,126:6-15.
    [36]孙治国.一类航天器布局设计问题的顺序、物理(空间)分解协调方法:(博士学位论文).大连:大连理工大学,2005.
    [37]曹斌,谭建荣,伊国栋.管线布局设计的约束冈素分析及建模方法研究.中国机械工程,2002,13(15):1318-1323.
    [38]Feng Enmin,Wang Xilu,Wang Xiumei,et al.An algorithm of global optimization for solving layout problems.European Journal of Operational Research,1999,114:430-436.
    [39]邓克文张刚,殷国富.产品设计的知识模型建模技术研究.现代制造工程,2005,(5):47-50.
    [40]邹纯稳,张树有,来建良.基于知识驱动的产品设计过程建模及应用研究.中国机械工程,2008,19(8):939-944.
    [41]孙守迁,唐明,潘云鹤.面向人机工程的布局设计方法的研究.计算机辅助设计与图形学学报,2000,12(11):870-872.
    [42]唐晓君,查建中,陆一平.布局问题的复杂性和建模方法.北方交通大学学报,2003,27(1):12-15.
    [43]滕弘飞,王奕首.人机结合与信息融合设计方法研究简报.中国科技论文在线,2005. http://www.paper.edu.cn/process/download.jsp?file=200508-185.
    [44]陈永府,黄正东,陈立平.数值与符号的耦合约束求解模型.计算机工程与设计,2008,29(11):2806-2808.
    [45]肖人彬.基于分形理论的病态结构问题研究.系统工程学报,1999,14(2):107-111.
    [46]Huang W Q,Xu K C.Two personification strategies for solving circles packing problem.Science in China(Series E),1999,42(6):595-602.
    [47]Huang W Q,Yah K A.A heuristic quasi-physical strategy for solving disks packing problem.Simulation Modeling Practice & Theory,2002,10(3-4):195-207.
    [48]葛文海.约束布局优化理论方法研究及其在大型航天器舱布局设计中的应用:(博士学位论文).大连:大连理工大学,1995.
    [49]Lee K H,Lee J K,Park N S.Intelligent approach to a CAD system for the layout design of a ship engine room.Computers and Industrial Engineering,1998,34(3):599-608.
    [50]Andreas V.Multi-agent room simulation for early stage buiding layout design:(Ph.D.thesis).Swiss:Swiss Federal Institute of Technology ETH,2003.
    [51]Szykman S,Cagan J.Constrained three-dimensional component layout using simulated annealing.Journal of Mechanical Design,1997,119(1):28-35.
    [52]Tazawa I,Koakutsu S,Hirata H.An evolution optimization based on the immune system and its application to the VLSI floor-plan design problem.Electrical Engineering in Japan,1998,124(4):27-36.
    [53]Corry P,Kozan E.Ant colony optimisation for machine layout problems.Computational Optimization and Apphcations,2004,38(3):287-310.
    [54]李宁,刘飞,孙德宝.基于带变异算子粒子群优化算法的约束布局优化研究.计算机学报,2004,27(7):897-903.
    [55]Yin S,Cagan J.An extended pattern search algorithm for three-dimensional component layout.Transactions of the ASME,March 2000,122:102-108.
    [56]唐飞,滕弘飞.一种改进的遗传算法及其在布局优化中的应用.软件学报,1999,10(10):1096-1102.
    [57]李广强,滕弘飞,霍军周.并行混合免疫算法及其在布局设计中的应用.机械工程学报,2003,39(6):79-85.
    [58]Zhang B,Teng H F.Multi-swarms particle swarm optimization for satellite cabin layout.Chinese Journal of Mechanical Engineering,2005,18(4):532-538.
    [59]Hogg T Huberman B A,Lukose R M.An economics approach to hard computational problems.Science,1997,25(3):51-53.
    [60]Walshaw C.Multilevel Refinement for Combinatorial Optimisation Problems.Annals of Operations Research,2004,131:325-372.
    [61]Braun R D,Moore A A,Kroo I M.Collaborative approach to launch vehicle design.Journal of Spacecraft and Rockets,1997,34(4):478-486.
    [62]李敏强,王琛,周静.CSCW系统中协同机制及协同活动模型.系统工程与电子技术,2000,22(4):28-31.
    [63]史彦军.复杂布局的协同差异演化方法研究:(博士学位论文).大连:大连理工大学,2005.
    [64]罗亚波,陈定方.面向远程布局的分布式虚拟车间研究.工程设计学报,2005,12(5):262-264.
    [65]Rechenberg I.Evolutions strategies.Stuttgart:Frommann-Holzboog,1994.
    66]Schwefel H-P.Numerical Optimization of Computer Models.New York:Wiley,1981.
    [67]Holland J H.Adaptation in natural and artificial systems.Ann Arbor:University of Michigan Press,1975.
    [68]De Jong K A.Analysis of Behavior of a Class of Genetic Adaptive Systems:(Ph.D.thesis).Michigan:University of Michigan,1975.
    [69]Goldberg D E.Genetic algorithms in search,optimization,and machine learning.MA:Addison-Wesley,1989.
    [70]Fogel L J.Autonomous automata.Industr Res,1962,4(1):14-19.
    [71]French M J.Conceptual Design for Engineers(third edition).London:Springer-Verlag,1999.
    [72]Kicinger R,Arciszewaki T,De Jong K A.Evolutionary computation and structural design:a survey of the state of the art.Computers and Structures,2005,83(23-24):1943-1978.
    [73]檀润华,王庆禹.产品设计过程模型、策略与方法综述.机械设计,2000,11(1):1-4.
    [74]Parmee I C,Bonham C R.Supporting Innovative and Creative Design using Interactive Designer /Evolutionary Computing Strategies.Fourth International Round-table Conference on Computational Models of Creative Design,Heron Island,Australia,1998:187-214.
    [75]Bentley P.Aspects of evolutionary design by computers.Proceedings of Advances in Soft Computing,Engineering Design and Manufacturing,London,1999:99-118.
    [76]滕弘飞,曾威,梁大伟等.演化设计方法及其应用.机械工程学报,2004,40(1):1-6.
    [77]Bentley P J(Ed.).Evolutionary design by computers.CA:Morgan Kaufmann Publishers,1999.
    [78]B(a|¨)ck T,Schwefel H-P.An overview of evolutionary algorithms for parameter optimization.Evolutionary Computation,November 1993,1(1):1-23.
    [79]Lin J L,Foote B,Pulat S,et al.Hybrid genetic algorithm for container packing in three dimensions.In Proceedings of 9th Conference on Artificial Intelligence for Applications,Orlando,USA,1993:353-359.
    [80]Rajasekharan M,Peters B A,Yang T.A genetic algorithm for facility layout design in flexible manufacyturing systems.International Journal of Production Research,1998,36(1):95-110.
    [81]Lee K Y,Han S N,Roh M I.An improved genetic algorithm for facility layout problems having inner structure walls and passages.Computers and Operations research,2003,30(1):117-138.
    [82]曹先彬,庄镇泉.一个基于启发式经验的立体布局进化策略.电子科学学刊,1998,20(3):404-408.
    [83]段国林,查建中,林建平.遗传算法在钟表机芯设计中的应用.软件学报,1998,9(7):515-519.
    [84]张良震,刘红.遗传算法应用于VLSI布局的研究.电路与系统学报,1999,4(3):47-53.
    [85]王金敏,王玉新,曾维川.基于遗传算法的布局求解法.天津大学学报,2001,34(3):307-311.
    [86]Reffat R,,Gero J.Computational situated learning in design.In:,ed.Artificial intelligence in design '00',Kluwer Academic Publishers,2000,589-610.
    [87]Boden M A.The creative mind:myths and mechanisms.New York:Basic Books,1992.
    [88]Funes P,Pollack J.Computer Evolution of Buildable Objects.Tech.Rep.CS-97-191,Brandeis University,1997.
    [89]Rosenman M.The generation of form using evolutionary approach.In:Dasgupta D and Michalewicz Z,ed.Evolutionary algorithms in engineering applications,Berlin:Springer,1997,69-86.
    [90]Bentley P J,Wakefield J P.Generic Evolutionary Design.In:Chawdhry P K and Roy R and Pant R K,ed.Soft Computing in Engineering Design and Manufacturing,Springer Verlag,Part 6,1997,289-298.
    [91]Pham D T,Yang Y.A genetic algorithm based prehminary design system.Journal of Automobile Engineers,1993,207(2):127-133.
    [92]Sriram D.DESTINY:A Model for Integrated Structural Design.Journal of Artificial Intelligence in Engineering,1986,1(2):109-116.
    [93]Harty,N.An Aid to Preliminary Design.In:Sriram D and Adey R,ed.Knowledge Based Expert Systems in Engineering Planning and Design,Boston,USA:Computational Mechanics Publications,1987.
    [94]Dagli C H Bahrami A.Hybrid intelligent packing system(HIPS) through integration of artificial neural networks,artificial intelligence,and mathematical programming.Applied Intelligence,1994,4(4):321-336.
    [95]钱学森,于景元,戴汝为.一个科学的新领域-开放的复杂巨系统及其方法论.自然杂志,1990,13(1):3-10.
    [96]戴汝为,王珏.巨型智能系统的探讨.自动化学报,1991,19(6):645-655.
    [97]戴汝为.从定性到定量的综合集成技术.模式识别与人工智能,1991,4(1):5-10.
    [98]路甬祥,陈鹰.人机一体化系统与技术-21世纪机械科学发展的方向.机械工程学报,1994,30(5):1-7.
    [99]路甬祥,陈鹰.人机一体化系统与技术立论.机械工程学报,1994,30(6):1-8.
    [100]路甬祥,陈鹰.人机一体化系统科学体系和关键技术.机械工程学报,1995,31(1):1-7.
    [101]李耀东,崔霞,戴汝为.综合集成研讨厅的理论框架、设计与实现.复杂系统与复杂性科学,2004,1(1):27-32.
    [102]Wang Y,Teng H-F.Knowledge fusion design method:Satellite module layout.Chinese Journal of Aeronautics,Accepted.
    [103]Eckert C,Kelly I,Stacey M.Interactive generative systems for conceptual design:an empirical perspective.Artificial Intelhgence for Engineering Design,Analysis and Manufacturing - Special Issue:Generative Systems in Design,1999,1S(4):303-320.
    [104]Parmee I C.Improving problem definition through interactive evolutionary computing.Artificial Intelhgence for Engineering Design Analysis and Manufacturing,2002,16:185-202.
    [105]Palli N,Azarm S,McCluskey P,et al.An interactive multistage Epsilon-inequaiity constraint method for multiple objectives decision making.Jouranl of mechanical design,1998,120:678-686.
    [106]Connell S O,Sullivan B O,Freuder E C.Strategies for interactive constraint acquistition.In Proceedings of the CP-2002 workshop on user-interaction in constraint satisfaction,2002:62-76.
    [107]Anderson D,Anderson E,Lesh N,et al.Human-gnided simple search:conbining information visualization and heuristic search.In Proceedings of the 1999 Workshop on New paradigms in Information Visualization and Manipulation in Conjunction with the Eight ACM Internation Conference on Information and Knowledge Management,Kansas,USA,1999:21-25.
    [108]Anderson D,Anderson E,Lesh N,st al.Human-guided simple search.Proceeding of AAAI 2000,Austin,USA,2000:209-216.
    [109]Scott S D,Lesh N,Klau G W.Investigating human-computer optimization.Internatioal Conference for Human-Computer Interaction,Minneapolis,USA,2002:155-162.
    [110]Klau G W,Lesh N,Marks J,et at.Human-guided tabu search.In Eighteenth National conference on Artificial Intelligence,Edmonton,Canada,2002:41-47.
    [111]蔡汉明,王晓波,荣荃.矩形排样的一种算法.青岛大学学报(工程技术版),2004,19(4):53-57.
    [112]唐晓君,查建中,陆一平.基于虚拟现实的人机结合方法及其在布局中的应用.机械工程学报,2003,39(8):95-100.
    [113]O'Brien C,Abdel B.An interactive approach to computer aided plant layout.International Journal of Production Research,1980,18(2):201-211.
    [114]Hornby G S.Generative representations for evolutionary design automation:(Ph.D.thesis).Waltham,MA,USA:Department of Computer Science,Brandeis University,2003.
    [115]Jo J.Interactive Evolutionary Design System:Process and Knowledge Kepresentation.In Fourth International Round-table Conference on Computational Models of Creative Design,Heron Island,Australia,1998:215-224.
    [116]Dawkins R.The blind watchmaker.Essex,U.K.:Longman,1986.
    [117]Takagi H.Interactive evolutionary computation:Fusion of the capabihties of EC optimization and human evaluation.Proceedings of the IEEE,September 2001,89(9):1275-1296.
    [118]Nagao M,Yamada M,Suzuki K,Ohuchi A.Evaluation of the image retrieval system using interactive evolutionary computation,in Workshop on Interactive Evolutionary Computation,Fukuoka,Japan,1998:25-30.
    [119]Louis S J,Tang R.Interactive genetic algorithms for the traveling salesman problem.In Genetic and Evolutionary Computation Conf,Orlando,FL,1999:1043-048.
    [120]Inoue T,Faruhashi T,Fujii M,et al.Development of nurse scheduling support system using interactive EA.In IEEE Int.Conf.Systems,Man,and Cybernetics,Tokyo,Japan,1999:533-537.
    [121]Jo Jun H,Gero J S.Space Layout Planning Using an Evolutionary Approach.Artificial Intelligence in Engineering,1998,12:149-162.
    [122]Parmee I C.Human-centric computational intelligence strategies for exploration and knowledge discovery.The Analyst,2005,130(1):21-34.
    [123]Packham I S J.Interactive visualisation for decision support using evolutionary computing:(Ph.D.thesis).Plymouth,UK:University of Plymouth,2003.
    [124]王克峰,孙晓静,姚平经.基于聚类分析和可视化的增强遗传算法-Ⅰ.算法的引出、原理与分析.过程工程学报,2004,4(5):438-444.
    [125]孙晓静,王克峰,姚平经.基于聚类分析和可视化的增强遗传算法-Ⅱ.算例分析及有效性验证.过程工程学报,2004,4(6):536-543.
    [126]Avigad G,Moshaiov A,Brauner N.Towards a General Tool for Mechatronic Design.Proceeding of the 2003 IEEE CSS Conference on Control Applications,CCA 2003,2003:1035-1040.
    [127]钱志勤,滕弘飞,孙治国.人机交互遗传算法及其在约束布局中的应用.计算机学报,2001,24(5):553-559.
    [128]苗玉彬,滕弘飞,刘占伟.基于HCI-SA/GA的演化设计方法及其在布局中的应用.机械工程学报,2003,39(2):133-139.
    [129]霍军周,李广强,滕弘飞.人机结合蚁群/遗传算法及其在航天器舱布局中的应用.机械工程学报,2005,41(3):112-116.
    [130]Caruana R,Mullins M.Estimating the Number of Local Minima in Complex Search Spaces.Neural Computing Surveys,2000,3:10-12.
    [131]Boese K D,Kahng A B,Muddu S.On the Big Valley and Adaptive Multi-Start for Discrete Global Optimzatious.Operations Kesarch Letters,1994,16(2):101-113.
    [132]Buntine W,Su L,Newton R.Adaptive Approach to Clustering for Discrete Optimization.Neural Computing Surveys,2000,3:27-30.
    [133]Osio I G,Amon C H.An engineering design methodology with multistage bayesian surrogates and optimal sampling.Research in engineering design,1996,8:189-206.
    [134]Boyan J A.Learning evaluation functions for global optimization:(Ph.D.thesis).Pittsburgh:Carnegie Mellon University,1998.
    [135]钟毅芳苏子健.系统近似建模技术的研究与比较.系统工程与电子技术,2005,27(5):834-836.
    [136]Baluja S.Population-based incremental learning:A method for integrating genetic search based function optimization and competitive learning.Tech.Rep.CMU-CS-94-163,Carnegie Mellon University,Pittsburgh,Pennsylvania,1994.
    [137]Pelikau M,Goldberg D E,Cantu-Paz E.Linkage problem,distribution estimation,and Bayesian networks.Evolutionary Computation,2000,8(3):311-340.
    [138]Larra(?)aga P,Etxberria R,Lozano J A,Pe(?)a J M.Optimization by learning and simulation of Bayesian and Gaussian networks.Tech.Rep.EHU-KZAA-IK-4/99,Intelligent Systems Group,Department of Computer Science and Artificial Intelligence,University of the Basque Country,Donostia-San Sebasti(?)n,December 1999.
    [139]Muhlenbein H,Mahnig T.FDA - A scalable evolutionary algorithm for the optimization of additively decomposed functions.Evolutionary computation,1999,7(1):45-68.
    [140]Jin Y.A comprehensive survey of fitness approximation in evolutionary computation.Soft Computing Journal,2005,9(1):3-12.
    [141]B(u|¨)che D,Schraudolph N N,Koumoutsakos P.Accelerating evolutionary algorithms with Gaussian process fitness function Models.IEEE Transactions on Systems,Man and Cybernetics,May 2005,35(2):183-194.
    [142]Biles J A.Genjam:A genetic algorithm for generating jazz solos.Proceedings of International Computer Music Conference,1994:131-137.
    [143]Brauke J,Schmidt C,Schmeck H.Efficient fitness estimation in noisy environment.Proceedings of Genetic and Evolutionary Computation,San Francisco,CA,2001:243-250.
    [144]Yang D,Flockton S J.Evolutionary algorithms with a coarse-to-fine function smoothing.Proceedings of IEEE CEC 1995,Perth,Australia,1995:657-662.
    [145]Matthews P C,Blessing L T M,Wallace K M.The introduction of a design heuristics extraction method.Advanced engineering informatics,2002,16:3-19.
    [146]Towell G,Shavlik J.The Extraction of Refined Rules from Knowledge-Based Neural Networks.Machine Learning,1993,13:71-101.
    [147]Tickle A B,Andrews R,Golca M,Dicdrich J.The truth will come to light:direction and challenges in extracting the knowledge embedded within trained artificial neural networks.IEEE Trans Neural Networks,1998,9(6):1057-1068.
    [148]Matthews P C.A Bayesian support tool for morphological design.Advanced Engineering Informatics,2008,22(2):236-253.
    [149]尹晓伟,钱文学,谢里阳.贝叶斯网络在机械系统可靠性评估中的应用.东北大学学报,2008,29(4):557-560.
    [150]Pacheco J E,Amon C H,Finger S.Bayesian surrogates applied to conceptual stages of the engineering design process.Journal of mechanical design,2003,125:664-672.
    [151]Johnson R A,Wichern D W.实用多元统计分析(第四版).陆璇译.北京:清华大学出版社,2001.
    [152]任永功.面向聚类的数据可视化方法及相关技术研究:(博士学位论文).沈阳:东北大学,2006.
    [153]Jolliffe I T.Principal component analysis.New York:Springer-Verlag,1986.
    [154]Gallagher M R.Multi-layer perceptron error surfaces:visualization,structure and roodeking:(Ph.D.thesis).Australia:University of Queensland,2000.
    [155]Tipping M E,Biship C M.Mixtures of Probabilistic Principal Component Allalysers.Tech.Rep.NCRG/97/010,Neural Computing Research Group,Aston University,1997.
    [156]Roweis S.EM Algorithms for PCA and Sensible PCA.Tech.Rep.CNS-TR-97-02,Computation and Neural Systems,California Institute of Technology.,1997.
    [157]Bishop C M,Tipping M E.A hierarchical latent variable model for data visualization.IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence,March 1998,20(3):281-293.
    [158]Wang Y,Luo L,Freedman M T,Kung S-Y.Probabilistic principal component subspaces:a hierarchical finite mixture model for data visualization.IEEE Transactions on Neural Networks,May 2000,11(3):625-636.
    [159]Collins T.Genotypic-Space Mapping:Population Visualization for Genetic Algorithms.Tech.Rep.KMI-TR-39,KMI,The Open University,Milton Keynes,UK,1996.
    [160]Poblheim H.Multidimensional Scaling for Evolutionary Algorithms-Visualization of the Path through Search Space and Solution Space Using Sammon Mapping.Artificial Life,2006,12:203-209.
    [161]Collins J J.Visualization of evolutionary algorithms using principal components analysis.Proceedings of the 1999 GECCO Workshop Program,San Mateo,CA,1999:99-100.
    [162]Yuan B,Gallagher M.On the importance of diversity maintenance in estimation of distribution algorithms.Proceedings of the Genetic and Evolutionary Computation Conference,Washington DC,USA,2005:719-726.
    [163]刘德全,滕弘飞.矩形件排样问题的遗传算法求解.小型微型计算机系统,1998,19(12):20-25.
    [164]Wang Y,Teng H-F,Shi Y-J.Cooperative coevolutionary scatter search for satellite module layout design.Engineering Computations,Accepted.
    [165]李广强.布局方案设计的若干理论、方法及其应用:(博士学位论文).大连:大连理工大学,2003.
    [166]滕弘飞,孙守林,葛文海等.转动圆桌平衡摆盘-带平衡性能约束的Packing问题.中国科学(A辑),1994,24(7):1212-1218.
    [167]李广强,滕弘飞.装填布局的同构和非同构模式.计算机学报,2003,26(10):1248-1254.
    [168]滕弘飞,黎自强,史彦军,王奕首.一种同构、非同构布局模式构造算法.计算机学报,2006,29(6):985-991.
    [169]M(u|¨)hlenbein H,Paaβ G.From recombination of genes to the estimation of distributions:Ⅰ.Binary parameters.Lecture Notes in Computer Science,PPSN Ⅳ,Berlin,Germany,1996:178-187.
    [170]Voigt H.On some difficulties in local evolutionary search.Proceedings of the 1999 Confess on Evolutionary Computation:1999:783-787.
    [171]Harik G R,Goldberg D E.Learning linkage.In:Belew R K and Vose M D,ed.Foundations of Genetic Algorithms 4,San Francisco,California:Morgan Kaufinann,1997,247-262.
    [172]Bosman P A N.Design and application of iterated density-estimation evolutionary algorithms:(Ph.D.thesis).Utrecht:Universiteit Utrecht,2003.
    [173]Larra(?)age P,Etxberria R,Lozano J A,Sierra B,Inza I,Pe(?)a J M.A review of the cooperation between evolutionary computation and probabilistic graphical models.Adaptive Systems,La Habana,1999:314-324.
    [174]周树德,孙增圻.分布估计算法综述.自动化学报,2007,33(2):113-124.
    [175]Rudlof S,K(o|¨)ppen M.Stochastic hill climbing with learning by vectors of normal distributions.Proc.of 1st Online Workshop on Soft Computing,Nagoya,Japan,1996:
    [176]Sebag M,Ducoulombier A.Extending Population-Based Incremental Learning to continuous search spaces.Parallel Problem Solving from Nature - PPSN V,LNCS,Berlin,1998:418-427.
    [177]Gallagher M,Frean M,Downs T.Real-valued evolutionary optimization using a flexible probability density estimator.Proceedings of Genetic and Evolutionary Computation Conference(GECCO' 99),San Francisco,CA,1999:840-846.
    [178]Tsutsui S,Pelikan M,Goldberg D E.Evolutionary algorithm using marginal histogram in continuous domain.Proceedings of the Optimization by Building and Using Probabilistic Models Workshop at GECCO - 2001,San Francisco,California,2001:230-233.
    [179]Bosman P A N,Thierens D.Advancing continuons IDEAs with mixture distributions and factorization selection metrics.Proceedings of the Optimization by Building and Using Probabihstic Models OBUPM Workshop at GECCO-2001,San Francisco,California,2001:208-212.
    [180]De Bonet J S,Isbell C L,Viola P.Mimic:Finding optima by estimating probability densities,in M.Mozer,M.Jordan and Th.Petsche,eds.Proceedings of Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems,1997:424-430.
    [181]Bosman P A N,Thierens D.Continuous iterated density esthnation evolutionary algorithms within the IDEA framework.Proceedings of the Optimization by Building and Using Probabilistic Models OBUPM Workshop at GECCO-2000,2000:197-200.
    [182]Baluja S,Davies S.Using optimal dependency-trees for combinatorial optimization:Learning the structure of the search space.Tech.Rep.CMU-CS-97-107,Carnegie Mellon University,January 1997.
    [183]Shachter R,Kenley C.Gaussian influence diagrams.Management Science,1989,35(5):527-550.
    [184]Dempster A P.Covariance selection.Biometrika,1972,32:95-108.
    [185]Speed T P,Kiiveri H.Gaussian Markov distributions over finite graphs.Annals of Statistics,1986,14:138-150.
    [186]Press W H,Teukolsky S A,Vetterling W T,Flannery B P.Numerical recipes in C:the art of scientific computing.Cambridge,New York:Cambridge University Press,1992,2nd edn.
    [187]Gao Y,Culberson J.Space Complexity of Estimation of Distribution Algorithms.Evolutionary Computation,2005,13(1):125-143.
    [188]Chickering D M.Learning bayesian networks is NP-Complete.Proceedings of the Fifth International Workshop on Artificial Intelligence and Statistics,1996:121-130.
    [189]Grahl J,Minner S,Rothlanf F.Behaviour of UMDA_c with truncation selection on monotonous functions.Proceedings of IEEE Confgress on Evolutionary Computation,Piscataway,New Jersey,2005:2553-2559.
    [190]Myers R H.Classical and modern regression with applications.Belomont:Duxbury Press,1994,second edn.
    [191]Dong W-S,Yao X.Covariance Matrix Repairing in Gaussian Based EDAs.Proceedings of CEC07,2007:415-422.
    [192]Grahl J,Bosman P A N,Kothlauf F.The Correlation-Triggered Adaptive Variance Scaling IDEA.GECCO 2006,Seattle,USA,2006:397-404.
    [193]Wagner M,Auger A,Schoenauer M.EEDA:A new robust estimation of distribution algorithms.Tech.Rep.5190,INBIA Futurs,Universite de Paris Sud,2004.
    [194]Po(?)k P,Franc V.Estimation of Fitness Landscape Contours in Eks.Proceeding of GECCO'07,London,England,2007:562-569.
    [195]Kern S,M(u|¨)ller S D,Hansen N,B(u|¨)che D,Ocenasek J,Koumoutsakos P.Learning probability distributions in continuous evolutionary algorithms - a comparative review.Natural Computing,2004,3(1):77-112.
    [196]B(a|¨)ck T,Michalewicz Z.Test landscapes.In:B(a|¨)ck T and Fogel D B and Michalewicz Z,ed.Handbook of Evolutionary Computation,New York:IOP Publishing,1997,14-20.
    [197]Jolliffe I T.Principal component analysis.New York:Springer-Verlag,2002,second edn.
    [198]Roweis S,Ghahramani Z.A Unifying Review of Linear Gaussian Models.Neural Computation,1999,11:305-345.
    [199]Tipping M E,Bishop C M.Mixtures of probabilistic principal component analyzers.Neural Computation,1999,11(2):443-482.
    [200]Cho D-Y,Zhang B-T.Continuous estimation of distribution algorithms with probabihstic principal component analysis.Proceedings of the 2001 Congress on Evolutionary Computation,2001:521-526.
    [201]Bishop C M.Bayesian PCA.Proceedings of Advances in neural information processing systems 11,1999:382-388.
    [202]Peres-Neto Pedro R,Jackson Donald A,Somers Keith M.Giving Meaningful Interpretation to Ordination Axes:Assessing Loading Significance in Principal Component Analysis.Ecology,2003,84(9):2347-2363.
    [203]Jackson D A.Stopping rules in principal components analysis:A comparison of heuristical and statistical approaches.Ecology,1993,74(8):2204-2214.
    [204]Ocenasek J,Kern S,Hansen N,Koumoutsakos P.A mixed Bayesianoptimization algorithm with variance adaptation.Proceeding of Parallel Problem Solving from Nature - PPSN Ⅷ,Berlin,2004:352-361.
    [205]Steel R G D,Torrie J H,Dickey D A.Principles and procedures of statistics:A biometrical approach.New York,NY:McGraw-Hill,1996.
    [206]滕弘飞,车超,王奕首.《拟卫星packing难题》的注记-已知全部最优解.中国科技论文在线,2006.http://www.paper.edu.cn/process/download.jsp?file=200602-193.
    [207]Pelikan M,Goldberg D E.Genetic algorithms,clustering,and the breaking of symmetry.Proceedings of Parallel Problem Solving from Nature Ⅵ,2000:385-394.
    [208]Duda R O,Hart P E,Stork D G.模式分类(原书第2版).北京:机械工业出版社,2003.
    [209]Verbeek J J,Vlassis N,Krose B.Efficient greedy learning of Ganssian mixture models.Neural Computation,2003,15(2):469-485.
    [210]Gallagher M,Yuan B.A general-purpose tunable landscape generator.IEEE Transactions on Evolutionary Computation,October 2006,10(5):590-603.
    [211]Juels A,Wattenberg M.Stochastic hillclimbing as a baseline mathod for evaluating genetic algorithm.NIPS96,1996:430-436.
    [212]Hoyweghen C V,Goldberg D E,Nandts B.From TwoMax to the Ising model:Easy and hard symmetrical problems.Proceedings of Genetic Evolutionary Computation Conference,2002:626-633.
    [213]Hoyweghen C V,Nandts B,Goldberg D E.Spin-Flip symmetrical and synchronization.Evolutionary Computation,2002,10(4):317-344.
    [214]Choi S S,Kwon Y K,Moon B K.Properties of Symmetric Fitness Functions.IEEE Transactions On Evolutionary Computation,2007,11(6):743-757.
    [215]Pe(?)a J M.On unsupervised learning of Bayesian networks and conditional Gaussian networks:(Ph.D.thesis).Donostia-San Sebastian:University of the Basque Country,July 2001.
    [216]Pe(?)a J M,Lozano J A,Larra(?)aga P,Inza I.Dimensionahty reduction in unsupervised learning of conditional Gaussian networks.IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence,June 2001,23(6):590-603.
    [217]Lu Q,Yao X.Clustering and learning Gaussian distribution for continuous optimization.IEEE Transactions on Systems,Man,and Cybernetics-Part C:Apphcations and Reviews,May 2005,25(2):195-204.
    [218]Li M,Tam H-Y.Hybrid evolutionary search method based on clusters.IEEE Transactions On Pattern Analysis And Machine Intelligence,2000,22(8):786-799.
    [219]Shir O M,B(a|¨)ck T.Niche radius adaptation in the cma-es niching algorithm.LNCS 4193,9th International Conference of Parallel Problem Solving from Nature - PPSN Ⅸ,Reykjavik,Iceland,2006:142-151.
    [220]Shir O M,Emmerich M,B(a|)ck T.Self-Adaptive Niching CMA-ES with Mahalanobis.Metric.Proceedings of IEEE-CEC 2007,Singapore,2007:.
    [221]Avigad G,Moshalov A,Brauner N.Concept-based interactive brainstorming in engineering design.JACⅢ,2004,8(5):454-459.
    [222]Verbeek J.Mixture models for clustering and dimension reduction:(Ph.D.thesis).Amsterdam:University of Amsterdam,2004.
    [22]岳博.BByes网络模型及其学习算法研究:(博士学位论文).西安:西安电子科技大学,2002.
    [224]Dempster A P,Laird N M,Rubin D B.Maximum likelihood from incomplete data via the EM algorithm.Journal of the Royal Statistical Society,Series B(Methodological),1977,39(1):1-38.
    [225]Ueda N,Nakano R,Ghahramani Z,Hinton G E.SMEM algorithm for mixture models.Neural Computation,2000,12(9):2109-2128.
    [226]Figueiredo M A T,Jain A K.Unsupervised learning of finite mixture models.IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence,March 2002,24(3):381-396.
    [227]李斌,钟润添,王先基,庄镇泉.一种基于递增估计GMM的连续优化算法.计算机学报,2007,30(6):980-985.
    [228]Cadima J,Jolliffe I T.Loadings and correlations in the interpretation of principal components.Journal of Apphed Statistics,1995,22(2):203-214.
    [229]McCormick B H,DeFanti T A,Brown M D.Visualization in scientific computing.Computer Graphics,1987,21(6).
    [230]Collins T D.The Apphcation of Software Visualization Technology to Evolutionary Computation -A Case Study in Genetic Algorithms:(Ph.D.thesis).Milton Keynes,UK:The Open University,1998.
    [231]Johnson C,Moorhead R,Munzner T,Pfister H.NIH/NSF Visualization Research Challenges.USA:IEEE Computer Society,2006.
    [232]任磊,王威信,周明骏,滕东兴,马翠霞,戴国忠.一种模型驱动的交互式信息可视化开发方法.软件学报,2008,19(8):1947-1964.
    (233]梁义芝,张维石,康晓予.仿真模型重用方法综述.计算机仿真,2008,25(8):1-5.
    [234]Tory M,M(o|¨)ller T.Human Factors In Visualization Research.IEEE Transactions On Visualization And Computer Graphics,2004,10(1):1-13.
    [235]Collins T D.Visualizing evolutionary computation.In:Ghosh A and Tsutsui S,ed.Advances in evolutionary computation:Theory and applications,New York:Springer,2003,95-116.
    [236]Bullock S,Smith T,Bird J.Picture This:The State of the Art in Visualization for Complex Adaptive Systems.Artificial Life,2006,12:189-192.
    [237]Collins T.Using software visualization technology to help evolutionary algorithm users valid their solutions.Seventh International Conference on Genetic Algorithms,1997:307-314.
    [238]Bullock S,Cartlidge J,Thompson M.Prospects for computational steering of evolutionary computation.Beyond Fitness:Visualizing Evolution-Workshop Proceedings of the Eighth International Conference on Artificial Life,University of New South Wales,Australia,2002:131-137.
    [239]Hart E,Ross P.GAVEL-A New Tool for Genetic Algorithm Visualization.IEEE Transactions on Evolutionary Computation,2001,5(4):335-348.
    [240]Pohlheim H.Understanding the Course and State of Evolutionary Optimizations Using Visualization:Ten Years of Industry Experience with Evolutionary Algorithms.Artificial Life,2006,12:217-227.
    [241]Vassilev V,Fogarty T,Miller J.Information characteristics and the structure of landscapes.Evolutionary Computation,2000,8(1):31-61.
    [242]Wiles J,Tonkes B.Hyperspace Geography:Visualizing Fitness Landscapes beyond 4D.Artificial Life,2006,12:211-216.
    [243]Koda T,Maes P.Agents with faces:The effects of personification of agents,in Proceedings of HCI'96,London,UK,1996:239-245.
    [244]El-Nasir M S,Ioerger T,Yen T.PETEEI:a pet with evolving emotional intelligence.In proceedings of Third International Conference on Autonomous Agents,Seattle,Washington,1999:9-15.
    [245]曾威,史彦军,滕弘飞.卫星舱布局CAD系统:Pro/Engineer二次开发若干关键技术.计算机辅助设计与图形学学报,2005,17(11):2575-2579.
    [246]刘占伟.人机结合的布局设计方法及其应用研究:(博士学位论文).大连:大连理工大学,2006.
    [247]曾威.卫星舱布局的双系统协同进化算法与CAD系统关键技术:(博士学位论文).大连:大连理工大学,2007.
    [248]陈希孺.概率论(第一册)概率论基础.北京:高等教育出版社,1981.
    [249]Pearson K.On lines and planes of closest fit to systems of points in space.Phil Mag,1901,6(2):559-572.
    [250]Hotelling H.Analysis of a complex of statistical variables into principal components.Jounal of Education Psychology,1933,24:417-441.
    [251]Rao C R.The use and interpretation of principal component analysis in applied research.Sankhya A,1964,26:329-358.
    [252]Qian G,Gabor G,Gupta R P.Principle components selection by the criterion of the minimum mean difference of complexity.Journal of multivariate analysis,1994,49:55-75.
    [253]Oja E.A simplified neuron model as a principal component analyzer.Journal of Mathe-matical Biology,1982,15:267-273.
    [254]南京大学数学系计算数学专业.线性代数.南京大学出版社,2006.
    [255]Murphy K P.An introduction to graphical models.Tech.rep.,Intel Research Technical Report,2001.
    [256]Smyth P.Model selection for probabilistic clustering using cross-validated likelihood.Statistics and Computing,2000,10(1):63-72.
    [257]Roberts S J,Husmeier D,Penny W.Bayesian approaches to Gaussian mixture modeling.IEEE Transactions on pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence,November 1998,20(11):1133-1142.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700