经筋刺法治疗膝关节骨性关节炎的临床研究
|
摘要
研究目的：
期望通过本研究充分发挥中医针灸疗法优势对膝关节骨性关节炎进行治疗,并为进一步拓展和推广其日后临床应用打下基础。
研究方法：
文献研究综述了中医学、现代医学对膝关节骨性关节炎的认识和治疗,以及经筋理论的研究进展。
临床研究选取符合纳入标准的病例60例,将其随机分为两组,即治疗组和对照组。治疗组以经筋理论为指导,以“以痛为腧”为原则,依据导师庄礼兴教授临床经验,循膝关节相关的经筋系统进行排查,每次选取4个痛点进行手法操作。快速刺入病灶点,针刺深度要达到骨膜,并沿经筋循行路线于该病灶点上下各1寸处傍刺。得气后留针30分钟,每隔5分钟行针一次,手法为捻转泻法,以患者能耐受为度。对照组为常规针刺组,参照石学敏主编《针灸学》(第五版),选择犊鼻、内膝眼、阳陵泉、足三里。针刺手法、补泻手法同治疗组,针刺深度按常规进行,同时不需傍刺。治疗共3个疗程,观察治疗前后McGill简化疼痛量表中的目测类比疼痛评分(VAS)、临床症状评分、WOMAC (Western Ontario and McMaster Universities)膝关节骨性关节量表以及临床疗效评价。
研究结果：
VAS评分比较：治疗前两组比较,无明显差异(P>0.05),提示两组患者疼痛程度相当。经治疗后评分均较治疗前明显下降,差异具有统计学意义(P<0.01,P<0.05),提示两种治疗方法均可以有效的缓解疼痛症状。治疗后两组比较P<0.05,提示2组治疗效果比较差异有统计学意义,以治疗组缓解疼痛程度明显。
临床症状评分结果：治疗前两组比较,无明显差异(P>0.05),提示两组患者临床症状相当。经治疗后评分均较治疗前明显下降,差异具有统计学意义(P<0.01,P<0.05),提示两种治疗方法均可以有效的改善临床症状。治疗后两组比较P<0.05,提示两组治疗效果比较差异有统计学意义,以治疗组改善明显。
WOMAC评分结果：疼痛症状评分方面,治疗前两组比较,无明显差异(P>0.05),提示两组患者疼痛评分相当。经治疗后评分均较治疗前明显下降,差异具有统计学意义(P<0.01,P<0.05),提示两种治疗方法均可以有效的改善疼痛症状。治疗后两组比较P<0.05,提示两组治疗效果比较差异有统计学意义,以治疗组改善明显。
僵硬症状评分方面：治疗前两组比较,无明显差异(P>0.05),提示两组患者僵硬症状评分相当。经治疗后评分均较治疗前明显下降,差异具有统计学意义(P<0.05),提示两种治疗方法均可以有效的改善僵硬症状。治疗后两组比较P>0.05,提示两组治疗效果比较差异无统计学意义,效果相当。
日常生活评分结果：治疗前两组比较,无明显差异(P>0.05),提示两组患者日常生活的困难评分相当。经治疗后评分均较治疗前明显下降,差异具有统计学意义(P<0.01,P<0.05),提示两种治疗方法均可以有效的改善日常生活的困难程度。治疗后两组比较P<0.05,提示两组治疗效果比较差异有统计学意义,以治疗组改善明显。
在临床疗效方面,治疗组可以达到76.67%,高于对照组63.33%；作为一种退行性改变,本病治愈率不高,在显效率方面,治疗组优于对照组(P<0.05)。
研究结论：
疼痛作为本病最早出现、最主要的症状,应作为衡量本病治疗效果的重要方面。在本研究中,VAS评分、临床症状评分、WOMAC中对于疼痛的评分均显示两组在治疗后疼痛症状均得到明显改善,通过组间比较可以进一步发现,采用经筋理论指导下的针刺方法止痛效果更加理想。
本病多见于中老年人,是影响中老年人生存质量的重要因素。随着人口的老龄化,其发病率逐年上升。因此提高患者生活质量,延缓病情发展是治疗该病的重要目标。本研究中,治疗后两组患者日常生活的困难评分较治疗前明显下降,差异具有统计学意义,提示两种治疗方法均可以有效的改善日常生活的困难程度。组间比较发现以治疗组改善明显。
本研究显示,治疗组可以达到76.67%,高于对照组63.33%；作为一种退行性改变,本病治愈率不高,在显效率方面,治疗组优于对照组。经筋刺法治疗膝关节骨性关节炎临床疗效确切；可以显著减轻疼痛症状、改善临床症状、提高生活质量,且操作简便,无不良反应,患者易于接受,是值得推广的疗法。
Objective:Knee osteoarthritis (KOA) is a kind of joint pathological changes marked by jiarticular cartilage degeneration and bone hyperplasia. The disease is most common in middle aged to elderly people. With the extension of human life, the incidence rises gradually. Concerned investigation shows, in our country the incidence of KOA is around 5% in the people over age 50, and 25% in those over 60 years old for women,15% for men.
At present,effective methods to reverse bone hyperplasia is still deficient, but for the reactive changes of surrounding tissue there can be kinds of methods. The common ones include drug interention, traditional Chinese medicine, joint flush and surgical treatment. Long-term use of drugs, particularly sedation, can easily produce a lot of complications; joint flush and surgical treatment are just partly used, because some older adults with basic disease can not tolerate, therefore chinese medicine becomes more and more important, for it can improve clinical symptoms and quality of life. Twelve meridian musculatures are part of meridian system, which get nutrition from twelve meridians, connet with joints of four limbs to hold skeleton and keep in touch with body, perfrom movement function. The essence of disease about this system is syndromes caused by the damage of muscle system that corresponding to twelve meridians. The musculature theory provides a simple and feasible way to treat knee osteoarthritis, and sets a firm theoretical basis. Therefore, it is significant to use the theory to guide the treatment of knee osteoarthritis.
Reseaches about meridional muscle region puncture in improving the musculature theory of "Neijing " and on the clinical observations are poor, so it is necessary to do deeper research on the clinical experiences of acupuncture doctors, to clear up and promote, in order that it can be widely used. For all above, this study selected randomized controlled method to observe the effect of meridional muscle region puncture in treating KOA.
Methods:The literature research summarized the understandings and treatments about KOA in traditional Chinese medicine and modern medicine, the development of musculature theory.
Clinical research part:60 cases fitted with the criteria were randomly divided into the treatment group and control group. The treatment group was guided by the musculature theory, with the rule"where there is a pain, there is a acupoint" as principle and clinical experiences from Tutor Prof. Zhuang Lixing. Ssearched for four pain pionts which located at the musculature that along with the knee joint. Inserted the needle quickly at the pain piont and deep into the periosteum, and inserted another two needles above and below the pain piont, all these pionts were at the same musculature. Retained the needles for 30 minutes after the arrival of qi,and rotated the needles with tonifying method every 5 minutes. Patients could endure for degrees. The control group were treated with conventional acupuncture and pionts such like Dubi, Neixiyan, Yanglingquan, Zusanli according to the reference" acupuncture amd moxibustion" (fifth edition, Ed. Shi Xuemin).The acupunture method, tonifying and reducing methods are the same as the treatment group, differences were to insert the needles into conventional acupuncture depth without lateral needling. Treated for three treatments. Before and after treatment, odserved the the visual analogy pain scale(VAS) in the McGill Simplified scale, clinical symptoms scores, WOMAC, KOA scale, then evaluated the clinical curative effect.
Results:The results showed that pain in both groups were significantly improved after treatment according to the VAS scores, clinical symptoms scores and WOMAC, with a better effect of relieving pain in the treatment group for guided by the musculature theory.
In terms of improving the quality fo life, Scores evaluating daily life's difficulties reduced with a statistically significance after treatment pointed out that both methods could help improve the difficulty in daily life. Compared with control group, treatment group is better in improvement. In the clinical curative effect, the total effective rate was over 60%, of which 76.67% went into the treatment group, and the effective rate of treatment group was higher than that of control group; As a degenerative change, the recovery rate is not high, but the treatment group was higher according to the significant efficiency.
Conclusion:Meridional muscle region puncture for Knee Osteoarthritis is actually effective; It can significantly reduce pain symptom, improve clinical symptoms and quality of life, simple but without adverse reaction, easy to be accepted, is worthy of widely clinical application.
期望通过本研究充分发挥中医针灸疗法优势对膝关节骨性关节炎进行治疗,并为进一步拓展和推广其日后临床应用打下基础。
研究方法：
文献研究综述了中医学、现代医学对膝关节骨性关节炎的认识和治疗,以及经筋理论的研究进展。
临床研究选取符合纳入标准的病例60例,将其随机分为两组,即治疗组和对照组。治疗组以经筋理论为指导,以“以痛为腧”为原则,依据导师庄礼兴教授临床经验,循膝关节相关的经筋系统进行排查,每次选取4个痛点进行手法操作。快速刺入病灶点,针刺深度要达到骨膜,并沿经筋循行路线于该病灶点上下各1寸处傍刺。得气后留针30分钟,每隔5分钟行针一次,手法为捻转泻法,以患者能耐受为度。对照组为常规针刺组,参照石学敏主编《针灸学》(第五版),选择犊鼻、内膝眼、阳陵泉、足三里。针刺手法、补泻手法同治疗组,针刺深度按常规进行,同时不需傍刺。治疗共3个疗程,观察治疗前后McGill简化疼痛量表中的目测类比疼痛评分(VAS)、临床症状评分、WOMAC (Western Ontario and McMaster Universities)膝关节骨性关节量表以及临床疗效评价。
研究结果：
VAS评分比较：治疗前两组比较,无明显差异(P>0.05),提示两组患者疼痛程度相当。经治疗后评分均较治疗前明显下降,差异具有统计学意义(P<0.01,P<0.05),提示两种治疗方法均可以有效的缓解疼痛症状。治疗后两组比较P<0.05,提示2组治疗效果比较差异有统计学意义,以治疗组缓解疼痛程度明显。
临床症状评分结果：治疗前两组比较,无明显差异(P>0.05),提示两组患者临床症状相当。经治疗后评分均较治疗前明显下降,差异具有统计学意义(P<0.01,P<0.05),提示两种治疗方法均可以有效的改善临床症状。治疗后两组比较P<0.05,提示两组治疗效果比较差异有统计学意义,以治疗组改善明显。
WOMAC评分结果：疼痛症状评分方面,治疗前两组比较,无明显差异(P>0.05),提示两组患者疼痛评分相当。经治疗后评分均较治疗前明显下降,差异具有统计学意义(P<0.01,P<0.05),提示两种治疗方法均可以有效的改善疼痛症状。治疗后两组比较P<0.05,提示两组治疗效果比较差异有统计学意义,以治疗组改善明显。
僵硬症状评分方面：治疗前两组比较,无明显差异(P>0.05),提示两组患者僵硬症状评分相当。经治疗后评分均较治疗前明显下降,差异具有统计学意义(P<0.05),提示两种治疗方法均可以有效的改善僵硬症状。治疗后两组比较P>0.05,提示两组治疗效果比较差异无统计学意义,效果相当。
日常生活评分结果：治疗前两组比较,无明显差异(P>0.05),提示两组患者日常生活的困难评分相当。经治疗后评分均较治疗前明显下降,差异具有统计学意义(P<0.01,P<0.05),提示两种治疗方法均可以有效的改善日常生活的困难程度。治疗后两组比较P<0.05,提示两组治疗效果比较差异有统计学意义,以治疗组改善明显。
在临床疗效方面,治疗组可以达到76.67%,高于对照组63.33%；作为一种退行性改变,本病治愈率不高,在显效率方面,治疗组优于对照组(P<0.05)。
研究结论：
疼痛作为本病最早出现、最主要的症状,应作为衡量本病治疗效果的重要方面。在本研究中,VAS评分、临床症状评分、WOMAC中对于疼痛的评分均显示两组在治疗后疼痛症状均得到明显改善,通过组间比较可以进一步发现,采用经筋理论指导下的针刺方法止痛效果更加理想。
本病多见于中老年人,是影响中老年人生存质量的重要因素。随着人口的老龄化,其发病率逐年上升。因此提高患者生活质量,延缓病情发展是治疗该病的重要目标。本研究中,治疗后两组患者日常生活的困难评分较治疗前明显下降,差异具有统计学意义,提示两种治疗方法均可以有效的改善日常生活的困难程度。组间比较发现以治疗组改善明显。
本研究显示,治疗组可以达到76.67%,高于对照组63.33%；作为一种退行性改变,本病治愈率不高,在显效率方面,治疗组优于对照组。经筋刺法治疗膝关节骨性关节炎临床疗效确切；可以显著减轻疼痛症状、改善临床症状、提高生活质量,且操作简便,无不良反应,患者易于接受,是值得推广的疗法。
Objective:Knee osteoarthritis (KOA) is a kind of joint pathological changes marked by jiarticular cartilage degeneration and bone hyperplasia. The disease is most common in middle aged to elderly people. With the extension of human life, the incidence rises gradually. Concerned investigation shows, in our country the incidence of KOA is around 5% in the people over age 50, and 25% in those over 60 years old for women,15% for men.
At present,effective methods to reverse bone hyperplasia is still deficient, but for the reactive changes of surrounding tissue there can be kinds of methods. The common ones include drug interention, traditional Chinese medicine, joint flush and surgical treatment. Long-term use of drugs, particularly sedation, can easily produce a lot of complications; joint flush and surgical treatment are just partly used, because some older adults with basic disease can not tolerate, therefore chinese medicine becomes more and more important, for it can improve clinical symptoms and quality of life. Twelve meridian musculatures are part of meridian system, which get nutrition from twelve meridians, connet with joints of four limbs to hold skeleton and keep in touch with body, perfrom movement function. The essence of disease about this system is syndromes caused by the damage of muscle system that corresponding to twelve meridians. The musculature theory provides a simple and feasible way to treat knee osteoarthritis, and sets a firm theoretical basis. Therefore, it is significant to use the theory to guide the treatment of knee osteoarthritis.
Reseaches about meridional muscle region puncture in improving the musculature theory of "Neijing " and on the clinical observations are poor, so it is necessary to do deeper research on the clinical experiences of acupuncture doctors, to clear up and promote, in order that it can be widely used. For all above, this study selected randomized controlled method to observe the effect of meridional muscle region puncture in treating KOA.
Methods:The literature research summarized the understandings and treatments about KOA in traditional Chinese medicine and modern medicine, the development of musculature theory.
Clinical research part:60 cases fitted with the criteria were randomly divided into the treatment group and control group. The treatment group was guided by the musculature theory, with the rule"where there is a pain, there is a acupoint" as principle and clinical experiences from Tutor Prof. Zhuang Lixing. Ssearched for four pain pionts which located at the musculature that along with the knee joint. Inserted the needle quickly at the pain piont and deep into the periosteum, and inserted another two needles above and below the pain piont, all these pionts were at the same musculature. Retained the needles for 30 minutes after the arrival of qi,and rotated the needles with tonifying method every 5 minutes. Patients could endure for degrees. The control group were treated with conventional acupuncture and pionts such like Dubi, Neixiyan, Yanglingquan, Zusanli according to the reference" acupuncture amd moxibustion" (fifth edition, Ed. Shi Xuemin).The acupunture method, tonifying and reducing methods are the same as the treatment group, differences were to insert the needles into conventional acupuncture depth without lateral needling. Treated for three treatments. Before and after treatment, odserved the the visual analogy pain scale(VAS) in the McGill Simplified scale, clinical symptoms scores, WOMAC, KOA scale, then evaluated the clinical curative effect.
Results:The results showed that pain in both groups were significantly improved after treatment according to the VAS scores, clinical symptoms scores and WOMAC, with a better effect of relieving pain in the treatment group for guided by the musculature theory.
In terms of improving the quality fo life, Scores evaluating daily life's difficulties reduced with a statistically significance after treatment pointed out that both methods could help improve the difficulty in daily life. Compared with control group, treatment group is better in improvement. In the clinical curative effect, the total effective rate was over 60%, of which 76.67% went into the treatment group, and the effective rate of treatment group was higher than that of control group; As a degenerative change, the recovery rate is not high, but the treatment group was higher according to the significant efficiency.
Conclusion:Meridional muscle region puncture for Knee Osteoarthritis is actually effective; It can significantly reduce pain symptom, improve clinical symptoms and quality of life, simple but without adverse reaction, easy to be accepted, is worthy of widely clinical application.
引文
[1]何斌,史晨辉.尿激酶型纤溶酶原激活物系统与软骨降解.农垦医学,2005.6,27(3)：229.
[2]江蓉星.骨性关节炎的临床治疗研究概况.中国中医骨伤科杂志,2003.2,11(1)：57.
[3]曲俊才.膝骨关节炎模型兔关节液中细胞因子白细胞介素1水平及复方归芪液的干预效应.中国组织工程研究与临床康复,2008,12：20.
[4]林国华,李万瑶,苏国龙.火针对实验性小鼠膝骨关节炎关节软骨病理改变的影响.广州中医药大学学报,2005,22(5)：373-376.
[5]高文香,刘元禄,李永生,等.补肾法防治兔膝关节骨性关节炎的病理形态学规察.中医正骨,1999,11(12)：13-15.
[6]汪青春,沈培芝,徐宇,等.不同方药治疗膝骨关节炎的组织形态学对比研究.中国中医骨伤科,1998,6(2)：1-3.
[7]郭建刚,冯坤, 赵然,等.壮筋活血汤对骨性关节炎软骨退变防治作用的生化研究.中国骨伤,1999,12(5)：19.
[8]唐旭升,杜宁,张吴.手法治疗大鼠实验性膝骨关节炎扫描电镜研究.中医正骨,2001.13(1)：3-4.
[9]Ficat RP. Idiopathic bone necrosis of the femoral head. Early diagnosis and treatment. Bone Joint Surg Br 1985:67(1):3-9.
[10]郑召民,许振华.骨内高压与活血化瘀.中国中医骨伤科,1994,2(3)：43-47.
[11]崔全军,许振华,刘保民,等.骨内高压减压前后血液流变学状态实验研究.河南医学研究,1992,1(1)：58.
[12]韦文武,王大伟.补气活血法治疗膝骨关节炎的实验研究.广西中医药,2004,27(5)：46—48.
[13]叶俊星,白书臣,吉璐宏.骨痛胶囊对日本大耳白兔膝骨内高压和血液流变学作用的实验研究.中国中医骨伤科杂志,2007,15(2)：45—48.
[14]黄涛,徐传毅,邹季,等.活血止痛汤治疗早期骨性关节炎的实验研究.中医正骨,1999,11(5)：3—5.
[15]邓廉夫.IL-1, TNF和IL-6与骨性关节炎.国外医学：创伤与外科基本问题分册,1996,17(2)：102-106.
[16]余丹丹.骨性关节炎实验研究进展.中医正骨,2000,12(12)：50-52.
[17]Ryoo HM, Van Wi jnen AJ, Stein JL, et al. Detection of a proliferation specific gene during development of the osteoblast phenotype by mRNA differential display. Cell Biochem,1997,64(11):106-116.
[18]Trippel SB. Growth factor actions on articular cartilage. Rheumatol Suppl,1995,43:129-132.
[19]王秀华,刘元禄,苏瓷兵,等.丹参关节内注射对兔膝骨关节炎细胞因子IL-1及TNF的影响.中医正骨,2003,10(10)：577-578.
[20]郭礼跃,胡慧华,米健国.古方稀莶丸对膝骨性关节炎模型家兔关节液中IL-1β、 TNF-α含量及关节软骨细胞形态学的影响.中国骨伤.2006,6(6)：377—378.
[21]潘海东,曲波,王耶.参麦注射液对骨关节炎动物模型血液中自细胞介素21水平的影响.中国中医骨伤科杂志,2000,8(1)：17—18.
[22]汪青春,石印玉,沈培芝.中药对膝骨关节炎小鼠关节软骨IL-1、iNOS基因表达的影响.山西医药杂志,1999,28(5)；381—383.
[23]俞杰,明顺培,张秀芬.针刀疗法对兔膝骨关节炎关节液中IL-1β, IL-6、TNF-α水平的影响.中国中医骨伤科杂志.2002,10(4)：15-18.
[24]吴弢,高翔,王拥军,等.益气化瘀利水方干预后兔膝骨关节炎软骨中转化生长因子1的变化.中国组织工程研究与临床康复,2006,10(39)：118-1 19.
[25]高翔,吴弢,王拥军,等.益气化瘀利水方干预兔膝骨关节炎软骨中胰岛素样生长因子1的变化.中国组织工程研究与临床康复.2006,10(39)：95-97
[26]王孟琳,熊晓荣,王婧锦.杜灵注射液对兔膝骨性关节炎TGF-β1水平的影响作用.陕西中医,2007,1(28)：117-119.
[27]彭丹,孙材江,周江南.一氧化氮在实验性骨关节炎软骨细胞凋亡中的作用.风湿病学杂志,2000,4(4)：232—234.
[28]Panasiuk AF, Iaroshuk GV, Mltrovich D. Effect of free radicals on proliferation and metabolism of chondrocytes and on sensitivity of a cellular monolayer to proteases. Vopr Med Khim,1995; 41(6):19-22.
[29]Schiller J, Amhold J, Schwinn J, et al. Reaetivity of cartilage and selected carbohydrates with hydroxyl radicals:an NMR study to detect degradation products. Free Radic Res,1998,28(2):215—218.
[30]韩崑,熊昌源.三联疗法对兔膝关节骨关节炎氧自由基代谢的影响.湖北中医杂志.2006,28(3)：9-10.
[31]马建兵,刘德玉,李堪印,等.中药对家兔实验性膝关节骨性关节炎氧自由基代谢的影响.中医正骨,2000,12(1)：8-9.
[32]汪青春,蒂蕙芳,沈培芝,等.中药对膝骨关节炎黑鼠血清SOD、HA、NO水平的影响.中医正骨,1999,11(5)：6-8.
[33]Zakeri Z, Lockshin RA. Physiological cell death during development and its relationship to aging. Ann NY Acad Sci,1994,719(1):212-229.
[34]Hashimoto S. Takahashi K. Amiel D, et al. Chondrocyte apoptosis and nitric oxide production during experimentally induced osteoarthritis. Arthritis Rheum,1998,41 (7):1266-1274.
[35]Blanco FJ, Guitian R, Vazquez-Martul E, et al. Osteoarthritis chondrocytes die by apoptosis. A possible pathway for osteoarthritis pathology. Arthritis Rheum,1998,41 (2):284—289.
[36]何新芳,明顺培,俞杰.针刀疗法对膝骨关节炎兔关节软骨细胞凋亡的影响.辽宁中医杂志,2006,33(7)：894-895.
[37]王松,沈霖,肖琳.艾灸疗法影响兔膝骨性关节炎软骨细胞凋亡的效应.中国组织工程研究与临床康复.2006,10(39)：55—58.
[38]方锐,孟庆才,王拥军.等.补肾通络方对大鼠膝关节炎软骨中半胱氨酸天冬氨酸特异性蛋白酶3的调节.中国组织工程研究与临床康复,2006,10(43)：67—69.
[39]蔡余力,李刚,颜冰,等.补肾壮骨胶囊治疗膝关节骨性关节炎的实验研究.中医正骨,2006,18(10)：1—4.
[40]卢思俭,姜全心,王成.益肾为主对兔膝骨关节炎模型软骨细胞凋亡的影响.山东中医杂志,2006,25(10)：696—698.
[41]粱伯进,唐兴荣.丹芪注射液关节腔注射改善创伤后关节退行性病变的实验研究.中国临床康复,2004,8(11)：2088—2090.
[42]吴弢,高翔,瞿倩,等.益气化瘀利水方对骨关节炎兔前列腺素代谢的影响.老年医学与保健,2004,10(1)：24-26.
[43]肖雷,蒋戈利,邢军,等.四步针药疗法治疗膝骨性关节炎的疗效观察.中医药学刊,2004,22(10)：1920-1921.
[44]李晓吴,黄清春,沈鹰.单刺曲池穴治疗膝关节骨关节炎68例.中国临床康复,2004,8(22)：4027.
[45]王健.大杼穴刺络拔罐治疗膝关节痛48例.中国针灸,2003,23(1)：35.
[46]褚建平.合谷刺治疗膝骨性关节炎15例.中国针灸,1998,18(11)：675—676.
[47]佘贤传.围刺配合神灯照射治疗骨性关节炎.新疆中医药,2000,18(3)：30.
[48]刘立安,马春燕.温针灸治疗老年膝骨关节病的临床观察.中国针灸,2003,23(10)：579—580.
[49]吴扬扬,廖静平.浮针刺法治疗膝骨关节疼痛.中国针灸,2005,25(4)：261—262.
[50]旷秋和.火针治疗膝骨性关节炎50例疗效观察.针灸临床杂志,2006,22(5)：19—20.
[51]伦志坚,叶继英.腹针结合局部针刺治疗膝关节骨性关节炎.广东医药杂志,2006,27(1)：12—13.
[52]丛莘,金庆文.针灸结合刺络放血治疗骨性膝关节炎的临床观察.中国自然医学杂志,2004,9(3)：172—174.
[53]王俊玲,施光其.温针灸加中药熏洗治疗老年性膝骨关节病50例.陕西中医,2004,25(8)：745.
[54]冯月英,曹金山.温针配合超短波治疗膝关节骨性关节炎疗效观察.针灸临床杂志,2004,20(7)：34—35.
[55]阮经文,王楚怀.针灸配合功能训练治疗膝骨性关节炎的临床研究.中国康复医学杂志,2003,18(10)：606.
[56]孙刚,王永锡.骨内静脉淤滞、骨内高压在骨性关节炎发病中的作用初探.中华骨科杂志,1991,11(5)：374—376.
[57]孙作露.针刺对大鼠试验性关节炎的影响-针刺活血化瘀效应观察.中国针灸,1996,16(2)：35—38.
[58]潘海乐,姚跃.骨性关节炎模型动物血液、关节液中IL-1水平检测.哈尔滨医科大学学报,2001,35(3)：192—194.
[59]赵锦松,李小霞.骨关节炎发病中的软骨免疫机制.中华风湿病学杂志,2005,9(7)：434—436.
[60]马朱红,刘心莲.针灸对类风湿性关节炎患者免疫-神经-内分泌系统影响的临床研究.中国针灸,1997,17(9)：529—531.
[61]唐照亮,宋小鸽.艾灸治疗类风湿性关节炎抗炎免疫作用机理的研究.针刺研究,2003,28(4)：292—298.
[62]康一凡,绛育.氧自由基与膝骨关节炎关系的实验及临床研究.第二军医大学学报,2001,22(10)：945—948.
[63]Burkhardt H, Schwi ngel M. Oxygen radicals as effectors of cartilage destruction. Direct degradative effect on matrix components and indirect action via activation of latent collagenase frompol ymor phonucl ear leukocytes. Athrits Rheum,1986,29(3):397—387.
[64]李美荣,王美美.骨关节炎患者血清和关节液一氧化氮及其合成酶变化的意义.安徽医药,2004,2(9)：108—109.
[65]彭丹,孙材江.一氧化氮在实验性骨关节炎软骨细胞凋亡中的作用.中华风湿病学杂志,2000,4(4)：232—235.
[66]朱梅菊,高顺生.针刺足三里穴对运动小鼠体内自由基代谢的影响.中国运动学杂志,2001,20(3)：263—265.
[67]张志军.一氧化氮、活性氧与针灸治疗.国外医学·中医中药分册,2001,23(5)：272—277.
[68]李宁丽,王利.骨关节炎与免疫关联性初探.上海免疫学杂志,2001,21(6)： 352—354.
[69]Payne SJT, Dinarello CA. Human Monocyte or recombinant and interleukin are specific for the secretion of metalloproteinases from chondroctes. J. Immunol,1987,138:498.
[70]陈启明.骨科基础科学.第2版.北京：人民卫生出版社,2001.394.
[71]管剑龙,施桂英.骨关节炎患者血清和滑液中金属蛋白酶-2和-9的研究.中华风湿病学杂志，2001,5(2)：102—105.
[72]王强.针灸对类风湿性关节炎患者免疫功能及抗自由基酶类的影响.中国中医药信息杂志,2001,8(8)：68.
[73]宋亚文,谢利民.针刺取穴与骨折愈合疗效关系初探.中国中医骨伤科杂志,2005,13(1)：12—15.
[74]李迎军,金成壁.骨性关节病患者关节液中微量元素测定及临床意义.现代放射学,1994,5(2)：481.
[75]林昂如,金明新,孟庆礼.骨关节炎关节液钙及多种微量元素的测定分析.中华骨科杂志,2005,(5)：290.
[76]张秀花,丁永清.针刺对体内微量元素变化的影响.中国中医药科技,2002,9(2)：66.
[77]董秀兰,塞冬.针刺治疗脱发40例及微量元素变化.中国针灸,1994,(增刊)：121—123.
[78]张俐,移平.针灸对骨折家兔微量元素的影响.中国中医骨伤科杂志,1999,7(5)：1—4.
[79]刘英杰,董彦,刘利芳.骨性关节炎的分期治疗：随机分组对照的3年随访.中国临床康复,2004,8(8)：1426-1427.
[80]庞晓峰,衣雪洁,常波.经络辨证与循经取穴治疗肩周炎的临床研究.针灸临床杂志,2001,17(12)：10.
[81]冯广扬,易焕彪,黄敬伟. 《黄帝内经》经筋学理论概述.中国中医基础医学杂志,1995,1(2)：15—16.
[82]陈晓莉.经筋病证治规律探析.四川中医,1994,4：14—15.
[83]刘涛.经筋实质管窥.针灸临床杂志,2007,23(1)：3-4.
[84]黄敬伟.经筋疗法.北京：中国中医药出版社,1996：1.
[85]杨世芳《灵枢·经筋》浅论.天津中医学院学报,1990(4)：12—13.
[86]秦玉革.《内经》经筋的实质是神经.中国针灸,2006,26(2)：147-150.
[87]王雨.十二经筋病候与针灸临床.中医杂志,1989,30(5)：20—21.
[88]吴金鹏.中医“经筋”及“膜原”实质的筋膜理论探讨.北京中医,2007,26(5)：283—285.
[89]韦英才.浅释经筋与经脉的异同及其临床意义.广州中医药大学学报,2007,24(3)：247-248.
[90]沈志生.内经经筋理论的再认识.中国针灸,2006,26(9)：639—640.
[91]廉玉麟.经筋的特点及其在针灸临床中的意义.天津中医学院学报,1984.1：40—42.
[92]周丽,皮明钧,谭达全.“筋”理论探析.湖南中医药大学学报,2007,27(5)：10—11.
[93]王茵萍.经筋病“以痛为腧”刍议.中国针灸,2000,6：375.377.
[94]董宝强,李曦明,董刚.论十二经脉气血多少与经筋的关系.中华中医药杂志,2008,23(2)：94—-97.
[95]王雨.十二经筋概述及其实质初探.中医杂志,1982,(12)：43—46.
[96]胥荣东,王君.“以知为数”释义.上海针灸杂志,2006,25(2)：49—50.
[97]刘金洪. 《灵枢·经筋》治筋痹法浅析.四川中医,1999,17(3)：11-12.
[98]赵勇,郭振芳,董福慧.经筋痹痛与软组织张力的相关性探讨.北京中医药大学学报,2003,26(61)：85—-86.
[99]杨丽美. 《内经》经筋理论的应用.宁夏医学院学报,2006,28(3)：262—263.
[100]黄敬伟,陈胜伟.中华经筋疗法的发掘研究.甘肃中医,1994,7(4)：44-45.
[101]曾昭荣. “激痛点”在颈肩腰腿痛上的诊治意义.颈腰痛杂志,1982,2(2)：8-11.
[102]李晶,刘辉.增生性膝关节炎结筋病灶点的临床观察.中国针灸.2002.22(8)：533-534.
[2]江蓉星.骨性关节炎的临床治疗研究概况.中国中医骨伤科杂志,2003.2,11(1)：57.
[3]曲俊才.膝骨关节炎模型兔关节液中细胞因子白细胞介素1水平及复方归芪液的干预效应.中国组织工程研究与临床康复,2008,12：20.
[4]林国华,李万瑶,苏国龙.火针对实验性小鼠膝骨关节炎关节软骨病理改变的影响.广州中医药大学学报,2005,22(5)：373-376.
[5]高文香,刘元禄,李永生,等.补肾法防治兔膝关节骨性关节炎的病理形态学规察.中医正骨,1999,11(12)：13-15.
[6]汪青春,沈培芝,徐宇,等.不同方药治疗膝骨关节炎的组织形态学对比研究.中国中医骨伤科,1998,6(2)：1-3.
[7]郭建刚,冯坤, 赵然,等.壮筋活血汤对骨性关节炎软骨退变防治作用的生化研究.中国骨伤,1999,12(5)：19.
[8]唐旭升,杜宁,张吴.手法治疗大鼠实验性膝骨关节炎扫描电镜研究.中医正骨,2001.13(1)：3-4.
[9]Ficat RP. Idiopathic bone necrosis of the femoral head. Early diagnosis and treatment. Bone Joint Surg Br 1985:67(1):3-9.
[10]郑召民,许振华.骨内高压与活血化瘀.中国中医骨伤科,1994,2(3)：43-47.
[11]崔全军,许振华,刘保民,等.骨内高压减压前后血液流变学状态实验研究.河南医学研究,1992,1(1)：58.
[12]韦文武,王大伟.补气活血法治疗膝骨关节炎的实验研究.广西中医药,2004,27(5)：46—48.
[13]叶俊星,白书臣,吉璐宏.骨痛胶囊对日本大耳白兔膝骨内高压和血液流变学作用的实验研究.中国中医骨伤科杂志,2007,15(2)：45—48.
[14]黄涛,徐传毅,邹季,等.活血止痛汤治疗早期骨性关节炎的实验研究.中医正骨,1999,11(5)：3—5.
[15]邓廉夫.IL-1, TNF和IL-6与骨性关节炎.国外医学：创伤与外科基本问题分册,1996,17(2)：102-106.
[16]余丹丹.骨性关节炎实验研究进展.中医正骨,2000,12(12)：50-52.
[17]Ryoo HM, Van Wi jnen AJ, Stein JL, et al. Detection of a proliferation specific gene during development of the osteoblast phenotype by mRNA differential display. Cell Biochem,1997,64(11):106-116.
[18]Trippel SB. Growth factor actions on articular cartilage. Rheumatol Suppl,1995,43:129-132.
[19]王秀华,刘元禄,苏瓷兵,等.丹参关节内注射对兔膝骨关节炎细胞因子IL-1及TNF的影响.中医正骨,2003,10(10)：577-578.
[20]郭礼跃,胡慧华,米健国.古方稀莶丸对膝骨性关节炎模型家兔关节液中IL-1β、 TNF-α含量及关节软骨细胞形态学的影响.中国骨伤.2006,6(6)：377—378.
[21]潘海东,曲波,王耶.参麦注射液对骨关节炎动物模型血液中自细胞介素21水平的影响.中国中医骨伤科杂志,2000,8(1)：17—18.
[22]汪青春,石印玉,沈培芝.中药对膝骨关节炎小鼠关节软骨IL-1、iNOS基因表达的影响.山西医药杂志,1999,28(5)；381—383.
[23]俞杰,明顺培,张秀芬.针刀疗法对兔膝骨关节炎关节液中IL-1β, IL-6、TNF-α水平的影响.中国中医骨伤科杂志.2002,10(4)：15-18.
[24]吴弢,高翔,王拥军,等.益气化瘀利水方干预后兔膝骨关节炎软骨中转化生长因子1的变化.中国组织工程研究与临床康复,2006,10(39)：118-1 19.
[25]高翔,吴弢,王拥军,等.益气化瘀利水方干预兔膝骨关节炎软骨中胰岛素样生长因子1的变化.中国组织工程研究与临床康复.2006,10(39)：95-97
[26]王孟琳,熊晓荣,王婧锦.杜灵注射液对兔膝骨性关节炎TGF-β1水平的影响作用.陕西中医,2007,1(28)：117-119.
[27]彭丹,孙材江,周江南.一氧化氮在实验性骨关节炎软骨细胞凋亡中的作用.风湿病学杂志,2000,4(4)：232—234.
[28]Panasiuk AF, Iaroshuk GV, Mltrovich D. Effect of free radicals on proliferation and metabolism of chondrocytes and on sensitivity of a cellular monolayer to proteases. Vopr Med Khim,1995; 41(6):19-22.
[29]Schiller J, Amhold J, Schwinn J, et al. Reaetivity of cartilage and selected carbohydrates with hydroxyl radicals:an NMR study to detect degradation products. Free Radic Res,1998,28(2):215—218.
[30]韩崑,熊昌源.三联疗法对兔膝关节骨关节炎氧自由基代谢的影响.湖北中医杂志.2006,28(3)：9-10.
[31]马建兵,刘德玉,李堪印,等.中药对家兔实验性膝关节骨性关节炎氧自由基代谢的影响.中医正骨,2000,12(1)：8-9.
[32]汪青春,蒂蕙芳,沈培芝,等.中药对膝骨关节炎黑鼠血清SOD、HA、NO水平的影响.中医正骨,1999,11(5)：6-8.
[33]Zakeri Z, Lockshin RA. Physiological cell death during development and its relationship to aging. Ann NY Acad Sci,1994,719(1):212-229.
[34]Hashimoto S. Takahashi K. Amiel D, et al. Chondrocyte apoptosis and nitric oxide production during experimentally induced osteoarthritis. Arthritis Rheum,1998,41 (7):1266-1274.
[35]Blanco FJ, Guitian R, Vazquez-Martul E, et al. Osteoarthritis chondrocytes die by apoptosis. A possible pathway for osteoarthritis pathology. Arthritis Rheum,1998,41 (2):284—289.
[36]何新芳,明顺培,俞杰.针刀疗法对膝骨关节炎兔关节软骨细胞凋亡的影响.辽宁中医杂志,2006,33(7)：894-895.
[37]王松,沈霖,肖琳.艾灸疗法影响兔膝骨性关节炎软骨细胞凋亡的效应.中国组织工程研究与临床康复.2006,10(39)：55—58.
[38]方锐,孟庆才,王拥军.等.补肾通络方对大鼠膝关节炎软骨中半胱氨酸天冬氨酸特异性蛋白酶3的调节.中国组织工程研究与临床康复,2006,10(43)：67—69.
[39]蔡余力,李刚,颜冰,等.补肾壮骨胶囊治疗膝关节骨性关节炎的实验研究.中医正骨,2006,18(10)：1—4.
[40]卢思俭,姜全心,王成.益肾为主对兔膝骨关节炎模型软骨细胞凋亡的影响.山东中医杂志,2006,25(10)：696—698.
[41]粱伯进,唐兴荣.丹芪注射液关节腔注射改善创伤后关节退行性病变的实验研究.中国临床康复,2004,8(11)：2088—2090.
[42]吴弢,高翔,瞿倩,等.益气化瘀利水方对骨关节炎兔前列腺素代谢的影响.老年医学与保健,2004,10(1)：24-26.
[43]肖雷,蒋戈利,邢军,等.四步针药疗法治疗膝骨性关节炎的疗效观察.中医药学刊,2004,22(10)：1920-1921.
[44]李晓吴,黄清春,沈鹰.单刺曲池穴治疗膝关节骨关节炎68例.中国临床康复,2004,8(22)：4027.
[45]王健.大杼穴刺络拔罐治疗膝关节痛48例.中国针灸,2003,23(1)：35.
[46]褚建平.合谷刺治疗膝骨性关节炎15例.中国针灸,1998,18(11)：675—676.
[47]佘贤传.围刺配合神灯照射治疗骨性关节炎.新疆中医药,2000,18(3)：30.
[48]刘立安,马春燕.温针灸治疗老年膝骨关节病的临床观察.中国针灸,2003,23(10)：579—580.
[49]吴扬扬,廖静平.浮针刺法治疗膝骨关节疼痛.中国针灸,2005,25(4)：261—262.
[50]旷秋和.火针治疗膝骨性关节炎50例疗效观察.针灸临床杂志,2006,22(5)：19—20.
[51]伦志坚,叶继英.腹针结合局部针刺治疗膝关节骨性关节炎.广东医药杂志,2006,27(1)：12—13.
[52]丛莘,金庆文.针灸结合刺络放血治疗骨性膝关节炎的临床观察.中国自然医学杂志,2004,9(3)：172—174.
[53]王俊玲,施光其.温针灸加中药熏洗治疗老年性膝骨关节病50例.陕西中医,2004,25(8)：745.
[54]冯月英,曹金山.温针配合超短波治疗膝关节骨性关节炎疗效观察.针灸临床杂志,2004,20(7)：34—35.
[55]阮经文,王楚怀.针灸配合功能训练治疗膝骨性关节炎的临床研究.中国康复医学杂志,2003,18(10)：606.
[56]孙刚,王永锡.骨内静脉淤滞、骨内高压在骨性关节炎发病中的作用初探.中华骨科杂志,1991,11(5)：374—376.
[57]孙作露.针刺对大鼠试验性关节炎的影响-针刺活血化瘀效应观察.中国针灸,1996,16(2)：35—38.
[58]潘海乐,姚跃.骨性关节炎模型动物血液、关节液中IL-1水平检测.哈尔滨医科大学学报,2001,35(3)：192—194.
[59]赵锦松,李小霞.骨关节炎发病中的软骨免疫机制.中华风湿病学杂志,2005,9(7)：434—436.
[60]马朱红,刘心莲.针灸对类风湿性关节炎患者免疫-神经-内分泌系统影响的临床研究.中国针灸,1997,17(9)：529—531.
[61]唐照亮,宋小鸽.艾灸治疗类风湿性关节炎抗炎免疫作用机理的研究.针刺研究,2003,28(4)：292—298.
[62]康一凡,绛育.氧自由基与膝骨关节炎关系的实验及临床研究.第二军医大学学报,2001,22(10)：945—948.
[63]Burkhardt H, Schwi ngel M. Oxygen radicals as effectors of cartilage destruction. Direct degradative effect on matrix components and indirect action via activation of latent collagenase frompol ymor phonucl ear leukocytes. Athrits Rheum,1986,29(3):397—387.
[64]李美荣,王美美.骨关节炎患者血清和关节液一氧化氮及其合成酶变化的意义.安徽医药,2004,2(9)：108—109.
[65]彭丹,孙材江.一氧化氮在实验性骨关节炎软骨细胞凋亡中的作用.中华风湿病学杂志,2000,4(4)：232—235.
[66]朱梅菊,高顺生.针刺足三里穴对运动小鼠体内自由基代谢的影响.中国运动学杂志,2001,20(3)：263—265.
[67]张志军.一氧化氮、活性氧与针灸治疗.国外医学·中医中药分册,2001,23(5)：272—277.
[68]李宁丽,王利.骨关节炎与免疫关联性初探.上海免疫学杂志,2001,21(6)： 352—354.
[69]Payne SJT, Dinarello CA. Human Monocyte or recombinant and interleukin are specific for the secretion of metalloproteinases from chondroctes. J. Immunol,1987,138:498.
[70]陈启明.骨科基础科学.第2版.北京：人民卫生出版社,2001.394.
[71]管剑龙,施桂英.骨关节炎患者血清和滑液中金属蛋白酶-2和-9的研究.中华风湿病学杂志，2001,5(2)：102—105.
[72]王强.针灸对类风湿性关节炎患者免疫功能及抗自由基酶类的影响.中国中医药信息杂志,2001,8(8)：68.
[73]宋亚文,谢利民.针刺取穴与骨折愈合疗效关系初探.中国中医骨伤科杂志,2005,13(1)：12—15.
[74]李迎军,金成壁.骨性关节病患者关节液中微量元素测定及临床意义.现代放射学,1994,5(2)：481.
[75]林昂如,金明新,孟庆礼.骨关节炎关节液钙及多种微量元素的测定分析.中华骨科杂志,2005,(5)：290.
[76]张秀花,丁永清.针刺对体内微量元素变化的影响.中国中医药科技,2002,9(2)：66.
[77]董秀兰,塞冬.针刺治疗脱发40例及微量元素变化.中国针灸,1994,(增刊)：121—123.
[78]张俐,移平.针灸对骨折家兔微量元素的影响.中国中医骨伤科杂志,1999,7(5)：1—4.
[79]刘英杰,董彦,刘利芳.骨性关节炎的分期治疗：随机分组对照的3年随访.中国临床康复,2004,8(8)：1426-1427.
[80]庞晓峰,衣雪洁,常波.经络辨证与循经取穴治疗肩周炎的临床研究.针灸临床杂志,2001,17(12)：10.
[81]冯广扬,易焕彪,黄敬伟. 《黄帝内经》经筋学理论概述.中国中医基础医学杂志,1995,1(2)：15—16.
[82]陈晓莉.经筋病证治规律探析.四川中医,1994,4：14—15.
[83]刘涛.经筋实质管窥.针灸临床杂志,2007,23(1)：3-4.
[84]黄敬伟.经筋疗法.北京：中国中医药出版社,1996：1.
[85]杨世芳《灵枢·经筋》浅论.天津中医学院学报,1990(4)：12—13.
[86]秦玉革.《内经》经筋的实质是神经.中国针灸,2006,26(2)：147-150.
[87]王雨.十二经筋病候与针灸临床.中医杂志,1989,30(5)：20—21.
[88]吴金鹏.中医“经筋”及“膜原”实质的筋膜理论探讨.北京中医,2007,26(5)：283—285.
[89]韦英才.浅释经筋与经脉的异同及其临床意义.广州中医药大学学报,2007,24(3)：247-248.
[90]沈志生.内经经筋理论的再认识.中国针灸,2006,26(9)：639—640.
[91]廉玉麟.经筋的特点及其在针灸临床中的意义.天津中医学院学报,1984.1：40—42.
[92]周丽,皮明钧,谭达全.“筋”理论探析.湖南中医药大学学报,2007,27(5)：10—11.
[93]王茵萍.经筋病“以痛为腧”刍议.中国针灸,2000,6：375.377.
[94]董宝强,李曦明,董刚.论十二经脉气血多少与经筋的关系.中华中医药杂志,2008,23(2)：94—-97.
[95]王雨.十二经筋概述及其实质初探.中医杂志,1982,(12)：43—46.
[96]胥荣东,王君.“以知为数”释义.上海针灸杂志,2006,25(2)：49—50.
[97]刘金洪. 《灵枢·经筋》治筋痹法浅析.四川中医,1999,17(3)：11-12.
[98]赵勇,郭振芳,董福慧.经筋痹痛与软组织张力的相关性探讨.北京中医药大学学报,2003,26(61)：85—-86.
[99]杨丽美. 《内经》经筋理论的应用.宁夏医学院学报,2006,28(3)：262—263.
[100]黄敬伟,陈胜伟.中华经筋疗法的发掘研究.甘肃中医,1994,7(4)：44-45.
[101]曾昭荣. “激痛点”在颈肩腰腿痛上的诊治意义.颈腰痛杂志,1982,2(2)：8-11.
[102]李晶,刘辉.增生性膝关节炎结筋病灶点的临床观察.中国针灸.2002.22(8)：533-534.