三部九候脉诊法探析及客观化研究
|
摘要
三部九候脉诊法,是我国中医自古以来脉诊所使用的一套方法。传统意义上的三部九候诊法把人看作自然界的一个缩影,运用天地人的观点,将人体分为上、中、下三部,每部各分为“天”、“地”、“人”三候,共九部,并认为这九个部分可以反映生活在自然界中人的情况。因通过观察脉象与形体是否相应,上中下三部是否相互调和,以诊察全身病变情况,此种三部九候脉诊法又可称为三部九候遍身诊法,是《内经》惟一列出专篇,用大量笔墨阐述最详尽的脉法(包括切脉部位、主病、辨病、意义等)。与其他脉法比较,突出了定位意义,丰富了《内经》脉学理论,是《内经》脉学理论的精华,为后世脉学发展奠定了理论基础。
另一方面,三部九候脉诊法也可用于寸口诊法,《难经》在《内经》寸口脉法的基础上正式确立了“独取寸口诊法”,并赋予了“三部九候”脉诊法新的内容。将寸口脉分寸、关、尺三部,每部各以轻、中、重指力按脉,分浮、中、沉,(《难经·十八难》)故也称为三部九候法。三部九候脉诊法辨病辨证,强调九候相参,综合分析,体现了诊法的整体观思想,其中尤为强调各部各候之间的相互参比意义。
因此,研究三部九候脉诊法的溯源、发展、具体运用、临床意义及相关认识等,对中医脉学诊断的理论及实践有非常重要的意义。但当前对三部九候脉诊法源流及应用的文献专门论述相当少,现本研究通过对脉学发展,尤其是对三部九候脉诊理论有重大贡献的《内经》、《难经》、《伤寒论》等典籍著作中的脉学相关内容进行梳理、摘录及分析,从两种不同三部九候脉诊法入手,对其脉学思想、诊脉方法、诊脉技术临床应用、现代客观化研究等几个方面分别进行论述,以期能够基本呈现三部九候脉学的丰富内容。且本研究在文献整理的基础上,结合个人临床经验及平时心得,对三部九候脉诊法提出自已的一些新见解；并据该经典脉诊学说,粗略归纳总结了一套六脉统合图示法,以期为中医脉诊客观化、精确化的研究提供新的思路和方向。
目的
本研究对当前各种文献、主要中医典籍中的脉学相关内容进行整理、摘录及分析,从三部九候遍诊法及三部九候寸口诊法两部分入手,对该脉诊法的源流、诊脉方法、临床应用、现代客观化研究等几个方面分别进行论述。并结合个人临床实践经验,进行相关客观化研究,以期对疾病的预后、临床辨证施治的指导、以及中医脉诊客观化、精确化的研究提供新的思路和启发,为脉诊研究走向新的高度提供可参考的依据。
方法
通过文献研究,对三部九候遍诊法与三部九候寸口诊法的的源流、诊脉部位、操作手法、临床应用及现代研究等进行分析、梳理,探讨其形成原因与机理；
基于三部九候学说,提出六脉统合图示法,五脏器官脉诊定位法,修正五脏脉位置,提出分寸高骨关尺四部新观念；
用拔罐法对受试者进行刺激,观察治疗前后脉象浮中沉、大中小,强弱虚实的变化；观察治疗前后脉率、温度、血压、六脉五脏脉穴位电导值的变化。
结果
通过对大量文献的分析、整理发现,三部九候遍诊法在《内经》中记载详细且应用广泛,诊脉部位以经络学说为依据,又与针灸取穴有所不同。针灸取穴注重腧穴的定位,即某一腧穴在体表的确切位置,而遍诊法的诊脉部位注重的是经线,并不局限于腧穴的特定位置；就诊脉方法而言,古人经验总结常有切、循、扪、按四种不同而又相互关联的诊法;该诊脉方法能反映脏腑病变,有助于临床分经诊脉、以脉证病、分辨寒热、判断病情轻重、生死及杂病的诊断。现代研究发现,该诊法还可用于诊断循环系统病变、指导针灸施治。且有学者通过采用单点和多部位取脉,运用仿生柔性压力传感器与B超探头复合多路压力传感器,通过对多路信息进行“位、数、形、势”的属性分析,重建动态三维指感脉图,对寸口和三部取脉所得信息进行定量比较研究,证实遍诊法获得的信息量要比独取寸口获得的信息量大。但这种遍身诊法与其它脉诊法相比较,行之于临床有诸多不便,故后世鲜有用之；
三部九候寸口诊法源于《内经》、确立于《难经》、完善于《脉经》,其形成原因与机理在各种典籍及现代研究中也有论述阐发；三部九候寸口诊法的部位即为寸口,分寸、关、尺三部,每部各以轻、中、重指力按脉,分浮、中、沉,共九候。关于寸关尺的定位,历代医家有很多论述,对其诊脉部位及分属脏腑历代医家亦有不同认识；其诊脉时间,《内经》中记载以平旦(清晨)时为宜,并提出以呼吸至数来判断脉之快慢的方法；《难经》中提出举按寻的诊脉方法,并一直为后世医家沿用。在此种脉学发展过程中,还总结出了有胃有神有根的平人脉象特征；而病理脉象历代医家各有看法,如《内经》在分散的十二篇中叙述了21种病理脉象,大体划分为七个类型和观察范围,《脉经》首次将病理脉象分为24种,《濒湖脉学》则载病脉27种,同时历代医家也曾用归类法将前人所述脉象“驭简执繁”,及至今人普遍将病理脉分为28种；对于脉诊的客观化,现代学者将现有的各种物理、化学、生物学进展相结合,做过大量相关研究,如脉图、脉波仪、脉象仪的研制,脉象信号的分类识别优化、脉诊专家数据库、中医远程脉诊软硬件的设计等；该种诊脉方法有助于判断疾病的病位病性、指导治疗,对推断疾病的进退预后有很重要的临床价值,临床可应用与内外妇儿各科,运用较为广泛,为后世医家所推崇；
拔罐后三部九候脉会有所变化,脉搏数减少,且前后改变率为61.3%；76.1%的受试者寸口部位温度呈寸>关>尺趋势；拔罐后温度拔罐后温度上升者占26.9%;下降者占11.9%；不变者为61.1%；拔罐后,收缩压不变或舒张压不变者占36.3%;收缩压上升或收缩压下降者占37.5%；舒张压上升或舒张压下降者占26.1%；六脉统合数字化与十二经原穴电导变动值之总和及五脏脉电导变动值之总和,无任何相关性。
结论
与其他脉法比较,三部九候遍诊法在《内经》中记载详细且应用广泛,突出了定位意义,丰富了《内经》脉学理论,是《内经》脉学理论的精华,为后世脉学发展奠定了理论基础；
三部九候寸口脉诊法随“独取寸口”理论发展而来,并不断得到完善。该脉法可断五脏六腑及十二经脉的疾病,既宗《黄帝内经》旨义,又有新的创造,临床应用广泛,有助于判断病位病性、指导治疗、预后。其各种形式的客观化研究,是将来脉诊标准化、形象化的重要研究方向。
寸口部位拔罐前后温度变化说明,寸部一般温度最高,关次之,而尺脉最低。当三部均一样偏高时,为亢奋、发热；三部均一样偏低时,为低下、失温；单独一部偏高时,则为独热；单独一部偏低时,则为独寒。
六脉统合图示法为传统脉学客观化提供了新的思路,值得进一步探讨研究。
Three portions & nine pulse-takings is a pulse diagnostic method of Chinese medicine since ancient times. Traditionally, by the theory of three portions & nine pulse-takings, the person was regarded as a microcosm of nature. By using the point of view about sky-earth-human, the human body can be divided into three parts as the upper, the middle and the lower which can reflect the situation of human in nature. By observing whether the pulse corresponds to body and whether the three parts conciliate with each other, the situation of the whole body was observed. This kind of method, called the general pulse diagnostic method of three portions & nine pulse-takings, is the only pulse diagnostic method listed in Neijing. Compared with the other kind of methods, this one emphasized the meaning of location, enriched the pulse theory in Neijing, is the essence of the pulse theory in Neijing, and established the theory foundation for the development of pulse theory.
On the other hand, the three portions & nine pulse-takings can also be used for wrist pulse-taking method. Based on Neijing, the wrist pulse-taking method was established in Canon of Difficult Issues and given much more content. The wrist pulse was divided into cun-section, guan-section and chi-section. Each section was divided into the float, the medium and the sunken. It is also known as three portions & nine pulse-takings. This kind of method emphasizes the coherence of the nine symptoms by comprehensive analysis, reflects the holistic mode of thinking, especially the reference meaning between each department and designate.
Therefore, the study of the source, the development of specific application, clinical significance and the related awareness about the three portions & nine pulse-takings has very important significance for the Chinese medicine pulse diagnosis theory and practice. However, the current literature about three portions & nine pulse-takings is very little. In this study, the contents about three portions & nine pulse-takings were sort out, extracted and analyzed and discussed from the theory, method, clinical application and modern objective study. Based on these works and combined with some own clinical experiences, some new ideas and a sort of six-meridian incorporative graphical method were brought up for supplement of study on the objectivity and accuracy of Chinese pulse-taking method.
Objective
In this study, some materials about pulse in Huangdi's Internal Classic, Classic of Difficult Issues and Ttreatise on Febrile Diseases were extracted and analyzed from the theory, method, clinical application and modern objective study. Based on these works and combined with some own clinical experiences, some new ideas and a sort of six-meridian incorporative graphical method were brought up for supplement of study on the objectivity and accuracy of Chinese pulse-taking method.
Methods
Through literature study, the source, theory, method, clinical application and modern objective study of the three portions & nine pulse-takings were analuzed and discussed.
Based on the theory of three portions & nine pulse-takings, a sort of six-meridian incorporative graphical method, zang-fu pulse-locating method were brought up, and some new idea about the four Categorization of wrist pulse.
Cupping method was used to stimulate the subjects to observe the changes of pulse manifestation, pulse rate, temperature, and blood-pressure, electric conductivity before and after treatment.
Results
Through literature study, the general pulse diagnostic method is recorded in detail and used widely. The location of pulse-taking is based on the theory of meridians and collaterals, but also different with it. Acupuncture focus on the exact position of acupoints on the body surface, while for the general pulse diagnostic method, it is meridian; as far as the method of diagnose is concerned, there were four different but interrelated diagnostic method, such as taking, searching, palpation and pressing which can reflect the disease of the internal organs, be helpful to diagnose the troubles by pulse syndrome, to distinguish heat and cold, to determine the severity, life and death, and miscellaneous disease diagnosis. Modern research has found that the diagnostic method can be used for diagnosis of circulatory system diseases, guidance acupuncture treatment. And some scholars studied the information from wrist pulse to confirm the information acquired from the whole body is much more than that from the wrist by using bionic flexible pressure sensor and B-probe complex multi-pressure sensors. But compared with the other methods, this general pulse diagnostic method is not so convenient in clinic, so it is rarely used later;
The three portions& nine pulse-takings in wrist is sourced from Neijing, established in Classic of Difficult Issues and finished in Pulse Classic. The formation and mechanism were discussed in different materials. The taking position is wrist and can be divided into the cun, the guan, the chi. each section was divided into the float, the medium and the sunken. About the location of the cun, the guan and chi as well as the zang-fu position there are many different descriptions. In Nei jing, the right time for taking pulse is morning; In Classic of Difficult Issues, the pulse-taking methods are lifting, pressing and searching. The normal pulse manifestation has stomach, vitality and root; for the abnormal pulse manifestation, different clinical practitioners have different opinions. For the objectivity of pulse diagnosis, modern scholars had done much effort to study.
After cupping, the three portions & nine pulse-takings were changed, the pulse rates reduced and the changing rate was 61.3%; in 76.1% of the subjects, it was shown that the temperature of the cun was highest and that of the chi was the lowest; after cupping, the temperature of 26.9% of the subjects raised; the temperature of 11.9% of the subjects reduced; the temperature of 61.1% of the subjects didn't change; after cupping, the rate of systolic blood pressure or diastolic blood pressure remained unchanging in the same account was 36.3%; 37.5% of the subjects was with systolic blood pressure increased or systolic blood pressure decreased; 26.1% of the subjects with diastolic blood pressure increased and diastolic blood pressure decreased; six digital pulse integration points with the second by the original value of the sum of the changes in conductivity and conductance changes in the value of the five internal organs of the sum of the pulse. There was no any relevance.
Conclusion
Compared with the other methods, the three portions & nine pulse-takings emphasized the meaning of location, enriched the pulse theory in Neijing, is the essence of the pulse theory in Neijing, and established the theory foundation for the development of pulse theory.
The three portions & nine pulse-takings in wrist were developed from the theory of wrist-pulse diagnostic method and finished gradually. This kind of method is not only based on the essence of Neijing, but also has new creation. It is widely used in clinic and helpful for distinguish the position and nature of diseases, guidance of treatment and prognosis. The objective studies of it are the important researching aspect for the standardizing and visualization of pulse diagnosis.
Changing of temperature before and after cupping shows that the temperature of the cun was highest and that of the chi was the lowest. When the temperature of the three parts is high which indicates excess and fever; while on the contrary, which indicates insufficiency and cold; when that of single one section is high, which indicates the one-hot; on the contrary, which indicates independent cold.
Six-pulse integration graphic method provides a new train of thought for the objective study of traditional pulse and is worthy of further investigation research.
另一方面,三部九候脉诊法也可用于寸口诊法,《难经》在《内经》寸口脉法的基础上正式确立了“独取寸口诊法”,并赋予了“三部九候”脉诊法新的内容。将寸口脉分寸、关、尺三部,每部各以轻、中、重指力按脉,分浮、中、沉,(《难经·十八难》)故也称为三部九候法。三部九候脉诊法辨病辨证,强调九候相参,综合分析,体现了诊法的整体观思想,其中尤为强调各部各候之间的相互参比意义。
因此,研究三部九候脉诊法的溯源、发展、具体运用、临床意义及相关认识等,对中医脉学诊断的理论及实践有非常重要的意义。但当前对三部九候脉诊法源流及应用的文献专门论述相当少,现本研究通过对脉学发展,尤其是对三部九候脉诊理论有重大贡献的《内经》、《难经》、《伤寒论》等典籍著作中的脉学相关内容进行梳理、摘录及分析,从两种不同三部九候脉诊法入手,对其脉学思想、诊脉方法、诊脉技术临床应用、现代客观化研究等几个方面分别进行论述,以期能够基本呈现三部九候脉学的丰富内容。且本研究在文献整理的基础上,结合个人临床经验及平时心得,对三部九候脉诊法提出自已的一些新见解；并据该经典脉诊学说,粗略归纳总结了一套六脉统合图示法,以期为中医脉诊客观化、精确化的研究提供新的思路和方向。
目的
本研究对当前各种文献、主要中医典籍中的脉学相关内容进行整理、摘录及分析,从三部九候遍诊法及三部九候寸口诊法两部分入手,对该脉诊法的源流、诊脉方法、临床应用、现代客观化研究等几个方面分别进行论述。并结合个人临床实践经验,进行相关客观化研究,以期对疾病的预后、临床辨证施治的指导、以及中医脉诊客观化、精确化的研究提供新的思路和启发,为脉诊研究走向新的高度提供可参考的依据。
方法
通过文献研究,对三部九候遍诊法与三部九候寸口诊法的的源流、诊脉部位、操作手法、临床应用及现代研究等进行分析、梳理,探讨其形成原因与机理；
基于三部九候学说,提出六脉统合图示法,五脏器官脉诊定位法,修正五脏脉位置,提出分寸高骨关尺四部新观念；
用拔罐法对受试者进行刺激,观察治疗前后脉象浮中沉、大中小,强弱虚实的变化；观察治疗前后脉率、温度、血压、六脉五脏脉穴位电导值的变化。
结果
通过对大量文献的分析、整理发现,三部九候遍诊法在《内经》中记载详细且应用广泛,诊脉部位以经络学说为依据,又与针灸取穴有所不同。针灸取穴注重腧穴的定位,即某一腧穴在体表的确切位置,而遍诊法的诊脉部位注重的是经线,并不局限于腧穴的特定位置；就诊脉方法而言,古人经验总结常有切、循、扪、按四种不同而又相互关联的诊法;该诊脉方法能反映脏腑病变,有助于临床分经诊脉、以脉证病、分辨寒热、判断病情轻重、生死及杂病的诊断。现代研究发现,该诊法还可用于诊断循环系统病变、指导针灸施治。且有学者通过采用单点和多部位取脉,运用仿生柔性压力传感器与B超探头复合多路压力传感器,通过对多路信息进行“位、数、形、势”的属性分析,重建动态三维指感脉图,对寸口和三部取脉所得信息进行定量比较研究,证实遍诊法获得的信息量要比独取寸口获得的信息量大。但这种遍身诊法与其它脉诊法相比较,行之于临床有诸多不便,故后世鲜有用之；
三部九候寸口诊法源于《内经》、确立于《难经》、完善于《脉经》,其形成原因与机理在各种典籍及现代研究中也有论述阐发；三部九候寸口诊法的部位即为寸口,分寸、关、尺三部,每部各以轻、中、重指力按脉,分浮、中、沉,共九候。关于寸关尺的定位,历代医家有很多论述,对其诊脉部位及分属脏腑历代医家亦有不同认识；其诊脉时间,《内经》中记载以平旦(清晨)时为宜,并提出以呼吸至数来判断脉之快慢的方法；《难经》中提出举按寻的诊脉方法,并一直为后世医家沿用。在此种脉学发展过程中,还总结出了有胃有神有根的平人脉象特征；而病理脉象历代医家各有看法,如《内经》在分散的十二篇中叙述了21种病理脉象,大体划分为七个类型和观察范围,《脉经》首次将病理脉象分为24种,《濒湖脉学》则载病脉27种,同时历代医家也曾用归类法将前人所述脉象“驭简执繁”,及至今人普遍将病理脉分为28种；对于脉诊的客观化,现代学者将现有的各种物理、化学、生物学进展相结合,做过大量相关研究,如脉图、脉波仪、脉象仪的研制,脉象信号的分类识别优化、脉诊专家数据库、中医远程脉诊软硬件的设计等；该种诊脉方法有助于判断疾病的病位病性、指导治疗,对推断疾病的进退预后有很重要的临床价值,临床可应用与内外妇儿各科,运用较为广泛,为后世医家所推崇；
拔罐后三部九候脉会有所变化,脉搏数减少,且前后改变率为61.3%；76.1%的受试者寸口部位温度呈寸>关>尺趋势；拔罐后温度拔罐后温度上升者占26.9%;下降者占11.9%；不变者为61.1%；拔罐后,收缩压不变或舒张压不变者占36.3%;收缩压上升或收缩压下降者占37.5%；舒张压上升或舒张压下降者占26.1%；六脉统合数字化与十二经原穴电导变动值之总和及五脏脉电导变动值之总和,无任何相关性。
结论
与其他脉法比较,三部九候遍诊法在《内经》中记载详细且应用广泛,突出了定位意义,丰富了《内经》脉学理论,是《内经》脉学理论的精华,为后世脉学发展奠定了理论基础；
三部九候寸口脉诊法随“独取寸口”理论发展而来,并不断得到完善。该脉法可断五脏六腑及十二经脉的疾病,既宗《黄帝内经》旨义,又有新的创造,临床应用广泛,有助于判断病位病性、指导治疗、预后。其各种形式的客观化研究,是将来脉诊标准化、形象化的重要研究方向。
寸口部位拔罐前后温度变化说明,寸部一般温度最高,关次之,而尺脉最低。当三部均一样偏高时,为亢奋、发热；三部均一样偏低时,为低下、失温；单独一部偏高时,则为独热；单独一部偏低时,则为独寒。
六脉统合图示法为传统脉学客观化提供了新的思路,值得进一步探讨研究。
Three portions & nine pulse-takings is a pulse diagnostic method of Chinese medicine since ancient times. Traditionally, by the theory of three portions & nine pulse-takings, the person was regarded as a microcosm of nature. By using the point of view about sky-earth-human, the human body can be divided into three parts as the upper, the middle and the lower which can reflect the situation of human in nature. By observing whether the pulse corresponds to body and whether the three parts conciliate with each other, the situation of the whole body was observed. This kind of method, called the general pulse diagnostic method of three portions & nine pulse-takings, is the only pulse diagnostic method listed in Neijing. Compared with the other kind of methods, this one emphasized the meaning of location, enriched the pulse theory in Neijing, is the essence of the pulse theory in Neijing, and established the theory foundation for the development of pulse theory.
On the other hand, the three portions & nine pulse-takings can also be used for wrist pulse-taking method. Based on Neijing, the wrist pulse-taking method was established in Canon of Difficult Issues and given much more content. The wrist pulse was divided into cun-section, guan-section and chi-section. Each section was divided into the float, the medium and the sunken. It is also known as three portions & nine pulse-takings. This kind of method emphasizes the coherence of the nine symptoms by comprehensive analysis, reflects the holistic mode of thinking, especially the reference meaning between each department and designate.
Therefore, the study of the source, the development of specific application, clinical significance and the related awareness about the three portions & nine pulse-takings has very important significance for the Chinese medicine pulse diagnosis theory and practice. However, the current literature about three portions & nine pulse-takings is very little. In this study, the contents about three portions & nine pulse-takings were sort out, extracted and analyzed and discussed from the theory, method, clinical application and modern objective study. Based on these works and combined with some own clinical experiences, some new ideas and a sort of six-meridian incorporative graphical method were brought up for supplement of study on the objectivity and accuracy of Chinese pulse-taking method.
Objective
In this study, some materials about pulse in Huangdi's Internal Classic, Classic of Difficult Issues and Ttreatise on Febrile Diseases were extracted and analyzed from the theory, method, clinical application and modern objective study. Based on these works and combined with some own clinical experiences, some new ideas and a sort of six-meridian incorporative graphical method were brought up for supplement of study on the objectivity and accuracy of Chinese pulse-taking method.
Methods
Through literature study, the source, theory, method, clinical application and modern objective study of the three portions & nine pulse-takings were analuzed and discussed.
Based on the theory of three portions & nine pulse-takings, a sort of six-meridian incorporative graphical method, zang-fu pulse-locating method were brought up, and some new idea about the four Categorization of wrist pulse.
Cupping method was used to stimulate the subjects to observe the changes of pulse manifestation, pulse rate, temperature, and blood-pressure, electric conductivity before and after treatment.
Results
Through literature study, the general pulse diagnostic method is recorded in detail and used widely. The location of pulse-taking is based on the theory of meridians and collaterals, but also different with it. Acupuncture focus on the exact position of acupoints on the body surface, while for the general pulse diagnostic method, it is meridian; as far as the method of diagnose is concerned, there were four different but interrelated diagnostic method, such as taking, searching, palpation and pressing which can reflect the disease of the internal organs, be helpful to diagnose the troubles by pulse syndrome, to distinguish heat and cold, to determine the severity, life and death, and miscellaneous disease diagnosis. Modern research has found that the diagnostic method can be used for diagnosis of circulatory system diseases, guidance acupuncture treatment. And some scholars studied the information from wrist pulse to confirm the information acquired from the whole body is much more than that from the wrist by using bionic flexible pressure sensor and B-probe complex multi-pressure sensors. But compared with the other methods, this general pulse diagnostic method is not so convenient in clinic, so it is rarely used later;
The three portions& nine pulse-takings in wrist is sourced from Neijing, established in Classic of Difficult Issues and finished in Pulse Classic. The formation and mechanism were discussed in different materials. The taking position is wrist and can be divided into the cun, the guan, the chi. each section was divided into the float, the medium and the sunken. About the location of the cun, the guan and chi as well as the zang-fu position there are many different descriptions. In Nei jing, the right time for taking pulse is morning; In Classic of Difficult Issues, the pulse-taking methods are lifting, pressing and searching. The normal pulse manifestation has stomach, vitality and root; for the abnormal pulse manifestation, different clinical practitioners have different opinions. For the objectivity of pulse diagnosis, modern scholars had done much effort to study.
After cupping, the three portions & nine pulse-takings were changed, the pulse rates reduced and the changing rate was 61.3%; in 76.1% of the subjects, it was shown that the temperature of the cun was highest and that of the chi was the lowest; after cupping, the temperature of 26.9% of the subjects raised; the temperature of 11.9% of the subjects reduced; the temperature of 61.1% of the subjects didn't change; after cupping, the rate of systolic blood pressure or diastolic blood pressure remained unchanging in the same account was 36.3%; 37.5% of the subjects was with systolic blood pressure increased or systolic blood pressure decreased; 26.1% of the subjects with diastolic blood pressure increased and diastolic blood pressure decreased; six digital pulse integration points with the second by the original value of the sum of the changes in conductivity and conductance changes in the value of the five internal organs of the sum of the pulse. There was no any relevance.
Conclusion
Compared with the other methods, the three portions & nine pulse-takings emphasized the meaning of location, enriched the pulse theory in Neijing, is the essence of the pulse theory in Neijing, and established the theory foundation for the development of pulse theory.
The three portions & nine pulse-takings in wrist were developed from the theory of wrist-pulse diagnostic method and finished gradually. This kind of method is not only based on the essence of Neijing, but also has new creation. It is widely used in clinic and helpful for distinguish the position and nature of diseases, guidance of treatment and prognosis. The objective studies of it are the important researching aspect for the standardizing and visualization of pulse diagnosis.
Changing of temperature before and after cupping shows that the temperature of the cun was highest and that of the chi was the lowest. When the temperature of the three parts is high which indicates excess and fever; while on the contrary, which indicates insufficiency and cold; when that of single one section is high, which indicates the one-hot; on the contrary, which indicates independent cold.
Six-pulse integration graphic method provides a new train of thought for the objective study of traditional pulse and is worthy of further investigation research.
引文
[1]韩建平.出土古脉书与三部九候说[J].中华医史杂志,1997,1.
[2]李兴.《内经》脉法——遍诊法浅析[J].陕西中医学院学报,1986,9,(3):13-18.
[3]周韶九,李育福.遍身诊脉法[J].广东医学,1964,1:13-18.
[4]曹洪欣.遍诊法探析[J].中医药信息,1990,4:7-8.
[5]赵桂玲.针灸诊脉宜用《素问》三部九候法.针灸临床杂志[J],2000,16,(5):4-5.
[6]司银楚,朱庆文,高蔚,等.基于可视化脉诊信息采集与识别的“独取寸口法”与“诊法”的信息学比较,世界科学技术——中医药现代化[J].2007,9,(3):24-27.
[7]杨杰,潘桂娟.《黄帝内经》脉学知识探讨[J].中国中医基础医学杂志,2007,13,(12):887-889.
[8]崔岩臻.杨铮.《黄帝内经》《难经》三部九候辨[J].中华中医药杂志,2007:379-380.
[9]杨秀英.脉诊源流浅谈[J].中国农村医学,1994,22,(8):60-62.
[10]朱进忠.数脉主病非仅热[J].山西中医,1996,12(2)：4-6.
[11]庄建西.谈脉诊中的“左肝右脾”[J].河南中医学院学报,2003,18(2)：8.
[12]尤大梁.中医脉诊寸关尺分属脏器理论初探[J].现代中西医结合杂志,2003,12(20)：2147-2168.
[13]丘瑞香,罗致强,朱雅宜.左右寸脉与心肺病证相关性探讨[J].广州中医学院学报,1995,12(1)：7-9.
[14]李久安.寸关尺脉位浅识[J].中华中医药学刊.1987.3:46-47.
[15]徐迪华,徐建秋,徐丽敏.中华脉诊的奥秘一200幅脉图解析.
[16]汪南玥,于友华,陈岩,闪增郁,李同达,陈燕萍.关于脉诊寸、关、尺长度的研究[J].中华中医药杂志,2009,24,(12):1633-1635.
[17]刘长海.寸口脉诊探讨[J].吉林中医药,1993,4:4--6.
[18]陈婷,公秀珍.关于《难经》脉法中的“独取寸口”[J]. 山东中医药大学学报,1997,21,(6):450-451.
[19]曲锋,刘彦廷,韩丽萍,严惠芳.浅谈脉诊独取寸口. 山西中医[J].2005,21,(5):58-59.
[20]颜之亨.脉诊“六部脏腑分属定位法”的临床经验[J].北京中医学院学报,1985,8(5):12
[21]张崇.脉象图与脉学研究的初步结果[J].江西中医药,1980,(3):38
[22]吴智兵.寸关尺与脏腑对应关系的探讨一一一附肝胆湿热证六部脉象分析.北京中医学院1992届硕士研究生学位论文
[23]沈霍夫,《内经》脉学研究——关于<内经>弦缓大小滑涩浮沉等21种脉象的整理及其现代概念.中医药学报[J].1987,21:4-12.
[24]赵棣华.脉象简化归类和实质的探讨.新中医[J].1975,7:52-54.
[25]苏飚. 浅析脉诊的源流及临床运用. 中国现代药物应用[J].2008,2,(20):99-100.
[26]张秋云,季绍良.针刺脾肾合穴与郄穴前后脾虚证脉图参的变化[J].河南中医,2000,20(2)：23-25.
[27]唐由君,张素芹.114例“再障”脉诊的临床研究[J].辽宁医杂志,1995,22(3)：116-117.
[28]许军峰.脉诊虚实与痛证针刺后机体反应的研究[J].浙江中医杂志,2003,38(11)：485-486.
[29]高建芸,赵京生.人迎寸口脉法及其对针灸临床的指导意义[J].中国针灸,2003,23(7)：427-428.
[30]平玉娟.脉诊与心律失常[J].中医研究,2001,4(4)：6-9.
[31]屈松柏,张晓星,张道亮.心脏病人心阴虚心气虚证候特征探讨[J].湖北中医杂志,1995,17(3)：24-26.
[32]张崇周.切脉诊断常见心律失常715例体会[J].实用中西医结合杂志,1995,8(6)：378.
[33]郭子光.心律失常的凭脉辨证[J].成都中医药大学学报,1996,19(1)：8-13.
[34]周家滨,李铁君.阳微阴弦脉在冠心病临床诊断中的价值[J].江苏中医,1997,18(10)：12.
[35]孙敏,曹洪欣,张华敏.冠心病脉诊研究[J].中医药学报,2004,32(3)：5-6.
[36]李国顺,蓝吉如.用按测法测量动脉血压的临床体会[J].湖南中医杂志,1997,13(3)：33-34.
[37]林乾树.137例慢性胃病患者舌、脉变化与胃黏膜病变关系之探讨[J].福建中医学院学报,1998,8(4)：5-6.
[38]周国英,王文赛.消化性溃疡出血的舌、脉象与证候关系[J].江西中医药,1999,30(6)：19.
[39]吴洪梅,凌昌全,朱德增.原发性肝癌患者的脉象特征观察[J].第二军医大学学报,2001,22(7)：618-620.
[40]王雁翔,王灵台,高月求,等.脂肪肝中医证型流行病学调查及其中医病因 病机初探[J].中国中西医结合杂志,2005,25(2)：126.
[41]文秀华.肺心病患者寸脉脉图与中医证型相关性研究.
[42]张会永.胸痹心痛(气阴两虚型)舌脉演变临床观察.辽宁中医药大学毕业论文
[43]张君,肾气不足证与肾阴亏虚证的中医脉象信息临床观察研究[J],中华中医药杂志,2009,24(1):46-49
[44]唐福安.察脉诊断早期妊娠的经验体会[J].浙江中医学院学报,1997,21(1)：40.
[45]熊大武,李千笛,刘承华.早期妊娠妇女脉象变化的观察报告[J].贵阳中医学院学报,1997,19(1)：57-58
[46]李爱华.胎产脉象探析[J].天津中医学院学报,1999,18(2):1-2.
[47]张登礼.诊脉审证辨别早期妊娠[J].湖北中医杂志,1998,20(2)：23-24.
[48]辛子兰.尿液绒毛膜促性腺激素与脉象意义[J].实用医技,2000,7(6)：408.
[49]王玉芳,李吉灵.早孕时脉诊对妊娠结局的意义[J].中华当代医学,2005,3(3)：55-56.
[50]许厥隆,杨冠英,沈红梅.妇女临产时中指指掌侧动脉变化的初步观察[J].云南中医中药杂志,1995,16(3)：36.
[51]李德荣.以脉象为主,把握胎儿性别的探讨[J].甘肃科技,1998,12(2)：16.
[52]项祺.肖通吾妇科月经病脉诊经验[J].山西中医,1998,14(1)：1-2.
[53]杨景芬脉诊与胶乳试验诊断早妊娠160例的观察[J].内蒙古中医药,1985,3：21-22
[54]黄顺杰, 围绝经期综合征的影响因素及中医证候临床研究,广州中医药大学博士毕业论文
[55]熊曼利,魏华.正常女大学生月经周期基础体温变化与双手脉象变化关系的探讨,广州中医药大学硕士毕业论文.
[56]杨志忠,陈一鸣.体温、脉搏动态变化与湿热辨证的关系[J].四川中医,1996,14(7)：10-11.
[57]刘静波.试论脉诊与人体的对应关系及指导意义[J].中国中医基础医学杂志,2003,9(12)：59-61.
[58]董振国.脉诊在骨伤科的临床意义[J].世界中医骨伤科杂志,2000,2(3)：42-43.
[59]舒友廉,王骜,娄卫海.浅谈脉诊在白癜风治疗中的意义[J].中国中医基础医学杂志,2003,9(9)：53-54.
[60]韩新平,马嘉瑾.晚期癌症应慎用温热之剂——一附145例晚期癌症舌象、脉象分析[J].贵阳中医学院学报,1999,21(3):36-38.
[61]萧天水.脘部疼痛的因症脉治[J].实用中西医结合杂志,1998,11(1)：55-56.
[62]孙文善.脉诊与针灸医学[J].针灸临床杂志,1997,13(4):6-8.
[63]胡忠平.小议脉诊在巨刺与缪刺合理选择上的重要意义[J],光明中医,2008,23(9)：1469-1470
[64]荆玉强 弦脉及其相兼脉的临床研究[J],中医药学报,1988,3:22-25
[65]吴噎明.舌诊、脉诊与脊椎病因诊断、治疗关系研究.广州中医药大学硕士毕业论文.
[66]苟春雁,王竹行.中医脉诊对面瘫预后判定及针刺治疗探析[J].重庆市中医院..2010,26(4):63-65
[67]段延萍,周杰,范晔,等.《内经》《难经》寸口脉诊法机理探析[J].陕西中医,2006,27(11)：1448—1450.
[68]王历.《伤寒论》脉法探析[J],辽宁中医杂志,2006,33(8)：947—948.
[69]王清华.《金匮要略》脉学特色考释[J],中医药学刊,2003,21(1):128—129
[70]祝小惠.《金匮要略》病证脉象分析[J],中国医药学报,2004,19(6):333—337.
[71]曲夷.《伤寒论》脉法权变[J],北京中医药大学学报,2007,30(1)::13—16.
[72]马小兰.岭南医家郭元峰《脉如》学术思想诠释[J],中医药学刊,2005,23(4):676—678
[73]丘瑞香,罗致强,朱雅宜.左右寸脉与心肺病证相关性探讨[J].广州中医学院学报,1995,12(1)：7-9.
[74]崔恒德,陈启石.心律失常时脉象与心电图的对比观察[J].江苏中医药,2004,25(8)：15-16
[75]李华东,赵庆英,门德良.脉诊速率与心电图关系的探讨[J].中华实用中西医杂志,2004,4(17)：1111.
[76]党德宏,党超.血压测脉的临床应用[J].辽宁中医杂志,2004,31(9)：729-730.
[77]张勤,张沛霖,宋沧桑,等.以针刺前后尿多巴胺含量与脉诊为指标提高震颤麻痹临床疗效[J].针灸临床杂志,2000,16(7)：53-54.
[78]孔宪明,池各敏郎,商泽谦二,等.脉象(诊)与加速度脉波的相关性研究[J].山东中医药大学学报,1997,21(2)：120-122.
[79]王燕. 中医脉象客观定量化理论方法研究[J].世界科学技术一中医药现代化,2005,7(1)：118—122.
[80]王燕,白涛. 基于虚拟现实技术的远程中医脉诊客观化研究[J].计算机仿 真,2006,23(5)：203—206.
[81]谭延亮,游开明,陈列尊,等. 脉诊客观化研究新思路. 四川中医,2007,25(8)：21—23.
[82]杨杰.中医脉动信号个体化诊断分析方法的理论探讨[J].世界科学技术中医药现代化,2007,9(5)：132—135.
[83]张治国,牛欣,杨学智,等.脉宽的可视化考察[J].中国中医药信息杂志,2008,15(5)：14—16.
[84]徐蓉娟,费兆馥.62例慢性胃炎患者寸口六部脉图与中医辨证关系的探讨[J].上海中医药杂志,1987,(10):45-4
[85]朱俊奎.寸口脉诊脏腑定位的探讨[J].辽宁中医杂志,1981,(1):17
[86]李果刚,费兆馥.高血压病寸口六部脉图心功能观察[J].上海中医药杂志,1993,(1):44-47
[87]L,Y-Wei. A New Scientific Method of Pulse Diagnosis [J]. American Jaurnal of Acupuncture,1984,12(3):205
[88]龚安特.中医“三部九候”切脉的力学机理[J].湖南医药杂志,1984,(1):2
[89]寿小云.中医脉象振动沉觉[J].北京中医药大学学报,1998,21(1):23
[90]黄世林,孙明异.中医脉象研究[M].北京：人民卫生出版社,1995
[91]庄泽澄.中医诊断学[M].北京：科学出版社,1999
[92]费兆馥.现代中医脉诊学[M].北京：人民卫生出版社,2003
[93]杨冰,牛欣,王玉来.脉诊仪的研制及分析方法的研究进展[J].北京中医药大学学报,2000,(11)：6—8
[94]蔡轶衍,沈兰荪,黄祥林.脉象分析仪的研究进展[J].电子测量与仪器学报,2000,16(4):55—58
[95]汤伟昌,孙汉均.ZMH—I型中医脉象传感器的研究设计[J].传感器技术,1990,(1):22—26
[96]王贻俊,王劲松,蔡新吉.MXY一11型脉象仪的设计[J].现代医学仪器与应用,2000,12(1):6-8
[97]金观昌,于森,鲍乃铿.PVDF多点脉搏波计算机辅助测试系统研究[J].清华大学学报自然科学版,1999(8):117
[98]刘明林,魏红等.中医脉诊客观化研究的思路与方法[J].辽宁中医学院学报,2004,6(3)：258—259
[99]王炳和,相敬林.基于神经网络方法的人体脉象识别研究[J].西北工业大学学报,2002,20(3):454—456
[100]姜涛.基于小波分析的中医脉象识别的研究：[学位论文].南京：河海大学,2003
[101]汤伟昌,孙汉钧,李斌芳.双路中医脉象检测方法的研究[J].中国医药学报, 2000,15(1)：14—17.
[102]石山仁,笠原宏.触觉检测脉波计一依手指触觉和压觉的可视化制成的脉波计[J].国外医学·中医中药分册,1991,(3):13—14.
[103]藤田六郎.用超声波脉诊仪的六部定位[J].国外医学·中医中药分册,1986,(1)：12—1
[104]冈田腾.东方医学中脉诊的临床实用化[J].国外医学·中医中药分册,1989,(2)：28—30.
[105]中谷义雄(著),叶少麟(译).良导络的原理及临床概要[J].浙江医学院学报.1958, (2)：191-197.
[106]房兴业.中国经络诊断中经穴电位测量方法研究[J].航天医学与医学工程.1989,(2)：24-25
[107]田淑荆,人体经络系统客观存在中国在50年代已经测定证实[J],世界科学技术
[108]商振德.人体生物电循环传导系统——经络系统.针灸经络研究回顾与展望国际学术讨论会文集
[109]莫浣英,李鹏,人体皮肤电现象的观察[J].上海中医药杂志,1989,7:21-29
[110]高桂宗,张永贤.电脑测定经络能量之研究[J].中国针灸,
[111]中医研究院针灸经络研究所,经络感传研究中疼痛反应客观指标的探索,
[112]成泽东,于琪.手三阳经井穴与合穴皮肤电流相关性研究[J]. Shanghai J Acu-mox,2009,8(28):478-480
[113]徐冬梅,谢玉华,健康人胃经五输穴体表阻抗的规律性研究[J],贵阳医学院学报,2005,12,30(6):523-524
[114]Agathe P,井穴皮肤电阻值的生理学变化[J]. Medical Acupuncture,2006, 17(2):12-19
[115]沈阳医学院生理教研组经络科研小组,经络电活动的研究[J].辽宁医学杂志,1960,8：52.54
[116]韩兆亮.人体双侧对称经络电阻抗失衡与疾病的相关研究[J].菏泽医专学报,1999,11,(1):9-11
[117]许云祥,胡翔龙.心包经循行线上皮肤低阻点的皮肤电位检测[J].福建中医学院学报,1999,5,(9):13-16
[118]曹东胜.运动员疲劳时经络阻抗的变化趋势研究[J].江汉大学学报,2004,32,(3):82-84
[119]胡武光.良导络在临床上的应用[J].江苏中医：
[120]刘芳,樊艳华.功能性消化不良患者身心症状及下肢脾胃经穴声电特性研究.北京中医药大学中医学专业硕士学位论文
[121]樊祥民；经络电阻抗测量与应用的实验研究[J].物理与工程,2008,3,(18):41-51
[122]汪惠敏.人体皮肤电的分维研究[J].浙江中医学院院报,1993,17,(4):50
[123]邢江淮,原存信.哮喘病及不同期型经穴失衡水平的观察[J].针灸学报,1992,5：22-23
[124]陈高彰,毕国伟.过敏性鼻炎病人与正常人的穴位良导络值比较研究[J].成都中医药大学学报,2001,6,(32)：33-34
[125]龚启华,余爱珍.穴位显示在临床上的观察
[126]祝怀萱,诸葛文.经络学说运用于临床的治疗报告[J].上海中医药杂志：
[127]筱原正明.良导络治疗与经络治疗中治本法、基本法、治标法以及临床法的比较：单例和多例受试者的比较[J].国外医学中医中药分册,1995,17,(5):54
[2]李兴.《内经》脉法——遍诊法浅析[J].陕西中医学院学报,1986,9,(3):13-18.
[3]周韶九,李育福.遍身诊脉法[J].广东医学,1964,1:13-18.
[4]曹洪欣.遍诊法探析[J].中医药信息,1990,4:7-8.
[5]赵桂玲.针灸诊脉宜用《素问》三部九候法.针灸临床杂志[J],2000,16,(5):4-5.
[6]司银楚,朱庆文,高蔚,等.基于可视化脉诊信息采集与识别的“独取寸口法”与“诊法”的信息学比较,世界科学技术——中医药现代化[J].2007,9,(3):24-27.
[7]杨杰,潘桂娟.《黄帝内经》脉学知识探讨[J].中国中医基础医学杂志,2007,13,(12):887-889.
[8]崔岩臻.杨铮.《黄帝内经》《难经》三部九候辨[J].中华中医药杂志,2007:379-380.
[9]杨秀英.脉诊源流浅谈[J].中国农村医学,1994,22,(8):60-62.
[10]朱进忠.数脉主病非仅热[J].山西中医,1996,12(2)：4-6.
[11]庄建西.谈脉诊中的“左肝右脾”[J].河南中医学院学报,2003,18(2)：8.
[12]尤大梁.中医脉诊寸关尺分属脏器理论初探[J].现代中西医结合杂志,2003,12(20)：2147-2168.
[13]丘瑞香,罗致强,朱雅宜.左右寸脉与心肺病证相关性探讨[J].广州中医学院学报,1995,12(1)：7-9.
[14]李久安.寸关尺脉位浅识[J].中华中医药学刊.1987.3:46-47.
[15]徐迪华,徐建秋,徐丽敏.中华脉诊的奥秘一200幅脉图解析.
[16]汪南玥,于友华,陈岩,闪增郁,李同达,陈燕萍.关于脉诊寸、关、尺长度的研究[J].中华中医药杂志,2009,24,(12):1633-1635.
[17]刘长海.寸口脉诊探讨[J].吉林中医药,1993,4:4--6.
[18]陈婷,公秀珍.关于《难经》脉法中的“独取寸口”[J]. 山东中医药大学学报,1997,21,(6):450-451.
[19]曲锋,刘彦廷,韩丽萍,严惠芳.浅谈脉诊独取寸口. 山西中医[J].2005,21,(5):58-59.
[20]颜之亨.脉诊“六部脏腑分属定位法”的临床经验[J].北京中医学院学报,1985,8(5):12
[21]张崇.脉象图与脉学研究的初步结果[J].江西中医药,1980,(3):38
[22]吴智兵.寸关尺与脏腑对应关系的探讨一一一附肝胆湿热证六部脉象分析.北京中医学院1992届硕士研究生学位论文
[23]沈霍夫,《内经》脉学研究——关于<内经>弦缓大小滑涩浮沉等21种脉象的整理及其现代概念.中医药学报[J].1987,21:4-12.
[24]赵棣华.脉象简化归类和实质的探讨.新中医[J].1975,7:52-54.
[25]苏飚. 浅析脉诊的源流及临床运用. 中国现代药物应用[J].2008,2,(20):99-100.
[26]张秋云,季绍良.针刺脾肾合穴与郄穴前后脾虚证脉图参的变化[J].河南中医,2000,20(2)：23-25.
[27]唐由君,张素芹.114例“再障”脉诊的临床研究[J].辽宁医杂志,1995,22(3)：116-117.
[28]许军峰.脉诊虚实与痛证针刺后机体反应的研究[J].浙江中医杂志,2003,38(11)：485-486.
[29]高建芸,赵京生.人迎寸口脉法及其对针灸临床的指导意义[J].中国针灸,2003,23(7)：427-428.
[30]平玉娟.脉诊与心律失常[J].中医研究,2001,4(4)：6-9.
[31]屈松柏,张晓星,张道亮.心脏病人心阴虚心气虚证候特征探讨[J].湖北中医杂志,1995,17(3)：24-26.
[32]张崇周.切脉诊断常见心律失常715例体会[J].实用中西医结合杂志,1995,8(6)：378.
[33]郭子光.心律失常的凭脉辨证[J].成都中医药大学学报,1996,19(1)：8-13.
[34]周家滨,李铁君.阳微阴弦脉在冠心病临床诊断中的价值[J].江苏中医,1997,18(10)：12.
[35]孙敏,曹洪欣,张华敏.冠心病脉诊研究[J].中医药学报,2004,32(3)：5-6.
[36]李国顺,蓝吉如.用按测法测量动脉血压的临床体会[J].湖南中医杂志,1997,13(3)：33-34.
[37]林乾树.137例慢性胃病患者舌、脉变化与胃黏膜病变关系之探讨[J].福建中医学院学报,1998,8(4)：5-6.
[38]周国英,王文赛.消化性溃疡出血的舌、脉象与证候关系[J].江西中医药,1999,30(6)：19.
[39]吴洪梅,凌昌全,朱德增.原发性肝癌患者的脉象特征观察[J].第二军医大学学报,2001,22(7)：618-620.
[40]王雁翔,王灵台,高月求,等.脂肪肝中医证型流行病学调查及其中医病因 病机初探[J].中国中西医结合杂志,2005,25(2)：126.
[41]文秀华.肺心病患者寸脉脉图与中医证型相关性研究.
[42]张会永.胸痹心痛(气阴两虚型)舌脉演变临床观察.辽宁中医药大学毕业论文
[43]张君,肾气不足证与肾阴亏虚证的中医脉象信息临床观察研究[J],中华中医药杂志,2009,24(1):46-49
[44]唐福安.察脉诊断早期妊娠的经验体会[J].浙江中医学院学报,1997,21(1)：40.
[45]熊大武,李千笛,刘承华.早期妊娠妇女脉象变化的观察报告[J].贵阳中医学院学报,1997,19(1)：57-58
[46]李爱华.胎产脉象探析[J].天津中医学院学报,1999,18(2):1-2.
[47]张登礼.诊脉审证辨别早期妊娠[J].湖北中医杂志,1998,20(2)：23-24.
[48]辛子兰.尿液绒毛膜促性腺激素与脉象意义[J].实用医技,2000,7(6)：408.
[49]王玉芳,李吉灵.早孕时脉诊对妊娠结局的意义[J].中华当代医学,2005,3(3)：55-56.
[50]许厥隆,杨冠英,沈红梅.妇女临产时中指指掌侧动脉变化的初步观察[J].云南中医中药杂志,1995,16(3)：36.
[51]李德荣.以脉象为主,把握胎儿性别的探讨[J].甘肃科技,1998,12(2)：16.
[52]项祺.肖通吾妇科月经病脉诊经验[J].山西中医,1998,14(1)：1-2.
[53]杨景芬脉诊与胶乳试验诊断早妊娠160例的观察[J].内蒙古中医药,1985,3：21-22
[54]黄顺杰, 围绝经期综合征的影响因素及中医证候临床研究,广州中医药大学博士毕业论文
[55]熊曼利,魏华.正常女大学生月经周期基础体温变化与双手脉象变化关系的探讨,广州中医药大学硕士毕业论文.
[56]杨志忠,陈一鸣.体温、脉搏动态变化与湿热辨证的关系[J].四川中医,1996,14(7)：10-11.
[57]刘静波.试论脉诊与人体的对应关系及指导意义[J].中国中医基础医学杂志,2003,9(12)：59-61.
[58]董振国.脉诊在骨伤科的临床意义[J].世界中医骨伤科杂志,2000,2(3)：42-43.
[59]舒友廉,王骜,娄卫海.浅谈脉诊在白癜风治疗中的意义[J].中国中医基础医学杂志,2003,9(9)：53-54.
[60]韩新平,马嘉瑾.晚期癌症应慎用温热之剂——一附145例晚期癌症舌象、脉象分析[J].贵阳中医学院学报,1999,21(3):36-38.
[61]萧天水.脘部疼痛的因症脉治[J].实用中西医结合杂志,1998,11(1)：55-56.
[62]孙文善.脉诊与针灸医学[J].针灸临床杂志,1997,13(4):6-8.
[63]胡忠平.小议脉诊在巨刺与缪刺合理选择上的重要意义[J],光明中医,2008,23(9)：1469-1470
[64]荆玉强 弦脉及其相兼脉的临床研究[J],中医药学报,1988,3:22-25
[65]吴噎明.舌诊、脉诊与脊椎病因诊断、治疗关系研究.广州中医药大学硕士毕业论文.
[66]苟春雁,王竹行.中医脉诊对面瘫预后判定及针刺治疗探析[J].重庆市中医院..2010,26(4):63-65
[67]段延萍,周杰,范晔,等.《内经》《难经》寸口脉诊法机理探析[J].陕西中医,2006,27(11)：1448—1450.
[68]王历.《伤寒论》脉法探析[J],辽宁中医杂志,2006,33(8)：947—948.
[69]王清华.《金匮要略》脉学特色考释[J],中医药学刊,2003,21(1):128—129
[70]祝小惠.《金匮要略》病证脉象分析[J],中国医药学报,2004,19(6):333—337.
[71]曲夷.《伤寒论》脉法权变[J],北京中医药大学学报,2007,30(1)::13—16.
[72]马小兰.岭南医家郭元峰《脉如》学术思想诠释[J],中医药学刊,2005,23(4):676—678
[73]丘瑞香,罗致强,朱雅宜.左右寸脉与心肺病证相关性探讨[J].广州中医学院学报,1995,12(1)：7-9.
[74]崔恒德,陈启石.心律失常时脉象与心电图的对比观察[J].江苏中医药,2004,25(8)：15-16
[75]李华东,赵庆英,门德良.脉诊速率与心电图关系的探讨[J].中华实用中西医杂志,2004,4(17)：1111.
[76]党德宏,党超.血压测脉的临床应用[J].辽宁中医杂志,2004,31(9)：729-730.
[77]张勤,张沛霖,宋沧桑,等.以针刺前后尿多巴胺含量与脉诊为指标提高震颤麻痹临床疗效[J].针灸临床杂志,2000,16(7)：53-54.
[78]孔宪明,池各敏郎,商泽谦二,等.脉象(诊)与加速度脉波的相关性研究[J].山东中医药大学学报,1997,21(2)：120-122.
[79]王燕. 中医脉象客观定量化理论方法研究[J].世界科学技术一中医药现代化,2005,7(1)：118—122.
[80]王燕,白涛. 基于虚拟现实技术的远程中医脉诊客观化研究[J].计算机仿 真,2006,23(5)：203—206.
[81]谭延亮,游开明,陈列尊,等. 脉诊客观化研究新思路. 四川中医,2007,25(8)：21—23.
[82]杨杰.中医脉动信号个体化诊断分析方法的理论探讨[J].世界科学技术中医药现代化,2007,9(5)：132—135.
[83]张治国,牛欣,杨学智,等.脉宽的可视化考察[J].中国中医药信息杂志,2008,15(5)：14—16.
[84]徐蓉娟,费兆馥.62例慢性胃炎患者寸口六部脉图与中医辨证关系的探讨[J].上海中医药杂志,1987,(10):45-4
[85]朱俊奎.寸口脉诊脏腑定位的探讨[J].辽宁中医杂志,1981,(1):17
[86]李果刚,费兆馥.高血压病寸口六部脉图心功能观察[J].上海中医药杂志,1993,(1):44-47
[87]L,Y-Wei. A New Scientific Method of Pulse Diagnosis [J]. American Jaurnal of Acupuncture,1984,12(3):205
[88]龚安特.中医“三部九候”切脉的力学机理[J].湖南医药杂志,1984,(1):2
[89]寿小云.中医脉象振动沉觉[J].北京中医药大学学报,1998,21(1):23
[90]黄世林,孙明异.中医脉象研究[M].北京：人民卫生出版社,1995
[91]庄泽澄.中医诊断学[M].北京：科学出版社,1999
[92]费兆馥.现代中医脉诊学[M].北京：人民卫生出版社,2003
[93]杨冰,牛欣,王玉来.脉诊仪的研制及分析方法的研究进展[J].北京中医药大学学报,2000,(11)：6—8
[94]蔡轶衍,沈兰荪,黄祥林.脉象分析仪的研究进展[J].电子测量与仪器学报,2000,16(4):55—58
[95]汤伟昌,孙汉均.ZMH—I型中医脉象传感器的研究设计[J].传感器技术,1990,(1):22—26
[96]王贻俊,王劲松,蔡新吉.MXY一11型脉象仪的设计[J].现代医学仪器与应用,2000,12(1):6-8
[97]金观昌,于森,鲍乃铿.PVDF多点脉搏波计算机辅助测试系统研究[J].清华大学学报自然科学版,1999(8):117
[98]刘明林,魏红等.中医脉诊客观化研究的思路与方法[J].辽宁中医学院学报,2004,6(3)：258—259
[99]王炳和,相敬林.基于神经网络方法的人体脉象识别研究[J].西北工业大学学报,2002,20(3):454—456
[100]姜涛.基于小波分析的中医脉象识别的研究：[学位论文].南京：河海大学,2003
[101]汤伟昌,孙汉钧,李斌芳.双路中医脉象检测方法的研究[J].中国医药学报, 2000,15(1)：14—17.
[102]石山仁,笠原宏.触觉检测脉波计一依手指触觉和压觉的可视化制成的脉波计[J].国外医学·中医中药分册,1991,(3):13—14.
[103]藤田六郎.用超声波脉诊仪的六部定位[J].国外医学·中医中药分册,1986,(1)：12—1
[104]冈田腾.东方医学中脉诊的临床实用化[J].国外医学·中医中药分册,1989,(2)：28—30.
[105]中谷义雄(著),叶少麟(译).良导络的原理及临床概要[J].浙江医学院学报.1958, (2)：191-197.
[106]房兴业.中国经络诊断中经穴电位测量方法研究[J].航天医学与医学工程.1989,(2)：24-25
[107]田淑荆,人体经络系统客观存在中国在50年代已经测定证实[J],世界科学技术
[108]商振德.人体生物电循环传导系统——经络系统.针灸经络研究回顾与展望国际学术讨论会文集
[109]莫浣英,李鹏,人体皮肤电现象的观察[J].上海中医药杂志,1989,7:21-29
[110]高桂宗,张永贤.电脑测定经络能量之研究[J].中国针灸,
[111]中医研究院针灸经络研究所,经络感传研究中疼痛反应客观指标的探索,
[112]成泽东,于琪.手三阳经井穴与合穴皮肤电流相关性研究[J]. Shanghai J Acu-mox,2009,8(28):478-480
[113]徐冬梅,谢玉华,健康人胃经五输穴体表阻抗的规律性研究[J],贵阳医学院学报,2005,12,30(6):523-524
[114]Agathe P,井穴皮肤电阻值的生理学变化[J]. Medical Acupuncture,2006, 17(2):12-19
[115]沈阳医学院生理教研组经络科研小组,经络电活动的研究[J].辽宁医学杂志,1960,8：52.54
[116]韩兆亮.人体双侧对称经络电阻抗失衡与疾病的相关研究[J].菏泽医专学报,1999,11,(1):9-11
[117]许云祥,胡翔龙.心包经循行线上皮肤低阻点的皮肤电位检测[J].福建中医学院学报,1999,5,(9):13-16
[118]曹东胜.运动员疲劳时经络阻抗的变化趋势研究[J].江汉大学学报,2004,32,(3):82-84
[119]胡武光.良导络在临床上的应用[J].江苏中医：
[120]刘芳,樊艳华.功能性消化不良患者身心症状及下肢脾胃经穴声电特性研究.北京中医药大学中医学专业硕士学位论文
[121]樊祥民；经络电阻抗测量与应用的实验研究[J].物理与工程,2008,3,(18):41-51
[122]汪惠敏.人体皮肤电的分维研究[J].浙江中医学院院报,1993,17,(4):50
[123]邢江淮,原存信.哮喘病及不同期型经穴失衡水平的观察[J].针灸学报,1992,5：22-23
[124]陈高彰,毕国伟.过敏性鼻炎病人与正常人的穴位良导络值比较研究[J].成都中医药大学学报,2001,6,(32)：33-34
[125]龚启华,余爱珍.穴位显示在临床上的观察
[126]祝怀萱,诸葛文.经络学说运用于临床的治疗报告[J].上海中医药杂志：
[127]筱原正明.良导络治疗与经络治疗中治本法、基本法、治标法以及临床法的比较：单例和多例受试者的比较[J].国外医学中医中药分册,1995,17,(5):54