摘要
本文首次利用自行研制的可视化天然高分子用单、双螺杆挤压机,采用统计学手段进行试验设计和数据分析,较详尽地考察了棉籽饼粕挤压脱毒的工艺和设备参数对脱毒效果的影响。此外,本文首创地运用控制容积法以及作者与课题组成员实验建立的蛋白质物料本构方程经验式对单螺杆挤压这种高含水率、高粘度物料的流场进行了数值模拟,讨论了不同流动模型及工艺参数对挤压过程的影响。
挤压脱毒试验结果表明,采用螺杆挤压法脱毒,简便易行、且能取得优良的脱毒效果,但各挤压加工参数间需良好匹配。而且,单、双螺杆挤压机和棉籽粉、棉籽粕上的脱毒规律也存在着差异。捏合盘的加入可降低棉籽饼粕中的游离棉酚含量,但宜适当放置,捏合盘长度、位置及交互效应的作用十分显著,间距的影响则不显著。此外,捏合盘参数对脱毒效果也存在着一定的影响。从挤压产品组织结构看,尽管存在差别,经挤压后的棉籽蛋白可以获得与大豆蛋白挤压产品相类似的组织化纤维结构;实际挤压脱毒中,游离棉酚可能同多种氨基酸及其盐类发生化学反应并存在着多个反应点,赖氨酸则是其中重要的反应成分。
挤压流场模拟结果表明,影响棉籽饼粕挤压过程的各加工参数中,含水率的影响最为显著,螺杆转速次之,且两者间存在交互作用:无量纲产量主要影响沿流向速度分布形态,而对其它量影响不大:螺槽截面上的粘度沿螺槽深度方向呈近壁面处小、中间位置处大的分布特性。本构方程则是决定上述这些挤出响应变量反应的关键因素。而棉籽饼粕属天然高分子物料,其挤压改性过程中的本构方程十分复杂。模拟中采用作者及其课题组成员实验得出的蛋白质物料本构关系经验式进行计算,结果也表明不同流动模型处理得到的结果并不相同。牛顿流体处理尽管数值上与非牛顿流体存在差异,但也能大致反映出挤出加工的实际情形;非牛顿、非等温且温度沿流向非充分发展情形则存在一个各变量从初期显著波动到逐渐趋于稳定,最后与充分发展情形一致的发展过程。
从脱毒结果看,螺杆挤压脱毒法效果明显,值得进一步研究和应用;从数值模拟结果看,本文采用的计算方法、处理及程序实现是成功的。
Effects of varying screw speed, moisture content and feed rate on cottonseed meal de-gossypol process were studied using both single-screw and twin-screw extruder. Experimental results indicated that difference in . detoxification rule could arise between single-screw and twin-screw extruder or cottonseed flour and meal. Effects of screw configuration, mainly kneading blocks (KB) indicated that incorporation of KB, if appropriately set, could considerably reduce the residual free gossypol (FG) content. The length and position of KB significantly affected the de-gossypol results, while the spacing effect was marginal. KB parameters take effect as well. As for the de-gossypol mechanism, FG might react with several kinds of Amino Acid and with more than one binding site, ε -Amino Acid possibly the most important. In addition, the extrusion product fibrous texture of cottonseed protein was similar to that of soy protein.Through an experiential rheological model of protein product extrusion, flow simulation of single-screw extrusion indicated that different flow models led to different results. Isothermal and Newtonian flow model could reflect the true extrusion process to some degree though numerically different from the non-Newtonian, while the non-Newtonian, non-isothermal and temperature-undeveloped model experienced a fluctuation of extrusion variable at the beginning and stability as well after enough length of development zone, with values the same as those fully developed. In addition, effects of moisture on extrusion process were shown to be dominant, screw speed the less and dimensionless volumetric flow rate mainly affected the velocity distribution along the channel. With the viscosity, a distribution of small value near the wall and great in the midst of channel depth was assumed.Seen from the detoxification and flow simulation result, the screw extrusion de-gossypol method and numerical flow simulation of this extrusion process were proved to be effective.
引文
1. China oil, Seed imports up, and up, and up. INFORM,1998,9(7)
2.赵国志,刘桂兰,朱文珊,棉籽饼粕脱毒作饲料蛋白质资源的现状与对策,中国油脂,1993,21(6):28—29
3.罗明朗,棉籽饼粕在饲料中的应用,粮食与饲料工业,1993,(6):28
4.王曙光,棉籽饼粕脱毒技术经济分析,中国油脂,1995,20(4):38—39
5.刘大川,齐玉堂,含水丙酮浸出棉籽油及脱除棉酚的研究,中国油脂,1992,17(6):3—7
6.李延云,棉籽饼(粕)生物脱毒运用工程技术,饲料工业,99年24卷1期
7. Sheldon. J. Segal., Gossypol A Potential Contraceptive for Men
8. R.J. Hron Sr., S.P. Koltun. J., Pominski et al, The Potential Commercial Aspects of Gossypol, JAOCS,1987,64(9):1316-1319
9. Mar'in, A.P.; et al, Retardation of polymer oxidation by natural antioxidant gossypol. Polymer Degradation and Stability, Kinetics of oxygen consumption, 1992,35(2): 141-146
10.史志诚,牟永义,饲用饼粕脱毒原理与工艺,中国计量出版社,1996
11.祁凌云等,棉籽粕脱毒新工艺技术研究,中国饲料,1991,3
12.黄祖德,混合溶剂一次浸出棉仁脱酚,中国油脂,1994,19(2):25—27
13. M.S Kuk, Hron., Cottonseed extraction with a new solvent system: Isohexane and Alcohol Mixtures, JAOCS,1998,75(8)
14. Hron, R.J. Sr.; Kuk, M.S., Ethanol extraction of oil, gossypol and aflatoxin from cottonseed, JAOCS, 1994,71(4):417-421
15. Kuk, M.S.; Hron, R.J. Sr., Adsorptive gossypol removal, JAOCS, 1993, 70(2): 209-210
16. Kuk, M.S.; Hron, R.J. Sr., Supercritical carbon dioxide extraction of cottonseed with co-solvents,JAOCS,1994,71(12): 1353-1356
17. Hron, R.J.; Kuk, M.S., Determination of free and total gossypol by high performance liquid chromatography, JAOCS, 1990,67(3): 182-187
18. Kuk, M.S.; Hron, R.J. Sr., Reverse osmosis membrane characteristics for partitioning triglyceride-solvent mixtures,JAOCS,1989,66(9):1374-1380
19. Hron, R.J. Sr.; et al, Ethanol vapor deactivation of gossypol in cottonseed meal, JAOCS,1996,73(10):1337-1339
20
20. Dowd, Michael K., Compositional characterization of cottonseed soapstocks, JAOCS,1996,73(10): 1287-1395
21. Lakshman, V.; Bhowmick, D.N., Effect of processing parameters on gossypol levels in protein isolates from cottonseed by alkali, Separation Science and Technology, 1994,29(5):2035-2046
22.刘大川,齐玉堂,含水丙酮浸出棉籽油及脱除棉酚的研究,中国油脂,1992,17(6):3—7
23.刘大川,阎杰,溶剂法浸出棉籽油和脱除棉酚的工艺研究,中国油脂,1999,24(4)6—8
24.刘长林,无毒高蛋白质棉仁粉的研究,北京工业大学学报,1996,22(2):119
25.陈以峰,棉酚缓解棉花光合抑制的效应初探,棉花学报,1996,8(1):55
26.袁金生等,TG—1型脱酚剂,中国饲料,1994,2
27.钟英长等,饲料资源开发与利用,中国饲料工业协会出版,1988,29—41
28.钟英长等,饲料资源开发与利用,饲料工业,1989,8:4—8
29.施安辉等,高效降解棉酚菌种的选育及小试工艺条件的研究,1990
30.吴波,李永明,闫中一,棉籽饼粕的生物脱毒研究,中国油脂,1996,21(6):28—29
31.吴波,闫中一,李永明,棉籽蛋白粉的生物脱毒研究,中国油脂,1999,24(1):54—55
32.马承融,沈维华,饲料资源开发与利用,中国饲料工业协会出版,1988,20—28
33.贺健,周秀英等,热喷饲料,内蒙畜牧科学院,1989,9
34.王载昆等,应用ZR热喷系统脱毒的菜籽粕饲喂肉用仔鸡的试验,饲料工业,1995,7
35. M. Harper, Extrusion of Foods, CRC, 1982
36.Ian Johnson,杨月祥译,挤压蒸煮对营养物的影响,粮食与饲料工业,1991,第9期,54—57
37.张亚苓,膨化原理及设备,食品工业科技,1987,第3期,37
38.杨铭意,谷物膨化机理的研究,食品科学,1989,第2期
39.刘天印,陈存社,食品挤压重组加工技术,轻工出版社,1998
40.唐振茂,王守礼,膨化技术及其应用,食品工业科技,1987,3,37
41.吕少芳,膨化技术原理及在粮食加工中的应用,郑州粮食学院学报,1989,第2期
42. D.V. Zasypkin, Tung-Ching Lee, Extrusion of Soybean and Wheat Flour as affected by Moisture Content, J.Food Sci,1998,63(6):1058-1061
43. N.Wang, P.R. Bhirud, R.T. Tyler, Extrusion Texturization of Air-Classified Pea Protein, J. Food Sci, 1999,64(3):509-513
44. R.Wulansari, J.R.Mitchell, J.M.V. Blanshard, Starch Conversion During Extrusion as Affected by Added Gelatin, J. Food Sci,1999,64(6):1055-1058
45. M.O. Iwe, I.Wolters, et al., Behaviour of Gelatinisation and Viscosity in Soy-Sweet Potato Mixtures by Single Screw Extrusion: A Response Surface Analysis, J. Food Engineering, 1998,38:369-379
46.文东辉等,基于响应面法的双螺杆挤压参数的研究和应用,粮食与饲料工业,1999,第12期,27—28
47. S.P. Clack, Continuous Extrusion Cooking of Cottonseed Kernels and of Partially Defatted Meal, JAOCS,1979,Vol 46, Dec.
48. T. S. De Buckle, L. E. Zapata, et al., Two Food Application of Cottonseed flours and Meals, JAOCS, Vol. 56, March 1979
49. M.V. Taranto, G.F. Cegla, et al., Textured Cottonseed and Soy Flours: A Microscopic Analysis, J. Food Sci,1978,43:767-771
50. G.F.Cegla, M.V.Taranto, et al., Microscopic Structure of Textured Cottonseed Flour Blends, J. Food Sci,1978,43,775-779
51. G.R. Jansen, J.M. Harper, L.O' Deen, Nutritional Evaluation of Blended foods made with a Low-Cost Extruder Cooker, J. Food Sci,1978,43:912-915
52. M.V. Taranto, G.F.Cegla, K.C. Rhee, Morphological, Ultrastructural and Rheological Evaluation of Soy and Cottonseed Flours Texturized by Extrusion and Nonextrusion Processing, J. Food Sci, 1978,43:973-979
53. F.R. Del Valle, M. Escobedo,et al., Preparation of Low Free Gossypol and High Available Lysine Cottonseed/Soybean Blends, J. Food Sci, 1986,51(5):1242-1244
54. Michael V. Taranto, W.W. Meinke, et al., Parameters Affecting Production and Character of Extrusion Texturized Defatted Glandless Cottonseed Meal, J. Food Sci, 1975,40:1264-1269
55. Hector Mayorga, Jaime gonzalez, et al., Preparation of A Low Free Gossypol Cottonseed Flour by Dry and Continuous Processing, J. Food Sci, 1975, 40: 1270 N1274
56. 王卫国等,莱籽饼脱毒工艺研究,粮食与饲料工业,1998,第5期,17-18
57. Dr. Khee Choon Rhee, Final Report Commercial Industrial Scale Demonstration of New Castor Meat Deluxification and Deallergenaiium Technology, Texas Engineering Experiment station, Texas A and M University system college station, Texas 77843-2476, Dec, 1989
58. E.Beck, Int. Plast. Engi, Vol.2, 316,1962
59. B.H. Maddock, Soc. Plastics Engi, J., Vol. 15, 383,1959
60. D.Rolyance, PES, Vol. 20, No. 15,1980
61. M.L. Hami & J.F.T. Pittman, PES, Vol. 20, 339, 1980
62. H.Kuhnle, Kunststoffe, Vol. 72, 267,1982
63. H.S.Rowell & D.Finlayson, Engineering, Vol.114, 606,1922
64. J.F.Carley, R.S.Mallouk and J.Mckelvey, Ind. Eng. Chem, Vol.4, 974,1953
65. P.H. Morgan et al, Plastics Progress, Londan, Illife books Ltd, 1951
66. J.F.Carley and R.A.Strub, Ind. Eng. Chem, Vol.45, 970,1953
67. J.S.Mallouk & J.M. Mckelvey, Ind. Eng. Chem, Vol.45, 983,1953
68. C.H.Jepson, Ind. Eng. Chem, Vol.45, 992,1953
69. W.Meskat, Kunststoffe, Vol.45, 87,1955
70. W.D.Mohr, R.L. Saxton and C.H. Jepson, Ind. Eng. Chem, Vol.49,1857,1957
71. W.d.Mohr, P.H.Squires and F.C.Stan, Soc. Plastics Engrs. J., Vol. 16,1015,1960
72. W.L. Gore and J.M.mckelvey, Theory of Screw Extruers, Vol. 3, New York Academic Press, 1959
73. W.D.Mohr and R.S.Mallouk, Ind. Eng. Chem, Vol.51, 765,1959
74. W.D.Mohr, P.H.Squires and F.C.Starr, Soc. Plastics Engrs.J., Vol.16, 1015,1960
75. D.L.Weeks and W.J.Allen, J.Mech.Eng.Sci., Vol.4, 380,1962
76. R.M.Griffith, Ind. Eng. Chem., Fundamentals, Vol.1,189,1962
77. B.S.Glyde and W.A.Holmes-Walker, Int. Plastics. Engi, Vol.2, 338,1962
78. F.W.Kroesser & S.Middleman, PES, Vol.5, 231,1965
79. J.M. Mckelvey, Soc. Plastics Engrs. Trans., Vol.5,231,1965
80. D.I.Marshell, I.Klein and R.H. Uhl, Soc. Plastics Engrs. J., Vol.20,329,1964
81. D.I.Marshell and I.Klein, Wire Prd., Vol.41,1054,1966
82. R.A.Barr and C.I.Chung, Soc.Plastics Engrs.J., Vol.22, 77,1966
83. A.M.Benis, Chem.Eng.Sci., Vol.22,805,1967
84. B.H.Maddock, Soc.Plastics Engrs.J., Vol.23,835,1967
85. B.Yates, PhD thesis, Cambridge University, 1968
86. H.J.Zamodits & J.R.A.Pearson, Trans. Soc. Rheol., Vol. 13, 359,1969
87. B.Martin, J.R.A.Pearson and B.Yates, Repott No.5, Polymer Processing Research Cetre, Dept. Of Chem. Engi, Cambridge University, 1969
88. R.T.Fenner, Extruder Screw Design, Illifer books, London, 1972
89. K.Palit and R.T.Fenner, AICHE J. Vol.18, 628,1972
90. K.Palit and R.T.Fenner, AICHE J. Vol. 18,1163,1972
91. R.T.Fenner, The Design of Large Hot Melt Extruders, Engineering design of plastics processing machinery, University of Bradford, England, 1974
92. G.Lider and Z.Tadmor, Theoretical analysis of residence time distribution functions and strain distribution functions in plasticating screw extruders, PES, Vol.16, 450,1976
93. R.T.Fenner, Polymer, Vol. 18, 617,1977
94. D.M. Bigg & S.Middleman, I & EC Fundam., Vol. 13,66,1984
95. S.Bruin, D.J.V.Zuilichem and W.Stolp, J. Fd. Process Engrs., Vol.21,1978
96. C.Kiparissides & J.Vlachopoulos, PES, Vol. 16, 712,1976
97. J.R.A. Pearson, The Chemical Engineer, 1977
98. CD. Denson & B.K. Hwang, PES, Vol.20, 965,1980
99. J.F.T.Pittman & K.Rashid, Journal of Polymer Engineering, Vol.5, No. 1,1985
100. I.Bruker, C.Miaw, A.Hasson and G.Balch, PES, Vol. 27, No.7,1987
101. Remsen,C.H and Clark, J.P., A viscosity model for a cooking dough, J. Food Processing Engng, 1978, 2(1), 39.
102. Jorge C.Oliveira, Mathematical modeling of food processing operations, Elsevier Pres, Chapter 5, the modeling of screw extrusion process, 1993
103. Schwartzberg, H.G., Food extrusion, FPBE News, 1979 ( American Institute of Chemical Engineers).
104. Chen, A.H., Jao, Y.C., Larkin, J.W. and Goldstein, W.E., Rheological model of soy dough in extrusion, J. Food Processing Engng, 1978, 2, 337-342
105. Cervone, N.W. and Harper, J.M., Viscosity of an intermediate moisture dough, J. Food Processing Engng, 1978, 2(1), 83
10
106. Fong, D.S.C., Experimental study of extrusion cooking of defatted soy flour, MS thesis, Chemical Engineering, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Blacksburg, Virginia, USA, 1978
107. Harper, J.M., Rhodes, T.P. and Wanninger Jr. L.A., Viscosity model for cooked cereal doughs, Chem. Engng Progr., Symp. Ser., 1971, 67(108), 40
108. Roller, M.B., Characterisation of the time temperature viscosity behaviour of curing β-staged epoxy resins, Polym. Engng Sci., 1975, 15(6), 406
109. Morgan, R.G., Suter, D.A and Sweat, V.E., Modeling the effects of temperature - time history, temperature, shear rate and moisture on apparent viscosity of defatted soy flour dough, American Society of Agricultural Engineers, St Joseph, Michigan, paper 79-6002, 1978
110. Harmann, D.V. and Harper, J.M., Modeling a forming foods extruder, J. Food Sci., 1974, 39,1099
111. Tsao, T.F., Harper, J.M. and Repholz, K.M., The effects of screw geometry on extruder operational characteristics, Am. Inst. Chem. Engrs. Symp. Ser., 1978, 74(172), 142
112. Fricke, A.L., Clarke, J.P. and Mason, T.F., Cooking and drying of fortified cereal foods: extruder design. Chem. Eng. Progr., Symp. Ser., 1977, 73(163), 134
113. Harper, J.M., Extrusion of Foods, 1978 (CRC Press, Boca Raton, Florida).
114. Kokini, J.L., Ho, C.T. and Karwe, M.V., (Eds) Food Extrusion Science and Technology, 1992(Dekker, New York).
115. Jaluria, Y., Heat and mass transfer in the extrusion of non-Newtonian materials, Adv. Heat Transfer, 1996, 28, 145-230.
116.林炳鉴、朱复华、薛平等,可视化双螺杆挤出机ZL 95 2 09631 5
117.袁明君,单螺杆挤出的过程研究,[博士学位论文],北京:北京化工大学,1997
118.北京化工大学,新型双螺杆挤出机的研制开发和工程肉制品开发,“八五”国家重点科技项目计划专题可行性论证报告,1994年12月
119.陈存社、林炳鉴,大豆分离蛋白双螺杆挤压组织化和流变性能的研究,中国食品学报,1998,Vol.3,No.1
120.陈存社、林炳鉴、杨雪,FTE型新型食品加工全程可视化双螺杆挤压机的研制,CINST,‘97食品机械文集,中国食品科学技术学会,1997年5月
121.陈存社、朱复华、林炳鉴.淀粉单螺杆挤出过程的可视化实验研究,农业机械学报,1998,Vol.2
122.陈存社、林炳鉴,螺杆转速和原料含水率对糯米单螺杆挤出过程的影响,中国食品学报,1998,Vol.3,No.1
123. Chen Cunshe, Lin Bingjian, Zhu Fuhua, Experimental Study on Corn Meal Extrusion Cooking with a Whole-Length Three-Direction Visualized Twin-Screw Extruder of Food, Proceedings of 1997 Beijing International Symposium on Food Processing And Packaging Technology, 1997, 10, P321-326
124. Lin Binjian, Yang Xue, Chen Cunshe, The Whole Process of Food Extrusion Researched by Visualization Technology, Proceedings of 1997 Beijing International Symposium on Food Processing And Packaging Technology, 1997, 10, P307-312
125.薛平、何亚东、林炳鉴,双螺杆挤压机挤出蛋白肉制品的研究,中国食品学报,1998,Vol.2,No.3
126.汪东彪,淀粉质原料在单螺杆挤出机中流动行为的探讨,[硕士学位论文],北京:北京化工大学,1996,5
127.王洪武,大豆蛋白质双螺杆挤压加工的研究,[硕士学位论文],北京:北京化工大学,1999,5
128.陈存社,食品挤压与质构重组技术的研究,[博士后研究工作报告],北京:北京化工大学,1998,10
129. F. Hsieh & J. C. Whittier, et al., Studies of Whole Cottonseed Processing with a Twin-Screw Extruder, J. Food Eng., 12, 1990, 293-306
130. Guy, R. C. E. & Horne, A.W., Extrusion and co-extrusion of cereals. In Food Structure—It's creation and evaluation, ed. J. M.V. Blanshard & J. R. Mitchell. Butterworths, London,1988, 331-49
131.杨伟雄,张开诚,测定棉籽酚的改良方法,食品科学,1989(2),p 42—46
132. Deepark Srivastava, R.Garg, et al., Optimization studies of blend composition and ageing parameters for making LDPE/HDPE/LLDPE films by response surface methodology, Macromol. Mater. Eng., 2000, 283,81-87
133. R.N.Chavez-Jauregui, M.E.M.P.Silva, and J.A.G.Areas, Extrusion Cooking Process for Amaranth (Amaranthus caudatus L.), J. Food Sci., Vol.65, No.6, 2000, 1009-15
134.Douglas C, Montgomery,实验设计与分析,汪仁官等译,中国统计出版社,北京,1998,第三版,p 600—630
135. Raymond H. Myers, Douglas C. Montgomery, Response Surface Methodology, JOHN WILEY & SONS, INC, New York, 1995, p 297—324
136. Gogoi, B.K., Choudhury, G.S., et al, Effects of location and spacing of reverse screw and kneading element combination during twin-screw extrusion of starchy and proteinaceous blends, Food Research International, 1996, 29 (5/6): 505-12
13
137. Screw Configuration Effects on Macroscopic Characteristics of Extrudates Produced by Twin-Screw Extrusion of Rice Flour, J. Food Sci, 1999,64(3):479-487
138. G.S. Choudhury, A. Gautam, Camire, Mary Ellen, Protein functionality modification by extrusion cooking, JAOCS, 1991,68(3):200-205
139.王洪武,周建国,林炳鉴,新型双螺杆食品挤压机加工复合组织蛋白的研究,农业机械学报,2000,Vol.32,No.2,66-69
140. C.M. Cater, C.M. Lyman, Reaction of Gossypol With Amino Acids and Other Amino Compounds, JAOCS, 1969, Vol.46, 649-653
141.江顺亮,单螺杆挤出理论研究,[博士学位论文],北京:北京化工大学,1996
142.陶文铨著,数值传热学,西安交大出版社,西安,1988
143.帕坦卡,S.V.著,张政译,传热与流体流动的数值计算,科学出版社,北京,1984
144. S.V. Patankar, A general-purpose computer program for two-dimensional elliptic situations, January 1982
145. Fenner. R.T., Developments in the analysis of steady screw extrusion of polymers, Polymer, 1977, 18, 617-635
146. P.S. Ghoshdastidar, G.Ghai and R.P. Chhabra, Computer simulation of three-dimensional transport during moistened defatted soy flour processing in the metering section of a single-screw extruder, Proc. Instn. Mech. Engrs, Vol. 214, Part C, 2000, 335-349
147. Schlichting, H., Boundary Layer Theory, McGraw Hill, New York, 1979
148.王洪武,国巨发,周建国等,大豆蛋白质面团流变性能的研究,中国食品学报,2000,Vol.4,No.1,25-30