摘要
圆盘式刀库及机械手作为立式加工中心的关键功能部件,是由刀库、刀库分度装置、气动装置、机械手、机械手传动装置、电气装置、定位夹紧装置、驱动装置、润滑装置等组成的典型机电一体化产品。它的主要功能是快速、可靠的自动选刀、换刀,为更好地实现立式加工中心的一次装夹多工序甚至全部工序加工,减少零件加工过程中的非切削时间,提高生产效率,降低零部件的制造成本等提供保障。圆盘式刀库及机械手这一复杂系统能否确保换刀动作准确、可靠等是当前立式加工中心研究的重点问题之一。故本文依托“高档数控机床与基础制造装备”科技重大专项--关键功能部件的可靠性设计与试验技术(2010ZX04014-011),以圆盘式刀库及机械手为研究对象进行可靠性增长研究。
论文首先依据圆盘式刀库及机械手的结构、工作原理和功能确定故障判据,明确故障传递关系,据此进行故障信息采集。其次,运用模糊FMECA对圆盘式刀库及机械手使用现场的故障信息进行分析,针对该方法中对故障模式频率、故障率和故障影响三个评判因素的权重的专家主观赋权问题,提出运用综合考虑主客观因素的模糊层次分析法确定三个因素的权重;针对模糊FMECA分析中出现的故障模式危害度值相同的现象,提出采用灰色关联理论对具有相同危害度值的不同故障模式进行进一步的优化分析,从而得到更详尽的故障模式危害度排序。根据故障分析结果,对当前圆盘式刀库及机械手的可靠性薄弱部位与危害度较大的故障模式,分别从其所涉及的制造、装配、外购件、使用等方面提出有针对性的可靠性增长措施;在此基础上,对圆盘式刀库及机械手的结构提出可靠性设计和工艺改进建议,以促进圆盘式刀库及机械手的可靠性增长。
最后,根据可靠性试验标准,结合工厂实际情况设计基本性能和关键部件的可靠性试验方案,并应用关键部件可靠性试验验证可靠性增长措施和可靠性设计改进建议的有效性。试验验证结果表明,对圆盘式刀库及机械手的薄弱部位与危害度较大的故障模式实施可靠性增长措施和可靠性设计改进建议之后,圆盘式刀库及机械手的平均故障率降低了5.37%,可靠性水平得到了较大的提升。因此,根据故障分析采取的可靠性增长措施和可靠性设计改进建议是有效的,可以有效的促进圆盘式刀库及机械手的可靠性增长。
Disc-type tool magazine and manipulator is an important functional componentof vertical processing center, it is compose of tool magazine, indexing devices of toolmagazine, pneumatic devices, manipulator, manipulator’s actuator, electrical devices,positioning and clamping devices, drive unit, lubrication devices etc. This makes thedisc-type tool magazine and manipulator become a typical mechatronic product. Thedisc-type tool magazine and manipulator can automatic choose and change tool fastlyand reliably, which realize the vertical processing center’s multi-process and even allmachining processes though one fixture, reducing non-cutting time of processing andimproving production efficiency, thereby greatly reduce the manufacturing cost ofeach part. Therefore, whether the complex disc-type tool magazine and manipulatorcan ensure accurate and reliable tool change action or not is one of the key issues ofvertical machining center. Hence, this paper is going to research on the reliabilitygrowth of the disc-type tool magazine and manipulator, which is rely on “High-endCNC machine tools and basic manufacturing equipment” the national science andtechnology major projects--the reliability design and testing techniques of keyfunctional components (2010ZX04014-011).
According to the structure, working principle and function of the disc-type toolmagazine and manipulator, this paper first determines the fault criterion and explicitfault transmission relationship of the disc-type tool magazine and manipulator, whichcould direct us to collect the fault information. Second, this paper makes use of fuzzyFMECA analysis method to analyze the disc-type tool magazine and manipulator’sfault information. Fuzzy hierarchy analysis, which considers the objective andsubjective factors, is proposed to calculate the weight of three decision-making factors:failure mode frequency, failure rate and failure impact of fuzzy FMECA analysismethod to solve the expertise’s subjective empowerment. Further more,the grayrelational analysis method is delivered to analyze the failure mode, which has thesame hazard,to get a more detailed order. According to the analysis result, we canidentify the disc-type tool magazine and manipulator’s weak link; which can direct usto take target reliability growth measures from the involved manufacturing, assembly,purchased parts and the use of the disc-type tool magazine and manipulator’s weakposition and large hazard failure mode. Further more, this paper delivers the improvement of the tool magazine and manipulator’s reliability design suggestion,which might improve the reliability of the tool magazine and manipulator.
Finally, according to the reliability criterion and combined with the factorypractical, the basic performance reliability experiment program and key componentreliability experiment program is designed, and put the key component reliabilityexperiment program into use to verify the effectiveness of the reliability growthmeasures and the improved reliability design suggestions. The reliability experimentverified that when we put the reliability growth measures and the improved reliabilitydesign suggestions into use, the average failure rate of the disc-type tool magazineand manipulator has been effectively reduced, which is reduced5.37percent.Therefore, the reliability growth measures and the reliability designsuggestions are effective, which can effectively promote the reliability growth of thedisc-type tool magazine and manipulator.
引文
[1]生意社.数控机床重大专项将加大对数控系统及功能部件的扶持力度[EB/OL].[2011-04-30].http://china.toocle.com/cbna/item/2011-04-30/5753796.html.
[2]生意社.“十二五”我国机床将推进数控系统和功能部件产业化[EB/OL].[2011-05-26].http://www.beehuu.com/machine/jcmj/2011-05-26/1307.html.
[3]国内资讯.我国为机床消费及生产大国进口替代空间巨大[EB/OL].[2011-05-07].http://www.bzjw.com/news/news-30230.cfml.
[4]谭汝谋.发展数控机床功能部件之我见[EB/OL].[2006-02-21].http://www.newmaker.com/art_14113.html.
[5]李保民.加速发展数控机床功能部件不断提高数控机床技术水平[J].现代制造技术与装备,2006(6):1-4.
[6]王晓峰,申桂香,张英芝等.基于群体决策和多赋值方式的加工中心关键部件RPN分析[J].吉林大学学报(工学报),2011,41(6):1630-1635.
[7]申桂香,樊少华,张英芝等.数控机床子系统可靠性影响度分析[J].吉林大学学报(工学报),2010,40,S:266-269.
[8]刘静.双凸轮联动自动换刀技术的研究[D].大连:大连理工大学机械学院,2008.
[9]韩越梅.加工中心自动换刀装置的研究进展[J].装备制造技术,2010,(5):128-129.
[10]Y.H.Jeong,H.Tae,B.K.Min,D.W.Cho.Virtual automatic tool changer of amachining centre with a real-time simulation[J].International Journal ofComputer Integrated Manufacturing,2008,21(8):885-894.
[11]申桂香,樊少华,张英芝等.随机模糊条件下加工中心故障模式分析[J].农业机械学报,2011,42(2):216--219.
[12]戚洪利.自动换刀装置及其控制的研究[D].兰州:兰州理工大学机电学院,2007.
[13]Guixiang Shen,Xiaofeng Wang,Yingzhi Zhang,etl.Fuzzy analysis on criticalityof tool magazine based on type-2membership function and intervalnumber[C].2010International Conference on Electrical and ControlEngineering,IEEE IAS Society,June26,2010-June28,2010,Wuhan,China:p3779-3783.
[14]薛玉霞,申桂香,张英芝.基于模糊逻辑的数控机床故障分析[J].吉林大学学报(工学报),2008,38,S:115-118.
[15]KIM Jae-Hyun,LEE Choon-Man.Multi-stage optimum design of magazine typeautomatic tool changer arm [J].J.Cent.South Univ,2012,(19):174-178.
[16]Zhongqi Sheng,Hualong Xie,Zhiwei Xu,and etl.Design System Developmentof tool magazine for CNC Machine Tools[J].Applied Mechanics and Materials,2009(16-19):155-159.
[17]韩越梅.加工中心自动换刀装置的研究进展[J].装备制造技术,2010,(5):128-129.
[18]陈玲毅,宋玉荣.XKH768卧式加工中心换刀故障分析一例[J].机械制造,2003,41(465):49.
[19]Selcuk Avci,M. Selim Akturk.Tool magazine arrangement and operationssequencing on CNC machines[J].Computers Ops Res,1996,23,(11):1069-1081.
[20]MUSTAFA ILHAN GOKLER,MURAT BJLGJN KOC.Design of an automatictool changer with disc magazine for a CNC horizontal machinecenter[J].Int.J.Mech.ToolsManufect,1997,37(3):277-286.
[21]A.N. Kobuladze and L.M. Prupis,Automatic tool changers for machining centerswith horizontal spindles[J].Machines and Tooling,1974,45,(5):56.
[22]KIM J H,LEE M J,LEE C M.Geometric optimal design of an ATC arm usingdesign of experiments[C].Proceedings of the IASTED International Conference(in Korean).2010:357362.
[23]Meltem Denizel.Minimization of the Number of Tool Magazine Setups onAutomated Machines:A Lagrangean Decomposition Approach[J].OperationsResearch,2003,51(2):309-320.
[24]LEE S W,LEE H K. Reliability evaluation of ATC for high-speed linecenter[J].Journal of Korean Society for Precision Engineering,2006,23(6):111118.
[25]Christos P.Koulamas.Design of toolmagazine and operational areas for amulti-tool machine European[J].Journal of Operational Research,1992,63(2):240-253.
[26]王科社,张怀存,杨庆东等.加工中心自动换刀装置[J].机械制造,1995,(5):31-33.
[27]E.Niemi.Optimal tool magazine operation.Part2:rotating magazines withbuffered tool change[J].Int J Adv Manuf Technol,2004,(24):567–572.
[28]百度百科.快速自动换刀技术[EB/OL].http://baike.baidu.com/view/1649161.htm.
[29]Chang qi Deng,Bin Li.The Research and Development of ATC Automatic ToolSelection Based on Aucol[J].Advanced Materials Research,2011,(383):4090-4095.
[30]新产品介绍[J].机电工程技术,2001,(2):44-47.
[31]黄菊生,吴晨曦,刘军安.微加工中心刀库定位控制技术[J].制造技术与机床,2009(4):25-28.
[32]张建成,张之敬,金鑫等.可重配置的微小型刀库控制系统[J].2008,28(10):865-869.
[33]王爱玲.现代化数控机床结构与设计[M].北京:兵器工业出版社,1999(9):1-170.
[34]付承云.数控功能部件选用指导手册[M].北京:机械工业出版社,2010,12.
[35]韩旭.重型立式车床盘式刀库数字化设计[D].哈尔滨:哈尔滨理工大学,2009.
[36]牛军燕.经济型自动换刀装置的设计、分析及控制研究[D].镇江:江苏大学,2011.
[37]雍文章,毛勋才,杨海英等.立式加工中心换刀故障分析[J].机床与液压,2006,(4):219-231.
[38]刘希平.汽车检测系统可靠性分析与建模研究[D].长春:吉林大学,2007.
[39]卜涛.数控车床可靠性增长技术的应用研究[D].长春:吉林大学,2008.
[40]刘翔飞.数控系统开发过程可靠性技术研究及应用[D].长春:吉林大学,2005.
[41]迟向磊.我国数控机床可靠性研究概况[J].机械工艺师,2001,3:22-23.
[42]赵荣.计算机硬件可靠性验证试验[J].PCShopper,2001,7:198-199.
[43]戴勤.自动换刀机械手结构设计及PLC控制研究[D].苏州:苏州大学,2010.
[44]张英芝,申桂香.基于模糊理论的数控车床故障分析[J].中国机械工程,2009,20(19):2354-2357.
[45]薛玉霞.基于模糊逻辑的数控机床故障综合分析方法的研究[D].长春:吉林大学,2005.
[46]王东明,于丽敏.基于模糊数学的加工中心危害度分析[J].机械设计与制造,2009,11:215-216.
[47]申桂香,李怀洋,张英芝等.基于危害性分析的冷却系统可靠性改进技术[J].制造技术与机床,2012,(4):82-85.
[48]张琳,李长俊,苏欣等.模糊层次分析法确定管路风险因素权重[J].石油机械,2006,34(6):43-45.
[49]王梦琦,王端民,杨雪.基于改进模糊综合评判的航空发动机状态评估[J].润滑与密封,2011,36,(1):80-84.
[50]兰继斌,徐扬,霍良安等.模糊层次分析法权重研究[J].系统工程理论与实践,2006,9(9):107-111.
[51]万阳,王立海.基于模糊层次分析法的采购质量方案优选[J].森林工程,2006,22(1):70-72.
[52]黄建新,边亚琴.基于灰色关联度的装备故障风险分析[J].火力与指挥控制,2010,35(9):178-180.
[53]刘晓峰.灰色多属性决策的投资项目经济评价研究[D].天津:天津大学,2007.
[54]Ben-Daya M,Raouf A.A Revised Failure Mode and Effects Analysis Model[J].International Journal of Quality Reliability Management,1993,3(1):43-47.
[55]Chang C L,Wei C C,Lee Y H.Failure Mode and Effects Analysis using FuzzyMethod and Grey Method[J]. Kybernetes,1999,28(9):1072-1080.
[56]Anand P, Wang J.Modified failure mode and effects analysis using approximatereasoning.Reliability Engineering and System Safety,2003,79(1):69-85.
[57]孙玉刚.灰色关联分析及其应用的研究[D].南京:南京航空航天大学,2007.
[58]贾亚洲,陈殿生,张立斌.数控机床可靠性增长技术的应用研究[J].制造技术与机床,2001(3):12-14.
[59]谢志东,金涛,宫延明.斗笠提升机输送链销轴断裂和分析[J].2008,5:279.
[60]张家驷.门座起重机大真轮支承环钢结构制造工序的质量控制[J].建设机械技术与管理,2008,8:121-124.
[61]申桂香,李怀洋,张英芝等.数控车床刀架系统故障分析[J].机床与液压,2011,39(19):126-129.
[62]张金权.台湾吉辅盘式刀库工作原理及故障排除[J].机电信息,2010,6:97.
[63]王元军,杨琪,俞晖等.某型卧式加工中心自动换刀系统[J].中国制造业信息化,2010,39(7):75-78.
[64]董军功.加工中心换刀机构的检修[J].制造技术与机床,2003,(5):64.
[65]李善章.刀库运行的可靠性[J].机床,1988,3:22-24.
[66]王元军,杨琪,俞晖等.某型卧式加工中心自动换刀系统[J].中国制造业信息化,2010,39(7):75-78.
[67]牟致忠.可靠性设计[M].北京:机械工业出版社,1993(2):1-10.
[68]孟勃敏.加工中心可靠性技术研究[D].西安:陕西科技大学,2011.
[69]梁楚华,朱志坚等.数控机床自动换刀系统产品化研究[J].机械工艺师,2008,8:20-21.
[70]赵爱娜.大型龙门自动换刀技术研究[D].南京:南京理工大学,2011.
[71]梅文华.可靠性增长试验[M].北京:国防工业出版社,2003.
[72]GB/T15174-94.可靠性增长大纲[S],北京:中华人民共和国电子工业部,1994.
[73]北巨刀库说明书.圆盘式刀库BT40-24T使用说明书[M].北巨精密机械有限公司,2008.
[74]咸博.圆盘式刀库机械手自动换刀系统可靠性试验台研究[D].长春:吉林大学,2011.
[75]JB/T10791.1—2007.带刀具自动交换装置的刀库[S].北京:机械工业出版社,2007.
[76]裴咏红.数控机床可靠性增长实用技术[D].长春:吉林大学,2004.
[77]魏领会.面向生命周期的加工中心可用性保证技术[D].长春:吉林大学,2007.
[78]王元军.MCH63卧式加工中心可靠性分析与研究[D].南京:南京航空航天大学,2010,1.
[79]GJB899A-2009.可靠性鉴定与验收试验[S].北京:中国人民解放军总武装部,2009,5,25.
[80]徐智.加工中心及其关键功能部件可靠性技术研究[D].重庆:重庆大学,2011,5.