绝经综合征病证评定量表的研究
|
摘要
研究目的:
本研究以绝经综合征为疾病载体进行中医药疗效评价方法学的探讨。在中医理论指导下,立足于中医学基本特点和优势,引入和应用内容分析法、心理测量学、临床流行病学和循证医学等科研方法,建立符合中医诊疗特色的绝经综合征病证评定量表,把不同证型模块整合到评定量表中,以期客观评价中医药的临床疗效。
研究方法及内容:
研究内容及方法:在国家科技部“十五”攻关项目研制的绝经综合征评定量表(CMRS)基础上针对绝经综合征病证特点,引入内容分析法,对绝经综合征中医辨证分型文献进行初步研究,归纳分析绝经综合征的主要证型,提取主症及次症等组成证型模块,将其整合到既往研究绝经综合征评定量表中,初步形成绝经综合征病证评定量表的条目池,形成具有辨证内涵的绝经综合征疗效评价量表的初步理论模型。选择小样本绝经综合征患者进行预调查,对调查结果采用条目分布考察法、相关分析法、t检验法、分辨力系数法等考察量表条目敏感性、重要性、代表性和区分性,使之能够更好地反应临床疗效。
主要研究结果:
1.基于内容分析法对绝经综合征证型研究
(1)证型归纳的结果
纳入研究的教材、专著、期刊文献共111篇。在所有的文献中初步采集到的各种按照不同术语表述的证型有74个。应用内容分析法,根据证候的命名和证候的分类原则,将证型本质相同而表述名称不同的证型合并后得到36个证型。对这36个证型在111篇文献中出现的频数和频率进行统计分析,频率大于25%的证型有6个:肾阳虚73.87%;肾阴虚65.77%,肾阴阳两虚46.85%,心肾不交36.64%,肝肾阴虚36.04%,脾肾阳虚28.83%。对以上的6个证型的证素的应用内容分析法进行定量统计分析。绝经综合征常因脏腑功能失调出现痰湿、瘀血、气郁等兼夹证,本研究中肝郁频率为21.62%,痰湿阻滞8.11%,气滞血瘀8.11%。
(2)绝经综合征的证候模块
在中医的理论中,人体是一个整体,阴阳是整体中的最基本的两个属性,阴阳平衡是健康的基本要求。绝经综合征出现率大于25%的6个证型中,可按照阴阳属性其分为三个证候模块。肾阴虚、肝肾阴虚、心肾不交具有阴虚的共性,组成阴虚模块;肾阳虚、脾肾阳虚具有阳虚的共性,组成阳虚模块,肾阴阳两虚为阴阳两虚模块。
2.基于内容分析法对绝经综合征证素的研究
(1)肾阳虚证
111篇文献中,有65篇文献包括肾阳虚证的详细证素描述,共40个证素。频率大于50%的证素有9个,分别为畏寒肢冷(96.92%),舌淡(86.15%),小便清长或夜尿频多(86.15%),精神萎靡(78.46%),面浮肢肿(73.85%),便溏(70.77%),面色晦黯(69.23%),腰腹冷痛(61.54%),脉沉细无力(58.46%)。
(2)肾阴虚证
有62篇文献包括肾阴虚证素的详细描述,共35个证素。频率大于50%的证素有14个证素,分别为舌苔少(96.77%),潮热汗出(96.77%),舌质红(95.16%),头晕(93.55%),脉细数(91.94%),五心烦热(91.94%),耳鸣(90.32%),腰膝酸软(83.87%),经色鲜红(62.90%),大便干结(61.29%),口干(58.06%),皮肤干痒(56.45%),尿少色黄(53.23%),失眠多梦(51.61%)。心烦易怒(35.48%),阴部干涩(13,20.97%),健忘(8,12.90%)。
(3)肾阴阳两虚证:
共38篇文献包括肾阴阳两虚证素的详细描述,共38个证素。频率大于50%的证素共7个,分别为耳鸣(38,100.00%),头晕(38,100.00%),潮热汗出(27,71.05%),畏寒(25,65.79%),舌淡(23,60.53%),腰膝酸软(23,60.53%),苔薄(20,52.63%)。
(4)心肾不交证:
共34篇文献包括心肾不交证素的详细描述,分为34个证素。频率大于50%的证素共有10个,分别为失眠多梦(33,97.06%),舌红(31,91.18%),心悸怔忡(29,85.29%),脉细数(27,79.41%),烦躁易怒(27,79.41%),健忘易惊(25,73.53%),心烦不宁(22,64.71%),苔少(19,55.88%),腰膝酸软(18,52.94%),头晕耳鸣(17,50.00%)。
(5)肝肾阴虚证:
有23篇文献包括肝肾阴虚证素的详细描述,共38个证素。频率大于50%的证素
共12个,分别为头晕(23,100.00%),舌红(22,95.65%),苔少(21,91.30%),耳鸣(19,82.61%),潮热汗出(18,78.26%),腰膝酸软(17,73.91%),五心烦热(17,73.91%),脉细数(14,60.87%),口干(14,60.87%),失眠多梦(13,56.52%),烦躁易怒(13,56.52%),便秘(12,52.17%)。
(6)脾肾阳虚证
有20篇文献包括脾肾阳虚证素的详细描述,共40个证素。频率大于50%的证素
共有10个,分别为便溏(19,95.00%),纳呆(18,90.00%),面浮肢肿(16,80.00%),畏寒肢冷(14,70.00%),腰背冷痛(13,65.00%),神疲乏力(12,60.00%),脉沉细(10,50.00%),苔薄白(10,50.00%),舌淡胖有齿印(10,50.00%),夜尿频多(10,50.00%)。
(7)肝郁证
有17篇文献包括肝郁证证素的详细描述,共33个证素。频率大于50%的证素共有7个,分别为精神抑郁多愁易怒(17,100.00%),胁肋胀痛(16,94.12%),苔薄黄(11,64.71%),舌红(11,64.71%),潮热汗出(11,64.71%),胸闷叹息(11,64.71%),苔薄白(9,52.94%)。
(8)气滞血瘀证
有7篇文献包括气滞血瘀证素的详细描述,共29个证素。舌质紫黯或有瘀斑的出现率最高(5,71.43%),周身刺痛(3,42.86%)、胸胁刺痛(3,42.86%)、胸闷痹痛(3,42.86%)出现频率也较高。
(9)痰湿阻滞证
有5篇文献包括痰湿阻滞证素的详细描述,共20个证素。苔厚腻湿滑(5,60.00%)的出现率较高,颜面浮肿(5,100.00%)出现率高。
不同证型的证素不尽相同,同一个证素可见于多个证型中,各证素对该证型的重要性都不同。本研究应用内容分析法对111篇绝经综合征文献的主要证型的证素进行了定性分析和定量统计,对各证型证素的频率进行排序,结合临床经验以及经过课题核心小组讨论后,主症主要提取自频率排前3位的证素中,次症主要提取自频率位于第4至第10位的证素中。
3.绝经综合征主要证型及兼央证的主症和次症
(1)肾阳虚证:
主症3个,畏寒肢冷、小便清长或夜尿频多、精神萎靡;次症6个,面浮肢肿、便溏、腰腹冷痛、纳少、脘腹胀满、腰膝酸软。
(2)肾阴虚证:
主症有3个,潮热汗出、头晕、五心烦热;次症有7个,耳鸣、腰膝酸软、大便干结、口干、皮肤干痒、失眠多梦及心烦易怒。
(3)肾阴阳两虚证:
主症有3个,分别为耳鸣、头晕、潮热汗出;次症有4个,分别为畏寒、腰膝酸软、腰背冷痛和健忘。
(4)心肾不交证:
主症有3个,分别为失眠多梦、心悸、烦躁易怒;次症有5个,分别为健忘、腰膝酸软、头晕、耳鸣、潮热汗出。
(5)肝肾阴虚证:
主症有3个,分别为头晕、耳鸣、潮热汗出;次症有6个,分别为腰膝酸软、五心烦热、口干、失眠多梦、烦躁易怒、便秘。
(6)脾肾阳虚证:
主症有3个,分别为便溏、纳呆、面浮肢肿;次症有6个,分别为畏寒肢冷、神疲乏力、夜尿频多、脘腹胀满、头晕、腰膝酸软。
(7)肝郁证:
主症有2个,分别为精神抑郁多愁易怒和胁肋胀痛;次症有4个,分别为潮热汗出、胸闷叹息、失眠多梦、乳房胀痛。
(8)气滞血瘀证:
主症1个,为舌质紫黯或有瘀斑,次症2个,头胀痛、失眠多梦。
(9)痰湿阻滞证:
主症1个:颜面浮肿,次症4个,分别为潮热汗出、胸闷烦躁、头晕、苔厚腻湿滑。
4.初步形成绝经综合征病证评定量表的模型
该量表模型能体现中医证候类型及变化特点,能反映中医药治疗后患者自我感觉、生理功能、角色功能、心理健康等软指标的改变。
结论:
证候标准化和客观化,是建立客观规范的中医临床疗效评价体系的必要前提。对于中医药的疗效评价的研究,应该是在证候内涵的基础上进行。本研究通过结合既往流行性调查及绝经综合征证候文献研究结果,探索对绝经综合征证型的分类及证素的定性定量研究,对具有证候内涵的疗效评价量表条目进行更加规范化和科学化的研究,形成符合中医证候特点的绝经综合征病证评定量表模型。
Purposes of Research:
With the menopausalsyndrome to be a carrier,we try to explorate the methodology of the TCM evaluation of therapeutic efficiency.According to the theory of chinese medicine,basic on the characteristic and advantage of TCM, using content analysis method,psychometrics,clinical epidemiology and evidence based medicine,construct a rating scale of menopausal syndrome with disease and combinated syndrome which is consonant with the diagnosing and curate characteristics of TCM.we consider to bring different syndromes module to the rating scale,expect to evaluate the curative effect of TCM objectively.
Research methods and content:
Base on the Chinese Menopause Rating Scale(CMRS) which was construct in the "fifteenth" critical project of the National Science and Technology Development,we study the the Chinese Menopause syndromes literature with the TCM differentiation of symptoms and signs for classification of syndrome, using content analysis methods.Study Menopause syndromes literature which come from monograph,teaching material and medicine magazine with the differentation of every type syndromes of menopausal syndrome,sum up and analysis the main syndromes,extract the chief and secondary symptom to compose the symptom-complex module,and add them to the menopausal syndrome rating scale of disease and syndrom.The item pool of the rating scale is initial formation.The initial theory module of evaluate the TCM curative effect with differentiation of syndromes is constructed.We chose some menopausal syndrome patients to carry out the investigation in advance in the chinic.Inspect the senstinve,importantance,representation and distinguish using the surveying distribution of items methods,discrete method,correlational analysis method、t test method、resolving power coefficient method method and make it to reflect the curative effect well.
Main results:
1.Preliminary study on TCM literature relative to menopausal syndromes,using the content anylysis method.
(1)The main syndromes of the menopausal syndrome.
Totally 111 pieces of TCM literature relative to menopause syndrome were evolved in the study.There are 74 kinds of syndromes initially extract from all literatures.There are many syndromes which has the same essence but with different terminology name.According to the essence of the syndromes and the standard of differention of syndromes,we carry on the analysis of the 74 kinds syndromes and obtain 36 kinds of syndromes.
We statistic the frequency of the 36 kinds of syndromes.There 6 syndromes whose frequency are higher than 25%.The kidney deficiency of yang syndrome appears 82 times(73.87%);73pieces literatures includ the kidney Yin deficient(65.77%);52 pieces literatures includ the kidney Yin and Yang deficiency(46.85%);44 pieces literatures includ type of failure of the heart and kidney integrating syndromes(36.64%);40 pieces literatures includ hepatic and renal yin deficiency(36.04%);32 pieces literatures includ the spleen kidney deficiency of yang(28.83%).We statistic the syndrome elements of the above syndromes using the content analysis,including the quantitative analysis and qualitative analysis.The menopause syndrome usually has companying with syndromes because the malfunction of zangfu organs.The main companying with syndromes are stagnation of liver-QI(21.62%),type of stagnation of phlegm-damp(8.11%)、qi-stagnancy and blood stasis(8.11%)。
(2) the syndrom module of menopause syndrome
The general idea is the basic in TCM theory and the human body is a whole.Yin and Yang are the two basic attributes in the whole body.a balance of Yin and Yang is the basic request of the body health,we split the main 6 sundromes of menopause syndrome according to the Yin and Yang attributes. Deficiency of kidney-YIN、hepatic and renal yin deficiency and failure of the heart and kidney integrating make up of the Yin deficiency module;The kidney deficiency of yang、the spleen kidney deficiency of yang make up of the Yang deficiency module;the kidney Yin and Yang deficiency is in the Yin and Yang deficiency module.
2.Study the syndrome elements of all kinds syndromes of MS using the content analysis method.
(1) Kidney deficiency of yang
There are 65literatures describe the kidney deficiency of yang' s syndrome elements,altogether 40 syndrome elements.The syndrome elements whose frequency are bigger than 50%are as follows,such as fear cold and member cold(96.92%);pale tongue(86.15%);clear abundant urineand Frequent urination at night(86.15%);listlessness(78.46%);swollenface and limbs(73.85%); loose stool(70.77%);laepcumx complexion(69.23%);waist abdomen cold pain (61.54%);deep or thready weak pulse(58.46%).
(2) Deficiency of kidney-YIN
There are 62 literatures describe the kidney Yin deficient' s syndrome elements,altogether 35 syndrome elements.The syndrome elements whose frequency are bigger than 50%are as follows,14 syndrome elements in total, such as tongue coating few(96.77%);hectic fever and perspiration(96.77%); red tongue(95.16%);dizzy(93.55%);thready and rapid pulse(91.94%);burning sensation of five centres(91.94%);sibilismus aurium(90.32%);waist and knee acidum weak(83.87%);menses blood colour bright red(62.90%);constipation (61.29%);Dry mouth(58.06%);the skin itches dryly(56.45%).
(3) The kidney Yin and Yang deficiency
There are 38 literatures describe the kidney Yin and Yang deficiency' s syndrome elements,altogether 38 syndrome elements.The syndrome elements whose frequency are bigger than 50%are as follows,7 syndrome elements in total, such assibilismus aurium(100.00%);dizzy(100.00%);hectic fever and perspiration(71.05%);hot and cold by turns(65.79%);pale tongue(60.53 %);waist and knee acidum weak(60.53%);tongue coating thinness(52.63 %)。
(4) Failure of the heart and kidney integrating
There are 34 literatures describe the failure of the heart and kidney integratings syndrome elements,altogether 34 syndrome elements.The syndrome elements whose frequency are bigger than 50%are as follows,10 syndrome elements in total,such as insomnia and multi-dreams(97.06%);red tongue (91.18%);palpitation(85.29%);thready and rapid pulse(79.41%);perturbed and irritability(79.41%);loss of memory(73.5%);perturbed(64.71%),tongue coating few(55.88%),waist and knee acidum weak(52.94%),dizzy and sibilismus aurium(50.00%)。
(5) Hepatic and renal yin deficiency
There are 23literatures describe hepatic and renal yin deficiency' s syndrome elements,altogether 38 syndrome elements.The syndrome elements whose frequency are bigger than 50%are as follows,12 syndrome elements in total, such as dizzy(100.00%);red tongue(95.65%);tongue coating few(91.30 %);sibilismus aurium(82.61%);hectic fever and perspiration(78.26%); waist and knee acidum weak(73.91%);burning sensation of five centres(73.91 %);thready and rapid pulse(60.87%);Dry mouth(60.87%);insomnia and multi-dreams(56.52%);perturbed and irritability(56.52%);constipation (52.17%)。
(6) The spleen and kidney deficiency of yang
There are 20 literatures describe the spleen kidney deficiency of yang' s syndrome elements,altogether 40 syndrome elements.The syndrome elements whose frequency are bigger than 50%are as follows,loose stool(95.00%),bad appetite (90.00%),swollen face and limbs(80.00%);fear cold and member cold(70.00 %);weary and hypodynamia(60.00%);deep or thready pulse(50.00%);tongue coating thin and white(50.00%);pale tongue and imprints of the teeth(50.00 %);clear abundant urineand Frequent urination at night(50.00%)。
(7) Syndrome of stagnation of liver-QI
There are 17 literatures describe stagnation of liver-QI' s syndrome elements,altogether 33 syndrome elements.The syndrome elements whose frequency are bigger than 50%are as follows,deprementia or sensitivity sentimentality(100.00%);hypochondrium distending pain(94.12%);thin and yellow coating(64.71%);red tongue(64.71%);hectic fever and perspiration (64.71%).
(8) Qi-stagnancy and blood stasis
There are 7 literatures describe qi-stagnancy and blood stasis' s syndrome elements,altogether 29 syndrome elements.The syndrome elements whose frequency are bigger than 50%are as follows,1 syndrome elements in total, such aspurple toung or ecchymosis(71.43%).
(9) Type of stagnation of phlegm-damp
There are 5 literatures describe type of stagnation of phlegm-damp' s syndrome elements,altogether 20 syndrome elements.The syndrome elements whose frequency are bigger than 50%are as follows,2syndrome elements in total, such asthickly furred and Slippery Nipple(60.00%);swollen face and limbs (100.00%).
Different syndroms' element are different,a syndrome element may appear in many syndromes,every syndrome element has different importance to different syndromes.This research statistics the syndrome element using the qualitative analysis、quantitative analysis and the content analysis methods,sorting to every syndrome elements by the frequency of occurrence,according to the clinical experience,as well as after the topic core group discussion.Most chief symptomes come from the top three syndrome elements.Secondary symptomes come from the syndrome elements in the top ten.
3.The chief symptomes and secondary symptomes of the main syndromes and accompanied with syndromes of the menopause syndromes.
(1) The kidney deficiency of yang
Chief symptomes:fear cold and member cold:clear abundant urine and frequent urination at night:listlessness,secondary symptomes:swollen face and limbs;loose stool;cold pain in back and abdomen,bad appetite,epigastric distension and depression,waist and knee acidum weak.
(2) Deficiency of kidney-YIN
Chief symptomes:hectic fever and perspiration;burning sensation of five centres;dizzy;secondary symptomes:sibilismus aurium;waist and knee acidum weak;constipation;the skin itches dryly;Dry mouth;insomnia and multi-dreams; perturbed and irritability。
(3) The kidney Yin and Yang deficiency
Chief symptomes:dizzy;sibilismus aurium;hectic fever and perspiration; secondary symptomes:fear cold and member cold;waist and knee acidum weak, loss of memory,waist and psychroalgia.
(4) Failure of the heart and kidney integrating
Chief symptomes:insomnia and multi-dreams;palpitation;perturbed and irritability;secondary symptomes:loss of memory;waist and knee acidum weak; dizzy;sibilismus aurium;hectic fever and perspiration;
(5) Hepatic and renal yin deficiency
Chief symptomes:dizzy;sibilismus aurium;hectic fever and perspiration; secondary symptomes:waist and knee acidum weak;burning sensation of five centres.
(6) Syndrome spleen and kidney deficiency of yang
Chief symptomes:bad appetite;loose stool;swollen face and limbs; secondary symptomes:fear cold and member cold;weary and hypodynamia; clear abundant urine and frequent urination at night;abdominal distension; dizzy;waist and knee acidum weak.
(7) Stagnation of liver-QI
Chief symptomes:deprementia or sensitivity sentimentality;hypochondrium distending pain;secondary symptomes:hectic fever and perspiration;chest feels tight and sigh;insomnia and multi-dreams,breast distending pain.
(8) Qi-stagnancy and blood stasis
Chief symptome:purple toung or ecchymosis;secondary symptomes:distention and pain of head;insomnia and dreamful sleep.
(9)Type of stagnation of phlegm-damp
Chief symptomes:puffiness of face;secondary symptomes:hectic fever and perspiration;chest distress and restlessness;dizzy;thickly furred and Slippery Nipple.
4.Initially construct a model of menopausal syndrome rating scale of disease and syndrome
The rating scale model can reflect the change of the pattern syndromes and the syndrome characteristic,it can reflect the change of the soft indicator such as sensation of oneself、physiologic function、role function and mental health and so on.
Conclusion:
The syndromes shoule have standardization and the objectification,the standardization and the objectification of the syndromes are the basic of establishing the Chinese medicine clinical curative effect system.We should study the clinical curative effect of TCM basic on the syndromes.This research summarizes the syndromes in many literatures,reference the formerly epidemic investigation result,and study syndromes classifieation and syndrome elements using qualitative and quantitate analysis.Study the item with syndrome connotation standardizedly and scientificly.Construct a menopausal syndrome rating scale of disease and syndrome model which is consonant with the characteristics of TCM.
本研究以绝经综合征为疾病载体进行中医药疗效评价方法学的探讨。在中医理论指导下,立足于中医学基本特点和优势,引入和应用内容分析法、心理测量学、临床流行病学和循证医学等科研方法,建立符合中医诊疗特色的绝经综合征病证评定量表,把不同证型模块整合到评定量表中,以期客观评价中医药的临床疗效。
研究方法及内容:
研究内容及方法:在国家科技部“十五”攻关项目研制的绝经综合征评定量表(CMRS)基础上针对绝经综合征病证特点,引入内容分析法,对绝经综合征中医辨证分型文献进行初步研究,归纳分析绝经综合征的主要证型,提取主症及次症等组成证型模块,将其整合到既往研究绝经综合征评定量表中,初步形成绝经综合征病证评定量表的条目池,形成具有辨证内涵的绝经综合征疗效评价量表的初步理论模型。选择小样本绝经综合征患者进行预调查,对调查结果采用条目分布考察法、相关分析法、t检验法、分辨力系数法等考察量表条目敏感性、重要性、代表性和区分性,使之能够更好地反应临床疗效。
主要研究结果:
1.基于内容分析法对绝经综合征证型研究
(1)证型归纳的结果
纳入研究的教材、专著、期刊文献共111篇。在所有的文献中初步采集到的各种按照不同术语表述的证型有74个。应用内容分析法,根据证候的命名和证候的分类原则,将证型本质相同而表述名称不同的证型合并后得到36个证型。对这36个证型在111篇文献中出现的频数和频率进行统计分析,频率大于25%的证型有6个:肾阳虚73.87%;肾阴虚65.77%,肾阴阳两虚46.85%,心肾不交36.64%,肝肾阴虚36.04%,脾肾阳虚28.83%。对以上的6个证型的证素的应用内容分析法进行定量统计分析。绝经综合征常因脏腑功能失调出现痰湿、瘀血、气郁等兼夹证,本研究中肝郁频率为21.62%,痰湿阻滞8.11%,气滞血瘀8.11%。
(2)绝经综合征的证候模块
在中医的理论中,人体是一个整体,阴阳是整体中的最基本的两个属性,阴阳平衡是健康的基本要求。绝经综合征出现率大于25%的6个证型中,可按照阴阳属性其分为三个证候模块。肾阴虚、肝肾阴虚、心肾不交具有阴虚的共性,组成阴虚模块;肾阳虚、脾肾阳虚具有阳虚的共性,组成阳虚模块,肾阴阳两虚为阴阳两虚模块。
2.基于内容分析法对绝经综合征证素的研究
(1)肾阳虚证
111篇文献中,有65篇文献包括肾阳虚证的详细证素描述,共40个证素。频率大于50%的证素有9个,分别为畏寒肢冷(96.92%),舌淡(86.15%),小便清长或夜尿频多(86.15%),精神萎靡(78.46%),面浮肢肿(73.85%),便溏(70.77%),面色晦黯(69.23%),腰腹冷痛(61.54%),脉沉细无力(58.46%)。
(2)肾阴虚证
有62篇文献包括肾阴虚证素的详细描述,共35个证素。频率大于50%的证素有14个证素,分别为舌苔少(96.77%),潮热汗出(96.77%),舌质红(95.16%),头晕(93.55%),脉细数(91.94%),五心烦热(91.94%),耳鸣(90.32%),腰膝酸软(83.87%),经色鲜红(62.90%),大便干结(61.29%),口干(58.06%),皮肤干痒(56.45%),尿少色黄(53.23%),失眠多梦(51.61%)。心烦易怒(35.48%),阴部干涩(13,20.97%),健忘(8,12.90%)。
(3)肾阴阳两虚证:
共38篇文献包括肾阴阳两虚证素的详细描述,共38个证素。频率大于50%的证素共7个,分别为耳鸣(38,100.00%),头晕(38,100.00%),潮热汗出(27,71.05%),畏寒(25,65.79%),舌淡(23,60.53%),腰膝酸软(23,60.53%),苔薄(20,52.63%)。
(4)心肾不交证:
共34篇文献包括心肾不交证素的详细描述,分为34个证素。频率大于50%的证素共有10个,分别为失眠多梦(33,97.06%),舌红(31,91.18%),心悸怔忡(29,85.29%),脉细数(27,79.41%),烦躁易怒(27,79.41%),健忘易惊(25,73.53%),心烦不宁(22,64.71%),苔少(19,55.88%),腰膝酸软(18,52.94%),头晕耳鸣(17,50.00%)。
(5)肝肾阴虚证:
有23篇文献包括肝肾阴虚证素的详细描述,共38个证素。频率大于50%的证素
共12个,分别为头晕(23,100.00%),舌红(22,95.65%),苔少(21,91.30%),耳鸣(19,82.61%),潮热汗出(18,78.26%),腰膝酸软(17,73.91%),五心烦热(17,73.91%),脉细数(14,60.87%),口干(14,60.87%),失眠多梦(13,56.52%),烦躁易怒(13,56.52%),便秘(12,52.17%)。
(6)脾肾阳虚证
有20篇文献包括脾肾阳虚证素的详细描述,共40个证素。频率大于50%的证素
共有10个,分别为便溏(19,95.00%),纳呆(18,90.00%),面浮肢肿(16,80.00%),畏寒肢冷(14,70.00%),腰背冷痛(13,65.00%),神疲乏力(12,60.00%),脉沉细(10,50.00%),苔薄白(10,50.00%),舌淡胖有齿印(10,50.00%),夜尿频多(10,50.00%)。
(7)肝郁证
有17篇文献包括肝郁证证素的详细描述,共33个证素。频率大于50%的证素共有7个,分别为精神抑郁多愁易怒(17,100.00%),胁肋胀痛(16,94.12%),苔薄黄(11,64.71%),舌红(11,64.71%),潮热汗出(11,64.71%),胸闷叹息(11,64.71%),苔薄白(9,52.94%)。
(8)气滞血瘀证
有7篇文献包括气滞血瘀证素的详细描述,共29个证素。舌质紫黯或有瘀斑的出现率最高(5,71.43%),周身刺痛(3,42.86%)、胸胁刺痛(3,42.86%)、胸闷痹痛(3,42.86%)出现频率也较高。
(9)痰湿阻滞证
有5篇文献包括痰湿阻滞证素的详细描述,共20个证素。苔厚腻湿滑(5,60.00%)的出现率较高,颜面浮肿(5,100.00%)出现率高。
不同证型的证素不尽相同,同一个证素可见于多个证型中,各证素对该证型的重要性都不同。本研究应用内容分析法对111篇绝经综合征文献的主要证型的证素进行了定性分析和定量统计,对各证型证素的频率进行排序,结合临床经验以及经过课题核心小组讨论后,主症主要提取自频率排前3位的证素中,次症主要提取自频率位于第4至第10位的证素中。
3.绝经综合征主要证型及兼央证的主症和次症
(1)肾阳虚证:
主症3个,畏寒肢冷、小便清长或夜尿频多、精神萎靡;次症6个,面浮肢肿、便溏、腰腹冷痛、纳少、脘腹胀满、腰膝酸软。
(2)肾阴虚证:
主症有3个,潮热汗出、头晕、五心烦热;次症有7个,耳鸣、腰膝酸软、大便干结、口干、皮肤干痒、失眠多梦及心烦易怒。
(3)肾阴阳两虚证:
主症有3个,分别为耳鸣、头晕、潮热汗出;次症有4个,分别为畏寒、腰膝酸软、腰背冷痛和健忘。
(4)心肾不交证:
主症有3个,分别为失眠多梦、心悸、烦躁易怒;次症有5个,分别为健忘、腰膝酸软、头晕、耳鸣、潮热汗出。
(5)肝肾阴虚证:
主症有3个,分别为头晕、耳鸣、潮热汗出;次症有6个,分别为腰膝酸软、五心烦热、口干、失眠多梦、烦躁易怒、便秘。
(6)脾肾阳虚证:
主症有3个,分别为便溏、纳呆、面浮肢肿;次症有6个,分别为畏寒肢冷、神疲乏力、夜尿频多、脘腹胀满、头晕、腰膝酸软。
(7)肝郁证:
主症有2个,分别为精神抑郁多愁易怒和胁肋胀痛;次症有4个,分别为潮热汗出、胸闷叹息、失眠多梦、乳房胀痛。
(8)气滞血瘀证:
主症1个,为舌质紫黯或有瘀斑,次症2个,头胀痛、失眠多梦。
(9)痰湿阻滞证:
主症1个:颜面浮肿,次症4个,分别为潮热汗出、胸闷烦躁、头晕、苔厚腻湿滑。
4.初步形成绝经综合征病证评定量表的模型
该量表模型能体现中医证候类型及变化特点,能反映中医药治疗后患者自我感觉、生理功能、角色功能、心理健康等软指标的改变。
结论:
证候标准化和客观化,是建立客观规范的中医临床疗效评价体系的必要前提。对于中医药的疗效评价的研究,应该是在证候内涵的基础上进行。本研究通过结合既往流行性调查及绝经综合征证候文献研究结果,探索对绝经综合征证型的分类及证素的定性定量研究,对具有证候内涵的疗效评价量表条目进行更加规范化和科学化的研究,形成符合中医证候特点的绝经综合征病证评定量表模型。
Purposes of Research:
With the menopausalsyndrome to be a carrier,we try to explorate the methodology of the TCM evaluation of therapeutic efficiency.According to the theory of chinese medicine,basic on the characteristic and advantage of TCM, using content analysis method,psychometrics,clinical epidemiology and evidence based medicine,construct a rating scale of menopausal syndrome with disease and combinated syndrome which is consonant with the diagnosing and curate characteristics of TCM.we consider to bring different syndromes module to the rating scale,expect to evaluate the curative effect of TCM objectively.
Research methods and content:
Base on the Chinese Menopause Rating Scale(CMRS) which was construct in the "fifteenth" critical project of the National Science and Technology Development,we study the the Chinese Menopause syndromes literature with the TCM differentiation of symptoms and signs for classification of syndrome, using content analysis methods.Study Menopause syndromes literature which come from monograph,teaching material and medicine magazine with the differentation of every type syndromes of menopausal syndrome,sum up and analysis the main syndromes,extract the chief and secondary symptom to compose the symptom-complex module,and add them to the menopausal syndrome rating scale of disease and syndrom.The item pool of the rating scale is initial formation.The initial theory module of evaluate the TCM curative effect with differentiation of syndromes is constructed.We chose some menopausal syndrome patients to carry out the investigation in advance in the chinic.Inspect the senstinve,importantance,representation and distinguish using the surveying distribution of items methods,discrete method,correlational analysis method、t test method、resolving power coefficient method method and make it to reflect the curative effect well.
Main results:
1.Preliminary study on TCM literature relative to menopausal syndromes,using the content anylysis method.
(1)The main syndromes of the menopausal syndrome.
Totally 111 pieces of TCM literature relative to menopause syndrome were evolved in the study.There are 74 kinds of syndromes initially extract from all literatures.There are many syndromes which has the same essence but with different terminology name.According to the essence of the syndromes and the standard of differention of syndromes,we carry on the analysis of the 74 kinds syndromes and obtain 36 kinds of syndromes.
We statistic the frequency of the 36 kinds of syndromes.There 6 syndromes whose frequency are higher than 25%.The kidney deficiency of yang syndrome appears 82 times(73.87%);73pieces literatures includ the kidney Yin deficient(65.77%);52 pieces literatures includ the kidney Yin and Yang deficiency(46.85%);44 pieces literatures includ type of failure of the heart and kidney integrating syndromes(36.64%);40 pieces literatures includ hepatic and renal yin deficiency(36.04%);32 pieces literatures includ the spleen kidney deficiency of yang(28.83%).We statistic the syndrome elements of the above syndromes using the content analysis,including the quantitative analysis and qualitative analysis.The menopause syndrome usually has companying with syndromes because the malfunction of zangfu organs.The main companying with syndromes are stagnation of liver-QI(21.62%),type of stagnation of phlegm-damp(8.11%)、qi-stagnancy and blood stasis(8.11%)。
(2) the syndrom module of menopause syndrome
The general idea is the basic in TCM theory and the human body is a whole.Yin and Yang are the two basic attributes in the whole body.a balance of Yin and Yang is the basic request of the body health,we split the main 6 sundromes of menopause syndrome according to the Yin and Yang attributes. Deficiency of kidney-YIN、hepatic and renal yin deficiency and failure of the heart and kidney integrating make up of the Yin deficiency module;The kidney deficiency of yang、the spleen kidney deficiency of yang make up of the Yang deficiency module;the kidney Yin and Yang deficiency is in the Yin and Yang deficiency module.
2.Study the syndrome elements of all kinds syndromes of MS using the content analysis method.
(1) Kidney deficiency of yang
There are 65literatures describe the kidney deficiency of yang' s syndrome elements,altogether 40 syndrome elements.The syndrome elements whose frequency are bigger than 50%are as follows,such as fear cold and member cold(96.92%);pale tongue(86.15%);clear abundant urineand Frequent urination at night(86.15%);listlessness(78.46%);swollenface and limbs(73.85%); loose stool(70.77%);laepcumx complexion(69.23%);waist abdomen cold pain (61.54%);deep or thready weak pulse(58.46%).
(2) Deficiency of kidney-YIN
There are 62 literatures describe the kidney Yin deficient' s syndrome elements,altogether 35 syndrome elements.The syndrome elements whose frequency are bigger than 50%are as follows,14 syndrome elements in total, such as tongue coating few(96.77%);hectic fever and perspiration(96.77%); red tongue(95.16%);dizzy(93.55%);thready and rapid pulse(91.94%);burning sensation of five centres(91.94%);sibilismus aurium(90.32%);waist and knee acidum weak(83.87%);menses blood colour bright red(62.90%);constipation (61.29%);Dry mouth(58.06%);the skin itches dryly(56.45%).
(3) The kidney Yin and Yang deficiency
There are 38 literatures describe the kidney Yin and Yang deficiency' s syndrome elements,altogether 38 syndrome elements.The syndrome elements whose frequency are bigger than 50%are as follows,7 syndrome elements in total, such assibilismus aurium(100.00%);dizzy(100.00%);hectic fever and perspiration(71.05%);hot and cold by turns(65.79%);pale tongue(60.53 %);waist and knee acidum weak(60.53%);tongue coating thinness(52.63 %)。
(4) Failure of the heart and kidney integrating
There are 34 literatures describe the failure of the heart and kidney integratings syndrome elements,altogether 34 syndrome elements.The syndrome elements whose frequency are bigger than 50%are as follows,10 syndrome elements in total,such as insomnia and multi-dreams(97.06%);red tongue (91.18%);palpitation(85.29%);thready and rapid pulse(79.41%);perturbed and irritability(79.41%);loss of memory(73.5%);perturbed(64.71%),tongue coating few(55.88%),waist and knee acidum weak(52.94%),dizzy and sibilismus aurium(50.00%)。
(5) Hepatic and renal yin deficiency
There are 23literatures describe hepatic and renal yin deficiency' s syndrome elements,altogether 38 syndrome elements.The syndrome elements whose frequency are bigger than 50%are as follows,12 syndrome elements in total, such as dizzy(100.00%);red tongue(95.65%);tongue coating few(91.30 %);sibilismus aurium(82.61%);hectic fever and perspiration(78.26%); waist and knee acidum weak(73.91%);burning sensation of five centres(73.91 %);thready and rapid pulse(60.87%);Dry mouth(60.87%);insomnia and multi-dreams(56.52%);perturbed and irritability(56.52%);constipation (52.17%)。
(6) The spleen and kidney deficiency of yang
There are 20 literatures describe the spleen kidney deficiency of yang' s syndrome elements,altogether 40 syndrome elements.The syndrome elements whose frequency are bigger than 50%are as follows,loose stool(95.00%),bad appetite (90.00%),swollen face and limbs(80.00%);fear cold and member cold(70.00 %);weary and hypodynamia(60.00%);deep or thready pulse(50.00%);tongue coating thin and white(50.00%);pale tongue and imprints of the teeth(50.00 %);clear abundant urineand Frequent urination at night(50.00%)。
(7) Syndrome of stagnation of liver-QI
There are 17 literatures describe stagnation of liver-QI' s syndrome elements,altogether 33 syndrome elements.The syndrome elements whose frequency are bigger than 50%are as follows,deprementia or sensitivity sentimentality(100.00%);hypochondrium distending pain(94.12%);thin and yellow coating(64.71%);red tongue(64.71%);hectic fever and perspiration (64.71%).
(8) Qi-stagnancy and blood stasis
There are 7 literatures describe qi-stagnancy and blood stasis' s syndrome elements,altogether 29 syndrome elements.The syndrome elements whose frequency are bigger than 50%are as follows,1 syndrome elements in total, such aspurple toung or ecchymosis(71.43%).
(9) Type of stagnation of phlegm-damp
There are 5 literatures describe type of stagnation of phlegm-damp' s syndrome elements,altogether 20 syndrome elements.The syndrome elements whose frequency are bigger than 50%are as follows,2syndrome elements in total, such asthickly furred and Slippery Nipple(60.00%);swollen face and limbs (100.00%).
Different syndroms' element are different,a syndrome element may appear in many syndromes,every syndrome element has different importance to different syndromes.This research statistics the syndrome element using the qualitative analysis、quantitative analysis and the content analysis methods,sorting to every syndrome elements by the frequency of occurrence,according to the clinical experience,as well as after the topic core group discussion.Most chief symptomes come from the top three syndrome elements.Secondary symptomes come from the syndrome elements in the top ten.
3.The chief symptomes and secondary symptomes of the main syndromes and accompanied with syndromes of the menopause syndromes.
(1) The kidney deficiency of yang
Chief symptomes:fear cold and member cold:clear abundant urine and frequent urination at night:listlessness,secondary symptomes:swollen face and limbs;loose stool;cold pain in back and abdomen,bad appetite,epigastric distension and depression,waist and knee acidum weak.
(2) Deficiency of kidney-YIN
Chief symptomes:hectic fever and perspiration;burning sensation of five centres;dizzy;secondary symptomes:sibilismus aurium;waist and knee acidum weak;constipation;the skin itches dryly;Dry mouth;insomnia and multi-dreams; perturbed and irritability。
(3) The kidney Yin and Yang deficiency
Chief symptomes:dizzy;sibilismus aurium;hectic fever and perspiration; secondary symptomes:fear cold and member cold;waist and knee acidum weak, loss of memory,waist and psychroalgia.
(4) Failure of the heart and kidney integrating
Chief symptomes:insomnia and multi-dreams;palpitation;perturbed and irritability;secondary symptomes:loss of memory;waist and knee acidum weak; dizzy;sibilismus aurium;hectic fever and perspiration;
(5) Hepatic and renal yin deficiency
Chief symptomes:dizzy;sibilismus aurium;hectic fever and perspiration; secondary symptomes:waist and knee acidum weak;burning sensation of five centres.
(6) Syndrome spleen and kidney deficiency of yang
Chief symptomes:bad appetite;loose stool;swollen face and limbs; secondary symptomes:fear cold and member cold;weary and hypodynamia; clear abundant urine and frequent urination at night;abdominal distension; dizzy;waist and knee acidum weak.
(7) Stagnation of liver-QI
Chief symptomes:deprementia or sensitivity sentimentality;hypochondrium distending pain;secondary symptomes:hectic fever and perspiration;chest feels tight and sigh;insomnia and multi-dreams,breast distending pain.
(8) Qi-stagnancy and blood stasis
Chief symptome:purple toung or ecchymosis;secondary symptomes:distention and pain of head;insomnia and dreamful sleep.
(9)Type of stagnation of phlegm-damp
Chief symptomes:puffiness of face;secondary symptomes:hectic fever and perspiration;chest distress and restlessness;dizzy;thickly furred and Slippery Nipple.
4.Initially construct a model of menopausal syndrome rating scale of disease and syndrome
The rating scale model can reflect the change of the pattern syndromes and the syndrome characteristic,it can reflect the change of the soft indicator such as sensation of oneself、physiologic function、role function and mental health and so on.
Conclusion:
The syndromes shoule have standardization and the objectification,the standardization and the objectification of the syndromes are the basic of establishing the Chinese medicine clinical curative effect system.We should study the clinical curative effect of TCM basic on the syndromes.This research summarizes the syndromes in many literatures,reference the formerly epidemic investigation result,and study syndromes classifieation and syndrome elements using qualitative and quantitate analysis.Study the item with syndrome connotation standardizedly and scientificly.Construct a menopausal syndrome rating scale of disease and syndrome model which is consonant with the characteristics of TCM.
引文
[1]张雅鸥,肖培根.补充和替代医学的发展现状[J].世界科学技术:中药现代化.2002,4(004):24-31.
[2]黄欣.WHO对传统医学的研究与评价方法论的限定草案[J].国外医学:中医中药分册.1999,21(004):58-64.
[3]商洪才,王保和,张伯礼.中药新药证候及疗效评价[J].中药新药与临床药理.2004,15(005):365-368.
[4]来佩琍.妇科疾病诊断标准[Z].北京:科学出版社,2001.
[5]Faure E D,Chantre P,Mares P.Effects of a standardized soy extract on hot flushes:a multicenter,double-blind,randomized,placebo-controlled study.[J].Menopause.2002,9(5):329.
[6]冯异,田占庄,陈伯英.围绝经期和抑郁症[J].国外医学:妇幼保健分册.2004,15(004):235-236.
[7]Li S,Holm K,Gulanick M,et al.Perimenopause and the quality of life[J].Clinical Nursing Research.2000,9(1):6.
[8]邓小虹,张淞文.北京地区围绝经期妇女健康现状的流行病学调查[J].北京医学.2002,24(004):235-238.
[9]李凤云,李立凤,朱秀琼,等.社区妇女围绝经期综合征患病与治疗现状[J].现代预防医学.2007,34(020):3967-3969.
[10]徐苓,赵珩.围绝经期的流行病学调查[J].生殖医学杂志.1993,2(001):23-27.
[11]黄薇,彭伟,吴艳乔,等.成都市围绝经期妇女生殖健康状况的现状调查[J].四川大学学报:医学版.2003,34(003):536-538.
[12]陆洪波,杨晓钊.南宁市妇女围绝经期综合征流行病学调查研究[J].广西医科大学学报.2001,18(005):761-763.
[13]张剑萍,李芬,盛秋,等.西安市高校女教师围绝经期综合征患病状况调查[J].中国老年学杂志.2008,28(003):286-288.
[14]程颖莲,莫端豪,练坚贞,等.社区妇女围绝经期综合征流行病学调查[J].中国妇幼保健.2007,22(015):2110-2112.
[15]卫生部继续医学教育委员会.女性生殖内分泌性激素补充疗法[M].北京医科大学,中国协和医科大学联合出版社,1999.
[16]王鑫,唐亮,何平.组织选择性雌激素活性调节剂辅助钙剂治疗绝经后骨质疏松症[J].中国妇幼保健.2008,23(011):1535-1536.
[17]陈子江,唐蓉,张中和.组织选择性雌激素活性调节剂和选择性雌激素受体调节剂的临床应用[J].中国实用妇科与产科杂志.2004,20(008):470-472.
[18]黄志军,沈守荣,袁洪.激素替代治疗对绝经妇女心脏保护效应的重新认识[J].医学与哲学:临床决策论坛版.2008,29(008):50-51.
[19]尚娟.激素替代疗法与冠心病预防[J].中华医学实践杂志.2006,5(12).
[20]林晶,孙晓波.更年期综合征激素替代治疗39例分析[J].
[21]石艳清,王爱玲,程建新,等.激素替代治疗更年期综合征的临床研究[J].实用医技杂志.2007,14(012):1595-1596.
[22]Home C R.Risks and benefits of estrogen plus progestin in healthy postmenopausal women,principal results from the women's health initiative randomized controlled trial☆[J].JAMA.2002,288:321-333.
[23]Beral V,Banks E,Reeves G,et al.Breast cancer and hormone-replacement therapy:the Million Women Study[J].The Lancet.2003,362(9392):1330-1331.
[24]Anderson G L,Limacher M,Assaf A R,et al.Effects of conjugated equine estrogen in postmenopausal women with hysterectomy:the Women's Health Initiative randomized controlled trial[J].Family Medicine.2004.
[25]郑峥,罗辉兰,谢梅青.激素替代治疗对绝经后妇女乳腺密度的影响--附150例分析[J].新医学.2008,39(004):222-224.
[26]杨淑臻,杨志丽.围绝经期综合征激素替代疗法的利与弊[J].
[27]韩志勤.激素替代治疗对更年期综合征患者心理因素的影响[J].中国医药导报.2008,5(001):153-154.
[28]姜宁,陈执中.一种新的饮食补充剂总状升麻提取物的研究与应用进展[J].食品与药品.2006,8(02A):28-30.
[29]黄雪卿.更年期综合征病人的护理指导[J].中国医药杂志.2004,1(003):174-175.
[30]郭开平,苏宜香.大豆异黄酮对绝经后妇女雌激素相关疾病影响研究进展[J].大豆科学.2008,27(002):331-333.
[31]高俊涛,赵春燕,宫丹.大豆异黄酮的研究进展[J].吉林医药学院学报.2005,26(1).
[32]Kass-annese B,Rncnp M S.Alternative therapies for menopause.[J].Clinical Obstetrics and Gynecology.2000,43(1):162.
[33]Hsieh C Y,Santell R C,Haslam S Z,et al.Estrogenic effects of genistein on the growth of estrogen receptor-positive human breast cancer (MCF-7) cells in vitro and in vivo.[J].Cancer research.1998,58(17):3833.
[34]AllredC D,Allred K F,Ju YH,et al.Soy processing influences growth of estrogen-dependent breast cancer tumors[J].Carcinogenesis.2004,25(9):1649.
[35]肖硕.大豆异黄酮与乳腺癌关系研究进展*[J].中国公共卫生.2008,24(5).
[36]Amato P,Marcus D M.Review of alternative therapies for treatment of menopausal symptoms[J].Climacteric.2003,6(4):278-284.
[37]Nedrow A,Miller J,Walker M,et al.Complementary and alternative therapies for the management of menopause-related symptoms:a systematic evidence review[]].Archives of Internal Medicine.2006,166(14):1453.
[38]姚乃礼.中医证候鉴别诊断学[Z].北京:人民卫生出版社,2002.
[39]朱文锋,黄碧群,陈新宇.病性证素辨别的意义与方法[J].中医药学刊.2006,24(002):204-205.
[40]赵晖,吴崇胜,陈家旭.中医证候诊断标准研究的方法学探讨[J].上海中医药大学学报.2008,22(004):47-50.
[41]朱文锋.构建“证素辨证”新体系的意义[J].浙江中医药大学学报.2006,30(002):135-136.
[42]张志斌,王永炎,吕爱平,et al.论证候要素与证候靶点应证组合辨证[J].中医杂志.2006,47(007):483-485.
[43]朱文锋,刘莺.病证症相结合的中医诊疗体系[J].北京中医药大学学报.1999,22(006):2-4.
[44]张志斌.现代证候概念研究发展趋势[J].山西中医学院学报.2006(01).
[45]封静,张志斌.现代证候概念研究发展趋势[J].山西中医学院学报.2006,7(001):54-56.
[46]张志斌,王永炎.证候名称及分类研究的回顾与假设的提出[J].北京中医药大学学报.2003,26(002):1-5.
[47]邓中炎.关于证候概念的探讨[J].广西中医药.1992,15(005):35-37.
[48]黎敬波,朱文锋.辨证规范化的难点和途径[J].医学与哲学.1995,16(012):645-646.
[49]王忠,王阶.后基因组时代中医证候组学研究的思考[J].中国中西医结合杂志.2001,21(008):621-623.
[50]申维玺.论中医“证”的现代医学属性和概念[J].中医杂志.2001,42(005):307-309.
[51]白云静,申洪波,孟庆刚,等.中医证候复杂性特征及证候研究思路探析[J].中国中医药信息杂志.2004,11(009):754-756.
[52]Greene J G.Constructing a standard climacteric scale[J].Maturitas.2008,61(1-2):78-84.
[53]王天芳,吴秀艳,赵燕,等.临床常见疾病中医证候要素分布特点的文献研究[J].中华中医药杂志.2007,22(009):594-597.
[54]陈淑慧,梁伟雄.浅谈中医证候疗效指标在中医临床疗效评价体系中的应用[J].新中医.2008,40(006):113-115.
[55]朱文锋.中医诊断学[J].中医教育.2002,21(006):39-40.
[56]申定珠,李家邦,蒋荣鑫,et al.证候蛋白质组学与中医证候学相关性探讨[J].中国中西医结合杂志.2006,26(004):366-368.
[57]周忠科,刘家强,王米渠.中医证候基因组学研究的探讨[J].中华中医药学刊.2008,26(004):826-827.
[58]汤朝晖,李炜弘,严石林,等.老龄肾阳虚证的差异表达基因谱研究的意义探讨[J].辽宁中医杂志.2008,35(002):311-313.
[59]Holsti O R.Content analysis for the social sciences and humanities[M].Addison-Wesley Reading,MA,1969.
[60]Ryan G W,Bernard H R.Data management and analysis methods[J].Handbook of qualitative research.2000,2:769-802.
[61]歐用生.開放社會的教育改革[M].心理 薹北市,1992.
[62]黄志澄.以人为主,人机结合,从定性到定量的综合集成法[J].西安交通大学学报:社会科学版.2005,25(002):55-59.
[63]张海男,罗建清.抑郁症常见中医证候类型第一轮专家问卷分析[J].湖南医科大学学报.2002,27(006):519-521.
[64]王儒飞,陈涌.中药“四气”定性分析法初探[J].中医杂志.1991,32(005):9-11.
[65]于河,刘建平.定性研究方法及其在医学领域内的应用[J].循证医学.2008,8(5).
[66]刘庆,岳小强,邓伟哲,等.应用舌诊综合信息分析系统对原发性肝癌舌质颜色的定量分析[J].中西医结合学报.2003,1(003):180-183.
[67]卫保国,沈兰荪.数字化中医舌象分析仪[J].中国医疗器械杂志.2002,26(003):164-166.
[68]翁维良,黄世敬.中医舌诊客观化研究[J].中国工程科学.2001,3(001):78-82.
[69]赵爱光,杨金坤.脾虚与胃癌发生,发展的相关性研究[J].上海中医药杂志.1998(005):10-12.
[70]梁茂新,洪治平.中医症状量化的方法初探:附虚证30症的量化法[J].中国医药学报.1994,9(003):37-39.
[71]陈启光,申春悌,张华强,等.因子分析在中医证候规范标准研究中的应 用[J].中国中医基础医学杂志.2004,10(008):53-56.
[72]Weaver T,Renton A,Tyrer P,et al.Combining qualitative studies with randomised controlled trials is often useful.[J].BMJ:British Medical Journal.1996,313(7057):629.
[73]Schumacher K L,Koresawa S,West C,et al.Qualitative research contribution to a randomized clinical trial[J].Research in nursing & health.2005,28(3):268-280.
[74]马文峰.试析内容分析法在社科情报学中的应用[J].情报科学.2000,18(004):346-349.
[75]邱均平,邹菲.国外内容分析法的研究概况及进展[J].图书情报知识.2003(006):6-8.
[76]宋旭昌.2007年iSchool科研热点分析[J].情报探索.2008(009):118-121.
[77]卢家婧.基于内容分析法的中美大学教学质量评价比较研究[J].继续教育研究.2008(005):87-89.
[78]曹琴仙,于淼.基于内容分析法的专利文献应用研究[J].现代情报.2007,27(012):147-150.
[79]Taylor R.Slain and Slandered:A Content Analysis of the Portrayal of Femicide in Crime News[J].Homicide Studies.2009,13(1):21.
[80]Lock M.Menopause in cultural context[J].Experimental gerontology.1994,29(3-4):307-317.
[81]Wiklund I.Methods of assessing the impact of climacteric complaints on quality of life:Methodological issues in menopause research[J].Maturitas(Amsterdam).1998,29(1):41-50.
[82]Mccoy N L.Methodological problems in the study of sexuality and the menopause:Methodological issues in menopause research[J].Maturitas(Amsterdam).1998,29(I):51-60.
[83]Dennerstein L,SmithAM,Morse C.Psychological well-being,mid-life and the menopause.[J].Maturitas.1994,20(1):1.
[84]Greene J G.Constructing a standard climacteric scale[J].Maturitas.2008,61(1-2):78-84.
[85]樊长征,焉石,李友林,等.基于形神一体观的疾病疗效评价指标研究思路探讨[J].中华现代中医学杂志.2008,4(1).
[86]杨定海.对现行医学模式的一点补充--基于非典疫情的思考[J].医学与社会.2004,17(002):27-28.
[87]许军.健康评价[J].国外医学:社会医学分册.1999,16(001):1-3.
[88]Farnik-brodzi M,Pierzcha W.The value of studies of quality of life in chronic respiratory tract diseases in the framework of holistic medicine[J].Wiadomo?ci lekarskie(Warsaw,Poland:1960).1998,51(7-8):316.
[89]赖世隆.中医药临床疗效评价若干关键环节的思考[J].广州中医药大学学报.2002,19(004):245-250.
[90]聂广宁,王小云,杨洪艳.中医药治疗更年期综合征的疗效评价现状[J].中华实用中西医杂志.2005,18(010):1544-1546.
[91]聂广宁,王小云,杨洪艳.中医药治疗更年期综合征随机对照试验文献的质量评价[J].中医药学刊.2005,23(011):2014-2016.
[92]于春泉,马寰,宫涛,等.量表学在中医证候研究中的应用探讨[J].辽宁中医杂志.2006,33(007):797-798.
[93]郭新峰,赖世隆。中医药临床疗效评价中结局指标的选择与应用[J].广州中医药大学学报.2002,19(004):251-255.
[94]平凡.中医药在美国[J].食品与药品.2005,7(02A):75-76.
[95]Mahady G B,Dog T L,Barrett M L,et al.United States Pharmacopeia review of the black cohosh case reports of hepatotoxicity.[J].Menopause.2008,15(4):628.
[96]赖世隆,郭新峰,梁伟雄,等.中风病疗效评价指标体系的初步研究[J].中国中西医结合杂志.2004,24(003):197-201.
[97]刘凤斌,方积乾,王建华.中医药临床疗效评价的探讨[J].中药新药与临床药理.2004,15(004):290-292.
[98]刘凤斌,赵利.建立中医疗效测评量表体系研究的设想[J].中国临床康复.2004,8(001):164-165.
[99]吴大嵘,杨小波,赖世隆.中医药研究中软指标测量工具的建立和应用探讨[J].中国中西医结合杂志.2006,26(004):293-297.
[100]王小云,聂广宁,杨洪艳,等.中医药治疗绝经综合征的临床证据[J].中国循证医学杂志.2007,7(009):685-689.
[101]刘雅芳,程伟.面对“告别中医药”[J].医学与哲学:人文社会医学版.2007,28(001):71-71.
[102]杨洪艳,王小云,聂广宁,等.绝经综合征疗效评定量表构建思路和循证研究探讨[J].循证医学.2007,7(3).
[103]郭新峰,朱泉,赖世隆.替代指标和中间指标及其在中医药疗效评价研究中应用价值的思考[J].中国中西医结合杂志.2005,25(007):585-590.
[104]朱文锋,张华敏.“证素”的基本特征[J].中国中医基础医学杂志.2005,11(001):17-18.
[105]姚乃礼.中医症状鉴别诊断学[Z].北京:人民卫生出版社,2000.
[106]陈可冀,宋军.病证结合的临床研究是中西医结合研究的重要模式[J].世界科学技术:中医药现代化.2006,8(002):1-5.
[107]刘平.病-证-效[J].结合研究的思考与探索[期刊论文]-中西医结合心脑血管病杂志.2007.
[108]李先涛,张伯礼.证候诊断标准研究的迫切性和可行性[J].天津中医药.2007,24(001):36-38.
[109]梁晓春.循证医学与中医临床疗效评价[J].中华全科医师杂志.2004,3(001):7-9.
[2]黄欣.WHO对传统医学的研究与评价方法论的限定草案[J].国外医学:中医中药分册.1999,21(004):58-64.
[3]商洪才,王保和,张伯礼.中药新药证候及疗效评价[J].中药新药与临床药理.2004,15(005):365-368.
[4]来佩琍.妇科疾病诊断标准[Z].北京:科学出版社,2001.
[5]Faure E D,Chantre P,Mares P.Effects of a standardized soy extract on hot flushes:a multicenter,double-blind,randomized,placebo-controlled study.[J].Menopause.2002,9(5):329.
[6]冯异,田占庄,陈伯英.围绝经期和抑郁症[J].国外医学:妇幼保健分册.2004,15(004):235-236.
[7]Li S,Holm K,Gulanick M,et al.Perimenopause and the quality of life[J].Clinical Nursing Research.2000,9(1):6.
[8]邓小虹,张淞文.北京地区围绝经期妇女健康现状的流行病学调查[J].北京医学.2002,24(004):235-238.
[9]李凤云,李立凤,朱秀琼,等.社区妇女围绝经期综合征患病与治疗现状[J].现代预防医学.2007,34(020):3967-3969.
[10]徐苓,赵珩.围绝经期的流行病学调查[J].生殖医学杂志.1993,2(001):23-27.
[11]黄薇,彭伟,吴艳乔,等.成都市围绝经期妇女生殖健康状况的现状调查[J].四川大学学报:医学版.2003,34(003):536-538.
[12]陆洪波,杨晓钊.南宁市妇女围绝经期综合征流行病学调查研究[J].广西医科大学学报.2001,18(005):761-763.
[13]张剑萍,李芬,盛秋,等.西安市高校女教师围绝经期综合征患病状况调查[J].中国老年学杂志.2008,28(003):286-288.
[14]程颖莲,莫端豪,练坚贞,等.社区妇女围绝经期综合征流行病学调查[J].中国妇幼保健.2007,22(015):2110-2112.
[15]卫生部继续医学教育委员会.女性生殖内分泌性激素补充疗法[M].北京医科大学,中国协和医科大学联合出版社,1999.
[16]王鑫,唐亮,何平.组织选择性雌激素活性调节剂辅助钙剂治疗绝经后骨质疏松症[J].中国妇幼保健.2008,23(011):1535-1536.
[17]陈子江,唐蓉,张中和.组织选择性雌激素活性调节剂和选择性雌激素受体调节剂的临床应用[J].中国实用妇科与产科杂志.2004,20(008):470-472.
[18]黄志军,沈守荣,袁洪.激素替代治疗对绝经妇女心脏保护效应的重新认识[J].医学与哲学:临床决策论坛版.2008,29(008):50-51.
[19]尚娟.激素替代疗法与冠心病预防[J].中华医学实践杂志.2006,5(12).
[20]林晶,孙晓波.更年期综合征激素替代治疗39例分析[J].
[21]石艳清,王爱玲,程建新,等.激素替代治疗更年期综合征的临床研究[J].实用医技杂志.2007,14(012):1595-1596.
[22]Home C R.Risks and benefits of estrogen plus progestin in healthy postmenopausal women,principal results from the women's health initiative randomized controlled trial☆[J].JAMA.2002,288:321-333.
[23]Beral V,Banks E,Reeves G,et al.Breast cancer and hormone-replacement therapy:the Million Women Study[J].The Lancet.2003,362(9392):1330-1331.
[24]Anderson G L,Limacher M,Assaf A R,et al.Effects of conjugated equine estrogen in postmenopausal women with hysterectomy:the Women's Health Initiative randomized controlled trial[J].Family Medicine.2004.
[25]郑峥,罗辉兰,谢梅青.激素替代治疗对绝经后妇女乳腺密度的影响--附150例分析[J].新医学.2008,39(004):222-224.
[26]杨淑臻,杨志丽.围绝经期综合征激素替代疗法的利与弊[J].
[27]韩志勤.激素替代治疗对更年期综合征患者心理因素的影响[J].中国医药导报.2008,5(001):153-154.
[28]姜宁,陈执中.一种新的饮食补充剂总状升麻提取物的研究与应用进展[J].食品与药品.2006,8(02A):28-30.
[29]黄雪卿.更年期综合征病人的护理指导[J].中国医药杂志.2004,1(003):174-175.
[30]郭开平,苏宜香.大豆异黄酮对绝经后妇女雌激素相关疾病影响研究进展[J].大豆科学.2008,27(002):331-333.
[31]高俊涛,赵春燕,宫丹.大豆异黄酮的研究进展[J].吉林医药学院学报.2005,26(1).
[32]Kass-annese B,Rncnp M S.Alternative therapies for menopause.[J].Clinical Obstetrics and Gynecology.2000,43(1):162.
[33]Hsieh C Y,Santell R C,Haslam S Z,et al.Estrogenic effects of genistein on the growth of estrogen receptor-positive human breast cancer (MCF-7) cells in vitro and in vivo.[J].Cancer research.1998,58(17):3833.
[34]AllredC D,Allred K F,Ju YH,et al.Soy processing influences growth of estrogen-dependent breast cancer tumors[J].Carcinogenesis.2004,25(9):1649.
[35]肖硕.大豆异黄酮与乳腺癌关系研究进展*[J].中国公共卫生.2008,24(5).
[36]Amato P,Marcus D M.Review of alternative therapies for treatment of menopausal symptoms[J].Climacteric.2003,6(4):278-284.
[37]Nedrow A,Miller J,Walker M,et al.Complementary and alternative therapies for the management of menopause-related symptoms:a systematic evidence review[]].Archives of Internal Medicine.2006,166(14):1453.
[38]姚乃礼.中医证候鉴别诊断学[Z].北京:人民卫生出版社,2002.
[39]朱文锋,黄碧群,陈新宇.病性证素辨别的意义与方法[J].中医药学刊.2006,24(002):204-205.
[40]赵晖,吴崇胜,陈家旭.中医证候诊断标准研究的方法学探讨[J].上海中医药大学学报.2008,22(004):47-50.
[41]朱文锋.构建“证素辨证”新体系的意义[J].浙江中医药大学学报.2006,30(002):135-136.
[42]张志斌,王永炎,吕爱平,et al.论证候要素与证候靶点应证组合辨证[J].中医杂志.2006,47(007):483-485.
[43]朱文锋,刘莺.病证症相结合的中医诊疗体系[J].北京中医药大学学报.1999,22(006):2-4.
[44]张志斌.现代证候概念研究发展趋势[J].山西中医学院学报.2006(01).
[45]封静,张志斌.现代证候概念研究发展趋势[J].山西中医学院学报.2006,7(001):54-56.
[46]张志斌,王永炎.证候名称及分类研究的回顾与假设的提出[J].北京中医药大学学报.2003,26(002):1-5.
[47]邓中炎.关于证候概念的探讨[J].广西中医药.1992,15(005):35-37.
[48]黎敬波,朱文锋.辨证规范化的难点和途径[J].医学与哲学.1995,16(012):645-646.
[49]王忠,王阶.后基因组时代中医证候组学研究的思考[J].中国中西医结合杂志.2001,21(008):621-623.
[50]申维玺.论中医“证”的现代医学属性和概念[J].中医杂志.2001,42(005):307-309.
[51]白云静,申洪波,孟庆刚,等.中医证候复杂性特征及证候研究思路探析[J].中国中医药信息杂志.2004,11(009):754-756.
[52]Greene J G.Constructing a standard climacteric scale[J].Maturitas.2008,61(1-2):78-84.
[53]王天芳,吴秀艳,赵燕,等.临床常见疾病中医证候要素分布特点的文献研究[J].中华中医药杂志.2007,22(009):594-597.
[54]陈淑慧,梁伟雄.浅谈中医证候疗效指标在中医临床疗效评价体系中的应用[J].新中医.2008,40(006):113-115.
[55]朱文锋.中医诊断学[J].中医教育.2002,21(006):39-40.
[56]申定珠,李家邦,蒋荣鑫,et al.证候蛋白质组学与中医证候学相关性探讨[J].中国中西医结合杂志.2006,26(004):366-368.
[57]周忠科,刘家强,王米渠.中医证候基因组学研究的探讨[J].中华中医药学刊.2008,26(004):826-827.
[58]汤朝晖,李炜弘,严石林,等.老龄肾阳虚证的差异表达基因谱研究的意义探讨[J].辽宁中医杂志.2008,35(002):311-313.
[59]Holsti O R.Content analysis for the social sciences and humanities[M].Addison-Wesley Reading,MA,1969.
[60]Ryan G W,Bernard H R.Data management and analysis methods[J].Handbook of qualitative research.2000,2:769-802.
[61]歐用生.開放社會的教育改革[M].心理 薹北市,1992.
[62]黄志澄.以人为主,人机结合,从定性到定量的综合集成法[J].西安交通大学学报:社会科学版.2005,25(002):55-59.
[63]张海男,罗建清.抑郁症常见中医证候类型第一轮专家问卷分析[J].湖南医科大学学报.2002,27(006):519-521.
[64]王儒飞,陈涌.中药“四气”定性分析法初探[J].中医杂志.1991,32(005):9-11.
[65]于河,刘建平.定性研究方法及其在医学领域内的应用[J].循证医学.2008,8(5).
[66]刘庆,岳小强,邓伟哲,等.应用舌诊综合信息分析系统对原发性肝癌舌质颜色的定量分析[J].中西医结合学报.2003,1(003):180-183.
[67]卫保国,沈兰荪.数字化中医舌象分析仪[J].中国医疗器械杂志.2002,26(003):164-166.
[68]翁维良,黄世敬.中医舌诊客观化研究[J].中国工程科学.2001,3(001):78-82.
[69]赵爱光,杨金坤.脾虚与胃癌发生,发展的相关性研究[J].上海中医药杂志.1998(005):10-12.
[70]梁茂新,洪治平.中医症状量化的方法初探:附虚证30症的量化法[J].中国医药学报.1994,9(003):37-39.
[71]陈启光,申春悌,张华强,等.因子分析在中医证候规范标准研究中的应 用[J].中国中医基础医学杂志.2004,10(008):53-56.
[72]Weaver T,Renton A,Tyrer P,et al.Combining qualitative studies with randomised controlled trials is often useful.[J].BMJ:British Medical Journal.1996,313(7057):629.
[73]Schumacher K L,Koresawa S,West C,et al.Qualitative research contribution to a randomized clinical trial[J].Research in nursing & health.2005,28(3):268-280.
[74]马文峰.试析内容分析法在社科情报学中的应用[J].情报科学.2000,18(004):346-349.
[75]邱均平,邹菲.国外内容分析法的研究概况及进展[J].图书情报知识.2003(006):6-8.
[76]宋旭昌.2007年iSchool科研热点分析[J].情报探索.2008(009):118-121.
[77]卢家婧.基于内容分析法的中美大学教学质量评价比较研究[J].继续教育研究.2008(005):87-89.
[78]曹琴仙,于淼.基于内容分析法的专利文献应用研究[J].现代情报.2007,27(012):147-150.
[79]Taylor R.Slain and Slandered:A Content Analysis of the Portrayal of Femicide in Crime News[J].Homicide Studies.2009,13(1):21.
[80]Lock M.Menopause in cultural context[J].Experimental gerontology.1994,29(3-4):307-317.
[81]Wiklund I.Methods of assessing the impact of climacteric complaints on quality of life:Methodological issues in menopause research[J].Maturitas(Amsterdam).1998,29(1):41-50.
[82]Mccoy N L.Methodological problems in the study of sexuality and the menopause:Methodological issues in menopause research[J].Maturitas(Amsterdam).1998,29(I):51-60.
[83]Dennerstein L,SmithAM,Morse C.Psychological well-being,mid-life and the menopause.[J].Maturitas.1994,20(1):1.
[84]Greene J G.Constructing a standard climacteric scale[J].Maturitas.2008,61(1-2):78-84.
[85]樊长征,焉石,李友林,等.基于形神一体观的疾病疗效评价指标研究思路探讨[J].中华现代中医学杂志.2008,4(1).
[86]杨定海.对现行医学模式的一点补充--基于非典疫情的思考[J].医学与社会.2004,17(002):27-28.
[87]许军.健康评价[J].国外医学:社会医学分册.1999,16(001):1-3.
[88]Farnik-brodzi M,Pierzcha W.The value of studies of quality of life in chronic respiratory tract diseases in the framework of holistic medicine[J].Wiadomo?ci lekarskie(Warsaw,Poland:1960).1998,51(7-8):316.
[89]赖世隆.中医药临床疗效评价若干关键环节的思考[J].广州中医药大学学报.2002,19(004):245-250.
[90]聂广宁,王小云,杨洪艳.中医药治疗更年期综合征的疗效评价现状[J].中华实用中西医杂志.2005,18(010):1544-1546.
[91]聂广宁,王小云,杨洪艳.中医药治疗更年期综合征随机对照试验文献的质量评价[J].中医药学刊.2005,23(011):2014-2016.
[92]于春泉,马寰,宫涛,等.量表学在中医证候研究中的应用探讨[J].辽宁中医杂志.2006,33(007):797-798.
[93]郭新峰,赖世隆。中医药临床疗效评价中结局指标的选择与应用[J].广州中医药大学学报.2002,19(004):251-255.
[94]平凡.中医药在美国[J].食品与药品.2005,7(02A):75-76.
[95]Mahady G B,Dog T L,Barrett M L,et al.United States Pharmacopeia review of the black cohosh case reports of hepatotoxicity.[J].Menopause.2008,15(4):628.
[96]赖世隆,郭新峰,梁伟雄,等.中风病疗效评价指标体系的初步研究[J].中国中西医结合杂志.2004,24(003):197-201.
[97]刘凤斌,方积乾,王建华.中医药临床疗效评价的探讨[J].中药新药与临床药理.2004,15(004):290-292.
[98]刘凤斌,赵利.建立中医疗效测评量表体系研究的设想[J].中国临床康复.2004,8(001):164-165.
[99]吴大嵘,杨小波,赖世隆.中医药研究中软指标测量工具的建立和应用探讨[J].中国中西医结合杂志.2006,26(004):293-297.
[100]王小云,聂广宁,杨洪艳,等.中医药治疗绝经综合征的临床证据[J].中国循证医学杂志.2007,7(009):685-689.
[101]刘雅芳,程伟.面对“告别中医药”[J].医学与哲学:人文社会医学版.2007,28(001):71-71.
[102]杨洪艳,王小云,聂广宁,等.绝经综合征疗效评定量表构建思路和循证研究探讨[J].循证医学.2007,7(3).
[103]郭新峰,朱泉,赖世隆.替代指标和中间指标及其在中医药疗效评价研究中应用价值的思考[J].中国中西医结合杂志.2005,25(007):585-590.
[104]朱文锋,张华敏.“证素”的基本特征[J].中国中医基础医学杂志.2005,11(001):17-18.
[105]姚乃礼.中医症状鉴别诊断学[Z].北京:人民卫生出版社,2000.
[106]陈可冀,宋军.病证结合的临床研究是中西医结合研究的重要模式[J].世界科学技术:中医药现代化.2006,8(002):1-5.
[107]刘平.病-证-效[J].结合研究的思考与探索[期刊论文]-中西医结合心脑血管病杂志.2007.
[108]李先涛,张伯礼.证候诊断标准研究的迫切性和可行性[J].天津中医药.2007,24(001):36-38.
[109]梁晓春.循证医学与中医临床疗效评价[J].中华全科医师杂志.2004,3(001):7-9.