摘要
本文对先进项目管理技术的理论方法和关键技术及其应用进行了探讨。
首先分析了传统项目管理理论方法和关键技术的局限性以及先进项目管理理论产生的背景,指出研究先进项目管理理论方法的必要性;同时论述了目前船舶管理的现状和项目管理对船舶行业的适用性。
本文对项目管理中的关键技术一网络计划评审技术(PERT)进行了深入的研究。通过引入灰色系统理论中的灰色预测、灰色评估和灰色嵌套技术到PERT中来,首次提出Grey-PERT方法,既解决了进度计划中返工回路的计算问题,又增加了进度计划的准确性和适用性。并通过船舶项目大节点进度计划为例,详细分析了Grey-PERT方法的计算过程、应用效果和优越性。
本文在传统项目管理理论方法(PM)的基础上,有效的集成了企业资源计划(ERP)、业务流程重组(BPR)、电子商务(EC)、供应链管理(SCM)、伙伴关系管理(ARM)等先进管理模式和信息技术,首次提出集成化的先进项目管理的理论体系框架。这是对传统项目管理理论方法适应新时代、新技术的有意义的补充。
同时在集成化的先进项目管理理论体系框架中,首次提出承包商关系管理模式,是对传统项目管理理论模式的发展。指出承包商关系管理是伙伴关系管理的重要组成部分,业务外包是21世纪灵捷制造模式企业间业务关系的主要运作形式之一。在详细分析承包商关系管理的功能、特点、重要性和关键技术之后,结合信息项目外包例子,详细的论述了承包商关系管理中的业务外包管理关键技术,并对其在船舶行业的应用改造方法予以讨论。
在行业应用方面,本文首次把项目管理理论系统引入船舶工程项目中来,拓展了项目管理理论的应用领域。针对船舶项目的特点,首次提出先进船舶项目管理系统模型,成为实施先进船舶管理的理论基础。并详细论述了实施本系统的总体设计框架,包括系统的实施方针、体系结构、功能设计及其关键技术。指出并详细论述了实施本系统部分功能的主要关键技术,即:灵捷船舶项目组的构建模式研究,船舶项目管理和企业资源计划集成模式研究、船舶项目一体化计划管理技术研究及其信息系统开发,以及灵捷船舶项目供应链管理技术研究。最后针对船舶项目的实际情况,建立船舶供应链承包商选择、评价体系,改进了船舶产品承包商选择方法和流程。
The overall aim of this study is to investigate the theories, methodologies, related important technologies and their applications in advanced project management.
In the introducing part, Firstly, it states the limitations of the traditional theories, methods and related technologies in project management, and then it describes the background of advanced project management and the significance of doing research on the theories and methodologies of advanced project management. Finally, it illustrates the present situation of the management of shipbuilding engineering projects and the applicability of advanced project management to the shipbuilding projects.
The study is an in-depth discussion to the crucial technology - Planning Evaluation and Review Technology (PERT) in project management. It is the first presentation of new calculation method - Grey-PERT by applying Grey Forecasting, Grey Evaluation, and Grey Nesting from the theory of Grey System into PERT. The method not only solves the problem of how to calculate the re-do duration in project processing or scheduling, but also increases the accuracy and applicability of scheduling and planning in a project. The calculating procedure, efficiency and advantages of this Grey-PERT are examined in details by giving an example in shipbuilding project planning.
Based on the traditional theory and methods in project management, the study is the first one to bring forward a new theoretical framework in project management (PM)-- Advanced Project Management Body of Knowledge (APMBOK). It has integrated the Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP), Business Process Reengineering (BPR), Electronic Commerce (EC), Supply Chain Management (SCM) and Customer Relationship Management (CRM) in the APMBOK. The new method may strengthen significantly the traditional project management in the process of modernization in the era of new information and technologies.
In the theoretical framework of APMBOK, for the first one, the study pointed out that Contractor Relationship Management is a complement to the traditional model of project management. Also, Contractor Relationship Management is the important component of Associate Relationship Management, and Project Outsourcing is the most important business operational form among those enterprises that are making flexible engineering models in the 21st century. After the in-depth discussion on the function, characteristics, and key technologies of Contractor Relationship Management, the study presents a practical example on how to manage an outsourcing software project.
In the application of APMBOK to shipbuilding engineering, still it is the first one of the kind of study in China to bring forward systematically the APMBOK theory to the field of the shipbuilding engineering projects. System Model of Advanced Shipbuilding Project Management is firstly presented, which includes practical principle, system structure frame, function model and some key technologies - Agile Ship Project Group, Integration between PM and ERP, the Whole Ship Planning Management and its Information System, and Agile Ship Supply Chain Management. At Last, the study sets up a system of the evaluation and selections contractor for ship projects Supply Chain, which improves the scientific method and process of ship product contractor selection.
引文
1.徐学光等,现代造船模式研究报告,中国船舶工业总公司,1999.6
2.李天和,D.Walden,设计集成管理系统,工业工程与管理,No.3,2000
3.李师兼,屈贤明.中国先进制造技术考察团先进制造技术考察报告,计算机世界,1995.4.26
4.田冯明,造船推行项目管理的探讨.广船科技.2000.6
5.纪国利等,船厂技术人员访谈录,2000.11.3
6. Donald J.Bowersox, David J.Closs:Logistical Management:The Integrated Supply Chain Process.McGraw-Hillcompanies, Inc. 1998.
7.马新安,张列平和冯芸.供应链合作伙伴关系和合作伙伴选择,工业工程与管理 2000.4.
8. www.entech.com.cn
9. www.pmi.org
10. Farrell, L. M., Risk management and the evaluation of entertainment investment projects. Project management Journal, 1994, ⅹⅹⅴ(2),37-43
11. Huang huaping, On the project construction management in the changjiang three gorges project, The 1st project management international conference, Xi'an, 1994, pp. 125-130
12. Faizul Hug, Testing in the software development life-cycle: now or later, International Journal of project management, 18(2000), 243-250
13. Waterridge. J, IT projects: a basis for success International Journal of Project Management 13 1995 pp169-172
14. Callahan, John; Moretton, Brian, Reducing software product development time International Journal of Project Management 191 Jan 2001 pp 59-70
15. Bhuiyan, Nadia; Thomson, Vince, Use of continuous approval methods in defence acquisition projects, International Journal of Project Management v 17 n 2 Apr 1999 pp121-129
16. Gell, Gunther; Madjaric, Miroslav; Leodolter, Werner; Kole, Wolfgang; Leitner, Hubert, HIS purchase projects in public hospitals of Styria, International Journal of Medical Informafics 58 Sep 2000 pp147-155
17. Guilmette, J.H., Lessons learned from the Environmental Management Development in Ukraine project. Water Quality Research Journal of Canada v 33 n 4 1998 pp511-518
18. Francis Hartman, Raft Ashrafi and George Jergers, Project management in the live entertainment industry:what is different?, international Journal of project management, Vol.16, No.5, pp.269-281, 1998
19. www.morrow.com
20. Raju Gvs, Sensitivity analysis of GERT networks. AIIE Trans v 3 n 2 June 1971 pp133-41
21. Moore, Laurence J.; Taylor, Bernard W. Ⅲ, Multi-team, Multi-project research and development planning with GERT.anagement Science v 24 n 4 Dec 1977 p401-410
22. Wang, Zhongtuo; Wang, Kei, New algorithm for the decision critical path method. Proceedings of the Chinese-U. S. Symposium on Systems Analysis. 1983 pp123-131
23. Moeller, Gerald L.; Digman, Lester A, Operationas planning with VERT. Operations Research v 29 n 4 Jul-Aug 1981 pp 676-697
24. Stinson, Joel P.; Davis, Edward W.; Khumawala, Basheer M, Multiple resource-constrained scheduling using branch and bound. AIIE Transactions (American Institute of Industrial Engineers) v 10 n 3 Sep 1978
25. Icmeli, Oya; Selcuk Erenguc, S. , Branch and bound procedure for the resource constrained project scheduling problem with discounted cash flows. Management Science 42 10 Oct 1996
26. Kaefer, Frederick , Project scheduling with resource constraints: a branch and bound approach. European Journal of Operational Research 125 1 2000 pp 216-217
27. Demeulemeester, Erik L.; Herroelen, Willy S., Efficient optimal solution procedure for the preemptive resource-constrained project scheduling problem. European Journal of Operational Research 90 2 Apr 19 1996 pp 334-348
28. Boettcher, Jan; Drexl, Andreas; Kolisch, Rainer; Salewski, Frank, Project scheduling under partially renewable resource constraints. Management Science v 45 n 4 1999 pp 543-559
29. Sankaran, Jayaram K.; Bricker, Dennis L.; Juang, Shuw-Hwey, Strong fractional cutting-plane algorithm for resource-constrained project scheduling. International Journal of Industrial Engineering : Theory Applications and Practice v 6 n 2 1999 pp 99-111
30. Sprecher, Arno; Kolisch, Rainer; Drexl, Andreas, Semi-active, active, and non-delay schedules for the resource-constrained project scheduling problem. European Journal of Operational Research 80 1 Jan 5 1995 pp 94-102
31. Dorndorf, Ulrich; Pesch, Erwin; Phan-Huy, Toan, Time-oriented branch-and-bound algorithm for resource-constrained project scheduling with generalized precedence constraints. Management Science 46 10 Oct 2000 pp 1365-1384
32. Carraway, Robert L.; Schmidt, Robert L., An improved discrete dynamic programming algorithm for allocating resources among interdependent projects. Management Science v 37 n 9 Sep 1991 p 1195-1200
33. Yang, Kum Khiong; Talbot, F. Brian; Patterson, James H., Scheduling a project to maximize its net present value: An integer programming approach. European Journal of Operational Research v 64 n 2 Jan 22 1993 pp 188-198
34. Mingozzi, Aristide; Maniezzo, Vittorio; Ricciardelli, Salvatore; Bianco, Luc, Exact algorithm for the resource-constrained project scheduling problem based on a new mathematical formulation. Management Science v 44 n 5 May 1998 pp 714-729
35. Sevkinaz Gumusoglu and Hulya Tutek, An analysis method inproject management using primal-dual relationships, International Journal of project management, Vol. 16, No.5, pp.321-327,1998
36. Lee, Jae-Kwan; Kim, Yeong-Dae, Search heuristics for resource constrained project scheduling. Journal of the Operational Research Society 47 5 May 1996 pp 678-689
37. Kim, Jae-Gon; Kim, Yeong-Dae; Lee, Dong-Ho, Simulated annealing algorithms for locating pickup and delivery points in an automated guided vehicle system. Journal of Engineering Valuation and Cost Analysis
34-5 2000 pp 205-215
38. Park, Moon-Won; Kim, Yeong-Dae, Branch and bound algorithm for a production scheduling problem in an assembly system under due date constraints. European Journal of Operational Research 123 3 2000 pp 504-518
39. Jun, Hong-Bae; Kim, Yeong-Dae; Suh, Hyo-Won, Heuristics for a tool provisioning problem in a flexible manufacturing system with an automatic tool transporter. IEEE Transactions on Robotics and Automation v 15 n 3 1999 pp 488-496
40. Park, Moon-Won; Kim, Yeong-Dae, Systematic procedure for setting parameters in simulated annealing algorithms. Computers & Operations Research v 25 n 3 Mar 1998 pp 207-217
41. Park, Moon-Won: Kim, Yeong-Dae, Search heuristics for a parallel machine scheduling problem with ready times and due dates. Computers & Industrial Engineering 33 3-4 Dec 1997 pp 793-796
42. Kim, Yeong-Dae, New branch and bound algorithm for minimizing mean tardiness in two-machine flowshops. Computers & Operations Research v 20 n 4 May 1993 pp 391-401
43. Kim, Yeong-Dae, Heuristics for flowshop scheduling problems minimizing mean tardiness. Journal of the Operational Research Society v 44 n 1 Jan 1999 pp 19-28
44. Kim, Jung-Ug; Kim, Yeong-Dae, Simulated annealing and genetic algorithms for scheduling products with multi-level product structure. Computers & Operations Research 23 9 Sep 1996 pp 857-868
45. Speranza, M. Grazia; Vercellis, Carlo, Hierarchical models for multi-project planning and scheduling. European Journal of Operational Research v 64 n 2 Jan 22 1993 pp 312-325
46. Kwanyuen, Bancha; Fontane, Darrell G , Heuristic branch-and-bound method for ground water development planning. Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management v 124 n 3 May-Jun 1998 pp 140-147
47. Taeho Ahn and S.Seiuck Erengue, The resourse constrained project scheduling problem with multiple crashable modes: A heuristic procedure, European journal of operational research 107(1998) 250-259
48. S.Dauzere-peres, W.Roux and J.B.Lasserre, Multi-resource Shop Scheduling with resource Flesibility, European Journal of Opertaional Research, 107(1998) 289-305
49. maciey Hapke, Andrzej Jaszkiewicz and Roman Slowinski, Interactive analysis of multiple-criteria project scheduling problem, European journal of operational research 107(1998) 315-324
50. Massimo De Falco And Roberto Macchiaroli, Timing of control activities in project management, International Journal of project management. Vol.16, No.1, pp.51-58, 1998
51. Ohmae, Yoshitsugu; Hasegawa, Susumu; Okuda, Minoru, Multi-project scheduling. Journal of Information Processing v 15 n 2 1992 p 267-279
52. Speranza, M. Grazia; Vercellis, Carlo, Hierarchical models for multi-project planning and scheduling. European Journal of Operational Research v 64 n 2 Jan 22 1993
53. Tsukada, Koji; Okada, Ken-ichi; Matsushita, Yutaka, Multi-project support system based on multiplicity of task. Proceedings-IEEE Computer Society's International Computer Software & Applications Conference
Nov 9-11 1994
54. Rautiainen, Kristian; Nissinen, Maarit; Lassenius, Casper, Improving multi-project management in two product development organizations. Proceedings of the Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences Jan 4-Jan 7 2000
55. Arno Sprecher and Andreas Crexl, Multi-mode resource-constrained project scheduling by a simple general and powerful sequencing algorithm. European Journal of Operational Research, 107(1998) 431-450
56. R. P. Mohanty and M.K.Siddiq, Multiple projects-multiple resources-constrained scheduling: some studies, INT. J. PROD. RES.,1989, Vol.27, No.2, 261-280
57. Franciszek Seredynski, Distributed scheduling using simple learning machines, European Journal of Opertaional Research, 107(1998) 401-413
58. 毛义华和许庆瑞,新产品组合管理研究,科研管理, Vol.21, No.1,Jan.2000
59. Yang, J. C., Exploration of the instrument conversion project. Advances in Instrumentation v 39 n pt 2 1984 pp 1411-1418
60. Kidd, J. B., Do today's projects need powerful network planning tools? International Journal of Production Research, 2000, 29, 1969-1978
61. Mansuy, John, Work breakdown structure. A simple tool for complex jobs. Cost Engineering v 33 n 12 Dec 1991 pp 15-18
62. Globerson, S, Impact of various work breakdown structures on project conceptualization, International Journal of project management, Vol. 12, pp.165-171, 1994
63. Hauser, Michael A., WBS development for an $11 billion transportation project. Transactions of the American Association of Cost Engineers Jun 19-22 1994
64. Bergseth, Robert R. , Insuring quality in government systems acquisition through the use of the work breakdown structure (WBS). Proceedings of the Project Management Institute Annual Seminar Symposium Sep 27-Oct 2 1991
65. Postula, Frank D., WBS criteria for effective project control. Transactions of the American Association of Cost Engineers Jun 23-26 1991
66. Rad, Parviz F., Deliverable-oriented work breakdown structure. AACE International. Transactions of the Annual Meeting Jun 27-Jun 30 1999
67. Skokan, Bryan; Khan, Mohammad A.; Engebretson, G Allan, Standardized cost structure for the environmental industry. AACE International. Transactions of the Annual Meeting Jun 28-Jul 1 1998
68. Cai Jianfeng, The thoughts of the whole project life cycle and the effects on project management, the 1th project management international conference in Xi'an, 1994, pp.64-67
69. John H Payne and J Rodney Turner, Company-wide Project management: the planning and control of programmes of projects of different type, International Journal of project management, Vol.17, No.1 pp.55-59, 1999
70. Dodin B. M. and Elmaghraby, S. E., Approximating the criticality indices of the activities in the PERT network. Int. J. Projectmanagement, 1993, 11, 165-174
71. 续晓春,PERT网络在工程风险估计中的应用初探,太原理工大学学报,Vol.31. No.1. Jan.2000
72. V M Rao Tummala, Applying a Risk Management Process to manage cost risk for an EHV Transmission line project. International Journal of project management, Vol. 17, No.4, pp.223-235, 1999
73. Elmaghraby, S. E. and Kamburowski, J., The analysis of activity networks under generalized precedence relations (GPRs) .Management Science, 1992, 38,1245-1263
74. Giovanni Mummolo, Measuring uncertainty and Criticality in network planning by PERT-path Technique, Internationa! Journal of project management, Vol.15, No.6. pp.377-387, 1997
75. Bowman, R. A., Efficient estimation of arc criticalities in stochastic activity networks. Management Science, 1995,41,58-67
76. Petar Jovanovic, Application of Sensitivity analysis in investment project evaluation under uncertainty and risk, International Journal of project management,Vol. 17, No.3, pp.217-222, 1999
77. Ching-hwang wang and Yu-chun Huang, A new Approach to calculating project cost varitance, International Journal of project management, 18(2000) 131-138
78. Martin Elkjaer, Stochastic Budget simulation, International Journal of project management, 18(2000) 139-147
79. 王立文,项目费用控制的一个有效手段,北京航空航天大学学报,Vol. 24,No.3,June 1998
80. Zheng, Bingnan , Research about the method of multiobjective evaluation for import technology and equipment. Proceedings of the 1991 Portland International Conference on Management of Engineering and Technology-PICMET '91 Oct 27-31 1991
81. Luis F Alarcon and David B Ashley, Project management decision making using cross-impact analysis, International Journal of project management, Vol. 16, No.3, pp.145-150,1998
82. Hu Wenxiu and Zhang Daohong, The application of fuzzy synthetically decision method in the post-evaluation of engineering projects, The 1st project management international conference, xi'an, 1994
83. Bartolomeo Sapio and Ermanno Antimi, WlSE(Weig.hted ImpactStructured Evaluation):a new method to analyze the project management context. International Journal of project management,Vol. 16, No.3, pp.173-183, 1998
84. MHV Hendriks, B Voeten and L Kroep, Human resourse allocation in a multi-project R&D environment, International Journal of project management. Vol. 17. No.3, pp.181-188, 1999
85. James Sommervil and Shirley Daiziel, Project teambuilding-the applicability of Belbin's team-role self-perception inventory, International Journal of project management, Vol.16, No.3, pp.165-171, 1998
86. Mohan Thite, Leadership styles in information technology projects, International Journal of project management, 18(2000) , 235-241
87. Rachel Burgess and Suzanne Turner, Seven Key features lor creating and sustaining commitment, International Journal of project management, 18(2000) , 225-233
88. Roderic J Gray, Alternative approaches to programme management, International Journal of project management,Vol.15, No.1, pp.5-9, 1997
89. Bartlett, C A and Ghoshal,S, Matrix management: not a structure, a frame of mind, Harvard business review(July-Aug., 1990)138-145
90. Robins, M J, Effective project management in a matrix-management environment, International Journal of project management, 11(1993), 11-14
91. PED Love, A Gunasekaran and H Li, Concurrent engineering: a stratege for Procuring construction projects, International Journal of project management, Vol.6, No.6, pp.375-383, 1998
92. G.Themistocleous, S.H. Wearne, Project management topic coverage in journals, International Journal of Project management 18(2000) 7-11
93.戴大双,陈伟忠,技术经济学,北京:机械工业出版社,1996.10
94. www.ccednet.com
95.王端良,建设项目进度控制,北京,中国水利水电出版社,1998
96.王学荫,灰色系统方法简明教程,成都科技大学出版社,1993
97. Deng Julong, Control Problems of Grey Systems, Systems & Control Letters, North Horland, 1982
98.温坤礼,灰色系统理论的研究以及与影像边界收缩及压缩上的应用,台湾,中央大学机械系博士论文,1998
99. Jen-Yang Chen, JGS, 1995, 1, pp. 9-12
100.程定安,王一凡,灰色系统学刊,台湾,1998,1(2),pp.147-157
101. Sinh-Hsing Chang and Jiun-Ken Hwang, JGS, 1998, 4, pp. 371-385
102. Huang G. H., Beata B. W. and Parkty G.G., Engineering Optimization, 1996, 26(2)
103. Morita H. Kase and I. Tamura Y., Electr. Engineering of Japan, 1995, 115(2)
104.罗庆成,徐国新,灰色线性规划与应用[M].镇江:江苏科学技术出版社,1989
105.严智渊,戴玉生,灰色系统预测与应用,江苏:江苏科学技术出版社,1989
106.张后启,ERP系统的成功应用模式,中外管理导报,1999.2
107.马永生,供应链管理,经理管理,2000.5
108.陈菊红,孙林岩,汪应洛,适应知识经济时代变化特征的灵捷虚拟企业,工业工程,2001.6
109.马士华,林勇,陈志祥,供应链管理,机械工业出版社,北京:2000.5
110. http://www.chnhrm.com.cn
111.史炜,外包手机让民族化口号随风而逝,中国企业报,2001.3.6-6
112.何新贵、王纬等,软件能力成熟度模型,清华大学出版社,北京.2000.11
113.国际标准组织:ISO 9001
114.张维迎,博弈论与信息经济学,上海:上海人民出版社,1997.2
115.徐学光,翁德伟,黄厚德,模块工程采购工作简介,中国海洋平台,1987.10,pp.37-39
116.薛劲松、宋宏等,CIMS的总体设计,北京:机械工业出版社,1997.4
117.孙波,项目管理在海洋工程中的应用及研究,硕士论文,大连理工大学,2001.3
118.张士杰等,渤海造船厂CIMS初步设计报告,1996.6
119.刘建峰,秦士元,应长春,船体分段制造日程计划的模拟与优化,2000.4
120.高介祜,现代造船模式的探索,上船科技,1998.3
121.陆蓓,张圣坤,虚拟理论在船舶工业中的应用——虚拟船厂,船舶工程,2001.1
122.王锡淮,肖建梅,计算机集成制造系统及其在造船工业中的应用,中国造船,1999.11
123.钟小如,海事业电子商贸新体验—网上采购,中国造船与航运,2001.1
124.刘晓冰,黄学文,高天一,面向动态联盟的伙伴企业选择决策方法及系统,工业工程,2001.6
125. Gao, S. X., Lin Y., Ji, Z. S., and Dai Y. S., (2000. 10) "Integrated Grey Network Project Management Information System". 2000 China Xi'an International Project Management Forum.
126.高绍新,纪卓尚,林焰,“项目管理理论中关于软件项目外包采购管理的探讨”,计算机工程,2002.1
127.高绍新,纪卓尚,林焰,“面向船舶与海洋工程的项目管理信息系统的系统分析和初步设计”,大连理工大学学报,2001.4
128. Gao, S. X., Ji, Z. S., Lin Y., and Ji G..L., (2000. 10 ) "The application of project management information system in naval architecture & ocean engineering projects". 2000 China Xi'an International Project Management Forum.
129. Gao, S. X., Ji, Z. S., Lin Y., and Ji G..L., "A Grey-PERT Method in dynamic planning control system for SBOE projects", International Journal of Production Research.