摘要
公私合作融资模式的出现,解决了政府在基础设施建设方面的资金短缺、经营管理效率低下的问题,通过政府的宏观管理,在财政资金少投入的情况下可以实现基础设施的有效供给;通过对政府行为的研究,可以制订出科学合理的补贴模式,实现在基础设施供给方面形成有效的激励约束,减少公众的财政负担。公私合作模式下,政府不再直接参与准公共基础设施项目的运作,从而可以成为投资与建设的“裁判员”和游戏规则的制定者,通过规范项目投资者的行为,能够提高企业的管理和效率,建立以市场为核心的多向决策机制、多维的相互制约和平衡机制,及早实现基础设施的正外部性与公益性目标。
公私合作的理论依据来源于福利经济学的定价理论,从研究强自然垄断产品的平均成本、边际成本、及无管制状态下公共产品的定价理论入手,研究了公私合作提供公共产品补贴的可行性,引入了效率参数,结果表明,只要满足条件(4-26)、(4-29)两个条件,对准经营性公共项目的财政补贴就能够带来社会福利的增加。事实上无论以何种形式对合作的项目进行补贴,总会出现政府的效率失真,我们只能通过完善我们的制度来实现效率的最小失真,增加政府补贴的效率。
利用经济学的效用论与博弈的观点分析了政府对项目进行补贴的效用;对财政补贴的政治成本与交易成本进行了对比,提出了政府在补贴的过程中应注意的事项。利用多目标决策理论对公私合作的补贴比例与特许年限进行了研究并运用算例对该决策机制进行了模拟。运用无限期重复博弈与声誉博弈理论对财政补贴过程中私营投资者的违规行为进行了研究,结果表明政府的处罚力度越大、投机被发现的概率越大,投资者违规的动机就越小。投资者的声誉越好,越有动力维持声誉;没有声誉的投资违规的频率最大。政府一方面要加大对违规的惩罚力度,另一方面要加强制度的建设来加强对投资风险的控制。
信息的不对称与投资的复杂性是投机风险存在的原因,公私双方利益诉求是合作的动力,私营投资者追求利益的最大化是投机行为存在的前提,为有效降低投机的存在,实现双方的共赢与公众的多赢,公私双方在合作过程中要建立长期以信任为目的的信任机制、合理的联盟贡献与补偿机制、及契约的完善机制,事前、事中、事后的项目风险控制与项目建设监管机制,对比目前政府项目投资的监管框架,改进了由政府大项目办为监督主体的政府投资监管的理论框架体系,有效减少私营投资者的投机行为。
借鉴相关研究理论,建立了政府行为影响项目绩效的结构方程,依据调研的数据与结构方程模型,得出了政府行为对项目绩效的影响效应,政府行为不仅可直接影响项目的绩效,而且可以间接通过影响投资环境与信任程度影响合作项目的绩效,提出了改进政府行为的政策性建议。
The emergence of public-private partnership financing model may solve the shortage of funds and management inefficiencies for the government in infrastructure building; through the government's macro-management and operation, we can achieve effective supply of infrastructure with less financial resources. Through the study of government behavior, we can develop a scientific and reasonable subsidy model, achieving an effective incentive and restraint in the infrastructure supply, reducing the public's financial burden. In public-private partnership model, the government is no longer directly involved in the operation of quasi-public infrastructure projects, and just acts as the "referee" in investment and construction and the maker of the game rules; and by regulating the behaviors of project investors we can improve enterprise management and efficiency, establish a market-centered multi-directional decision-making mechanism, a multi-dimensional mutual restraint and balance system, so that the goal of positive externalities and public welfare of infrastructure can be realized as soon as possible.
The theoretical basis for public-private partnership is the pricing theory of welfare economics. Starting from study of the pricing theory, namely strong natural monopoly products pricing, the average cost pricing, marginal cost pricing, and public goods pricing theory without control of a state, we research the feasibility that government provide public goods subsidies for the public-private partnership project and introduce the efficiency parameters. Through analysis of the conditions of government subsidies, we find that so long as subsidies meet the conditions that is (4-26) and (4-29), the financial subsidies can lead to social welfare increasing for the Quasi-public project.
In fact whatever form do we supply subsidy with for co-operation projects, the efficiency distortion of government always appear. By improving our system we can only achieve the efficiency minimum distortion, so we realize the goal that increases efficiency of the government subsidies.
The economics effectiveness and game theory are adopted to analyze the effectiveness that government provides subsidies. By contrasting the policy cost with transaction cost, we put forward the advice that government should pay attention to issues in the process of government subsidies. We use multi-objective decision theory to study the relation between the subsidy scale for public-private partnership and the franchise year and simulate the example for the decision-making mechanism.
We study the irregularities of private investors in course of financial subsidies and applicate the indefinite game theory, repeated games to research risk of financial subsidies, we find that violation motivation of the investor become less if the greater the punishment of the government for violator and the greater the probability of speculative be found is. The better the reputation for the investors is, the more motivated do the investors have to maintain the reputation; however the violation frequency of investor without reputation is the greatest among investors. The Government has to increase the penalties for speculative investors, on the other hand government should strengthen the building of the system to strengthen the investment risk control.
Speculative risk is due to the existence of information asymmetry and investment complexity, each of public and private has interest and aspiration oneself, the pursuit of the most interests of private investors is the premise of the existence of speculative behavior, in order to effectively reduce the speculative existence and to achieve win-win-win with the public, private and public parties in the process of cooperation we should establish a long-term trust mechanism and rational alliance contributions and compensation mechanisms and the improving mechanism of contracts and project risk control and construction monitoring mechanism in the pre-post, so we will effectively reduce the private investor speculation.
Drawing on relevant research theory, we establish the structure equation governmental action affecting the structure of project performance, based on research data and structural equation model we educe impact effects that governmental action affect the performance of the project, namely governmental action can not only directly affect the performance of the project but also can indirectly affect the performance of cooperative projects by influencing the investment climate and the degree of trust. At last the policy recommendations are proposed to improve government action.
引文
[1]郭磊.城市基础设施新的融资渠道一引入私人投资[J].城市研究,1999(1):18-20.
[2]中华人民共和国国民经济和社会发展第十一个五年规划纲要[N].人民日报,2006,2(22):1-2
[3]吴庆玲.城市基础设施领域项目融资模式创新[J].商业时代,2007(4):95-97.
[4]孙洁.PPP管理模式对公共财政的影响[J].财政研究,2004(10):21-23.
[5]Ventnen, A., Public involvement in multi-objective water level regulation development projects—evaluating the applicability of public involvement methods[J]. Environmental Impact Assessment Review,2005(25):281-304.
[6]陈月梅,徐震宇.基于P P P视角的城市公共基础设施投融资模式选择—兼论南京三桥的投融资模式[J].建筑经济,2007(12):30-33.
[7]Grimsey, D. and M.K., Lewis. Evaluating the risks of public private partnerships for infrastructure projects[J]. International Journal of Project Management,2002.20(2):107-118.
[8]Parker, D. and K. Hartley., Transaction costs, relational contracting and public private partnerships:a case study of UK defence[J]. Journal of Purchasing and Supply Management,2003.9(3):97-108.
[9]冯锋,张瑞青.公用事业项目融资及其路径选择[J].软科学,2005(6):52-55.
[10]Thackway, R. and K., olsson. Public/private Partnerships and Protected Areas:Selected Australian Case Studies[J]. Landscape and Urban Planning,1999(44):87-97.
[11]雷晓康,公共物品私人提供的理论分析[J].西安电子科技大学学报,2003.13(1):39-44.
[12]Chowdhury, A.N. and C. Charoenngam., Factors influencing finance on IPP projects in Asia:A legal framework to reach the goal[J]. International Journal of Project Management,2009.27(1):51-58.
[13]王刚,庄焰.地铁项目融资模式研究[J].深圳大学学报理工版,2006(3):217-222.
[14]Tsamboulasa, D.A. and S. Kaprosb., Freight village evaluation under uncertainty with public and private financing[J]. Transport Policy,2003(10).141-156
[15]Sobhiyah, M.H., M.R. Bemanian, and Y.K. Kashtiban., Increasing VFM in PPP power station projects-Case study:Rudeshur gas turbine power station[J]. International Journal of Project Management,2008(7):1-10.
[16]Xueqing, Z., Concessionaire Financial Capability in Developing Build-Operate-Transfer Type Infrastructure Projects[J]. Journal of Construction Engineering & Management,2005. 131(10):1054-1064.
[17]El-Gohary, N.M. H. Osman, and T.E. El-Diraby., Stakeholder management for public private partnerships[J]. International Journal of Project Management,2006.24(7):595-604.
[18]Fischer, K., A. Jungbecker, and H.W. Alfen., The emergence of PPP Task Forces and their influence on project delivery in Germany[J]. International Journal of Project Management,2006. 24(7):539-547.
[19]Spackman, M., Public-private partnerships:lessons from the British approach[J]. Economic Systems, 2002(26):283-301.
[20]P, M.S. and B.C. Y., Evaluation of government subsidies to large-scale energy projects[J]. Advances in Futures and Options Research,1988(3):169-181.
[21]Cheah, C.Y.J. and J. Liu., Valuing governmental support in infrastructure projects as real options using Monte Carlo simulation[J]. Construction Management and Economics,2006.24:545-554.
[22]于国安.特许权合约中政府的收入担保水平分析[J].河海大学学报(自然科学版),2004.32(6):707-711.
[23]高峰,郭菊娥,龚利.基础设施项目政府担保的双障碍期权价值研究[J].管理工程学报,2008(3):19-24.
[24]高峰,郭菊娥.基于障碍期权的基础设施项目政府担保价值研究[J].预测,2007(2):76-80.
[25]高峰,郭菊娥,李君.我国基础设施建设中的公私合作模式*[J].经济导刊,2008(1):68-69.
[26]王乐,郭菊娥,孙艳.基于实物期权的基础设施项目融资中政府担保价值研究[J].运筹与管理,2008(2):112-117.
[27]Ozorhon, B., D. Arditi, and M. Irem Dikmen., Effect of host country and project conditions in international construction joint ventures[J]. Project Management,2007.25(8):56-63.
[28]M, H., S. A, and CRAM-1., Model for international construction risk assessment[J]. Journal of Management in Engineering,2000.16(1):59-69.
[29]高晋康,汤火箭,杨春禧.改善成都市投资法律环境的对策研究[J].财经科学,2003(1):120-124.
[30]邓晓兰,曾小春,廖凯.论财政分权体制中的地方政府公债融资权[J].财贸经济,2005(5):39-42.
[31]杨大光,牟晓伟.关于区域投融资机制创新的思考——一以东北地区为例[J].经济纵横,2009(10):49-51.
[32]吴秋艳,周国栋.深化政府投资项目管理体制改革的思考[J].宏观经济管理,2008(第2期):42-44.
[33]Gazis., D.C., A computer model for the financial analysis of urban housing projects[J]. Socio-Economic Planning Sciences,1971.5(2):125-144.
[34]Mainali, B. and S., Silveira. Financing off-grid rural electrification:Country case Nepal[J]. Energy In Press, Corrected Proof, Available online,2010.08(12).
[35]Kato, K., T. Uemura, Y. Indo, A. Okada, K. Tanabe, S. Saito, Hitoshi Oguma, Hirotaka Yamauchi, E. Shiomi, Madoka Saegusa, and K. Migita., Current accounts of Japanese airports[J]. Journal of Air Transport Management,2010(8).88-93.
[36]Borger, B.D., Fay Dunkerley, and S. Proost., Capacity cost structure, welfare and cost recovery:Are transport infrastructures with high fixed costs a handicap[J]. Transportation Research Part B: Methodological,2009.43(5):506-521.
[37]Gary Q. Bull, M. Bazett, O. Schwab, S. Nilsson, A. White, and S. Maginnis., Industrial forest plantation subsidies:Impacts and implications[J]. Forest Policy and Economics,2006.9(1):13-31.
[38]Cao, S., C. Xu, L. Chen, and X. Wang., Attitudes of fanners in China's northern Shaanxi Province towards the land-use changes required under the Grain for Green Project, and implications for the project's success[J]. Land Use Policy,2009.26(4):1182-1194.
[39]Zhao, X. and L. Ortolano., Implementing China's national energy conservation policies at state-owned electric power generation plants[J]. Energy Policy,2010.38(10):6293-6306.
[40]Kuwahata, R. and C.R. Monroy., Market stimulation of renewable-based power generation in Australia[J]. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews,2010.15(1):534-543.
[41]何正文,徐.渝,朱少英.项目融资费用分担及联合支付进度问题研究[J].系统工程,2004(3):15-19.
[42]张沈生,张炯,柳正.项目投资与融资决策的理论方法与模型研究[J].沈阳建筑大学学报(自然科学版),2004.20(4).360-365.
[43]方必和,陈安英.刘慧萍,工程项目融资结构决策分析[J].基建优化,2005(1):50-52.
[44]赵立力,卜祥智,谭德庆.基础设施BOT电厂项目中的政府购买保证研究[J].管理工程学报,2008.22(1):45-49.
[45]王健,安实,赵泽斌.基于财政补贴的拥挤定价下公交收费策略研究[J].管理工程学报,2006(2):84-89.
[46]何寿奎.基于管理效率的公私合作项目伙伴选择与激励机制[J].数学的实践与认识,2010(8):1-7.
[47]刘向杰,田泽永.公私合营项目无追索融资模型研究[J].经济问题,2008(9):89-91.
[48]王联备,苏志欣.模糊层次分析法在基础设施项目融资模式选择中的应用研究[J].价值工程,2006(12):140-143.
[49]Engel, E., R. Fischer, and A. Galetovic, The basic public finance of public-private partnerships[N]. NBER Working,2008,3(6).35.
[50]Li-Yin, S., P. Andrew, and D.X. P., Role of public private partnerships to manage risks in public sector projects in Hong Kong[J]. International Journal of Project Management,2006.24(7):587-594.
[51]A.Ng and L. Martin., Risk allocation in the private provision of public infrastructure [J]. International Journal of Project Management,2007.25(1):66-76.
[52]B, L., Risk Management of Public-Private Partnership Projects[D]. Glasgow:Glasgow Caledonian University,2003.31-56
[53]孙艳,郭菊娥.基础设施项目融资中政府担保的影响因素[J].统计与决策,2007(27):53-56.
[54]J, F.N., Opportunism, organizational economics and the network approach[J]. Scand.J. Mgmt, 1996(2):189-205.
[55]程剑鸣.融资担保风险中的不确定因素控制及其应用[J].当代财经,2005(9):38-42.
[56]王增忠.公私合作制项目特许期的确定方法[J].上海师范大学学报(自然科学版),2008.37(1):68-73.
[57]刘江华.项目融资风险分担研究[J].工业技术经济,2006(8):125-127.
[58]Lam, K.C., D. Wang, P.T.K. Lee, and Y.T. Tsang., Modelling risk allocation decision in construction contracts[J]. International Journal of Project Management,2007.25(5):485-493.
[59]万冬君,王要武,姚兵.基础设施PPP融资模式及其在小城镇的应用研究[J].土木工程学报,2007.39(6):115-119.
[60]何寿奎,傅鸿源.基于风险分摊的PPP项目投资决策与收益分配研究[J].建筑经济,2006(10):9-13.
[61]范小军,赵一.基础项目融资风险的分担比例研究[J].管理工程学报,2007(1):98-100.
[62]范小军.大型基础项目融资风险的动态模糊评价[J].上海交通大学学报,2004(3):450-454.
[63]何寿奎.城市基础设施P P P建设模式挑战与对策[J].生产力研究,2007(8):65-67.
[64]周高平,周直.基础设施项目投资风险灰色预测模型研究[J].中南公路工程,2006(2):145-149.
[65]柯永建,王守清,陈炳泉.基础设施PPP项目的风险分担*[J].建筑经济,2008(4):31-36.
[66]Essig, M. and A. Batran., Public-private partnership-Development of long-term relationships in public procurement in German y[J]. Journal of Purchasing & Supply Management, 2005(11):221-231.
[67]Bettignies, J.-E.D. and T.W. Ross., The economics of public-private partnerships [J]. Canadian Public Policy-Analyse de Politiques,2004,30(2):135-154.
[68]Osborne, D., Banishing bureaucracy:the five strategies for reinventing Government. Reading[M]. Addison Wesley Pub,1997:397.
[69]湛中乐,刘书燃.PPP协议中的公私法律关系及其制度抉择[J].法治研究,2007(4):3-11.
[70]李秀辉.PPP一种新型的项目融资方式[J].中国软科学,2002(2):51-55.
[71]张启智.城市公共基础设施投融资方式的选择与政府职能定位[J].内蒙古师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2007(2):104-107.
[72]夏秀梅.论以城市政府作为基础设施投资主体的合理性[J].现代财经,2008(5):14-19.
[73]邓小鹏,申立银.PPP模式在香港基础设施建设中的应用研究及其启示[J].建筑经济,2006,287(9):14-18.
[74]达霖.格里姆赛,莫文.K.刘易斯.公私合作伙伴关系:基础设施供给和项目融资的全球革命[M]. 北京:人民大学出版社.270.2007.
[75][英]达霖.格里姆赛.公私合作伙伴关系:基础设施供给和项目融资的全球革命[M].北京:中国人民大学出版社.2008.
[76]刘谨,陈基义.国内基础设施建设的新模式—上海洋山港建设模式探析[J].建筑经济,2008(2):39-41.
[77]贾纬璇,何向军.在我国城市铁路客运枢纽站建设中的应用[J].建筑经济,2007(1):59-61.
[78]沈桂平.城市基础设施公私合作模式所有权归属的模型分析[J].城市轨道交通,2007(4):1-3.
[79]D.D., S., Vollrath, and H.W. Alfen., A comparison of Project Finance and the Forfeiting Model as financing forms for PPP projects in Germany[J]. International Journal of Project Management,2007.
[80]Douglas, L. and M. Anthony., Development and Maintenance of a Robust Public Sector Comparator [J]. Structure Project Finance,2004(1):86-95
[81]陈永胜.西部经济发展与法律促进的理论依据[J].甘肃政治学院学报,2001(58):95-98.
[82]姜士伟.论政府行为规范化[J].行政论坛,2007.82(4):13-18.
[83]刘辉,李尧远.基础设施市场化中的政府角色定位研究—基于制度分析视角[J].学术交流,2008.170(5):72-74.
[84]王秀云.我国基础设施投融资体制变迁及改革路径[J].中国城市经济,2008(5):3-4
[85]吴荻.城市基础设施建设与政府职能改革[J].兰州学刊,2006.149(2):172-174.
[86]郭小聪,黄伟娥.公用事业公私合作的新思路—政府应对公用事业市场化的新问题[J].江苏行政学院学报,2007(1):90-95.
[87]葛芳芳,汪霄.我国基础设施建设推行PFI模式的影响因素分析及发展对策研究[J].特区经济,2008(1):223-224.
[88]何卫东.我国城市环境基础设施市场化运作的现状与法律思考[J].法制经纬,2008(2):19-22.
[89]刘仁忠,黄志华.我国城市环境基础设施投融资问题初探[J].长江论坛,2006(5):69-71.
[90]肖翔.基础设施BOT投融资模式的难点及建议[J].中国铁路,2006(9):43-46.
[91]黄河东.城市公共物品市场化供给的路径研究[J].科技创业,2008(2):73-75.
[92]刘萍,丁海泉.我国政府在BOT投融资中的角色分析[J].哈尔滨商业大学学报(社会科学版),2007.92(1):38-40.
[93]朱茑.政府在城镇基础设施项目融资中的行为定位[J].上海企业,2006(7):61-63.
[94]王丽英.论城市基础设施市场化改革中政府监管的主要环节[J].中央财经大学学报,2008(4):5-66.
[95]钱维.改革基础设施投资制度的建议[J].宏观经济管理,2006(6):58-59.
[96]廖雨果.公私合作制(PPPs)中的政府角色分析[J].甘肃行政学院学报,2006(3):55-59.
[97]肖兴志.自然垄断产业规制改革模式研究[M].2003,大连:东北财经大学出版社.73-75.
[98]龙朝晖.自然垄断产业的规模经济性和范围经济性与管理体制改革[J].中山大学学报,2002. 42(2):27-29.
[99]王含春.强自然垄断定价理论研究述评[J].生产力研究,2008(15):149-151.
[100]王含春.强自然垄断规制定价模式分析[J].北京交通大学学报(社会科学版),2008.7(3):43-47.
[101]高金超.天然气行业垄断行为的经济学分析[J].经济与管理,2008.22(5):9-12.
[102]雷晓康.公共物品的提供模式及政府管制的效率比较[J].太原理工大学学报(社会科学版),2005.23(2):55-59.
[103]申心吉.自然垄断定价理论与中国电价激励性规制分析[J].重庆邮电学院学报,2005(2):170-173.
[104]陈宏平.管制下的企业行为与绩效分析[J].兰州大学学报(社会科学版),2000.28(1):22-27.
[105]王俊豪.A-J效应与自然垄断产业的价格管制模型[J].中国工业经济,2001(10):33-40.
[106]让-雅克.拉丰,让.梯若尔.政府采购与规制中的激励理论[M]..2004,上海:上海三联出版社.
[107]张同江.博弈理论在BOT项目招投标中的应用研究[D].天津:天津大学,2005.
[108]董再平.论公共产品的市场提供[J].经济与管理,2006(10):9-13.
[109]邓连喜.公私合作模式在准经营性基础设施项目中的应用[J].城市轨迹交通,2007(11):4-7.
[110]Li-Bing, A. Akintoye, P.J. Edwards, and C. Hardcastle., The allocation of risk in PPP/PFI construction projects in the UK[J]. International Journal of Project Management,2005, 23(1):25-35.
[111]范恒蔚.PPP模式在准经营性基础设施项目中的应用[J].经济视角,2006(12):45-46.
[112]王灏.城市轨道交通投融资问题研究[M].2006,北京:中国金融出版社.
[113]詹镇荣.论民营化类型中之公私协力[J].[台]月旦法学杂志,2003(11):8-29.
[114]al, D.D.e., A comparison of Project Finance and the Forfeiting Model as financing forms for PPP projects in Germany [J]. Project Management,2007.7(1):1-12.
[115]赵俊怀.论我国地方公共产品供给民营化[J].经济体制改革,2003(6):98-101.
[116]武恒光.綦好东,我国农村公共品融资机制绩效与声誉机制研究[J].河北经贸大学学报,2007(2):71-76.
[117]杨荣基.尖端博弈论[M].2007,北京:中国市场出版社.
[118]Kreps, D., M. M, R. J, and R. Wilson., rational cooperation in the finitely repeated prisoners"dilemma"[J]. Economic Theory,1982(27):245-52.
[119]张维迎.博弈论与信息经济学[M].2002,上海:上海三联出版社.463-473.
[120]Kreps, D.M.W., R.B., Reputation and imperfect information[J]. Economic theory 1982.27:53-79.
[121]Das, T.K. and B.-S. Teng., A risk perception model of alliance structuring[J]. Journal of International Management,2001.7(1):1-29.
[122]张喆,贾明,万迪防.不完全契约及关系契约视角下的PPP最优控制权配置探讨[J].外国经济与管理,2007.29(8):24-31.
[123]张晋东.基础设施领域竞争机制引入方式研究[J].经济经纬,2007(4):20-23.
[124]A.Ng, Loosemore, and Martin., Risk allocation in the private provision of public infrastructure[J]. International Journal of Project Management,2007.25(1):66-76.
[125]张雷宝.地方政府公共投资效率研究[M].2005,北京:中国财政经济出版社.
[126]漆思思.政府与私营企业的合作[J].兰州学刊,2005:123-127.
[127]Alonso-Conde, A.B., C. Brown, and J. Rojo-Suarez., Public private partnerships:Incentives, risk transfer and real options[J]. Review of Financial Economics,2007.16(4):335-349.
[128]黄燕,杨振斌,石秋霞.地方政府经营城市、创租行为及其发展趋向解析[J].城市问题,2007(2):72-78.
[129]Das, T.K. and B.-S. Teng., Resource and management in the strategic alliance making process[J]. Journal of Management,1998.24(1):21-42.
[130]魏玮.战略联盟组织的稳定性、组织治理与信用约束机制.经济管理,2006(8):49-56.
[131]何寿奎,傅鸿源.公共项目公私伙伴关系合作机制研究[J].统计与决策,2007(22):60-62.
[132]K, A.F., Risk perception and Bayesian analysis of international construction contract risks:The case of payment delays in a developing economy[J]. Project Management,2007(5):1-11.
[133]国彦兵.新制度经济学[M].第2版ed.2006:立信会计出版社.45-57.
[134]柯武刚,史漫飞.制度经济学社会秩序与公共政策[M].2000,北京:商务印书馆.157-160.
[135]Zayed, T., M. Amer, and J. Pan, Assessing risk and uncertainty inherent in Chinese highway projects using AHP[J]. Project Management,2007(5):1-12.
[136]刘向杰;黄喜兵;孔凌宇;公私合作中投机行为的防范[J].城市问题,2010(1)27:58-63
[137]顾海军.公共项目经济评价问题研究[D].南京:河海大学,2006.
[138]谢琳琳.公共投资建设项目决策机制研究[D].重庆:重庆大学,2005.
[139]鲍良.公共投资项目绩效评价与管理体系研究[D].北京:中国地质大学,2008.
[140]潘镇.联盟中的信任——一项中国情景下的实证研究[J].中国工业经济,2008(4):44-55.
[141]邱皓政,林碧芳.结构方程模型原理与应用[M].2008,北京:中国轻工业出版社.
[142]黄定轩,不同角色视角的建筑施工项目关键因素实证分析[J].土木工程学报,2007(4):104-110.
[143]宋华,徐二明,胡左浩.企业间冲突解决方式对关系绩效的实证研究[J].管理科学,2008.21(1):14-22.
[144]李永锋.合作创新中情境因素、合作效果与信任关系的实证[J].长沙理工大学学报(社会科学版),2007(2):82-86.
[145]李永锋.合作创新中企业声誉、共享价值观和相互信任的实证研究[J].技术经济与管理研究,2007(6):34-37.
[146]廖成林,仇明全.敏捷供应链背景下企业合作关系对企业绩效的影响[J].南开管理评论,2007. 10(1):106-120.
[147]陈晓红,吴小瑾.企业对外部环境满意度的规模差异实证研究[J].经济管理,2008(3):17-23.
[148]刘向杰,张克勇.公私合营监督机制研究[J].经济经纬,2008(6):19-22.
[149]吴小瑾,陈晓红.基于社会资本的集群中小企业融资行为研究[J].中南财经政法大学学报,2008(3):121-127.
[150]陈晓红,吴小瑾.中小企业社会资本的构成及其与信用水平关系的实证研究[J].管理世界,2007(1):153-155.
[151]张汉亚.投资环境研究[M].第1版,北京:中国计划出版社,2005.
[152]刘顺忠,官建成.区域创新系统信用环境的营造[J].科研管理,2002(3):74-79
[153]李朋林.人才环境及基于神经网络的陕西经济发展预测模型研究[J].管理学报,2008.5(5):733-736.
[154]王顺.我国城市人才环境综合评价指标体系研究[J].中国软科学,2004(3):148-151.
[155]李辉,李向阳,徐宣国.基于信任的供应链伙伴关系维系管理方法研究[J].管理工程学报,2007(4):72-80.
[156]M, R.D., SIM B SITKIN, and R.B.C. CAMERER., Not So Different Afterall:A Crossdiscipline View of Trust[J]. Academy of Management Review,1998.23(3):393-404.
[157]Hu and Bentler., Cutoff criteria for fit indexes in covariance structure analysis:Coventional criteria versus new alternatives[J]. Structural Equation Modeling,1999.6(1):1-55.
[158]Hair, J.F.J., W.C. Black, A., R.E., and R.L. Tatham., Multivariate data analysis(6th ed)[M]. Upper Saddle River, Prentice-Hall.,2006.
[159]tabachnick, B.G. and L.S. Fidell., using multivariate statistics[M].2007, Boston:Allyn and Bacon.
[160]Anderson, J.C. and D.W. Gerbing., Structural equation modeling in practice:A review and recommended two-step approach[J]. Psychological Bulletin,1988(103):411-423.
[161]James, L.R., Mulaik,S.A and J.M. Brett., causal analysis:Assumptions,models,and data[M]. Beverly Hills, sage,1982:1-176
[162]潘文安.供应链伙伴关系、整合能力与合作绩效的实证研究[J].科技进步与对策,2006(5):105-109.