四种北方阔叶树苗木对汽车尾气污染的生理反应及抗性评价
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
随着汽车保有量急剧上升,汽车尾气已经成为我国城市大气污染的第一污染源。汽车尾气直接和间接产生的污染物质对城市绿化植物的生长、发育和繁殖产生了深刻的影响。研究汽车尾气对绿化植物的影响及植物的抗性对城市环境的美化有着重要意义。本研究采用开顶式熏气室,设置相同浓度(25μg·m~(-3))不同处理时间(1、3、5、7d)和相同处理时间(2h)不同浓度(40、60、80、100μg·m~(-3))两种方式对一年生盆栽苗进行熏气处理,研究了汽车尾气对五角槭(Acer mono Maxim)、山荆子(Malus bacata Borkh)、山梨(Pyrus ussuriensis Maxim)和茶条槭(Acer ginnala Maxim)四种极具绿化价值北方阔叶树种的伤害症状和叶液pH值、膜脂过氧化、自由基清除系统及光合系统的影响。研究结果表明:
     1 汽车尾气胁迫下,树种不同,其受害症状及症状出现的早晚不同。高浓度处理下,四树种症状出现的先后为:山荆子、五角槭、山梨、茶条槭。叶片完全枯干的顺序为:山荆子、山梨、五角槭、茶条槭
     2 汽车尾气胁迫下,四树种的叶液pH值均出现下降,但下降幅度明显小于其它指标。茶条槭下降幅度最小,处理7d后比对照下降了1.52%,100μg·m~(-3)浓度下比对照下降了2.72%,山梨的下降幅度最大,处理7d后比对照下降了9.42%,100μg·m~(-3)浓度下比对照下降了13.89%。五角槭和山荆子介于两者之间。
     3 汽车尾气胁迫下,四树种的膜脂过氧化均受到影响,相对电导率上升,MDA含量增加。随着处理时间的延长,五角槭的相对电导率和MDA含量上升幅度最大,分别比对照升高了68.1%和52.50%,山荆子次之,茶条槭最小。随着处理浓度的增加山荆子的上升幅度最大,分别比对照升高了99.75%和52.52%,山梨次之,五角槭和茶条槭上升幅度较小。
     4 汽车尾气胁迫下,四树种的自由基清除系统受到严重影响。SOD、POD活性除山荆子在最高浓度处理下出现下降外,均呈上升趋势。从SOD活性变化幅度来看,五角槭和山荆子的变化幅度明显大于山梨和茶条槭。从POD活性的变化来看,由于茶条槭、五角槭的基础POD活性值与山荆子和山梨相差较大,造成茶条槭、五角槭的相对变化幅度远远大于山荆子和山梨,但其绝对值的变化幅
    
    度则远远小于山荆子和山梨。四树种的ASA含量均呈现下降趋势。山荆子和山
    梨的下降幅度大于五角械和茶条械。
     5汽车尾气胁迫下,四树种的光合系统也遭到严重影响。叶绿素含量、叶绿
    素a/b值、脚压m、脚汪刃、qP、。Psn、净光合速率均呈现下降趋势,qN则显
    著上升。从叶绿素含量来看,山荆子和山梨的下降幅度大于五角械和茶条械。从
    叶绿素确值的变化幅度来看,处理7d后四树种的变幅相差不大,100 p 9 .m-3
    浓度下山荆子和五角械的下降幅度大于山梨和茶条械。从Fvl下m、孙汪刃、qP、qN、
    。PSn、净光合速率的变化幅度总的来看,山荆子变幅最大,茶条械的变幅最小,
    五角械和山梨介于两者之间。
     6采用急性伤害表观症状评价法、多指标综合评价法对四树种抗性进行评
    价。其抗性大小顺序为:茶条械>五角械>山梨>山荆子。
With the rapid increase of the number of automobiles, automobile exhaust has become the first air pollution source in our country cities. The pollution matter produced by automobile exhaust has profound effect on the growth, development and propagation of greening tree species in cities. It is important to study the effect of automobile exhaust on the greening tree species and the tolerance of plants to automobile exhaust for the beautifying of the city environment. The effects of automobile exhaust on injury symptom, pH value of leaf cell juice, peroxidation of membrance lipid, free radical scavenging system and photosynthetic system of four greening tree species, Acer mono Maxim, Mains bacata Borkh, Pyrus ussuriensis Maxim, sad Acer ginnala Maxim were studied by means of fumigation in open top chamber. During the fumigation test, the four plants were exposed to exhaust gas of the same concentration (25 ug.m-3) for different time span (1, 3, 5,7d) and same time span(2h) but different concentration (40, 60. 80, 100 ug.m-3) , the results showed:
    1 Under the stress of automobile exhaust, apparent injury symptoms and the time series of appearance of injury symptoms were different in different tree species. Under the high concentration treatment, the order of appearance of injury symptoms in four trees was: Mains bacata Borkh, Acer mono Maxim, Pyrus usswiensis Maxim, Acer ginnala Maxim. The order of complete withering of leaves was: Malus bacata Borkh, Pyrus ussuriensis Maxim, Acer mono Maxim, Acer ginnala Maxim.
    2 Under the stress of automobile exhaust, pH value of leaf cell juice of four plants declined, but the variety was significantly less than other indexes. The variety range of Acer ginnala Maxim was least, the variety was decreased 15.2% than that of CK after seven days, under the stress of 100 u g .m-3, the variety range was decreased 2.72% than that of CK. The variety of Pyrus ussuriensis Maxim was highest, the variety range was decreased 9A2% than that of CK after seven days, under the stress of 100ug .m-3, the variety range was decreased 13.89% than that of CK. The variety range of four plants followed the order of Acer ginnala Maxim< Malus bacata Borkh and Acer mono Maxim< Pyrus ussuriensis Maxim.
    3 Under the stress of automobile exhaust, peroxidation of membrance Lipid were affected, relative conductivity and malondialdehyde(MDA) content were increased. With the increase of fumigation time, the variety range of relative conductivity and
    
    
    
    malondialdehyde(MDA) content of Acer mono Maxim was highest, followed by that oiMalus bacata Borkh, that of Acer ginnala Maxim was least With the increase of treatment concentration, that was enhanced 99. 75% and 52. 52% than that of CK, the variety range of Malus bacata Borkh was highest, that of Pyrus ussuriensis Maxim was in second place, that of Acer mono Maxim and Acer ginnala Maxim were least
    4 Under the stress of automobile exhaust, the free radical scavenging system was seriously affected. Superoxide dismutase(SOD)activiry, peroxidase(POD) activity of four plants were increased except Malus bacata Borkh in the high concentrate treatment The variation of SOD activity of Acer mono Maxim and Malus bacata Borkh were higher than that of Acer ginnala Maxim and Pyrus ussuriensis Maxim. From the variation of POD activity due to the basic POD activity values of Acer mono Maxim and Acer ginnala Maxim were far discrepant from that of Malus bacata Borkh and Pyrus ussuriensis Maxim, the relative variation of POD activity of Acer mono Maxim and Acer ginnala Maxim were far higher than that oiMalus bacata Borkh and Pyrus ussuriensis Maxim, while the absolute variation of Acer mono Maxim and Acer ginnala Maxim were far lower than that of Malus bacata Borkh and Pyrus ussuriensis Maxim.The ASA contents of four plants were declined, the variation of Malus bacata Borkh and Pyrus ussuriensis Maxim were higher than that of Acer mono Maxim and Acer ginnala Maxim .
    5 Under the stress of automobile exhaust, photosynthetic systems were damaged. Chlorophy
引文
1. Agrawal M, et al. 1982. Effect of ozone and sulphur dioxide pollutants separately and in mixture on chlorophyll and carotenoid pigments of Oryza sativa. Water, Air and soil polllution, 18:449.
    2. Anttonen S, et al. 1995. Fatty acids and ultra sturcture of ozone-exposed Aleppo pine (Pinus halepensis Mill.) needles. Environmental Polluiont, 87:235-242.
    3. Bacic T, Popovic Z. 1998. Preliminary report on epicuticular wax surface condition on stomata of Abies alba Mill. Needles from Risnjak National Park in Croatia. Acta Biologeca Cracoviensia Series Botaneca, 40:25~31.
    4. Biondi F, et al. 1992. Correlation between environmental parameters and leaf injury in Nicotiana tabacum L. CV.Bel-W3. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment, 22(1): 73~87.
    5. Bolhar-Nordenkampf H R, Oquist G.1993.Chlorophyll fluorescence as a tool in photosynthesis research. In: Photosynthesis and Production in a Changing Environment a field and laboratory manual London: Chapman & Hall, 193-206.
    6. Cnnningham et al. 1999. Environmental Science: A Global Concern. Boston: Mc Graw-Hill Higher Education, 385-409.
    7. Dodd I C, Doley D.1998. Growth responses of cucumber seedling to sulphr dioxide fumigation in a tropical environment Environmental & Experimental Botany 39(1):41~47.
    8. Genty B, et al. 1989. The relationship between the quantum yield of photosynthetic electron transport and quenching of chlorophyll fluorescence. Biochim Biophys Acta, 990:87-92.
    9. Heath R I.1994.Alterations of plant metabolism by ozone. Exposure. In: Ruth G Alscher et al. ed. Plant responses to the gaseous enviromnent London: 121~147.
    10. Kammerbauer J, Dick T. 2000. Monitoring of urban traffic emissions using some physiological indicators in Ricinus commanis L .Plants. Environ contamina Toxicol, 39:161~166.
    11. Krause G., Weis E.. 1991. Chlorophyll fluorescence and photosynthesis: the basics. Annu Rev Plant Physiol. Plant Mol. Bio., 142, 313-349
    12. Loppi S, et al. 1998. Biomonitoring of geothermal air pollution by epiphytic lichens and forest trees. 36(4-5):1079~1082.
    13. Maxwell D P. et al .1994. Growth at low temperature mimics high light acclimation in ChloreUa vulgaris. Plant Physiol, 105: 535-543.
    14. Maxwell K, Johnson GN .2000. Chlorophyll fluorescence- a practical guide. Journal of Experimental Botany, 51, 659-668.
    15. Mudd J B, Kozlowsld T T. 1975. Responses on plants to air pollution. New York: Academic Press, 141-158.
    
    
    16. Osmond C B, et al. 1980. Adaptive significance carbon dioxide cycling photosynthesis in water-stressed plants. In Turner N C, Kramer P J(eds). Adaptation of Plants to Water and High Temperature Stress. New York: John Wiley & Sons, 139~154.
    17. Qifu M, Murray F. 1991. Responses of potato plants to sulfur dioxide, water stress and their combination. New Phytologist, 118(1): 101~110.
    18. Scheidegger C., Schroeter B. 1995. Effects of ozone fumigation on epiphytic macrolichens: Ultrastructure, CO_2 gas exchange and chlorophyll fluorescence. Environmental Pollution, 88: 345-354.
    19. Schreiber U., et al. 1994. Chlorophyll fluorescence as a no intrusive indicator for rapid assessment of in vivo photosynthesis. In: Schulze E D, Caldwell M M (eds). Ecophysiology of photosynthesis. Berlin: Springer, V., 100, .49-70.
    20. Singh S.K., et al .1991. Air pollution tolerance index of plants. Journal of Environmental Management, 32:45~55.
    21. Tanaka K.1980. Role of superoxide dis in the defense against SO_2 toxicity and induction of superoxide dis mutase with SO_2 fumigation. In: Research report from the national institute for environmental studies. Tokyo: The National Institute for Environmental studies, 11:165.
    22. Tripathi B D, Tripathi A. 1992. Foliar injury and leaf diffusive resistance of rice and white bean in response to SO_2 and O_3 simply and in combination. Environmental. Pollution, 75 (3), 265-268.
    23. Tripathi B D, Tripathi A. 1992. Foliar injury and leaf diffusive resistance of rice and white bean in response to sulfur dioxide and ozone, singly and in combination. Environmental Pollution, 75(3):265~268.
    24. Van Hove LWA, Bossen ME. 1994. Physiological effects of five months exposure to low concentrations of O_3 and NH_3 on Douglas fir (Pseudotsuga menisci). Physiological Plant, 92: 140-148.
    25. Van Kooten O, Snel JFH. 1990. The use of chlorophyll nomenclature in plant stress physiology. Photosynthe Research, 25:147~150.
    26. Varshney S .R. K. et al. 1984. Effects of sucfur dioxide on ascorbic axid in crop plants0. Environmental pollution (Series A), 35 (4):285~290.
    27. Yungfeng Shan. 1996. The individual and combined effects of ozone simulated acid rain on growth gas exchange rate and water use efficiency of Pinus armandi Franch.. Environmental Pollution, 91:355~361.
    28.敖惠修,夏汉平.1999.大气污染与草坪植物选择.广东园林,(2):42~43.
    29.白月明,等,2001.臭氧对水稻叶片伤害、光合作用及产量的影响.气象,27(6):17~23.
    30.白月明,等,2002.O_3浓度增加对油菜的诊断试验研究.应用气象学报,13(3):364~370.
    31.卞泳梅,陈树元.1982.二氧化硫对植物细胞膜透性的影响.植物生理学通讯,(1):41~44.
    32.蔡志全等.2003.夜间低温胁迫对两种生长光强下藤黄幼苗叶片荧光特性和活性氧代谢的影响.应用生
    
    态学报,14(3):326~331.
    33.曹洪法,Talor O C 1985.低浓度SO_2长期暴露下菜豆的生长发育和气孔反应.见:中国环境科学研究院第—届学术报告会论文集.北京:中国环境科学出版社,106~114.
    34.曹洪法,等.1985.植物对SO_2污染的反应.环境科学,6(6):59~66.
    35.曹洪法.1990.我国大气污染及其对植物的影响.生态学报,10(1):7~12
    36.曹燕.2000.SO_2和氟化物对农作物危害的鉴别与防治.云南环境科学,19(1):26~28.
    37.陈树元,刘绍考.1986.开顶式田间熏气装置中SO_2浓度场的分布特性.环境科学,7(1):7~13.
    38.陈小勇,等.1995.低浓度二氧化硫引起蚕豆叶片过氧化氢累积及几种清除剂变化的研究.华东师范大学学报,(3):71~76.
    39.陈小勇,宋永昌.1994.蚕豆监测大气SO_2污染的指标筛选研究.应用生态学报,5(3):303~308.
    40.陈由强,等.2000.渗透胁迫对花生幼叶活性氧伤害和膜脂过氧化作用的影响.中国油料作物学报,22(1):53~56.
    41.丛者福.1998.SO_2污染空气下树木叶片叶绿素含量的动态变化.新疆农业大学学报,21(4):297~300.
    42.杜式华,等.1985.小麦幼苗对SO_2的生理反应.农业环境保护,3:10.
    43.段昌群.1995.植物对环境污染的适应与植物的微进化.生态学杂志,14(5):43~50.
    44.高吉喜,等.1996.臭氧对植物新陈代谢的影响.农村生态环境,12(4):42~46.
    45.高吉喜等.1997.二氧化硫对植物新陈代谢的影响(Ⅱ)——对光合、呼吸与物质代谢的影响.环境科学研究,10(6):5~9.
    46.高吉喜,等.1998.SO_2和酸雨对大豆的单—及复合效应应用与环境生物学报,4(2):132~135.
    47.高吉喜,等.1998.氟化物对植物新陈代谢影响研究进展.环境科学进展,6(3):25~30.
    48.高吉喜.1997.二氧化硫对植物新陈代谢的影响(Ⅰ)——对气孔、膜透性与物质代谢的影响.环境科学研究,10(2):36~39.
    49.勾晓华,王勋陵.1995.氟化氢对植物叶片中的SOD酶活力和MDA含量的影响.西北植物学报,15(5):71~76.
    50.顾尚华.2001.汽车尾气污染——城市环境的隐型杀手.经济与管理,(1):40~41.
    51.郭蕾,金银龙.2003.大气污染及对人体健康的影响.卫生研究,32(13):284~286.
    52.郭世永.1998.汽车尾气中NO_x的还原研究.新疆工学院学报,19(3):251~254.
    53.郭延平,等.2003.高温胁迫对柑橘光合速率和光系统Ⅱ活性的影响.应用生态学报,14(6):867~870.
    54.国家环保局科技标准司.1997.大气污染综合排放标准详解.北京:国家环境科学出版社,305~311.
    55.何冰,等.1997.干旱胁迫对甘薯叶片质膜透性及抗氧化酶类的影响.广西农业大学学报,16(4):287~291.
    56.何承坤,等.1996.干旱胁迫对番茄活性氧代谢的影响.福建农业大学学报,25(3):307-311.
    57.黄韵珠,王勋陵.1991.臭氧对辣椒不同发育时期光合作用的影响.农业环境保护,10(2):60~63.
    
    
    58.蒋高明.1992.大气污染指示植物的研究.城市环境与城市生态,5(4):40~45
    59.蒋高明.1993.木本植物对大气污染指示与监测作用研究.中科院植物所博士论文,1~111.
    60.金明红,等.2000.臭氧对水稻叶片膜脂过氧化和抗氧化系统的影响.环境科学,21(13):1~5.
    61.金明红,冯宗炜.2000.臭氧对冬小麦叶片膜保护系统的影响.生态学报,20(3):444~447.
    62.久保明弘.1996.大气污染植物遗伝子发现量变化.国立环境研究所,15(6)
    63.孔国辉,等.1984.98种园林植物对氯气的反应和抗性研究.生态学报,4(1):21~23.
    64.孔樟良,周霞萍.1994.二氧化氮、氯气对温州蜜柑叶片毒害实验初报.浙江柑桔,(1):42.
    65.李从质.1999.世纪末的最后一战——我国展开的汽车尾气治理之战.价格与市场,(4):46~47.
    66.李汉卿,等.1985.环境污染与生物.北京:黑龙江科学技术出版社,6~32.
    67.李合生.2001.植物生理生化实验原理和技术.高等教育出版社,58~207.
    68.李吉跃,等.1999.北京市大气污染状况及抗污染树种的选择.首都绿化委员会办公室,北京市科协技术学会编,21世纪的首都绿化.北京:中国林业出版社,249~251.
    69.李世承等.1986.大气污染与植物脱镁叶绿素的关系.辽宁大学学报,(4):58.
    70.李双喜,等.1999.汽车尾气污染的危害及控制.哈尔滨建筑大学学报,32(2):35~39.
    71.李珍珍,韩阳.2000.抗坏血酸对小麦种子老化及幼苗脂质过氧化的影响.辽宁大学学报,27(2):170~172.
    72.林植芳,等.1985.花生离体叶片衰老的调节 1.抗坏血酸和甘氨酸对几种酶的活性影响.植物生理学通讯,(4):33.
    73.刘鸿先,等.1985.低温对不同耐寒力的黄瓜幼苗子叶各细胞中SOD的影响.植物生理学报,11(1):48~57.
    74.刘荣坤,等.1983.植物对二氧化硫生理反应的研究Ⅱ—植物气孔与伤害几ABA的保护效应.植物生理学通讯,(4):25~29.
    75.刘荣坤,李世承.1982.二氧化硫对蓖麻叶质膜透性、叶绿素含量和花粉生长的影响.中国环境科学,3(2):29~43.
    76.刘荣坤.1982.二氧化硫对植物伤害及其机理的研究.中国环境科学,(6):75~78.
    77.刘艳菊,丁辉.2001.植物对大气污染的反应与城市绿化,植物学通报,18(5):577~586.
    78.刘燕云,等.1989.五种农作物对SO_2的剂量反应及其急性伤害阈值.中国环境科学,9(3):183~190.
    79.刘祖祺,张石城.1994.植物逆境生理学基础.北京:中国农业出版社,333~369.
    80.庞士铨.1990.植物逆境生理学基础.哈尔滨:东北林业大学出版社,83~120.
    81.彭长连,等.1998.旅游和工业化对亚热带森林地区大气环境质量及两种木本植物叶绿素荧光特性的影响.植物学报,40(3):270~276.
    82.彭长连,等.2000.高温对生长在加副CO_2条件下水稻离体叶片叶绿素荧光的影响.热带亚热带植物学报,8(2):91~96.
    83.彭长连,等.2002.城市绿化植物对大气污染的响应.热带亚热带植物学报,10(4):321~327.
    
    
    84.彭新凯,胡朝辉.2001.汽车尾气污染及其控制对策.中国标准化,(5):10~11.
    85.钱易,唐孝炎.2000.环境保护与可持续发展.北京:高等教育出版社,57~63.
    86.钱永常,余叔文 a.1991.大豆对SO_2的适应性反应.植物生理学报,17(3):232~238.
    87.钱永常,余叔文 b.1991.大豆适应SO_2过程中出现的15KD蛋白.植物生理学报,17(4):365~372.
    88.邱栋梁,等.2002.模拟酸雨对龙眼叶片气体交换和叶绿素a 荧光参数的影响.植物生态学报,26(4):441~446.
    89.邱国敏.2001.汽车尾气对空气污染的危害与对策.工业安全与环保,27(8):35~36.
    90.沈岳年,高丽蓉.1999.汽车尾气污染的危害及治理对策.内蒙古石油化工,25:27~29.
    91.舒俭民,曹洪法.1987.低浓度SO_2长期暴露对菜豆生长和产量的影响.中国环境科学,5:9~12.
    92.舒俭民,等.1988.低浓度SO_2对小麦生长的影响.农业环境保护,7(3):16~18.
    93.苏行,等.2002.广州市大气污染对两种绿化植物叶绿素荧光特性的影响.植物生态学报,26(5):599~604.
    94.孙志虎.2002.茶条槭、山荆子、山桃和山梨抗旱性研究.东北林业大学硕士论文.21~22.
    95.唐文天.1982.大气中气体污染物浓度的时间分布特征.环境科学,3(6):11~15.
    96.田砚亭,等.1983.几种苗木对35SO_2的吸收和运转.环境科学,4(6):35~38.
    97.王焕校,吴玉树.1981.植物受氯气危害后叶汁pH及细胞膜透性的变化.中国环境科学,(3):61~64.
    98.王金文.2002.汽车尾气污染的因素及预防措施.安徽建筑工业学院学报(自然科学版),10(2):48~51.
    99.王明启,王莉.1991.工厂绿化抗污树种选择的研究.吉林林学院学报,7(3):58~62.
    100.王英斌.1998.全球植物生存告急.环境,(11):15.
    101.温达志,等.2003.30种园林植物对短期大气污染的生理生态反应.植物生态学报,27(3):311~317.
    102.吴国平,等.1999.我国四城市空气中PM_(2.5)和PM_(10)的污染水平.中国城市科学,19(2):133~137.
    103.吴丽英,等.1989.二氧化硫对作物光合强度和呼吸强度影响的研究.农业环境保护,8(2):9~12.
    104.武宝玕,格林·托德.1985.小麦幼苗中过氧化物歧化酶与幼苗脱水忍耐力相关性研究.植物学报,27(2):152~160.
    105.小林伸治.2002.自动车排出粒子状物质排出特性大气中动态解析.国立环境研究所,21(5)
    106.徐云,等.1994.臭氧和氟化氢复合熏气对小麦叶片形态和生理机能的影响.西北植物学报,14(6):64~69.
    107.许大全.2002.光合作用效率.上海:上海科学技术出版社,29~35.
    108.严重玲,等.1995.模拟酸雨对绿豆、玉米生理生态特性的影响.应用生态学报,6,增刊,124~131.
    109.杨敏生,等.1997.树木抗旱性研究进展.河北林果研究,12(1):87~93.
    110.杨小波,等.2001.城市生态学.北京:科学出版社,129~147.
    111.杨玉珍.1995.植物受氟化物污染后糖代谢及叶汁pH值的变化研究.河南农业大学学报,29(3):95~97.
    112.殷京生,孙曰.1998.环境现代化:—个不能忽略的城市发展问题.环境,(10):6~7.
    
    
    113.桜井健郎.2000.自动车排出挥发性有机化合物(VOC)调查.国立环境研究所,19(1)
    114.余叔文,等.1979.植物对二氧化硫的反应和抗性研究(Ⅱ)质膜透性的变化和二氧化硫伤害.植物生理学报,5(4):403~409.
    115.余叔文.1981.大气污染伤害植物症状图谱.上海:上海科学技术出版社,5~21.
    116.余晓,秦毓茜.2000.不容忽视的环境问题之首——大气污染.农业与技术,20(2):25~26.
    117.俞飞,等.1993.SO_2、NO_2及其复合污染对青菜体内抗坏血酸含量的影响.环境科学,14(1):64~66.
    118.曾广权,等.1985.ML—1型开顶式熏气室的构造与性能.环境科学,6(4):6~11.
    119.张建国,等.1994.京西山区人工林水分参数的研究(Ⅲ).北京林业大学学报,16(4):46~53.
    120.张雷明,等.2003.长期施氮对旱地小麦灌浆期叶绿素荧光参数的影响.应用生态学报,14(5):695~698.
    121.张涛.2001.汽车尾气污染与双燃料技术研究.云南环境科学,20(1):31~34.
    122.张泽煌,等.2000.低温胁迫对茄子的伤害及茄子抗寒机理.福建农业学报,15(1):40~42.
    123.张志杰,张维平.1991.环境污染生物监测与评价.北京:中国环境科学出版社,1~204.
    124.赵勇,等.2002.郑州市大气环境中的NO_2污染与灰色预测.安全与环境学报,2(4):38~40.
    125.郑淑颖,王丽萍.1999.广州城市的氧化型污染及其对植物的影响.生态学报,18(4):25~29.
    126.郑淑颖.2000.二氧化硫污染对植物影响的研究进展.生态科学,19(1):59~64.
    127.中国大百科全书.1983.环境科学.北京:中国大百科全书出版社,483~484.
    128.周军英,等.1993.SO_2和NO_2复合污染对番茄超氧化物歧化酶及叶片伤害的影响.中国环境科学,13(6):429~432.
    129.周康群,冯岩.2001.臭氧对广州主要栽培蔬菜生长的影响.华中农业大学学报,20(4):344~347.
    130.周以良,等.1986.黑龙江树木志.哈尔滨:黑龙江科学技术出版社,267~412.
    131.邹晓燕,等.1989.植物对SO_2的敏感性与超氧化物歧化酶活性的关系.中国环境科学,9(6):427~432.
    132.佐治光.2000.植物大气污染障害古问题对新仮说.国立环境研究所,19(3)

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700