摘要
代工模式在相当一段时间内仍是我国大部分代工企业的务实选择,以及赖以生存的主要方式。但是,随着全球经济增长速度的逐步减慢,国际竞争日益加剧,贴牌模式(即代工模式)的弊端也逐渐显现出来。越来越多的代工企业面临着转型升级的重要问题。因此,自主品牌决策成为代工企业的一个重要战略选择。
代工生产和自主品牌是企业依附经营和自主经营的战略选择问题。对于企业而言,代工或自主品牌的选择受多方面因素影响的,除了受企业自身的资源和能力的影响,还需要考虑环境的复杂性和动态性带来的机会和威胁,企业家精神和适合的战略导向的引导与推动。而来源于企业家精神和企业创业的战略领域的企业家导向,在环境日益不确定的今天越来越受到学者的关注和重视。发展自主品牌是企业自主创新的重要方面,企业家导向对企业创新方式选择有重要影响,然而对环境的不确定性、创新方式选择进行整合研究的较少,而这也是本文研究的目的和方向。
结合这一背景,通过文献的综述,从代工企业的角度,将不确定性环境、企业家导向、代工企业自主品牌战略决策的选择三者综合考虑,发现三者的关系趋势从而提出假设,进而问卷调查用实证分析来验证各个变量间的关系。具体而言,通过对相关文献的归纳和梳理,通过相关分析分析出企业家导向、不确定性环境与自主品牌决策存在着显著的相关关系;通过回归分析得出,企业家导向对自主品牌战略决策有着显著的正向相关关系,不确定性环境总体上对自主品牌决策具有负向的影响;通过回归分析证实不确定性环境对企业家导向与自主品牌战略决策间的关系具有调节作用。本文的实证研究,对于代工企业在不确定环境中更好地运用企业家导向做出战略选择,进而转型升级,提升竞争优势具有重要的参考价值。
本文在实证研究的基础上,对代工企业的品牌战略选择提出了相应的对策和建议,代工企业应重视企业家自身的引导行为,在企业内部培养企业家导向,转变观念,审时度势,抓住机遇。文章最后总结了本研究的不足之处以及今后研究的展望。
Subcontracting model is the main form of survival for Chinese foundries with cooperation of multinational companies, is still the practical choice.OEM tendency has also become an important strategic choice. However, with further global economic growth gradually slowed down, increasing international competition, the drawbacks of OEM is gradually revealed, subcontracting manufacturers must consider restructuring. Therefore, independent brand strategy decision is an important strategic choice.
OEM and independent brand decision is choosing between dependent management and independent management. Strategic options is affected by many kinds of factors, not only internal resources and capabilities, but also the opportunities and threats brought the complexity and the dynamic nature of the environment, entrepreneurship and Strategic orientation. Entrepreneurial Orientation (EO)is the critical construct in the strategic management and entrepreneurship, which is increasingly paid more attention by the scholars. Development of own brands is an important aspect of independent innovation of enterprises. Entrepreneurial Orientation (EO) has an important impact on the selection of innovation-oriented mode.However, there is little integrate research on the Environment Uncertainty (EU), Entrepreneurial Orientation (EO) and independent brand decision, which is the purpose of and direction this research.
In conjunction with this background, through literature review, from the perspective of the foundry business, the paper makes comprehensive consideration of the environment uncertainty, Entrepreneurial Orientation (EO) and independent brand decision of foundries, finding out the relationship among them to raise assumptions and use the statistics analysis to validate them.
Specifically, through the Pearson correlation analysis, we find entrepreneurial orientation, environmental uncertainty and independent brand decision-making has significant correlation. And also, though regression analysis, we find entrepreneurial orientation is significantly and positively associated with independent brand decision-making; environmental uncertainty has negative impact on independent brand decision-making. Finally, though hierarchical regression analysis, we find the uncertainty of the environment play a regulatory role for the relationship between entrepreneurial Orientation and self-brand tendency.
Finally, based on the investigation and analysis above, some suggestions are put forward to the independent brand decision-making of subcontracting manufactures, and summarizes the research gaps and future research prospects.
引文
[1]Abraham.K,Taylor. Firms'use of outside contractors:Theory and Evidence:Theory and Evidence[J].Journal of Labour Eeonomies,1996.14:394-424.
[2]Amsden AH. Asia's Next Giant:South Korea and Late Industrialization[M].New York: Publication,1989.
[3]Andreas Rauch,Johan Wiklund, G.T.Lumpkin,Michael Frese. Entrepreneurial Orientation and Business Performance:An Assessment of Past Research and Suggestions for the Future. Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice.2009,(5):761-781
[4]Barney, J.B. Firm resources and sustained competitive advantage [J].Journal of Management,1991(17):99-120.
[5]Bourgeois, L. Strategy and Environment:A Conceptual Integration [J]. Academy of Management Review 5(January) 1980, (5):25-39.
[6]Buchko A. Conceptualization and Measurement of Environmental Uncertainty:An Assessment of the Miles and Snow Perceived Environmental Uncertainty Scale[J].Academy of Management Journal,1994,(37):410-425.
[7]Cheng J S,Blankson C,Wu P C S,Chen S SM.A Stage Model of International Brand Development:The Perspectives of Manufacturers from Two Newly Industrialized Economies South Korea and Taiwan[J]. Industrial Marketing Management,2005,34(5): 504-514.
[8]Ching H & Wayne C. From Contract Manufacturing to Own Brand Management:The Role of Learning and Cultural Heritage Identity[J]Management and Organization Review,2008(4):109-133
[9]Churchill N.C & Lewis V.L., The Five Stage of Small Business Growth[J].Harvard Business Review,1983,3(61):30-50
[10]Clark T.P.& R.Varadarajan,W.M.P ride. Environmental Management:The Construct and Research propositions [J]. Journal of Business Research,1994,29(1):23 28.
[11]Covin J.G., Slevin D.P. A conceptual model of entrepreneurship as firm behavior [J]. Entrepreneurship:Theory & Practice.1991,16(1):7-24,
[12]Covin,J.G.,Slevin,D.P. A Conceptual Model of Entrepreneurship as Firm Behavior [J].Entrepreneurship:Theory&Practice.1991,16(1):7-24
[13]Jeffrey G. Covin G.T.,Lumpkin.Entrepreneurial Orientation Theory and Research: Reflections on a Needed Construct[J]. Entrepreneurship:Theory&Practice.2011(9):855-870
[14]Dess G.G.&Beard D.W. Dimensions of Organizaxional Task Environments[J].Administrative Science Quarterly,1984,29(1):52-73.
[15]Dess G.G.,Lumkin GT. and MeFarlin D.. The role of Entrepreneurial Orientation in Stimulating Effective Corporate Entrepreneurship, Academy of Management Executive, 2005 (19):147-156.
[16]Dess, G G., G. T. Lumpkin and L. G. Covin. Entrepreneurial Strategy Making and Firm Performance:Tests of Contingency and Configurational Models[J]. Strategic Management Journal,1997, (18):677-695..
[17]Doyle,Peter H. Building Successful Brands:The Strategic Options.[J] Journal of Consumer Marketing,1999,7(2):5-20.
[18]Duncan R.B.Characteristics of Organizational Environments and Perceived Environmental
[19]Dyer JH, Singh H. The Relational View:Cooperative Strategy and Sources of Interorganizational Competitive Advantage [J]. Academy of Management Review,1998, 23(4):660-679;
[20]Forbes N,Wield D. From Followers to Leaders:Managing Technology and Innovation in Newly Industrializing Countries[M].Rutledge,2001:137-140
[21]Frese M., Brantjes A, Hoorn R., Psychological success factors of Small scale businesses in Namibia:The roles of Strategy process,Entrepreneurial Orientation and the Environment[J]Journal of Developmental Entrepreneurship,2002(7):259-282.
[22]GrafLA, M Hemmasi, JA Lust and Y Liang. Perception of Desirable Organizational Reforms in Chinese State Enterprises [J]. International Studies of Management and Organization, 1990, (20):47-56.
[23]Grant, R. M. Contemporary Strategy Analysis,4th. USA:Blackewell Publishers, Inc:5., 2002:115-129.
[24]HAMEL G.,PRAHALAD C.K. Competing for the Future[M].Boston,MA:Harvard Business School Press,1994.
[25]Hobdy,M.,Innovation in East Asia:The Challenge to Japan[M]. Edward Elgar Publishing Limited,1995.
[26]Hobdy M. The electric industries of Asia-Pacific:Exploiting International Production Networks for Economic Development. Asian-Pacific Economic iterature[J].2001,15(1):3-30
[27]Horng C, Chen W. From Contract Manufacturing to Own Brand Management:The Role of Learning and Cultural Heritage Identity [J]. Management and Organization Review,2008, 4(1):109-133.
[28]Huber, GP. Perceived Environmental Uncertainty:Effects of Information and Structure[J]. Academy of Management Review,1975,18:133-143
[29]Hult,Knight G A. Innovativeness:Its antecedents and impact on business performance J.Industrial Marketing Management,2004 (33) 5:429-438.
[30]Jansen,J.J.P.,Van Den Bosch,F.A.J.,Volberda,H.W..Exploratory Innovation, Exploitative Innovation, and Performance:Effects of Organizational Antecedents and Environmental Moderators[J]. Management Science,2006,52(11):1661-1674.
[31]Jeffrey and Susan. Marketing Strategy Selection:Impact of Entrepreneurial Orientation and Environmental Perception[J]. The Marketing Management Journal,2002,(12):32-36
[32]Kim,Linsu.From Imitation to Innovation[M] Massachusetts:Harvard Business School Press,1997
[33]Knight G A. Cross-cultural Reliability and Validity of Scale to measure Firm Entrepreneurial Orientation[J].Journal of Business Venturing,1997,12(2):213-225
[34]Kotler,P. Marketing Management. Prentice Hall:Englewood Cliffs.,1994:112-136
[35]Lee Jin Ren, Chen Jen Shyang. Dynamic Synergy Creation with Multiple Business Activities: Toward a Competence-based Business Model for OEM Suppliers[J].Advances in Applied Business Strategy,1999(1) 35-36
[36]Lee J-R,Chen J-S. Dynamic Synergy Creation with Multiple Business Activities:Toward a Competence-based Business Model for OEM Suppliers[J].Advances in Applied Business Strategy,2000(6A):209-228.;
[37]Lee,Sukoco.The Effects of Entrepreneurial Orientation and Knowledge Management Capability on Organizational Effectiveness in Taiwan:The Moderating Role of Social Capital [J].International Journal of Management 2007,3 (24):549-572.
[38]Lumpkin,Dess G G..Clarifying the Entrepreneurial Orientation Construct and Linking it to Performance [J].Academy of Management Review 1996,(21) 1:135-172.
[39]McNamara,G.,Aime,F.&Vaaler,P M.Is Performance Driven by Industry-or-firm-specific factors? A Response to Hawawini,Subramanian and Verdin[J].Strategic Management Journal,2005,26(11):1075-1081
[40]Mengue B.,Auh.Creating a Firm-level Dynamic Capability through Capitalizing on Market Orientation and Innovativeness,Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science,2006,34(1):63-73.
[41]Miller D. The correlates of entrepreneurship in three types of firms [J]. Management Science,1983(29):76-78
[42]Miller D..The Structure and Environmental Correlates of Business Strategy[J].Strategic Management Journal,1987,7(3):233-249.
[43]Milliken FJ. Three type of Perceived Uncertainty about the Environment J]. Academy of management review,1987,12(l):133-143
[44]Mintzberg H. Strategy Making in Three Modes [J]. California Management Review,1973, 16(2):44-53
[45]Mintzberg H. The Structure of Organizations [M].Prenctice-Hall.1979.
[46]Pan Fan, Zhang Zigang K. Cross-cultural Challenges when Doing Business in China, Singapore Management Review [J].2004, (26):1-8.
[47]Papadakis,Lioukas, and Chambers. Strategic Decision Making Process:The Role of Management and Context [J].Strategic Management Journal,1998, (19):115-147.
[48]Pfeffer J., Salancik, G. R. The External Control of Organizations. A Resource Dependence Perspective. Stanford:Stanford University Press.2003:70-71
[49]Porter, M.E, Competitive Advantage:Creating and Sustaining Superior Performance [M].Free Press, New York.1985.6.
[50]Prahalad CK, Hamel G The Core Competence of the Corporation[J].Harvard BusinessReview,1990,68(3):79-91
[51]Quinn J B. Strategic Outsourcing:Leveraging Knowledge Capabilities [J]. Sloan Management Review,1999,40(4):9-21
[52]Rajagopalan N, Rasheed A, Datta D. Strategic Decision Processes:Critical Review and Future Directions [J].Journal of Management,1993 (19):349-384.
[53]Rauch A.,Wiklund J.,Lumpkin,G.T&Frese M. Entrepreneurial Orientation and Business Performance:Cumulative Empirical Evidence[J]. Paper presented at the 2004 Babson College-Kauffman Foundation Entrepreneurship Research Conference.
[54]Russell R D, Russell C J. An Examination of the Effects of Organizational Norms, Organizational Structure, and Environmental Uncertainty on Entrepreneurial Strategy [J]. Journal of Management,1992(4):639-656.
[55]Schenkar O.. International Joint Ventures'Problems in China:Risks and Remedies [J]. Long Range Planning,1990(23):82-90.
[56]Stevenson H. H. and L. C. Jarillo. A Paradigm of Entrepreneurship:Entrepreneurial Management [J]. Strategic Management Journal,1990 (11):17-27.
[57]Tao Yao,Srinivas Talluri.Outsourcing timing,contract selection,and negotiation [J]. International Journal of Production Research,2010,1(48):305-326
[58]Tan J.&Litschert R.J.,Environment-strategy Relationship and its Performance Implication: An Empirical Study of the Chinese Electronic Industry[J]. Strategic Management Journal,1994,15(1):1-20.
[59]Tan J.,Tan D., Environment-strategy Co-evolution and Co-alignment:A Staged Model of Chinese SOEs under Transition[J].Strategic Management Journal,2005,26:141-157.
[60]Tan, L. Regulatory Environment and Strategic Orientations in a Transitional Economy:A Study of Chinese Private Enterprise [J]. Entrepreneurship:Theory and Practice,1996(Fall): 31-46.
[61]Thompson, JD. Organizations in action[M].New York:McGraw-Hill,1967
[62]Volberda,H.W.Building the flexible firm:How to remain competitive[M].Oxford University Press,1998.
[63]Voss Z.G,Moorman C., An Empirical Examination of the Complex Relationships between Entrepreneurial Orientation and Stakeholder Support[J].European Journal of Marketing, 2005(39):1132-1150.
[64]Wassim Aloulou and Alain Fayolle. A Conceptual Approach of Entrepreneurial Orientation within Small Business Context[J].Journal of Enterprising Culture,2005,13(1):21-45
[65]Wiklund, L. The Sustainability of the Entrepreneurial Orientation-Performance Relationship [J]. Entrepreneurship:Theory and Practice,1999(24):27-48.
[66]Wiklund,J. Entrepreneurial orientation as predictor of performance and entrepreneurial behavior in small firms[M]..Babson Park, MS:Babson College.,1998:281-296
[67]Yi-Ping Lien. An Empirical Study of OEM in Taiwan's Apparel Industry[J]. Global Economic Review,2009.9(38):297-319
[68]Zahra S.A.,Nielsen, A.P.& Bogner W. Corporate entrepreneurship,knowledge,and competence development[J].Entrepreneurship:Theory and practice,1999,23(3):169--190
[69]Zahra,S.A.Technology Strategy and Financial Performance:Examining the Moderating Role of the Firm's Competitive Environment[J].Journal of BusinessVenturing,1996,11(3):189-219.
[70]陈宏辉·“贴牌”是一种过时的战略选择吗——来自广东省制造型企业的实证分析[J].中国工业经济,2008,1(1):96-104
[71]陈柳,刘志彪.代工生产、自主品牌和内生激励[J].经济评论,2006,9(5):8-13
[72]陈晓萍,徐淑英,樊景立等.组织与管理研究的实证方法[M].北京:北京大学出版社,2010:162-174.
[73]陈振祥.ODM策略之理论架构与实证[D].台湾人学商学研究所博十论文,1997:5-25
[74]邓建萍.中国制造业外包模式研究[D].北京对外经济贸易大学博士论文,2010:10-30
[75]高展军.市场导向、企业家导向对技术创新的影响研究[J].经济界,2008(5):20-22
[76]谷雨.国际代工模式变迁与中国制造企业升级[D].天津财经大学硕士学位论文,2010:2-37
[77]胡军,陶锋,陈建林.珠三角OEM企业持续成长的路径选择-基于全球价值链外包体系的视角[J].中国工业经济,2005(8):42-49.
[78]冀山君.中国OEM代工模式的效应分析和转型研究[D].浙江大学硕士毕业论文,2008
[79]焦豪.创业导向下企业动态能力提升机制研究[D].浙江大学硕士学位论文,2007
[80]焦晓波等.不确定环境下的创业导向、创新和营销能力演化[J].管理研究案例与评论,2010(5):343-362
[81]李大元.不确定环境下的企业持续优势[D].浙江大学博士学位论文,2008
[82]李艺,司有和.探索式创新、利用式创新与绩效:战略和环境的影响[J].南开管理评论,2008(5):4-12.
[83]李雪松.环境不确定性对知识管理战略实施效果的影响[D].重庆大学博士学位论文,2009
[84]刘兰.GVC视角下江苏省OEM企业的可持续发展研究[D].江苏大学硕士学位论文,2010
[85]刘宇.企业家导向、市场导向、产品创新与企业绩效的关系研究[D].吉林大学博世学位论文,2009:10-45
[86]刘志彪.全球化背景下中国制造业升级的路径与品牌战略[J].财经问题研,2005(5):25-31
[87]刘志彪.中国沿海地区制造业发展:国际代工模式与创新[J].南开经济研究,2005(5):37-45
[88]刘志彪.重新审视沿海地区的国际代工模式[N].光明日报,2006-5-23
[89]楼天阳.企业家导向的理论基础、测量及相关变量[J].浙江工商大学学报,2011(5):68-75
[90]卢锋.产品内分工:一个分析框架[R].北京:北京大学中国经济中心讨论稿系列,No1C20040051
[91]吕黎.中国代工企业特色的升级战略路径研究[J]企业活力,2009(10):81-84
[92]聂卉.国际代工与中国自主品牌的关系研究综述[J].当代经济,2009,9(9):60-62
[93]汪浩瀚.从确定性到复杂性——经济理论和分析方法的变革[J].福建论坛,2001(5)
[94]汪涛,郭锐.中国企业品牌战略决策影响因素研究——环境不确定性、企业家导向和组织能力[J].武汉大学学报,2008,11(6):852-857
[95]汪涛,郭锐.基于环境不确定性和企业家导向的中国企业品牌战略决策研究[J].中国软科学,2008(3):97-107
[96]王海燕,周元.新型贴牌与自主创新[J].中国软科学,2007(9):21-24
[97]王高成.不确定性环境下的企业柔性研究[D].合肥工业大学硕士论文,2009:5-36
[98]王益谊,席酉民.组织环境的不确定性研究综述[J].管理工程学报,2005,19(1):46-49
[99]魏江,焦豪.创业导向、组织学习与动态能力关系研究[J].外国经济与管,2008,30(2):36~41
[100]温家宝.十一届人大三次会议政府工作报告[EB/OL].http://www.gov.cn/20101h/content_1548053.htm
[101]吴解生.代工企业成长空间与竞争策略经济问题探索[J].2010(2):109-113
[102]夏先良.中国企业从OEM升级到ODM的商业模式抉择[J].财贸经济,2003(9):15-17
[103]新华网.代工企业:要么转移,要么升级[EB/OL].[2010-7-9].http://finance.qq.com/a/20100709/004706.htm
[104]刑建文.环境动态性对创业导向与绩效关系的作用研究[D].吉林大学硕士学位论文,2009
[105]徐秀琴,张凯祥.“代工困境”与“升级”迷思:解构从OEM到OBM的虚假关系[C].东海大学“台湾金融与产业发展”博士生研讨会,2008
[106]薛红志.论竞争战略对创业导向-绩效关系的影响[J].外国经济与管理,2005,27(12):28-36
[107]杨桂菊.本土代工企业自创国际品牌——演进路径与能力构建[J].管理科 学,2009,12(6)132-140
[108]杨桂菊.代工企业转型升级:演进路径的理论模型——基于3家本土企业的案例研究[J].管理世界,2010(6):130-134
[109]杨桂菊.国际代工背景下企业自创品牌的决策思路[J].改革,2007(11):80-84
[110]张映红.动态环境对公司创业战略与绩效关系的调节效应研究[J].中国工业经济,2008(1):106-111
[111]张玉利.创业管理[M].北京:机械工业出版社,2008,204-205.
[112]张玉利等.创业管理研究新观点综述[J].外国经济与管理,2006,28(5):1-7