美日能源税制与相关产业发展研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
能源税收体系的构建,有助于节约能源、保护环境,其根本是通过对纳税人、征税主体以及能源税率等要素的设计,将节能和环保理念融入到一国的税法体系当中,受到诸多学者和政策决策者的关注和研究。中国石油对外依存度已经超过50%,能源安全与否将对中国经济安全产生直接影响。但中国目前还没有完整的能源税收体系,这一有力控制能源消费手段的缺失,对中国有效控制能源消费、缓解能源紧张局面、保证中国能源安全产生了极大的负面效应。虽然中国目前能源税收体系还不科学、不完整,但是与能源相关的税制改革已经通过某些税种的改革逐步展开,换而言之,在能源环境严峻的今天,中国构建比较系统的能源税制只是时间问题,故笔者希望通过本文的研究能够对中国能源税制的设计起到借鉴作用。
     本研究通过理论和实证方法,对美日两国能源税制发展与演变,能源税制定位及构成和能源税制对能源产业、环境产业和低碳产业的影响进行了系统分析,发现如下重要结论:
     第一,美日能源税立法的核心目的是节约能源和开发替代传统能源的清洁能源。美日能源税收减免等优惠措施的覆盖范围从早期的家庭能源消费到有限的节能设备;与此同时,对替代能源的激励亦从早期数量有限的几种替代能源到如今几十种清洁能源的生产、供给乃至相关设备。而在上述措施实施的过程中,环保理念始终被坚持。能源税法有利于能源市场化机制的运行。美日政府在利用能源税收等财政手段调节能源生产消费的同时,注重能源市场自身机制的作用,逐步放开相关领域的管制。故能源税法在调节能源生产和消费的同时,亦在为能源市场竞争机制提供有力政策保障。
     第二,美国能源税收支出的目的侧重于保证传统能源的安全,鼓励新能源的发展。日本能源税收支出侧重于鼓励新能源发展,试图通过新能源发展替代传统能源,效果显著。日本能源税收政策的实施对日本各产业能源强度的降低作用显著,而美国则很不明显。究其原因,美国本土能源资源丰富,并且在海外亦有庞大能源供应基地,美国政府虽有能源危机意识,但在实践执行中并未能够严格予以执行。相比美国,日本能源资源贫瘠,能源危机意识十分强烈,日本政府的外交和经济活动很多都是围绕能源资源进行,并且在日常生产生活中将提高能源效率、开发新能源置于重要位置。
     第三,美日两国能源税收的征收有助于两国环保产业的发展。两国技术进步对清洁能源或可再生能源的使用都起到了积极的促进作用。由于能源税和技术进步对能源效率的改善存在作用,这可能导致两国均出现能源的回弹效应,即扩大能源的消耗,但如果回弹效应过大,会导致企业主体进一步改善其能源消耗技术,提高利用效率。
     第四,美国能源消耗虽然较大,但美国自身能源资源较为丰富,美国采取能源税收政策,主要是基于长期能源绩效和环境目标考虑,为此对美国能源价格影响并不显著。相比美国,日本能源资源十分匮乏,其出台能源税收政策不仅关注长期利益,也关注能源税的短期绩效,因而通过能源税征收提高能源价格,达到抑制能源需求,降低能耗、降低碳排放的目的。
Construction of the energy tax system helps to save energy to protect theenvironment, it is simply by the taxpayer, tax and energy tax and other main elements ofthe design, the concept of energy saving and environmental protection be integrated intoa country's tax system by many scholars and attention and research policy makers.China's dependence on foreign oil has more than50%, energy security will have a directimpact on China's economic security. But the energy tax system of China has not beencomplete yet currently and being lack of the method to regulate energy consumption, itis negative to control energy consumption and alleviate energy shortage as well asensure the energy security. Although the current energy tax system of China is notscientific and integrated sufficiently, the tax reform which is related to energy has beencarried out gradually by the improvement of relevant tax laws and regulations. That is tosay it is only a matter of time to finish the implementation of China's energy tax systemunder the circumstances of today’s poor energy environment. Therefore I really hopethere‘s a positive effect for china’s energy tax system construction by this article.
     In this study, theoretical and empirical approach used in this paper and analyze thefollowing aspects: the US-Japan bilateral energy development and evolution of taxation,energy taxation and energy taxation constitutes positioning and energy industries,environmental industries and low-carbon industries, at the end, this paper found thefollowing important conclusions:
     First, the core purpose of the US-Japan energy tax legislation is to save energy anddevelop clean energy alternatives to traditional energy sources. Coverage of theUS-Japan energy tax from the early household energy consumption to the limitedenergy-saving equipment; Meanwhile, incentives for alternative energy from alternativeenergy sources are also expanded from a few types of early to now dozens of cleanenergy production, as well as related equipment supplied. In the process ofimplementation of the above measures, environmental philosophy has always beenupheld. Energy tax in favor of the energy market operation mechanism. U.S. andJapanese governments, while the use of energy taxation and other fiscal measures toregulate energy production and consumption, focusing on the role of energy market mechanism itself, the gradual liberalization of controls related fields. Therefore, theenergy tax at the same time regulating energy production and consumption, but alsoprovides strong policy support for the energy market competition mechanism.
     Second, the purpose of the U.S. energy tax expenditures focused on ensuring thesafety of traditional energy sources, encourage the development of new energy sources;Japan's energy tax expenditures focused on encouraging the development of new energysources, trying to replace traditional energy sources through the development of newenergy sources, and the effect is significant. The implementation of Japan's energy taxpolicy for reducing Japan's energy intensity of each industry is indicated significantly,while the United States is very not obvious. The reason is that the United States is richin energy resources, and there are huge energy supply bases overseas, despite the U.S.government has the consciousness of energy crisis, but in practice the strictimplementation can not be enforced; compared to the United States, Japan Energyresource is poor, has strong sense of energy crisis, a lot of diplomatic and economicactivities are carried out around the Japanese government 's energy resources, andimprove energy efficiency in the daily production and life, the development of newenergy has been putted into an important position.
     Third, the United States and Japan contribute to energy taxes levied on thedevelopment of bilateral environmental industry; the technological advances haveplayed a positive role in promoting in clean energy or renewable energy use; due to theenergy tax and technical progress on energy efficiency improvement effect exists,which may cause two effects are likely to rebound energy, i.e., the expansion of theenergy consumption, but if the rebound effect is too large, it will lead to further improveits corporate body energy consumption technology to improve efficiency.
     Fourth, although the larger U.S. energy consumption, but the United States hasabundant energy resources, the United States adopted energy tax policy is mainly basedon long-term energy performance and environmental goals, therefore, the U.S. energyprices is not affected significantly; compared to the United States, Japan's energyresources are very scarce, the introduction of energy tax system is not only concernedabout the short-term performance, but also long-term interests, and therefore energy taxlevied by raising energy prices, to curb energy demand, reduce energy consumption, thepurpose of reducing carbon emissions.
引文
②尹晓亮,战后日本能源政策[M]社会科学文献出版社,2010
    ①Adelman, M.A. The Genie out of the Bottle. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press,1995.
    ①American Petroleum Institute.“Gasoline and Diesel Taxes,” Accessed on June15,2006.
    ①Bergstrom, Theodore C.“On Capturing Oil Rents with a National Excise Tax.” American Economic Review,72(2):194-201,1982. BP.“Statistical Review of World Energy2006,” London: BP,2006.
    ①Carlson, Curtis P.“The Corporate Alternative Minimum Tax Aggregate Historical Trends,”Department of theTreasury Office of Tax Analysis, OTA Paper93,2005.
    ②Cooper, John C.B.“Price Elasticity of Demand for Crude Oil: Estimates for23Countries.”OPEC Review,27(1):1-8,2003.
    ①Deutch, John and Ernest J. Moniz, editors. The Future of Nuclear Power. Cambridge, MA:Massachusetts Instituteof Technology,2003.
    ①Doyle, Joseph J., Jr. and Krislert Samphantharak.“$2.00Gas! Studying the Effects of a Gas Tax Moratorium,”National Bureau of Economic Research, NBER Working Paper No.12266,2006.
    ①Edwards, Chris; Ada Rousso; Peter Merrill and Elizabeth Wagner.“Cool Code: Federal Tax Incentives to MitigateGlobal
    Warming.” National Tax Journal,51(3):465-484,1998.
    ①Asako,K.,S.Kawanishi,and T. Ono (2002)“Sustainable Development and Exhaustible Resources and Environment[in Japanese],”Economic Review, Vol.53, No.3, pp.236-246.
    ①Ishi, H (1999) What is the Environmental Tax?[in Japanese], Tokyo: Iwanami Shoten.
    ①雷鸣.日本节能与新能源发展战略研究[D].吉林大学,2009.
    ②陈伟.日本新能源产业发展及其与中国的比较[J].中国人口.资源与环境,2010,06:103-110.
    ①Internal Revenue Service.2011.“Statistics of Income Historical Table20: Federal Excise Taxes,1999-2010.”Washington, DC: Internal Revenue Service.
    ①Joint Committee on Taxation.2011. Present Law and Analysis of Energy-Related Tax Expenditures andDescription of the Revenue Provisions Contained in H.R.1380, the12New Alternative Transportation to GiveAmericans Solutions Act of2011. JCX-47-11. Washington, DC: Joint Committee on Taxation.
    ①Marron, Donald B.2011.“Spending in Disguise.” NationalAffairs Number8, Summer, pp.20-34.
    ①Metcalf, Gilbert E.2008.“Using Tax Expenditures toAchieve Energy Policy Goals,” Working Paper13753,Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research.
    ①National Commission on Fiscal Responsibility and Reform.2010. The Moment of Truth. Washington, DC:National Commission on Fiscal Responsibility and Reform.
    ②Office of Management and Budget.2011. Fiscal Year2012Analytic Perspectives, Budget of the United StatesGovernment. Washington, DC: Office of Management and Budget.
    ①Sherlock, Molly F.2011. Energy Tax Policy: Historical Perspectives on and Current Status of Energy TaxExpenditures (CRS Report R41227). Washington, DC: Congressional Research Service.
    ①Aasness, J., T. Bye, and H. T. Mysen (1996),“Welfare Effects of Emission Taxes in Norway,” Energy Economic,18(4),335–346.
    ②Aasness, J., T. Bye, and H. T. Mysen (1996),“Welfare Effects of Emission Taxes in Norway,” Energy Economic,18(4),335–346.
    ①Abdelkhalek, T. and J. Dufour (1998),“Statistical Inference for Computable General Equilibrium Models, withApplication to a Model of the Moroccan Economy,”The Review of Economics and Statistics,80(4),520–534.
    ①Armington, P. S.(1969),“A Theory of Demand for Products Distinguished of Place of Production,” InternationalMonetary Fund Staff Papers,16(1),159–178.
    ①Bandara, J. S.(1991),“Computable General EquilibriumModels forDevelopment PolicyAnalysis in LDCs,”Journal of Economic Survey,5(1),3–69.
    ①Berndt, E. R. and D. O. Wood (1975),“Technology, Prices, and the Derived Demand for Energy,” The Review ofEconomics and Statistics,57(3),259–268.
    ①Bosetti, V., C. Carraro, M. Galeotti, E. Massetti, and M. Tavoni (2006),“WITCH: AWorld Induced TechnicalChange HybridModel,” The Energy Journal,27,13–37.
    ①Bovenberg,A. L. and R.A. deMooij (1994),“Environmental Levies and Distortionary Taxation,” The AmericanEconomic Review,84(4),1085–1089.
    ①Bovenberg, A. L. and L. H. Goulder (1996),“Optimal Environmental Taxation in the Presence of Other Taxes:General Equilibrium Analyses,” The American Economic Review,86(4),985–1006.
    ③Burki, A. A. and M. Khan (2004),“Effects ofAllocative Inefficiency on Resource Allocation and EnergySubstitution in Pakistan’s Manufacturing,” Energy Economics,26(3),371–388.
    ①Burniaux, J.-M., J. P. Martin, G. Nicoletti, and J. O. Martins (1992),“GREEN a Multi-Sector, Multi-RegionGeneral Equilibrium Model for Quantifying the Costs of Curbing CO2Emissions: A Technical Manual,” OECDWorking Paper, No.116.
    ①Burniaux, J.-M. and T. Truong (2002),“GTAP-E: An Energy-Environmental Version of the GTAP Model,” GTAPTechnical Paper, No.16.
    ①Caloghirou, Y. D., A. G. Mourelatos, and H. Thompson (1997),“Industrial Energy Substitution during the1980sin The Greek Economy,” Energy Economics,19(4),476–491.
    ②Chang, K.-P.(1994),“Capital-Energy Substitution and the Multi-Level CES Production Function,” EnergyEconomics,16(1),22–26.
    ②P.F.Peretto,M.Connolly,The manhattan metaphor,J.Econ.Growth12(2007)329–350.
    ①House of Representatives Report No.95-496, Part III95th Congress1st Session,Energy Tax Act of1977,1978IRB LEXIS2278,July1978, the Committee on Ways and Means.
    ①Senate Report No.95-132495TH Congress2d Session, Energy TaxAct of1977,1978IRB LEXIS2275,July1978, the Committee of Conference.
    ①Conference Report No.102-1018,2nd Session Energy Policy Act of1992October5,1992,1993IRB LEXIS1993, January1993.
    ②Description ofAChairman's Amendment in the Nature ofASubstitute For H.R.2511,The "Energy Tax Policy Actof2001"Scheduled for Markup By the House Committee on Ways and Means on July18,2001, Prepared by the Staffof the Joint Committee on Taxation.
    ①Comparison of Title XIII OF H.R.6,The "Enhanced Energy Infrastructureand Technology TaxAct of2005,"aspassed by the House of Representatives and Title XV OF H.R.6,The "Energy Policy Tax Incentives Act of2005,"asamended by the Senate, Prepared by the Staff of the Joint Committee on Taxation.
    ①Description and Technical Explanation of the Conference Agreement of H.R.6, TITLE XIII, the "Energy TaxIncentives Act of2005",Prepared by the Staff of the Joint Committee on Taxation.
    ①Arrangements for Publicly Owned Minerals, World Bank Working Paper,August1990
    ①Robert F. Conrad and Zmarak M. Shalizi, AFramework for theAnalysis of Mineral Tax
    ①Ueta, K.(2001)“Theoretical and Policy Issues Surrounding the Environmental Tax [in Japanese],” JapanAssociation of Science of Taxation, ed.,Environmental Problems and Taxation, Kyoto: HouRitsu Bunka Sha, pp.1-12.
    ①Ueta, K.(2002)“Environmental Protection and the Government System [in Japanese],” Environmental Protectionand Public Policy, Tokyo: Iwanami Shoten, pp.92-122.
    ①Oshima, K.(1997)“Reexamining the Fiscal System for Environmental Protection [in Japanese],” Research onEnvironmental Disruption, Vol.27, No.2, pp.36-42.
    ①Kaneko, H (2009) Tax Laws:9th Edition, Tokyo: Koubundou Publishers.
    ①Koyama, S.(2000)“APerspective on Greening Motor Vehicle Taxes [in Japanese],” Research on EnvironmentalDisruption, Vol.29, No.4, pp.56-62.
    ①Koyama, S. and A. Kishimoto (2001)“Estimation of External Costs Caused byAutomobile Traffic in Japan [inJapanese],” Transport Policy Studies Review, Vol.4, No.2, pp.19-30.
    ①Kanemoto, R.(2001)“The Tax System forAutomobiles and Environmental Policy [in Japanese],” Expresswaysand Automobiles, Vol.44, No.7, pp.7-13.
    ①EnvironmentalAgency (2000) New Policy Development Utilizing the Global Warming Tax—Research Group onthe Use of Economic Instruments in Environmental Policy [in Japanese], Tokyo: Ministry of Finance Printing Office.
    ①Ministry of the Environment (2009) The Global Warming Tax in the Request for the FY2010Taxation Revisionfrom the Ministry of the Environment: Specific Proposals [in Japanese].
    ①Research Group on the Use of Economic Instruments for Environmental Taxes and Fees (1997) Countermeasuresto Global Warming and the Environmental Tax [in Japanese], Tokyo: Gyosei.
    ②Kume, Y.(2000)“EconomicAnalysis on the Revenues Designated for Road Construction [in Japanese],”Kensetsu Opinion, Vol.7, No.8, pp.22-25. Institute of Behavioral Sciences (2002)Data-Based International Comparisons: Transportation-Related Data Set2000[in Japanese], Institute ofBehavioral Sciences.
    ①Shimizu, S.(2002)“The Special Account for the Development of Electric Power Facilities and Electric PowerDeregulation [in Japanese],” Public Finance and Public Policy, Vol.30,2002, pp.26-33.
    ①Shimizu, S.(1991)“The Creation of the Program to Promote the Establishment of Power Plants: Nuclear PowerDevelopment andGovernment Budget (1)[in Japanese],” Shogaku Ronshu, Vol.59, No.4, pp.139-160.
    ①Shimizu, S.(1991)“The Development of the Account for Promoting the Development of Electric Power Facilities:Power Development and Government Budget (1)[in Japanese],” Shogaku Ronshu, Vol.59, No.6, pp.153-170.
    ②Government Tax Commission (2002) The Report of Government Tax Commission [in Japanese].
    ①Petroleum Association of Japan (every year) The Handbook of the Petroleum Tax System [in Japanese],Petroleum Association of Japan.
    ①Metcalf, Gilbert E.2008.“Using Tax Expenditures to Achieve Energy Policy Goals,” Working Paper13753,Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research.
    ①Ishi, H (1999) What is the Environmental Tax?[in Japanese], Tokyo: Iwanami Shoten.
    ①Ito, Y.(1980)“Exhaustible Resources and Optimal Growth [in Japanese],” Expressways and Automobiles, Vol.23,No.5, pp.25-29.
    ①Imai, K.(1973)“International Industrial Organization and Resource Problems [in Japanese],” ContemporaryEconomics, Vol.11, pp.104-119.33
    ①Ueta, K.(2001)“Theoretical and Policy Issues Surrounding the Environmental Tax [in Japanese],” JapanAssociation of Science of Taxation, ed., Environmental Problems and Taxation, Kyoto: HouRitsu Bunka Sha, pp.1-12.
    ①Ueta, K.(2002)“Environmental Protection and the Government System [in Japanese],” Environmental Protectionand Public Policy, Tokyo: Iwanami Shoten, pp.92-122.
    ①Oshima, K.(1997)“Reexamining the Fiscal System for Environmental Protection [in Japanese],” Research onEnvironmental Disruption, Vol.27, No.2, pp.36-42.
    ①Kaneko, H (2003) Tax Laws:9th Edition, Tokyo: Koubundou Publishers.
    ①Koyama, S.(2000)“A Perspective on Greening Motor Vehicle Taxes [in Japanese],” Research on EnvironmentalDisruption, Vol.29, No.4, pp.56-62.
    ①Koyama, S. and A. Kishimoto (2001)“Estimation of External Costs Caused by Automobile Traffic in Japan [inJapanese],” Transport Policy Studies Review, Vol.4, No.2, pp.19-30.
    ①赵爱国.日本煤炭清洁利用及对我国的启示[J].中国煤炭.2007(10)
    ②Kanemoto, R.(2001)“The Tax System for Automobiles and Environmental Policy [in Japanese],” Expresswaysand Automobiles, Vol.44, No.7, pp.7-13.
    ①Environmental Agency (2000) New Policy Development Utilizing the Global Warming Tax—Research Group onthe Useof Economic Instruments in Environmental Policy [in Japanese], Tokyo: Ministry of Finance Printing Office.
    ①Ministry of the Environment (2009) The Global Warming Tax in the Request for the FY2010Taxation Revisionfrom the Ministry of the Environment: Specific Proposals [in Japanese].
    ①王常先.美国环境产业模块[J].世界环境,1995,03:36-37.
    ①胡江潮,范小宁,王陈敏.美国能源产业发展状况及启示[J].浙江经济,2002,22:34-36.
    ①张祯,张宏武.美国环境产业相关政策及启示[J].中国环保产业,2006,11:41-44.
    ①J·B·伯科威茨,张晓.走向成熟的美国环境产业[J].中国环保产业,1998,03:26-28.
    ②洪蔚.美国环境产业迅速增长[J].广州环境科学,1999,04:46.
    ①石成春.日本的技术系和人文系环境产业发展现状与趋势[J].中国环保产业,2002,Z1:74-75+77.
    ①李娜.管窥美国环境产业进入中国市场的战略[J].环境经济,2013,Z1:71-74.
    ②白泉,佟庆.美国的能源多样化战略及对我国的启示[J].宏观经济管理.2005(04).
    ①Comparison of Title XIII OF H.R.6,The "Enhanced Energy Infrastructureand Technology TaxAct of2005,"aspassed by the House of Representatives and Title XV OF H.R.6,The "Energy Policy Tax Incentives Act of2005,"asamended by the Senate, Prepared by the Staff of the Joint Committee on Taxation.
    ①苏宏伟,胡继立. JASDAQ、日经指数与日本的货币需求结构分析[J].现代日本经济,2010,(1):18-23.
    ②苏宏伟,刘志恒.日本高科技产品贸易模式实证分析[J].现代日本经济,2012,(04):27-36.
    ③胡江潮,范小宁,王陈敏.美国能源产业发展状况及启示[J].浙江经济,2002,22:34-36.
    ①彭娜.日本环境产业促进法对中国经济产业转型的启示[J].湖南财政经济学院学报,2013,04:19-24.
    ②李冬.日本环境产业的发展[J].东北亚论坛,2009,01:84-90.
    ①于晶.基于环境产业发展的中日环境贸易政策比较研究[D].中国海洋大学,2011.
    ①李亚建,吴莲.美国低碳战略的转变及对中国的启示[J].中共天津市委党校学报,2011,04:55-58.
    ①郭鸿鹏,马成林,杨印生.美国低碳农业实践之借鉴[J].环境保护,2011,21:71-73.
    ①周柯李姗姗.美国低碳交通的政策法律经验与启示[N].法制日报,2012-03-28012.
    ①House of Representatives Report No.95-496, Part III95th Congress1st Session,Energy Tax Act of1977,1978IRB LEXIS2278,July1978, the Committee on Ways and Means.
    ①李淑萍.美国低碳融资战略演进的驱动因素解析[J].商场现代化,2011,12:26-27.
    ①左鑫.美国低碳电力技术综述[J].华中电力,2010,05:77-80.
    ②门丹.美国低碳经济政策转向研究:原因、定位及经济绩效[D].辽宁大学,2013.
    ①陈志恒.日本低碳经济战略简析[J].日本学刊,2010,04:53-66+158.
    ①孙超骥,郭兴方.日本低碳经济战略对我国经济发展的启示[J].价格月刊,2011,09:42-46.
    ①金永男.日本低碳经济政策践行及对我国的启示[D].东北财经大学,2012.
    ①何一鸣,鲍泓.日本低碳产业国际竞争对策分析[J].现代日本经济,2011,03:27-34.
    ②董冬.日本低碳经济发展分析[D].吉林大学,2010.
    ①王新,李志国.日本低碳社会建设实践对我国的启示[J].特区经济,2010,10:96-98.
    ①蒋亚娟.比较法视域下的能源战略与能源税改革[J].改革与战略,2007,02:56-59.
    ②蒋亚娟.论中国能源税的立法生成:模式与构建[J].理论与改革,2007,06:110-113.
    ③韩凤芹,苏明,傅志华,黄运.中国能源税问题的初步研究[J].经济研究参考,2008,55:2-12.
    ①姜克隽,胡秀莲.中国能源税体系设想[J].绿叶,2007,07:26-27.
    ①王姗妮.论可持续发展思想下的中国能源税立法改革[D].北方工业大学,2010.
    ②华昱.能源税问题探析——基于实例与模型的分析[J].南京财经大学学报,2008,03:54-57.
    [1]Deutch, John and Ernest J.Moniz. The Future of Nuclear Power[M]. Cambridge, MA:Massachusetts Institute of Technology,2003.
    [2]Ishi, H. What is the Environmental Tax?[M]. Tokyo: Iwanami Shoten,1999.
    [3]Kaneko, H. Tax Laws:9th Edition[M]. Tokyo: Koubundou Publishers,2003.
    [4]Ueta, K. Theoretical and Policy Issues Surrounding the Environmental Tax[M]. Kyoto: HouRitsuBunka Sha,2001.
    [5]Ueta, K. Environmental Protection and the Government System[M]. Environmental Protectionand Public Policy, Tokyo: Iwanami Shoten,2003.
    [1]Adelman, M.A. The Genie out of the Bottle. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press,1995.
    [2]American Petroleum Institute.“Gasoline and Diesel Taxes,” Accessed on June15,2006.
    [3]Armington, P. S.(1969),“A Theory of Demand for Products Distinguished of Place ofProduction,”International Monetary Fund Staff Papers,16(1),159–178.
    [4]Arrangements for Publicly Owned Minerals, World Bank Working Paper, August1990
    [5]BP.“Statistical Review of World Energy2006,” London: BP,2006.
    [6]Burniaux, J.-M. and T. Truong (2002),“GTAP-E: An Energy-Environmental Version of the GTAPModel,” GTAP Technical Paper, No.16.
    [7]Burniaux, J.-M., J. P. Martin, G. Nicoletti, and J. O. Martins (1992),“GREEN a Multi-Sector,Multi-Region General Equilibrium Model for Quantifying the Costs of Curbing CO2Emissions: ATechnical Manual,” OECD Working Paper, No.116.
    [8]Carlson, Curtis P.“The Corporate Alternative Minimum Tax Aggregate HistoricalTrends,”Department of the Treasury Office of Tax Analysis, OTA Paper93,2005.
    [9]Comparison of Title XIII OF H.R.6,The "Enhanced Energy Infrastructureand Technology TaxAct of2005,"as passed by the House of Representatives and Title XV OF H.R.6,The "EnergyPolicy Tax Incentives Act of2005,"as amended by the Senate, Prepared by the Staff of the JointCommittee on Taxation.
    [10]Conference Report No.102-1018,2nd Session Energy Policy Act of1992October5,1992,1993IRB LEXIS1993, January1993.
    [11]Congressional Budget Office.2005. Taxing Capital Income: Effective Rates and Approaches toReform. Washington, DC: Congressional Budget Office.
    [12]Cooper, John C.B.“Price Elasticity of Demand for Crude Oil: Estimates for23Countries.”OPEC Review,27(1):1-8,2003.
    [13]Davis, T.L.O., Lyne, V.D.(1994) Dispersal of the larval stage of the Southern BlueTn Tuna,1hunnusmaccoyii, in the East Indian Ocean. In: Sammarco, P.W., Heron, M.L.(Eds.), TheBio-Physics of Marine Larval Dispersal. American Geophysical Union, Coastal and EstuarineStudies45,137D148.
    [14]Description and Technical Explanation of the Conference Agreement of H.R.6, TITLE XIII, the"Energy Tax Incentives Act of2005",Prepared by the Staff of the Joint Committee on Taxation.
    [15]Description of A Chairman's Amendment in the Nature of A Substitute For H.R.2511,The"Energy Tax Policy Act of2001"Scheduled for Markup By the House Committee on Ways andMeans on July18,2001, Prepared by the Staff of the Joint Committee on Taxation.
    [16]Doyle, Joseph J., Jr. and Krislert Samphantharak.“$2.00Gas! Studying the Effects of a Gas TaxMoratorium,” National Bureau of Economic Research, NBER Working Paper No.12266,2006.
    [17]Energy Information Administration.“Annual Energy Review2004,” Energy InformationAdministration,2005.
    [18]Environmental Agency (2000) New Policy Development Utilizing the Global WarmingTax—Research Group on the Use of Economic Instruments in Environmental Policy [C], Tokyo:Ministry of Finance Printing Office.
    [19]Environmental Agency (2000) New Policy Development Utilizing the Global WarmingTax—Research Group on the Use of Economic Instruments in Environmental Policy [inJapanese], Tokyo: Ministry of Finance Printing Office.
    [20]Feng, Ye; Don Fullerton and Li Gan.“Vehicle Choices, Miles Driven, and PollutionPolicies,”National Bureau of Economic Research, Working Paper No.11553,2005.
    [21]General Accounting Office.“Effects of the Alcohol Fuels Tax Incentives,” U.S. GeneralAccounting Office, GAO/GGD-97-41,1997.
    [22]Government Tax Commission (2002) The Report of Government Tax Commission [in Japanese].
    [23]House of Representatives Report No.95-496, Part III95th Congress1st Session,Energy Tax Actof1977,1978IRB LEXIS2278,July1978, the Committee on Ways and Means.
    [24]Institute of Behavioral Sciences (2002) Data-Based International Comparisons:Transportation-Related Data Set2000[in Japanese], Institute of Behavioral Sciences.
    [25]Internal Revenue Service.2011.“Statistics of Income Historical Table20: Federal Excise Taxes,1999-2010.” Washington, DC: Internal Revenue Service.
    [26]Internal Revenue Service.2011.“Statistics of Income Historical Table20: Federal Excise Taxes,1999-2010.” Washington, DC: Internal Revenue Service.
    [27]Joint Committee on Taxation.2011. Present Law and Analysis of Energy-Related TaxExpenditures and Description of the Revenue Provisions Contained in H.R.1380, the12NewAlternative Transportation to Give Americans Solutions Act of2011. JCX-47-11. Washington,DC: Joint Committee on Taxation.
    [28]Joint Committee on Taxation.2011. Present Law and Analysis of Energy-Related TaxExpenditures and Description of the Revenue Provisions Contained in H.R.1380, the12NewAlternative Transportation to Give Americans Solutions Act of2011. JCX-47-11. Washington,DC: Joint Committee on Taxation.
    [29]Marron, Donald B.2011.“Spending in Disguise.” National Affairs Number8, Summer, pp.20-34.[30]Metcalf, Gilbert E.2008.“Using Tax Expenditures to Achieve Energy Policy Goals,”Working Paper13753, Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research.
    [31]Ministry of the Environment (2009) The Global Warming Tax in the Request for the FY2010Taxation Revision from the Ministry of the Environment: Specific Proposals [in Japanese].
    [33]National Commission on Fiscal Responsibility and Reform.2010. The Moment of Truth.Washington, DC: National Commission on Fiscal Responsibility and Reform.
    [34]Office of Management and Budget.2011. Fiscal Year2012Analytic Perspectives, Budget of theUnited States Government. Washington, DC: Office of Management and Budget.
    [35]Parry, Ian&Goulder, Lawrence&Williams III, Roberton(1997), When Can Carbon AbatementPolicies Increase Welfare? The Fundamental Role of Distorted Factor Markets," DiscussionPapers dp-97-18-rev, Resources For the Future.
    [36]Petroleum Association of Japan (every year) The Handbook of the Petroleum Tax System [inJapanese], Petroleum Association of Japan.
    [37]Research Group on the Use of Economic Instruments for Environmental Taxes and Fees (1997)Countermeasures to Global Warming and the Environmental Tax [in Japanese], Tokyo: Gyosei.
    [38]Robert F. Conrad and Zmarak M. Shalizi, A Framework for the Analysis of Mineral Tax
    [39]Senate Report No.95-132495TH Congress2d Session, Energy Tax Act of1977,1978IRBLEXIS2275,July1978, the Committee of Conference.
    [40]Sherlock, Molly F.2011. Energy Tax Policy: Historical Perspectives on and Current Status ofEnergy Tax Expenditures (CRS Report R41227). Washington, DC: Congressional ResearchService.
    [41]Zhong xiang (2004), Transition without transformation: Russia involutionary road to capitalism,BerkeleyUniver-sity of California.
    [1]董冬.日本低碳经济发展分析[D].吉林大学,2010.
    [2]金永男.日本低碳经济政策践行及对我国的启示[D].东北财经大学,2012.
    [3]王姗妮.论可持续发展思想下的中国能源税立法改革[D].北方工业大学,2010.
    [4]于晶.基于环境产业发展的中日环境贸易政策比较研究[D].中国海洋大学,2011.
    [1] J·B·伯科威茨,张晓.走向成熟的美国环境产业[J].中国环保产业,1998,03:26-28.
    [2]白泉,佟庆.美国的能源多样化战略及对我国的启示[J].宏观经济管理.2005(04)
    [3]郭鸿鹏,马成林,杨印生.美国低碳农业实践之借鉴[J].环境保护,2011,21:71-73.
    [4]韩凤芹,苏明,傅志华,黄运.中国能源税问题的初步研究[J].经济研究参考,2008,55:2-12.
    [5]何一鸣,鲍泓.日本低碳产业国际竞争对策分析[J].现代日本经济,2011,03:27-34.
    [6]洪蔚.美国环境产业迅速增长[J].广州环境科学,1999,04:46.
    [7]胡江潮,范小宁,王陈敏.美国能源产业发展状况及启示[J].浙江经济,2002,22:34-36.
    [8]胡江潮,范小宁,王陈敏.美国能源产业发展状况及启示[J].浙江经济,2002,22:34-36.
    [9]胡宗义,蔡文彬,陈浩.能源价格对能源强度和经济增长影响的CGE研究[J].财经理论与实践,2008,02:91-95.
    [10]华昱.能源税问题探析—基于实例与模型的分析[J].南京财经大学学报,2008,03:54-57.
    [11]黄英娜,郭振仁,张天柱,王学军.应用CGE模型量化分析中国实施能源环境税政策的可行性[J].城市环境与城市生态,2005,02:18-20.
    [12]姜克隽,胡秀莲.中国能源税体系设想[J].绿叶,2007,07:26-27.
    [13]蒋亚娟.比较法视域下的能源战略与能源税改革[J].改革与战略,2007,02:56-59.
    [14]蒋亚娟.论中国能源税的立法生成:模式与构建[J].理论与改革,2007,06:110-113.
    [15]蒋亚娟.论中国能源税的立法生成:模式与构建[J].理论与改革,2007,06:110-113.
    [16]李冬.日本环境产业的发展[J].东北亚论坛,2009,01:84-90.
    [17]李娜.管窥美国环境产业进入中国市场的战略[J].环境经济,2013,Z1:71-74.
    [18]李淑萍.美国低碳融资战略演进的驱动因素解析[J].商场现代化,2011,12:26-27.
    [19]李亚建,吴莲.美国低碳战略的转变及对中国的启示[J].中共天津市委党校学报,2011,04:55-58.
    [20]廉春慧.推动能源税制改革应对能源危机[J].财会研究,2005,10:10-11.
    [21]彭娜.日本环境产业促进法对中国经济产业转型的启示[J].湖南财政经济学院学报,2013,04:19-24.
    [22]石成春.日本的技术系和人文系环境产业发展现状与趋势[J].中国环保产业,2002,Z1:74-75+77.
    [23]苏宏伟,胡继立. JASDAQ、日经指数与日本的货币需求结构分析[J].现代日本经济,2010,(1):18-23.
    [24]苏宏伟,刘志恒.日本高科技产品贸易模式实证分析[J].现代日本经济,2012,(04):27-36.
    [25]苏明,傅志华,许文,王志刚,李欣,梁强.碳税的中国路径[J].环境经济,2009,09:10-22.
    [26]孙超骥,郭兴方.日本低碳经济战略对我国经济发展的启示[J].价格月刊,2011,09:42-46.
    [27]谭宗宪.关于我国能源税收制度的思考[J].能源与环境,2004,04:19-20.
    [28]陶冶,薛惠锋.我国能源结构-产业结构协调性演进规律研究[J].环境保护科学,2009,04:102-104.
    [29]王常先.美国环境产业模块[J].世界环境,1995,03:36-37.
    [30]王哲林.环境税的国际比较及借鉴[J].税务研究,2007,07:78-82.
    [31]肖江华,张春红.社会责任语境下对公司捐赠的法律约束[J].行政与法(吉林省行政学院学报),2006,01:122-124.
    [32]徐国泉,姜照华.技术进步、结构变化与美国能源效率的关系[J].科学学与科学技术管理.2007(03)
    [33]徐利.转变外向型经济发展方式积极应对国际金融危机—基于浙江省实例的外向型经济转型的调研报告[J].财政研究,2009,04:39-43.
    [34]徐益谦,顾璠.美国能源部洁净煤技术(CCT)示范研究计划(摘要)[J].能源研究与利用.1993(05)
    [35]鄢小兵.从经济学的角度看美国低碳农业及对我国的启示[J].科技创业月刊,2011,17:23-25.
    [36]杨岚,毛显强,刘琴,刘昭阳.基于CGE模型的能源税政策影响分析[J].中国人口.资源与环境,2009,02:24-29.
    [37]张为付,潘颖.能源税对国际贸易与环境污染影响的实证研究[J].南开经济研究,2007,03:32-46.
    [38]张祯,张宏武.美国环境产业相关政策及启示[J].中国环保产业,2006,11:41-44.
    [39]张志仁.利用税收手段控制非点源污染的可行性探讨[J].农业环境与发展,2004,01:39-40.
    [40]赵爱国.日本煤炭清洁利用及对我国的启示[J].中国煤炭.2007(10)
    [41]周波,杜亚丽.促进节能减排的财税政策选择[J].大连海事大学学报(社会科学版),2007,05:40-43.
    [42]朱晓冲,毕丽.促进节能减排的财税政策研究[J].经济纵横,2007,13:38-40.
    [43]Aasness, J., T. Bye, and H. T. Mysen (1996),Welfare Effects of Emission Taxes inNorway[J].Energy Economic,18(4),335-346.
    [44]Abdelkhalek, T. and J. Dufour (1998),Statistical Inference for Computable General EquilibriumModels, with Application to a Model of the Moroccan Economy[J].The Review of Economicsand Statistics,80(4),520-534.
    [45]Bandara,J. S.(1991),Computable General EquilibriumModels forDevelopment Policy Analysisin LDCs[J].Journal of Economic Survey,5(1),3-69.
    [46]Bergstrom,Theodore C(1982),On Capturing Oil Rents with a National Excise Tax[J].AmericanEconomic Review,72(2):194-201.
    [47]Berndt,E. R. and D. O. Wood (1975),Technology,Prices,and the Derived Demand for Energy[J].The Review of Economics and Statistics,57(3),259-268.
    [48]Bosetti,V.,C. Carraro,M. Galeotti,E. Massetti,and M. Tavoni (2006),WITCH: A World InducedTechnical Change HybridModel[J]. The Energy Journal,27,13-37.
    [49]Bovenberg,A. L. and L. H. Goulder (1996),Optimal Environmental Taxation in the Presence ofOther Taxes: General Equilibrium Analyses[J]. The American Economic Review,86(4),985-1006.
    [50]Bovenberg,A. L. and R. A. deMooij (1994),Environmental Levies and DistortionaryTaxation[J].The American Economic Review,84(4),1085-1089.
    [51]Burki,A. A. and M. Khan (2004),Effects of Allocative Inefficiency on Resource Allocation andEnergy Substitution in Pakistans Manufacturing[J].Energy Economics,26(3),371-388.
    [52]Caloghirou,Y. D.,A. G. Mourelatos,and H. Thompson (1997),Industrial Energy Substitutionduring the1980s in The Greek Economy[J].Energy Economics,19(4),476-491.
    [53]CarloCarraro,MarzioGaleotti,MassimoGallo(1996),The mesoscale structure of the LeeuwinCurrent: a comparison of laboratory model and satellite images[J]. Journal of GeophysicalResearch96,16739-16757.
    [54]Chang,K.-P.(1994),Capital-Energy Substitution and the Multi-Level CES ProductionFunction[J]. Energy Economics,16(1),22-26.
    [55]Edwards,Chris; Ada Rousso; Peter Merrill and Elizabeth Wagner(1998),Cool Code: Federal TaxIncentives to Mitigate Global Warming[J].National Tax Journal,51(3):465-484.
    [56]F.Mare(2009),Capital-Energy Substitution and the Multi-Level CES Production Function[J].Energy Economics,16(1),22-26.
    [57]Fraumeni,Barbara M(1997),The Measurement of Depreciation in the U.S. National Income andProduct Accounts[J].Survey of Current Business,77(7):7-23.
    [58]Gerard H.Kuper(1996),ENSO events,the Leeuwin Current and larval recruitment of the WesterRock Lobster[J].Journal du Conseil45,13-21."
    [59]Godal,Holtsmark(2001),An empirieal investigation of briberyi n international trade,EuropeanJournal for De-velopment Researeh10(1):40一49.
    [60]Goulder,L.H.(1995),Effects of carbon taxes in an economy with prior tax distortions: anintertemporalgeneral equilibrium analysis[J].Journal of Environmental Economics andManagement29(3).,271-297.
    [61]Goulder,Schneider(2006),Seabird abundance,distribution and breeding patterns in relation to theLeeuwin Current[J].Journal of the Royal Society of Western Australia74,129-132.
    [62]Gupta,Sanjeev&Miranda,Kenneth&Parry,Ian(1995),Public expenditure policy and theenvironment: A review and synthesis[J].World Development,Elsevier,vol.23(3),pages515-528.
    [63]Imai,K.(1973),International Industrial Organization and Resource Problems[J]. ContemporaryEconomics,Vol.11,pp.104-119.
    [64]Ito,Y.(1980),Exhaustible Resources and Optimal Growth[J].Expressways and Automobiles,Vol.23,No.5,pp.25-29.
    [65]Kanemoto,R.(2001),The Tax System for Automobiles and Environmental Policy[J].Expressways and Automobiles,Vol.44,No.7,pp.7-13.
    [66]Kanemoto,R.(2001),The Tax System for Automobiles and Environmental Policy[J].Expressways and Automobiles,Vol.44,No.7,pp.7-13.
    [67]Koyama,S.(2000),A Perspective on Greening Motor Vehicle Taxes[J].Research onEnvironmental Disruption,Vol.29,No.4,pp.56-62.
    [68]Koyama,S.(2000),A Perspective on Greening Motor Vehicle Taxes[J].Research onEnvironmental Disruption,Vol.29,No.4,pp.56-62.
    [69]Koyama,S. and A. Kishimoto (2001),Estimation of External Costs Caused by AutomobileTraffic in Japan[J].Transport Policy Studies Review,Vol.4,No.2,pp.19-30.
    [70]Koyama,S. and A. Kishimoto (2001),Estimation of External Costs Caused by AutomobileTraffic in Japan [J].Transport Policy Studies Review,Vol.4,No.2,pp.19-30.
    [71]Kume,Y.(2000),Economic Analysis on the Revenues Designated for Road Construction[J].Kensetsu Opinion,Vol.7,No.8,pp.22-25.
    [72]Lawrence Goulder(2005),Dispersal of tropical marine larvae to the Great Australian Bight by theLeeuwin Current[J].Australian Journal of Marine and Freshwater Research32,493-500.
    [73]Oates (1995),Dispersal of tropical marine larvae to the Great Australian Bight by the LeeuwinCurrent[J].Australian Journal of Marine and Freshwater Research32,493-500.
    [74]Oshima,K.(1997),Reexamining the Fiscal System for Environmental Protection[J]. Research onEnvironmental Disruption,Vol.27,No.2,pp.36-42.
    [75]Oshima,K.(1997),Reexamining the Fiscal System for Environmental Protection [J]. Research onEnvironmental Disruption,Vol.27,No.2,pp.36-42.
    [76]P.F.Peretto,M.Connolly(2007),The manhattan metaphor[J].Econ.Growth12,329-350.
    [77]Pearce,A.F.(1991),Eastern boundary currents of the southern hemisphere[J]. Journal of the RoyalSociety of Western Australia74,35-45.
    [78]R.A.McDOUGALL(1999),The Leeuwin Current and larval recruitment to the rocklobster shery of Western Australia[J].Journal of the Royal Society of Western Australia74,93-100.
    [79]Roy Boyd,Kerry Krutilla,W.KIPViseusi(1995),Eastern boundary currents of the southernhemisphere[J].Journal of the Royal Society of Western Australia74,35-45.
    [80]Shimizu,S.(1991),The Creation of the Program to Promote the Establishment of Power Plants:Nuclear Power Development and Government Budget (1)[J].Shogaku Ronshu,Vol.59,No.4,pp.139-160.
    [81]Shimizu,S.(1991),The Development of the Account for Promoting the Development of ElectricPower Facilities: Power Development and Government Budget (1)[J].Shogaku Ronshu,Vol.59,No.6,pp.153-170.
    [82]Shimizu,S.(2002),The Special Account for the Development of Electric Power Facilities andElectric Power Deregulation [J]. Public Finance and Public Policy,Vol.30,pp.26-33.
    [83]Tiezz(2005),Continental shelf currents near the Abrolhos Islands,Western Australia[J].AustralianJournal of Marine and Freshwater Research40,113-128.
    [84]Tullock,G.(1967),the Welfare Costs of Monopolies,Tariffs,and Theft[J].Western EconomicJournal5,224-32.
    [85]Ueta,K.(2001),Theoretical and Policy Issues Surrounding the Environmental Tax[J]. Kyoto:HouRitsu Bunka Sha,pp.1-12.
    [86]Ueta,K.(2002),Environmental Protection and the Government System[J]. EnvironmentalProtection and Public Policy,Tokyo: Iwanami Shoten,pp.92-122.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700