教育、人力资本、经济增长——理论阐释和实证检验
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
自改革开放以来的30年,我国经济总量的增长举世瞩目,同时伴随的是各个地区,城市和乡村发展的非均衡,这种非均衡的现实状态和人力资本形成密切相关,因此,从人力资本角度研究我国的经济增长,是有意义的,也是重要的。本文从这个角度出发,研究人力资本的形成、度量和总量上的变化,将全国每一个省份的人力资本存量都利用收入法和成本法加以计量,给出各个省份的人力资本形成数量和变化趋势,进而研究人力资本和教育、经济增长之间的关联,利用面板数据模型,聚类分析等手段将各省状态按照人力资本、经济增长等指标进行分类,并考察不同类别的增长方式和增长途径,最后,根据实证结论,给出我国应该采取的人力资本战略分析。
     人力资本测算结果的表明:从存量上看,我国人力资本存量的增速远远不如物质资本的增速;从流量上看,我国人力资本形成过程中,更多的依赖于教育投入,研发成本所占份额过小。聚类分析的结果表明:全国可以划分为六大类,第一类包括北京、天津和上海,第二类广东、江苏、浙江和山东,第三类是重庆,第四类是河北、辽宁、安徽、河南、湖北、湖南、四川,第五类是以西部地区为主,包括东北地区的吉林和黑龙江的15个省份,西藏自成一类。
     关联模型的结果表明:教育年限较短是制约我国人力资本形成的瓶颈;人均教育年限的增加,对人均GDP的增加比总量上的增加具有更大的作用;我国存在劳动力人口多,素质低的问题,同时人力资本利用效率极低,因此,提高人力资本利用效率,增强劳动力素质,是实现经济增长的关键因素。在对策上,增加教育投入、优化教育结构、支持研发和创新和人才培养是我国亟待解决的问题。
Economic growth is the persistent theme in economics’study, especially in the causes of economic growth, the role and effectiveness of the mechanism, and the large amount of literature from various angles have been carried out in-depth analysis. And during China's 30 years of reform and opening, the growth of total economic output attracts worldwide attention, at the same time, there’s the non-equilibrium development of different regions, and the urban and rural regions, the reality of this non-equilibrium is closely related to human capital formation, therefore, the study of China’s economic growth from the human capital point of view is meaningful and important.
     From this perspective, this paper studied human capital’s formation, measurement and the changes in total, and measured each province’s human capital stock by using the income method and cost method, and given the various provinces’amount of human capital formation and their trends, and researched the link among human capital, education and economic growth, using panel data model and cluster analysis to classified the provinces in accordance with human capital and economic growth indicators, and studied the different types of growth mode and growth path, and finally, according to the empirical conclusions, gave the strategic analysis of human capital should be adopted in our country.
     The paper has three main parts within six chapters.
     The first part is introduction, chapters 1 and 2, it gives the theory of economic growth, and introduced literatures of the human capital-related research.
     Introduction gives the article’s study background and significance, and introduces the research framework of this article.
     The first chapter is the economic growth theory’s summary, first of all, introduced the sort of economic growth theory and ideology in detail, and further introduced the classical growth theory, neo-classical growth theory, and the theory of endogenous technological progress, gives the theoretical basis to follow-up study in this paper.
     Chapter 2 is the education and human capital formation, first of all, given the definition of capital, and given variety explanations and understandings on capital, and then given the meaning of human capital based on the definition of capital, research on the context and process of understanding the human capital, further given this article’s understanding and the definition of human capital, and ultimately theoretically expatiated and analyzed the relationship between education and human capital formation, and gives two models of the relationship between education and economic growth.
     The second part is chapter 3, chapter 4 and chapter 5, which is the principal part and core content of this. First of all, the article gave the method of measurement of human capital, and measured China's human capital stock and flow by using income method and cost method, and used the results of estimation to study association among these results, economic growth and education indicators.
     Chapter 3 is the human capital calculation methods. First of all, given the characteristics of human capital, and based on a better understanding of the characteristics of human capital, summed up the measure methods of human capital, including revenue-based approach, education approach, competency-based methods and methods of integration, in order to provide a measure of human capital method.
     Chapter 4 estimated China's human capital by using revenue and cost method. First of all, given typical characteristics and fact of China's human capital, further using cost and income methods, respectively measured the human capital stock and flow, and studied in national data and various provinces respectively, and received the national human capital data and the human capital data of various provinces.
     The analysis according to the results of measurement shows that from the stock point of view, China's growth rate of human capital stock is far less than the growth rate of physical capital, which shows that human capital investment is still not to be the relative importance, but also the investment in human capital can not be more effective in promoting economic growth comparing physical capital; from the flow point of view, in our country’s human capital formation process, the investment in education is main part, and R & D cost share is too small. In addition, human capital is far less important than the material capital, economic development and economic growth mode are still more dependent on physical capital investment rather than investment in human capital.
     Chapter 5 is the relationship among investment in education, human capital and economic growth. Using human capital stock data from chapter 4, the paper classified various regions in China, and further gave the education indicators of various regions, with introducing the economic growth indicators, carried cluster analysis by using three types of indicators. Firstly, all provinces are divided into similar categories, and for each category, it researches the transmission mechanism of education on human capital formation, and study the transmissions of human capital and education investment into economic growth.
     The result of cluster analysis shows that, in accordance with human capital, education and economic growth indicators, the country can be divided into six categories, the first category includes Beijing, Tianjin and Shanghai, the second category is Guangdong, Jiangsu, Zhejiang and Shandong, the third type is Chongqing, the fourth category is Hebei, Liaoning, Anhui, Henan, Hubei, Hunan, Sichuan, the fifth category is 15 provinces including the north-eastern regions of Jilin and Heilongjiang, and mainly is western regions, and Tibet is a category of its own.
     From the results of education and human capital associated model, the shorter number of years of education is the constraints of our human capital formation, therefore, to increase investment in education, to expand the scope of education, to improve the level of education, and to increase number of years of education are important. The estimated results by using per value show that the increase in per number of years of education has a greater role in the increase of the stock of per human capital.
     From the results of connection between education and economic growth, per number of years of education’s increase has more effect on the increase in per GDP than the increase in overall, obviously, China's relatively low level of education, and increasing educational investment, expanding the scope of education, and increasing the number of years of education are necessary measures.
     From the results of associated model of human capital and economic growth, China's the problem of great amount of labor population within low quality, at the same time, the utilization efficiency of human capital is very low, therefore, improving the human capital efficiency, and enhancing the quality of the workforce are the key factors in economic growth.
     The third part is the sixth chapter, which using empirical results and our country’s reality, given the development strategy of human capital. This article concluded that: increasing educational investment, optimizing the education structure, supporting the R & D and innovation, and personnel training are serious problems in our country, and increasing educational investment needs to increase government expenditure on education, encourage the community school, take full advantage of the development of information technology to improve the level of education; optimizing the educational structure should be mainly from the development of vocational education, focusing on corporate training and quality education, to promote the rationalization of the structure of education; to support R & D and innovation should be from the perspective of improving the national innovation system, promoting human resources flow and other aspects, and introducing personnel reasonably, so as to further promote the long-term stability of China's economic development.
引文
①周建春:《从耕地流失谈农民土地权益的保护》,《中国发展观察》,2005年第3期。
    ②联合国发展署,2007/2008 Human Development Report。
    ③李实:《中国个人收入分配研究与展望》,《经济学季刊》第2卷第2期。
    
    ①西奥多·W·舒尔茨:《改造传统农业》,商务印书馆,1987。
    ②詹姆斯·赫克曼:《中国的人力资本投资》www.cenet.org.cn,2005年12月4日。
    ③杨黛:《我国农村的人力资本投资与教育改革》,《南方农村》,2004年5期。
    ④《中国人口统计年鉴》2004。
    ①Barro, Robert J. and Gary S. Becker, "Fertility Choice in a Model of Economic Growth" Economictric, 1989, 57; Galor, Oded and David N. Weil, "Population, Technology, and Growth: From Malthusian Stagnation to the Demographic Transition and Beyond", American Economic Review, 2000, 90.
    ②Aghion, Philippe, Eve Carloli, "Inequality and Economic Growth: The Perspective of the New Growth Theories", Journal of Economic Literature, 1999, 37.
    
    ①库兹涅茨:《各国的经济增长》商务印书馆,1999
    ②萨缪尔逊:《经济学》,高鸿业等译,中国发展出版社,1992
    ③刘易斯:《经济增长理论》,梁小民译,上海人民出版社,1994
    ④亚当.斯密:《国民财富的性质和原因研究》郭大力等译,商务印书馆,1981
    
    ①马尔萨斯:《人口原理》,朱映等译,商务印书馆,1994
    ②李嘉图:《李嘉图著作和通信集》,郭大力等译,商务印书馆,1981
    ③哈罗德:《动态经济学》,黄范章译,商务印书馆,1981;多马:《经济增长理论》,商务印书馆,1983。
    ①哈罗德:《动态经济学》,黄范章译,商务印书馆,1981;多马:《经济增长理论》,商务印书馆,1983。
     ①索洛:《经济增长因素分析》,商务印书馆,1991。
    ①布兰查德:《宏观经济学》,经济科学出版社,1994。
    ①罗默:《高级宏观经济学》,商务印书馆,2003。
    ①西奥多·舒尔茨,《论人力资本投资》,北京经济学院出版社,1990
    
    ①西奥多·舒尔茨,《论人力资本投资》,北京经济学院出版社,1990
    ②加里·S·贝克尔:《人力资本》,北京大学出版社,1987年
    ③Romer, Paul M, "Increasing Return and Long-Run Growth", Journal of Political Economy, 1986,94
     ①Lucas, Robert E. Jr., "On the Mechanism of Economic Development", Journal of Monetary Economics, 1988, 22.
    ①[美]斯皮格尔:《经济思想的成长》,中国社会科学出版社,1999。
    
    ①[美]斯皮格尔:《经济思想的成长》,中国社会科学出版社,1999。
    ②[美]斯皮格尔:《经济思想的成长》,中国社会科学出版社,1999。
    ③张五常:《经济解释》,商务印书馆,2001。
    ①[美]斯皮格尔:《经济思想的成长》,中国社会科学出版社,1999。
    
    ①亚当.斯密:《国民财富的性质和原因研究》,郭大力等译,商务印书馆,1981。
    ②约翰·斯图亚特·穆勒:《政治经济学原理——及其在社会哲学上的若干应用》,商务印书馆,1991。
    
    ①李斯特:《政治经济学的国民体系》,商务印书馆,1981。
    ②马歇尔:《经济学原理》,商务印书馆,1964。
    ①西奥多·W·舒尔茨:《人力资本投资》,北京经济学院出版社,1990。
    
    ①Irving Fisher, The Nature of Capital and Income, New York: The Macmillan Co.1996.
    ②舒尔茨:《应对非均衡的能力的价值》,《经济学杂志》,1975.13
    ①雅各布·明塞尔:《人力资本研究- -雅各布·明塞尔论文集》,中国经济出版社,2001。
    ①李玲:《人力资本运动与中国经济增长》,中国计划出版社,2003。
    ①王金营:《人力资本与经济增长:理论与实证》,中国财政经济出版社,2001。
    ①教育投入不能代表教育收益,教育对人力资本的促进作用不是简单的线性函数,因此,用教育指标代替人力资本显然不是客观的。
    ②Petty:《政治算术》,商务印书馆,1978。
    ③Dublin,L.I.and Lotka,A.(1930).The Money Value of Man.Ronald Press Co.,New York,N.Y.Cited in Kiker (1966)Farr,W.(1853).Equitable taxation of property.Journal of Royal Statistics,16(March issue);Graham,J.W.and Webb,R.H.(1979).Stocks and depreciation of human capital:New evidence from a present-value perspective.Review of Income and Wealth,25(2);Ahlroth,S.,Bjorklund,A.,and Forslund,A.(1997).The output of the Swedish education sector[J].Review of Income and Wealth,43(1).
    ①Jorgenson,D.W.and Fraumeni,B.M.(1989).The accumulation of human and non-human capital,1948-1984.In Lipsey,R.E.and Tice,H.S.,editors,The Measurement of Savings,Investment and Wealth,pages; Barro,Robert .(1991).Economic Growth in a Cross Section of Countries.Quarterly Journal of Economics 106(2); Mankiw,N.Gregory,David Romer,David N.Weil(1992).A Contribution to the Empirics of Growth.Quarterly Journal of Economics 107.
    ①Eisner,R.(1985).The total incomes system of accounts].Survey of Current Business,65(1).
    ②Le,T.,Gibson,J.,and Oxley,L.(or Le et al,2003).Cost-and income-based measures of human capital[J].Journal of Economic Surveys, 17(3).
    ③Machlup F.Mansfield U The Study of Information: Interdisciplinary Messages 1983
    ①Dublin,L.I.and Lotka,A.(1930).The Money Value of Man. Ronald Press Co.,New York,N.Y.Cited in Kiker (1966).
    ②B.A.Weisbrod,Economics of Public Health,Philadelphia:University of Pennsylvania Press,1961.
    ①Graham,J.W.and Webb,R.H.(1979).Stocks and depreciation of human capital:New evidence from a present-value perspective.Review of Income and Wealth,25(2).
    ②Jorgenson,D.W.and Fraumeni,B.M.(1992).The output of the education sector.In Griliches,Z.,editor,Output Measurement in the Services Sector.The University of Chicago Press,Chicago,I.L.
    ③Mulligan,Casey B.,Xavier Sala-i-Martin(1997).A Labor Income-Based Measure of the Value of Human Capital:An Application to the States of the United States.Japan and the World Economy 9(2).
    ①Koman,R.and Marin,D.(1999).Human capital and macroeconomic growth:Austria and Germany, 1960-1997:An update.Discussion Papers in Economics 569,University of Munich,Department of Economics,Munich.
    ①Psacharopoulos,George(1994).Returns to Investment in Education:A Global Update.World Development 22.
    ②Kyriacou,George A.(1991).Level and Growth Effects of Human Capital:A Cross-Country Study of the Convergence Hypothesis. Economic Research Reports 19-26,C.V.Starr Center for Applied Economics,New York University,May.43.
    ①Nehru,Vikram,Eric Swanson,Ashutosh Dubey(1995).A New Database on Human Capital Stock in Developing and Industrial Countries:Sources, Methodology,and Results.Journal of Development Economics 46(2).
    ②OECD(2001).The Well-being of Nations:The Role of Human and Social Capital. OECD working paper,Paris.
    ①.沈利生、朱运法:《人力资本与经济增长分析》,社会科学出版社,1999。
    [1] [德]柯武刚、史漫飞,制度经济学,北京:商务印书馆,2000年版。
    [2] [美]R·科斯,A·阿尔钦,D·诺斯等,财产权利与制度变迁,上海:三联书店,1995年版。
    [3] [美]奥尔森,集体行动的逻辑,上海:三联书店,1995年版。
    [4] [美]奥利弗·E·威廉姆森,资本主义经济制度,北京:商务印书馆,2002年版。
    [5] [美]康芒斯,制度经济学,北京:商务印书馆,1962年版。
    [6] [美]罗伯特·索洛,经济增长因素分析,北京:商务印书馆,1991年版。
    [7] [美]诺斯、托马斯,西方世界的兴起(中译本),北京:华夏出版社,1989年版。
    [8] [美]诺斯,经济史中的结构与变迁(中译本),上海:三联书店,1994年版。
    [9] [美]舒尔茨,论人力资本投资,北京:北京经济学院出版社,1992年版。
    [10] [美]舒尔茨,人力资本投资——教育与研究的作用,北京:商务印书馆,1990年版。
    [11] [美]约翰·N·德勒巴克、约翰·V·C·奈,新制度经济学前沿,北京:经济科学出版社,2003年版。
    [12] [美]约瑟夫·熊彼特,经济发展理论,北京:商务印书馆,1990年版。
    [13] [英]阿瑟·刘易斯,经济增长理论,北京:商务印书馆,1996年版。
    [14] [英]亚当·斯密,国民财富的性质和原因的研究,北京:商务印书馆,1974年版。
    [15]龚六堂,经济增长理论,湖北:武汉大学出版社,2000.11。
    [16]郭亚军,综合评价理论与方法,北京:科学出版社,2002.8。
    [17]侯风云,中国人力资本形成及现状,北京:经济科学出版社,1999.4。
    [18]侯亚飞,人口质量与经济增长方式,北京:中国经济出版社,2000.5.
    [19]胡君辰、郑绍濂,人力资源开发与管理,上海:复旦大学出版社,1999.8。
    [20]胡永远,替代效应下的个人人力资本投资研究,厦门大学博士论文,2003.10。
    [21]赖德胜,教育与收入分配,北京:北京师范大学出版社,1998年3月,
    [22]李建民:人力资本通论,上海:三联书店上海分店,1999.8。
    [23]李京文等,生产率与美日中经济增长研究,北京:中国社会科学出版社,1993.4。
    [24]李玲,人力资本运动与中国经济增长,北京:中国计划出版社,2003.1.
    [25]李忠民,人力资本:一个理论框架及其对中国一些问题的解释,北京:经济科学出版社.1999.12。
    [26]孟夏,经济增长的内生技术分析,天津:天津人民出版社,2001.9。
    [27]钱雪亚,中国人力资本水平研究,浙江大学博士论文,2005.10。
    [28]沈利生、朱运法,人力资本与经济增长分析,北京:社会科学文献出版社,1999.1。
    [29]史清琪、秦宝庭、陈警,技术进步与经济增长,北京:科学技术文献出版社,1985.10。
    [30]谭崇台主编.发展经济学.上海人民出版社,1989年版。
    [31]王小鲁,樊纲主编,中国经济增长的可持续性,经济科学出版社,2000年12月第1版。
    [32]杨子慧,中国历代人口统计资料研究,改革出版社,1995.10。
    [33]游宪生,经济增长研究,上海:上海立信会计出版社,2000.3。
    [34]张富春,资本与经济增长,北京:经济科学出版社,2000.3。
    [35]张抗私等,当代劳动经济学,北京:经济科学出版社,2000.6。
    [36]张培刚主编.新发展经济学,河南人民出版社,1999年版。
    [37]赵人伟,李实,李思勤.中国居民收入分配再研究,北京:中国财政经济出版社,1999.10.
    [38]周天勇:劳动力与经济增长,上海:上海三联出版社,1994.10。
    [1]安应民,高新才.人力资本要优先投资.北京社会科学,2(1999)。
    [2]白雪梅.教育与收入不均等:中国的经验研究.管理世界,2004年第6期.
    [3]包迪鸿、盛乐,人力资本投资对经济增长贡献率的实证研究与分析,商业研究,2005.8.
    [4]边雅静、沈利生,人力资本与我国东西部经济增长关系的实证研究,数量经济技术经济研究,2004,12.
    [5]蔡昉.城乡收入差距与制度变革的临界点.中国社会科学,2003年第5期.
    [6]蔡昉.为什么劳动力流动没有缩小城乡收入差距? .理论前沿,2005年第20期.
    [7]蔡鹏鸿.亚洲经济兴起的现状及前景.世界经济研究,2,(1995)。
    [8]曹晋文,我国人力资本与经济增长的实证研究,财经问题研究,2004,9:9-13.
    [9]陈德翔.发展中国家与相互依存的世界经济.世界经济研究,1,(1995),
    [10]戴亦一,人力资本核算问题研究,统计研究,1999年增刊:90-92.
    [11]邓翔,李建平.中国地区经济增长的动力分析.管理世界,2004年第11期.
    [12]丁栋虹.从人力资本到异质型人力资本与同质型人力资本.理论前沿,2001,(5):12-14.
    [13]董拴成(2002),人力资本对中国经济增长作用的实证分析,北方经贸,2002年第10期,
    [14]都阳.教育对贫困地区农户非农劳动供给的影响研究.中国人口科学,1999年第6期.
    [15]段成荣.中国人口受教育状况分析.人口研究,2006年第1期,第30卷.
    [16]方竹兰.论人力资本及其制度分析价值.学术月刊,2002.10:26-32.
    [17]高素英等,人力资本与河北省经济增长的实证研究,河北工业大学学报,2005.2:37-41.
    [18]龚六堂、谢丹阳,我国省份之间的要素流动和边际生产率的差异分析,经济研究,2004.1:45-53.
    [19]顾六宝,张明倩.CES经济增长模型中“贫困陷阱”理论的实证分析.统计研究.2001年第12期.
    [20]郭剑雄.人力资本、生育率下城乡收入差距的收敛.中国社会科学,2005年第3期.
    [21]郭庆旺,贾俊雪.积极的财政政策对区域经济增长与差异的影响.中国软科学,2005年第7期.
    [22]郭庆旺,贾俊雪.中国全要素生产率的估算:1979-2004 .经济研究,2005年第6期.
    [23]郭熙保.农村劳动力及其转移问题:理论思考与中国的经验.世界经济,2002年第12期
    [24]韩宗礼:我国教育投资的经济效益探析,教育研究,1990.1.
    [25]郝枫,人力资本对天津经济增长贡献的实证研究,统计与信息论坛,2005.3:86-91.
    [26]何枫等,我国资本存量的估算及其相关分析,经济学家,2003.5.
    [27]何金定,扩展的人口素质指数:一种对物质生活质量指数的改造,南方人口,1999.1:34-38.
    [28]侯风云.城乡发展差距的人力资本解释,理论学刊,2004年第2期.
    [29]侯风云.论人力资本概念,山东大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2000,(6).
    [30]候风云.中国农村人力资本收益率研究.经济研究,2004年第12期.
    [31]胡鞍刚.从人口大国到人力资本大国:1980—2000 .中国人口科学,2002年第5期.
    [32]胡永远,人力资本与经济增长:一个实证分析,经济科学,2003.1:54-60.
    [33]黄乾.人力资本产权的概念、结构与特征.经济学家,2000.5:38-45.
    [34]黄兆良.关于人力资源的若干思考.资源科学,2001,(4):31-35.
    [35]黄祖辉,王敏,万广华.我国居民收入不均等问题:基于转移性收入角度的分析.管理世界,2003年第3期.
    [36]赖德胜.教育、劳动力市场与收入分配.经济研究,1998年第5期.
    [37]李宝元,人力资本产权与中国企业改革,学术论坛,2000.3:30-34.
    [38]李坤望(1996),中国经济增长因素的比较分析,中州学刊,1996年第1期。
    [39]李实,丁赛.中国城镇教育收益率的长期变动趋势.中国社会科学,2003年第6期.
    [40]李治国、唐国兴,资本形成路径与资本存量调整模型——基于中国转型时期的分析,经济研究,2003.2:34-42.
    [41]李忠强等,人力资本、人力资本不平等与地区经济增长,中国人口科学,2005年增刊:105-110.
    [42]梁昭,国家经济持续增长的主要因素分析,世界经济,2000,7,50-56.
    [43]廖楚晖,我国农村劳动力转移与农民收入增长关系的实证研究,当代财经,2004.12.
    [44]林燕平.中国地区国民收入差距研究.北京:北京大学出版社,2000年版.
    [45]林毅夫,刘培林.中国经济发展战略与地区收入差距.经济研究,2003年第3期.
    [46]林毅夫.深化市场改革是解决当前农民问题的关.经济研究,11(1998)。
    [47]刘华等,人力资本与经济增长的实证分析,华中科技大学学报(自然科学版)2004.7:64-66.
    [48]刘世锦.结构转换缺口:中国经济面临的问题与选择.管理世界,6(1998)。
    [49]刘秀梅,田维明.我国农村劳动力转移对经济增长的贡献分析.管理世界,2005年第1期.
    [50]刘迎秋.论人力资本投资对中国经济成长的意义.管理世界,1997年第3期.
    [51]陆铭,陈钊.城市化、城市化倾向的经济政策与城乡收入差距.经济研究,2004年第6期.
    [52]孟晓晨等,中国主要省区人力资本利用效率及流动方向研究,人文地理,2005.6:5-10.
    [53]钱雪亚、王杰,中国人力资本水平实证研究,统计研究,2004.3:39-45.
    [54]桑秀国.利用外资与经济增长:一个基于新经济增长理论的模型及对中国数据的验证.管理世界,2002年第9期.
    [55]沈坤荣,马俊.中国经济增长的“俱乐部收”特征及其成因研究.经济研究,2002年第1期.
    [56]石磊,高帆.地区经济差距:一个基于经济结构的实证研究.管理世界.2006年第5期.
    [57]舒元、徐现祥,中国经济增长模型的设定:1952—1998,经济研究,2002.11:3-11.
    [58]孙杰:《克鲁格曼的理论“接口”和诺斯的“贸易由制度启动”命题——关于贸易理论的发展和制度创新比较优势的思考》,《经济研究》1997年第12期。
    [59]孙强,人力资本与中国经济的持续增长,云南财贸学院学报,1999.3:6-11.
    [60]孙志军.中国教育个人收益率研究:一个文献综述及其政策含义.中国人口科学,2004年第5期.
    [61]唐平.农村居民收入差距的变动及影响因素分析.管理世界,2006年第5期.
    [62]田成诗,盖美.我国劳动生产率对经济增长贡献的经济计量研究.中国软科学,2004年第6期.
    [63]万德梅、李燕萍,中国人力资本核算的统计框架,中南财经政法大学学报,1998.10:32-35.172
    [64]万广华,陆铭,陈钊.全球化与地区间收入差距:来自中国的证据.中国社会科学,2005年第3期.
    [65]万广华.解释中国农村区域间的收入不均等:一种基于回归方程的分解方法.经济研究,2004年第8期.
    [66]万广华.中国农村区域间居民收入差异及其变化的实证分析.经济研究,1998年第5期.
    [67]王艾青、安立仁,中国人力资本存量分析,学术研究,2004.9:26-32.
    [68]王超然、罗然然,我国教育与经济增长的实证研究,统计与信息论坛,2004.4:76-78.
    [69]王德劲,要素投入、人力资本与经济增长:一个实证研究,统计与信息论坛,2005.5:62-66.
    [70]王德劲、向蓉美.我国人力资本存量测算.统计与决策,2006(5):100-102.
    [71]王德劲等.我国人力资本存量估算:基于收入方法.统计与信息论坛,2006(5):68-74.
    [72]王贵新,黄颖钰.中国省际人口迁移与东部地带的经济发展:1995-2000 .人口研究,2005年第1期.
    [73]王皓,我国人口质量的评估方法,统计与决策,1999.4:14-15.
    [74]王金营.西部地区人力资本在经济增长中的作用核算.中国人口科学,2005年第3期.
    [75]王俊改、谢韦克,我国不同时期人口生命素质指数比较,南方人口,1997.1:9-13.
    [76]王青云,人口总体核算与人口质量评价,科技进步与对策,2004.8:110-112.
    [77]王文博、陈昌兵,包含制度因素的中国经济增长模型及实证分析,统计研究2002.5:3-6.
    [78]王小鲁,樊纲.中国收入差距的趋势和影响因素分析.经济研究.2005年第10期.
    [79]王毅敏等.人力资本范畴分析及现实思考,中国人力资源开发,2003.3:16-19.
    [80]王志刚,龚六堂,陈玉宇.地区间生产效率与全要素生产率增长率分解(1978-2003) .中国社会科学,2006年第2期
    [81]魏新、邱黎强.中国城镇居民家庭收入及教育支出负担率研究.教育与经济,1998年第4期.
    [82]吴兵、王铮,中国各省区人力资本测算研究,科研管理,2004.4:60-65
    [83]吴克功,论人力资源与人力资本及其转化,科技与管理,2002.3:121-123.
    [84]夏业良.论人力资本投入与转移中的后发利益.市场与人口分析,3(1999)。
    [85]肖红叶,郝枫.京津沪资本存量估算与经济增长因素比较研究,现代财经,2004.7:3-7.
    [86]徐增文.农村劳动力流动与农业劳动力的流失.中国农村经济,1995年第1期.
    [87]杨菁:《博弈论中的可信承诺及其在新制度经济学中的应用》,《世界经济情况》2004年第6期。
    [88]杨菁:《可信承诺理论及其应用》,《经济学动态》2003年第11期。
    [89]杨君、龚玉池:《有效制度供给不足与中国经济增长》,《经济学家》2001年第1期。
    [90]杨瑞龙:《论我国制度变迁方式与制度选择目标的冲突及协调》,《经济研究》1994年第5期。
    [91]杨瑞龙:《我国制度变迁方式转换的三阶段论》,《经济研究》1998年第1期。
    [92]杨云彦.劳动力流动、人力资本转移与区域政策.人口研究,1999年第23卷第5期.
    [93]姚树荣,张耀奇.人力资本涵义与特征论析.上海经济研究,2001,(2):54-57.
    [94]叶常林、徐德信:《改革呼唤制度企业家》,《经济问题探索》2000年第6期。
    [95]叶茂林等,教育对经济增长贡献的计量分析,数量经济技术经济研究,2003.1:89-92.
    [96]易纲,樊纲,李岩.关于中国经济增长与全要素生产率的理论思考.经济研究,2003年第8期.
    [97]岳书敬,刘朝明.人力资本与区域全要素生产率分析.经济研究,2006年第4期.
    [98]张帆,中国的物质资本和人力资本估算,经济研究,2000.8:65-71.
    [99]张海星,公共投资与经济增长的相关性,财贸经济,2004.12:43-49.
    [100]张红宇.城乡居民收入差距的平抑机制:工业化中期阶段的经济增长下政府行为选择.管理世界,2004年第4期.
    [101]张锦鹏.增长极理论的负效应.当代经济科学,6(1999),第99页。
    [102]张军,资本形成、工业化与经济增长:中国的转轨特征,经济研究,2002.6:3-14.
    [103]张军、吴桂英、张吉鹏,中国省际物质资本存量估算:1952-2000,经济研究,2004.10.
    [104]张军、章元,对中国资本存量K的再估计,经济研究,2003.7:35-44.
    [105]张军等,中国省际物质资本存量估算:1952—2000,经济研究,2004.10:35-44.
    [106]张立光,史有军,李华.贸易开放度对经济增长的长期均衡效应.财经科学2004.1.
    [107]张林秀,霍艾米,罗斯高等.经济波动中农户劳动力供给行为研究.农业经济问题,2000年第5期.
    [108]张明海,增长和要素替代弹性——中国经济增长1978—1999年的实证研究,学术月刊,2002.8:78-82
    [109]张衔,黄金辉,邓翔.东中西部地区农户人力资本投资行为比较分析.中国农村经济,2005年第
    [110]张小蒂,李晓钟.对我国长三角地区全要素生产率的估算及分析.管理世界,2005年第11期.
    [111]赵力涛.中国农村的教育收益率研究.中国社会科学,2006年第3期.
    [112]赵耀辉.中国农村劳动力流动及教育在其中的作用.经济研究,1997年第2期.
    [113]周德禄,基于人口指标的群体人力资本核算理论与实证,中国人口科学,2005.3,56-62.
    [114]周晓、朱农.论人力资本对中国农村经济增长的作用.中国人口科学,2003年第6期.
    [115]周亚,中国人力资本的分布差异研究,教育与经济,2004.2:17-20.
    [116]朱翊敏、钟庆才,广东省经济增长中人力资本贡献的实证分析,中国工业经济,2002.12:73-80.
    [117]朱勇,张宗益.技术创新对经济增长影响的地区差异研究.中国软科学,2005年第11期.
    [118]邹薇,张芬.农村地区收入差异与人力资本积累.中国社会科学,2006年第2期.
    [119]邹薇、庄子银:《中国改革过程的性质、特征与动态优化》。《经济研究》1995年第9期。
    [1] Barro,Robert J.,Xavier Sala-i-Martin(1995).Economic Growth .New York et al. McGraw-Hill.
    [2] Becker,Gary S.(1964/1993).Human Capital:A Theoretical and Empirical Analysis,with Special Reference to Education .Third Edition. Chicago and London:University of Chicago Press.
    [3] Bowman,M.J.(1962)Economics of Education .HEW Bulletin 5.
    [4] Card(eds.).Handbook of Labor Economics .Volume 3C:2943-2984. Amsterdam et al.:North-Holland.
    [5] Charles P.Kindleberger:Economic Development,Third Edition,1977.
    [6] Denison,Edward F.(1967).Why Growth Rates Differ:Postwar Experience in Nine Western Countries .Washington,D.C.:The Brookings Institution.
    [7] Edwards,E.(ed.),Employment in Development Nations,Columbia University Press
    [8] Fei,G.H.and Ranis,G.,Development of the Labor Surplus Economy:Theory and Policy,Richard D.Irwin,1964.
    [9] Forrest McDonald:Alexander Hamilton,W.W.Norton Co.New York,1979.
    [10] Ghatak,S.,An Introduction to Development Economics,Allen&Unwin, 1986.
    [11] Ghatak,S.and Ingersent,K.,Agriculture and Economic Development, Wheat sheaf Books,1987.
    [12] Gillis,M.Perkins,D.H.Roemer,M.and Snodgrass,D.R.,Economics of Development, Norton&Company,1987.
    [13] Harbinson,F.H.,Human Resource as the Wealth of Nations,Oxford University Press,1973.
    [14] Herrick,B.and Higgins,J.D.:Economic Development of a Small Plane, Norton&Company, 1979.
    [15] Herrick,B.and Kindleberger,C.P.:Economic Development,McGraw-hill, 1983.
    [16] Meier,G.M.,Leading Issues in Economic Development,Oxford University Press,1984.
    [17] North Douglass:Institutional Change and American Economic Growth,Cambridge University Press,1971.
    [18] Schultz,T.W.Investing in People:The Economic of Population Quality, University of California Press,1990.
    [19] The World Bank:the East Asia Miracle:Economic Growth and Public Policy,Oxford University Press,1993.
    [20] Todaro,M.P.,Economic Development in the Third World,Longman,Fourth Edition,1981.
    [21] W.L.Blackwell : The Beginning of Russian Industrialization , 1800-1960 , Princeton University Press,1968.
    [1] Abramvitz M.(1956).Resource and Output Trends in the United States Since 1870,American Economic Review.
    [2] Adams,C.C.(1994).The Knot Book:An Elementary Introduction to the Mathematical Theory of Knots.New York:W.H.Freeman.
    [3] Aghion,Philippe,Peter Howitt(1998).Endogenous Growth Theory . Cambridge,Mass.and London :MIT Press.
    [4] Ahlroth,S.,Bjorklund,A.,and Forslund,A.(1997).The output of the Swedish education sector .Review of Income and Wealth,43(1):89–104.
    [5] Anan de Brauw,Jikun Huang,Scotte Rozelle,etc.(2002).The Evolutions of China’s Rural Labor Markets during the Reform,Journal of Comparative Economics,Vol.30,(2):7.
    [6] Atkinson,A.B.(1970).On the Measurement of Inequality,Journal of Economic Theory,2.
    [7] Barro,Robert J.(1999).Human Capital and Growth in Cross-Country Regressions .Swedish Economic Policy Review 6(2):237-277.
    [8] Barro,Robert J.,Jong-Wha Lee(2000).International Data on Educational Attainment:Updates and Implications .Center of International Development Working Paper 42,April.
    [9] Barry R.Chiswick(1971).Earnings Inequality and Economic Development.Quarterly Journal of Economics 85:21.
    [10] Bencivenga,Valerie Rand Smith,Bruce D.(1997).Unemployment,Migration and Growth.Journal of Political Economics.Vol.105(3).
    [11] Benhabib and Spiegel(1994).The role of human capital in economic development: evidence from aggregate cross-country data .Journal of monetary economics,vol.34,pp143-173.
    [12] Bowles,S.,Gintis,H.,and Osborne,M.,(2001)The determinants of earnings:A behavioural approach ,Journal of Economic Literature,39(4),1137–1176.
    [13] Brandt,Loren and Carsten A.Holz(2004).Spatial Price Differences in China:Estimates and Implications,Manuscript,Social Science Division, Hong Kong University of Science and Technology,Hong Kong.
    [14] Caves,D.W.,Christensen,L.R.and W.E.Diewart(1982).The Economic Theory of Index Numbers and Measurement of Input, Output and Productivity,Econometrics:50.
    [15] Chen and Fleisher(1996).Regional Income Inequality and Economic Growth in China,Journal of Comparative Economics,22:141.
    [16] Chiswick,Barry R.(1998).Interpreting the Coefficient of Schooling in the Human Capital Earnings Function .Journal of Educational Planning and Administration 12(2):123-130.
    [17] Coleman,J.(1988),Social Capital in the Creation of Human Capital, American Journal of Sociology,Vol.94,Supplement,pp.S95-120.
    [18] Dagum,C.and Slottje,D.J.(2000).A new method to estimate the level and distribution of household human capital with application .Structural Change and Economic Dynamics,11(2):67–94.175
    [19] De la Fuente,Angel,Rafael Doménech(2000).Human Capital in Growth Regressions:How Much Difference Does Data Quality Make?,CEPR Working Paper 2466,May.
    [20] Dong Xiaoyuan:Two-tier Land Tenure System and Sustained Economic Growth in Post-1978 Rural China.World Development,24(5),1996.
    [21] Dublin,L.I.and Lotka,A.(1930).The Money Value of Man .Ronald Press Co.,New York,N.Y.Cited in Kiker(1966).
    [22] Eicher,Theo S.,Garcia-Penalosa,Cecilia(2001).Inequality and Growth:The Dual Role of Human Capital in Development,The Journal of Development Economics:173.
    [23] Eisner,R.(1985).The total incomes system of accounts .Survey of Current Business,65(1):24–48.
    [24] Engel,E.(1883).Der Werth des Menschen .Verlag von Leonhard Simion,Berlin.Cited in Kiker(1966).
    [25] Farr,W.(1853).Equitable taxation of property .Journal of Royal Statistics,16(March issue):1–45.
    [26] Fields,Gary S.,Yoo,GyeongJoon(2000).Falling labor income inequality in Korea’s economic growth: Patterns and underlying causes. Review of Income and Wealth 46:139–159.
    [27] Gary S.Becker(1964).Human capital:An Theoretical and Empirical Analysis with Special Reference to Education,Published by National Bureau of Economic Research,New York.
    [28] Graham,J.W.and Webb,R.H.(1979).Stocks and depreciation of human capital: New evidence from a present-value perspective .Review of Income and Wealth,25(2):209–224.
    [29] Gundlach,Erich,Desmond Rudman,Ludger W??mann(1998).Second Thoughts on Development Accounting .Kiel Working Paper 895,December.
    [30] Hanushek,Eric A.,Dennis D.Kimko(2000).Schooling, Labor Force Quality, and the Growth of Nations .American Economic Review:forthcoming.
    [31] Harris,J.R.and Todaro,M.P.,“Migration Unemployment and Development:A Two-Sector Analysis”,American Economic Review,March 1970.
    [32] Hayami and Ruttan(1970),Agricutural productivity differences among countries,American economic review,1970(6),pp895~911..
    [33] Heckman,James J.,Peter J.Klenow(1997).Human Capital Policy . University of Chicago, Mimeo.
    [34] Huselid and Barnes(2002).Human Capital Measurement Systems as A Source of Competitive Advantage,Harvard Business School working paper, 2002.10.
    [35] Islam,Nazrul(1995).Growth Empirics:A Panel Data Approach . Quarterly Journal of Economics 110(4):1127-1170.
    [36] Jacques Silber(1989).Factor Components,Population Subgroups and the Computation of the Gini Index of Inequality,The Review of Economics and Statistics,Vol.71,(2).
    [37] James J.Heckman(2002).China’s investment in human capital . NBER working paper series 9296.http://www.nber.org/papers/w9296.
    [38] Jeong,B.(2002).Measurement of human capital input across countries: A method based on the laborer’s income .Journal of Development Economics, 67(2):333–349.
    [39] John L.Glascock、C.F.Sirmans and Geoffrey k.Turnbull:Owner Tenancy as credible commitment under uncertainty,Journal of the American Real Estate and Urban Economics Association 1993 Vol21,1.
    [40] John R.Harris and Michael P.Todaro(1970).Migration,Unemployment and Development: A Two-Sector Analysis,American Economic Review.Vol.60.
    [41] Jorgenson,Dale W.(1995).Productivity.Volume 1:Postwar U.S. Economic Growth.Volume 2:International Comparisons of Economic Growth .Cambridge,Mass.And London:MIT Press.
    [42] Kakwani,Nanak C.(1977).Measurement of Tax Progressively:An International Comparison, The Economic Journal 87:71–80.
    [43] Kanbur and Zhang(2005).Fifty Years of Regional Inequality in China:A Journey Through Central Planning,Reform and Openness.Review of Development Economics 9(1).
    [44] Kendrick,J.(1976).The Formation and Stocks of Total Capital . Columbia University Press for NBER,New York,N.Y.
    [45] Klenow,Peter J.,Andrés Rodríguez-Clare(1997).Economic Growth:A Review Essay .Journal of Monetary Economics 40:597-617.
    [46] Krueger,A.B.and Lindahl,M.(2001).Education for growth: Why and for whom?,Journal of Economic Literature,39(4):1101–1136.
    [47] Kuznets,Simon(1955).Economic Growth and Income Inequality,The American Review,Vol.45,
    [48] Laroche,M.,M′erette,M.,and Ruggeri,G.C.(1999).On the concept and dimensions of human capital in a knowledge-based economy context . Canadian Public Policy-Analyse de Politiques,25(1):87–100.
    [49] Laroche,M.and Merette,M.(2000).Measuring human capital in Canada .Minist`ere des Finances du Canada,Division des Etudes Economiques et Analyses de Politiques.
    [50] Le,T.,Gibson,J.,and Oxley,L.(2006),A Forward-Looking Measure of the Stock of Human Capital in New Zealand .Manchester School,Vol.74, No.5,pp.593-609,2006.9.
    [51] Lewis,W.A.,“Economic Development with Unlimited Labor”,The Manchester School, May 1954.
    [52] Li Hai aheng(2003).Economic Transition and Returns to Education in China, Economics of Education Review.Jun.Vol.22,Issue 3.
    [53] Lin:Institutions and Economic Development,First Asian Development Bank Conference on Development Economics,Manila,Philippines,October 1992.
    [54] Loren Brandt and Carsten A..Holz(2004).Spatial Price Differences in China:Estimates and Implications.The Pre-Published Version.
    [55] Lucas,R.E.J.(1988).On the mechanics of economic development . Journal of Monetary Economics, 22(1):3–42.
    [56] Ludger J.loaning(2002).The impact of Education on Economic Growth in Guatemala, working paper.Ibero-american institute for economic research. 2002.6.
    [57] Machlup,F.(1984).The Economics of Information and Human Capital,volume 3.Princeton University Press,Princeton,N.J.
    [58] Macklem,R.T.(1997).Aggregate wealth in Canada .Canadian Journal of Economics, 30(1):152–168.
    [59] Mankiw,N.Gregory,David Romer,David N.Weil(1992).A Contribution to the Empirics of Growth .Quarterly Journal of Economics 107: 408-437.
    [60] Maroles,R.Armando(1998).Determinants of growth in an error-correction model for EI Salvador .IMF working paper,WP,98.104.
    [61] Metha,M.M,Human Resource Developing Planning:with Special Reference to Asia and the Far East,The Macmillan Company of India Limited,Delhi and Bombay,1976.
    [62] Michael P.Todaro(1969).A Model of Labor Migration and Urban Unemployment in Less Developed Countries.The American Economic Review.Vol.59.
    [63] Mincer,Jacob(1974).Schooling,Experience,and Earnings .New York: National Bureau of Economic Research.
    [64] Morduch,Jonathan,Sicular,etc.(2002).Rethinking Inequality Decomposition, with Evidence from Rural China.The Economic Journal 112.
    [65] Mulligan,Casey B.,Xavier Sala-i-Martin(1997).A Labor Income-Based Measure of the Value of Human Capital:An Application to the States of the United States .Japan and the World Economy 9(2):159-191.
    [66] North Douglass and Barry Weingast:Constitutions and Commitment:The Evolution of Institution Governing Public Choice in Seventeenth-Century England,Journal of Economic History 1989Vol49,4.
    [67] Oxley,L.and Zhu,W.(2002).How much human capital does New Zealand have?,In Econometric Society Australasian Meeting,Brisbane.
    [68] Peter Nolan,China's Rise,Russia's Fall:Politics,Economics and Planning in the Transition from Stalinism,New York:St.Martin's Press,1995.
    [69] Ponald J.Johnston(1998).Human Investment:An International Comparison.Published:Paris France, OECD.
    [70] Psacharopoulos,George(1994).Returns to Investment in Education:A Global Update .World Development 22:1325-1343.
    [71] Ramos,Joseph,R.(2000).Poverty and Inequality in Latin America:A Nonstructural Perspective, Journal of Interamerican Studies and World Affairs:141-157.
    [72] Romer Paul.M.(1986)Increasing Returns and Long-run Growth.Journal of Political Economy,Vol, 94.
    [73] Rosen,Sherwin(1985).The Theory of Equalizing Differences.In Ashenfelter and Layard,Handbook of Labor Economics.
    [74] Rozelle,Scott(1994).Rural Industrialization and Increasing Inequality:Emerging Patterns in China’s Reforming Economy.Journal of Comparative Economics 19.
    [75] Schultz,T.W.(1961).Investment in human capital .American Economic Review,51(1):1–17.
    [76] Shorrocks,A.F.,and D.Slottje(2002).Approximating Unanimity Orderings:An Application to Lorenz ominance,Journal of Economics,Supplement 9:101.
    [77] Shorrocks,A.F.and Wan,G.H.(2005).Spatial Decomposition of Inequality, Journal of Economic Geography,5(1).
    [78] Solow,Robert M.(1957).Technical Change and the Aggregate Production Function .Review of Economics and Statistics 39:312-320.
    [79] Tao,H.-L.and Stinson,T.F.(1997).An alternative measure of human capital stock .Development Center Bulletin 97/01,University of Minnesota.
    [80] Temple,J.(1999).A positive effect of human capital on growth . Economics Letters, 65(1):131–134.
    [81] Temple,Jonathan(2000).Growth Effects of Education and Social Capital in the OECD .University of Oxford,Mimeo.
    [82] Treadgold,M.(2000).Early estimate of the value of Australia’s stock of human capital .History of Economics Review,0(32):46–57.
    [83] Tsui,Kai Yuen(1991).China's Regional Inequality,1952-85,Journal of Comparative Economics, vol.15.
    [84] Uzawz,Hirofumi(1965).Optimum Change in an Aggregative Model of Economic Growth. International Economic Review,Vol,6.
    [85] Victor Nee(1989).A Theory of Market Transition:From Redistribution to Markets in State Socialism. American Sociological Review.
    [86] W.Arthur Lewis(1954).Economic Development With Unlimited Supplies of Labor,Manchester School,Vol.22.
    [87] W.T.Woo.Chinese Economic Growth(1988).Sources and Prospects,The Chinese Economy,Paris, in Fouquin M.and Lemoine F.(eds.).
    [88] Wan,G.H.(2004).Accounting for Income Inequality in Rural China,Journal of Comparative Economics,32(2).
    [89] Wan,Guanghua(2001).Changes in Regional Inequality in Rural China:Decomposing the Gini Index by Income Sources.Australian Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics 43.
    [90] Wickens,C.H.(1924).Human capital .In Report of the Sixteenth Meeting of the Australasian Association for the Advancement of Science,pages 536–554,Wellington.Government Printer.
    [91] Yan Wang and Yudong Yao ( 2001 ) .Sources of China’s Economic Growth, 1952-99:Incorporating human capital accumulation .The World Bank Working Paper.2001.3
    [92] Yang Yao:Government Commitment and the Outcome of Privatization in China,working papers of China Center for Economic Research,Beijing University,2001.
    [93] Yong,Alwyn(1995).The Tyranny of Numbers:Confronting the Statistical Realities of the East Asian Growth Experience,the Quarterly Journal of Economics,MIT Press,vol.110(3).
    [94] Zhang,Y.and Wan,G.H.(2006).Growth and Redistributive Impact on Poverty in China, Journal of Comparative Economics5:43.
    [95] Zhao,Wei and Xueguang,Zhou(2001),Institutional Transformation and Returns to Education in rban China:An Empirical Assessment.Mimeo,Department of Sociology,Duke University.
    [96] Zheng Jinghai and Hu Angang(2004).An Empirical Analysis of Provincial Productivity in China(1979-2001),Working Paper,Goteb org,Department of Economics.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700