新型国人颈椎前路内固定系统初步设计与相关实验研究
|
摘要
研究背景
基于颈椎前路内固定系统在临床应用中发现问题为本论文选题切入点：
1、颈椎前路内固定系统固定临近节段出现系列问题：诸如异位骨化、退行性变出现或加重、间盘突出、椎间隙变窄、椎体滑脱、稳定性下降等并发症。纠其原因，与内固定刚性固定后，其固定范围内应力摭挡效应加大，钢板弹性小、钢性大相关。2、相对于四肢骨折的多种可选择的内固定器而言，目前颈椎前路内固定器械品种较为单一，尤其对于合并骨质疏松、矮小症和儿童、颈椎畸型等特殊人群颈椎疾病患者，可选择性少，还不具备多样化的颈椎前路内固定器。3、目前国内常用颈椎前路内固定钢板主要依据于欧美国家种族颈椎解剖学特点设计的，与国人相比，其钢板显得比较宽大与厚重，尤其是行上颈椎或颈胸交界治疗时，术中显露与创伤过大，不便于安放与操作。因此，众多学者一直在不懈的努力围绕改进颈椎前路钢板设计，以设计一种应力摭挡效应小、固定后骨破坏干扰小、螺钉抗拨力强、个体化、微创、便于操作的生物学弹性新型颈椎前路固定钢板而展开各种实验研究。但到目前为止，依然是一个悬而未解的课题。本论文旨在设计并研究一种解决以上问题的一种新型颈椎前路内固定系统。
研究内容
为解决以上问题，分别设计并应用四种形状不同的新型颈椎前路钢板（X形钢板、X形中间开孔钢板、工形钢板、H形钢板）和Orion前路钢板进行比较实验研究，基于整体功能的测定比单纯内固定性能的测定更有意义的理念，对每种钢板固定前、后的颈椎标本进行应变、应力遮挡效应、应力松弛、蠕变特性测试、骨密度测试、骨纤维结构观察、骨组织形态计量学参数指标测量等多项对比分析，得出相应的统计学实验数据。
结果表明
X形和工形钢板优于其它形状设计钢板，具有体积小巧，应力遮挡率小；内固定后，内固定螺钉孔边缘部位骨密度降低小、骨组织计量等参数指标改变小；螺钉抗拨出能力强；防止因钢板固定引起的螺钉与骨界面应力过于集中等优点，与其它3种钢板相比，具有统计学差异。X形中间开孔钢板和H形钢板的应力遮挡率较大，内固定后，内固定螺钉孔边缘部位骨密度降低较明显、骨组织计量等参数指标改变较大，且与Orion钢板的各项指标相接近。
结论
与其它3种钢板比较，新型X形和工形前路颈椎钢板具有减少内固定的应力遮挡、钉骨界面的骨质破坏以及融合的相邻节段远期发生退变的机率；对固定节段钉骨接触界面的骨质破坏较小；固定螺钉抗拨出能力相对较强；可适用于国人及骨质疏松、矮小症和儿童、颈椎畸型等颈椎疾病的特殊人群；操作相对简单便于安放；创伤相对较小等诸多优点。“工”形钢板还可以在多种型号的改进方面有相对较大的拓展空间和优势。本研究结果可为临床治疗颈椎疾病筛选、设计一种微创、简便操作、更科学、更符合弹性固定及生物学固定的新型前路内固定钢板。其意义在于可为新型颈椎前路内固定钢板的设计提供生物力学基础数据和科学依据；也为颈椎前路钢板的改进提供改进方案和理念参考；更为其临床远期应用奠定实验基础。
本论文经查新证实，该实验研究既往文献未见报道。
Research Background
With the widely use of Chinese cervical internal fixation system in clinic,the goodtherapeutic effect of it has been recognized by many scholars.The commonly used of anteriorcervical internal fixation steel plate system is the fixation of single cortical screws,forexample,AO's Morscher steel plate (cervical spine locking plate,CSLP) and Sofamor-Danek's Orion steel plate (anterior cervical locking plate system,ACLPS).Pose a Question
We found its problems during the long time clinical work:1.It is mainly suited to racesin European and American countries as their anatomical features of cervical vertebra notours.2.Relative to internal fixation system of extremities fractures which has variouschoices,at present,the appearance design of anterior cervical internal fixation is single andalso the choice of it is litter.The difference between steel plate and screw is only length whilewidth and appearance are almost the same.To children and special groups which suffer fromcervical vertebra diseases such as osteoporosis,dwarfism and so on,it still has no individual,personalized and diversificational anterior cervical internal fixation devices.3.The anteriorcervical internal fixation system still has many problems,such as complications which arehyperostosis,degenerative change,herniated disk,Stability down and so on that occur in fixedadjacent segments,and the weight different clinical symptoms which occur relevantly.Objective
The paper design four different kinds of shape's new type of anterior cervical steelplates which are suitable for Chinese cervical vertebra's anatomical features (x-shaped、x-shaped middle-hole、工-shaped and H-shaped).Consulted and compared with Orionanterior cervical steel plate and screws internal fixation system,then through experimentalstudy of biomechanics, bone histomorphometry,pathology analysis of organization form and so on,to conclude corresponding statistics experimental data and do the statistical analysis inorder to design and screening a group of new type of anterior cervical internal fixationsystem which is more reasonable、scientific and suitable for Chinese people in clinicaltreatment of cervical vertebra diseases.Methods
Combining with Chinese people's anatomical features of cervical vertebra,design fourdifferent kinds of shape's new type of anterior cervical internal fixation system.The researchis divided into3parts:
1.Design the shape of steel plate and be divided into groups.Make and prepare theexperimental model1)Get40samples of pigs' cervical vertebra (c2-c7) to be randomly divided into5groups,thatis the group of steel plate of Orion type,x-shaped steel plate,x-shaped middle-hole steel plate,工-shaped steel plate and H-shaped steel plate (n=8).2)Review literatures to obtain Chinese people's anatomical parameters of cervicalvertebra,and then design and make the4kinds of steel plates according to the appearancewith the skill of steel plate and single cortical screws.Do the internal fixation with the4newkinds of steel plates after c4,5herniated disc anterior interbody fusion seperately.Steelplates' material:00Cr18Ni14Mo3,plate height is32MM,the width of plate is17mm,the lengthof screw is12mm,the perimeter of screw is3.5mm,screw aperture is3.5mm,the thickness ofthe wall of hole is2.0mm,thickness of plating is19mm,the flutes pitch is1.75mm,the screwcore diameter is2.5mm.（Seeing in the chapter of designation of steel plate spesifically）3)Paste strain gauge on the6related measured sites in internal fixation specimens of groups(that is below four screw holes after plate's fixation and near the center of plate in the relatedvertebra after fixation).
2.Biomechanics and other aspects' research in5kinds of steel plates'fixation1) Measure the Strain electric of c4,5segments of pigs'cervical vertebra before internalfixation.Based on the principle and technology of strain electric,set specimens of each groupto the electronic universal testing machine respectively to measure specimens' Strain electricof each group under the condition of compression, flexion, extension, left lateral bending,right lateral bending successively by resistance strain gauge. 2)Remove intervertebral disc and end plate in c4/5of each group,then implant bone pieces ofthe same,after that fix the steel plate.Paste strain gauge on the same6sites again,that ispasting sites of the two time are the same. Dynamically pressure on the electronic universaltesting machine to specimens, measure specimens' Strain electric of each group after internalfixation seperately under the condition of compression, flexion, extension, left lateralbending, right lateral bending by resistance strain gauge.Making the use of the one-wayHook's Law,calculate Strain of specimens in each group before and after fixation.Accordingto the stress shielding rate computational formula to calculate stress shielding rate of variousspecimens in various states.3)Do the stress relaxation and creep tests of5kinds of anterior cervical internal fixation ofsteel plate and screws system.The computer system collects100sets of experimental dataand automatically output data and curves after finishing. Deal experimental data withthree-parameter model at the end of the experiment to obtain stress relaxation equation ofeach group.
3.Do the bone mineral density measurement,observation of bone histomorphometry andmeasurements of bone histomorphometry of5kinds of anterior cervical internal fixation ofsteel plate and screws system in Chinese people.Results
1.The results of stress shielding rate show that the x-shaped steel plate and工-shapedsteel plate in the groups of compression, flexion, extension, left lateral bending, right lateralbending, have the litist stress shielding rate,which has significant difference (p＜0.05).
2.The results of stress relaxation show that there is not significant different among withdown amount of the stress in7200s (p>0.05).The results of creep tests show that,in the samehorizontal stress,the difference was not significant in7200s' increased amount of thestrain(p>0.05).
3.The results of bone mineral density measurement show that:1)The bone mineral density of the cancellous bone from the edge of fixed sites is notablylower than that of the non-fixed sites,which has a statistics difference (P<0.05);2)The bone mineral density of the cancellous bone of cervical vertebra in the screw holeedge of X-shaped steel plate is higher than that of other groups,which has a statistics difference (P<0.05);3)The bone mineral density in the screw hole edge of工-shaped steel plate is higher thanthat of x-shaped with middle-hole,H-shaped and Orion-type (P<0.05);4)The bone mineral density in the screw hole edge of x-shaped with middle-hole is higherthan that of H-shaped and Orion-type,which has a statistics difference (P<0.05);5)The bone mineral density in the screw hole edge of H-shaped is higher than that ofOrion-type,which has a statistics difference (P<0.05);6)The bone mineral density of the cancellous bone from the screw hole edge of fixed sites isalmost the same between X-shaped and工-shaped,which has no statistics difference(P>0.05);7)The bone mineral density of the cancellous bone from the screw hole edge of fixed sites inthe X-shaped and工-shaped are notably higher than that in the other groups,which has astatistics difference (P<0.05).
4.The results of the observation of bone histomorphometry show that:1)The trabecular bone of vertebral cancellous bone in the non-fixed sites are arranged indense and neatly;2)The trabecular bone of vertebral cancellous bone in the fixed sites are arrangeddisorderly,even some of the trabecular bone fracture;3)The bone tissue form of the cancellous bone from the edge of screw-fixed sites in theX-shaped is better than that in the other groups;4)The trabecular bone in the screw hole edge of X-shaped with middle-hole and工-shapedare arranged much more disorderly,the fracture are more seriousyl;5)The trabecular bone in the screw hole edge of H-shaped and Orion-type are arranged mostdisorderly,the fracture are most seriously.5.The results of measurements of bone histomorphometry show that:1)&2)The values of the non-fixed control group are greater than those of the other groupsbesides trabecular seperating degree, whose values are less than the other fixation groups，both of which has a statistics differences (p＜0.05);3)While the values of the X-shaped steel plate fixation group and工-shaped steel platefixation group are greater than the average of the other groups besides trabecular seperating degree, whose values are less than the other internal fixation groups,both of which has astatistics differences (p＜0.05);4)There is no statistics difference in the values of the screw hole edge between X-shaped and工-shaped(P>0.05);5)There is no statistics difference in the values of the screw hole edge between H-shaped andOrion-type besides trabecular seperating degree(P>0.05);6)The values of trabecular seperating degree in the screw hole edge of X-shaped are lower tothat in other groups,which has a statistics difference (P<0.05);7)There is no statistics difference in the values of trabecular seperating degree in the screwhole edge between H-shaped and Orion-type(P>0.05),which is also right between X-shapedand I-shaped(P>0.05).Conclusion
The research results indicate:The new type of X-shaped and工-shaped steel plate haveadvantages after internal fixation,for example,stress shielding rate is minor,the down amountof bone mineral density in the screw hole edge is minor,the changes of index or parameterssuch as the measurement of bone tissue are minor,and so on.They can reduce stress shieldingafter internal fixation to some extent,they could reduce the happening of vertebralosteoporosis in fixed segments relatively,at the same time,they could prevent that the stressof interface between screws and bone is too centralized caused by the fixation of steelplate,as well as that reduce bone destruction of interface between screws and bone andenhance intensity of screws in resistance to dial out.All of facts above prompt that the newtype of X-shaped and工-shaped steel plate could ease the happening of regression inadjacent segments of fixation fusion segments in long term to some extent,the designation ofwhich is more suitable for ideas of elastic fixation、biological osteosynthesis(BO) and theoryof biomechanics.Among them,工-shaped steel plate still has a larger development space inimprovement of diversified models and has certain advantages of aspects such asmorphology,biomechanics,improvement of model and so on.The research results couldprovide scientific basis at the aspect of the design and improvement in morphology for thenew type of cervical anterior internal fixation steel plate,also they have certainenlightenment significance to the improvement of steel plate.While the results of the other groups are lager accordingly.Innovations point
1.The paper is different from previous similar research. Previous research mostly basedon simulation regression、fracture、dislocation and so on of lower segments of cervicalvertebra,then do the experiments of stability and viscoelasticity under the condition ofanteflexion,extension,left lateral bending, right lateral bending and so on by transplantingbones or cervical anterior internal fixation system after Titanium nets fusion,such as anteriorsteel plate and screws、posterior lateral mass screws、 pedicle screw(PS) and so on.Thisexperiment uses steel plates of different geometric shape,that is X-shaped、X-shapedmiddle-hole、工-shaped, H-shaped and Orion-type after simulation c4,5herniated diskinterbody fusion to do the internal fixation,then study the comparation of each group instress shielding rate,bone histomorphometry,bone mineral density and other aspects. It hasbeen proved that this experiment have not been reported in the previous literature by noveltychecking.
2.The designation of steel plate and screws for the new type of anterior cervical internalfixation system change the situation that instruments of anterior cervical internal fixation aresingleness so that the choices are little in clinic.Also it provides steel plate and screws whichare diversified and more selective for the new type of anterior cervical internal fixationsystem to be more suited to children and special groups which suffer from cervical vertebradiseases such as osteoporosis,dwarfism and so on in China.Its operation is relatively easy,atthe same time,it exposes relatively small trauma,and also it easy to be clamped,placed andfixed.
基于颈椎前路内固定系统在临床应用中发现问题为本论文选题切入点：
1、颈椎前路内固定系统固定临近节段出现系列问题：诸如异位骨化、退行性变出现或加重、间盘突出、椎间隙变窄、椎体滑脱、稳定性下降等并发症。纠其原因，与内固定刚性固定后，其固定范围内应力摭挡效应加大，钢板弹性小、钢性大相关。2、相对于四肢骨折的多种可选择的内固定器而言，目前颈椎前路内固定器械品种较为单一，尤其对于合并骨质疏松、矮小症和儿童、颈椎畸型等特殊人群颈椎疾病患者，可选择性少，还不具备多样化的颈椎前路内固定器。3、目前国内常用颈椎前路内固定钢板主要依据于欧美国家种族颈椎解剖学特点设计的，与国人相比，其钢板显得比较宽大与厚重，尤其是行上颈椎或颈胸交界治疗时，术中显露与创伤过大，不便于安放与操作。因此，众多学者一直在不懈的努力围绕改进颈椎前路钢板设计，以设计一种应力摭挡效应小、固定后骨破坏干扰小、螺钉抗拨力强、个体化、微创、便于操作的生物学弹性新型颈椎前路固定钢板而展开各种实验研究。但到目前为止，依然是一个悬而未解的课题。本论文旨在设计并研究一种解决以上问题的一种新型颈椎前路内固定系统。
研究内容
为解决以上问题，分别设计并应用四种形状不同的新型颈椎前路钢板（X形钢板、X形中间开孔钢板、工形钢板、H形钢板）和Orion前路钢板进行比较实验研究，基于整体功能的测定比单纯内固定性能的测定更有意义的理念，对每种钢板固定前、后的颈椎标本进行应变、应力遮挡效应、应力松弛、蠕变特性测试、骨密度测试、骨纤维结构观察、骨组织形态计量学参数指标测量等多项对比分析，得出相应的统计学实验数据。
结果表明
X形和工形钢板优于其它形状设计钢板，具有体积小巧，应力遮挡率小；内固定后，内固定螺钉孔边缘部位骨密度降低小、骨组织计量等参数指标改变小；螺钉抗拨出能力强；防止因钢板固定引起的螺钉与骨界面应力过于集中等优点，与其它3种钢板相比，具有统计学差异。X形中间开孔钢板和H形钢板的应力遮挡率较大，内固定后，内固定螺钉孔边缘部位骨密度降低较明显、骨组织计量等参数指标改变较大，且与Orion钢板的各项指标相接近。
结论
与其它3种钢板比较，新型X形和工形前路颈椎钢板具有减少内固定的应力遮挡、钉骨界面的骨质破坏以及融合的相邻节段远期发生退变的机率；对固定节段钉骨接触界面的骨质破坏较小；固定螺钉抗拨出能力相对较强；可适用于国人及骨质疏松、矮小症和儿童、颈椎畸型等颈椎疾病的特殊人群；操作相对简单便于安放；创伤相对较小等诸多优点。“工”形钢板还可以在多种型号的改进方面有相对较大的拓展空间和优势。本研究结果可为临床治疗颈椎疾病筛选、设计一种微创、简便操作、更科学、更符合弹性固定及生物学固定的新型前路内固定钢板。其意义在于可为新型颈椎前路内固定钢板的设计提供生物力学基础数据和科学依据；也为颈椎前路钢板的改进提供改进方案和理念参考；更为其临床远期应用奠定实验基础。
本论文经查新证实，该实验研究既往文献未见报道。
Research Background
With the widely use of Chinese cervical internal fixation system in clinic,the goodtherapeutic effect of it has been recognized by many scholars.The commonly used of anteriorcervical internal fixation steel plate system is the fixation of single cortical screws,forexample,AO's Morscher steel plate (cervical spine locking plate,CSLP) and Sofamor-Danek's Orion steel plate (anterior cervical locking plate system,ACLPS).Pose a Question
We found its problems during the long time clinical work:1.It is mainly suited to racesin European and American countries as their anatomical features of cervical vertebra notours.2.Relative to internal fixation system of extremities fractures which has variouschoices,at present,the appearance design of anterior cervical internal fixation is single andalso the choice of it is litter.The difference between steel plate and screw is only length whilewidth and appearance are almost the same.To children and special groups which suffer fromcervical vertebra diseases such as osteoporosis,dwarfism and so on,it still has no individual,personalized and diversificational anterior cervical internal fixation devices.3.The anteriorcervical internal fixation system still has many problems,such as complications which arehyperostosis,degenerative change,herniated disk,Stability down and so on that occur in fixedadjacent segments,and the weight different clinical symptoms which occur relevantly.Objective
The paper design four different kinds of shape's new type of anterior cervical steelplates which are suitable for Chinese cervical vertebra's anatomical features (x-shaped、x-shaped middle-hole、工-shaped and H-shaped).Consulted and compared with Orionanterior cervical steel plate and screws internal fixation system,then through experimentalstudy of biomechanics, bone histomorphometry,pathology analysis of organization form and so on,to conclude corresponding statistics experimental data and do the statistical analysis inorder to design and screening a group of new type of anterior cervical internal fixationsystem which is more reasonable、scientific and suitable for Chinese people in clinicaltreatment of cervical vertebra diseases.Methods
Combining with Chinese people's anatomical features of cervical vertebra,design fourdifferent kinds of shape's new type of anterior cervical internal fixation system.The researchis divided into3parts:
1.Design the shape of steel plate and be divided into groups.Make and prepare theexperimental model1)Get40samples of pigs' cervical vertebra (c2-c7) to be randomly divided into5groups,thatis the group of steel plate of Orion type,x-shaped steel plate,x-shaped middle-hole steel plate,工-shaped steel plate and H-shaped steel plate (n=8).2)Review literatures to obtain Chinese people's anatomical parameters of cervicalvertebra,and then design and make the4kinds of steel plates according to the appearancewith the skill of steel plate and single cortical screws.Do the internal fixation with the4newkinds of steel plates after c4,5herniated disc anterior interbody fusion seperately.Steelplates' material:00Cr18Ni14Mo3,plate height is32MM,the width of plate is17mm,the lengthof screw is12mm,the perimeter of screw is3.5mm,screw aperture is3.5mm,the thickness ofthe wall of hole is2.0mm,thickness of plating is19mm,the flutes pitch is1.75mm,the screwcore diameter is2.5mm.（Seeing in the chapter of designation of steel plate spesifically）3)Paste strain gauge on the6related measured sites in internal fixation specimens of groups(that is below four screw holes after plate's fixation and near the center of plate in the relatedvertebra after fixation).
2.Biomechanics and other aspects' research in5kinds of steel plates'fixation1) Measure the Strain electric of c4,5segments of pigs'cervical vertebra before internalfixation.Based on the principle and technology of strain electric,set specimens of each groupto the electronic universal testing machine respectively to measure specimens' Strain electricof each group under the condition of compression, flexion, extension, left lateral bending,right lateral bending successively by resistance strain gauge. 2)Remove intervertebral disc and end plate in c4/5of each group,then implant bone pieces ofthe same,after that fix the steel plate.Paste strain gauge on the same6sites again,that ispasting sites of the two time are the same. Dynamically pressure on the electronic universaltesting machine to specimens, measure specimens' Strain electric of each group after internalfixation seperately under the condition of compression, flexion, extension, left lateralbending, right lateral bending by resistance strain gauge.Making the use of the one-wayHook's Law,calculate Strain of specimens in each group before and after fixation.Accordingto the stress shielding rate computational formula to calculate stress shielding rate of variousspecimens in various states.3)Do the stress relaxation and creep tests of5kinds of anterior cervical internal fixation ofsteel plate and screws system.The computer system collects100sets of experimental dataand automatically output data and curves after finishing. Deal experimental data withthree-parameter model at the end of the experiment to obtain stress relaxation equation ofeach group.
3.Do the bone mineral density measurement,observation of bone histomorphometry andmeasurements of bone histomorphometry of5kinds of anterior cervical internal fixation ofsteel plate and screws system in Chinese people.Results
1.The results of stress shielding rate show that the x-shaped steel plate and工-shapedsteel plate in the groups of compression, flexion, extension, left lateral bending, right lateralbending, have the litist stress shielding rate,which has significant difference (p＜0.05).
2.The results of stress relaxation show that there is not significant different among withdown amount of the stress in7200s (p>0.05).The results of creep tests show that,in the samehorizontal stress,the difference was not significant in7200s' increased amount of thestrain(p>0.05).
3.The results of bone mineral density measurement show that:1)The bone mineral density of the cancellous bone from the edge of fixed sites is notablylower than that of the non-fixed sites,which has a statistics difference (P<0.05);2)The bone mineral density of the cancellous bone of cervical vertebra in the screw holeedge of X-shaped steel plate is higher than that of other groups,which has a statistics difference (P<0.05);3)The bone mineral density in the screw hole edge of工-shaped steel plate is higher thanthat of x-shaped with middle-hole,H-shaped and Orion-type (P<0.05);4)The bone mineral density in the screw hole edge of x-shaped with middle-hole is higherthan that of H-shaped and Orion-type,which has a statistics difference (P<0.05);5)The bone mineral density in the screw hole edge of H-shaped is higher than that ofOrion-type,which has a statistics difference (P<0.05);6)The bone mineral density of the cancellous bone from the screw hole edge of fixed sites isalmost the same between X-shaped and工-shaped,which has no statistics difference(P>0.05);7)The bone mineral density of the cancellous bone from the screw hole edge of fixed sites inthe X-shaped and工-shaped are notably higher than that in the other groups,which has astatistics difference (P<0.05).
4.The results of the observation of bone histomorphometry show that:1)The trabecular bone of vertebral cancellous bone in the non-fixed sites are arranged indense and neatly;2)The trabecular bone of vertebral cancellous bone in the fixed sites are arrangeddisorderly,even some of the trabecular bone fracture;3)The bone tissue form of the cancellous bone from the edge of screw-fixed sites in theX-shaped is better than that in the other groups;4)The trabecular bone in the screw hole edge of X-shaped with middle-hole and工-shapedare arranged much more disorderly,the fracture are more seriousyl;5)The trabecular bone in the screw hole edge of H-shaped and Orion-type are arranged mostdisorderly,the fracture are most seriously.5.The results of measurements of bone histomorphometry show that:1)&2)The values of the non-fixed control group are greater than those of the other groupsbesides trabecular seperating degree, whose values are less than the other fixation groups，both of which has a statistics differences (p＜0.05);3)While the values of the X-shaped steel plate fixation group and工-shaped steel platefixation group are greater than the average of the other groups besides trabecular seperating degree, whose values are less than the other internal fixation groups,both of which has astatistics differences (p＜0.05);4)There is no statistics difference in the values of the screw hole edge between X-shaped and工-shaped(P>0.05);5)There is no statistics difference in the values of the screw hole edge between H-shaped andOrion-type besides trabecular seperating degree(P>0.05);6)The values of trabecular seperating degree in the screw hole edge of X-shaped are lower tothat in other groups,which has a statistics difference (P<0.05);7)There is no statistics difference in the values of trabecular seperating degree in the screwhole edge between H-shaped and Orion-type(P>0.05),which is also right between X-shapedand I-shaped(P>0.05).Conclusion
The research results indicate:The new type of X-shaped and工-shaped steel plate haveadvantages after internal fixation,for example,stress shielding rate is minor,the down amountof bone mineral density in the screw hole edge is minor,the changes of index or parameterssuch as the measurement of bone tissue are minor,and so on.They can reduce stress shieldingafter internal fixation to some extent,they could reduce the happening of vertebralosteoporosis in fixed segments relatively,at the same time,they could prevent that the stressof interface between screws and bone is too centralized caused by the fixation of steelplate,as well as that reduce bone destruction of interface between screws and bone andenhance intensity of screws in resistance to dial out.All of facts above prompt that the newtype of X-shaped and工-shaped steel plate could ease the happening of regression inadjacent segments of fixation fusion segments in long term to some extent,the designation ofwhich is more suitable for ideas of elastic fixation、biological osteosynthesis(BO) and theoryof biomechanics.Among them,工-shaped steel plate still has a larger development space inimprovement of diversified models and has certain advantages of aspects such asmorphology,biomechanics,improvement of model and so on.The research results couldprovide scientific basis at the aspect of the design and improvement in morphology for thenew type of cervical anterior internal fixation steel plate,also they have certainenlightenment significance to the improvement of steel plate.While the results of the other groups are lager accordingly.Innovations point
1.The paper is different from previous similar research. Previous research mostly basedon simulation regression、fracture、dislocation and so on of lower segments of cervicalvertebra,then do the experiments of stability and viscoelasticity under the condition ofanteflexion,extension,left lateral bending, right lateral bending and so on by transplantingbones or cervical anterior internal fixation system after Titanium nets fusion,such as anteriorsteel plate and screws、posterior lateral mass screws、 pedicle screw(PS) and so on.Thisexperiment uses steel plates of different geometric shape,that is X-shaped、X-shapedmiddle-hole、工-shaped, H-shaped and Orion-type after simulation c4,5herniated diskinterbody fusion to do the internal fixation,then study the comparation of each group instress shielding rate,bone histomorphometry,bone mineral density and other aspects. It hasbeen proved that this experiment have not been reported in the previous literature by noveltychecking.
2.The designation of steel plate and screws for the new type of anterior cervical internalfixation system change the situation that instruments of anterior cervical internal fixation aresingleness so that the choices are little in clinic.Also it provides steel plate and screws whichare diversified and more selective for the new type of anterior cervical internal fixationsystem to be more suited to children and special groups which suffer from cervical vertebradiseases such as osteoporosis,dwarfism and so on in China.Its operation is relatively easy,atthe same time,it exposes relatively small trauma,and also it easy to be clamped,placed andfixed.
引文
[1]陈仲强，于泽生．脊柱内固定技术的现状与发展[J]．中华医学杂志，2006，86（25）：1729-1730．
[2] Fuller KA，Wellman BJ，et al.ComPlieation of Posterior artieular mass plate fixation ofthe subaxial cervical spine in43executive patients. Spine，1998，23:193一200
[3] Lowery GL，McDonough RF.The significance of hardware failure ifn anterior cervicalplate fixation:patients with2-to7-year follow-up. Spine，1998，23:181一187
[4]瞿东宾，朱青安，等，脊柱融合术后邻近节段退变及其机制[J]。中国脊柱脊髓杂志，1998，8(6):344一346
[5]邓高明，徐盛明，王新伟．脊柱内固定器械的生物力学评价方法[J]．颈腰痛杂志，2004，25（3）：211-213．
[6] Bailey, Badgley C. Stabilization of the cervical spine by anterior fusion. J Bone JointSurg Am,1960,42(3):565-594．
[7] Regiswhaid MD, Kevinfoley MD, Geralderodts MD, et al. The Cervical Spine StudyGroupAnterior Cervical Plate.Nomenclature Neurosurg Focus,2002,12(1):15-19．
[8] Bohler J, Gauclernak T. Anterior plate stabilization for fracture dislocations of the lowercervical spine J. Trauma,1980,20(1):203-205．
[9] Schulte K, Clark CR.GoelVK Kinematics of the cervical spine following discotomy andstabilization.Spine,1989,14:1116-1121．
[10]Haid RW, Foley KT, Rodts GE, et al. The Cervical Spine Study Group anterior cervicalplate nomenclature.Neurosurg Focus2002,12(1):15-19．
[11]彭翠宁．颈椎前路钢板内固定系统在脊柱固定中的生物力学特性[J]．中国组织工程研究与临床康复，2008，12（39）：7711-7715．
[12]昌耘冰，尹庆水，夏虹等．AxIS侧板钢板螺钉内固定系统对颈椎骨折脱位后颈髓功能恢复作用[J]．中国临床康复，2003，7（6）：998-1001．
[13]Spivak JM,Chen D,Kummer FJ.The effect of locking fixation fixation screws on thestability of anterior cervical plating.Spine1999;24:334-338
[14] Ryken TC,Clausen JD,Traynelis VC,et al.Biomechanical analysis of bone mieraldensity,insertion technique,screw torpue,and holding strength of anterior cervical platescrews.J Neurosurg1995;83:325-329
[15]陈波，柳峰。颈椎前路单纯椎间融合器与钢板并用恢复颈椎生理曲度[J].中国临床康复，2003,7(8):1279
[16] Coe JD,Warden KE，Stutterlin CE3rd,et al.Biomechanical evaluation of cervical spinalstabilization mothods I human cadaveric model.Spine1989;14:1122-1131
[17] Zdeblick TA.Cooke ME,Wilson D,et al.Anterior cervical discectomy,fusion,andplating.Spine1993;18:1794-83
[18] Connolly PJ,Esses SI,Kostuik JP.Anterior cervical fusion:Out-come analysis of patientsused with and without anterior cervical plates.J Spinal Disord1996;9:202-206
[19] Lowery GL,MeDonoug RF.The significance of hardware failure in anterior cervicalplate fixation.Spine1998;23:181-186
[20] Sutterlm CE III, McAfee PC Warden KE, et al. Abiomechanioal evaluation of cervicalspinal stabilization methods in a bovine model Static and cyclical loading [J].Spine,1988,46(13):795-802．
[21]王炳强，李东，杨雍等．颈椎侧块钢板内固定研究进展[J]．颈腰痛杂志，2007，28（4）：328-330．
[22]杨金江，王炳强，王志义等．下颈椎单侧侧块钢板内固定的稳定性研究[J]．颈腰痛杂志，2006，（3）：166-169．
[23]杨雍，王炳强，李东等．单侧短节段侧块内固定系统在颈椎病单开门减压术中的应用[J]．颈腰痛杂志，2006，27（4）：254-257．
[24] Heller JG,Esters BT Zaouali M,et al.Cervical lateral mass screws:Biomechanicl studyof variables affecting pullout strength [J]．J Bone Joint Surg Am,1996,78(5):1315-1321．
[25] Nabil Ebraheim.M.D Posterior Lateral Mass Screw Fixntion:Anatomic andRdiograpaic Considerations [J].Orthopacdic Journal,1999,42(12):66-72．
[26] Album I K, Itoh h, Tanceichi h．et al．Tran spedicuiar screw fixation for traumaticleisions of the middle and lower cervical spine: description of the techniques andpreliminary report[J]．J Spinal Disord,1994,32(7):119-123．
[27]田纪伟，袁文，张清港．颈椎椎弓根内固定系统研究进展[J]．中国矫形外科杂志，2006，14（4）：308-312．
[28] Album I K, Kanedak, Shono Y,et al.Onestage posterior decomp ression andreconstruction of the cervical spine by using pedicle screw fixation systems[J]．JNeurosurgery,1999,9(11).19-22．
[29]赵宝林，何凤江，马洪顺．异种骨椎间融合器附加椎弓根钉行后路椎体间融合术的生物力学分析[J]．北京生物医学工程，2007，26（5）：526-530．
[30]张忠君，王巍，马洪顺．颈椎小关节切除对颈椎稳定性影响的实验研究[J]．生物医学工程研究，2008，27（4）：284-286．
[31] Haid RW,Foley KT,Rodts GE,et al.The Cervical Spine Sindy Group anterior cervicalplate nomenclature.Neurosurg Focus．2002,12(1):15-20．
[32]何立民，郝定均，郭华等．下颈椎椎体槽式钢板与AO钢板抗应力强度实验比较[J]．伤残医学杂志，2008，10（4）：6-7．
[33]李超，干阜生，王以进等．拱桥弹性钢板椎弓根固定器的研制与临床应用[J]．中国脊柱脊髓杂志，2002，12（5）：330-334．
[34]蒋振松，张佐伦，刘兰成．脊髓型颈椎病患者的颈椎CT测量及临床意义[J]．中国脊柱脊髓杂志，2003，12（4）：220-223．
[35] An hS, Gordin R, Renner K.Anatomic considerations for plate screw fixation of thecervical. Spine1991,16(10):548-501．
[36]徐波，金大地．下颈椎后路钢板螺钉固定的解剖学研究[J]．中华骨科杂志，2000，20（5）：279-282．
[37] Pait TC,McAllister PV,Kaufman hh.Quadrant anatomy of the articular pillars(lateralcervical mass)of the cervical spine.J Neurosurgery1995,82（10）:11-14．
[38] Heller JG, Silor Dh, Sufferlin CE.Complications of posterior cervical plating. Spine1995,32(20):2442-2448．
[39] Anderson PA, henley MB, Grady MS, ET al.Posterior cervical arthrodesis with Aoreconstruction plates and bone graft. Spine1991,16(3):72-79．
[40] Kotani Y, Cunningham BW, Abumi K, te al.Biomechonical analysis of cervicalstabilization systems: An assessment of transpedicular screw fixation in the cervicalSpine. Spine1994;19(22):2852-2856．
[41]于博，靳安民，吴广森等．人工可吸收颈椎融合器组织相容性的实验研究[J]．中国临床康复，2003，7（6）：908-911．
[42] Jones EI, heller JG, Silcox Dh, et al.Cervical pedicle screws versus lateral mass screws.Spine1997,22(4):997-1002．
[43]罗飞，许建中，王序全等．三种颈椎前路内固定装置对术后脊柱稳定性的作用[J]．中国临床康复，2003，7（20）：2830-2833．
[44] Album I K,Shono Y,Kotani Y.et al.Indirect posterior reduction and fusion of thetraumatic herniated by using a cervical pedicle screw system.J Neurosurgery2000,92(1):30-37．
[45] Smith MD, Emery SE, Dudley A, et al.Vertebral antery injury during anteriordecompression of the cervical spine. Aretrospective review of ten patients.J Bone JointSurg Br1993,75(2):410-415．
[46] Ebraheim NA,Lu J,Brown JA,et al,Vulnerability of vertebral antery in anterolateraldecompression for cervical spondylosis.Clin Orthop1996,32(1):146-151．
[47] Pait TG,Killefer JA,Arnautovic KI,Sugical anatomy of the anterior cervical spine; thedisc space, vertebral antery,and associated bony structures. The disc space, vertebralantery, and associated bony structures. Neurosurgery1996,39(3):769-776．
[48] Oga M,Yuge I,Terada K,et al.Tortuosity of the vertebral avtery in patients with cervicalspondylotic myelopathy:risk factor for the vertebral artery injury during anteriorcervical decompressin.Spine1996,21（6）:1082-1089．
[49]闫德强，谢志军，于德有等．颈椎弓根螺钉内固定的解剖学研究[J]．中华骨科杂志，2002，22（11）：657-661．
[50]傅一山，陈正形．颈椎椎弓根置钉的影像学测量[J]．中国脊柱脊髓杂志，2001，11（1）：29-31．
[51]徐荣明，校佰平，冯建翔等．颈椎椎弓根螺钉内固定技术有关问题探讨[J]．脊柱外科学杂志，2003，1（1）：19-22．
[52] Miller RM, Ebrabeim NA, xn R, et al.Anatomic consideration of transpedicular screwplaccment in the cervical spine. An analysis of two approaches. Spine1996,38(21):2317-2322．
[53] Karaikovic EE, Yingsakmongkol W, Gaines RW Jr.Accuracy of cervical pedicle screwplacement using the funnel technique. Spine2001,46(10):2456-2462．
[54] Kumaresan S,Yoganandan N,Pintar FA,et al.Finite element modeling of cervicallaminectomy with graded facetectomy.J Spinal Discord1997,10(1):40-46．
[55] Kleinberger M.Application of finite element techniques to the study of cervical spinemechanics, Proceedings of the37th Step Car Crash Coference.USA:SAF International1993,261-272．
[56] Yoganandan N, Kumaresan S, Voo L, et al.Finite element model of the human lowercervical spine: parametric analysis of the C4-C6unit. J Bionmech Eng1997,119(1):87-92．
[57] Zhang Qh,Teo EC,Ng hW,et al.Finite element analysis of moment-rotationrelationships for human cervical spine.J Biomech2006,39(1):198-193．
[58]宋楠，程黎明．有限元分析法评价脊柱医源性负荷研究进展[J]．国际骨科学杂志，2007，28（4）：217-218．
[59] Sadegh AM,Tchako A.Vertebarl stress of a cervical spine model under dynamicload.Technol health Care2000,8(2):143-154．
[60] Ng hW,Teo EC.Nonlinear finite element analysis of the lower cervical spine(C4-C6)under axial loading.J Spinal Discord2001,14(3):201-210．
[61] Kumaresan S,Yoganandan N,Pintar FA,et al.Contrbution of disc degeneration toosteophyte formation in the cervical spine: a biomechanical investigation.J Orthop Res2001,19(5):977-984．
[62] Stemper BD,Yoganandan N,Pintar FA,et al.Development of extension kinematiccorridors to validate a head/neck finite element model. Biomed Sci Instrument2001,37(1):239-244．
[63]艾福志，尹庆水，夏虹等．经口咽前路寰枢椎复位钢板固定的三维运动稳定性和抗拔出力研究[J]．解放军医学杂志，2004，29（3）：223-225．
[64]李超，阮狄克，谈诚等．垂直负荷下颈椎前路限制性与非限制性钢板的生物力学比较[J]．第二军医大学学报，2005，26（12）：1388-1391．
[65]冯敬，蒋涛，陈良等．颈椎前路钢板内固定术对维持椎间高度的作用．中国修复重建外科杂志，2004，18（4）：344-345．
[66]徐育林，秦继斌，钟志坚．Orion钛钢板加钛网融合器治疗颈椎病．中国修复重建外科杂志，2004，18（4）：274-275．
[67]陈雷，李宜照，赵秀文等．双节段颈椎椎间融合固定对邻近下位关节生物力学的影响[J]．山东医药，2009，49（42）：87-88．
[68]荆玉华，田大胜，钱军等．颈椎融合内固定对相邻节段椎间关节压力影响的生物力学研究[J]．颈腰痛杂志，2009，30（3）：200-202．
[69]夏军，顾昕，黄煌渊．四种下颈椎内固定技术初始稳定性的生物力学比较[J]．中华创作骨科杂志，2004，6（4）：430-433．
[70]何达，韩骁，陶俭铎等．颈椎人工间盘置换与颈椎内固定置入对相邻节段退变的生物力学影响[J]．中国组织工程研究与临床康复，2008，12（22）：4229-4232．
[71]赵筑川，曹永飞，彭智等．颈椎前路钛网钢板固定及自体髂骨植骨在不同颈椎节段中的生物力学研究[J]．中国修复重建外科杂志，2006，20（11）：1077-1079．
[72]王晓军，刘伟强，阎志进等．颈椎前路植入内固定系统的有限元模拟及生物力学研究[J]．北京生物医学工程，2008，27（2）：267-271．
[73]曹永飞，赵筑川，彭智等．颈椎前路钛网植骨钢板内固定在不同颈椎节段中的生物力学比较[J]．生物医学工程学杂志，2007，24（2）：320-323．
[74]陈向东，张烽，范卫民等．Orion钢板固定后对植骨块及小关节突应力影响的实验研究[J]．中国矫形外科杂志，2003，11（3、4）：243-245．
[75]张烽，陆建华，赵俭等．颈前路Uniplate与Orion钢板单间隙固定生物力学研究[J]．中国矫形外科杂志，2008，16（19）：1490-1492．
[76] Album I K,Panjabi MM,Duranceau J.Biomechanlcal evaluation of spinal fixationdevices l Part stability provided by six spinal devices and interbody bone graft[J].Spine,2003,14(11):1249-1250．
[77] Ulrich C,Woresdoerfer O,Kalff R,et al. Biomechanics of fixation systems to thecervical spine[J].Spine,1991,116(1):4-8．
[78] Resnick DK, Trost GR.Use of ventral plates for cervical arthrodesis [J]. Neurosurgery,2007,53(1):112-117．
[79] Wang JC,M Donough PW,Endow K, et al.The effect of cervical plating on single levelanterior cervical discectomy and fusion[J].Spinal Discord1999,12(2):467-471．
[80] Samartzis D,Shen Fh,Lyon C,et al.Does rigid instrum negation increase the fusion ratein one level anterior cervical discectomy and fusion[J]. Spine,2004,34(3):636-643．
[81] Rickets on R.Single level anterior disectomy and fusion with and without plating Aprospective randomized study[R].Proceedings of the11thA nnualConference of theNorthAmerican Spine Sociely,Van corver B.C,Canada1996,251-253．
[82]刘建国．应力遮挡效应对骨折愈合的影响[J]．医用生物力学，1992，7（2）：138-140．
[83]刘建国．应力遮挡的生物效应[J]．医用生物力学，1992，7（2）：136-137．
[84]刘建国，徐莘香．应力遮挡效应与骨折愈合的实验和临床研究[J]．中华医学杂志，1994，74（8）：483-485．
[85]曹斌，张守平，王兆林等．低应力遮挡效应交锁髓内钉的研制与生物力学研究[J]．中国矫形外科杂志，2004，12（2）：930-933．
[86]裘世静．接骨板应力遮挡作用对疏松骨结构的后期影响[J]．医用生物力学，1992，7（4）：202-204．
[87]王以进．应力遮挡效应的理论基础和影响因素[J]．医用生物力学，1992，7（3）：198-190．
[88]袁旬华．应力遮挡的生物效应[J]．医用生物力学[J]．1992，7（1）：59-61．
[89]朱俊峰，张先龙，王成焘等．股骨假体近端应力遮挡对成骨细胞增殖调亡的影响[J]．临床骨科杂志，2009，12（3）：332-335．
[90]王禹基，孙俊英，董天华等．表面置换和全髓关节转换股骨近端应力遮挡比较[J]．中国骨与关节损伤杂志，2008，23（3）：183-185．
[91]朱元，毕大卫，全仁夫．纳米氧化锆梯度复合羟基磷灰石内固定材料的应力遮挡[J]．中医正骨，2008，20（8）：3-4．
[92]辛兵，侯筱魁，李永刚．脊柱固定器的应力遮挡[J]．中国矫形外科杂志，2000，7（2）：154-155．
[93] Heary RF,Albert TJ,Ludwig SC,et al.Surgical anatomy of the vertebral arteries.Spine,1996,21:2074．
[94] Smith MD,Emery SE,Dudley A,et al.Vertebral artery injury during anteriordecompression of the cervical spine.J Bone Joint Surg,1993,75B(3):410
[95]蒋富贵，瞿东滨，朱志刚，等．颈椎前路减压及内固定的解剖学问题．中国临床解剖学杂志，2000，18（4）：310-311．
[96]金大地，陈建庭，江建明，等．Orion锁定型颈椎前路钢板系统在颈椎外科中的应用．中华骨科杂志，1999，19(7)：328．
[97]张延哲，朴成东，马洪顺．双侧颈椎5%小关节切除后的应力松弛及其流变特性[J]．中国组织工程研究与临床康复，2009，13（13）：2501-2504．
[98]麻文焱，李鹏，马洪顺等．正常与病态股骨头松质骨蠕变方程的比较研究[J]．生物医学工程研究，2008，27（4）：281-283．
[99]王杨，刘大禹，李新颖等．三参数模型计算股骨颈松质骨的蠕变方程[J]．中国组织工程研究与临床康复，2011，15（35）：6483-6486．
[100]吴宗岱，陶宝祺主编．应变电测原理及技术[M]．北京：国防工业出版社，1982，236-237．
[101]张红石．补虚化瘀针法对去势大鼠骨质疏松模型骨物理学及工型胶原MRNA影响研究[D]．长春中医药大学硕士学位论文，2006.6．
[102]Zaveri GR, Ford M.Cervical spondylosis the role of anterior instrumentation afterdecompression and fusion J Spinal Discord,2001,14(1):10-16．
[103]柏传毅，王坤正，魏美钢等．颈椎钛板—融合器的研制及生物力学研究[J]．中国脊椎脊髓杂志，2003，13（10）：608-611．
[104]李振宇，马洪顺，姜洪志等．人体腰段脊柱粘弹性实验研究[J]．中国生物医学工程学报，1990，9（4）：241-245．
[105]周轶，高建军，金慰芳等．骨质疏松动物实验中的骨物理密度检测[J]．中国骨质疏松杂志，2003，9（1）：41-42．
[106]辛兵，李永刚，侯筱魁．脊柱内固定对椎体骨密度的影响[J]．上海第二医科大学学报，1998，18（3）：190-192．
[107]杨豪，程少丹，郑福增．颈椎病动物模型发病过程中颈椎骨密度的动态变化[J]．中国临床康复，2005，9（10）：70-71．
[108]丛锐，罗卓荆，李明全等．不同时期颈椎病患者颈椎骨密度变化与椎体变形关系[J]．中国临床康复，2003，7（5）：744-745．
[109]李旭芬，朱沛，李凤新等．骨密度测量部位选择探讨[J]．中国临床康复，2003，7（32）：4395-4397．
[110]丛锐，孙银中，李明全．腰椎滑脱症患者的骨密度变化分析[J]．中国临床康复，2002，6（3）：385-387．
[111]丛锐，王全平，冯立宁等．骨质疏松合并颈椎病的颈椎影像学及骨密度变化[J]．第四军医大学学报，2001，22（15）：1419-1421．
[2] Fuller KA，Wellman BJ，et al.ComPlieation of Posterior artieular mass plate fixation ofthe subaxial cervical spine in43executive patients. Spine，1998，23:193一200
[3] Lowery GL，McDonough RF.The significance of hardware failure ifn anterior cervicalplate fixation:patients with2-to7-year follow-up. Spine，1998，23:181一187
[4]瞿东宾，朱青安，等，脊柱融合术后邻近节段退变及其机制[J]。中国脊柱脊髓杂志，1998，8(6):344一346
[5]邓高明，徐盛明，王新伟．脊柱内固定器械的生物力学评价方法[J]．颈腰痛杂志，2004，25（3）：211-213．
[6] Bailey, Badgley C. Stabilization of the cervical spine by anterior fusion. J Bone JointSurg Am,1960,42(3):565-594．
[7] Regiswhaid MD, Kevinfoley MD, Geralderodts MD, et al. The Cervical Spine StudyGroupAnterior Cervical Plate.Nomenclature Neurosurg Focus,2002,12(1):15-19．
[8] Bohler J, Gauclernak T. Anterior plate stabilization for fracture dislocations of the lowercervical spine J. Trauma,1980,20(1):203-205．
[9] Schulte K, Clark CR.GoelVK Kinematics of the cervical spine following discotomy andstabilization.Spine,1989,14:1116-1121．
[10]Haid RW, Foley KT, Rodts GE, et al. The Cervical Spine Study Group anterior cervicalplate nomenclature.Neurosurg Focus2002,12(1):15-19．
[11]彭翠宁．颈椎前路钢板内固定系统在脊柱固定中的生物力学特性[J]．中国组织工程研究与临床康复，2008，12（39）：7711-7715．
[12]昌耘冰，尹庆水，夏虹等．AxIS侧板钢板螺钉内固定系统对颈椎骨折脱位后颈髓功能恢复作用[J]．中国临床康复，2003，7（6）：998-1001．
[13]Spivak JM,Chen D,Kummer FJ.The effect of locking fixation fixation screws on thestability of anterior cervical plating.Spine1999;24:334-338
[14] Ryken TC,Clausen JD,Traynelis VC,et al.Biomechanical analysis of bone mieraldensity,insertion technique,screw torpue,and holding strength of anterior cervical platescrews.J Neurosurg1995;83:325-329
[15]陈波，柳峰。颈椎前路单纯椎间融合器与钢板并用恢复颈椎生理曲度[J].中国临床康复，2003,7(8):1279
[16] Coe JD,Warden KE，Stutterlin CE3rd,et al.Biomechanical evaluation of cervical spinalstabilization mothods I human cadaveric model.Spine1989;14:1122-1131
[17] Zdeblick TA.Cooke ME,Wilson D,et al.Anterior cervical discectomy,fusion,andplating.Spine1993;18:1794-83
[18] Connolly PJ,Esses SI,Kostuik JP.Anterior cervical fusion:Out-come analysis of patientsused with and without anterior cervical plates.J Spinal Disord1996;9:202-206
[19] Lowery GL,MeDonoug RF.The significance of hardware failure in anterior cervicalplate fixation.Spine1998;23:181-186
[20] Sutterlm CE III, McAfee PC Warden KE, et al. Abiomechanioal evaluation of cervicalspinal stabilization methods in a bovine model Static and cyclical loading [J].Spine,1988,46(13):795-802．
[21]王炳强，李东，杨雍等．颈椎侧块钢板内固定研究进展[J]．颈腰痛杂志，2007，28（4）：328-330．
[22]杨金江，王炳强，王志义等．下颈椎单侧侧块钢板内固定的稳定性研究[J]．颈腰痛杂志，2006，（3）：166-169．
[23]杨雍，王炳强，李东等．单侧短节段侧块内固定系统在颈椎病单开门减压术中的应用[J]．颈腰痛杂志，2006，27（4）：254-257．
[24] Heller JG,Esters BT Zaouali M,et al.Cervical lateral mass screws:Biomechanicl studyof variables affecting pullout strength [J]．J Bone Joint Surg Am,1996,78(5):1315-1321．
[25] Nabil Ebraheim.M.D Posterior Lateral Mass Screw Fixntion:Anatomic andRdiograpaic Considerations [J].Orthopacdic Journal,1999,42(12):66-72．
[26] Album I K, Itoh h, Tanceichi h．et al．Tran spedicuiar screw fixation for traumaticleisions of the middle and lower cervical spine: description of the techniques andpreliminary report[J]．J Spinal Disord,1994,32(7):119-123．
[27]田纪伟，袁文，张清港．颈椎椎弓根内固定系统研究进展[J]．中国矫形外科杂志，2006，14（4）：308-312．
[28] Album I K, Kanedak, Shono Y,et al.Onestage posterior decomp ression andreconstruction of the cervical spine by using pedicle screw fixation systems[J]．JNeurosurgery,1999,9(11).19-22．
[29]赵宝林，何凤江，马洪顺．异种骨椎间融合器附加椎弓根钉行后路椎体间融合术的生物力学分析[J]．北京生物医学工程，2007，26（5）：526-530．
[30]张忠君，王巍，马洪顺．颈椎小关节切除对颈椎稳定性影响的实验研究[J]．生物医学工程研究，2008，27（4）：284-286．
[31] Haid RW,Foley KT,Rodts GE,et al.The Cervical Spine Sindy Group anterior cervicalplate nomenclature.Neurosurg Focus．2002,12(1):15-20．
[32]何立民，郝定均，郭华等．下颈椎椎体槽式钢板与AO钢板抗应力强度实验比较[J]．伤残医学杂志，2008，10（4）：6-7．
[33]李超，干阜生，王以进等．拱桥弹性钢板椎弓根固定器的研制与临床应用[J]．中国脊柱脊髓杂志，2002，12（5）：330-334．
[34]蒋振松，张佐伦，刘兰成．脊髓型颈椎病患者的颈椎CT测量及临床意义[J]．中国脊柱脊髓杂志，2003，12（4）：220-223．
[35] An hS, Gordin R, Renner K.Anatomic considerations for plate screw fixation of thecervical. Spine1991,16(10):548-501．
[36]徐波，金大地．下颈椎后路钢板螺钉固定的解剖学研究[J]．中华骨科杂志，2000，20（5）：279-282．
[37] Pait TC,McAllister PV,Kaufman hh.Quadrant anatomy of the articular pillars(lateralcervical mass)of the cervical spine.J Neurosurgery1995,82（10）:11-14．
[38] Heller JG, Silor Dh, Sufferlin CE.Complications of posterior cervical plating. Spine1995,32(20):2442-2448．
[39] Anderson PA, henley MB, Grady MS, ET al.Posterior cervical arthrodesis with Aoreconstruction plates and bone graft. Spine1991,16(3):72-79．
[40] Kotani Y, Cunningham BW, Abumi K, te al.Biomechonical analysis of cervicalstabilization systems: An assessment of transpedicular screw fixation in the cervicalSpine. Spine1994;19(22):2852-2856．
[41]于博，靳安民，吴广森等．人工可吸收颈椎融合器组织相容性的实验研究[J]．中国临床康复，2003，7（6）：908-911．
[42] Jones EI, heller JG, Silcox Dh, et al.Cervical pedicle screws versus lateral mass screws.Spine1997,22(4):997-1002．
[43]罗飞，许建中，王序全等．三种颈椎前路内固定装置对术后脊柱稳定性的作用[J]．中国临床康复，2003，7（20）：2830-2833．
[44] Album I K,Shono Y,Kotani Y.et al.Indirect posterior reduction and fusion of thetraumatic herniated by using a cervical pedicle screw system.J Neurosurgery2000,92(1):30-37．
[45] Smith MD, Emery SE, Dudley A, et al.Vertebral antery injury during anteriordecompression of the cervical spine. Aretrospective review of ten patients.J Bone JointSurg Br1993,75(2):410-415．
[46] Ebraheim NA,Lu J,Brown JA,et al,Vulnerability of vertebral antery in anterolateraldecompression for cervical spondylosis.Clin Orthop1996,32(1):146-151．
[47] Pait TG,Killefer JA,Arnautovic KI,Sugical anatomy of the anterior cervical spine; thedisc space, vertebral antery,and associated bony structures. The disc space, vertebralantery, and associated bony structures. Neurosurgery1996,39(3):769-776．
[48] Oga M,Yuge I,Terada K,et al.Tortuosity of the vertebral avtery in patients with cervicalspondylotic myelopathy:risk factor for the vertebral artery injury during anteriorcervical decompressin.Spine1996,21（6）:1082-1089．
[49]闫德强，谢志军，于德有等．颈椎弓根螺钉内固定的解剖学研究[J]．中华骨科杂志，2002，22（11）：657-661．
[50]傅一山，陈正形．颈椎椎弓根置钉的影像学测量[J]．中国脊柱脊髓杂志，2001，11（1）：29-31．
[51]徐荣明，校佰平，冯建翔等．颈椎椎弓根螺钉内固定技术有关问题探讨[J]．脊柱外科学杂志，2003，1（1）：19-22．
[52] Miller RM, Ebrabeim NA, xn R, et al.Anatomic consideration of transpedicular screwplaccment in the cervical spine. An analysis of two approaches. Spine1996,38(21):2317-2322．
[53] Karaikovic EE, Yingsakmongkol W, Gaines RW Jr.Accuracy of cervical pedicle screwplacement using the funnel technique. Spine2001,46(10):2456-2462．
[54] Kumaresan S,Yoganandan N,Pintar FA,et al.Finite element modeling of cervicallaminectomy with graded facetectomy.J Spinal Discord1997,10(1):40-46．
[55] Kleinberger M.Application of finite element techniques to the study of cervical spinemechanics, Proceedings of the37th Step Car Crash Coference.USA:SAF International1993,261-272．
[56] Yoganandan N, Kumaresan S, Voo L, et al.Finite element model of the human lowercervical spine: parametric analysis of the C4-C6unit. J Bionmech Eng1997,119(1):87-92．
[57] Zhang Qh,Teo EC,Ng hW,et al.Finite element analysis of moment-rotationrelationships for human cervical spine.J Biomech2006,39(1):198-193．
[58]宋楠，程黎明．有限元分析法评价脊柱医源性负荷研究进展[J]．国际骨科学杂志，2007，28（4）：217-218．
[59] Sadegh AM,Tchako A.Vertebarl stress of a cervical spine model under dynamicload.Technol health Care2000,8(2):143-154．
[60] Ng hW,Teo EC.Nonlinear finite element analysis of the lower cervical spine(C4-C6)under axial loading.J Spinal Discord2001,14(3):201-210．
[61] Kumaresan S,Yoganandan N,Pintar FA,et al.Contrbution of disc degeneration toosteophyte formation in the cervical spine: a biomechanical investigation.J Orthop Res2001,19(5):977-984．
[62] Stemper BD,Yoganandan N,Pintar FA,et al.Development of extension kinematiccorridors to validate a head/neck finite element model. Biomed Sci Instrument2001,37(1):239-244．
[63]艾福志，尹庆水，夏虹等．经口咽前路寰枢椎复位钢板固定的三维运动稳定性和抗拔出力研究[J]．解放军医学杂志，2004，29（3）：223-225．
[64]李超，阮狄克，谈诚等．垂直负荷下颈椎前路限制性与非限制性钢板的生物力学比较[J]．第二军医大学学报，2005，26（12）：1388-1391．
[65]冯敬，蒋涛，陈良等．颈椎前路钢板内固定术对维持椎间高度的作用．中国修复重建外科杂志，2004，18（4）：344-345．
[66]徐育林，秦继斌，钟志坚．Orion钛钢板加钛网融合器治疗颈椎病．中国修复重建外科杂志，2004，18（4）：274-275．
[67]陈雷，李宜照，赵秀文等．双节段颈椎椎间融合固定对邻近下位关节生物力学的影响[J]．山东医药，2009，49（42）：87-88．
[68]荆玉华，田大胜，钱军等．颈椎融合内固定对相邻节段椎间关节压力影响的生物力学研究[J]．颈腰痛杂志，2009，30（3）：200-202．
[69]夏军，顾昕，黄煌渊．四种下颈椎内固定技术初始稳定性的生物力学比较[J]．中华创作骨科杂志，2004，6（4）：430-433．
[70]何达，韩骁，陶俭铎等．颈椎人工间盘置换与颈椎内固定置入对相邻节段退变的生物力学影响[J]．中国组织工程研究与临床康复，2008，12（22）：4229-4232．
[71]赵筑川，曹永飞，彭智等．颈椎前路钛网钢板固定及自体髂骨植骨在不同颈椎节段中的生物力学研究[J]．中国修复重建外科杂志，2006，20（11）：1077-1079．
[72]王晓军，刘伟强，阎志进等．颈椎前路植入内固定系统的有限元模拟及生物力学研究[J]．北京生物医学工程，2008，27（2）：267-271．
[73]曹永飞，赵筑川，彭智等．颈椎前路钛网植骨钢板内固定在不同颈椎节段中的生物力学比较[J]．生物医学工程学杂志，2007，24（2）：320-323．
[74]陈向东，张烽，范卫民等．Orion钢板固定后对植骨块及小关节突应力影响的实验研究[J]．中国矫形外科杂志，2003，11（3、4）：243-245．
[75]张烽，陆建华，赵俭等．颈前路Uniplate与Orion钢板单间隙固定生物力学研究[J]．中国矫形外科杂志，2008，16（19）：1490-1492．
[76] Album I K,Panjabi MM,Duranceau J.Biomechanlcal evaluation of spinal fixationdevices l Part stability provided by six spinal devices and interbody bone graft[J].Spine,2003,14(11):1249-1250．
[77] Ulrich C,Woresdoerfer O,Kalff R,et al. Biomechanics of fixation systems to thecervical spine[J].Spine,1991,116(1):4-8．
[78] Resnick DK, Trost GR.Use of ventral plates for cervical arthrodesis [J]. Neurosurgery,2007,53(1):112-117．
[79] Wang JC,M Donough PW,Endow K, et al.The effect of cervical plating on single levelanterior cervical discectomy and fusion[J].Spinal Discord1999,12(2):467-471．
[80] Samartzis D,Shen Fh,Lyon C,et al.Does rigid instrum negation increase the fusion ratein one level anterior cervical discectomy and fusion[J]. Spine,2004,34(3):636-643．
[81] Rickets on R.Single level anterior disectomy and fusion with and without plating Aprospective randomized study[R].Proceedings of the11thA nnualConference of theNorthAmerican Spine Sociely,Van corver B.C,Canada1996,251-253．
[82]刘建国．应力遮挡效应对骨折愈合的影响[J]．医用生物力学，1992，7（2）：138-140．
[83]刘建国．应力遮挡的生物效应[J]．医用生物力学，1992，7（2）：136-137．
[84]刘建国，徐莘香．应力遮挡效应与骨折愈合的实验和临床研究[J]．中华医学杂志，1994，74（8）：483-485．
[85]曹斌，张守平，王兆林等．低应力遮挡效应交锁髓内钉的研制与生物力学研究[J]．中国矫形外科杂志，2004，12（2）：930-933．
[86]裘世静．接骨板应力遮挡作用对疏松骨结构的后期影响[J]．医用生物力学，1992，7（4）：202-204．
[87]王以进．应力遮挡效应的理论基础和影响因素[J]．医用生物力学，1992，7（3）：198-190．
[88]袁旬华．应力遮挡的生物效应[J]．医用生物力学[J]．1992，7（1）：59-61．
[89]朱俊峰，张先龙，王成焘等．股骨假体近端应力遮挡对成骨细胞增殖调亡的影响[J]．临床骨科杂志，2009，12（3）：332-335．
[90]王禹基，孙俊英，董天华等．表面置换和全髓关节转换股骨近端应力遮挡比较[J]．中国骨与关节损伤杂志，2008，23（3）：183-185．
[91]朱元，毕大卫，全仁夫．纳米氧化锆梯度复合羟基磷灰石内固定材料的应力遮挡[J]．中医正骨，2008，20（8）：3-4．
[92]辛兵，侯筱魁，李永刚．脊柱固定器的应力遮挡[J]．中国矫形外科杂志，2000，7（2）：154-155．
[93] Heary RF,Albert TJ,Ludwig SC,et al.Surgical anatomy of the vertebral arteries.Spine,1996,21:2074．
[94] Smith MD,Emery SE,Dudley A,et al.Vertebral artery injury during anteriordecompression of the cervical spine.J Bone Joint Surg,1993,75B(3):410
[95]蒋富贵，瞿东滨，朱志刚，等．颈椎前路减压及内固定的解剖学问题．中国临床解剖学杂志，2000，18（4）：310-311．
[96]金大地，陈建庭，江建明，等．Orion锁定型颈椎前路钢板系统在颈椎外科中的应用．中华骨科杂志，1999，19(7)：328．
[97]张延哲，朴成东，马洪顺．双侧颈椎5%小关节切除后的应力松弛及其流变特性[J]．中国组织工程研究与临床康复，2009，13（13）：2501-2504．
[98]麻文焱，李鹏，马洪顺等．正常与病态股骨头松质骨蠕变方程的比较研究[J]．生物医学工程研究，2008，27（4）：281-283．
[99]王杨，刘大禹，李新颖等．三参数模型计算股骨颈松质骨的蠕变方程[J]．中国组织工程研究与临床康复，2011，15（35）：6483-6486．
[100]吴宗岱，陶宝祺主编．应变电测原理及技术[M]．北京：国防工业出版社，1982，236-237．
[101]张红石．补虚化瘀针法对去势大鼠骨质疏松模型骨物理学及工型胶原MRNA影响研究[D]．长春中医药大学硕士学位论文，2006.6．
[102]Zaveri GR, Ford M.Cervical spondylosis the role of anterior instrumentation afterdecompression and fusion J Spinal Discord,2001,14(1):10-16．
[103]柏传毅，王坤正，魏美钢等．颈椎钛板—融合器的研制及生物力学研究[J]．中国脊椎脊髓杂志，2003，13（10）：608-611．
[104]李振宇，马洪顺，姜洪志等．人体腰段脊柱粘弹性实验研究[J]．中国生物医学工程学报，1990，9（4）：241-245．
[105]周轶，高建军，金慰芳等．骨质疏松动物实验中的骨物理密度检测[J]．中国骨质疏松杂志，2003，9（1）：41-42．
[106]辛兵，李永刚，侯筱魁．脊柱内固定对椎体骨密度的影响[J]．上海第二医科大学学报，1998，18（3）：190-192．
[107]杨豪，程少丹，郑福增．颈椎病动物模型发病过程中颈椎骨密度的动态变化[J]．中国临床康复，2005，9（10）：70-71．
[108]丛锐，罗卓荆，李明全等．不同时期颈椎病患者颈椎骨密度变化与椎体变形关系[J]．中国临床康复，2003，7（5）：744-745．
[109]李旭芬，朱沛，李凤新等．骨密度测量部位选择探讨[J]．中国临床康复，2003，7（32）：4395-4397．
[110]丛锐，孙银中，李明全．腰椎滑脱症患者的骨密度变化分析[J]．中国临床康复，2002，6（3）：385-387．
[111]丛锐，王全平，冯立宁等．骨质疏松合并颈椎病的颈椎影像学及骨密度变化[J]．第四军医大学学报，2001，22（15）：1419-1421．