川西北高原壤塘县大骨节病病区水文地球化学特征及其与病情相关关系的研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
大骨节病(Kaschin-Beck Disease,KBD)病因十分复杂,尽管短期内难以取得统一认识,但是缓解大骨病病区病情,解除广大患病群众疾苦,是一项迫在眉睫、势在必行的重要任务。本文以川西北高原壤塘县为大骨节病典型病区,从各种致病学说的共同点出发研究影响病情的环境因素尤其是水文地球化学环境因素,以期为川西北高原特别是壤塘县综合防治大骨节病提供科学依据。
     基于文献调研和病情调查的基础上,本文首先总结国内大骨节病区的地质环境特征及水化学特征。其次,通过壤塘县地表水、浅表地下水(土井水和泉水)、钻孔地下水(探采结合井水)的水质分析及区域水文地球化学调查,研究则曲河和杜柯河两大流域的地质环境及水文地球化学环境特征。进而,用统计学方法分析地质环境尤其是水文地球化学环境与大骨节病情分布的相关关系,研究影响大骨节病情的水文地球化学环境因素,构建大骨节病病情的水文化学影响因素模型。最后,从水文地球化学角度提出了壤塘县的大骨节病防病治病途径。论文主要取得了以下几方面的成果或结论:
     (1)引入病情指数概念,并用统计方法对病情指数用于指示大骨节病病情的可行性进行了检验。壤塘县全县12个乡镇,除壤柯镇属非病区外,其余11乡均属重病区,则曲河流域病情指数为31.0,而在杜柯河流域病情指数为23.96。从流域分布特征看,处于干河流域的地区上游由于浅切割、曲流发育、径流较短,其病情往往较干河流域中下游地区严重。
     (2)壤塘县域内地下水主要为两种类型:松散岩类孔隙水和基岩裂隙水。松散岩类孔隙水主要分布于则曲河沿岸的漫滩、阶地及支沟沟口堆积扇一带,占整个县域面积的0.71%,基岩裂隙水是县域内分布最广泛的地下水类型,可进一步细分为风化网状裂隙水和构造裂隙水两个亚类。
     (3)壤塘县各种水体的常量离子中主要为HCO_3~-、Ca~(2+)、Mg~(2+)等,县域内地表水及浅表地下水矿化度多在150mg/L以下,常量离子的平均值比大渡河背景值、松潘非病区含量平均值均小,呈现低矿化的特征。县域内主要离子与矿化度均表现为地表水<浅表地下水<钻孔地下水的特征,说明钻孔地下水为代表的深循环地下水深度大,路径长,能有效提高饮水中的矿化度。
     (4)与长江源河源区河水原水比较,壤塘县域的微量元素总体上呈富集特征,总体上呈现则曲河流域大于杜柯河流域的规律。从不同水源类型比较,微量元素浓度总体上排列为溪沟水>干流水>土井水>钻孔水>泉水,但就具体某种元素而言,不同水源类型规律性不强,差别较大。
     (5)壤塘县域内腐殖酸总量与胡敏酸、富啡酸、COD_(Mn)指标之间呈正相关关系,从流域比较,则曲河流域腐殖酸总量均大于杜柯河流域,则曲河流域腐殖酸总量由低到高变化趋势为钻孔水<干流水<泉水<溪沟水<土井水,杜柯河流域域腐殖酸总量的由低到高变化趋势为钻孔水<流域平均<干流水<溪沟水<泉水。
     (6)壤塘县域内地质环境与大骨节病病情指数存在以下关系:侵蚀高原低山区病情指数最高,其次为剥蚀丘状高原区,侵蚀高山峡谷区病情指数最低;泥岩区总体上病情指数较低,而其它砂板岩地区病情指数总体上较高;在壤塘县三类主要土壤类型中,以棕壤、暗棕壤区村寨病情指数最为严重,其次为草甸土分布区,而褐土类分布区病情指数相对较轻。
     (7)就本次采样而言,壤塘县大骨节病情与微量元素和有机物指标的相关系均不显著,通过大骨节病情的水文地球化学影响因素分析,以矿化度为代表的常量指标与大骨节病病情呈显著负相关关系。因此,低矿化度是影响壤塘县大骨节病情的重要因素,微量元素和有机物对大骨节病病情的影响不显著。
     (8)以矿化度和常量离子的对数值作为自变量,病情指数作为因变量构建了壤塘大骨节病情水文地球化学影响模型,按则曲流域和杜柯流域构建的影响模型模拟效果好,则曲流域的影响模型为y=149.687-23.852lnx,杜柯河流域的影响模型为y=104.478-16.592lnx (其中y为病情指数,x为矿化度值),按县域构建的影响模型模拟效果差。按流域构建的影响模型拟合效果较好,按县域构建的影响模型拟合效果差,说明矿化度是影响大骨节病情的主要因素,但不是唯一因素,与其它地质环境因素或者生活方式也有较大关系。
     (9)从水文地球化学角度出发,提出了深井安全供水、移民安置、易地育人等防治途径。并结合地质环境与病情的相关性分析,提出了移民安置选址的适宜性评价模型。
The pathogeny of Kaschin-Beck Disease is very complex, and it is difficult to get unified recognition on the research of pathogeny in a short term, but it is an extremely urgent and imperative task to relieve patients’sufferings from KBD in Kaschin-Beck disease areas. Based on the common grounds of various etiological doctrines, the environmental factors, especially the hydrogeochemical factors in the typical area hit by KBD—Zamtang County in the northwest Sichuan Plateau, were studied in this paper, to provide scientific evidences and guides for comprehensive prevention and treatment of KBD.
     Firstly, features of geological environment and hydrochemistry characteristic in KBD area in China were summarized based on documentary surveys and investigation of patients’conditions. Secondly, the geological and hydrogeochemical environment of Zequ River and Duke River were studied through the quality analysis of the surface water, shallow groundwater (well water and spring water), and drilling groundwater (prospecting-mining wells) in Zamtang County. Thirdly, the relationship of KBD distribution with geological environment, especially hydrogeochemical environment was analyzed using statistical methodology, and an influencing factors model was established. Finally, measurements to prevent and treat KBD from the prospective of hydrogeochemistry were presented.
     The study mainly obtains results and conclusions as follows:
     (1) The definition of disease index is introduced to indicate conditions of KBD, and the feasibility of this indication is conducted with statistical methods. Apart from one non-disease area, Rangke Town, KBD are very serious in other eleven townships of Zamtang County. The disease index of Zequ River is 31.0, while that of Duke River is 23.96. Based on features of basin distribution, conditions of KBD are more serious in upstream areas than in downstream areas along the main stream basins for the characteristic of shallow cutting, meandering stream developed and runoff short in upstream areas.
     (2) Ground water in Zamtang County is divided into two categories: pore-space water in loosening rocks and bedrock fissure water. Pore-space water is mainly distributed in floodplain area, terrace and accumulation fan along the Zequ River, accounting for 0.71% of the whole county area. Bedrock fissure water is the most widely distributed underground water in the county, which can be further classified into two segments: weathering mesh fissure water and structural fissure water.
     (3) Constant ions of water in Zamtang County primarily are HCO_3~-, Ca~(2+), Mg~(2+), etc. Surface water and shallow groundwater in the county shows the low TDS characteristic less than 150mg/L, and its average amount of constant ion is less than the background value in Dadu River and Songpan non-disease area. Major ions and TDS of water in the county both show the regular of surface water < shallow groundwater      (4) Compared with the river water in source region of Yangtze River, trace elements of water in Zamtang County shows enrichment features generally, demonstrating the law that trace elements in the Zequ River are more than those in the Duke River. According to different sources of water, the density of trace elements is ranked roughly as: water from brooks>water from main steams>well water>drilling water>spring water, but in terms of specific elements, trace elements in different sources of water mentioned above are short of law with great difference.
     (5) Humic amount in the Zamtang County shows positive correlations with humic acid, fulvic acid and index of COD_(Mn). According to river basins, total volume of humic acid in the Zequ River exceeds that in the Duke River. Specifically speaking, total volume of humic acid in the Zequ River ranges from low to high: drilling water     (6) There is a relationship between geological environment in the Zamtang County and disease index of KBD as: disease index of the low mountains of erosion plateau is the highest, the second is the denudation hummocky plateau, and the lowest is the erosion alpine canyon; disease index in the mudstone areas is lower on the whole, while index in the other sand-slate areas is roughly higher. Among the three types soil of Zamtang County, disease index in brown soil and dark brown soil is the highest, the second is the countryside covered by meadow soil and disease index in the countryside with cinnamon soil is relatively lower.
     (7) For the purposes of this sample, it is found that KBD in the Zamtang County has a less obvious relationship both with trace elements and organic stuff respectively. Through the analysis of hydrogeochemical factors affecting KBD, the obviously negative correlation between KBD and constant index represented by TDS is obtained. Therefore, low TDS plays an essential role in KBD, but the trace elements and organic stuff has on unremarkable influence on KBD.
     (8) A hydrogeochemical influence model of KBD in Zamtang County is designed, taking mineralization and logarithm of constant ions as independent variables, and disease index as dependent variables. Simulation effect of the influence model is good. The influence model of Zequ River is y=149.687-23.852lnx, and the model of Duke River is y=104.478-16.592lnx (y stands for disease index; x stands for TDS); on the contrary, simulating effects of county structure is unsatisfying, indicating TDS is the main but not only factor of KBD, other geological environment factors or life-style can also have some impacts on KBD.
     (9) From the view hydrogeochemical point, some effective prevention approaches were put forward, such as safe water supply from deep well, immigration settlement and transferring children to non-disease areas to receive education, etc. Combining the correlation analysis of geological environment and conditions of KBD, the study also designs a feasible evaluation model of immigration settlement and site selection.
引文
[1] Abrahan ZJ,1986.Urov or Kaschin-Beck disease:Fusarium species their biology and toxicology[M].New York:A Wiley-Inter.science Publication:280-296
    [2] Cao JL,XiongYM,Zhang SHY,et a1,1998.The experimental stud-Y on the effects of six mycotoxins on the cultural chondrocytes[J].Xi’an Med Univ,10(1):1-8
    [3] Chen Daizhong,Ren Shangxue,Lu Wulong,1993. Effect of applying selenium fertilizer to improve soil and increase selenium level in food ofr prevention and treatment of Kaschin-Beck disease[J],Journal of Environmental Sciences,5(3):299-309
    [4] Chen JH,Chu YL,Cao JL,et al, 2006.T-2 toxin induces apoptosis.and selenium partly blocks,T-2 induced apoptosis in chondro-cytes through modulation of the Bax/Bcl-2 ratio[J].Food and Chem Toxicol,44(4):567-573
    [5] Creppy EE Update of survey,2002.regulation and toxic effects in Europe.Toxicol Lett,127(13):19-28
    [6] Edward Derbyshire,2001.Geological hazards in loess terrain,with particular reference tothe loess regions of China[J], Earth-Science Reviews 54:231–260
    [7] Guo X,Zhang SHY,Mo DX ,1992. The role of low selenium in theoccurrence of Kashin-Beck disease [J].xi’an Med Univ 4(2 ):99-106
    [8] Hayes MA,Bellamy JEC,Schiefier HB, 1980. subacute toxicity of dietary T-2 toxin;MorpHological and hematological effects [J] Can J Comp Med, 44:203-208
    [9] J.E.BUNNELL, R.B.FINKELMAN, J.A.CENTENO, O.SELINUS, 2007.Medical Geologe a globally emerging discipline[J],Geologica Acta 5(3):273-281
    [10] Jeffrey G. White, Robert J. Zasoski,1999.Mapping soil micronutrients[J], Field Crops Research 60:11-26
    [11] Kevin H.Johannesson,Klaus J.Stetzenbach,David K.Kreamer,Vernon F.Hodge, 1996.Multivariate statistical analysis of arsenic and selenium concentrations in groundwater from south-central Nevad and Death Valley California[J],Journal of Hydrology (178),181-204
    [12] Liang HJ,Tsai CL,Chen PQ,et a1,1999.Oxidative injury induced by synthetic humic acid polymer and monomer in cultured rabbit articular chondrocytes[J].Life Sci,65(11):1163-1173.
    [13] Mo DX,1986.Pathology of selenium deficiency in Kashin-Beck disease[C] .Combs JrGF,Spallhoz JE,Levander OA,et a1.Se.1enium in biology and medicine. New York:No Strand Reinhold Com pany,1986:859-986.
    [14] Moreno Reyes R,Suetens C,Mathieu F,et a1,1998.Kashin-Beck osteoarthr0pathy in rural Tibet in relation to selenium and iodine status [J] N Engl j Med, 339(16):1112-1120.
    [15] P.Sudre,F.Mathieu, 2001. Kashin-beck disease:from etiology to prevention or from prevention to etiology[j],International Orthopaddics, 25:175-179;
    [16] PHilippe A. Rossignol, Jennifer Orme-Zavaleta,2006. Global climate change and itsimpact on disease embeddedin ecological communities[J], Environmental Geosciences,13(1) :55–63
    [17] Ren FL,Guo X,Zhang RJ,et a1,2007.Effects of selenium and io-dine deficiency on bone,cartilage growth plate and chondro·cyte differentiation in two generations of rats[J].Osteoarthri-tis Cartilage,1 5(10):1171-1177
    [18] Richard J.Reeder,Martin A.A. Schoonen,2006. Metal Speciation and Its Role inBioaccessibility and Bioavailability[J], Reviews in Mineralogy & Geochemistry(64): 59-113
    [19] Tan Jianan,Wang WuYi,Zhu ZiYu,Wang Lizhen,Lu Yilun, 1988. Selenium in Environment and Kaschin-Beck Disease[J],Chinease Journal of Geochemistry, Vol.7,No.3,273-280
    [20] Tiku M L,1990. Liexh ] B. Robertson F M. J lmmunol, 145(2) :690-696
    [21] UNEP ILO WHO IPCS MPH,1990.Proceedings of international workshop on Kashin-Beck disease and non-com municable diseases[c] Geneva:WHO.
    [22] Wang SH,Guo X,Tan WH,et a1,2008.Detection of serum pro-teomic changes and discovery of serum biomarkers for Kashin-Beck Disease using surface-enhanced laser desorption ionization mass spectrometry (SELDI-TOF MS)[J].J Bone Miner M etab,26(4):385-393.
    [23] Wang SHJ,Guo x t Zuo H,et a1,2006.Chondrocyte apoptosis and expression of Bcl-2,Bax,Fas,and iNOS in articular cartilage in patients with Kashin-Beck disease[J].J Rheumatol 33(3):615-6l9
    [24] Wang Weizhe,Yang Zhiwei,You Shengzhi,1991.Study on the action and mechanism of humic acids in Kaschin-Beck diseas[J],Journal of Environmental Sciences 3(4):87-94
    [25] Wang Wenhua,Yang Chunlin,Qi Ruiming,Wang Zijian Peng,1991. An Research on Organic Matters in the drinking water of Kaschin-Beck Disease area[J],Journal of Environmental Sciences, 3(4),35-47
    [26] Wang WZH,Guo X,Chen JCH,et a1,2008.MorpHology and pHe-notype expression of types I,Ⅱ,Ⅲ,and X collagen and M M P-13 of chondrocytes cultured from articular cartilage with Kashin-Beck disease in vitro[J].J Rheumatol, 35(4):696-702.
    [27] Wei X,Wright GC Jr,Sokoloff L,1986.The effect of sodium sele-nite on chondrocytes in monolayer culture [J].Arthritis Rheum,29(5):660-664.
    [28] Wright GC Jr,Marasas WFO,Scoloff,1987.Effect of fnoarochromanone and T-2 toxin on articular chondrocytes in monolayer culture [J] Fundamental and Applied Toxicology 9(3):595-600
    [29] Yasuyki E,1990.An outline of history of research on Kashin-Beck disease in Japan: Proceedings of international workshop on Kashin-Beck disease and noncommunicable diseases[C].Geneva:W HO,1990(149),151-157.
    [30] Zhai SHSH,1990.Investigation on the relationship between Kashin-Beck disease and drinking water : Proceedings of international workshop on Kashin-Beck disease and non-communicable diseases[c].Geneva:WHO:96-101.
    [31] Zongqiang Gao, Xiong Guo,Chen Duan,Weijuan Ma,Peng Xu,Ruiyu Liu,Qisheng Gu,Junchang Chen, ,2009.In vitro effects of sodium hyaluronate on the proliferation and the apoptosis in chondrocytes from patients with Kashin-Beck disease and osteoarthritis[J],Journal of Nanjing Medical University 23(2),104-110
    [32]安永会,贾小丰,李旭峰,等,2010.中国大骨节病地质环境特征及其病因研究[J].中国地质,37(3):563-570
    [33]白迺彬,1991.大骨节病病区环境微量元素多元统计分析[J] .环境科学,6(8):14-18
    [34]白小文,毕华银,吕社民,等,1996.T-2毒素致雏鸡大骨节病模型实验[J].中国地方病防治杂志, 11(3):149-153
    [35]白小文,吕社民,白锶,等,1996.T-2毒素致雏鸡大骨节病模型实验~胫骨上端的病理形态学观察[J].中国地方病防治杂志,11(3):149-150.
    [36]毕华银,庞伟,吕旌乔,等,1998.榆林病区水黄腐酸对大鼠的急性毒性实验报告[J].地方病通报,13(3):15-17.
    [37]毕华银,王治伦,2002.大骨节病病因问题再议[J].中国地方病防治杂志,17(3):189-193.
    [38]毕华银,王治伦,1995.关于大骨节病的病因问题-提示大骨节病病毒病因的组织学证据[J],中国地方病防治杂志,10(3):164-167
    [39]毕华银,郑滨,张富军,等,1998. H-黄腐酸在雏鸡体内的示踪实验观察[J].地方病通报,13(3):18-19.
    [40]边归国, 2008.无机氟化物对人体健康影响机理研究新进展[J],化工生产与技术,15(5),13-16;
    [41]曹俊岭,熊咏民,等,1994.T-2毒素对培养软骨细胞生长代谢的作用[J].中国地方病学杂志,13(5):269-271
    [42]曹学义,1987.大骨节病:地方病学导论[M].新疆:新疆人民出版社:279-297.
    [43]曾令霞,许鹏,Schrauzer GN,等,1999.大骨节病区与非病区儿童发中39种元素含量及Logistic分析[J].中国地方病学杂志,18(6):445-449.
    [44]陈静生,1990.环境地球化学[M].北京:海洋出版社
    [45]丛建民,2007.氟化物中毒对骨病发病机制影响的研究[J],中国地方病防治杂志,22(4),271-273;
    [46]崔才磊,于红阳,杨素霞,2003.河南省大骨节病自然消长因素20年观察[J],中国地方病防治杂志,18(5):299-301
    [47]邓佳云,李德云,1999.从四川省大骨节病与硒的关系看硒在病因学中的地位[J].中国地方病防治杂志,14(4):249-251
    [48]丁德修,张矢远,1991.硒与大骨节病关系[J].西安医科大学学报,12(1):14-18
    [49]范正一,周鸣等,1990.中国地方病图集[M].中国科学院地理研究所,180-183
    [50]方中达,1998.植病研究法(第三版).北京:中国农业出版社,179-210
    [51]封剑南,王志刚,1992.污染镰刀菌及T-2毒素的霉大米食物中毒[J].中华预防医学杂志,26(6):284-286
    [52]龚弘强, 2004.西藏谢通门县碘硒盐防治大骨节病效果观察[J],地方病通报,19(1):61-62
    [53]光磊,邢秋菊,2004.引发克山病和大骨节病的地理环境因素分析[J],山西师范大学学报(自然科学版),18(2):81-86
    [54]郭平,1997.大骨节病区FA对软骨细胞ALPase活性的影响[J] .地方病通报,12(1):4-6
    [55]郭平,于臻,罗玲,等,1999.大骨节病区FA对培养软骨细胞分化的影响[J].华北煤炭医学院学报,1(1):1-4
    [56]郭雄, 2008.大骨节病病因与发病机制的研究进展及其展望[J].两安交通大学学报(医学版),29(5):481-488
    [57]郭雄,张竞远,莫东旭,1991.大骨节病患儿五年补硒防治效果观察[J],中华医学杂志,1(12):700-703
    [58]郭雄,张矢远,殷红,1994.真菌及其毒素与大骨节病关系的研究现状[J].中国地方病防治杂志,9(3):155-159
    [59]郭雄,左弘,2005.利用现代分子生物学技术深入研究大骨节病的分子发病机制[J].中国地方病学杂志,24(6):701-704
    [60]郭雄。丁德修,曾令霞,等,1999.低硒与大骨节病关系的前瞻性研究[J].中国地方病学杂志,18(1):70-73
    [61]郭娅,2004.西部大骨节病区实施异地育人工程的探讨[J].西南民族大学学报(人文社科版),(12):67-69
    [62]韩吟文,马振东,2003.地球化学[M].北京:地质出版社,246-252.
    [63]侯少范,王卫中,等,1994.多元素与大骨节病关系的稳定性研究[J],地理研究,13(4):28-35
    [64]侯少范,王五一,等,1994.大骨节病病情下降与环境因素的定位研究[J].环境科学学报,14(2):198-203
    [65]侯少范,朱振源,谭见安,1984.人体发育过程中硒的动态及其与大骨节病的关系[J],地理学报,39(1),75-84
    [66]霍昌基,周裔意, 1992.生活饮用水的硬度与大骨节病的关系[J].中国地方病学杂志, 11(5):1-2
    [67]蒋辉,1993.环境水文地球化学.北京:中国环境科学出版社
    [68]荆俊杰,谢吉民,2008.微量元素锰污染对人体的危害[J].广东微量元素科学,15(12):6-9
    [69]孔祥瑞,1982.必需微量元素的生理及临床意义(第1版)[M].合肥:安徽科学出版社,50-56
    [70]李德云,邓佳云,朱岚,等,1999.对大骨节病区8年病情与发硒监测分析[J] .中国地方病防治杂志,14(1):37-39
    [71]李端生,2009.低氟与大骨节病[M].吉林:吉林科技出版社
    [72]李芳生,莫东旭,任宏造,等,1984.中国大骨节病基础研究的进展[C].北京:北京科技出版社
    [73]李富忠,邓佳云,杨荣明,等,2006.2005年四川省成人大骨节病调查报告[J].地方病通报,21(1):23-25
    [74]李继云,陈代中,任尚学,等,1991.影响人体硒低的环境因素-陕西渭北高塬大骨节病区的调查[J].环境科学,13(6):3-7.
    [75]李江,2001.2000年西藏昌都地区大骨节病病情监测报告[J].中国地方病学杂志, 20(2):130-131
    [76]李立,李芳生,1992.Se、PC缺乏及环境低温可能是大骨节病的发病基础[J] .地方病译丛, l3(8):5
    [77]李强,赵志军,2006.青海省大骨节病病情回顾分析[J] .中国地方病学杂志,25(6):675-677
    [78]李群伟,王志武,许弘凯,2000.西部大骨节病病情现状及防治对策[J],中国地方病学杂志,15(4):221-223
    [79]李荣俊,2006.免疫分子与大骨节病软骨损伤关系的研究进展[J],中国地方病防治杂志, 21(6):342-344
    [80]李生广,孙珊,吴莲英,等,1993.镰刀菌T-2毒素对培养软骨细胞的影响[J].生物化学与生物物理进展,20(5):365-367
    [81]李顺江,李巍,胡霞、杨林生,西绕若登, 2008.西藏土壤-植物-动物(人)系统中硒含量与大骨节病的关系[J],生态学杂志,27(12):2157-2170
    [82]李顺江,杨林生,等,2006.西藏大骨节病地区儿童发硒与病情分布的关系[J].中国地方病学杂志,25(1):70-72.
    [83]李斯纯,熊咏民,王治伦,等,1998. T-2毒素和硒对小型猪肋软骨基质代谢的影响[J].地方病通报, 13(3):1-4
    [84]李胜伟,赵松江,曹楠,等,2010.壤塘县大骨节病饮水性致病因素分析及改水模式探索[J].中国地质,37(3):594-599.
    [85]李胜伟,赵松江,曹楠,等,2010.壤塘县大骨节病与地质环境的关系研究[J].四川地质学报,30(3):319-322.
    [86]李维云,陈代中,任尚学,刘务农,1992.影响人体硒低的环境因素-陕西渭北高塬大骨节病区德调查[J].环境科学,13(6),16-22
    [87]李曦滨,江卫,2002.陕西渭北黄土旱塬区水环境与地方病的关系[J],地球学报,23(S):69-72
    [88]李芸生,等,1987.发、毛、粮、饲料中8种化学元素对大骨节病致病作用的研究[J].中国地方病防治杂志,2(1):11-13
    [89]李志斌,陶明,李志剐,等,1999.大骨节病病区饮水有机物调查研究[J].西安医科大学学报,10(3):29-31
    [90]连国奇,胡继伟,秦樊鑫,等,2008.氟对人体的危害及检测方法研究进展[J].地方病通报,23(5):125-127;
    [91]林年丰,李昌静,等,1990.环境水文地质学.地质出版社
    [92]林年丰,1984.永寿大骨节病科学考察文集:大骨节病的有机水土病因研究[c].北京:人民卫生出版社:115-117.
    [93]林年丰,汤洁,1983.大骨节病与环境地质因素的相关分析[J].长春地质学院学报,1983(1),81-89
    [94]林年丰,汤洁,1992.新疆塔里木西部平原生态环境地质综合研究[M].长春:吉林大学出版社
    [95]刘国,许模,等,2010.中国大骨节病区水环境化学组分特征研究综述[J] .中国地质,37(3):571-576
    [96]刘致函,1979.大骨节病病因研究概况[J].西安医学院学报,(3):4-15
    [97]吕旌乔,王丽娟,2000.T-2毒素与大骨节病[J].中国地方病防治杂志,15(1):122-128
    [98]麻春雷,2002.中草药治疗大骨节病的疗效观察[J],中国地方病防治杂志,17(2):122-126
    [99]莫东旭,1984.大骨节病的病因学说中无机元素研究的进展[J],地方病通讯,(2):8-9
    [100]莫东旭,1995.T-2毒素两种地方病“病因”.中国地方病学杂志[J].10(5):294-297
    [101]莫东旭,丁德修,王治伦,等,1997.硒与大骨节病关系研究20年[J].中国地方病防治杂志,12(1):18-21
    [102]莫东旭,1996.T-2毒素、MON和硒对中国小香猪罹患骨软骨病的影响[J].中国地方病学杂志,11(3):130.133.
    [103]南京大学地质系,1984.地球化学[M],科学出版社
    [104]平智广,等,2004.大骨节病核心家庭发病特点的流行病学研究[J].中华流行病学杂志,25(10):848-851
    [105]钱会,马致远,2005.水文地球化学.北京:地质出版社
    [106]强环.河北省大骨节病防治概况[J],地方病通报。1993.2, 8(1):105-106
    [107]屈福荣,王殿璋,等,1991.克山病病区和大骨节病病区人群与非病区人群血中微量元素对比研究[J].地方病通报,9(4):18-19
    [108]全国大骨节病病情调查组,2001.2001年全国大骨节病病情调查报告[J].中国地方病学杂志,20:333-334
    [109]全国大骨节病病情调查组,2002.2002年全国大骨节病病情调查报告[J].中国地方病学杂志,21:368-370
    [110]全国大骨节病病情调查组,2004.2003年全国大骨节病病情调查报告[J].中国地方病学杂志,23(2):147-149
    [111]全国大骨节病病情调查组,1999.大骨节病病情调查10年总结[J].中国地方病学杂志,18:356-367
    [112]任宏伟,1993.大骨节病病情下降与饮水关系的探讨[J].地方病通报,(8):54-56
    [113]莎日,孙天志,伊力奇,等,1992.大骨节病区外环境21种元素水平与病区活跃指数的相关分析[J].地方病通报,7(2):80-82
    [114]山县登(日),1998.微量元素与人体健康[M].北京:地质出版社
    [115]苏斌,2008.微量元素锰与人体健康[J].世界元素医学,15(4):17-20
    [116]孙殿军,1997.黑龙江省大骨节病区非病区主食中T-2毒素监测报告[J].中国地方病学杂志.16(4):207-209
    [117]孙殿军,杨建伯,金澜,1993.大骨节病病区玉米致幼鸡骨软骨病的病理形态观察[J].中国地方病学杂志,12(5):272-274
    [118]孙泽人,张文荣,刘军伟,1987.大骨节病与水中的天然有机物[J].中国地方病学杂志,6(6):335-337
    [119]谭见安,1989.环境硒与健康(第1版)[M].北京;人民卫生出版社
    [120]谭绪恕,吕秀文,郭英华,等,1996.大骨节病病因研究新假说产生硫酸软骨素CHS酶的厌氧菌是主要病因[J].中国地方病防治杂志,I1(1):14-17
    [121]汪群慧,于雨泽.硒与人体健康及其分析方法[J],世界元素医学,15(4):44-46
    [122]王建平,谢洪毅,2006.阿坝壤塘县大骨节病区环境地质分析[J],南水北调与水利科技,4(2):29-32,
    [123]王建平,谢洪毅,2006.壤塘县大骨节病区区域环境水文地质调查[J],水科学与工程技术(1):18-20
    [124]王建平、谢洪毅,2006.阿坝壤塘县大骨节病区环境水文地质调查[J].资源环境与工程,20(1):48-51.
    [125]王建平、谢洪毅,2005.四川阿坝壤塘县大骨节病区环境地质初步评价[J].四川地质学报,25(3):169-171.
    [126]王金达,刘景双,于君宝,等, 2001.我国大骨节病区环境中腐植酸机器衍生物研究[J].中国地方病防治杂志,16(3):154-156
    [127]王明远,章申,1981.我国大骨节病病区的化学地理特征[J].地理学报,36(2):180-186
    [128]王维哲,冯兰飞,1989.水中有机物致大骨节病的实验研究[J].环境科学,10(1):16-21
    [129]王维哲,由胜志,王晓颖,董瑶,1990.大骨节病区粮和腐植酸的过氧化损伤效应及微量元素硒、锌的实验观察[J].中国公共卫生学报,9(6):297-300
    [130]王文华,刘俊华,王治伦,等,1999.榆林大骨节病区饮水井的研究(Ⅰ饮水井的地下剖面与底质的物化性质表征)[J].中国地方病防治杂志,14(3):1-2
    [131]王文华,齐瑞明,彭安,等,1991.对大骨节病病区饮用水中有机物的初步鉴定[J],环境化学,10(6):124-129
    [132]王文华,1999.榆林大骨节病区饮水井的研究[J].中国地方病防治杂志,14(3):145-146
    [133]王西存,侯振杰,等, 1991.陕西永寿养马庄综合措施防治大骨节病效果观察[J].中国地方病学杂志,10(2):3-4
    [134]王永国,等,2005.阿坝县大骨节病22年动态监测[J],预防医学情报杂志,21(1):94-96
    [135]王云剑,等,1984.永寿大骨节病科学考查文集(第1版).北京:人民卫生出版社
    [136]王志武,刘运起,宋久成,1992.大骨节病家庭聚集性及其流行病学意义[J].中国地方病学杂志,11(5):295-296
    [137]王志武,2005.中国大骨节病防治研究近10年进展和未来10年展望[J].中国地方病杂志. 24(6):591-592
    [138]王治伦,2005.大骨节病4种病因学说的同步研究[J] .西安交通大学学报(医学版), 26(1):1-7
    [139]王子健,彭斌, 1991.彭安大骨节病区水土中有机物对硒存在形态和生物有效性的影响[J],环境科学,l2(4):88
    [140]西安医学院大骨节病基础研究组,1973.用放射性研究大骨节病患者的硫代谢[J].陕西新医药,12:55-60.
    [141]夏怡凡,2010.SPSS统计分析精要与实例详解[M].北京:电子工业出版社
    [142]夏正国,等,2001.2000年四川省大骨节病监测结果分析[J].地方病防治杂志,16(2):109-110
    [143]肖新平,1986.陕西省永寿县大骨节病区水化学特征及其与病的关系[J],陕西地质,4(1):70-78
    [144]熊绍礼。吉林省大骨节病与饮用地下水中某些胶原元素关系的研究[J],地方通病报。1991,6卷第3期:56-59
    [145]熊咏民,张矢远,罗毅,等,1997.T-2毒素致小型猪关节软骨的毒性实验研究[J].中国地方病防治杂志,12(1):4-6
    [146]徐刚要,曹小刚,吕哓亚,2004.退耕还林还草与控制大骨节病[J].地方病通报,19(2):1-7
    [147]许模,刘国,等,2010.川西北高原壤塘县大骨节病区微量元素特征研究[J] .中国地质,37(3):571-576.
    [148]徐吉敏,吴梅兰,程建华,等,1999.碘与大骨节病的关系[J] .地方病通报,14(4):36-38
    [149]荀黎红,等,1991.大骨节病区饮用水腐植酸含量测定[J].内蒙古地方病防治研究,l6(1):24
    [150]杨建伯,1994.镰刀菌毒素导致大骨节病研究进展[J].中国地方病学杂志,2:114-117
    [151]杨建伯,1995.大骨节病病因研究报告.中国地方病学杂志[J],14(4):201-204
    [152]杨建伯,孙殿军,1994.镰刀菌T-2毒素致鸡雏关节软骨病变观察[J].中国地方病学杂志,13(1):1-4
    [153]杨建伯,孙殿军,王志武,1995.大骨节病病区病户主食中T-2毒素检出报告[J].中国地方病学杂志,14(3):200-204.
    [154]杨建伯,1988.乾县、抚松、双鸭山换粮防治大骨节病效果观察.换粮防病历史回顾[J].中国地方病学杂志,7(4):230-233
    [155]杨建伯,1998.大骨节病发病与流行的机制[J].中国地方病学杂志,l7(4):201-206
    [156]杨林生,吕瑶,李海蓉,等,2006.西藏大骨节病区的地理环境特征[J],地理科学,26(4):466-468
    [157]杨林生,吕瑶,李海蓉,等,2005.西藏山地半淋溶土壤分布与大骨节病关系研究[J],地理科学研究,24(2):24-27
    [158]殷培璞,郭雄,1992.综合措施防治大骨节病十年研究[J],地方病通报.7(3):103-107
    [159]应桂英,贾勇等,2007.腐植酸与软骨损伤关系的研究进展[J].卫生研究,36(2):238-241
    [160]袁时宁,莫东旭, 1987。铊致软骨坏死及亚硒酸钠拮抗作用的实验研究[J],中华病理学杂志,16(3):206-209
    [161]扎西桑珠,等,2003.溪涨大骨节病病区硒含量检测结果分析[J].中国地方病防治杂志,18(3):177-179
    [162]翟树生,1991.大骨节病与饮水关系的研究[J].中国地方病防治杂志,6(7):17-20
    [163]张宝弟,郭雄,白广禄,等,2004.血清细胞凋亡相关因子与大骨节病关系的研究[J].中国地方病学杂志,23(2):172-175
    [164]张勃夫,1988.生态环境与大骨节病[J],吉林地质,(1):21-26
    [165]张法治,1989.自由基及腐植酸对软骨细胞的损伤[J].北京医科大学学报,21(6):493-495.
    [166]张建华,2008.阿坝县大骨节病病区饮水安全浅析[J].四川水利,(2):49-50;
    [167]张立成,等,1992.长江河源区水环境地球化学[M].北京:中国环境科学出版社
    [168]张丽珊,朱岩,可夫,等,1990.东北大骨节病病区主要土壤腐殖酸硒与大骨节病关系的研究[J].应用生态学报,1(4):333-337
    [169]张矢远,郭雄,于志道,等,1996.大骨节病区粮及患者血清中镰刀菌毒素的检测[J].中国地方病防治杂志,11(2):88-90
    [170]赵志军,李强,文海,2005.大骨节病与病区饮用水的关系[J].地方病通报,20(3):109-111
    [171]赵志军,李强,等,2006.微小病毒B19与骨关节病的关系[J].中国地方病防治杂志,25(16):734-738
    [172]中共中央地方防治领导小组,1984.永寿大骨节病考察文集.北京:人民卫生出版社
    [173]周福祥,李桂珍,等,1999.潍坊市改水控制大骨节病经验[J].中国地方病学杂志,(6):487-489
    [174]朱参胜,等,2001.病区的搬迁措施对大骨节病流行的影响[J].地方通病报,16(1):26-29
    [175]朱颜明,何岩,等,2002.环境地理学导论.北京:科学出版社
    [176]左弘,郭雄,康龙丽,等,2006.大骨节病患者12号染色体6个STR位点基因频率分析[J].南方医科大学学报,26(4):414-4l7

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700